Bravo!!! Stand on one leg!!!

@flutepancake1312

8 ай бұрын

Thank you so much!

When I was a kid in the early 70s I had no idea this was Bach, I just knew that i loved this Tull tune.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Happy to hear that! And you still appreciate, I guess!

@cslloyd1

24 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 more than ever. Back in those days when all this great classic rock was being produced, we never considered that it was a window of greatness - i just figured great music would always be created (it’s all i knew at that age). Lo and behold, it was a fleeting moment when greatness was a feast before the long famine that has followed since.

@DavidSmith-ss1cg

21 күн бұрын

That the flute part was helped along by one of the MOST bad-ass Bass solos in history certainly didn't hurt Old Bach's little "ditty" at all.

@coopersy

19 күн бұрын

Opposite for me… I was like “wow, it’s okay for them to play classical music!” I had no idea.

It’s amazing how many great musicians acknowledge a great debt to JS Bach

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Absolutely agree! Are you a musician as well?

@carlranns6658

28 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312Not professionally but music is innate to us all. I've been listening to Bach since the late 1980s and think his music is amazingly dense and intense, totally unlike anything else I"ve heard. Rick Beato has an interesting KZread video called The Bach Effect: What the GREATS Hear That You Don’t

@DanielByers-qf9qi

26 күн бұрын

What is called Common Practice Western Music is most of all attributable to Bach's 371 Chorales for the Lutheran Liturgy. He wanted to make four-part chorales that commoners could sing. He was so consistent in establishing major-minor relationships, especially for use of the leading tone, that his techniques became the de facto "rules" still observed today.

Written by Bach...Perfected by Tull

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Totally agree! Are you a flutist as well?

@gregthornton4209

Ай бұрын

Unfortunately, No...@@flutepancake1312

@roncoletta6513

27 күн бұрын

There is nothing to be perfected with Johann Sebastian Bach.

@gregthornton4209

26 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 no, but I do play bass...

@claudedeschamps5196

15 күн бұрын

Perfected? No interpreted

When Bach heard Ian’s interpretation he was grinning from ear to ear.

Lovely! I love both Bach and Tull! :)

you should have done the leg thing like ian anderson haha

@flutepancake1312

2 ай бұрын

OMG you're so right!!!!

Such beautiful playing, brava!

@flutepancake1312

8 ай бұрын

Thank you so much!

It was written by J.S. Bach for lute (lute-clavesin). Suit BWV 996

I’ve played this piece with great joy on flute and guitar. Of course, I first heard it in my youth as played by Ian Anderson. A gift either way. Nice interpretation. Thanks.

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Thank you so much for the connection, I truly love to hear stories like yours! Are you still into playing instruments?

@CameraLaw

Ай бұрын

Yes, piano, guitar, and flute. An increased focus on music became my unexpected retirement game plan during lockdown. It is challenging, good for the soul and always forward looking. “If I go slowly and pay attention today, then tomorrow, I’ll play this better.”

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

@@CameraLaw totally agree! Actually, I started this channel during lockdown, it was such a great opportunity to focus on passions!

Lovely. I added the Tull version at the end , learning to sing the notes like Ian Anderson adds a whole new dimension, I loved doing the quick runs with the voice added, Bravo !!

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Wow, do your have a KZread channel where I can hear and see you? His technique is so difficult, I wondered if he was the only human being who could do that!😂

I love your interpretation. although I like the strength, the metallic confusion, the desperate language and the blue earthquake of Ian Anderson

Well. That was well done, but I was expecting a discussion about the question -Bach or Jethro Tull.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

We can discuss here, if you want!

@peterv7258

17 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 Well, relating to that question, the composition is Bach, though I believe that Jethro Tull's arrangement of the piece is somewhat unique compared to the way a straight classical ensemble would play it. I think Tull speeds up the tempo a little, and the distinctive low bass line makes the melody stand out a lot. When I have heard classical groups play the piece it isn't quite as hummable. I wonder in what ways they transposed the composition from whatever instruments a classical group uses to the rock band instruments and flute. Though I don't know, I think a lot of his stuff is adapted to classical ensembles, because he mostly wrote for the organ. But I could be wrong about that generalization.

