Scar and Scott technically won twice due to double victory shared with grian and double life being soul-linked

@fnaffoxy1987

5 ай бұрын

By the rules of the mechanics of the seasons, only Scott has technically won twice. 3rd Life could only ever have one winner just like Last Life and Limited Life could only have one. Double Life was the exception. Grian and Scar were asking if they could both win in hopes they didn't have to fight, but they had to, even the other dead players were calling for bloodshed between the two. Double Life is still Pearl's victory though.

@DanDanPlushMC

5 ай бұрын

​@@fnaffoxy1987whenever grian and scar fought before they started fighting they claimed it as a double victory no matter who won

@fnaffoxy1987

5 ай бұрын

@@DanDanPlushMC Doesn't matter, everybody agrees that Grian solely won 3rd Life, just like all the members agree Pearl solely won Double Life even though her and Scott died at the same time.

@thidasidupraveen8550

5 ай бұрын

@@fnaffoxy1987Pearl won double life and scott came in 2nd place.Pearl Said in a stream in double life the last name that appears in chat is the winner

@fnaffoxy1987

5 ай бұрын

@@thidasidupraveen8550 I'm well aware. I was saying that Scott winning Double Life has a much better argument than Scar does for winning 3rd Life, even though there's definitively one winner for both.

Funnily enough, every winner except Scar died. - Grian jumped off and died of fall damage - Scott got /killed - Pearl got soulbound killed - Martyn ran out of time - Scar submitted his task and no one killed him afterwards (at least in his video)

@andrewbloom7694

5 ай бұрын

Im pretty sure Grian /killed martyn in limited life too, it was in a different pov though.

@Piper_Allen

5 ай бұрын

@@andrewbloom7694 he did

@Vexillogically

5 ай бұрын

@@andrewbloom7694In which pov?

@vemijoev

5 ай бұрын

@@andrewbloom7694It was just a joke in an animatic

@collaredjacket6196

5 ай бұрын

i was really confused why he didnt die it could be really intersersting if after he pressed the succed button he died

I love how all the other players make a whole deep dialogue when they win, meanwhile Scott puts confetti on the screen and celebrates profusely when he wins.

Its so interesting that Scar didnt die in his video. Everyone else died in their own way but Scar with only half heart didnt die at the end of all of it. But scar being scar, he probably died off camera by fall damage 😅

@teresar6348

3 ай бұрын

Everyone dies eventually. If he didn't die in game, he dies with that hard drive way down the line.

@zelbayanym

Ай бұрын

martyn added that to lore

@jacob_the_idiot

27 күн бұрын

@@teresar6348The Winner’s curse (I believe that’s what the fandom has dubbed it-)

I appreciate the fact that pearl has only ever won one because she feels too bad about killing people and just half heartedly attacks people in the last sessions. That’s why she won double life, she didn’t feel bad about attacking anyone

@elrac7333

4 ай бұрын

You are on to something here. Pearl in her villain arc won. Then Martin in a last second villain arc also won. Then Scar, in his season long forced villain arc won as well.

@tristand7996

4 ай бұрын

​@@elrac7333the only reason why pear DIDNT win secret life was because she litteraally didnt want to in the last fight you can clearly see that she wasnt really trying to fight scar

@Youraverageoscfan666

Ай бұрын

@@tristand7996 apparently I’ve been summoned by a profily

@Pokeianj

Ай бұрын

She definitely could have killed Scar in secret life

@user-kx8pu6ys5i

24 күн бұрын

I mean, tbf, in secret life scar had almost 20 more hearts than she did(but also she let scar have the kill on gem)

The end of Double Life still makes me tear up, and that finale speech by Martyn still gives me goosebumps. Still hoping for a Joel, Etho and Bdubs victory.

@connorbingham4764

4 ай бұрын

Hey I'm waiting for the day of a Jimmy victory. Wont that be something

I can't wait until they have enough winners to do a season of only winners. To see who would be the first 2 time winner

@_PTUBE101_

5 ай бұрын

I feel like Scott or Pearl would have at least 2 wins before everyone has one They are very consistent Ever since he got the low placement of 10th in 3rd Life, Scott has gotten 1st in Last Life, 2nd individual or dual 1st in Double Life, 3rd in Limited Life, and 4th in Secret Life Meanwhile Pearl’s track record (considering that she was not in 3rd Life) is 4th in Last Life, 1st individual or dual 1st in Double Life, 4th again in Limited Life, and 2nd in Secret Life If anyone is getting a second individual win first it will be one of them

