California's Climate Hypocrisy | Jennifer Hernandez & Reihan Salam

American environmentalism is at a crossroads. Laws championed by environmental activists of the past are now hindering the reforms advocated by today's environmentalists, who deem them crucial to combat climate change. But lost in this debate between preservationists and climate hawks is a realistic understanding of the effects that "green" rules and regulations have on the everyday citizen. Nowhere is this clearer than in California.
Jennifer Hernandez practices environmental, land use, and civil rights law in California. She joins Reihan Salam to discuss the class politics of environmentalism and the failures of the Golden State's model of environmental regulation.
Related reading:
California’s Climate Hypocrisy, City Journal online, www.city-journal.org/article/...
California’s Administrative Power Grab Hurts Californians, Does Nothing For Climate; Breakthrough Journal, thebreakthrough.org/journal/n...

Пікірлер: 250

  • @nkder1
    @nkder110 ай бұрын

    Hernandez is so correct. California is not a state to emulate unless you WANT high energy prices, shortages and the highest poverty rate in the Country.

  • @alanrobertson9790

    @alanrobertson9790

    10 ай бұрын

    In a way the California experiment is good. It shows everyone else what not to do.

  • @pudding7074

    @pudding7074

    10 ай бұрын

    @@alanrobertson9790 I second that statement.

  • @zombieapocalypse3837

    @zombieapocalypse3837

    10 ай бұрын

    @@alanrobertson9790 If only "the people" are paying attention and are able to learn from this disaster of one-party rule. With the flight from California to other states, people tend to bring their political baggage with them, so I am not holding my breath.

  • @erikkovacs3097

    @erikkovacs3097

    10 ай бұрын

    Are you kidding? Gavin Newsom views California as a model that needs to be exported to the rest of the country. Most of the California government has this view. Most of the democratic party has this view.

  • @nkder1

    @nkder1

    10 ай бұрын

    @@erikkovacs3097 You are correct, they do tell everyone that everything in CA is wonderful. It is up to the rest of us to shine the light of truth on how bad democrat fascism truly is based on the actual effects of their policies on working people.

  • @erikjohnson2594
    @erikjohnson259410 ай бұрын

    I'm a Californian and am pretty aware of the news. However, most Californians are mystified by why our electric bills have tripled in the last few years, why produce is so expensive (inflation + punitive water prices even for farmers + higher shipping costs), why modest homes cost a million dollars, why our gas prices are sometimes double the national average.

  • @JamesFitzgerald
    @JamesFitzgerald10 ай бұрын

    The problem is apocalyptic environmentalism is the defacto religion of the managerial/professional class. No sacrifice is too severe to impose upon the working class and the poor. For the m/p class these expenses are trivial. Btw, it is not just EVs that impose costs upon the working class and poor. Ever ratcheting fuel economy standards result in auto engines with a rube goldberg air/fuel/exhaust sensors that eventually fail and impose severe costs upon lower income people for no significant improvement in air quality while allowing the wealthy who support these programs to feel superior to the working people who make this great state work. The politicians are ratcheting up the costs of energy and transportation to the poor for no good reason other than to make themselves feel virtuous and superior to the common people. It has too stop.

  • @captsorghum

    @captsorghum

    10 ай бұрын

    Note the CAFE standards as currently implemented are based on length and wheelbase of the vehicle, at least for trucks and SUVs. Larger vehicles are allowed to burn more fuel, so it's easier to meet the requirements.

  • @alanwilson3661
    @alanwilson366110 ай бұрын

    Ownership of property is the key to wealth creation.

  • @Sovereign_Citizen_LEO

    @Sovereign_Citizen_LEO

    10 ай бұрын

    And the Globalist Usury International Central Bankers/ WEF/ etc. who are forcing Communism on us, are all about abolishing Private Property. That is what the Global Warming/ "Sustainable Development" Climate Conspiracy is all about. The real goal is to destroy the Middle Class, by making Energy/ Oil unaffordable. The method is to Create Artificial Scarcity Under the Guise of Environmental Necessity.

  • @jerrymoore838

    @jerrymoore838

    10 ай бұрын

    Exactly

  • @ESLforDoctors
    @ESLforDoctors10 ай бұрын

    this is the most important political issue of our day. WEF is trying to export California's disaster to the world.

  • @Sovereign_Citizen_LEO

    @Sovereign_Citizen_LEO

    10 ай бұрын

    And it has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with Climate. Global Warming is a 100% scam (a Conspiracy to bring about a Communist World Government controlled by Globalist Usury International Central Bankers). The real goal of all of this, is to "Create Artifical Scarcity Under the Guise of Environmental Necessity". The purpose is to destroy the American and Western Middle Class. They know very well, that if they destroy the Middle Class, financially (and that is exactly what they've been doing and what the Plandemic was about and now Biden and massive Inflation/ two Great Recessions/ Depressions in barely a decade) they remove all Political Power from the people, and can therefore consolidate the Power of the Democrat Communist Party.

  • @wheel-man5319

    @wheel-man5319

    8 ай бұрын

    🤯

  • @JamesFitzgerald
    @JamesFitzgerald10 ай бұрын

    This is music to my ears. California doesn't care about the working class.

  • @jazzfan7491

    @jazzfan7491

    10 ай бұрын

    Hardly. California is working hard to build a ton more housing as fast as possible. California may not "care" about the working class resenting minorities. But it certainly cares that the working class have decent lives and high incomes. That's why so many people want to live there. 🤓

  • @christopherkelly9985

    @christopherkelly9985

    10 ай бұрын

    @@jazzfan7491did you not listen to the interview?

  • @wheel-man5319

    @wheel-man5319

    8 ай бұрын

    ​@@christopherkelly9985Obviously it didn't. It is a shill for the oppressors.

  • @christopherd6399
    @christopherd639910 ай бұрын

    I'm so glad i stumbled upon this video! I love listening to brilliance.

  • @edwarddiamond9696
    @edwarddiamond969610 ай бұрын

    Ex native Californian: Hollywood has hyped and glamorized the California dream lifestyle for well over 100 years. The VC and tech. industry served to fuel the flames of desire. If you are a wealthy incumbent, what better way to raise your status then make it increasingly unaffordable to even exist in California. Kind of like the old taunting, aspirational phrase about NYC... if you can make it there, you can make it anywhere.