@RexKarrs

12 күн бұрын

Throw in Webber/Rice "This Jesus Must Die" from "Jesus Christ Superstar." Same melody.

@robinswamidasan

6 күн бұрын

@@RexKarrs You're right. It hadn't occurred to me.

Hearing Ian Anderson's version at age 10 turned me on to JS Bach ❤

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Lovely story!😍Thanks for the connection, I truly appreciate to hear those kind of stories!

@billsanderson1442

27 күн бұрын

I fell in love with flute in high school in the 1970s. Our high school hosted many jazz and orchestra concerts. Two flautists that were magical were Paul Horn and Moe Koffman. I still listen to my Moe Koffman Plays Bach album. After I played the album for a friend, he asked if I knew Jethro Tull, and I fell down another lovely musical rabbit hole. Grazie Anna, for a lovely performance.

@flutepancake1312

23 күн бұрын

@@billsanderson1442 🤗

Just found your piece here; as I struggle to re-learn sight reading and playing my flute (after many years away) this is a go-to composition that I played as the Bach version when young. Now I enjoy the Tull version as well, and your blend is wonderful!

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Wow, thank you so much for the appreciation! that's so good you're practicing again, may I ask why you decided to come back to the flute?

@richk3135

Ай бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 I'm retired now and have the time (way too much time). It's a challenge and my mama would've been thrilled. Thanks again!

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

@@richk3135 Spending time playing an instrument is always a great choice! Please keep practicing, lets's keep in touch and let me know about your progress!

In the long, never-ending and vast evolution of music, "new music" has always borrowed directly or inadvertently from the music that preceded those writing and composing the "new music." That's one of the beautiful aspects of music. It's a continuum of a legacy and shared human experience, hip-hop and disco included.

I like the music clever word play, Flute Pancake. Ian and JS would definitely approve.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Thank you so much for your kind words!

Bouree by Bach was nice but had no energy and no feeling … Ian Anderson (Jethro Tull) brings the tune to life and interjects the feeling, and definitely the excitement!!

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

OMG you perfectly described it!!! Are you a flutist?

Bouree was on the "Living in the Past" album which I owned in the 70's. I do not recall any attribution in or on the album materials regarding Bach as the composer of the tune or even the inspiration for the melody. So I thought Anderson composed it.

@robinswamidasan

6 күн бұрын

Yes, I do think Tull should have acknowledged JS Bach as the composer in their album credits. Aand also, the 3 composers adapted in "By Kind Permission of", in the same album.

Brilliant Thank you

Very nice blend of the two! That said...I could see Glenn Cornick's spirit over your shoulder, waiting for his chance to solo. Be well, keep on doing!

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Thank you so much for your great comment, truly love it!

Jethro Tull for sure! :) It's truly amazing what a 'gateway drug' this piece of music was for so many of us back in the 60s. Within a few years of my first hearing this I was studying Early Music (!) at the Royal Conservatory, while making my living playing in various Rock bands! I have no doubt that this was one (of many) "Baroque Rock" adaptations of music that swung my interests in that direction, and have lasted a lifetime. If you want to hear another excellent adaptation of Bach from around this same period, from another British Prog Rock band, please check out the ubiquitous "Fugue In D Minor" by the band Egg. I promise you won't be disappointed! :)

You play the flute magisterial. 👏👏👏👏👏.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

You're too kind, thank you so much!

Excellent madam!

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Thank you so much!!!

This is my first visit to your channel. A great tone, very warm & smooth. I want to thank YOU! As mentioned below when you do a faster paced cover of Ian you must do on one leg!!! Bravo!!!!!!!!!

@flutepancake1312

9 күн бұрын

Thank you so much, I truly appreciate connecting with people on my YT channel! Of course, I have to improve the one-leg stand and prepare another Jethro Tull piece!

