I keep finding official, completely working Gamecube controllers in fair condition for under $9 (needs cleaning and may be scuffed) at Goodwill and other Thrift stores. So it may be smart to look there if you don’t care for cosmetic condition.

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

All the goodwill's near us are total GARBAGE. There's a St. Vincent DePaul where I've found like black label FFVII and stuff every now and then but all the stuff we find there usually has our price tags still on it LOL

@Artimidorus

8 ай бұрын

That's pretty shocking. Usually Goodwill takes things they consider 'valuable' and push it through to their auction sites. I've not had a Goodwill near me that ever sold actual non-board game games.

@SwerveNation

Ай бұрын

saint Vincent depaul?​are u in da bay@@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Good review. Thanks for doing this. I love your attention to the difference in facets, between the two 🔥

Mario Sunshine should be the real test since it uses pressure for the trigger.

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

If Mario Sunshine didn't FLY off the shelves every time we get it in I would have absolutely used that or smash melee. Unfortunately we almost NEVER have those hanging around since they practically sell out of our hands when we go to put them out.

@Zetchzie

5 ай бұрын

Luigis mansion too

@donkboywtf5327

3 ай бұрын

😂😂​@N😊ostalgicNetwork

Finally, a controller that won’t cost my liver and doesn’t suck

Excellent video! I think I need a couple new controllers actually! Do you all carry any 3rd party AV cables for the GameCube as well? I’ve heard the originals are super hard to find. I’ve been passing my N64 one back and forth between the 2 and I’d like to get a more dedicated one.

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

Yeah we've got tons! We also have all in one av-hdmi cables for the snes/n64/gc as well

Was really interested in the precision of the gray control stick. I play Rogue Squadron games and the controller I have now is way too sensitive; I got left or right with it and it acts like I’m pushing it hard over

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

11 ай бұрын

I'll have to make a short connecting this up to PC using one of the GC->USB converters. IF that even works which I'm not 100% sure it will I'll see. Then I can show off the actual precision of the control stick.

Modded my Wii last year - decided to put Nintendont on it and play some GameCube games but don’t want to spend a lot for a first party controller just to play Double Dash. I ordered the xyab jungle green to match my Oled Switch, DS Lite & Retroid Pocket 2S. Can’t wait to play when I finally get it. Thanks for the recommendation.

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

5 ай бұрын

Yippeeee! They're solid back ups for the price point, as OEMs are getting quite expensive nowadays.

Thank you soo much!!! I've been looking for some CGN controllers and they are expensive.... So thanks a bunch!

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

11 ай бұрын

Glad I could help!

I wish I had taken my aftermarket(different company) out of the box as soon as I got home. The D-pad leans back and to the left, but now I can't get my money back lol

I want one to play gamecube games on my wii

I've been looking for a cheap one that I can use for the dolphin emulator

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

This one would probably work if you have a gamecube-usb hub like the ones they make for the Switch. Otherwise you'd have to find a USB one or maybe the wireless power A one can work with Bluetooth.

@knux85-58xunk

Жыл бұрын

And they also sell those, I've looked on their website. The selection of items is vast to say the least.

@davidmchau

Жыл бұрын

What’s the difference if any at all, between this and others like the old Skool brand and the other eBay Amazon knock offs. They have the same plastic package. Are all these no name GameCube controllers coming from the same factory from China with different packaging?

I ended up sucking it up and paying full price for an OEM controller. But I would totally buy one of these for some 2P action, or in case something happens to my controller.

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

8 ай бұрын

Heck yeah that's what they're for!

what i really wanna know about is the material of the gray control stick. i just really want to find replacement stick covers that are the same firm rubbery material as an OEM controller. the c-stick details sounded right to me but you didn't describe the feel of the left stick much.

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

7 ай бұрын

To me the grey stick is pretty similar to the OEM, hence why I didn't cover it as much as the c-stick. I'd have to take one of these bad boys apart and see if their stick covers have the same construction inside so you could just swap covers onto an OEM. Some of these third party controllers switch up the design of the insides to save plastic costs, so it might be shaped different and not just swap easy-peasy, so I'll have to check and get back to you on that!

Have you tried playing smash bros with that new 3rd party gamecube controller?

