Ahsoka is a soulless show, so I REWROTE an episode to give it one.

Ойын-сауық

Let’s look at a more mature vision for what Ahsoka, Anakin Skywalker and Star Wars could have been.
CHAPTERS:
Is Ahsoka a religious experience? 0:00
Ahsoka’s stoic facade 4:58
Anakin is no Jedi 13:38
REWRITING EPISODE 5 Preface 22:18
REWRITING EPISODE 5 Part 1 24:00
REWRITING EPISODE 5 Part 2 27:58
Sabine 40:04
What does it mean to be a Jedi? 45:34
Thrawn 50:04
Positive reaction to Ahsoka 56:14
#ahsoka #starwars

Пікірлер: 20

  • @nastykitty44
    @nastykitty447 ай бұрын

    I had to double check the views while watching, your channel definitely deserves more attention and i hope the algorithm serves in your favour and i look forward to watching more!

  • @lowtemperaturehands

    @lowtemperaturehands

    7 ай бұрын

    Thank you! I still have a thing or 2 to learn. There is already a lot of great content out there in this space, but I'm very glad you enjoyed it!

  • @jlassijlali290
    @jlassijlali2903 ай бұрын

    12:00 Sabine can't tell Ezera she did doom the Glaxy and he will respond: Ok! i will help save it! They have that strong bond that they will put all Glaxy in line for eah other

  • @jlassijlali290
    @jlassijlali2903 ай бұрын

    Oh! the old days of rebels see Ezra has hard time controll and use the force throw first two season even after Kanan training!

  • @coletrain583
    @coletrain5837 ай бұрын

    I'm complaing more about the nature of Sabine's relationship with Ezra? If Dave Fiolni and now even the cast are insistant on their relationship being platonic, why did put all the tropes often used for a romantic arc for Sabine's character (many scenes even comming more as foreshdowing than anything else), despite the diolouge trying to make it that's the case when it's not due to the contex presented. Even Rebels, there a lot subtle hints and teases of romantic contex. Was the point was the show was to argue with the audience that was the case? If it was put there, it must be for a good reason rather than screw with us. It dosen't make sense and it ruins her character, rather progress it. In reality, it's almost like the show is trying to lie to us that isn't the case, but in practice it is. It just all feels like this plantonic bs was hammered in the show and it ruined the point of the story. Sabine is like totally in love with the guy. If that's not bad enough, there is brief, subtle musical reference to John Williams’ “Across the Stars,” the love theme for Anakin and Padme’ from Star Wars Episode II: The Attack of the Clones here, which is followed immediately by Sabine’s theme, basically confirming her romantic future with Ezra.(To hear the “Across the Stars” fragment, listen to the Ahsoka Soundtrack Vol. 2, Epilogue II from 2:34-2:39. I included the recording at the end of this blog post.). Dave wrote this he must know what he is doing, so if it's openly confirmed, then it would fix Sabine's character and make her motives more understandable.

  • @lowtemperaturehands

    @lowtemperaturehands

    7 ай бұрын

    Great catch!

  • @coletrain583

    @coletrain583

    7 ай бұрын

    @@lowtemperaturehands Thanks.

  • @dontrellmayfieldjr2868

    @dontrellmayfieldjr2868

    6 ай бұрын

    @@coletrain583 I’m glad you brought that up….. It is very foreshadowing .. and yes, basically from Rebels to Ahsoka series it’s very clear that Sabine & Ezra has so many signs, teases ,and hints throughout 9 years. there is romantic vibe behind the music between Ezra and Sabine.

  • @coletrain583

    @coletrain583

    6 ай бұрын

    @@dontrellmayfieldjr2868 I’m glad you noticed.

  • @coletrain583

    @coletrain583

    6 ай бұрын

    @@dontrellmayfieldjr2868 Is Dave Filoni gonna throw away all that buildup what would lead to a great story and powerful relationship over a FemFlash ship with Sabine and Ship, due to massive (and dare I say it unssearay) fan request? Please assure me that can;t the case. I'm not against LGBTQ relationships, just don't make Sabine not be into someone else, other than Ezra after all this.

  • @NeinBreaker
    @NeinBreaker7 ай бұрын

    So much could've been better if they had people who actually knew and gave a damn about the material in charge. But if Amazon's TROP is anything to go by ("Back to the books, back to the books", anyone?), then the chances of this happening in the near future is smaller than a Planck. Star Wars really should've gone on a hiatus after the much-reviled Disney Trilogy.

  • @lowtemperaturehands

    @lowtemperaturehands

    7 ай бұрын

    Wasted potential indeed!