  • @williamstuhldreher2466
    @williamstuhldreher246610 ай бұрын

    Awesome interview. As a transplant Texan, we laugh uncontrollably at the sheer monomania characterizing the dominant Democrat powerhouse running modern California. Sadly, many of us non-Californians who have visited, and/or worked there spending varying amounts of time do love the place.

  • @shortstraw4

    @shortstraw4

    10 ай бұрын

    Texas is five years from flipping blue so get ready

  • @bearowen5480

    @bearowen5480

    10 ай бұрын

    Love the place that it was, or the place it is becoming?

  • @nkder1

    @nkder1

    10 ай бұрын

    @@shortstraw4 Not even close.

  • @captsorghum

    @captsorghum

    10 ай бұрын

    Seems like it got worse around 2010, when California switched from so-called modified open primaries, to fully open top-two primaries. At the time this was billed as a way to elect more moderates, but it seems to have had the opposite effect.

  • @maryflores2301

    @maryflores2301

    10 ай бұрын

    @@shortstraw4in your dreams. Not gonna happen. That’s why the Democrats are wanting all of these illegals in. Not gonna happen, dream on.

  • @joenaylor34
    @joenaylor3410 ай бұрын

    Oh my gosh this is exactly what I figured out myself (but couldn’t express as eloquently as this speaker): a lot of these radical progressive initiatives are going to put a huge financial burden squarely on the poorest people. When California begins to run out of working class people to maintain the roads, pick up the trash, run the fast food places etc. maybe a lot of foolishness will stop.

  • @lauravictorious4670

    @lauravictorious4670

    10 ай бұрын

    The foolishness won't stop until the wicked people running and ruining California are removed from power.

  • @bearowen5480

    @bearowen5480

    10 ай бұрын

    By the time that the foolishness stops, it will be way too late to save the once great and noble state of California.

  • @bonniechase5599

    @bonniechase5599

    10 ай бұрын

    I suspect that this has become the intent, to consolidate power. Any thinking person now knows how dopey the CO2 narrative is, so the draconian measures are not about saving the environment.

  • @juliusjanardhanseptimus352

    @juliusjanardhanseptimus352

    10 ай бұрын

    No it will not. It will be a drug lords haven, a crime haven, a illegal alien haven, and it will revert to a its neighbouring state south, a narco state (to some extent it already is) and a black african state. The deep blue monster is trying to move to other states to devour and it is jailing all its opponents by any and all means.

  • @yasi4877

    @yasi4877

    10 ай бұрын

    That's why there are illegal migrants

  • @tedhamilton2362
    @tedhamilton236210 ай бұрын

    Shifting pollution production from one country to another doesn't reduce pollution. Air moves over the planet and if a very 'dirty' country's air moves 'next door' to the clean country, the air gets dirty there too. Madness!

  • @Sovereign_Citizen_LEO

    @Sovereign_Citizen_LEO

    10 ай бұрын

    Exactly. And all the so-called clean energy "technologies" are the most polluting environmentally destructive industries/ technologies in existence (overall barely less polluting than fossil fuel powered vehicles if were talking about vehicles and their lifetime emissions). And the end of life toxic waste and environmental pollution is far worse.

  • @captsorghum

    @captsorghum

    10 ай бұрын

    Imported solar panels and EV components do exactly that.

  • @somewhere6
    @somewhere610 ай бұрын

    When I have gone to California, I have not met the people likely to support these policies. Nonetheless, they are obviously there and dug in.

  • @sethbrodie

    @sethbrodie

    9 ай бұрын

    I live in CA. I support these policies (they are not perfect). I'm not rich (I do own most of a house). The issue is complicated, but I believe climate is not a "value", it is reality. I choose not to live in denial. It's your right to do so, but I will not. Sacrifices must be made for the good of all.

  • @somewhere6

    @somewhere6

    9 ай бұрын

    @@sethbrodie The denial is in people who refuse to look at the history of the climate or even study the data at all and yet blindly adhere to a force-fed ideology that demands that you make sacrifices that the people pushing it never will because they know it is fraud.

  • @wheel-man5319

    @wheel-man5319

    8 ай бұрын

    ​@@sethbrodieyou're suicidal.

  • @captsorghum
    @captsorghum10 ай бұрын

    Perhaps the best interview I've seen on KZread. This speaks to things I've always known at some level, and fills in many of the blanks. The hypocrisy is nothing new; just look at tax policy with regard to housing. California still allows pre-TCJA limits for mortgage interest and property tax deductions. So owner-occupants generally get a 9.3 percent discount on these expenses (on top of federal deductions), while renters pay them as part of their rent with no discount. The value of these tax deductions roughly scales with the price of the home. So California rewards home buyers, and indirectly builders and lenders, for building MacMansions with long commutes. Those serving Bay Area commuters are now being built in the central valley. All of this requires more freeway lanes and other infrastructure. The central valley is known for 108F summers, so these 3000 square foot tract homes use a ton of energy on air conditioning at a time of day when the grid is most heavily loaded. If California politicians were sincere about reducing carbon emissions, they would start by phasing out expensive tax policies that encourage this sort of waste, before spending more to subsidize solar installations and EVs that only benefit those who don't need help. Don't get me wrong, I have no objection to people living where they want and driving what they want, so long as I'm not paying taxes to support their lifestyle.

  • @catallaxy
    @catallaxy10 ай бұрын

    Jennifer Hernandez, is using her brains. Thank you, very much.

  • @christopherkelly9985
    @christopherkelly998510 ай бұрын

    Fantastic interview. Jennifer is a hero!

  • @titan2583
    @titan258310 ай бұрын

    Funny how states are destroyed and run into the ground over many year, but people still keep voting the same way, even if they move state, they never learn.

  • @ReneeCaraway

    @ReneeCaraway

    10 ай бұрын

    Not funny. Sad.

  • @damagingthebrand7387

    @damagingthebrand7387

    10 ай бұрын

    Greatest propaganda ever, there are only two parties. Republicans are the worst party I can imagine... except the modern Democratic party.

