What do you think Elizabeth may have thought of her uncle King Richard after the disappearance of her brothers? Let me know below and remember to check out my Patreon at www.patreon.com/historycalling and my Amazon storefront at www.amazon.com/shop/historycalling

@anweshabiswas4813

Ай бұрын

Is it true that Elizabeth of york was such an icon that She was the apple of her father's eye , had wrapped her uncle Richard iii around her finger and married his enemy and managed to get him head over heels in love with her . My question is how she had wrapped her uncle Richard iii around her finger ???

@anweshabiswas4813

Ай бұрын

It is a great mystery , I have no clue what Uncle and niece thought about each other and disappearence of her brothers . I need a time machine to go to that era and see what happened at that time, was the king really guilty ???

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Hmm, I'm not sure we have enough evidence to say she had either of them wrapped around her finger, but her position as the best claimant to the throne meant that she was certainly very valuable to Richard and then to Henry Tudor.

@trustmemysonisadoctor8479

Ай бұрын

I always enjoy your videos, they are educational and entertaining. I look forward to next weeks video.

@faytsampouri6197

Ай бұрын

And a grandmother 😊

If women had been recognized as potential heirs she probably would have met the same fate as her brothers.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, I think she might have, or else Richard might have bumped off Anne Neville and married her, niece or no niece.

@sue-anneastman3502

Ай бұрын

🤢🤮

@lisalking2476

27 күн бұрын

I believe she would have been killed also 😢

@melissaclark1051

6 күн бұрын

More likely men would try to marry her and rule over her while doing their best to get her pregnant

@emilybarclay8831

3 күн бұрын

I believe she would have been forced into marriage as opposed to killed. After all, she was 17 when her father died, a perfectly marriageable age, and why kill such a valuable marriage candidate? Any man who married her would be -jure uxoris_ king of England. The reason male heirs were executed is because their male rivals obviously couldn’t marry them. Not so with women. Just look at how practically every unmarried Protestant king and prince was competing for Elizabeth I’s hand.

I imagine she know exactly what her uncle had done, and she knew how to survive and advance, not unlike her mother. Laying low, keeping her suspicions to herself, being charming, and biding her time, which her mother and Margaret Beaufort made sure would come. She seems to have done well and found some measure of love in her marriage to Henry Tudor. I find it so interesting that in so many points in royal history it is the women who keep things together and move things forward. He may not have needed her to gain his throne, but he certainly needed her to hold it with any semblance of legitimacy. A truly interesting woman. I wish we knew more about her.

I am soo glad you touched upon Philippa Gregory's novels and just how slanderous they can be to real-life figures when a reader isn't aware of the actual history. I love Margaret Beaufort and just how strong-willed she was in face of such adversity, but Gregory, for some reason, thought her novels needed more drama and made her the villain! Like you mentioned, there's no proof of any of this, so why go down this train of thought? History is dramatic enough on its own! And don't get me started on how Arthur was conceived in "The White Princess"...

@IMAMONGUS

Ай бұрын

I never finished the White Princess because of that very scene! I hated Gregory's characterization of Henry.

@history_loves_anime8927

18 күн бұрын

@@IMAMONGUS I just hate Philippa Gregory's portayal of historical figures in general. I've read all her Tudor novels and majority of the War of the Rose's ones and it made me want to throw them, especially with how much she seems to hate any woman with a cunning mind and ambition (Margaret Beaufort, Anne Boleyn, Elizabeth I, Catherine of Aragon).

@emilybarclay8831

3 күн бұрын

It truly saddens me that so many modern Tudor history fans have had their introduction to that period via Gregory’s hogwash, it’s created so many armchair historians with a complete misunderstanding of the major players of TWoTR

Elizabeth of york is one of my favorite historical characters. It seems to me that she was an adaptable and accepting woman. She knew what the expectations of her were and accepted them. She fulfilled her role in every way, even developing a loving relationship with Henry 7....a medieval royal woman to the core ❤❤

@StellinhaJF

Ай бұрын

So is she my favourite queen too, my dear queen, as I often call her. I'm from Brasil - with an s.

I like her a lot! Got a major soft spot for her lol. Seems to have been truly kind, a devoted mother, and not as… fiery, let’s say, as I think Elizabeth Woodville was. Really wish she had lived longer🥲

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, same here. It can't have been easy living the life she did and having to marry someone she'd probably been raised to think of as the enemy. She must have had great patience to bear all the twists and turns thrown at her.

@lfgifu296

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling Indeed! And to then go on to have a loving relationship with him is even more admirable

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, it is remarkable how well suited those two seem to have been, but more on that in next week's video :-)

@mareniquevanniekerk7864

Ай бұрын

​@@lfgifu296I feel exactly the same way about her! Couldn't have said it better myself!

