Purdy is #1 in QBR, passer rating, while having a #22 O-Line and average receiver separation. How biased you can get?

@Paul-tp9yh

Ай бұрын

Simms is slow to catch on, like some others- Brock is a lock at the second ranked qb in the nfl and he might challenge for the top spot in time. These naysayers just don’t know how to evaluate Purdy’s skill set, that’s on them.

@freddead1438

Ай бұрын

simms is blinded by his absolute faith in shanahan it sounds like

@cw8134

Ай бұрын

@Paul-tp9yh He is not a lock as the 2nd best QB in the league, he had maybe the best statistical year of any QB but that doesn't make him the best QB, Brees had some insane years but I don't think anyone ever ranked him over Manning or Brady...To be top tier you need to do it consistently, it's why having Stroud and Love so high is just dumb, they did well but it was their first year starting...having Dak that high is a fucking joke, the choke artist is a top QB? Trevor Lawrence has played half a season of decent football and he is ranked above Purdy gtfo.... this list is a troll meant to generate clicks

@Paul-tp9yh

Ай бұрын

@@cw8134 It’s a matter of opinion, the data just keeps adding up, not just stats but film.

@cw8134

Ай бұрын

@Paul-tp9yh Don't get me wrong I Love Purdy. I think he is the truth, unlike Kaep, who flamed out after a couple of good seasons, Purdys skill set translates much better to longterm success I just think it's too early to say he is a top 5 QB, is he playing like a top 5 QB, he sure was last year but to be top 5 you gotta do it for a few years in a row not just 1.5.

Purdy outplayed Allen and Lamar against the Chiefs but Purdy gets held to a double standard.

@CapeCod_y2k

Ай бұрын

My brother in law said the same thing and he’s a die hard patriots fan who’s originally from Boston lol

@Joes35

Ай бұрын

He didn’t outplay Josh Allen. That’s just a lie. Josh had 3 TD no picks, 76 rushing yards and scored more points in regulation with a worse team and worse coaches than Brock had. This is what gets me with fellow 49er fans, Brock is awesome but we got people pretending he’s better than Josh Allen and is a top 5 elite QB. Brock is better than Simms thinks but a lot of 49er fans overrate him

@JC-hq7iu

Ай бұрын

@@Joes35no one is saying he’s a better qb than Allen weirdo. But he did objectively play better and will continue to improve being only 24. Allen has already hit his ceiling

@bryanchambers1964

Ай бұрын

@Joes35 Brock had a higher qbr and passer rating by about 5 points each with a worse offensive line. At this point I wouldn't say Brock is better than Allen but we need to see more.

@paulyc2468

Ай бұрын

Im a 49ers fan and wouldn't call him elite. His potential is so high tho. It's too early for all that talk I wouldn't say he's up there pass Allen and Lamar but I think he could be. The kid is smart and agile. Happy to have brock what a story. They do have a lot of double standards for him tho. Ravens and bills played the same defense and everytime purdy left the field they had a lead whether it's a field goal or not.

Only in this guy's mind a QB who led a comeback TD win drive in 4th quarter is worse than the QB with game ending int on 1st down with 3 times outs left. Never seen a player more crucified for woulda-ints than actually ints.

😂😂😂 Purdy's decison making under pressure was the difference, when he made an off schedule throw or scrabbled to avoid the rush. When Love tried to make off schedule throws, he threw two picks.

@anotherjewishsharpnicholas9425

Ай бұрын

Love had like a couple good games all season. Simms has lost his mind.

@knn4247

Ай бұрын

Jordan Love has nearly the same passing yards against the Blitz as Brock Purdy. Except Jordan is playing with 1st and 2nd year players while Purdy is playing with all pros. 🤦‍♂️

@nicholassitter6400

Ай бұрын

​@@knn4247Love's line is way better than Purdy's.

@knn4247

Ай бұрын

@@nicholassitter6400 they still have nearly the same time to throw.

Simms is over stating the amount of wide open throws Purdy is making. I've seen a bunch of times where the play breaks down and Purdy extends the play with his legs and makes an off base throw to create for his team. Kyle Shanahan is great but he isn't the greatest coach to ever call a game where he's just scheming up guys wide open every single play.

@micahkiyimba8641

Ай бұрын

Shanahan is overrated. I hardly recall any open WRs in the SuperBowl and yet SF almost won based on defense and Purdy's clutch drives in the 4th.

