Saw you reading these on Goodreads and was WAITING for this video

@kylajayapurna9058

5 ай бұрын

i live for this comment

@dtbkaylee

5 ай бұрын

HALEYY

@margaritacharalambidou9304

5 ай бұрын

haley poping up here, my worlds are colliding

@SnakeSlaya22

5 ай бұрын

I NEED this collab

@DylPickle0400

5 ай бұрын

omg haley i didnt know u watch jack too!!! my fav booktuber watches my other fav booktubers vids

booktok's obsession with hockey players should be studied

@hejti3894

5 ай бұрын

i find it creepy in a way idk

@preebooked

5 ай бұрын

I find that if they want to thirst after fictional players then it's like weird but not offensive to other people. But when they take it to the extreme like alex's case it's so creepy. Like he didn't give you consent. Respect it. He's a human. He has real life problems and family.

@LawOfSlay

5 ай бұрын

No fr It’s super creepy and even as a skater- the sexualization of our sport is wild and idk why people can’t just respect and not be so overly obsessed over people like that. Ik a lot of people who are bothered by it at my rink. There really is no excuse for that even if there’s reasons behind it.

@curtisgrant1078

5 ай бұрын

They do the same with motorcyclers as well

@preebooked

5 ай бұрын

@@curtisgrant1078 um yeah. There's this whole booktok X bikertok thing going on where they're posting thirst traps for each other. And there was this one 16 year old biker who wanted to be a part of the trend and gain a community of followers I guess, and he posted a video with a few teen dystopian novels like he hunger games, maze runner etc. then women in then comments section said that "those books aren't real books, you should instead read haunting Adeline" (context: haunting Adeline is a very toxic, problematic, abusive, romanticizing stalker romance, with various triggers and SA scenes in it) and I was like how dare you recommend these kinda books to a minor?!? But then some other women in e comments were also saying that "you need to learn from adult books and come back to me when you're a real man" and that's borderline grooming. A grown ass woman talking about a 16 year old boy who's posting for fun and clout in a sexual manner is pedophilia. But, the fact that no one in the comments section disagreed with those comments made me think that maybe they should stop normalising things like these. They don't get to make any minor (I'm a minor lmao sorry for the rant) feel unsafe in their safe space that they made to do something fun with no pressure from people. So yeah, I get you. You're point is valid.

This situation definitely got so much worse because the Seattle Kraken supported this terrible behavior. Can't imagine how stressed out Alex would have been that his own employers and management were essentially not only giving the green light but also more opportunities for these young women to sexually harass and humiliate him in public. Props to his wife for stepping up and publicly calling out how disrespectful and damaging this behaviour is in order to protect her husband and family which is what finally brought everything to light and made it stop.

@lesdeuxtigres

5 ай бұрын

After the whole controversy I kept wondering how the stress would affect the team. I think it’s interesting that the Kraken made the playoffs last season, but this season they are bottom 3 in their conference, and bottom in the rankings overall for the league.

@stschubs

5 ай бұрын

I wonder what that girls mother/father/guardian thinks....like omg can you imagine if the child you raised subjected another human to that, spoke that way, treated that way to another person? It's staggering. The idea that the management was like ya, let's treat our players like sex idols, can't see anything wrong with that, like what. Tell us you're new to the NHL without telling us you're new to the NHL *eyeroll*

@runa_7022

5 ай бұрын

@@lesdeuxtigresjust wanna say... dont think the booktok drama is why we arent doing well this season 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅

@elise85391

4 ай бұрын

@@lesdeuxtigresit’s hard to say, because these things change every season for so many reasons. But I could see that having an influence

@elise85391

4 ай бұрын

@@stschubsI mean, I almost hope they don’t know how to use the internet, cause yeah, that’s just embarassing

Jack reprimanding himself for saying 'girthy' is literally hilarious.

@nishthamathur9585

5 ай бұрын

that was the exact moment i paused to check the comments lmao

@kgal1298

5 ай бұрын

I'm absolutely dying at this. I need more guys to review smut.

@devlyn873

5 ай бұрын

And yet "balls deep" just sailed right on by...

The fact that you're making an academic discussion about hockey smut is hilarious to me and I'm so here for it 😂

@kgal1298

5 ай бұрын

Honestly I'd love to take this entire phenom into a sociology course.

Gosh, I’m so tired of that “tiny woman, big strong dude” romance trope. Can someone write a romance novel between a girl who is a big muscular pro wrestler and a lanky, skinny short king who likes chess or something? I’d read that

@cakt1991

5 ай бұрын

There are definitely books for other body types. Olivia Dade is known for her fat rep, and released a book last year with two fat leads…she used the same designer as the one who did the cover for Icebreaker, but that artist really shows her range when working with Olivia Dade! But funny you mentioned chess players, because Ali Hazelwood wrote a chess player romance, and I’m 90% sure he’s still a giant, and she’s still tiny. It is YA though, so maybe it will be less sexual?