@shanesunil

5 ай бұрын

​@@_PTUBE101_There's a meme about the last session (it's in the Secret Life Session 9 Memes video) about how Pearl was trying to lose and ended up 2nd and how Jimmy was trying to win and ended up being out 2nd. Also, fun fact: Pearl apparently has the highest average rank among all players in the Life Series, at 2.75

@tinathena17

5 ай бұрын

​@@_PTUBE101_ pearl didnt even want to win secret life and she's rocking with some iron gears on the last ep but still placed 2nd. She's incredible

@shanesunil

5 ай бұрын

@@tinathena17 And even bigger fact - When asked about the Secret Life finale during her live stream, Pearl said "Something happened. Some people may or may not have noticed anything different. Just don't look too much into it." And we all said that we did notice that she didn't use her bow against Scar and that she had 3 Golden Apples but decided not to eat them.

@tinathena17

5 ай бұрын

@@shanesunil i didnt notice that! I kinda knew she was not aiming to win though, she said it a few eps back that she wants her mounders to win.

Every season winner arc: 1. good friends 2.Honored late game battle 3. Drama arc 4. betrayal arc 5. villain arc 6. romantic arc?? Redemption arc???

@JessieQueefingNostril

5 ай бұрын

Betrayal*

@L.AWNM0.W3R

4 ай бұрын

i actually want a romantic one lmao

@screm5514

4 ай бұрын

Romantic one with joel and lizzy

@L.AWNM0.W3R

4 ай бұрын

@@screm5514 AW I UNIRONICALLY WANT THAT TO HAPPEN!

@CERISTHEDEV

4 ай бұрын

Lizzie or joe winning s6 would be crazy

I love Double Life the most. But all seasons were awesome.

@St3rl1n9

5 ай бұрын

Me too

@karupsvivek992

5 ай бұрын

I loved 3rd life and last life the most

@koo2463

5 ай бұрын

same

@imMittensKitten

28 күн бұрын

Same :)

The ending to secret life was so wholesome, Scar was so surprised he won lol.

Scar not realising that he won will always be classic.

I feel like there is an unwritten rule of you can't win more than once. Because Smajor could've won in limited and double life but "sacrificed" himself, as well as Pearl didn't really fight back in secret life - she fought like she just didn't want to win.

@lolickypeepee23xdd6

5 ай бұрын

idk about that tbh, maybe but they honestly just dont seem to want to- there really is no incentive to win, its just a "plot device" basically to drive the series forward and reach the last man standing outcome but theyre all friends and their real goal is making content

@anonymouscommenter2425

5 ай бұрын

Yeah there defo is, Pearl said in some of her secret live vids that she was playing for bdubs to win, I image the previous victors are meant to act as guides for their teams and give their life it comes to it. Only time they would probably not do it this way would be if there were only victors left due to a stray creeper or something

@TopHat0278

5 ай бұрын

I disagree on smajor as martyn killed him and impulse while they where off guard and he let gem kill him because he was one shot away from death, pearl on the other hand has said she has got a win under her belt and now want her allies to win as she wanted bigb to win limited life and either bdubs or joel to win secret life, and whenever her allies die she goes to the next in line (impulse In limited and scar in secret)

@gatlinggun511

5 ай бұрын

I think they just don’t want to win twice

@ellis007

5 ай бұрын

The reason why smajor wouldve won limited life is because he had about 5 hours? I think that much or around it compared to impluse and martyn who were under an hour. Smajor let them kill him to be on even time. He couldve easily won since of his extra hours. As well as on double life he sacrificed himself. Pearl is iffy @@TopHat0278

Anyone notice that the odd numbered series were won by Hermits (Grian, Pearl, Scar), while the even numbered ones weren't? (Scott and Martyn)

@vemijoev

5 ай бұрын

😨 woah

@_m_4867

5 ай бұрын

Soooo you are saying nexts IS finally the Joel sweep right? RIGHT???/hj (Im a bit delusional sorry)

@darkdragoness5

5 ай бұрын

@@vemijoev what's going to further blow your mind is that the even numbered Life series don't use the three life system (Last Life gave players a random amount of lives, and Limited Life had time for their lives) and both of those had systems in place to get players more life. The even numbered ones also had the bogeyman system.