If Chris Simms truly believes that if Jordan Love was playing for the 49ers they would have won the Super Bowl. That’s fine. He can have that opinion. I don’t agree with it. He argues that Love showed more in seven weeks than what Purdy showed…in a season.

@Lapwings

Ай бұрын

1,5 season

Please be specific on these throws in the superbowl

Acting like Purdy only throws to wide open receivers, he makes more tight window throws at a rate that I've never seen before, you'd think he's lucky until you see how often he does it. He earned the right to be called top 5, there's no evidence to the contrary except your feelings. He's MVP caliber and noone can take that away from him until he does something different than being top 3 in all the relevant QB stats on the field cause he's been nothing but top 5 since he first walked on the field. Facts over feelings 🖕

@BratatoChip

Ай бұрын

Damn you must be his agent my guy 👍🏼👍🏼

@mightguy123456

Ай бұрын

The hyperbole here shows how disingenuous you really are. “Tight window throws like you’ve never seen before”. Come on my guy. He’s really good! But undeniably he’s a YAC merchant that throws slant/out routes and screens to wide open receivers.

@dbuck161

Ай бұрын

You’re the one in your feelings dude. If he was top 5 the niners easily would have won the Super Bowl

@ayushnayak1442

Ай бұрын

@@dbuck161 He's not top 5. But he's definitely a good QB that deserves his flowers.

@dbuck161

Ай бұрын

@@ayushnayak1442 agreed. He got my respect this year. More than capable QB. Let’s just pump the brakes a little here

He lead the league in a ton of passing categories and led the team on two game winning comebacks in the playoffs (in the lions game he put the entire team on his back) and he has done 3 things that has never been done by a qb in niners history (completion percentage over 90 while throwing over 20 passes, perfect passer rating while throwing more than 20 passes, and is the single season passing leader which he did in 16 games). I do not know what else you want from him if he can do all of these things and only be at 17, give me a break.

@cw8134

Ай бұрын

Yea but hurr durr Trevor lawrence has half a season of decent football, jordan love has started one season, Dak and Jalen both have stacked teams and shit the bed... but Purdy was the last pick soooo

@simonevans5562

Ай бұрын

The Packers games was not a comeback lmao. It was a 4 point game to start the 4th Q and had like 6 different lead changes. That's not a comeback bro. That's punch for punch and Niners won a dogfight. Exactly why people say Niners fan put him on a pedestal.

@FJoeB1998

Ай бұрын

@@simonevans5562 false, we were down 7 at the start of the fourth quarter and later in the quarter he marched us down the field for a touchdown.

@simonevans5562

Ай бұрын

@FJoeB1998 okay lol. It started at 7 and 1 minute later was down to 4 lol. It was a 4 point game with 14 minutes left. Not a comeback

@FJoeB1998

Ай бұрын

@@simonevans5562 so you would be okay calling Purdy’s drive a “game winning drive” but wouldn’t be okay calling it a comeback? What is your definition of a comeback? What arbitrary number do you have to be trailing by?

Wow the Jordan Love bootlicking when he’s been in the league for 4 years 😂😂😂 Get a grip Chris Simms.

@jacob7224

Ай бұрын

I think the only person that needs to get a grip is the guy telling an ex NFL qb that he’s a bootlicker and needs to get a grip because he analyzed a player and they’re not as good as San Fran fans think.

@tylerasweet

Ай бұрын

Bootlicking? Lmao I don’t think you know what that word means. He ranked Love 13th. Relax

@ayushnayak1442

Ай бұрын

@@jacob7224 He is pretty good. Watch experts break down his film and then talk lol. Fans like you are too blind to see his talent but I don't blame you for that. JT O Sullivan by the way.

@BLGClipsx

Ай бұрын

So you agree with people who backs your opinion? 🤡

@ALWAYSTHINK4YOURSELF

Ай бұрын

Jordan love doesn’t have any boots to lick. See google for the definition.

Purdy’s 9.6 yards per attempt is #1 all time. This guys out of it

@Drewswaggy

Ай бұрын

Sign Purdy you will regret it. The talent around him will decrease showing his true self. Brock has Debo kittle and C.m You overlooking that he’s mid.

@justice85151

Ай бұрын

@GoldTau-t1b 💯 🎯

one guy choked in the playoffs and one guy didn't head to head, shouldn't that be the difference here or am i missing something

@dustinrustick8450

Ай бұрын

Love choked? Give me a break. His Kicker and his defense choked.