@strawberryswerv

5 ай бұрын

I’ve got the perfect book for you! His Secret Illuminations by Scarlett Gale is perfect for this. I absolutely loved it and its sequel

@wouldntyouliketoknow7057

5 ай бұрын

There is actually a k-drama called weightlifting fairy kim bok-joo

@minfires7572

3 ай бұрын

There's a book called night shift where the girl is 5"11 and the guy was 6 sth

@AK9B2009

3 ай бұрын

@@wouldntyouliketoknow7057 I just finished watching it and although I love it, you could tell that the min character was shown as still being relatively skinny compared to her teammates.

i thought we peaked with reviewing jane eyre laid bare but now we’re talking about hockey smut and i am HERE FOR IT

@kabina7994

5 ай бұрын

jane eyre laid bare is such a core moment of this channel i am HERE for it also

@marziahadi7156

5 ай бұрын

Fr that damn title haunts me at least once a month. I can't ever take the original book seriously again 😂

@cubitum-eamus

5 ай бұрын

@@marziahadi7156 “the classic novel with an erotic twist” 💀

@irine_elle

5 ай бұрын

​@kabina7994 trueee! i didn't even like the original Jane Eyre but that abomination made me curious af

@shadow-1000

5 ай бұрын

Is your username the reference that I think it is?

If Icebreaker has one hater, it’s me, and if Icebreaker has no haters that means I’m dead.

@Brownies008

2 ай бұрын

Omggg real😭

@idubidubi4576

27 күн бұрын

REALL US BRO

Booktok is such a scary place like hyping up okay-ish hockey smut books is one thing but taking real life people and making them into this fictional version of what you have in your brain is another. it’s so beyond weird that these days rpf has become so popular that people don’t feel any type of shame coming up to and harassing these people

@maisierogers6020

5 ай бұрын

i think the thing is is that it's poorly disguised rpf, but not actually claimed as it. hockey rpf has gone from niche online spaces where people write relatively privately to published books that blatantly write about real players but pretend they don't (some of them are pretty undeniable haha) and then people openly discuss them on a much more mainstream platform

@sunshineeee

5 ай бұрын

Which is so wild bc in fanfic communities we’re finally seeing a true crackdown on Rpf and hatred of if the past few years. Like somehow on Ao3 in the actual fandom space that is viewed as the poster child for these things ppl hate it but it’s reached weird booktok shit and fanfic fandom space is getting blamed again lmao

@Louisa-Sophie

5 ай бұрын

I mean the problem with RPF is when it actually reaches the real world. It's all fine and good as long as everybody understands that the fourth wall needs to be preserved (ie understand difference between reality and fantasy and not try to mix them)

@clarerichardson8770

5 ай бұрын

@@Louisa-Sophie is it? IS IT? 🤍

@sunshineeee

5 ай бұрын

@@Louisa-Sophie No, RPF is always wrong. Part of its existence is literally doing just that, mixing reality and pretend. These are REAL people. It’s in the name. I’m not harping on you when I mention this, but even saying something like “fourth wall” here, is dangerous. Fourth wall is about fictional media. These people are not fictional, so it doesn’t matter if the places they’re written in are pretend. They’re real people, and headcanoning and writing about real people is actively bad, even just in the sense that the people who are being written about have spoken about disliking it. It’s about autonomy and privacy. /gen /nm

Someone get Jack a Kindle so he can read smut freely 😂😂😂

@lesdeuxtigres

5 ай бұрын

Like, Jack this a book you read on KINDLE! Or hiding in your bedroom, never the subway!

@kgal1298

5 ай бұрын

He may die if he goes into Kindle Unlimited. There's things in there that no man should ever read.

@Xk8rsx

5 ай бұрын

@@lesdeuxtigres exactly like 😆😆 whenever he said he read on the train I was like NOOOO 🫢🫢🫢

@Xk8rsx

5 ай бұрын

@@kgal1298 true that. 😆😆 some things should stay hidden 😆😆

@rachel5399

5 ай бұрын

​@@kgal1298my boyfriend got me a kindle for christmas one year, and he paid for a year of kindle unlimited. I found maybe three books on there worth downloading, the rest were just smut. 😂 literally thousands of books with guys on the cover, glistening and shirtless. 😂😂

18:59 whenever book authors write ‘growl’ as an alternative all I can think about is the person making the tiniest bark that sounds like a chihuahua begging for food 😭

@LilyEvans1996

5 ай бұрын

Hahahaha I don’t know why but I find the growling hot in books, but I can’t ever imagine taking it seriously in real life 😅

@userabby17

5 ай бұрын

IKR omg what the heck are we supposed to imagine for that, I just self-insert another word, like writing has gotten so bad authors can't even pick a word other than 'GROWL' out of all the words

@taiyabazaheer9492

5 ай бұрын

Same

@sohinidutta97

5 ай бұрын

YES and also who tf has ever growled/had a partner growl during actual sex? XD

@lelnel6242

5 ай бұрын

@@LilyEvans1996 Werewolves... If I read the word 'growl' I am associating it with werewolves and since I prefer fluffly romance part like cuddling and rubbing face/cheeks to scent SO, I read a lot werewolf fanfiction(mostly Teen Wolf). Growl=werewolves= hot

Watching this video with NO prior knowledge of these books or the drama is very entertaining, but I feel incredibly sorry for that hockey player, those videos were so invasive

He took that book on the subway? W O W 💀 a kindle babe, a kindle.

i think it’s super weird that grown adults are still not understanding boundaries and consent. because the whole argument that oh “but the team was going along with it!!!!” means nothing once consent is taken back and boundaries are set. once someone says they’re uncomfortable with something, it should be very easy for you to say oh wow my bad i’ll stop doing that now!!!! but instead they all decided to get defensive. and i understand why said booktoker felt scapegoated, but unfortunately for her, she WAS one of the most (if not the most) vocal. and then to call the wife a “bitch” for clearly setting boundaries after her entire family felt uncomfortable….thats so weird man. it could all be so simple 😭

@hannah-wd9qn

5 ай бұрын

while i agree with you that she should’ve taken accountability when the player and his wife made known that they felt uncomfortable, i don’t think that the kraken just “went along” with it. they actively enabled and encouraged this behavior because they profited from it and that is also very problematic

@readwithana

5 ай бұрын

@@hannah-wd9qn and i never said that fact wasn’t problematic, however, the people who were at the forefront of this issue have millions of followers within the booktok community and to use the fact that the team was going along with it as the excuse for their behavior is gross. both things can be true.