Marvelous playing and beautiful sound!

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

You're too kind, thank you so much!

Oh my. Your tone is is flawless.

@flutepancake1312

2 ай бұрын

Ohhhh❤ you're too kind!!! By the way, I'm really happy to know you enjoy my videos! are you a flute player as well??

@kingbeauregard

2 ай бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 No, I've just been listening to Jethro Tull since the 80s, so KZread deemed I should see your video. I know little about playing a flute, but I know when someone does it well. At this moment in fact, there's a Finnish woman named Heline (that's her channel name, "Heline") doing a live flute performance. Maybe pop in and give her a listen if you're feeling it.

@flutepancake1312

2 ай бұрын

@@kingbeauregard Thank you for the advice, unfortunately she's no more live, but I'm gonna check her videos for sure!

@kingbeauregard

2 ай бұрын

@@flutepancake1312Her initial reaction to Jethro Tull is a treat.

@BartdeBoisblanc

Ай бұрын

@@kingbeauregard Ah a Heline fan! Yes fans love her flute playing and the way she pronounces his name too.🙂

Beautifully played! Brava! Thank you!

@flutepancake1312

23 күн бұрын

Thank you!🤗

@russelljackman1413

22 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 You are very welcome!

Beautifully performed

i go with tull, why, my teenage years + high school years.. thats hard to beeeet

That was lovely. Your tone is very rich and smooth - I love it.

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

You're too kind! Thank you so much, your appreciation really means a lot to me! Are you a flute player as well?

Bach made it... Tull made it famous! Tip o' the hat to both of those geniuses.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

You're too kind, thank you so much!

Nicely done . . .

I choose Godspeed You! Black Emperor. I'll try the White...and recommend Soupçon de Fruit's Rose d'Anjou.

Tull, but then again I've never sat in the 7th row like I got to with Tull... Your very good yourself. Thank you.

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Thank you so much for the connection!

trying to categorize music is an exercise in futility. the great Duke Ellingtons famoulsy noted, "If it sounds good it IS good". Bach is foundational. Pianist Jacques Loussier did well interpreting a bunch of Bach as jazz. Arthur Feidler took a lot of Pop music transcribed it for classical orchestra. Probably moe people were exposet to Bouree through Ian Anderson and Jethro Till than were exposed to it through music classes, but hopefully that exposure led them to listen to more Bach. Everyone wins.

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Your comment is amazing! thank you for the connection, I truly love reading this! I guess you're really into music, aren't you?

@twain3074

Ай бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 ..you know, I never really thought of myself as into music until recently, as I've exposed my partner to lots of stuff she had never heard. I'm mid 70's. Growing up, there was a lot of music in movies and cartoons on TV that was from the 20-30-and 40's so I kind of accepted it as my own. We got a big box stereo that came with 100 LPs, so I listened to a big variety of bands broadway show albums, vocal groups and niche acts like 'the harmonicats'. THEN we had the Beatles, British Invasion and all the Folkies. Classical was fundamental, going back to my church day. We had a real pipe organ, and one of my teachers was a little lady, Ilse Schmidt, who was masterful on it, and loved Bach. And as a young man, Playboy was a big thing, and the promoted the heck out of Jazz. There is SO much that is pleasing to listen to, or in my case evokes memories of time and place. One of my great regrets is never having learned to play. I am glad for you that you did and do. Please make it a goal to dip your toe into as many artist as you can, particularly the one who are from decades before you. There is much that is marvelous, and you never know what will inspire you.

@PaisleyPatchouli

22 күн бұрын

Yes, you're absolutely right; I was 13 in 1969 when Tull's Bouree was released, the next week I bought my first copy of the Brandenburgs, and by 1972 I was studying Early Music full time at the Royal Conservatory. It wasn't just the Tull/Bach mashup that did it for me though; at that time there were many groups combining styles and was even a "Baroque Rock" style of music. ;)

I would love to have a copy of the sheet music as I never could figure out the notes in the middle section. I love how you added the third octave at the end. Thank you 🙏

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Hi there! thank you for the connection! I can easily share the scores, please dm me on instagram!

