Who is your favorite?

@emanuelemazzotti7864

Жыл бұрын

Lisa....!!!

@geristracener5253

Жыл бұрын

Lady Gaga for sure. 👅👅👅👅💨💨💨

@christianfernandogarcia262

Жыл бұрын

LISA ES LA VOCALISTA CON MAS AMPLITUD DE REGISTROS, REALMENTE LA ESCUCHO Y ME SORPRENDE, PARA MI GUSTO LA MEJOR

@geristracener5253

Жыл бұрын

@@christianfernandogarcia262 who. ? English Please.

@christianfernandogarcia262

Жыл бұрын

Lisa fischer is the best for me

Thumbs up for Lisa🔥

Lisa took this song to levels unknown to this planet the voice is crystal clear, it’s absolutely phenomenal. Then comes the build up to the solo which is a musical overload-on the brain, neurons start firing off at rapid pace, & you are Rocktified to the max. The energy in anticipation to it is electrifying on the Soul. There’s MASTERPIECE written all over it……☝🏻🎤🎼 …..Thanks Ed

@EdBmusic1

Жыл бұрын

Enjoy Naomi, your song, with amazing talented singers

@naomi8529

Жыл бұрын

@@EdBmusic1 that was very nice of you, thanks Ed ☝🏻🙏🏻✌🏻🎤

@freakbennett2263

Жыл бұрын

She had the chance for the Supreme Level of Experience. playing with The Rolling Stones, with her vocals for any other artistes of ROCK prove that. in other words I"m gonna have to place Lisa Fischer the no 1 of any who tried the song, her performance of Gimme Shelter at her shows is one the best interpretation of the song, oh I'm rambling, too stoned, jus sayin !😎✌😎!

The backup singers, not the stars, do this song justice!!! Merry, Lisa and Sasha do it the best! Lisa has a special place in my heart because she takes this to soaring heights! Merry's was perfect for the recording and the premier voice of 1969. Her vocals and sound capture the angst of that era. A moment in time that can't be duplicated.

@danielmeara9376

2 ай бұрын

wrong word - primal, not premier.

@DzignrGrl

2 ай бұрын

@@danielmeara9376 I need mean premier here, but yes her sound was primal too.

I've seen Sasha in Paris. I had chills she was absolutely amazing. Merry Clayton is the original but Lisa revived this song. Great performance by Chanel & Florence too ! Thanks for this great video Ed!

@EdBmusic1

Жыл бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it!

Lisa Fisher... Great powerful singer...similar like Tina Turner.. She's got the voice, the groove and the move.. Faraway miles from the others.. Which I don't comment at least two, a casting error... In KZread, we can see part of a U2 concert playing ( or killing the song...) Gimmie Shelter, then Mick appear singing as invited and for the feminine vocal, invited too, nobody expected, the great Fergie... Stunning..!

Thumbs up for Merry🌸

Thumbs up for Sasha❤

Thumbs up for Florence💖

this was a brilliant thing to do. Thank you

Love Lisa ❤️ 😍 💖 ❣️

LISA‼️‼️‼️FISCHER‼️‼️‼️‼️👉💯🎤🎤🎤🎤🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼

Faszinierend, diese Röhren.....hat sich gelohnt, diese einmaligen Ausschnitte der Concerte......herzlichen Dank.....🌹.......🌻

Number one and my favorite is Lisa Fischer, best all.

Lisa fischer 💯

Wonderful 😍😍

Thumbs up for Lorelei❤‍🔥

Fantastic singer. Fantastic song, for ever!

Thank you Ed

Lisa 👍

Lisa forever 🔥🔥🔥💯💥💯❤️

Thumbs up for Chanel👩‍🎤

wow cool thanks

Good idea : my dear ! And now all guest musicians. A long list, I think. Greetings from Germany-Hannover

Gimme Shelter🎵めちゃくちゃカッコよくて、メロディもカッコよくて、大好きになりました！！🤟😍❤️🎵

Merry, can be no other ⭐️

Wahnsinn, die verschiedenen Ausschnitte.....super Stimmen...🔝

@EdBmusic1

Жыл бұрын

Hast du vielleicht auch ein Favorit?

@EdBmusic1

Жыл бұрын

Gimme Shelter ist ein washsinnige Song

@wilmabaumann4499

Жыл бұрын

@@EdBmusic1 Lisa Fischer !!! 🎼🎵🎶💯...