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

I haven't, but I have played smash with the Old Skool controller which is the usual brand we carry of 3rd party retro accessories. These two controllers are actually identical, likely the same factory that produces them just different companies licensing them. I haven't had any problems, but as with any 3rd party controller they feel a little different. Great for if you're having a party, but not for your every-day use controller

Do they “feel” like a GameCube controller more or less?

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

3 ай бұрын

They have the exact same form-factor, but the membranes on the buttons are definitely a springy-er/newer feeling rubber. The triggers have a little more give than the OG, but still have that slide and click feel. Overall, these are the closest to original Gamecube controllers I have found without costing $60+

Walmart sells them for under $50 are they refurbished they don’t say used

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

3 ай бұрын

Walmart's online store functions like Amazon, there are a ton of third party sellers that sell through their website, some of which are "verified" and others not. When ordering something like an older controller through Walmart, it's 100% an independent seller and NOT actually Walmart. It's a toss up. More likely than not, they are used and MAYBE refurbished. I can't imagine at that price they are third party controllers, nor could they be NEW OEM, since those would be far more expensive.

Is this one as good/better than the coveted white Japanese GameCube controller with the dot on the back?

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

11 ай бұрын

Got NO idea lol. These are solid 3rd party options for some multiplayer mario party/smash nights. It won't be your MAIN controller, but gives your other players the same form factor and general feel.

Where would you recommend getting an OEM controller and how much do they usually cost?

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

6 ай бұрын

I mean, I would LOVE to recommend US, but we almost NEVER have an excess of OEM Gamecube controllers. Pretty much every one we get goes back out with a system. For whatever reason, Gamecube is one of the main systems we tend to get traded in without any controllers. Honestly, scouting Facebook marketplace and sites like Mercari are where you'll find the best deals; however, you will likely have to do some minor repairs like replacing a C-Stick or button membranes. If you want to buy one in good working order, local game stores or online resellers who service their products are pretty much your only options. I wouldn't pay more than $30/35 for one that's in really good shape.

@b2dub3

2 ай бұрын

eBay, you can find a decent OEM for 30 or so.

Does the one you tested still work as id like to know their life span and durability also how’s the left stick rubber?

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

10 ай бұрын

Yeah, it's still kicking. I use it to test Gamecube games here. I don't use it super consistently, just whenever the need arises, and that's what I would suggest these for. Mario party/smash nights with your friends every once in awhile and you need another controller. I don't think these would be super great for your standard every-day-play controller as they might wear out faster than an oem or a nicer 3rd party. I haven't noticed any wear on mine, but with the wear and tear of playing with it constantly it's bound to happen with the cheaper plastic. The left stick rubber is fine, no real complaints. The right stick was weirder to me.

@GcubePlayer8

10 ай бұрын

@@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade what would be the best 3rd party controller? then and thanks

Are there any great wireless controllers in the non bulky form?

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

4 ай бұрын

Most wireless GC controllers try and emulate the design of the official Wavebird, which is on the bulky side. I would recommend the Retro Fighters controllers, as they try to make really ergonomic controllers with modern quality of life and sensibilities. I haven't personally used their Brawler/Battler GC controllers, but I have used their Dreamcast and N64 wireless options, which are all my GO-TO controllers for those systems. They are more of a Switch Pro-controller style with Gamecube button layout if that makes sense.

Does it work with a mayflash adapter?

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

It SHOULD since it acts as just a standard GC controller and works on wii. Unfortunately I don't have one to test it with

think a custom shell would work on these? don’t really want to mod my real nintendo controllers

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

Yeah I don't see why no. It's really the same form factor. There might be some minor adjustment to the inside of whatever custom shell you get but shouldn't be anything too difficult.

Ay yo, my shit broke after 2 games of melee. Cstick, the yellow one wont work

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

8 ай бұрын

Bruh, that's the second person who's had a stick go out on one of these. I haven't had anything go out on mine, but quality control on these isn't SUPER tight, so it could be individual copies or there's some flaw. Try contacting XYAB about it, they were friendly and communicative with me and I have high hopes they'll help you out.

i jusy ordered a smoke gray controller and it should be here Thursday

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

WOOO

@iloveuriveYT

Жыл бұрын

Are they still working

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, I actually have this controller hanging out in the studio to test GC games and whenever me and Adam want to play some Melee in our freetime! Haven't had any problems so far!

Does it have rumble? I couldn't tell from the video

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

7 ай бұрын

yup!