@mangogrower5426

Ай бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 Hello again and thank you for replying. I’m afraid I don’t have instagram or any social media. But you really breathed life into that piece. Thank you 🙏

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

@@mangogrower5426 Please contact me by email, annalaura.colombana@gmail.com Thank you again for the appreciation!

La vita e bella❤

@flutepancake1312

8 ай бұрын

It is in my to do list😀

Very nice.

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Thanks for you appreciation, it really means a lot to me!

Tull’s version has a really cool electric bass line and double recording, things not available to Bach.

Even Bach was naughty. He pinched Minuet in G from Christian Peltzold and the Toys pinched it from him for 'A Lovers Concerto'.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Your comment is so amazing, truly love it! Actually, I didn't know that, but now I have a completely different consideration of Bach!

Beautiful

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Thank you!

Jethro

This sounds great, but what would make it even better would be to add an upright bass... plucked, not bowed... a little counter-point?

@flutepancake1312

23 күн бұрын

I know, but my channel is for solo flute, so...

@freesk8

22 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 True, but sometimes KZreadrs do collaborations... It tends to get them more subscribers. I'll bet you could find a solo bass player who would love to do a collab...

Beautiful but I miss the bass solo.

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Gotta do some more practice!😉

Simply beautiful! And the music is delightful as well.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

You're too kind, thank you so much!

@slkinia

21 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 You are quite welcome. I'm an expert. 😉

Ian Anderson was the flautist and principal composer in the band Jethro Tull. His work is quite exceptional as is your interpretation. Mr. Anderson deserves credit for his compositions, however. Bach composed the Brandenburg Concertos while performing with the Köthen orchestra, yet he is credited for those compositions, not the orchestra. Mr. Anderson deserves no less.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Absolutely agree, thank you so much for the connection!

Johanderson Bach? Or Sebast-IAN Anderson?

@flutepancake1312

9 күн бұрын

Lovely!

@Fuzcapp

9 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 😁

Love the arrangement and the musician. Please find a room or studio.

_Only really works if you stand on one leg and twirl it like a baton!_

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

I know, I know...but still have to practice!

You are flutier than a pancake madam!

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

You're too kind, thank you so much!

Ian Anderson doesn’t run out of puff

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

you're right, it must be some kind of magic⭐

Che dire, Bach è Bach, mi hai ricordato quando ascoltavo un amico tentare di eseguire un pezzo per contrabbasso bellissimo e difficilissimo, non ricordo se di Bartok o di Eccles, insomma quel tipo di esecuzioni per cui i musicisti prog sbavano. Non so se conosci la mitica "Hotel California" degli Eagles, ho notato che molti amici non sanno che è stata praticamente parzialmente copiata da un pezzo dei Jethro "We Used To Know", c'è però da dire che gli Eagles hanno fatto un buon lavoro sulla "melodia" del famosissimo assolo che vi hanno aggiunto. In ogni caso due pezzi strepitosi che il maestro Bach non avrebbe disdegnato

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Completamente d'accordo sul fatto che Bach è il primo rocchettaro della storia (Bach...o Back?) ...e in ogni caso Hotel California è una delle prossime registrazioni che ho in mente di eseguire! Grazie per il prezioso commento!

White room would be a great cover tune for you

@flutepancake1312

9 күн бұрын

Thank you, I'll give it a try for sure!

Bravo. One leg up girl! Lol.

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Omg should have done it!!! By the way, thank you for the connection! Are you a flute player as well?

I thought you had to stand on one leg to play the Jethro Tull flute solos.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Still have to practice for that!

A duo with Ian Anderson would be perfect|

sorry too clinical sounds empty in that echo room.

Jethro Tull.