@boblandry7572

Жыл бұрын

TY

No one can come Close to Merry and Lisa

@danielmeara9376

2 ай бұрын

Merry ruled it. Lisa a not too distant second

I would say Lisa if I had to choose - but the truth is that I prefer Gimme Shelter without the backup. The tune is Mick's - no question.

There’s only one and we all know who that is. Everyone else take a seat.

@kianknight729

Жыл бұрын

Merry Clayton

Lisa forever

Mary Clayton = THE GOVERNOR Say no more, ❤️⭐️🌞❤️ .. The Part we’re her Voice Cracks and Jagger Whoops is just MEGA so primal and pure brings tears to the eyes. The Stones got Liquid Gold on tape the night they got Mary to come down and record this and they know it, hats off to these Ladies there is some great singers here but Mary Clayton just has that Iconic quality that just can’t be matched.. GOD BLESS HER ❤️❤️⭐️🌞❤️

Merry !

Chanel Heynes🔥🔥🔥great performance 👉San Siro 21.June 2022. ❤️💯❤️

Thumbs up for Mary⭐

Clayton fer sure, Fischer fer sure. the rest ok. !😎✌😎!

It is all in the attitude.

@stnwrd

Жыл бұрын

BTW Merry Clayton is the best. Lisa Fischer did a great rendition.

Thumbs up for Grace✨

Ahora me doy cuenta por que sasha quedo definitivamente!

😮

Cindy Mizelle on the 1989 Steel Wheels tour would trade off with Lisa some nights on the Gimme Shelter solo, she sang in that spot Dec 3rd 1989 in Toronto and on some of the Tokyo shows, Lisa wasn't in the show the opening night in Philadelphia and another singer named Pamela Quinlan handled Gimme Shelter and on the European leg in 1990 both Lorelei McBroom and Sophia Jones traded off each night, Lisa 100% is the best

@EdBmusic1

Жыл бұрын

Nice, I didn't know about the other female singers did the job in on the Steel Wheels and Urban Jungle tours. I know about Sophia Jones and Cindy Mizelle, but I didn't know they did this part as well. Thanks for informing

Lisa Fischer, end of debate.

Lisa

Lisa’s vocals and stage presence are sorely missed and a disgrace that she was simply dropped because of her age after over two decades on stage with the Stones.

Merry and Sasha did great, the other ones are great singers but they don’t carry the song like thees two did imo.

Nothing beats Merry Clayton’s original. The others are just screaming and there’s no real emotion. Merry just nails it and can’t be duplicated.

@danielmeara9376

2 ай бұрын

What a inane comment - true for some but certainly not all

Thumbs up for Lady Gaga⚡

LISA is Best.

Nobody can beat the original but Lisa is great. The others don't even get close. And the seem to know, because they all try to compensate but all they do is overacting.

You gotta have some gospel in you to sing this section. Those who did did a somewhat a decent job. It’s Lisa and Sasha for me although I came to know this song cause I’m a huge MJB fan. She did an okay job. Gaga wasn’t all that good and she has a great voice.

@geristracener5253

Жыл бұрын

She sure did.shes great in concert.. 2012.

@geristracener5253

Жыл бұрын

No 2010. Monster tour.

Lady Gaga was my favorite, it was great

@danielmeara9376

2 ай бұрын

nope - this is not her strength

MERRY CLAYTON AND LISA FISCHER BUT NO SASHA ALLAN ! SORRY .....

Lisa Fischer (the one and only) 💎 and Merry Clayton 💍 are the only ones who sang this song. The rest just screamed out 👎🏼

Florence Grace and Gaga all failed compared to Merry and Lisa.

I’d say Merry and Lisa are tied . Merry gives you the emotion of what the lyrics actually mean. Often people only focus on the way someone sings this song but forget about the words and the message of the song. Lisa gives you the range and power. I’d give Sasha second place. Cindy Mazelle in second place with Sasha. I’m sorry but Florence and Grace Potter were awful! It’s a noooooo.

Lisa fisher is the best vocalist I have heard . Whitney Houston could have easily done this song. Gaga sounded horrible. Mariah Carey could have done this as well and one more...Ariana grande maybe !

@danielmeara9376

2 ай бұрын

Mariah Carey - what an asshole you are.

How comes white girls can't do gimme shelter?

❤️🇲🇨❤️🇲🇨

Lady GAGA, Florence and Mary Blige were awful. Merry Clayton and Lisa Fischer dead heat for the best of the best. Too bad Clayton never did it live.

@tmn8547

Жыл бұрын

I always wondered why Merry wasn’t ever invited to sing it live even just once with The Rolling Stones?! 😮