@lfgifu296

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling aaah the wait😞😞 looking forward to it :)

I love learning about the English queens. Oh, if only Elizabeth of York had left behind a diary or a cachet of letters. My latest obsession is Philippa of Hainult, the mother of all of those sons whose descendents all went to war with each other. I'd love to write a book about her, but the information is so scant.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

I know. I was saying in another comment that she'd be great to have to dinner, assuming you could get her to dish the dirt. Yes, I looked at Philippa a little bit for my video on Joan of Kent. She was a very interesting woman too. As you say though, it's just a pity how scant the info. on some of these figures is, especially the women. Even Elizabeth is tough to write about at times.

@athenaathenaisc1473

Ай бұрын

@HistoryCalling ... the only way to write about Philippa is in novelized form, to be sure.

One of the great tragedies of history is the lack of diaries by women who were literate and were at hand witnesses to the incredible events going on around them. It would be thrilling to discover what Elizabeth really throught of Richard III, what she felt about her missing brothers, her viewpoint on Henry's claim to the throne and their marriage - to say nothing of her own personal ambitions, hopes, joys and fears. Would she have ever even considered the idea of being Queen in her own right? Or did she feel Queen consort was the only 'right and fitting' role for a woman, no matter what their claim to the throne might be? My best guess is she was terrified of her Uncle's potential for violent action against her and her remaining family and did as he wished for reasons of safety and security.

Elizabeth of york was the daughter of a king , niece of a King , sister of a King , wife of a King , and mother of King I am totally obsessed with the personalities who participated during wars of the roses Please make more videos on it . ❤❤❤❤

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Oh I've got a whole playlist on the WotR. If you haven't had a look yet, I think you'd enjoy it.

@perniciouspete4986

Ай бұрын

Considering their practice of incestuous marriage over generations, it's possible that many ancient Egyptian queens were all of the above, also.

@mmhthree

Ай бұрын

@@perniciouspete4986 Not Elizabeth of York.. she almost had to marry her Uncle though. She got lucky... sorta.

@ClaiireeLiizz

Ай бұрын

And a grandmother of a King and the first two Queens in their own right

@perniciouspete4986

Ай бұрын

@@mmhthree What part of "ancient Egyptian queens" did you miss? HINT: she wasn't one.

Thank you for this very complete description of Elizabeth’s early years. All the novels aside, it seems to me that the princess must have felt the need to be extremely careful in her behavior towards her Uncle Richard, who held such power over her, her mother and surviving siblings. Her mother would have taken charge of any important negotiations. Elizabeth would have followed instructions. Even after becoming queen, she doesn’t seem to have any record of speaking up in any significant way. Hope you had a good holiday and, as always, I look forward to next week.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thanks Ann. Yes, I'm sure she was walking on eggshells around him. I know I would have been. I think keeping her head down, even after becoming Queen, was a wise move. More on that next week of course and yes, my holiday was good thank you. It was a bit of a rude awakening to have to get up this morning and get back to work though, as I only got home 24 hours ago :-)

@annieandelsieofarendelle3294

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCallingSomeone else suggested this but maybe she just didn’t want to be England’s ruling monarch, even though her claim is better. All the politicking and power plays tore her family apart and resulted in the deaths of several of her family members, and really who wants to be apart of that life?

@lisalking2476

Ай бұрын

I'm sure she feared for her life as well,ruthless times they were in her days😢 I'd have detested him killing my brothers and never game him a child 💯

Well done (once again)! QEY is, perhaps, my favorite medieval female royal (along with Margaret Beaufort, Eleanor of Aquitaine, and QE1). Your treatment, here, is simply brilliant, cogent, and persuasive. Thanks for your candor and sharing. Keep up the good work!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thanks Mark. More next week on her Queenship, as I just couldn't do her justice in one video.

Thank you for this video - I've been intrigued by Elizabeth because of her unique part in English history (seriously being a daughter, sister, niece, wife and mother of kings is nothing to squeeze at).

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Me too. I wish we had more info. on her life. She'd be great to have at a dinner party too (assuming you could get her to dish the dirt of course).

@Lionstar16

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling Admittedly it's a fictional novel, but 'Elizabeth of York: the Last White Rose' by Alison Weir is a really good read.

@athenaathenaisc1473

Ай бұрын

@Lionstar16 ... I agree on Alison Weirs' books.

@ClaiireeLiizz

Ай бұрын

She was also the Grandmother of a King as well as the first two Queens in their own right

@lisalking2476

27 күн бұрын

​@@ClaiireeLiizzglad you added that because I didn't hear that mention in the video and many of us didn't know,thank you 😊

Hello HC, would you consider making a video about Elizabeth’s other siblings (I mean her royal sisters, Grey half-brothers and Edward’s illegitimate children)? I think they are a really interesting topic because we don’t really hear anything about them, maybe except for Cecily. A great video as always, War Of Roses is my favorite era in English history 😊🌹

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

I would indeed. It really just depends on the availability of sources.

👏👏Whenever I watch your videos related to The War of the Roses, I'm always glad there isn't a test afterward, HC. 😉 This a strong entry and I really enjoyed it. No way to be sure, but I could imagine Elizabeth being terrified of Richard. Another woman of grit. Welcome back from vacation, HC. 🙏🏼

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

I'm glad I'm not being tested either. Every time I make one of these I have to go back to the older ones first and reacquaint myself with the family trees. It's just too complex to keep in my head all the time. Yes, I think I'd have been scared of him too.