@nicholassitter6400

Ай бұрын

​@dustinrustick8450 he threw a game losing interception. If Purdy did that people would be killing him. They're already killing him for losing the Superbowl to the best defense in the league because his line let a free rusher get through (twice).

@dustinrustick8450

Ай бұрын

@nicholassitter6400 Get real, that INT is so overblown. his kicker missed a kick that would have put them up 7, then the defense let the niners go on a 6 minute go ahead drive, which left one minute on the clock. All momentum was gone and Love knew he needed a TD to end that game. The kicker wasn't going to be relied upon. The Game was already over when the Packers got the ball back.

When Shanny calls bootlegs and the defense is ready for it, Brock bails him out. He is as good as any QB diagnosing the plays before the snap. His Anticipation throws are wow throws. He does not have Pat Mahomes arm but he can compete with him on a given sunday.

Jordan Love throws 2 picks & people say he’s amazing. Purdy didn’t throw any picks, yet people critique him for the almost interceptions more harshly

@renz4738

Ай бұрын

Guy threw 2 passes straight to defenders that were dropped. It ain’t all about it stats. Get off your knees for Brock and wake up

@Thebluesky0311

Ай бұрын

@@renz4738 Yes that is football, that happens to every QB. There is a reason why current or former players and coaches speak very highly of him!

This the same guy that had Kellen Mond in his top 5😂😂😂😩🤦🏽‍♂️.

Why are people taking Chris simms seriously? He died on the Zach Wilson hill and that’s where we should leave him.

@johnbox271

Ай бұрын

The same reason I take Brett Kollmann seriously, even after he basically called the Chiefs complete idiot for drafting Patrick Mahomes: they give detailed rational for their opinions. Of course like everyone they are sometime wrong.

@BLGClipsx

Ай бұрын

Stop crying 😂😂😂😂😂

@davidh7123

Ай бұрын

So mean

@glow4417

Ай бұрын

Purdy is massively overrated by 49er fans.

@Justin-us2tu

Ай бұрын

Name your favorite NFL or fantasy analyst and I’ll show you multiple big misses Johnbox271. Perfect is a perception, not reality.

Talks about all these "wide open" receivers... This is tracked, and the offense hes in gives him about middle of the pack in terms of wide open throws.

I like how Purdy has 7 phantom interceptions but Chris conveniently forgets love had two dropped interceptions as well (and two that were actually caught).

I don’t know about anyone else, but when I need expert advice on quarterbacks, I always go to a failed quarterback who had FAR less yards in their CAREER than Purdy had in one season. And the playoffs.

So now Purdy is up to SEVEN almost-interceptions in the Green Bay game? 😂

@bongomanbwire

Ай бұрын

It'll be 10 soon.

@tjayd1225

Ай бұрын

It’ll be 12 by Monday

@TommyD1213

Ай бұрын

Hahahahaha on an absolute terrible weather day…and I just checked, it was 19 dropped interceptions.

@cw8134

Ай бұрын

He should have thrown X interceptionsnand gets dinged for it but Love doesnt get dinged for the interceptions he did throw? Guy is a clown

@judshuttie70

Ай бұрын

Lmao yes Simms adding extra by day, the most annoying thing for me is he's inconsistent I'm Brock fan niners fan but to highlight how he chooses what matters yesterday he said Tua is 18 because in 1 playoff game in cold he looked bad and skims dosnt want to have to worry about the qb in playoffs so Tua is ranked lower yet he has dak way higher a guy with what called an elite team last year yet every playoffs dak shits bed but he's not down with Tua.

You know Steve Young wasn't really that good. Jeff George would have more than one Super Bowl with the 49ers if he had Mike Shanahan drawing up plays and that much talent around him. (this is sarcastic but pretty much the same argument Simms is making)

I think you have to look at Purdy as a sum of his parts. His only real “weakness” is not having a killer arm but he’s good to very good at almost every other trait. He just has no other real weakness. Smart. Accurate. Throws on time. Throws on target. Even keeled. Etc. etc. But if you look at his numbers it pretty much proves he’s really good. High-60s completion percentage. Three on a TD-2-INT ratio. Over 100 on his passer rating. Crazy win-loss percentage. One Super Bowl appearance and maybe would’ve been two outside a freak injury. I just think he’s highly underrated and I usually root for strong-armed quick-release guys too.