@vemijoev

5 ай бұрын

@@darkdragoness5 Double woah😨😰

@Peevee-xs4xq

4 ай бұрын

soo next season is finally bigbs win!!1!1 (I've been rooting for him since third life. It's never gonna happen I'm insane)

I find it quite sad that scar instinctivly says "come on grian" but then remembers that grian is dead 7:47

@imMittensKitten

28 күн бұрын

NO I DIDN'T REALIZE THAT- Ahhh my heart ;-;

both scar and pearl won while being villains

@diegovera1353

5 ай бұрын

I mean Gem was pretty evil too it was really just an evil showdown at the end

@lolickypeepee23xdd6

5 ай бұрын

with the 2 armies dynamic in 3rd life depending on your perspective grian could also be seen as the villain (it really looks like it from ren or martyn povs)

@anonymouscommenter2425

5 ай бұрын

Martyn was also a villain in the end really

@DarkRedX_X-gang

5 ай бұрын

@@lolickypeepee23xdd6 I mean depends on who started the red winter war

@littlelost_things2822

Ай бұрын

really, all of the winners could be interpreted as villains in the story depending on the pov you view them from. but scar and pearl definitely embraced their roles.

My ranking to the endings by how dramatic it was: *1st: Double Life* *2nd: Third Life* *3rd: Limited Life* *4th: Secret Life* *5th: Last Life*

@demi172

4 ай бұрын

i'd say it's 1st: Limited Life 2nd: Double Life 3rd: Third Life 4th: Secret Life 5th: Last Life

Now you gotta add the winner of the April fools special: real life

@MCYTLife

Ай бұрын

Something Real Life SMP Related might be coming out real soon (maybe today, who knows...)

I just realized Scott could've won 3 times in a row and placed in the top 4 in every season except for 3rd Life Is this where Jimmy's luck went?

@pileofsocks8287

4 ай бұрын

Yeah

@bcmoore671

13 күн бұрын

It wasn't luck, it was strategy.

I find it interesting how everyone who went into the final session of Secret Life with over 30 hearts made the final 3 3rd - Gem: 57 hearts 2nd - Pearl: 50 hearts 1st - Scar: 40 hearts

@shanesunil

5 ай бұрын

I like how this is basically the opposite of Last Life, where the top 2 players were the ones who started with only 2 lives - Scott and Ren.

@darkdragoness5

5 ай бұрын

It's also funny that the ranking for the top 3 highest health at the start of the session is the reverse of the final three

@tyreek.6815

5 ай бұрын

Bdubs would’ve been there if scar didn’t keep randomly taking hearts away lol. Not to mention his whole life

@loromc7

5 ай бұрын

@@shanesunilgrian started with 2

@_PTUBE101_

5 ай бұрын

@@loromc7 and he got 7th still good

Fun Fact: Grian and Martyn are the only 2 of the 5 winners to not be finalists twice Grian🤜🏻Scar Scott🏹Ren Pearl🪢Scott Martyn🗡️impulse Scar🏹Pearl

@bcmoore671

13 күн бұрын

If you consider the finalists the final 2, you are excluding Ren and impulse.

“You may slay me and take the enchanter” best quote ever

I really like Martin's win honestly. Idk it's just clean in the sense that he did it to win and nothing else. Also- saying pearl won double life and not Scott kinda negates the entire 'double life' thing. I would say they both won, though you could definitely give pearl a little more credit for doing most of the work to win at the end.

@CheeseMiser

5 ай бұрын

THE LAST NAME IN CHAT TO DIE WINS AS PER THE SERVER RULES

Pearl's double life win will remain iconic

bro in the double life series Pearl turned into a whole final boss in the end, she had an axe and some dogs and killed two teams of two people with worse armor Thain they had while laughing.

Personally, if I was Scar, I would’ve gone beast mode and clicked: Re-roll for a harder task

@niello5944

4 ай бұрын

Task can't be rerolled iirc.

@teresar6348

3 ай бұрын

That would be a great way to sneak peek into the next life series.

@jiyzo

3 ай бұрын

It wouldve been win the next life series 💀. And it would be cool if the same punishment amd rewards carried over

To clarify, Only Grian won 3rd Life and only Pearl won Double Life

I started watching at Double Life, so this was interesting to see how the first 2 ended

The thumbnail for this is so perfect

My ranking for the intensity/drama of the endings ✨ Higher Drama #1: Secret Life #2: Limited Life #3: Double Life #4: Third Life #5: Last Life Higher Funni It was really hard to rank them because their endings are all pretty dramatic, Last Life is 5th in "drama" because Scott's cheerfulness and confetti was funni and a big contrast to the others. Also Limited Life and Secret Life have equally balanced drama/lore imo, but since SL fight was longer and everyone still had gear, SL was more intense for me.