Why are these labelled romance. They’re erotica. Nothing wrong with erotica, but let’s be honest please. Like imagine if I recommended you a romance movie and then sent you a link to p*rn h*b

@lizibeff

5 ай бұрын

HAHAHA that’s such a good metaphor for it lmao

@4eva123

5 ай бұрын

erotica is a sub-genre of romance...

@anaserranocorces4551

5 ай бұрын

Agree is pure erotica not romance.

@cakt1991

5 ай бұрын

I mean, there is a plot, even if it’s not much of one. The presence of a lot of sex doesn’t make it erotica, although people throw the term around. Erotica is its own genre, where the “sex journey” is centered. Steamy/erotic romance, which is more what I think these are, contain romantic plots, even if there’s still lots of sex. Basically it comes down to, is the sex the plot, or does it complement the plot?

@anaserranocorces4551

5 ай бұрын

@@cakt1991 what you are describing is erotica, if it were plainly just sex it would be pornography. Nothing wrong with readinv erotica, nobody is saying that. But is different from one or two scenes in a romantic novel

yeah, some people on booktok truly scare me. lately some women there started to sexualize a 16 year old just because he was riding a motorcycle. they started to recommend adult books to him too. like imagine that this kid was reading YA books like Hunger Games and Divergent and they were recommending him Haunting Adeline which romanticizes r@pe and is problematic on so many levels. they need to touch some grass asap

@Kingdomheatsox2

5 ай бұрын

I attend a book club that focuses exclusively on YA. It’s a mix of adults, teenagers and children and the amount of times the adult members and staff recommend smut or 18+ books really frustrates me. One member will talk openly about Pucking Around just after another talks about how much they enjoyed Wings of Fury. It’s not a safe space for those kids.

@Louigiart

5 ай бұрын

Reading the comments on his TikTok gives me the creeps!

@alyssavermette

5 ай бұрын

I don't understand why they would do that especially if they know he's a minor like I fear some morals have gone out the window like that sounds a little predatory even if that's not the intention we are talking about a child he shouldn't have to deal with that

@alexandrite61

5 ай бұрын

the way booktok worships Haunting Adeline needs to be studied because I just. dont. get. it.

@Dasha-pv1xk

5 ай бұрын

WHAT?!?!!?

I need a video essay on Colleen Hoover books now from Jack and I'D BE SO FULFILLED.

@lottecooper4370

5 ай бұрын

an eternal rant, PLEASE!

@lelnel6242

5 ай бұрын

You mean the author were the parents are joking about their infant baby boy's big balls, and then the baby dies?

@zeinabdiallo4401

5 ай бұрын

@@lelnel6242this is literally the best summary of colleen hoover “books”. literally her in one sentence

@destituteanddecadent9106

4 ай бұрын

Idk, that means he has to go into it expecting to hate it and read several books all while scheming to shoot a diss video, targeting one particular author. That would feel very uncharacteristic of his content style.

@mariepatricia7592

2 ай бұрын

I remember he gave 3 stars to 2 books of her i think and already said people are so harsh with her. She writes books in a way it's easy to read for some. So I don't think he will hate all her books just because some of her books were bad

i’m a huge fan of hockey romances and have thirsted over my fair share of male leads, so I totally understand fans of this genre being thirsty for these fictional hockey men. the problem is when it bleeds into real life. you can sexualize fictional characters, not real people especially when they deadass have SPOUSES 💀💀💀 the seattle kraken situation just gives me the ick

@annikakamath3931

5 ай бұрын

agreed

@neonice6137

5 ай бұрын

they are not romance they are erotica , like saying p0rn is romance

@elise85391

4 ай бұрын

And you can even have crushes on them irl, cause that’s always been a thing, people having a celebrity crush or whatever, but keep that shit off the internet. I’m not on TikTok, but it seems like a lot of the content has become- videos that should have never been made.

Honestly, I’m living for this 30 minute video essay on viral hockey smut, I couldn’t think of anything better to watch rn

I was shocked as soon as you mentioned the wife, out of all hockey players to sexualise, WHY choose a MARRIED man??

@elise85391

4 ай бұрын

Right! He looked young in the first pic, so I kind of just assumed he was young and unmarried! But to do that to a married man with children is crazy

I always prefer the phrasing “rivals to lovers” to “enemies to lovers” because having the two love interests be rivals says to me that there actually is a reason for the shared dislike for each other. Two people competing for the same thing. I don’t love this genre either, but if it has to be anything, I very much prefer the rivals dynamic.