I think the Duke of Clarence might have fared better if he minded his own business 😂

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, he does seem to have been a bit of a plonker.

I'm beginning to think I will never sort out all the Edwards, Richards, Henrys, Elizabeths, and even Margarets. But your videos certainly help. It is so frustrating that we don't have more first hand accounts of that time. Knowing how much the nobility valued learning, and facility in multiple languages, I find it truly odd that we don't have more letters or diaries to explore for information. It makes me wonder if there is more to be unearthed. How fascinating would it be to discover an account of Elizabeth's time in sanctuary with her siblings and mother, written by her own hand, and able to be authenticated? Or perhaps a written testimony of what had transpired by Elizabeth Woodville written after she retired from court? I've always wondered why she did so, since her counterpart stayed active in politics until her death.

@alancoe1002

Ай бұрын

Takes a few years, but you can do it. Nickname them as a mnemonic

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

I feel the same way. The number of Edwards, Prince of Wales is particularly mind bending :-) Yes, I'd love the kind of documents you mention too. It certainly makes me grateful for Queen Victoria's diary.

@catherineball5071

Ай бұрын

I memorised the horrible histories song 🎵William, William, Henry, Stephen, Henry, Richard, John oy! 🎵 Helps to remember all the monarchs but not helpful with all the consorts and other big names!

Philips Gregory’s novels are a guilty pleasure for me, she just frames them as though every single rumor ever was absolutely 100% true, so I can’t take them seriously.

@JadlynJ

27 күн бұрын

Her novels are great for entertainment only, I think.😂 For ppl who love Margret Beaufort or Elizabeth of york, they probably wouldn't enjoy the novels. It was a complete character assassination of those two women.

Wonderful video on Elizabeth of York. So well documented and beautifully presented. Thank you 😊❤

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you very much. More next week as I just couldn't do her justice in only one video :-)

@helpinyerdasellavon

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling looking forward to it! You did excellent work! Thank you 🙏🏻❤

btw I love her so much, Elizabeth of York is one of my favorites queen of England, Catherine of Aragon and Anne Boleyn too, I'm very obsessed with both of them so I love all the content you have made 🥺, also is so cool to know more about the Stuart and the Hanoverian (I have the feeling that they're not so popular in the poo culture as Plantagenet/Tudor monarchs

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, I'd love to do more on the Stuarts and Hanoverians as that is actually the era I studied at university and later wrote on (more the Hanoverian era actually). I do have playlists on them and I'll maybe try to do a little bit more on them in the future.

@blossomceriwen

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling oh, sounds fascinating 🥺. Hope your channel keeps growing and have many opportunities. Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us :)

I am so happy you made this! Elizabeth is my favourite historical women so to see a video of your on your account makes me so happy!!!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

You're very welcome. I've been working my way through the women of the Wars of the Roses in chronological order for a couple of years now, so it took me some time to get to her, but I'm very happy to have finally made it as well. More next week as I couldn't do her justice in just one video.

@danesba1

Ай бұрын

​@@HistoryCallingcan't wait til next week!

This is the period of history that has always fascinated me. Wonderful video HC.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE GENEROUS DONATION GILL. I'm glad you're enjoying hearing about Elizabeth. I agree, it's a mesmerising (and terrifying) period of history.

Well, as you pointed out yourself, she, Elizabeth knew her so called Uncle Richard Gloucester was guilty of the death of her half-brother Richard Grey, who had done nothing to deserve the death he got so I think she kept her own counsel in King Richard III presence. I think she was far cleverer than most historians give her credit for being. I wonder if she was there when the Duke of Buckingham threatened her mother to give up little Richard of York or else when they were all in Sanctuary which really wasn't that much of a sanctuary when you come down to it.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, I wonder too how much she saw of what happened the day the Duke of York was taken from sanctuary. It must have been horrible to feel so powerless.

@08andylee

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling Indeed!

I’ve just started this video but thank you for putting out such good content! I always love watching your videos, they’re so interesting and really informative, keep it up!!❤❤❤

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you so much. I've been wanted to get to Elizabeth for a couple of years now, so I'm glad to finally be covering her life.

Thank you for the video, I'm currently obsessed with your channel. Your voice is so pleasing to hear and you make content in very detailed way. I love it Anyway, I think is funny you mentioned the white princess book and others P. Gregory books because those books and the series was my introduction to the war of the roses and later for the tudor era. Imagine my shock when I star to investigate about the real events and result that Richard III was a villain and not the sweet and kind boy that we see in the white queen (I fell so hard for him TT) and I have a very bad image of Margaret Beaufort (Gregory series really messed up with my head 😅). Anyway, I think Elizabeth probably hate her uncle, he most likely make her brothers kill and take everything from them, I think that's probably how she feel about him pero who knows, there's so much obscurity before Tudor era apparently. Can't wait for part 2 😊🫶🏻✨

@loewenalia

Ай бұрын

After I watch her videos two or three times I use them to go to sleep, her voice is just the right amount of relaxing magic to it. But it only works if I have watched the video three or four times first.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you so much (and pleasant dreams too) :-)

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you very much. Yes, I'm afraid I'm not a great fan of Ms Gregory (as a purveyor of history that is - I don't mind her as a fiction writer but the problem is that she blurs the lines rather a lot). The way in which she has affected how people think of Lady Margaret Beaufort is particularly annoying to me. I think LMB could sue for defamation today if she was still alive.