It started with The Grian & Scar duo and Grian won, and funnily enough it ended with Scar Truly showing that they were destined to win from the start

I love the feeling when seeing the last person all alone where people thrived before

Can't wait for Life Series Season 17 where Jimmy will win finally... in his video of the Life Series in a Hunger Games And This Happenned...

Martyn's win is so satisfying, the good old betrayal

Scott won most of the series in my opinion. Scott lost third life, he won last life he sacrificed himself in double life Martyn "cheated" in limited life All of Scott's deaths in secret life were sacrifices.

Pearl’s win was so emotional…

Of course Scar didn't notice he won 😂

I love how it’s Grian who told scar❤😊

Scar has improved so much!

Martin has no chill

still hoping for BigB or Skizz to win one 🤞

A theory I have so, notice how in almost every season, all the winners besides grian died without their own will like, Scott was literally killed mid air, pearl and Scott both died even thought pearl won and Martyn no matter what he did eventually even if he didn’t win he would’ve died anyway and I think scar didn’t get his reward for the secret and just kept getting “win secret life” bc I know everyone thinks the giant rock in the middle or secret keeper is a watcher, I think it’s kinda the watchers saying “no matter what you do, we always win” and it works with grian aswell bc he’s a watcher so if my theory is right (I know grian won) technically scar was the last person standing Grian being the last thing there meant he was going to end the seris idk I think it’s an interesting theory but ye

Have you noticed the pattern of all the winners realizing they’ve won? -Grian was sad -Scott cheered -Pearl was sad -Martyn cheered -Scar was sad

@user-kx8pu6ys5i

24 күн бұрын

not really, pearl was shocked, and scar was confused. which are different emotions than simply "sad"

And now we have Cleo technically added to this list if we count the vr season

Scarlet pearl does sound like a villain.

5am unhinged Peral is just hilariously

scott is extremely underrated, top 4 every time since s2 and won "twice"

I am hoping gem would win secret life but scar winning was such an unexpected thing

Definitely pearl wining was the best

You probably should watch series of the winner

Every winner gets more crazy after one winner, so what if the final season is Lizzie winning-

This will blow up I know it

Wait i thought martyn won twice, guess i was tripping probably mixed up with scott

I mean scott got the final in double life technically

if he wanted to smajor could have easily won limited life and maybe survived longer in secret life

@tristand7996

4 ай бұрын

and pearl aalso could haave easily won secret life like if you waatch her footage you can clearly see thaat she wasnt even trying to win

Dang InTheLittleWood didn’t care AT ALL 😂

I see a pattern. Do you see the pattern?…

@yoshiflash579

5 ай бұрын

Double life pairs? So Cleo wins next?

@TYAdv

5 ай бұрын

@@yoshiflash579 no look at every other season…

@jujiemandane9610

5 ай бұрын

What pattern?

@TheDiggityDuck

5 ай бұрын

Double Life Pairs, Cleo Next!!!

@Charle596

5 ай бұрын

@@TYAdv What is the pattern

i think they all won by being the last to lose all of their lives

I would argue if there could only be one winner of double life, it would be Scott, since he did the final kill. Sure, he blew up himself, but since there was no way for him to kill Pearl without ending himself, I'd argue it doesn't matter who he hit with his attack. Fact is, through the soul bond he got the final kill of another player. Tbh though, the most logical thing is to count Scott and Pearl equally as winners. They're the winning team, even though they didn't act like a team throughout this series at all.

@LRM12o8

5 ай бұрын

EDIT: apparently Grian explained somewhere sometime that the winner is the last name to displayed in a death message in chat

@ipolinalts

4 ай бұрын

I am going to riot if I see one more text block that said Scott won and not pearl

I hate how Scott ended it in last life that’s such a weird way to win

It is pdd to aee scar end wirhout dying or secret life in that matter.... The only life series that did not end with a death... 3rd life grian jumped... Last life scott got shot by a skeleton? i think, did not keenly watched.... Doubleife was scott again... Bleww himself and killing pearl as they are linked... Limted life got martyn ran out of time.... Now scar just won and hained hearts.... The only person who actually survived a life series and is to live forever as it would be uncertain to actually know the outcome /s....unless truth was shown

@joegoff1895

5 ай бұрын

Grian used /kill on Scott

@karmatick4418

5 ай бұрын

Anyone k ow where that drown3d came?