  • @JamesAnderson-dp1dt
    @JamesAnderson-dp1dt10 ай бұрын

    That system isn't broken at all. The outcomes you warn of are actively desired. Consider electrical companies like those in Hawaii and California. First, expensive Green mandates are imposed, which the companies have to spend massively to meet -- which defers maintenance and brush-clearing. Prices go way up IF the state Democrats will allow a rate increase. Eventually electricity gets too expensive. OR, state Dems *refuse* rate increases, as they've done in Hawaii, and you get horrible fires sparked by the lousy, aging infrastructure which the electric company can't afford to repair. Then the lawsuits drive the company toward bankruptcy. In either case, what will be left to do? Why, the Dem-controlled government will just *have* to take over the electric company. Only responsible thing to do, right? And the Democrat party, which openly raves against the capitalist system and constantly seeks more government control, gets what it wants -- government control over yet another sector of the economy. Same with housing. When their "necessary" mandates result in enough people losing their homes or being unable to rent, the Dems will take control of housing. The State will build and maintain whatever sort of housing it thinks people should have. And before dismissing this as a conspiracy theory, take a close look at the way so many Progressives are touting and demanding State Socialism. Note how running these things into the ground dovetails neatly with their expressed desire to wrest control away from the capitalist system so that government can ensure all these things itself. If you believe that they mean what they say, and that damaging private-enterprise systems tends to make their stated goals possible, the most reasonable explanation is that this stuff is "feature", not "bug".

  • @JamesAnderson-dp1dt

    @JamesAnderson-dp1dt

    10 ай бұрын

    Same thing with cars. Most people won't be able to afford an EV, and the grid couldn't handle it anyway. Nor will the charger infrastructure be there. There'll be fires, collapsed parking garages, massively decreased state revenue from gasoline taxes. How can this work? It isn't intended to work. It's intended to fail in such a fashion that Dems get most people out of their cars, which Democrats have openly stated they want to do. If you're wondering what happens to rural folk who can't afford EVs yet rely upon being able to drive to work and to buy food -- Dem politicians and most Dem votes don't care what becomes of them. The only people who they think exist, or even deserve to exist, are the Blue-voting urbanite lemmings like themselves.

  • @Sovereign_Citizen_LEO

    @Sovereign_Citizen_LEO

    10 ай бұрын

    And the Democrats are not the ones behind it. It is the Globalist Usury International Central Bankers and their agents and allies who lobby the Democrats to destroy America, and put them in Political Power so that they sell out our nation for their own personal wealth and career advancement.

  • @charlesdunbar1211
    @charlesdunbar121110 ай бұрын

    Nice to see someone that sees California's stupid policies for what they are. The big question is how do we get the right people elected with such corrupt voting system.

  • @captsorghum

    @captsorghum

    10 ай бұрын

    Seems like it got worse around 2010 with the advent of top-two open primaries.

  • @mariocaponera7918
    @mariocaponera791810 ай бұрын

    These bureacrats should be held accountable for the $ damages to every single citizen & business

  • @uncletoy774
    @uncletoy77410 ай бұрын

    ANOTHER GREAT INTERVIEW YOU NEED TO DO IS PATRICK MOORE

  • @bearowen5480

    @bearowen5480

    10 ай бұрын

    Yes, and Bjorn Lundberg and Willie Soon too.

  • @uncletoy774

    @uncletoy774

    10 ай бұрын

    @@bearowen5480 B.......I.......N......G.......O....BINGO MY FRIEND

  • @GailForce-eu5kx
    @GailForce-eu5kx10 ай бұрын

    WELL DONE and TRUE

  • @cisnerosigonda
    @cisnerosigonda10 ай бұрын

    Thank you for this conversation. This has been on my mind for the last years as a life long Californian.... What the hell is environmentalism if it simply destroys traditional ways of life? If feels, just like Covid, a little too convenient. When people make the greed argument - or even the selfish NIMBY - it still does not capture the control component. There is something that is fundamentally about control in climate. If EVERYTHING emits, then ANYTHING can be made illegal, including travel, food, Jesus, the skate park down the road. So this gets spelled out to the micron of CO2. Why does this momentum exist? Is it a Communist Spirit? Does it have a brain? Money certainly talks. It could just be extortion, monopolies, and world government. I think the UN has to go. It sucks as a climate arbiter, as a peace making unit and even as a human rights forum. It is useless. But I digress. We are not the bees knees here in Cali. As much as it's gone to our heads. We created our own artificial environment full of movies and tech, glamor and riches that makes us presumptuous. The stitches are starting to come off with our reality can suck me I don't need materials or even energy. The final Omm that nobody heard. I hope that people at a basic level get pissed about something if only that they were robbed of two years of their lives.

  • @dallasweaver4061
    @dallasweaver406110 ай бұрын

    The activists who cause all this damage benefit. We need to make the activists liable for their damages. We have some laws that allow these attorneys to collect "legal costs" that are padded with the costs of their "experts" which is why they file against agencies. It looks like organizations like CBD which has lots of lawyers and very unimpressive "experts" make a good parasitic living feeding off of agencies. A change in the law making lawyers liable for the costs imposed upon others would make legal parasites a less profitable business and we would have less of it.

  • @CarlStreet
    @CarlStreet10 ай бұрын

    Outstanding!

  • @JohnWOler
    @JohnWOler10 ай бұрын

    Yountville, CA is a prime example of NIMBY. Nearly all of the service workers I met there, lived in Fairfield and beyond, while residential homes are owned by the super rich and maintained as vacation homes. Yountville Elementary School had to shut down because families have been priced out of their own town. EAT THE RICH

  • @doyourbest7655
    @doyourbest765510 ай бұрын

    An environmental attorney that gets it? Wow!

  • @anthonymorris5084
    @anthonymorris508410 ай бұрын

    Newsom: No ICE cars will be allowed in California by the year 2035. Exactly one week later - Newsom: Please stop charging your cars between certain hours because the electric grid can't handle it.

  • @nix2knicks24
    @nix2knicks2410 ай бұрын

    So true. Wealthy ideologues write and benefit from policies that crush those in lower income brackets ranging from poverty to middle class. Homes in California have been made unaffordable for people trying to get a first home. Incentives for electric cars, or solar panels or eco landscaping are targeted toward people who already own property. They eventually save those home owners more money making the already wealthy and fortunate even wealthier. For people who rent, the rent increases are so high there’s getting to be no chance of saving up for a home in the future. Renters do not have the ability for tax breaks or wealth growth from incentives targeted at building updates. No infrastructure has been built around renters reliably charging electric cars. People aren’t only driving petrol because the don’t care about the environment, they’re driving them because environmental infrastructure is only being built for the wealthy.

  • @wheel-man5319

    @wheel-man5319

    8 ай бұрын

    The poor get poorer, and the rich get richer. Oh I'm absolutely certain that we actually have a dangerously low level of co2 in the atmosphere.