@girlboss8643

5 ай бұрын

i agree rivals to lovers is such a better term for it. i feel like rivals to lovers implies that both people respected each other enough to see each other as a threat. you can't be threatened by someone unless you admit to yourself that they are as skilled as you. this being the basis for a romance shows that both people will come into the relationship with pre established respect and admiration for one another that i think can be missing from a lot of other tropes. it's still really common for women in romance novels to be looked down on by the love interest

@Lunaa2209

5 ай бұрын

I believe enemies to lover only work in fantasy books

@afuantics175

4 ай бұрын

I feel like Beach Read was a great example of this!

it’s wild to me how cutesy the covers of booktok smut are, it’s concerning how often I see them put in the YA section haha

That Uber scene in Icebreaker was so cringey omg! And although Nathan says he cares about consent, what about the consent of the other ppl in the Uber? Because it's clear afterwards that they saw everything. I was honestly disturbed by that.

@Showtunediva

21 күн бұрын

Me too!

@KarlieStarrSings

23 сағат бұрын

Yeah, it was super weird how they just fooled around with everyone in the uber with them. And the author just expects us to believe they were too drunk to notice. 1) No one is too drunk to notice. 2) What about the poor uber driver. Don't they get any respect?

i think it’s very strange how they began to sexualize a real person, i can’t imagine how uncomfortable he must have felt to be talked about like that

" they are sooo tiny tiny, you can put them in your pocket" got me laughing so hard

Booktok drama is always so fascinating to me. People will say the most unhinged things and then get mad when they are reminded that the things they do and say one post about online actually have consequences in the real world

Went to the book store with friends recently and found Icebreaker under the KIDS section, so we immediately picked up the stack and put it on the appropriate shelf. Good gosh 😭

There was also that one writer who literally wrote a fanfic book about Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce, barely changing the names. That was insane. Thankfully, it was removed from everywhere.

@evychittenden13

5 ай бұрын

Major Swiftie here, and that's so disgusting. I can somewhat understand people writing fanfic about fictional characters but real people is just repulsive.

@skyward7903

5 ай бұрын

@@evychittenden13 People have been writing RPS since forever but it MUST be contained in fanfic-only spaces only. They're not supposed to be visible to anyone who is not intentionally searching for them. I remember the After book release that was so disgusting, the boys knew about it and also kept getting asked in interviews about it ew

@appletart7262

27 күн бұрын

@@evychittenden13 What’s the issue with writing fanfic about fictional stuff since you say “somewhat”?

not hockey books, romance books and spicy books literally being the three horsemen of the apocalypse 😭

Seattle Kraken enabling the sexual harassment of one of their players provides a really interesting case study into the commodification of the body in sport. Usually, athletes’ bodies are commodified so the team can, understandably, compete and make money in the sport they exist within, however, Alex’s own team allowed his body to become a double source of income as they leaned into him being used as a source of desire. They effectively participated in the removal of Alex’s autonomy for money.

i think enemies-to-lovers is also popular because it's comforting to see two people falling in love even after seeing and experiencing the worst of one another, because that's something many people want for themselves

ice-breaker is basically 90% smut

@katrinawelsh6627

5 ай бұрын

I’m halfway through it and literally every page has at least one sex reference if smut isn’t occurring 😭

@kgal1298

5 ай бұрын

So it's actually just erotica? If the sex starts before your 30% into the book then it's erotica and I think people need to be honest about that. Otherwise you can have romance/smut that takes like 70% of the way to get through you get that a lot with Ali Hazelwood, but it's not terribly vile.

@KarlieStarrSings

23 сағат бұрын

it's P*rn with plot filler

booktuber lexi (aka newlynova) described that icebreaker’s plot was set up like episodes of a sitcom lmao

@achilles7815

2 ай бұрын

Reading another comment about it originally coming from wattpad, this makes a lot of sense now

i understand the importance of not sex shaming but i’m almost concerned for some the people who become obsessed with these types of stories and people who use this genre as a form of escapism. I find that some of these stories can be quite problematic and offer delusion when it comes to their perception of sex and men in general. going as far as sexual harassment and assault

@kgal1298

5 ай бұрын

It's the same thing with people who become hyper-obsessed with porn. This is still porn with a story around it. People really need to not get too caught up in their fantasy worlds it can be hard to escape it.

@rachel5399

5 ай бұрын

You're so right. I hate how most "romance" books are just smut. No cute moments where we really get to see these two individuals, AS two individuals instead of just two bodies that will be used to satisfy the reader's lust. I'm all for a realm of sex positivity. Of course, as a woman, I can easily observe a world in which we are obsessively desired after, but not allowed to know it or use that to fulfill our own human, biological needs of sex. It's just that, when you write a 300+ page book that is really just porn, and where every other page is your characters being intimate, what are we really achieving, as writers? It just feels lazy to me. You can have your characters have fun, casual sex, just like you can have them have passion filled and very intimate sex, and STILL be aware of their humanity and their existence as people. These books like the ones used in reference in this video, are so stale when it comes to plot, and character quirks. They're just bodies. It's the same whenever a show or movie indulges in this type of writing. I don't know what I, as the reader or viewer, is supposed to obtain, learn, or be interested in when it's just two people who're horny for each other. Entertainment is subjective, but I like to view sources of media from a writing standpoint, and I always give them credit for knowing their audiences and feeding them based off of their preferences, but I just feel like limiting our readers and our feelings as readers when people inflate these books to such high lengths. I want to discuss the elements of storytelling with a fellow reader. I don't want to feel like we watched the same porno movie together.