@micahkiyimba8641

Ай бұрын

The only thing he doesn't have is a cannon Otherwise he has everything we look for. Accuracy, mobility, clutch ability and being humble.

Simms you lost credibility with me. This eval is ludicrous. Let’s talk about your other cant miss prospects.

@TTSCAM

Ай бұрын

Like who Zack Wilson if u doing it for 8 years u gone get a couple wrong

@user-mg6bk2yy1g

Ай бұрын

If Purdy had played in a below average team no one would have questioned that Nr 17 spot. This is just because it's 49ers you know that. It's a good not great QB but with great talent around him.

@kyle013100

Ай бұрын

​@@user-mg6bk2yy1gAnd Jalen Hurts had AJ Brown Devonta Smith Dallas Goedert and now has Saquon Barkley yet he gets ranked top 10 for a few years now come on stop it.

@karenhardie1132

Ай бұрын

Simms is criticizing Purdy for interceptions that didn't happen. He's off his rocker.😂

He said "all Purdy's highlights are player wild open" is insane misinformation

Anyone notice Simms keeps increasing the number of intercept-able passes Purdy threw? Last video, it was 4. Now it’s 7 🙄

@jayhawk1204

Ай бұрын

Simms the ultimate hater bro….tf?!

Jordan Love throws 2 picks & people say he’s amazing. Purdy didn’t throw any picks, yet people critique him for the almost interceptions more harshly 🤔

@knn4247

Ай бұрын

Hard to judge when you don't give any context. Jordan Love went 9 weeks straight without throwing any picks but everybody only talks about the two picks at the end of the season. Purdy struggled versus the Packers defense all game until the last drive. The same Packers defense that gave up 30 points to the Bryce Young's 2W and 15L Panthers. Jordan played bad versus a good defense, Purdy looked suspect against bad ones.

@vincenttalley5938

Ай бұрын

@@knn4247 No matter how you slice it, Purdy is getting judged harder for not turning the ball over vs Love turning it over twice 🤷‍♂️

@knn4247

Ай бұрын

@@vincenttalley5938 Purdy is getting judge more because he looked terrible in the playoffs on the most stacked team in NFL. Jordan Love nearly turned his team into a contender in a rebuild year.

@huh3719

Ай бұрын

@@knn4247Purdy struggles in the rain. Dude was wiping his hands after every play, idk why he struggles so much, maybe he has small hands. Jordan Love is really good, but his last pass was god awful, cross body into triple coverage nowhere near the receiver. That’s my biggest takeaway, everyone knows playoffs are a different beast, Jordan Love made more poor decisions that cost his team the loss. Purdy lead the final drive to beat the Packers and the second half of the Lions game was phenomenal. He says Jordan Love would’ve won the sb, I think the Lions would be in the sb instead of the Niners if Love was the qb.

@huh3719

Ай бұрын

@@knn4247how did he look terrible? Literally just the raining packers game, he didn’t look that good, but he still lead the final drive to get the team the victory

Simms saying that the 49ers would’ve won the Super Bowl if Jordan Love was the QB is like saying Space X would’ve had people on Mars by now if I was the owner instead of Elon Musk. You can’t be credible if you live in hypothetical land. Also, Simms is trying to give all credit to Kyle Shanahan and none to Purdy because he’s a great play caller. News flash dude, the QBs job is to execute the play that the play caller gives them.

Brock Purdy’s 2023 Season Metrics: 1. Passing Yards: 4,805 yards (Top tier) 2. Touchdowns: 34 TDs (Top tier) 3. Completion Percentage: 68.8% (Top tier) 4. Passer Rating: 104.2 (Top tier) 5. QBR (Quarterback Rating): 69.1 (Top tier) 6. Yards per Attempt (YPA): 8.3 (Top tier) 7. Interception Rate: 8 interceptions (Low rate, Top tier) 8. Advanced Metrics: • EPA (Expected Points Added): High, indicating significant positive impact. • CPOE (Completion Percentage Over Expected): High, demonstrating exceptional accuracy beyond expectations.

@BratatoChip

Ай бұрын

🤝🤝

@danielalfano2424

Ай бұрын

@@BratatoChip 🤝

@chuco915C

Ай бұрын

How many pass attempts?

@danielalfano2424

Ай бұрын

@@chuco915C don’t you have Google?