@AshniaAshinia

Ай бұрын

Same. P. Gregory's novels and TV series were my introduction into history.😂 Although The White Queen and The White Princess are really entertaining , when I read about ACTUAL history I was so shocked by the difference in personalities of the characters and real historical figures. Low-key, although I try to separate fiction from reality, I still find myself holding animosity towards Margret Beaufort and Anne Neville because of the show.💀

I have never heard of any soap opera that can beat the English aristocracy for intrigue, murder, and mayhem. This is so much fun. As for your question on her thoughts about Richard, I don't know that she would've been thinking on it. She would be much more interested in simply keeping head attached to her neck. Thank you for another thrilling chapter in the lives of Britain's rulers. 😊😊❤❤

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

I know and of course the soap opera continues to this day (though thankfully with less murder)! See you next week :-)

🌹 I am a Lancastrian for life! 🌹 Great video, as per usual 🫶🏽

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you very much! 🤗

One of my favourite individuals of our history. The things that she had to go through is absolutely fascinating! This is definitely my most favourite part of our history. The Plantagenet dynasty changed the course of history so many times that's it truly is fascinating! Thank you, HC, for bringing her to life. Would you ever consider writing a series of books on the wars of the roses? I, for one, would love it if you did, and I would get the entire collection! I love your work and how you present facts. Thank you! ❤

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. I don't know about a book series on the Wars of the Roses, but I'd certainly consider writing something as researching and writing history is really my first love and I miss it.

Elizabeth of York is my favorite Tudor queen. She is probably my favorite queen consort. She had a most interesting life. I do wonder how different things would have turned out if she hadn't had her last child

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Indeed, yes. Or if that child had been a boy who'd lived (therefore making it a bit less urgent that H8 have a son).

@heatherwilson9717

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling I think Henry still would have felt it was urgent for him to have a son. His ego was involved as much as the stability of the monarchy.

I love your videos so much! The research , the eloquent explanation, the interesting themes… perfect! I love this part of English history, and it’s been so fun and enriching to watch all of your videos in the matter. Thank you 😃

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you very much. I'm so glad you enjoy the videos. I've been wanting to get to Elizabeth for ages now, but I was working my way through all the women of the Wars of the Roses and it's literally taken me over two years. I'm glad I've made it to her though.

Thanks for doing this video at this time in particular. I recently watched 'The White Princess ' (please don't judge me 😅) and needed this and your follow-up as a pallette cleanser. Philippa Gregory seems to have a thing for believing all medieval gossip was true.

@akaLaBrujaRoja

Ай бұрын

No shame, I like watching the movies and tv series for the vibe and visuals, but then I come to this channel and a few others to follow up on the historical reality.

Thank you so much for the additional visual when it comes to an extensive family tree 😀 I've viewed this history by you i believe a coupla years ago. Got so confused with following the family lines however I heard every word. Its making more sense now, even with all the duplicates in names, thank you 😀 sidenote: im more of a map person

I really liked Elizabeth of York. Your videos are always so thorough and well researched. Thank you so much! ❤😊 xo

hello HC! not quite done yet but just wanted to say loving it so far, love hearing about the years leading up to her birth and really showing what she’s being born into!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. Yes, it was a messy world she arrived into. :-0

@ns-wz1mx

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling for sure some turbulent times!

Elizabeth of York is probably my favorite historical queen and she truly is so much more important than we give her credit for. So much of English/British history hinges on her yet there's a lot we don't know, leaving room for endless speculation and mystique. Thank you for this video!

As always, loved this video. I'm so impressed as you name off the various lineages. I "know" the lines of desent, but even with them sitting in front of me, I could never do it so smoothly. I don't know how people kept this straight back then, but I know they did. Can't wait for next week.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. Yes, the family tree is a real headache to keep straight and I know I go through it every time I do a Wars of the Roses video, but I always think it bears repetition just to help viewers (and myself) keep all the historical figures straight in their heads.

Gosh, I adore your work HC. You're so even-handed amidst your complex tales of yore. Thank you as always

Along with Elizabeth I’m a huge supporter of her mother and Jacquetta! I can’t imagine she had any positive feelings for Richard after the death of her father and brothers, I certainly believe she would have stood firmly with her mother and been a willing participant in the plans made for her.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, it would be fascinating to know her thoughts on Richard as up until 1483 he'd been a good uncle all things considered. It was always George, Duke of Clarence who was considered the dangerous one. I like Elizabeth Woodville and Jacquetta too. Do see my videos on them if you haven't already. The one on Jacquetta was popular enough that I noted other KZreadrs stealing it (stealing the topic and research I mean - they didn't simple re-air my exact video as YT doesn't allow that), so I must have been onto something.