@angietoonz6605

5 ай бұрын

Agreed. I enjoy a good sex scene in a book, but i can't imagine reading a whole 800 page book of JUST sex. I like the build up, the plot, the romance -- and that adds to the sex scene. I mean, I don't wanna shame people who get off on this or just want a good sex book for fun. But the way it's bleeding into real life and not just a little sneaky read before bed...feels odd?

@zoefoley6818

2 ай бұрын

@@rachel5399that’s why I love YA romance. people hate on it but there are so many good authors who really show their characters personalities and those moments I crave. I think one or two sex scenes in a book is fine but a whole book of just that?

@achilles7815

2 ай бұрын

For me personally, as an enjoyer of these types of books, it becomes a problem when the relationships have abusive tendencies. So many books have toxic and abusive partnerships and romanticize that (and not just in books but all media). I had borderline panic attacks from scenes that portrayed 🍇 as okay and romanticized it.

That woman's attitude of "It's just for entertainment" is pretty gross. She's loudly catcalling the guy in public, but I guess as long as she says "Oh I'm just joking lol", then it's perfectly fine. Guys would get cancelled in a second by doing the same thing. Possibly even charged with harassment.

@achilles7815

2 ай бұрын

100% this! Just imagine a guy making a tiktok like that woman, talking about her 3… you know. And then doing it in PUBLIC and in PERSON. That would absolutely not be okay if a man did this and straight up be a lawsuit. Of course there are grey areas but this situation was harrassment. UNHINGED. And then the author DEFENDING THIS?? I always think of that phrase from another tiktoker although different situation: „If it‘s not okay for a dad to do, it‘s not okay for a mum to do.“ And ever since then I see more and more situations where this applies.

every time jack speaks im so in awe of how well spoken and thoughtful he is. i kinda wanna say intelligent, but it doesn't feel like it fully covers how clever he feels when he speaks. im always realizing new things and perspectives and still it feels like listening to a friend because he doesn't speak like a dry besserwisser, he's on my level and so fucking funny, and it's just ALWAYS so enlightening. seeing the title of this video, you wouldn't expect anything big, but he always manages to speak delicately and intelligently about real issues and interesting quirks without ever shaming any group of people or interest or anything. idk, im just so impressed by him, constantly. i truly aspire to be more like him.

@user-je6io6cv5d

5 ай бұрын

He went to Durham its right behind Oxbridge for literature degree

I read Icebreaker because it was all over tiktok and I was like fine. I had to know. I was actually surprised that the book wasn't just all romance and spice and actually had plot and character development. I was not expecting it to talk about how hard it can be to have toxic people in your life and how hard it can be to no longer have those people in your life. Anastasia's ex-friend and Nate's family weren't just added to make either of them angsty and were actually treated with care and weight and I thought that was very surprising and interesting. (This isn't to say there aren't things like I wasn't rolling my eyes over, but still.) I also like how Hannah Grace also writes consent into her books. Sure, it seems a little out of place and too good to be true, but I would rather read about someone pausing and asking for consent than books to be promoting the opposite. Be the change you wish to see and all that.

I think people are way too comfortable literally sexually harassing real life people in their quest to "have fun or let loose" its sickening, and especially so when the victims have stepped forward asking for it to stop!!

I am all for face claiming and using celebrities, etc. in order to make a physical comparison to what I see in my head as a reader. But I had no idea other people were taking it this far ! A great video essay on this topic Jack

Enemies to lovers needs to have legitimate reasons for them to be enemies and to eventually get over it. If its just 'ugh i hate that guy' it doesn't work well

considering that the drama that just happened with romance booktok and the 16 year old boy( a literal child) i dont think the romance / dark romance subgenre will ever really not have their reputation completely ruined. its like jack said though, as SOON as someone says they are uncomfortable the person(s) responsible need to take accountability and then stop what they are doing. when all this hockey stuff happened i just couldn't believe people were going to the games and actually yelling things like crack my back & not recognizing how that could make someone feel. especially women- as a young woman myself ive been catcalled & made uncomfortable by men in my life more times than i can count. i cant fathom turning around and doing that to another human

There’s one Hockey book called Icebreaker by A.L. Graziadei about 2 hockey players that play in the Same team. This one was good because Hockey actually played an extremely important role. And it talks about important topics like mental health, family issues, sexuality etc. and there was not even one smut scene. The characters had depths and reasons to act the way they did. Therefore I can recommend it to everybody who wants to read a good hockey book

I think one thing I always struggle with is the way that the sex is written in these books. These characters are often teenagers and it’s bizarre to me that they have sex like pornstars. I know it’s dramatic and sex sells and it matters that it’s hot and steamy. But sometimes it just feels so unrealistic

@elise85391

4 ай бұрын

I’ve found that they’re mostly junior/senior age college students. So still very unrealistic, but they are adults. But I know a lot of people get sick of college romances by the time they’re like 25 bc the characters just feel too young

We need more of these deep dives into drama and controversies of the book community. 😂😮

@Mariamox

5 ай бұрын

Yessss

The thing with having am ensemble cast is because Hannah Grace is writing books about some of the other characters and their relationships (2. books is Wildfire came out in October and a third book comes out this summer) and maybe bc icebreaker is the first book in this interconnected standalone series we get introduced to everyone who could possibly get a book

One part of me is delighted that male bisexuality is normalized in these books; one part of me is appalled at the faceclaiming; one part of me is GOBSMACKED that 800pp of muttering murmuring grating gritting sells this well. Conflicted; I think most of us are against the i invasive intrusive bits, yet see the celebratory facets as okay, and there's no way to have one without the other because people are gonna be their nasty selves no matter what.