@chuco915C

Ай бұрын

@@danielalfano2424 yes but I want them to do it.

Simms threw for 3100 yards 12 touchdowns and 18 interceptions… For his career.

I think #17 is not "above average" in a 32 team league

@zakbednar4939

Ай бұрын

Yeah but each team has at least 2 qbs

@tylerasweet

Ай бұрын

17 out of like 96 qbs in the league? Sure it is

@vietqta

Ай бұрын

@@zakbednar4939 So then the position is that he's an above average QB but below average starting QB. I think I disagree with that considering he was a finalist for league MVP and really lost it on one week in the final stretch.

@stratgame117

Ай бұрын

​@@zakbednar4939"above average starting QB" is what was said.

Simms is the guy who sounds like he knows what he’s talking about. But in reality he’s just yapping. Basically that oration scene in Billy Madison. “We are all dumber for having listened to this”

Spoken like a person who lives by the saying "Who are you going to believe, me or your own eyes?".

You mean the guys who's made a Conference Championship as a rookie and then lost a SuperBowl in OT and he's not even 25 yet shouldn't be revered by that team's fanbase. Simms is just mad because he is Kyle Shanahan's buddy and everyone with sense and objectivity who watched the playoffs and SB58 came out with the same opinion. Purdy is clearly special and Shanahan's bad coaching is what's holding SF back. Shanahan doesn't deserve the genius reputation he gets.He has a good scheme but he's.yet to prove he can avoid fucking up big games.

Simms digging a bigger hole day by day. There are some people that are wed to their stupidity and will go all in rather than respectively cash out. Revisit this video in 9 months. He’ll say Purdy missed more interceptions than TD passes.

Kyle is one of Chris’ bestfriends….. so you know he isn’t being bias.

@Fortune_88862

Ай бұрын

Its actually why he is bias he wants Kyles system to get more credit than the players.

Dude is just content farming on purdy

Most of Purdy’s throws were in between defenders. Facts

Simms on SF v GB in playoffs: "Purdy should have thrown SEVEN interceptions in that game; he got lucky." This is why nobody takes Phil Simms' kid seriously.

Shanahan literally said Purdy makes decisions all the time that makes him scratch his head but he sighs in relief due to Purdy being a great decision maker and being hyped in a nutshell 😂

I think where niners fans are frustrated is if Brock does anything positive it’s immediately discredited. If Brock makes a bad play, it’s 100% him. If Trey Lance was doing exactly what Brock was doing, nobody would be ranking him 17th best in football, they’d be ranking him top 10 at very least. Jordan love plays for Matt Lafleur…a Shanahan scheme pupil as well.

Your boy Kyle would be on his way out without the greatness of Brock Purdy

Simms has joined the haters club. Now Brock is criticized for interceptions that didnt happen. Does he realize how ridiculous that makes him look.😂 Love didn't make the superbowl, he threw an interception.

@Grable424

Ай бұрын

to be fair, Purdy was playing one of the worst defenses in the league last year who dropped all the turnover worthy plays he threw, and jordan was playing one of the best defenses in the league last year who didn't drop the turnover worthy plays he threw. That's what Chris Simms is saying. I don't feel like that is debatable. It's just facts.

@Grable424

Ай бұрын

If you go back and watch that game (I have because apparently I'm a masochist), Jordan was playing pretty great for most of that game and just made a boneheaded decision at the end. Purdy made terrible decisions for 90% of the game and got lucky our defense has bricks for hands.

2:51 No one has ever said that Brock Purdy is the only guy who could do this. Where is he coming up with this stuff? Is he insane? Nobody has said that!

Watch the tape. It's one elite play after another by Purdy.

How can you dilute the Brock Purdy praise by stating he "missed alot of throws" and hit guys "who were so open there wasn't a defender on the screen", but then completely ignore Jordan Love literally shrinking in the final minute of a PLAYOFF game and throwing a ball that ended the game?

@champsnike

Ай бұрын

Dak, Trevor Lawrence, Baker Mayfield, Kyler Murray, Aaron Rodgers (at 41!), Kirk Cousins.....all should be lower than Purdy. The numbers and the eye test back that up, and that gets Purdy to 9, which is where the real conversation/argument should START.

@BMXTraining

Ай бұрын

That last throw of the season for love was a great decision. Keep those coming vs the Niners!