This video is so much more informative than the Biography you reviewed earlier on Patreon. Thank you for this video.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. Yeah, that bio left a lot to be desired unfortunately.

One of your best yet! 👑

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you very much. More on Elizabeth next week too, as I get into her queenship (I couldn't do her justice in one video).

You teach us so beautifully. I have learned bits and pieces here after decades of interest in these families. Many thanks!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

You're very welcome. Here to help 😃

YES!!!! i have been waiting for this video for a long time!!! Thank you, thank you!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

You're very welcome. More next week on her Queenship too, as I couldn't do her justice in one video.

You do such an amazing job of explaining the very convoluted history of England. Just the family trees give me a headache, but I understand it when you explain it. Thank you for making it so much clearer.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. I'm glad they help. Honestly, I need them as much as my viewers do to try to keep everyone straight in my mind. Plus, so many of them have the same name. It's a nightmare!

Always enjoy your videos. Keep up the great content!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. More on Elizabeth next week too, as I get into her queenship.

I don’t always click like but I do like all your videos! They’re informative, interesting and entertaining. I’m usually listening more than watching so that’s why I don’t click like but for your personal info, I do like your videos!

Yes!!! Time for Elizabeth of York!!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes. It's taken me a while to work through all the women of the Wars of the Roses to get to her, but her time has finally come :-) More next week too on her Queenship.

Nice to be on the side of social media that loves Elizabeth of york. Fandoms of P.Gregory all constantly hate on her for the nonsense and misrepresentations in the novels and shows.

Thanks for another fantastic video! ♥️

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

You are so welcome. Thank you for watching and commenting :-)

An excellent episode. Very interesting 😊

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. More on Elizabeth next week too, as I get into her queenship.

I love your videos and Elizabeth of York is one of my favorite characters of the time period. The picture you have displayed when you discuss Elizabeth Woodville's father "Lord Rivers" being executed - I think that is her brother Antony who inherited his title.

🙏 thank you so much for the family tree with highlights and explanations 😊 Serious cudos 👍

@HistoryCalling

14 күн бұрын

You're welcome. They're a bit of a nightmare to put together, but I need them as much as my viewers to help me keep track of everything :-)

I love the series the white queen, the white princess and the Spanish princess. It's also nice to just listen too. Great video.

🇺🇸 here. Really enjoyed this. A lot of the info is new to me. I think she would have despised Uncle Richard. Thank you! ☮️

Great sketch of this marvelous lady. (my relative?) I really enjoy the illustrations. Excellent work. Thanks BTW: I'm not sure if you know or have a choice in your sponsors but the advertiser on this particular video is quite unusual. FYI

Enjoyed the video! It was like the opening chapter of one of the Old Testament books! 😊

Thanks v much for this HC 💖

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

My pleasure 😊

Love the war of the roses videos thank you @Historycalling

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

You're very welcome. It's a confusing period to keep track of, but I find it fascinating too.

@wendym215

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling indeed it is and very fascinating

Yay, Elizabeth of York is one of my very favorites!! To answer your question, after watching your analysis of the disappearance of her two younger brothers (little boys that Elizabeth would possibly have remembered holding, kissing, and playing with as infants), and the well-founded guard her mother held against him, I’m pretty confident that Elizabeth privately felt uncomfortable around Richard, at the very least. She may have had to put on a smile for the sake of good relations, which she seems to have been good at. But I don’t see any cause in her inward character or outward demeanor that would have led her to actually want to marry Richard, much less fall in love with him and try to work him over

Welcome back! Hope you enjoyed your holiday 😊

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. I sure did and I have a blister on my foot to prove it (lots and lots of walking) 😃

Excellent. Great account and many thanks!

Also, hope your Holiday went well :) Idk if you noticed but Dr Owen Emmerson (may have spelled it wrong :’) commented on your latest video!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

It did thank you and I saw his comment and dropped a little response to it as well. It's just a pity of course that the new research into that painting hasn't been published yet, as I would have incorporated it.

@lfgifu296

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling :’) well, his comment will be there for ppl to see, so it can be considered an addition to the video lol. You couldn’t have done anything about it, so ‘tis chill

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, that's true :-)

awesome video Hc, really loved it! in my opinion, i think Elizabeth may have been a bit leery about Richard given what happened in the past. but i guess that’s how i’d feel if i was her in that situation.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. Yes, I'd have had trouble sleeping in the same building as him as well if I'd been her.

@ns-wz1mx

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling right!?!

20:04 I think you got confused there.😅 Great video nonetheless! Keep up the good job! 😃

@edithengel2284

Ай бұрын

How so?

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Oh sorry. You're right. Edward IV, not Henry IV. All these Henrys, Edwards and Elizabeths are so confusing! I've actually made that error before but managed to catch it before the video aired. This is obviously the one that got away.