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Wow really? I would say myself Bach! Thank you for the connection, hope you're enjoing hanging around in my channel!😉

@kirtroguestar471

Ай бұрын

I was wrong lol. Big jethro Tull fan when I was a kid. Only heard jethro tulls version. As an adult in college art class my professor played bach’s version; first time I heard Bach’s version, it sounded a little different. I guess I don’t know the difference. Great job. You’re very talented.

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

@@kirtroguestar471 Thank you so much for the appreciation! I truly love stories like yours, and let me say, if music touches your heart doesn't matter if it is Bach or a random musician improvising...let music and love flow!

Prof fote sei❤

After the first minute, I decided it must be Bach, since both her feet appeared to still be on the floor. 😀

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

I know, but I still have to practice playing on one leg!

Bach, of course. The last part was destroyed by (whats his name?)

Easy swing ma non troppo

@flutepancake1312

8 ай бұрын

lovely reply🤩

A quando il prossimo video??

@flutepancake1312

3 ай бұрын

Registrazioni pronte, manca però il tempo di fare editing😅

Now that's some UGLY room reverb!!

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Please let me know what you think about my other videos, the reverb is different for sure!

Not only Jethro Tull steeling from Bach, also Deep Purple and many others...😁

@flutepancake1312

9 күн бұрын

I think Bach was the first Rock star in history!

@petrklic7064

9 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 Steve Morse and Jon Lord said the same think. Strange thing is that i do not like Bach, but i love rock bands inspired by him 🤔🤔

Cose

Absolutely wonderful!!! Otherwise needs more sax but I say that about almost everything.

You play well but you should put some acoustic treatment in that room. It smears the sound of what you are playing detrimentally. A nice room reverb is great but too much hurts the music.

kzread.info/dash/bejne/jJt4y6p-ftzKeag.html Telemann o de Andre ?

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Telemann!😎

This is neither Bach nor Tull. This is you building your layers upon what Ian Anderson had built upon Bach. This is just fine; Bach built upon chorales written earlier by others every day of the week.

@flutepancake1312

9 күн бұрын

Lovely answer!

I would say : "Bach AND Jethro Tull". It's not the same tune. It is an adaptation.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Thank you for coming in this discussion, actually you're the first one to say this!

@jsimonlarochelle

23 күн бұрын

@@flutepancake1312 I forgot to say that your interpretation is also very good.

@flutepancake1312

23 күн бұрын

@@jsimonlarochelle 🤗

You know, the first part of that also sounds like the number from Jesus Christ Superstar, "This Jesus Must Die." ANNAS What then to do about Jesus of Nazareth? Miracle wonderman, hero of fools. PRIEST THREE No riots, no army, no fighting, no slogans. CAIAPHAS One thing I'll say for him -- Jesus is cool. ANNAS We dare not leave him to his own devices. His half-witted fans will get out of control. PRIESTS But how can we stop him? His glamour increases By leaps every moment; he's top of the poll...........

In this case, I prefer Ian's version, sorry Johann Sebastian 😉

@flutepancake1312

23 күн бұрын

😂

Scuse me ?

@flutepancake1312

9 күн бұрын

About what?

Bach. The heartbeat of Tull was Martin Barre...not Ian Anderson. Always has been...always will be...no matter how hard Ian tries to rewrite history.

@flutepancake1312

9 күн бұрын

Agree!

Herod’s theme in Jesus Christ Superstar.

Tull doesn't play it in E minor.

@dalemoore387

5 күн бұрын

Tull doesn’t play it at all. Ian Anderson does.

Tull not her

Hate to be negative but....the sucking sound when she takes a breath detracts from the musicianship.....the rest is OK.

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Thabk you for the connection! Actually I still work a lot to improve that aspect, and have a lot to do!

Bach rules of course, the Tull´s tryout is out of the mastery, what a joke

@flutepancake1312

Ай бұрын

Thank you for the connection!

Un bel crossover tra l'originale e Ian Anderson: molto bello! 😄

@flutepancake1312

24 күн бұрын

Grazie!