@SilverTriforce25

7 ай бұрын

@@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade Fantastic! I've been using cheap amazon ones without rumble and it's just not the same even if everything else works!

is this on amazon??

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

Yup! XYAB Gamecube controller. Most of the other 3rd party controllers you'll find on amazon are technically the same manufacturer and have the same type of packaging and and exact same look, just licensed to different brand names like XYAB, Old Skool, and others

@PiggeuStilled

Жыл бұрын

@@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade thank you!

What’s the best 3rd party GameCube controller then

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

10 ай бұрын

dang uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Idk, really subjective question. I like the Retrofighters wireless DuelistGC and BattlerGC. Both are really solid and I love that company.

Where can I find these?

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

You can get a lot of these manufactured by the same place just a different license on amazon and stuff. The main distributor we carry for stuff like this, Old Skool, is the exact same controller and packaging just licensed by a different company. We sell those in store and soon our online store!

@connorplays6263

Жыл бұрын

@@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade okay, So I actually had to type in "Smoke Gray GameCube controllers" just to find the ones in this video, maybe I might try and get one

Dude my control stick already broke down :(

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

8 ай бұрын

BRUH Which one? Main control or C-stick? I haven't had any breakage on mine, but I was more worried about the triggers than I was the control sticks OOF

@gugleore

8 ай бұрын

@@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade the main one

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

8 ай бұрын

Try contacting XYAB and see if they will send you a replacement. They seemed pretty communicative to me so hopefully they can help you out

@gugleore

7 ай бұрын

@@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade lmao Nevermind my sticks are working again

But can it melee?

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

If I had it handy I would have tried ;-; but Melee sells AS SOON as we put it out on the shelf.

@TheSuperScoot

Жыл бұрын

The shoulder buttons don't even click when fully pressed. This is absolute rubbish for competitive Melee and I don't need to hold one in my hands to confirm that statement.

@dragonquestfan2002

Жыл бұрын

​@@TheSuperScoot but would it be good enough for a newbie learning how to play?

@TheSuperScoot

Жыл бұрын

@@dragonquestfan2002 You mean like a literal first-timer who doesn't even know the basic controls yet? Yeah I guess they could use this. I would still suggest you look into a PhobGCC/Frame1/B0XX over this junk if you have any sort of interest in tournaments or competitive play of any sort.

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

Yeah that's what I mean when I say it's for cheap Mario Party parties and stuff. No 3rd party controller at this price point is going to be adequate for any sort of competitive play. Controllers like these are made for parents to pick up 2 or 3 so their kids can all play together at a birthday party or for a few homies who all want to relieve the glory days and play some Mario Party. There are ABSOLUTELY better options out there, especially for competitive melee, but these $15 controllers still have their place.

Uh damnit I was planning on making my driveway out of GameCube controllers

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

10 ай бұрын

Probably cost as much as concrete and a contractor nowadays...

I ordered this just now in the smoke black color, i'll tell you how it goes when it arrives!

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

Awesomee

@jayzpov

Жыл бұрын

@@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade I recieved it thursday and it works great, i used it with nintendont and other emulators and it worked just fine with no drift or input lag. Do you think i can buy replacement shells and custom buttons or would they not fit?

@iloveuriveYT

Жыл бұрын

​@@jayzpovthey still work

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, I was going to say they probably can! Only thing is they might have some slightly differently shaped PCBs or screw-posts/supports within the shell so you might have to modify a custom shell a little with a Dremel or other lil sandy/cutty device to make sure you don't damage any of the goodies in there, but that would probably be the worst of it

Blister.

me who wants to do comp melee 😭 f it ima just have to spend more on a better one :/

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

8 күн бұрын

yeeeeeeah for competitive melee you almost NEED an OEM

Man, Madcatz is still getting so much hate from their 20 yo controller.

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

8 ай бұрын

They DESERVE IT

@Shrock568

8 ай бұрын

@@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade wow🤣

Don't you know Nintendo make brand new one

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

6 ай бұрын

Bet it costs about 4x as much tho

This controller does not compare to the original

4:3 much

Wiizer lmao

@NostalgicVideoGamesArcade

3 ай бұрын

I made this like 2 years ago on an ink.Jet printer in the office as a joke.And then it became like a thing on tiktok and i'm so mad