Me in the bookstore, totally unaware of booktok hype, looking at Icebreaker: Aw, this looks like a cute little romance story :) Me now: I am never buying a book again without checking GoodReads first 😂

13:18 Jack thank you so much for commenting on how misogyny plays into things women like especially these books and how it can impact the perception of people reading them. I love what you said “if you don’t like them you don’t have to read them”. As a female who is constantly put down because of my interests it’s so refreshing to see that guys understand why it happens and see the problem. Thank you.

'Let's not start saying the word girthy now.' That's hilarious jack

jack in 2021: *reading jane eyre laid bare* i can’t believe i’m reviewing erotica on this channel jack at the end of 2023: “double penetration”

as someone who plays ice hockey I'm afraid of reading these books 📚

@starmangriff

5 ай бұрын

i play hockey and my friend lent me icebreaker and i read the first half of it completely grossed out. at least in the first half there’s not that much about hockey or figure skating or anything it’s pretty much just straight smut and them doing weird stuff like fucking in an uber that also has all of their friends in it, and the dude drawing a map of the g spot or smth i don’t remember

@evychittenden13

5 ай бұрын

I can assure that icebreaker literally never talks about hockey. The only way hockey plays into the book really is by bringing in the male main characters friends who are his entire hockey team, and it cause the two main characters to meet. I've read the book and I literally don't even know what position Nate plays because they never even talk about it. Him playing hockey doesn't really contribute much to the plot.

@taiyabazaheer9492

5 ай бұрын

Are you single?

@lilhedonistcannibal123

5 ай бұрын

​@@taiyabazaheer9492 did you not watch the video, this is what he's talking about

I translated the Hungarian edition of Icebreaker - it came out here in late September in time for the annual book fair. The head of the publishing company told me they had to up the initial print amount because of the pre-orders, and the first print still sold out within a week. As for the book itself, I appreciated the way mental health and toxic friendships were treated, but it really could have used some extensive rewrites - it was originally a Wattpad story, as far as I know, that was later self-published, and you can tell by the structure that the author kinda winged it, and just went with the updates from week-to-week, or I don't know what her schedule was. It's not a book I would have chosen to read myself (I hate all kinds of spectator sports :'D), but I'm starting the next year with the translation of the next book in the series, and I'm genuinely curious what the author was able to do with an actual editor in tow.

@achilles7815

2 ай бұрын

I‘m sorry you translated THAT?? I don‘t know whether to be impressed or horrified, my condolecense either way 💀 Now I need to know the hungarian word for double penetration… Godspeed to you, friend…. You probably need it

@achilles7815

2 ай бұрын

And of course it‘s coming from fucking (pun intended) wattpad

@achilles7815

2 ай бұрын

I‘m sorry but you translated THAT?! I don‘t know whether to be impressed or horrified, my condolecence either way 💀 This must have been… an interesting experience. Now I need to know the hungarian words for some of these things…. Good luck with the next book of the series. I have a feeling you‘ll need it 💀

@orsiszujer6951

2 ай бұрын

@@achilles7815 No condolences needed :) it really wasn't as bad as you'd think - despite its flaws, it's a well-intentioned book (well, they both are), and while sex scenes are an issue in themselves (Hungarian just doesn't have the right vocab, so translating them is always a chore), it wasn't even near the worst or most difficult thing I've ever translated. And the second book is already done - in fact, it was published this week.

It's the dedication for me. Can never be wrong with a 30 min hockey smut review.

Was fully waiting for Jack to say, “This video is brought to you by the NHL.” 😂

I’ve been so curious as to what this video would be after seeing your stories and worst books of the year video 😭

I have zero interest in booktok, hockey, romance, hockey romance, or scandals related to any of it..... and yet here I am watching a 28 minute video on it all. I appreciate the fact that you take the genre seriously, try to understand what the appeal is even if it doesn't appeal to you, and how you review the books seriously despite the content. It makes your videos feel like you've got something to say rather than just pumping out "content" around whatever the latest scandal is. Keep up the good work, Jack. Doesn't matter what you cover, if you put as much thought into it as you have been doing, we'll watch it.

Booktok continues to try to make me feel like a giant at my height of 5'9 and size 8, which isn't all that tall or large, but these books alway seem to have characters that are so petite at like 5 foot and a size xxs... almost all the time the positive physical characteristics of the women in these books is how tiny their wrists are or how easily dwarfed they are by their respective partners- its so frustrating because I feel like the majority of FMCs are all the same.

i have never read a hockey romance book but i did read a fuffy fanfic where buffy was a figure skater and faith was a hockey player and it was pretty great lol

@bettyward8777

5 ай бұрын

Imma need the title, immediately

@demitwice

5 ай бұрын

​@@bettyward8777i cant remember what it was called cause i read it at my colleges library but i think the title was a taylor swift song lol im sorry!!

For me, as a woman who likes the occasional hockey romance, the appeal is that they're hot and the sport is dangerous; hockey players are like knights of the modern world lmao. And in a world where 'bros before hoes' is standard, getting to experience total devotion from a sport-focussed guy through fiction is exciting. It's likely the Elle Kennedy Off-campus series that made hockey players the leading sports romance characters, as her books were addictive. They set the standard for that genre and created an ideal sporty male protagonist.