  • @captsorghum
    @captsorghum10 ай бұрын

    A small point that doesn't really change the argument: catalytic converters use precious metals and not rare earth elements. Rare earth elements are mostly used in the production of magnets and electronic devices.

  • @catallaxy
    @catallaxy10 ай бұрын

    Socialism as an ideology, had it's credibility injured by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's book “The Gulag Archipelago” when it won the Nobel prize for literature in 1973. Sixteen years later, communism collapsed in the Soviet Union, after 40 years of Hell on Earth. The mastermind of a Marxist think tank in Germany, Heinrich Boell, saw the writing on the wall, in 1973, when he read the book and used his Marxist cell to brainstorm an alternative to Socialism, as a reaction to The Gulag Archipelago. Boell's cell founded the first Green Party, in the world, in Germany, in 1975. They decided to requisition and modify The Communist Manifesto by substituting the constituency of the “Worker” and the “Working Class” with “Nature” and the “Environment”. The bad guys remained the same, the Free Market Enterprise System (“Capitalism” according to Karl Marx.) When communism did collapse, in 1989, the Leftists went into a profound depression. Then they noticed Boell's Environmentalism and realized that it was a good vehicle for Marxism, in lieu of Socialism, after its credibility was finally destroyed, after the people of Eastern Europe rejected it, en mass. Therefore, Environmentalism is the new Marxist ideology moving into the 21st century.

  • @debbiechristie9241
    @debbiechristie924110 ай бұрын

    Yeah, rare minerals in a Cadillac converter in a lot of areas of poor people one in five Cadillac converters literally sawed out with electric, saws and stolen

  • @nicoledickens2366
    @nicoledickens236610 ай бұрын

    Heat pumps on our already poorly run electric system. Ridiculous.

  • @moleman1211
    @moleman121110 ай бұрын

    Fun fact, because of california's "green" policies, i cant afford to replace my catalytic converter in my car, so my car is spewing out smog like a mofo.

  • @anthonymorris5084
    @anthonymorris50849 ай бұрын

    Environmentalists are great at bringing to public attention environmental issues. Just never let an environmental solve the problem. Their solution always is "you can't do that anymore".

  • @wheel-man5319

    @wheel-man5319

    8 ай бұрын

    It's also you can't build that!

  • @cherylnagy126
    @cherylnagy12610 ай бұрын

    Rare Earth minerals are expensive as well as highly toxic

  • @bearowen5480

    @bearowen5480

    10 ай бұрын

    And often mined and processed by state-enslaved or oppressed laborers!

  • @alexanderzebroski2391

    @alexanderzebroski2391

    10 ай бұрын

    @@bearowen5480 Let us remember that it was the CCP that put America's biggest rare earth mineral mine out of business.

  • @reddahlias2595
    @reddahlias259510 ай бұрын

    She makes too much sense to be in California. The NPR tone of the interview is funny because NPR would never have her on their propaganda station.

  • @nicoledickens2366
    @nicoledickens236610 ай бұрын

    28:13 it's coming from the resentment around the 90's car companies refusal to go electric. That's why Elon established Tesla in the first place. It's just been abstracted so far that it's Chesterton's Fence.

  • @johnl5316
    @johnl531610 ай бұрын

    Yet, the majority of Californians would rather have these consequences than vote for a different political party. They are going down with the ship. And their laws adversely affect the rest of the county

  • @lauravictorious4670

    @lauravictorious4670

    10 ай бұрын

    It's not the voters is the voting fraud that gets and keeps the public serpents in power.

  • @daniellarson3068

    @daniellarson3068

    10 ай бұрын

    Do they have a choice? You've got Democrats or the guys who invaded the Capital and do not even believe in global warming.

  • @debbiechristie9241
    @debbiechristie924110 ай бұрын

    Do you want to help the poor think the Like poor, we don’t have homes we don’t have garages, we live in shady areas with lots of crime a lot of us rent apartments so we can’t have solar panels on our roofs, want to help the poor think like the poor, and Americans first

  • @cherylnagy126
    @cherylnagy12610 ай бұрын

    Critical Thinking would enable the lawmakers to project, to extrapolate, the logical consequences, the logical results, of the legislation being enacted.

  • @christophercharles3169
    @christophercharles316910 ай бұрын

    Climate policies never favor the poor. Remember that when you laugh at or scold someone who believes its about control.

  • @rogerlong6969
    @rogerlong696910 ай бұрын

    If human beings actually had an endless source of free clean green energy… Which does not exist it would only fuel the acceleration of the destruction of the biosphere. Deforestation, ocean, depletion, habitat, loss, desertification, biodiversity loss, soil, degradation, groundwater, depletion, global, warming, overpopulation, rampant, pollution, and the six mass extinction would all continue to accelerate exponentially.

  • @CJinsoo
    @CJinsoo10 ай бұрын

    This a great video. About a quarter way through and half to point out that a big part of the problem is a misunderstanding of basic economics and incentives. For example, even if the steel industry could become competitive in 1975, it would mean electric arc furnaces and getting rid of 90% of the employees. The companies AND the unions milked it dry. they extracted as much as they could out of it and made it impossible to transition to a moe competitive industry. Look no farther than Weirton Steel, which had the employees take over the company. they stuck around for 20 more years but they also shed roughly 90% of their employees-and this was employee owned. On the elites side, they have a command and control vision of the world. they are dangerous psychopaths when you give them this much control over people’s lives. they don’t understand basic economics, they think you can just force everything to close and everything you want to be produced. But they have no awareness of how incredibly foolish and impossible their vision is to implement, as well as dangerous.

  • @fossil9158
    @fossil915810 ай бұрын

    The sale of new gas powered lawnmowers, leaf blowers, and chainsaws, at or below 25 HP, are also banned in CA as of January 2024. Haven't heard of firefighters being exempt. Next year's fire season could get interesting. And the sale of new portable gas powered generators will be banned as of 2028.

  • @daniellarson3068

    @daniellarson3068

    10 ай бұрын

    What if someone drives to Oregon or Nevada to buy one? Just spill some paint on it to make it look old.

  • @captsorghum

    @captsorghum

    10 ай бұрын

    @@daniellarson3068 I wonder if the agricultural checkpoints on the border will begin checking for illegal gas engines, rather than bug-infested fruit.

  • @kewlbeone5949
    @kewlbeone594910 ай бұрын

    100% true

  • @gregpatterson1988
    @gregpatterson198810 ай бұрын

    Great information.