@edithengel2284

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling Very thoughtless they all were of future historians.😀

I apologize that this is beside the point: I saw on an older video of yours that people ask about your accent?! How can anyone mistake it? It's fabulous btw. Also, love this subject!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Haha, thank you very much. I think it's just an accent that a lot of people aren't familiar with. You don't hear Northern Irish voices on TV or in the movies very much (though Jamie Dornan has, to his credit, done quite a bit using his own accent, but I think he's still most famous for being Christian Grey and he was playing American in that).

I loved the Matilda video! I too found Edward and Eleanor interesting. I would watch any of your videos as they all teach me so many things I did not know. I wonder if Henry the VIII’s life was never to be stable after the death of his mother? The many queens could not “match” up kind of thing. Glad to have you back and hope your holiday was a happy one.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. I find her story so interesting and though more people would like it as she's the basis of Rhaenyra Targaryen, but it didn't do terribly well. Yes, I'm sure a psychologist would have a field day with Henry's mummy issues, trying to figure out if all the wives were a replacement for her.

Thank you for your videos

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

You're very welcome. Thank you for supporting by watching and commenting, especially when the video has just gone out.

@MaryamofShomal

Ай бұрын

Amen 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 I love her work!!!

She probably didn't like him very much. Looking forward to next weeks second part. Thank you HC for such great content.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

You're welcome. See you next week for more on her Queenship.

I quite agree that Margaret Beaufort never had ambitions that her son could become King until the murder of the sons of Edward IV. Even for someone as fiercely attached to her son as Margaret was, such ambition would have been both dangerous and ludicrous.

Henry VII was devoted to only 2 women, Margaret and Elizabeth. Amazing

@neilbuckley1613

Ай бұрын

I suspect the only rival Elizabeth had in Henrys haert was his treasure chest.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, he does seem to have really loved them both, which is all the more remarkable when you consider how little time he spent with his mother until he was in his late 20s.

@roodbennett

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling well he obviously knew her of her relentless quest to get his lands and title(s) back for him. It was medieval law that she could not retain custody, when she remarried.

I'm so sorry, HC, I had to give up half way through. I've never understood the multitude of convolutions of the Wars of the Roses and despite your excellent explanations I got hopelessly lost (again).

Catherine of Aragon wore Elizabeth's head dress. Pretty sure that one with diamond and rubies was hers.

Had my nephew paint a picture for my book. It is a red rose with defined thorns bleeding,. Woe!

Hi, awesome live history video I enjoyed it. How are you doing? I'm doing well and so is my cat Benjamin. We're both enjoying the warm weather. How is the weather where you are? Have a great day see you next video in the next video in the future could you do Robert Dudley. He was a historical man in the 16th century 😊

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thanks Michelle. Cloudy here unfortunately. Apparently Sunday was a nice day, but I only arrived back in Northern Ireland that night, so I missed most of it. Yes, something on Leicester is on my list :-)

Elizabeth was also the mother of two queens: Margaret of Scotland and Mary of France. And the grandmother of two more queens (and a king), although I guess if you keep going down the generations in that way, you would end up with every subsequent monarch of England, Scotland after Margaret, and the UK, etc. And heaven knows how many other kings and queens in other countries.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, absolutely. I tried to get cover the fact that she's the ancestor of all the monarchs of England (later Britain) from Henry VIII on with my little progenitrix comment at the start because, as you say, she's related to so many of them I wouldn't have been able to list them all :-)

We disagree on the ambitions of Henry and his mom but I sincerely enjoy your videos! Thank you for doing one on Elizabeth of York. History seems to forget that Henry VIII was descended from the Yorkists also. From the material history has left to us to interpret, it appears Elizabeth navigated her life with dignity and grace. I wonder if she felt she was marrying her sworn enemy? Circumstances changed so often during this period and it seems you never knew, from one day to the next, with whom your loyalties should lie. I do believe her reaction to her marriage helped the two sides finally start to come together and put an end to massive bloodshed. That is, until the next thing came along for the people to be divided about. Looking forward to more of your informative videos! Thanks!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

No problem. We can always agree to disagree. I really only every take issue with that when people are rude about it, but you obviously weren't at all, so thank you for that :-) Yes, it would be fascinating to know Elizabeth's private thoughts about the marriage. It's a pity we don't have more of her private papers.

What an excellent account. Thank you.

By the way your patron bio says you still upload videos on Fridays etc. (I much prefer the Monday schedule) I thought you’d want to know

I think she's fascinating! I wish there were more records of such amazing women. Whenever they are intelligent and politically savvy- they get the insult and threat of "witchcraft". Thank you again!!! ~Tammy

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, it is very annoying when that happens. Anne Boleyn has had similar insults thrown at her.