@kgal1298

5 ай бұрын

I agree, it just got out of control. It's also happening with bikers on tiktok too and I'm like "guys these are real people"

@infinityisntfar

5 ай бұрын

The knights of the modern world thing is so accurate 🤧

@XxstardropzdreammxX

2 ай бұрын

I love your explanation!

Omg Jack is so productive I don't know what we did to deserve this many videos, but THANK YOUUU

People can argue all they want about "letting people read what they want" but theres a line to that. There are so many books these days that has definitely crossed the said line. Yes, books can be about anything BUT books exist to show us a world which mass media cant and dont care about. Its there to make us think. Appreciate the hidden and unseen. If books like these keep coming out and celebrated while some of the best books are pushed back, im really worried. At some point, things really gets vulgar

as a queer person in a sports fandom who has read way too many fanfics - the appeal of sports + romance to me is always queer teammate relationships! so I think I'd hate this type of 'teeny tiny girl' and 'big huge guy' thing so much 😂

The way you are so respectful to different genres and people and authors in general is so wholesome. We need more people like you in the world. I seriously look up to you so much in that way. You are so funny but someone else is never the butt of the joke you have real humor and just altogether seem like such a lovely person. Thank you for everything you do for us🥲

as a girl hockey player… i find it SO WEIRD how hockey guys are so sexualized. and not even gonna lie i did love icebreaker, but looking at all the booktok hockey drama it’s just so disgusting. and it makes me feel so weird even tho i’m not a hockey guy. as one who has been around them my whole life it’s just gross 😭

@achilles7815

2 ай бұрын

Absolutely this! I literally screamed in shock when they actually invited that crazy woman to a game. I would have been terrified! TERRIFIED! Imagine a hockey team doing this with reversed genders?? Inviting an obsessed, down bad to literal hell, mal fan to a woman‘s hockey game?! Unhinged! I hope you stay safe, babe 😭

“They are big and strong and they hit people” LOLOLOL dear god

Look I’m not on TikTok and I’ve been reading hockey romance for years. The majority of them are garbage, but some are so so good. Pucking Around and Icebreaker are… garbage. I’m bummed the sub-sub-genre is getting a bad wrap 😂 edit to say: definitely the sudden fetishization via booktok of hockey (and hence the players) isn’t great 😅 great breakdown of the phenomenon!!

@cs1-01aaminanaushad5

5 ай бұрын

Can u suggest some good ones

@hopetherespudding

5 ай бұрын

Could you recommend any of your favourites? I don't want to start with these two lol

@nana6923

5 ай бұрын

Read „The Deal“//Off-Campus-Series by Ellen Kennedy 😉

If you want an actually good literary book that involves hockey, checkout Beartown by swedish author Frederik Backman. It's a trilogy. The two other books are Us Against You, and The Winners. It's an incredibly crafted and written story/world exploring rape culture. The fact that it was so impressively handled by the author who is a cis-man is so appreciated.

Not him reading that smut out loud 😭😭😭😭😭

love when u these types of videos - kinda like a video essay where u talk not just specifically about the books u read but also the broader context and the implications of them outside the pages

Literally just watched your podcast with jordan where you briefly explained this and I needed more. When it finished, this video notif popped up and I HAD to drop everything and come here. As a consumer of hockey romance, this is fascinating to watch. 💓💓💓

I adore these video essays, Jack! Keep it going.

I read those books and actually enjoy them for the same reason I watch bad movies...... they just hit in that weird extremely satisfying spot inside my head 😂😂

I always love seeing your point of view and the way you explain everything via the literature side. Essays are my comfort videos!!

I love your videos because not only do I laugh the entire time but you really do a deep dive into what you’re talking about and bring up incredibly interesting points that I don’t think would have occurred to me otherwise. Keep up the good work.

As a writer, I started off as a fanfic writer (smut shorts, respectively) but as I got more progressively into my own real books with storylines that were more than 5000 words long I realized that using real people for it is not only dangerous and sometimes fetishizing but also limiting as hell

"this would kill a victorian child"

I found your channel and have watched a lot of your videos. I am so happy that you prefer classic and poetry books a lot. Your recommendations are great. Whenever I am looking for a classic book, I come to your channel and get a lot of recommendations. Keep up the good work.

I looked up Pucking Around on goodreads and one of the reviews it shows at the top is just "puck around and pind out" LMAO Kat on goodreads absolute top notch comedy

I’ve only read icebreaker and never heard of pucking around, also wasn’t aware of the scandal, and now I’m sitting here jaw dropped, no words at all. 😮

as a canadian who grew up going to school with hordes of hockey players i cannot understand what the draw of hockey romances could be 😭😅

All jokes aside, this is actually really messed up. Thank you for informing us about this Jack! It's common sense not to sexualize someone and for the author herself to not take accountability for it, infuriates me.

the growth of book content on the internet is crazy. i was into the og booktubers when they all had around 200k

I think this is one of my favourite videos of yours. It's so informative while also being entertaining. Many thanks!

The fact that I knew EXACTLY what scene he was talking about in "Icebreaker" just goes to show that that Uber scene traumatized us all.😖

@dianaandthebookhunt

5 ай бұрын

Haha, while I get that it may traumatize some, trust me that not all are traumatized by that scene. Us romance lovers stan fictional steamy scenes, because we have a way to suspend our disbelief. We obviously would not condone many of these situations in real life, but in fiction, why not?!