  • @soulmourne2698
    @soulmourne26987 ай бұрын

    ahsoka is bad, not as bad as kenobi or the sequels, but its super dissapointing, i was specting that this show would match the quality of season 7 the clone wars, ahsoka was supposed to destroy the sith (kathleen and disney) not join them, we got something similar to mandalorian season 3, not awful but far worse than it should have been. I think that ahsoka should have been an animation show with a similar style to rebels, and the writting should have been much better. Ahsoka is one of the best characters in the franchise, but in this show she doesnt feel like her, yes we know that the realization of anakin being vader must have been very hard for her to handle, but i mean she managed to handle thousands of clones she loved shooting at her while saving rex and while feeling in the force that anakin was suffering a lot. They nerfed ahsoka a lot, i'm sorry but its absurd that baylan can match ahsoka, he shouldnt even be close, ahsoka managed to mantain a fight with vader for minutes in rebels, vader was one of the strongest sith lords that have ever existed. Then the show have big issues with dialogue and being so slow, also sabine is not very well written, she isnt the same sabine of rebels or at least not the sabine of rebels season 4, yes in season 1 and 2 she did what she wanted but after her development in season 3 she changed and grew a lot, not only that but also how her force powers are developed is stupid, it makes no sense how in the first episodes she cant move a cup but in the last episode sudenly first she pulls a lightsaber and 5 minutes later of using the force for the first time throws a full grown man 20 miles away to a ship with the force, thats just lazy garbage development. Is not as absurd as rei but its the same garbage idea of giving the force and making perfect female characters that kathleen wants. Ahsoka is my favourite star wars character and i was so so dissapointed with this show, litterally imo the only decent episodes are 3-5. Filoni has failed us this time, he is human and he can make mistakes or maybe kathleen had something to do?

  • @lowtemperaturehands

    @lowtemperaturehands

    7 ай бұрын

    Great points, completely agree. I also wanted to give Ahsoka a fair chance despite the disappointing start, but by episode 5 I had I really lost faith.

  • @darktenor4967
    @darktenor49676 ай бұрын

    I am growing honestly extremely tired of positions of moral relativism. Handled correctly, existentialism is a plea for authenticity and hard, life experience, for people to look outside themselves and ask honest questions. However, so much morality represented in modern entertainment just asserts the most facile brand of relativism. Nothing has any meaning, because any special meaning is: "whatever it means to you." Indeed any attempt to impose moral meaning is simply "the patriarchy!", or "white privilege." This is a faux profundity which appeals not to moral introspection, or artistic integrity, but only to the worst excesses of selfishness, narcissism and personal identity. Indeed, for all of Nietzsche's hatred of personal attachments or allegiances to principles like the state or the family, the one thing you could never accuse Nietzsche of is advocating the easy option. Implying that an absolute set of values such as those of the Jedi, or even the Jedi code leavened with compassion as showed by Luke Skywalker are simply subservient to "being yourself", is exactly the sort of facile, none-specific claptrap I'd expect in Modern star wars, indeed even trying to adapt star wars, at route a mythological story with definite moral underpinnings about redemption, compassion, and actual moral responsibility, to the superficial world of self-empowerment is trying to put a square peg in a round hole. this is why Luke Skywalker had to be broken, since not only is he the wrong sort of person (ie a straight white male), but he also represents something anathema to the modern cult of relativism, someone who follows principles bigger than his own ego. At this point, I'm actually finding myself far more interested in stories which actually exemplify, and promote moral virtues such as compassion, persistence through suffering, and forgiveness, since imho it's those sorts of stories, and those sorts of more basic human values we really should be focusing on at the moment. From the sound of it, Asoka should have been one of these stories, with a wise and experienced jedi imparting wisdom even having seen the old order and what she believed fall. But really, in 2023, we were never going to get that.

  • @lowtemperaturehands

    @lowtemperaturehands

    6 ай бұрын

    Ooh, thanks for taking the time to make another incredibly thought-out comment, it offers more to ponder over than the entirety of Ahsoka! I don't respect when writers opt for a morally relativistic approach when implored for the sake of pandering and codling the audience with words of self-validation. I find it to be a sign of cowardice on the part of the writer. Plato for example, also astutely observed that such a tactic was the mark of the sophist who would go from Greek city to Greek city telling the people what they want to hear to win their favour but would ultimately know nothing. You could say that Nietzsche, who resides on the other side of the spectrum to Platonic morality, might be an advocate for ‘being yourself’ but the huge caveat to that was there’s nothing the least bit comforting about what he had to say, liberating perhaps but certainly not comforting. Anyway, I'm certainly no expert but I believe that much is safe to say. Facile relativistic morality certainly makes for such an empty viewing experience. What about Ashoka is thought provoking? Nothing. What about Ahsoka elicits some kind of emotional response in the viewer that is more than simply self-validation or nostalgia driven? Nothing. It leaves the show as something that can be seen and heard but not truly experienced. I see some Star Wars fans scratching their heads wondering why Ahsoka didn’t revive Star Wars and I’d say this is largely why that was. Anyway, I do wonder whether such messaging tactics are due to the fragility of modern audiences. Certainly, if you say the ‘wrong’ thing there will be a backlash. I do worry that this fragility is starting to result in the loss of thought-provoking meaningful stories and creative freedom, because everything must ultimately conform to a rigid set of principles and beliefs that offers nothing new. So, seeing as some of these modern ‘stories’ wont give us any food for thought, I thought I'd offer up some of my own thoughts on what Ahsoka, Anakin and Star Wars could be. Then you can accept or reject my ideas as you see fit and form your own amalgam of what Star Wars could be. Wow, this ended up being a long comment… No need to go to the trouble of writing another reply btw! Appreciate the thought you’ve put into it already!

  • @samueltv9428
    @samueltv94285 ай бұрын

    The main problem with this wirh this rewrite to much dialogue from anakin he need to tell this over time and no true a text wall

  • @TheInfiniteSheldon
    @TheInfiniteSheldon7 ай бұрын

    "modern Star Wars sucks" Star Wars fans, since 1997.

  • @mattsmith1859
    @mattsmith18597 ай бұрын

    It really doesn't suck. Yes, some of the movies aren't very good but Ahsoka was very good and well recieved. You're like one of them that bitched about episodes 1,2, and 3 not being 'real Star Wars'.

Келесі