Great video

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you :-)

I always thought Anne Neville was buried under the right hand door, as you look at it, going into St Edwards Shrine? Where in the Abbey is this marker? Great video, by the way x

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

The marker is just to the right of Anne of Cleves' tomb, basically in front of Poets' Corner (so Poets' corner was behind me as I took the picture). I hope I'm explaining that well enough. It's been a while since I was there so I pray I'm visualising it properly in my head. I think I am :-)

That's a seriously complicated family tree - no wonder few people can understand it !

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Pity the poor soul (me!) who had to put it together as well :-)

@rickjensen2717

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling you have my sympathy 😊

I hope you had a great holiday HC and hitting the ground running with a cracking video. Elizabeth of York is a pivotal figure in English history. As a Plantagenet who married a Tudor, she is a fascinating person. Having had to endure 2 rounds of sanctuary in Westminster Abbey, the loss of her brothers, her half brothers, her Uncles, her mothers' lands and her own legitimacy, I should have thought this would have made her a very cautious and careful young girl. Just 1 misspoken word may have ended her life. I am not surprised we do not have much evidence from her as it could have been used in evidence against her by any enemy. Lord knows what she saw and heard as a youngster growing up. Whatever she thought about Richard 3rd, she was not going to let anyone know it, other than her mother. I should imagine she privately held him in contempt, but in public had to seem agreeable to her direct uncle. As for Henry 7th, it was supposed to be a love match of sorts. Not sure about that either, love does not seem to enter the equation with royal marriages, just a contract. I think Henry had to marry her to legitimise his own kingship and to stop the families from constant warring. What I don't get about her son Henry 8th is why he persecuted all the other Plantagenets in his family. He had his own children, so were they that much of a threat to him? Including old ladies? Thanks HC. 🙂

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thanks Elisabeth. Yes, she'd be a great dinner guest, wouldn't she (assuming you could get her talking about her family)? Henry VIII was kind enough to his remaining Plantagenet relatives for a long time, but as we know he got very nasty as he got older and when Lady Salisbury's son ticked him off, he took it out on her.

Truly a tumultuous life, it is a wonder she emerged from it all to be relatively normal. Wasn’t there something about her father considering marrying her to Henry Tudor when her engagement to the Dauphin fell through? Although that was probably a lure to get HT to England and on to the sharp end of E4’s sword.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, that was briefly discussed but like you (and Henry I think) I'm not sure I believe that Edward was being sincere.

Love her story. She's very over looked I think. Nice work. Thank you.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. I think so too. I'd love to have her to dinner and grill her about what she really thought of her uncle Richard and having to marry Henry VII and just everything to do with the Wars of the Roses really :-)

What are those head-dresses called? Not the English hood but the large white ones. Love your videos very informative

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Oh, I'm not sure I'm afraid. Google is probably your best bet for an answer to that one I think.

@maudzie93

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling 'Escoffion' is what seems to come up, something very striking about them, which was the idea I suppose

Welcome back!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Thank you. It's always rough having to go back to work though after a week off :-)

I am so glad you provided kinship diagrams.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yes, those family trees are a nightmare. I need the diagrams as much as my viewers do. It's such a headache to keep everyone straight.

I think Elizabeth of York was an educated young girl who knew that her marriage to Henry Vii was a diplomatic affair and not necessarily a romantic liaison; she knew that she had to wed Henry. However, I believe that she was aware that her brothers were both alive when she married and the last throw of the dice had been played when the Yorkists lost at the Battle of Stoke (Edward, her brother, may have been killed in the battle or survived and sent to Devon); her other brother Richard, was indeed 'Perkin Warbeck' but she was unable to confirm his identity as she had not seen him for many years and had an heir to think about; she was in a very difficult position - she had to side with her husband and her heir. It is a very sad story and must have been traumatic for her; she was a popular queen and died at a young age. Richard III did not kill his nephews : he would have executed his other nephew Edward to stop any power being taken from him. Thank you for your videos and time in putting out your informative content.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Hi there. Thank you for watching and commenting. While I don't think that the Princes in the Tower survived, we can certainly agree to disagree on that and what I do agree with you on, is that no matter what happened, it must indeed have been very very tough on poor Elizabeth.

@HonestyandTruth-re7db

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling Thank you for your respectful remark; we can indeed agree to disagree.

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Well I really appreciated you writing one that was polite as well. I get so many horrible people who disagree with my take on Richard and his nephews that it's always a pleasant surprise to get someone like yourself who can put across a view different to my own without being a nasty troll about it, so I wanted to acknowledge that and return the favour :-)

@HonestyandTruth-re7db

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling IF anyone killed the princes it wasn't Richard III, may I recommend a book, 'The Deceivers' by Geoffrey Richardson. His book is well written but I do not agree with his theory.

@mimisor66

Ай бұрын

​@@HonestyandTruth-re7dbcould the boys have made an escape? I find it strange that if they were killed, their bodies were not shown, as to put to rest any attempt to use their names to combat Richard's right to the throne. They could have claimed the boys died of disease.

great description of her!!

People didn’t value women, didn’t bother with portraits, weren’t too precious about birth dates, didn’t keep their personal correspondence. Not knowing that people would value what has been lost to history, hundreds of years on.