Man I hate how scar didn't die at the end everyone else did it so it's a tradition and scar broke that

@Ramen747_

5 ай бұрын

Martyn acc had a really cool lore reason behind it, that it was the watchers being a bit cruel and leaving scar to slam the success button again and again before dying and moving onto the next game

Technically by death message pearl died last so pearls the winner no Scott because they didn’t want a shared victory unlike third life where it was in feeling shared

@HC_Fan

4 ай бұрын

Also rip jellie

You forgot Real Life

@MCYTLife

Ай бұрын

This video came out a few months before Real Life so I'm not able to add it in but if you want I can make an updated version with Real Life in it

50tj suh

Next series prediction: It's called "Timmy Life", where Solidarity starts off as a red name with unlimited lives until the first person dies to guarantee Jimmy isn't out first.

i was the 1000th like, pog

Why the hell would you make that your thumbnail? I've only watched the first four and now Secret Life is spoiled! Clicked on the video just to comment this

3rd Life was a double win technically. Meaning Grian and Scar won. This also means Scar has the most life series wins that being 3rd Life and now Secret Life

@demi172

4 ай бұрын

well double life could also be classified as a double win, so scott also has two wins

@soupspeaker

4 ай бұрын

@@demi172 I mean, yeah, but I didn't say double life because grian stated it was a double win. It was never stated in double life, so, I left it ot

- btw, i also count scott winning on pearl's victory in double-life (on paper only). - as with scar, i count it unofficially, or on paper who won there was solely grian... however, just like they said, whatever happens its a win for both of them. - but on record, yes, scott has actually won twice.

@demi172

4 ай бұрын

grian has said that the winner is the last one to have their death message displayed in chat so scott hasn't won twice by official standards

No offence to Scott but last life had the worst winner even though it was the best series. That was Joel’s session

@lekilia

5 ай бұрын

Why?

@CubicalYarn

5 ай бұрын

He may have turned red too early but he was a nuisance throughout the entire season, also he might have gotten the most kills but I don't know if it's true. I was hoping for him to win too but he was a bit too reckless and apart from Grian, I don't recall him having any other allies.

@MrEgg0

5 ай бұрын

@@CubicalYarn scar and pearl won with almost no allies the whole time

SOMEBODY ALREADY DID THIS VIDEO!!!

And this is why I don't understand people saying Scott is a great PVPer. He missed every long shot in his series win and only got a bunch because Ren doesn't fight real smart. Ren could easily rival Joel and other top PVPers if he didn't go barreling in full bore. I definitely see Pearl winning again in future Life series. Not Scott.

@demi172

4 ай бұрын

scott practically gave the win to martyn and REALLY gave the win to pearl just due to the fact that he had already won, he cohosts MCC theres no debate whether or not hes an amazing pvper

@celticlion

4 ай бұрын

@@demi172 Except Double Life was before Scott's win. The bottom line is Scott has no real pvp skills. Build skills yes, brainstorming ideas of what to collab with others in builds yes, but not PVP. Mumbo is scarier than Scott and that's because you don't expect anything because it's Mumbo but Secret Life showed how insanely accurate Mumbo can be with redstone traps. Least if Grian, Scar or Joel aren't touching it lol

@saitohajime9939

2 ай бұрын

@@celticlionhow high are you? Double life was the 3rd life series while Last life (the one Scott won) was the 2nd life series. It just sounds like you hate Scott and that’s it. Your argument falls so far behind because Scott is an Admin or Co Admin (I don’t fully remember) of MCC, he’s places top 4 in the life series from Last life to Secret life (3rd life which was more or less a beta test for Grian he placed 10(?)) and if you looked Martyn finished Scott first because he’s more of a threat than Impulse which says a lot because Martyn is just as good at PVP as Scott is

@celticlion

2 ай бұрын

@@saitohajime9939 I'm not. Just pointing out what I've observed. And what I've observed is Scott is a wet towel in PVP. If it came down to who is scarier on a 1v1, my choices wouldn't include Scott.

@saitohajime9939

2 ай бұрын

@@celticlion then your painfully bad at observing…

thanks for spoiling the last season 😒

@cora_jones

4 ай бұрын

why did you watch the video that’s ur fault

@demi172

4 ай бұрын

its in the thumbnail he wouldve seen the winner without clicking thats the problem@@cora_jones

@cora_jones

4 ай бұрын

@@demi172 oh that makes sense lol