  • @happyinparadise7812
    @happyinparadise781210 ай бұрын

    I'm from California. Very far from!! Gracias Dios

  • @casebeth
    @casebeth10 ай бұрын

    California has abysmal transit. This also needs to change

  • @ronunderwood5771
    @ronunderwood577110 ай бұрын

    There are electric semis operating in California in and around the ports. Most are being charged by diesel powered generators. Because the local grids can’t handle the truth. Opps, I meant load.

  • @ceecee6679
    @ceecee667910 ай бұрын

    Government needs to butt out of our lifestyles.

  • @1bookhouse1
    @1bookhouse110 ай бұрын

    An excllent discussion, brilliant in its frank, common sense, and reality-based argument. Hitting on all the concerns anpbiut the Green New Deal agenda. I do think that linking this to the racial aspect of Jim Crow is lazy and cheapens/over simplifies this very complex message. As indicated, this is an economic and class divide. Not a racial one. Paradise California was economically very poor and 94% white. She really hits on the fad aspect.

  • @CSGATI
    @CSGATI10 ай бұрын

    They take a problem with a magnitude of 2 and act like it is an 11 crazy people.

  • @kimwiser445
    @kimwiser44510 ай бұрын

    Serfdom. Where do they think the tax dollars are going to come from when they destroy all these industries?

  • @hestermalatesta5355
    @hestermalatesta535510 ай бұрын

    I live in Middletown, Ohio. We're lucky to even have a busing system, The Butler County Regional Transit Authority, and free to ride, for now, at that, but it's still a huge hassle riding fixed routes that only hit a given stop once an hour, for example having to decide whether to ride a bus almost all the way around again for 50 minutes, to get from the YMCA at a local hospital, to Towne Blvd. where there are 3 grocery store chains, or go on a 40-minute walk for the sake of not waiting around, on a trip that by car, is probably 5 minutes. There is a shuttle service, called BGo, that costs $5 per way, but it has limited availability, and also wait time. Cities like Cincinnati and Dayton have more bus lines, that run every 15 or 30 minutes, and the BCRTA lines in Oxford serve Miami University students, and so are more frequent. But I have only ever lived in semi-post-industrial suburbs, Hamilton, for my first 32 years, and now Middletown, since 2020. I depend on a voucher to make rent, so I am kind of stuck at an apartment complex that doesn't offer recycling pickup, by a creek that's covered in growth, my guess is from fertilizer runoff. There's potential for more local food growing, though. A lot of good land, even with the invasive honeysuckle and Bradford pear trees, lol, the latter of which, now, it's finally illegal to sell or plant in housing developments. There are lots of walnut trees, if anyone felt like gathering and processing them. And Sunchokes. I'm going to be taking a Master Gardener class starting at the end of September, 2023. Just the other day, I was thinking about how goldenrod plants, which have yellow flowers pollinators love, and have sturdy stems, and can even get to like 7feet tall, could serve the same role as corn, for climbing beans, in a Three Sisters planting system. It's exhausting getting places though, without a personal vehicle. And being limited to certain stops, setting an entire day's trajectory, instead of being able to wander.

  • @daniellarson3068

    @daniellarson3068

    10 ай бұрын

    Not sure how this links with the woman's discussion, but nice piece. I have long had this thought that if goldenrod could somehow be made into an edible crop, a lot of marginal land could be cultivated.

  • @jazzfan7491
    @jazzfan749110 ай бұрын

    Is the Manhattan Institute calling for the end of single family zoning? California Republicans will certainly be interested to hear that.

  • @GailForce-eu5kx
    @GailForce-eu5kx10 ай бұрын

    TRUST ME

  • @tomb5552
    @tomb555210 ай бұрын

    Heat pumps run about $11,000 installed.

  • @cherylnagy126
    @cherylnagy12610 ай бұрын

    remote work is only made possible through the use of Computers, which necessitate the use of highly toxic components in their manufacture.

  • @jamesrosskelly
    @jamesrosskelly10 ай бұрын

    The take on forests on Federal Lands saying that the existing condition is being protected is not so. NEPA (the National Environmental Policy Act) requires only that the "existing condition" is described. If the existing condition has over stocked forest then that is the no action alternative and the Agency (Forest Service or BLM) can prescribe thinning and logging. Other laws impinge upon this like the Endangered Species Act and create side boards. NEPA does not protect the existing condition. Does CEQA (an act modeled on NEPA) really do this? Most every thing else is a stellar description of what is going on.

  • @michaelmcmenzie6928
    @michaelmcmenzie692810 ай бұрын

    The new laws are unconstitutional and some lawyer needs to step up and behalf of these middle class poor people ensue the state but they won't

  • @benrasmussen9878
    @benrasmussen98789 ай бұрын

    nice information. That is why we moved out of state.

  • @luck484
    @luck48410 ай бұрын

    I am looking to find the AQMD document mentioned. I also want to find policies that allow or support such legislation. I am to angry to express myself.

  • @standTrueNorthStrongandFree
    @standTrueNorthStrongandFree9 ай бұрын

    wouldn't know where to begin.. critiquing

  • @MrSkid56
    @MrSkid5610 ай бұрын

    A Heat Pump is part of the AirConditioning system as it removes heat from the inside living area. A water heater can be either Electric or Natural gas powered to add heat to the water used inside the house or apartment for water uses. A stand alone Air Conditioning window mounted unit are more expensive to use as they are plugged into 110v as opposed to a more energy efficient wired on a separate 220v on a 60 Amp breaker.

  • @leonardeast3389

    @leonardeast3389

    10 ай бұрын

    There are heat pump water heaters now being sold. They draw heat from the room to heat the water, rather than generating heat directly from gas or electricity. There are also integrated heat pump systems that combine heating, air conditioning, and water heating: www.energy.gov/energysaver/heat-pump-water-heaters. These systems are incredibly expensive, compared to the conventional ones. She's saying that soon, in CA, you won't be able to purchase a conventional gas or electric water heater.

  • @captsorghum

    @captsorghum

    10 ай бұрын

    The efficiency difference between 115 and 230 is trivial. Whole-house units use a lot of energy pushing air through ducts, including into rooms that are not even in use.

  • @robertpoen5383
    @robertpoen538310 ай бұрын

    5:00 "You can have a strong, robust middle-class industrial economy and also a cleaner environment that is healthier, safer." Can you? Really? Under what laws of physics is that even possible? It's the same mentality that gave us "infinite growth on a finite planet."