I think sometimes its easy to forget how young some of history's major players were. Elizabeth would have only been 16 when her uncle (alledgedly) killed her brothers, only 19 when she married Henry, a mother by 21 and she only lived until I think her mid-40s. I beleive she probably did have a deep disgust for her uncle but Im not sure her laying low was a political move about biding her time, I'm sure she was just terrified and unsure where to turn. Poor girl saw so much trauma when she was barely even an adult Edit: she actually only lived until she was 37. That's the age I am now and some days I still don't feel like a proper adult 😂

@emilybarclay8831

3 күн бұрын

The historical figure that always comes to mind when I think of what you said is one princess who’s name I cannot recall for the life of me who died at 21 while pregnant with her 7th child. Pretty sure she was married to her uncle. I shall scour the internet until I can find her name!

@emilybarclay8831

3 күн бұрын

Found her, Margaret Theresa of Spain. The sister of Charles II of Spain aka ‘Charles the bewitched’, her lineage was so horrifically inbred that she was actually more inbred than the offspring of two full siblings, and she was married to her uncle (who insisted his wife refer to him as uncle) at the age of 15 and spent the next 6 years constantly pregnant, dying at just 21 of exhaustion while four months pregnant. Of her 7 pregnancies only one of her children lived to adulthood, her daughter Maria Antonia, who herself died at 23 from complications from childbirth with her 3rd child. None of her children survived. Such an insane waste of life.

Elizabeth of York is one of my favourites in history!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE VERY KIND DONATION VICTORIA. I love Elizabeth too. It's taken me a couple of years to work my way through all the women of the Wars of the Roses to get to her, but I'm glad I finally made it. More net week on her Queenship too!

I feel like you can quiz me now with those family trees you show lol! They are a big help! It would make sense if elizabeth was highly suspicious of her uncle! Had he not have kidnapped them, assuming he did, King Edward V would have been on the thrown. Henry Tudor wouldn’t have even needed to be considered. Richard lll destroyed everything his brother built.

Whenever i read about the War of the Roses, i think that there is such a thing as too many sons.

Great video sad that it takes til next week

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Ah, but hopefully it'll be worth the wait to hear all about her Queenship. I just couldn't fit it all in in one video.

This is a really random thing, but to mix up the B-roll of that bouquet of roses, you could get a new bouquet and add some action to it, like maybe tossing them one by one onto a pile, or even just letting the petals flutter to the ground! I don't mean the suggestion to come off as rude, nor do I think mine are better! Maybe it's just my neurospicy brain that gets locked onto the fact that it's the same slow pan down the stems...and once you get down to the stems, the impact of the imagery is lost. If you could create movement within the frame, though, then you could keep the focus on the red and white roses! Anyway. I'm sorry, I know that has nothing to do with the content of the video. I always really enjoy watching your stuff!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

That's ok. I don't like having to reuse video either actually. I just filmed that in my garden though which is why they're lying on the grass. Had I panned up you'd have seen the house and my neighbours' houses and I wanted to keep it anonymous (also the houses don't fit in with the idea of the 15th century as you can probably imagine). I have other footage of white roses and red roses (separately), but what I'd really love is to find a great flowerbed in a National Trust property or the like that has both in it which I could then use.

Hi GGM!

Great video! You mentioned that Elizabeth would have been Elizabeth I. We know that when they ascend to the throne today they choose a regaining name (maybe different than their given name). When did that start?

@beth7935

19 күн бұрын

I don't know about any rules, but I know an even earlier example of a monarch taking on a different reigning name: Robert III of Scotland (r. 1390-1406, son of Robert II) was originally named John. He became king at 53, so he'd been John for a long time, & he already had a younger brother called Robert. I'd be kinda annoyed if my sibling stole my name to be king with, lol, but I have no idea how 14thc Scottish royalty felt about such things.

Thank you ☺️

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

And thank you for watching and commenting :-)

@melissasheppard6674

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling I found a cute fanfic about Elizabeth of York and Henry VII during their engagement prior to the wedding, on Archive of Our Own.

She’s always been my fav consort! 👸🏼

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

Yeah, I like her too. I wish we knew more about her.

Again, you did a magnificent job telling the story of the War of the Roses and my families history (my mother's maiden name is Westmoreland, direct ancestry to Anne Neville). I have studied my ancestry for over 20 years, dating it back to the 4th century and the War of the Roses, my family's civil war, has always been the most difficult part to follow and all it's players. THIS story and your narrating made it so simple to follow the twists and turns. Thank you so much!

@HistoryCalling

Ай бұрын

You're very welcome. I'm glad I could help. Westmoreland is a great surname. I've looked at some people in the 18th century who I suspect must be related to you too and I think there's a street in Dublin named after you/your mum.

@AmputeeAdventures

Ай бұрын

@@HistoryCalling A lot of Thomas' and Joseph's Westmorelands in that era are my great grands. I tracked the ancestry back to Erc, king of Dal Riada, Northern Ireland in 470 AD