@squidwardtentacles7144

5 ай бұрын

@@dianaandthebookhunt Oh no, I get it! I'm a romance girly too, but I also read books that Jack reads. I read an okay amount of genres so I'm not a stranger to smutty books. I'm reading one right now funny enough.😅 But what I mean is that I just found that scene so disturbing cuz of setting. Like their friends were legit less than 2 feet away from them, including the cab driver who probably has a backway mirror and might have been privy to the whole thing. It's just time and place, you know.😂🥲

@dianaandthebookhunt

5 ай бұрын

I totally get it! I have personal issues with some types of steamy scenes in dark romances for example, so I get it. It's all subjective & that's why there will always be people on both sides of the discussion. It's just important to approach the subject with as much respect as Jack is showing in this video 😊

@Machie0

13 күн бұрын

OMFG, thats the scene that made me stop reading it all together 😪

I do love how the first part of this video was actually analyzing why these books are popular, not just "lol these dames and their silly romances"

This was a really fascinating video to watch, especially as I myself saw many of these booktok posts when the drama ensued🏒

“Why is it always you three” KILLED me 😂😂😂😂

I’ve been hearing about this topic for a while and I’m so happy that are several content creators doing an inquest.

The fact that these books are basically 90% smut but have cutesy pastel covers doesn't sit right with me- feels like they're being marketed towards an audience which are way too young to be reading it

@Patricia-xw3ns

5 ай бұрын

yeah it looks like a "fluffy" romance when it is actually just a horny one

@nedstrange8078

5 ай бұрын

Don't agree at all - bookshops and libraries have children's and young adult sections and while of course teenagers and children do (and absolutely should) read some adult books (not this one obv), that doesn't mean this is being marketed to them.

@lifebooksandeverything

5 ай бұрын

@@nedstrange8078that's definitely true. But I'm thinking more about the "BookTok" sections that bookstores have these days where the genres aren't clearly defined and have a mixture of books which are appropriate for a younger audience as well as inappropriate. It may just be the book stores I frequent that aren't categorizing these books properly though

@4eva123

5 ай бұрын

pastels = feminine. they're being written by women for women and marketed to women, not children. infantilisation of female media is the problem, not a book cover trend

@Patricia-xw3ns

5 ай бұрын

@@nedstrange8078 It depends on where you come from. The libraries I know have a children's section but none for older Teenagers. YA is mixed with adult books and only devided by genre like romance or fantasy. However, books are marketed through their names and covers because every genre has a "signature" style when it comes to the title and the cover. This means that one could take a random book and sort it into the genre only by looking at the cover. That is part of marketing. these books are designed in a way that is usual for YA romance and not adult books.

As a chartered bus driver, I've taken many hockey teams to games and tournaments, and without a doubt, I can attest to the fact that girls/women love hockey players. The stands are filled with decked out and dolled up teenie boppers to full blown hottie moms all keeping tabs on their favorite future NHL prospect/husbands.

I haven't read, nor do I plan to read Pucking Around. I did read and enjoy Icebreaker. I didn't know what it was about when I picked it up and honestly didn't expect so much... spice, but I did like the way it tackled issues for the FMC (need for control, anxiety, eating disorders, dysfunctional relationships,...). It was honestly a decent read.

@melaniegrace7707

5 ай бұрын

I could have written this comment myself I feel the same way

Jack, you never ever miss! Love this video essay!!

Thank you for explaining this to me! I have thought about where this explosion of _"hockey-smutt"_ came from, and its appeal, but I'm way too uninterested in the extremely narrow genre to actually read the books for myself - so truly, thank you! This was a *very* good video, and you did a great job in explaining this phenomena. And, I gotta say; Poor Wennberg, he's Swedish like me. And I know for certain that us Swedes _(generally)_ do not appreciate that kind of MASSIVE attention, especially when it's unwanted attention. Though in this case, I'm pretty sure that nobody in the world would like the kind of attention he and his wife got. Completely unwarranted and extremely disgusting behaviour.

I have been waiting for this, ever since jack reviewed these books on goodreads, I'm so here for it.....

thanks for the nuanced and well thought out review! very entertaining video, keep up the good work! in jack we trust 🥂

I mean this seems to me like it's just the same thing people do with face claiming actors for other books, or just for their actual roles, the difference, that made this seem like it was a different short of situation is that, like you said, they're not celebrities, they're usually not the center of attention in that way so it's easier to acknowledge when the line was crossed

Loving the multiple uploads!

thank you so much for this video jack, i personally have read icebreaker and totally agree and appreciate your opinion. I love how you can ACTUALLY discuss about the good and the bad things about a book and are able to differentiate between your subjective opinion and what it means for society on itself. I, however did not know about the scandal that the other book you reviewed had caused, so thank you so much for spreading that information, because i think that its very much an issue that needs to be adressed and the community has to figure out. ❤

I’m not on TikTok, so I had no idea that any of this happened omg. I’d seen a couple things relating to “being too into hockey players” but I didn’t know all of the details, so thanks for sharing. This was wild though! TikTok is crazy

Just came across your channel last night and watched a few videos ... This is all i have got to say. Vibrant, inspiring and so adorable indeed best booktuber out there.❤ My search for a booktuber or simply someone who can suggest me some good reads ends here owing to certain shared interests such as normal people,Sally Rooney, diasporic literature,Greek mythology and political allegories . Man you are such a sweetheart .Thanks for existing and keep coming up with more such videos.