  • @glenndavis4452
    @glenndavis445210 ай бұрын

    It is a very obvious fact that our politicians do not have any idea of basic physics and thermodynamics. So they are hostage to the “climate hysteria” science, and don’t want to listen to any of other highly qualified PhDs who know far better about the impossibility of CO2 leading to the massive extra heat energy required to increase our gigantic planet surface temperature. In general I agree with many environmental issues, but this one is based on badly flawed science and mathematical models. It is really frustrating watching politicians who have no idea what the real science is doing things that are economically disastrous in the name of saving the planet. If you are up to understanding some science, Tom Nelson has a excellent channel with many, many real scientists explaining how wrong GGGW theory is.

  • @StephenGillie
    @StephenGillie10 ай бұрын

    This is almost a feature length presentation. Could you release a shorter version that's edited to like 5-15 minutes and is more focused?

  • @dennismiller5725
    @dennismiller572510 ай бұрын

    Watch "Not just bikes"

  • @occamsrazor1285
    @occamsrazor128510 ай бұрын

    0:56 Bay Area native!

  • @andylangeland496
    @andylangeland49610 ай бұрын

    This lady is doing the Lord's work...

  • @stanleytolle416
    @stanleytolle41610 ай бұрын

    The cost of electric cars is massively dropping. CA needs to build nuclear reactors with heat storage to counter act the problems with renewable electric generation. Charging will become more common everywhere. Even heat pump are dropping in price. Biggest problem not gearing things to lower income people.

  • @andylangeland496

    @andylangeland496

    10 ай бұрын

    Instead they (we) shut down our nuclear plants... only one left operating

  • @jackjarrett3738
    @jackjarrett373810 ай бұрын

    "A growing state"!!(?)

  • @edpiv2233
    @edpiv223310 ай бұрын

    If you look at the climate change disclaimer that they put under the title, what are the long term shifts in weather patterns?Specifically. Just wondering.

  • @shpedoikal

    @shpedoikal

    10 ай бұрын

    Heavier precipitation, stronger storms, more temperature extremes (both high and low), longer periods of drought.

  • @yasi4877

    @yasi4877

    10 ай бұрын

    @@shpedoikal No so

  • @cdineaglecollapsecenter4672
    @cdineaglecollapsecenter467210 ай бұрын

    Surely there has to be a way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions without further impoverishing the already impoverished. I'm willing to bet the Manhattan Institute isn't interested in coming up with it though. I live in a mobile home. I try hard to keep my greenhouse gas emissions down. I don't want to be used as an excuse to keep the fossil fuel companies in business.

  • @cherylnagy126
    @cherylnagy12610 ай бұрын

    reevaluation of legislation which is presently extant

  • @wallyblackler46
    @wallyblackler4610 ай бұрын

    Can I get a film of those people going and collecting peoples cars should be really good kind of messy but good

  • @shpedoikal
    @shpedoikal10 ай бұрын

    Heat pumps use less power than gas furnaces + air conditioning units. Plus you use no gas. What are they talking about?

  • @captsorghum

    @captsorghum

    10 ай бұрын

    Aren't they talking about electrical power? Gas furnaces don't use any, except to move air through a central unit. Wall-mounted A/C units are generally lower capacity, therefore less power-hungry to cool a single room.

  • @shpedoikal

    @shpedoikal

    10 ай бұрын

    I'll explain. A heart pump uses electricity for a blower and a pump. A gas furnace has a blower plus a compressor and fan. When I swapped out my gas furnace for geothermal, my electric bill went down and my gas bill disappeared.

  • @captsorghum

    @captsorghum

    10 ай бұрын

    @@shpedoikal Why would a gas furnace have a compressor? What is there to compress? There is a blower and small fan to guarantee a draft. Older wall furnaces have neither. Heat pumps use a compressor (perhaps what you are calling a pump) as well as a fan and blower (or two fans).

  • @sethbrodie
    @sethbrodie9 ай бұрын

    There is a lot wrong in this, but let me just say this. Climate is not a "value", it is objective reality. If you think humanity can be saved without any sacrifice, you are wrong. If you think the wealthy will suffer less, well, welcome to America.

  • @MrNomyar
    @MrNomyar10 ай бұрын

    Similar environmental policies, or more precise energy transition policies, are causing poverty in Europe too. Farmers and fisheries are stopped, but there seems to be no integral vision. Living in cities with global supplies is only helping multinational companies and globalists, who are well penetrated into governments and ngo's. Not so much the average civilian unfortunately.

  • @jamesdellaneve9005
    @jamesdellaneve900510 ай бұрын

    We've not got bottom. Just move.

  • @KaplenPayne
    @KaplenPayne10 ай бұрын

    The people worried about the climate want me to forgo my sustainable garden, solar power and contained livestock out in my rural land. And go consume in a dense horrible urban area.... Plz stay in cali

  • @jamesruscheinski8602
    @jamesruscheinski86029 ай бұрын

    develop substantive choice republic

  • @cherylnagy126
    @cherylnagy12610 ай бұрын

    metamorphosed

  • @cryptodoc-SD
    @cryptodoc-SD9 ай бұрын

    You will own nothing and be happy.

  • @wheel-man5319

    @wheel-man5319

    8 ай бұрын

    Klaus Schwab.....

  • @hellokitty8552
    @hellokitty855210 ай бұрын

    I thought ivys don’t offer scholarships.

  • @alexanderzebroski2391

    @alexanderzebroski2391

    10 ай бұрын

    Need based.

  • @KaplenPayne
    @KaplenPayne10 ай бұрын

    15:15 did you tho? Might wanna brush up on china's economy

  • @mountbara
    @mountbara9 ай бұрын

    You can call it the green jim crow, but it has zero to do with race and everything to do with class.

  • @wheel-man5319

    @wheel-man5319

    8 ай бұрын

    It does have everything to do with class. But never doubt that racism is at least as much of a reason.

  • @mountbara

    @mountbara

    8 ай бұрын

    @@wheel-man5319 If it is not expressly racism, then you are projecting your own feelings on it.

  • @shastacastor
    @shastacastor9 ай бұрын

    Elder and Shellenberger would have helped tame this bs but ca voted for the status quo. I love this woman but I have trouble feeling bad for Californians. CA will end up with super rich and homeless drug addicts. Congrats.

  • @wheel-man5319

    @wheel-man5319

    8 ай бұрын

    There's no way that tbtb would let go of their power.

  • @shpedoikal
    @shpedoikal10 ай бұрын

    Blaming forest fires on "a failure of forest management" is total nonsense

  • @andylangeland496

    @andylangeland496

    10 ай бұрын

    Wildfires are not exceptional in California history... but when you don't allow removal of dead trees it is literally "adding fuel to the fire" - this was going on for years, I know the government relented for a bit after several bad fire seasons and allowed some removal of dead trees in the past decade ... live trees are really hard to burn in and of themselves... the indigenous tribes used to burn the Yosemite Valley floor to prevent larger/out of control wild fires. This is not specific to California... the indigenous people in Virginia historically burned the forest as well - the fires would clear the underbrush but leave the large trees still alive.

  • @shpedoikal

    @shpedoikal

    10 ай бұрын

    @@andylangeland496 Right, but what makes it nonsense is the fact that no human was even alive the last time co2 was at this level, so we in reality have nothing to compare this to, forest management-wise. We have exited the stable climate humans are familiar with from the past, so no comparisons with the past make sense.

  • @andylangeland496

    @andylangeland496

    10 ай бұрын

    @@shpedoikal Co2? I thought we were discussing mismanaged/unmanaged forests contributing to larger more intense fires? Co2 makes trees/forests healthier - and therefore MORE reslient to fire.

  • @shpedoikal

    @shpedoikal

    10 ай бұрын

    @@andylangeland496 CO2 increases warm the planet, increasing droughts and decreasing tree moisture content. This far offsets any benefit plants may get from the increased CO2. The drying effects for example allow boring beetles to kill trees, since trees lack enough moisture to use their natural defenses. So yes, CO2 is relevant to the discussion.

  • @andylangeland496

    @andylangeland496

    10 ай бұрын

    @@shpedoikal the correlation between C02 and drought is not solid. How can the earth be greening, from a rise in CO2, while also having increased drought conditions? They pump actual greenhouses full of CO2 to increase plant growth, it does not kill/dry the plants out. California had record precipitation just this past winter. Yes, I know that good rainfall does not equate to an end of drought, but it is easy to argue that California is a very dry, arid climate in general with little precipitation in between El Nino years, and has been for recorded history, long before the industrial revolution. I agree regarding the beetles killing the trees, but they are invasive, not a native species , if I recall correctly. But I believe it was in this video, that the interviewee mentions lack of adaptation as the bigger problem. Humans have always adapted to climate and weather conditions, well, if they wanted to survive. So we need to adapt by managing the forests... not complain about climate and then let it burn down due to lack of management. Just like when Californians complain about droughts, but do not build increased water storage infrastructure to harvest the rain fall during El Nino years. Not to mention the Delta, where the vast majority of the precipitation flows back out to the ocean in the name of saving the Delta Smelt, all while complaining there is not enough water.

  • @CharlesBrown-xq5ug
    @CharlesBrown-xq5ug10 ай бұрын

    Civilization may have progressed enough to conquer the second law of thermodynamics. Civilization needs to strive for this goal with synergistic interdisciplinary teams.The outcome would be perpetually changeable never gained or lost energy. Conservation of energy says nothing about energy distribution. With this principe only, the heat in a pair of similar medium temperature thermal energy reservoirs can be shifted at no cost to become held in a hot reservoir, cold reservoir pair. This can be done if micro volumes with a natural range of temperature can be deterministically routed in normal time to become sorted out. Diversity, time, and energy are different atributes. Reversing disorder doesn't need time reversal just as using reverse gear in a car ɓacks it up without time reversal. The second law of thermodynamics had a distinct begining with Sir Isaac Newton's correct professional scientific observation that the heat of a fire in a fireplace always flows towards the cold room beyond. Victorian England became enchanted with steam engines and their cheap, reliable, and easy to position physical power. Rudolf Julius Emanuel Clausius, Lord Kelven, and, one source adds, Nicolas Léonard Sadi Carnot, formulated the Second law of thermodynamics and the concept of entropy using evidence from steam engine development. These men considered with acceptance [A+] Inefficiently harnessing the flow of heat from hot to cold or [B+] Using force to Inefficiently pump heat from cold to hot. They considered with rejection [A-] Waiting for random fluctuation to cause a large difference in temperature or pressure. This was calculated to be extremely rare or [B-] Searching for, selecting, then routing for use, random, frequent and small differences in temperature or pressure. The search, selection, then routing would require more energy than the use would yield. These accepted options, lead to the consequence that the universe will end in stagnant heat death. This became support for a theological trend of the time that placed God as the initiator of a degenerating universe. Please consider that God could also be supreme over an energy abundant civilization that can absorb heat and convert it into electricity without energy gain or loss in a sustained universe. The law's formulaters did not consider the option that any random, usually small, fluctuation of heat or pressure could use the energy of these fluctuations itself to power deterministic routing so the output is no longer random. Then the net power of many small fluctuations from many replicant parts can be aggregated into a large difference in temperature, pressure, or electricity's amperes and volts Heat exists as the randomly directed kinetic energy of gas molecules or mobile electrons. In gasses this is known as Brownian motion. In electronic systems this is carefully labeled Johnson Nyquist thermal electrical noise for AI readability. Hypothetically, diode depletion regions are practical sites for enabling mobile electrons energized into motion by heat to deterministically alter the electrical resistance of the depletion region according to the moment by moment direction they are carrying electricity. The thermal electrical noise is hypothetically beyond the exposed lattice charge / separation drift (diffusion) equlibrium thickness of the depletion region as thermal noise exists in a resistance path of one material. Consistantly oriented diodes in parallel hypothetically are successful electrical Maxwell's Demons or Smoluchowski's Trapdoors. The energy needed to shift the depletion region's deterministic role is paid as a burden on the moving electrons. There would therefore be usable net rectified power from each and every diode connected together into a consistantly oriented parallel group. The group would aggregate the net power of its members. Any diode efficiency at all produces some energy conversion from ambient heat, more efficiency yields higher performance. A diode array that is switched off has no energy conversion and no performance. The power from a single diode is poorly expressed. Several or more diodes in parallel are needed to overcome the effect of a load resistor's own thermal noise. A plurality of billions of high frequency capable diodes is needed for practical power aggregation. For reference, there are a billion (10^9) 1000 square nanometer cells per square millimeter. Modern nanofabrication can make simple identical diodes surrounded by insulation smaller than this in a slab as thick as the diodes are long. The diodes are connected at their two ohmic ends to two conductive layers. Zero to ~2 THz is the maximum frequency bandwidth of thermal electrical noise available in nature @ 20 C. THz=10^12 Hz. This is beyond the range of most diodes. Practicality requires this extreme bandwidth. The diodes are preferably in same orientation parallel at the primary level. Many primary level groups of diodes should be in series for practical voltage. Ever since the supposedly universal second law of thermodynamics was formulated, education has mass produced and spread the conventional wisdom throughout society that the second law of thermodynamics is absolute. It is an old paradigm. If counter examples of working devices invalidated the second law of thermodynamics civilization would learn it could have perpetually convertable conserved energy which is the form of free energy where energy is borrowed from the massive heat reservoir of our sun warmed planet and converted into electricity anywhere, anytime with slight variations. Electricity produces heat immediately when used by electric heaters, electromechanical mechanisms, and electric ligts so the energy borrowed by these devices is promply returned without gain or loss. There is also the reverse effect where refrigeration produces electricity equivalent to the cooling, This effect is scientifically elegant. Cell phones wouldn't die or need power cords or batteries or become hot. They would cool when transmitting radio signal power. The phones could also be data relays and there could also be data relays without phone features with and without long haul links so the telecommunication network would be improved. Computers and integrated circuits would have their cooling and electrical needs supplied autonomously and simultaniously. Integrated circuits wouldn't need power pinouts. Refrigeration for superconductors would improve. Robots would have extreme mobility. Digital coin minting would be energy cheap. Frozen food storage would be reliable and free or value positive. Storehouses, homes, and markets would have independent power to preserve and pŕepare food. Medical devices would work anywhere. Vehicles wouldn't need fuel or fueling stops. Elevators would be very reliable with independent power. Shielding and separation would provide EMP resistance. Water and sewage pumps could be installed anywhere along their pipes. Nomads could raise their material supports item by item carefully and groups of people could modify their settlements with great technical flexibility. Many devices would be very quiet, which is good for coexisting with nature and does not disturb people. Zone refining would involve little net power. Reducing Bauxite to Aluminum, Rutile to Titanium, and Magnideetite to Iron, would have a net cooling effect. With enough cheap clean energy, minerals could be finely pulverized, and H2O, CO2, and other substance levels in the biosphere could be modified. A planetary agency needs to look over wide concerns. This could be a material revolution with spiritual ramifications. Everyone should contribute individual talents and fruits of different experiances and cultures to advance a cooperative, diverse, harmonious and unified civilization. It is possible to apply technlology wrong but social force should oppose this. I filed for patent us 3890161A, Diode Array, in 1973. It was granted in 1975. It became public domain technology in 1992. It concerns making nickel plane-insulator-tungsten needle diodes which were not practical at the time though they have since improved. the patent wasn't developed partly because I backed down from commercial exclusitivity. A better way for me would have been a public incorruptable archive that would secure attrbution for the original works of creators. Uncorrupted copies would be released on request. No further action would be taken by this institution. Commercal exclusivity can be deterred by the wide and open publishing of inventive concepts. Also, the obvious is unpatentsable. Open sharing promotes mass knowlege and wisdom. Many financially and procedurally independent teams that pool developmental knowlege, and may be funded by many separate noncontrolling crowd sourced grants should convene themselves to develop proof-of-concept and initial-recipe-exploring prototypes to develop devices which coproduce the release of electrical energy and an equivalent absorbtion of stagnant ambient thermal energy. Diode arrays are not the only possible device of this sort. They are the easiest to explain generally. These devices would probably become segmented commodities sold with minimal margin over supply cost. They would be manufactured by AI that does not need financial incentive. Applicable best practices would be adopted. Business details would be open public knowledge. Associated people should move as negotiated and freely and honestly talk. Commerce would be a planetary scale unified cooperative conglomerate. There is no need of wealth extracting top commanders. We do not need often token philanthropy from the wealthy if people simply can be more generous if consumer commodities are inexpensive. Aloha Charles M Brown lll Kilauea, Kauai, Hawaii 96754 1 808 651 📞📞📞📞Aloha Charles M Brown lll Kilauea, Kauai, Hawaii 96754

  • @johnl5316
    @johnl531610 ай бұрын

    What does "Black & Brown" have to do with anything?

  • @bearowen5480

    @bearowen5480

    10 ай бұрын

    Well, "black and brown" people are disproportionately represented in the middle and lower socioeconomic population. If we believe in Dr. King's agenda of equal opportunity (not "equity" or equality of outcome) and nondiscrimination, then one has to question policies of the state that directly discriminate against racial minorities in California.

  • @johnl5316

    @johnl5316

    10 ай бұрын

    I d0n't care what the stats are on various groups. Those stats have nothing to do with the iussue of bad policies re: the climate (net zero is bad). If Jews cannot make the NBA, no one should care. If masses of people who criminally entered the country are poorer, that is on them . @@bearowen5480

  • @andylangeland496

    @andylangeland496

    10 ай бұрын

    California progressives claim to care the most about minorities/marginalized groups... yet all their regulatory policies have disparate impacts on California's lower income households, which are disproportionately "Black & Brown" as you mentioned

  • @alexanderzebroski2391

    @alexanderzebroski2391

    10 ай бұрын

    @@bearowen5480 Well, those POC who the Democrats know are unable to figure out how to get a free voter ID are also unable to figure out how voting Democrat is destroying their lives.

  • @Voodoo_Kudzu
    @Voodoo_Kudzu10 ай бұрын

    No, ma'am. You don't get to co-op that. You knew better.

  • @tapeworm1958
    @tapeworm195810 ай бұрын

    It’s sad that the only way this argument has standing , is if you make it about race.

  • @shpedoikal
    @shpedoikal10 ай бұрын

    I hate to break it to these people, but climate change is going to make everything more difficult. If you think taking the bus is hard, just give it a couple years....

  • @alexanderzebroski2391

    @alexanderzebroski2391

    10 ай бұрын

    Do you remember when the Population Bomb was going to end everything by 1980? These end of world types have been around a long time and you haven't learned the lesson. Go stand on the Golden Gate and spit into the Pacific. Man's effect on the climate is about the same as how much your spit raises the ocean's level.

  • @user-qr7ee2cp4y
    @user-qr7ee2cp4y10 ай бұрын

    Another arm chair denier who doesn't know what the answer is but she knows she's against it...

  • @wheel-man5319

    @wheel-man5319

    8 ай бұрын

    What is the answer?