@karenhardie1132

Ай бұрын

Simms is a joke. Brock is now criticized for interceptions that didn't happen. 😂

@BMXTraining

Ай бұрын

@@karenhardie1132 that’s great. Ints that didn’t happen.

@karenhardie1132

Ай бұрын

@@BMXTraining Haters will never be happy. He can win 10 superbowls and they will still hate him. Makes zero sense. He is an incredible underdog success story and seems like a good guy.

WATCH THE GB GAME! Love should have had 6 picks. Greenlaw dropped 2 and so did the db’s

Love chocked, what are you talking about, hes talking out of his ass the whole time

Purdy is a great overall story, but he has a noodle arm. That matters when playing against great defenses. The 49ers were 1 and 3 against the AFC North last year. Simms is right. Purdy would be toast on a less talented team and in a stronger division.

Purdy, in one and a quarter seasons, has a regular season record of 18 - 4 and a playoff record of 4 - 1 in games he started and finished. Purdy's passer rating for those five games is 111.4. Below are six QBs that Simms ranked higher than Purdy. Their playoff records and stats, in games they started and finished, have a combined record of 6 - 11, and the six QBs have an average passer rating of 77.6. Additionally, their average number of years in the league is 5 and a half. The stat that matters most for a QB is wins in the playoffs. Not only does Purdy stack those wins, but he also plays at a level in the playoffs that none of the below even come close to. Lamar Jackson, 6-year vet, PO rec: 1 - 3 (RTG 75.7) Dak Prescott, 8-year vet, PO record: 2 - 4 (RTG 91.8) Justin Herbert, 4-year vet, PO record: 0 - 1 (RTG 84.7) T Lawrence, 3-year vet, PO record: 1 - 1 (RTG 72.1) B Mayfield, 7-year vet, PO record: 2 - 1 (RTG 100.4) Kyler Murray, 5-year vet, PO record: 0 - 1 (RTG 40.9)

Please let me on this show! I would love to chat about this one. I have some takes ready for this one..

People are way over hyping Love based on a few games against bad teams like the bears or the choking cowboys. Please keep in mind he played worse than Purdy did in the divisional, people seem to forget that.

@jasonokafor6866

Ай бұрын

Purdy played mid for three straight playoff games including the super bowl.

@nicholassitter6400

Ай бұрын

@@jasonokafor6866 maybe a few bad quarters but watch the 2nd half of the lions game again. Love looked great against the cowboys (who the niners also destroyed, the Shannahan offense runs circles around Dan Quinn) but was bad against the niners and lost. Dunno how anyone could claim Love is better than Purdy.

Simms is gaslighting us. Here is reality: Purdy one spot ahead of Tua= Troll. Jordan Love one spot ahead of Rodgers = Troll. Jared Goff one spot ahead of T Law= Troll. Dak one spot ahead of Hurts = Troll. Penix Jr one spot ahead of Jayden Daniels =Troll. Daniel Jones one spot ahead of Watson = Troll.... the whole list is a troll

Chris Sims point is that Purdy’s game winning drive against the Packers doesn’t count and Jordan Love’s two crucial interceptions with a lead at halftime don’t count either.

When the Shanahan special isn’t working and firing on cylinders there isn’t a lot Purdy does? Did he miss the whole second half of the Lions game? He played better that second half than Jordan Love had ever played. 150+ passing yards, 45+ rushing yards, 0 turnovers, 80%+ completion rate in just that second half. That’s never been done before in the regular or post season in over 2 decades

Chris is Using Brock as a scape goat for reason why his buddy Kyle hasn't gotten it done.. sorry bud this ain't no Jimmy G.

Shanhan took Jimmy freaking garroppolo to the super bowl and niners fans are wondering why people are low on purdy.

@kevinalan2028

Ай бұрын

Mostert took Jimmy to a SB. This time it was Purdy taking Kyle to a SB

@kennyb1997

Ай бұрын

One barley threw 10 times under 100 yards the other made a 17 point comeback with his legs and throws

@micahkiyimba8641

Ай бұрын

Because we watch the games. JimmyG threw 17 passes in his 1st 2 post season games. Purdy jas never thrown below.30 passes in a playoff game he's finished and in fact the most pass attempts he's had in ANY game was Vs the Packers.

@kennyb1997

Ай бұрын

@@kevinalan2028 bro he went nuclear 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 4tds 200 Plus yards

Chris, we are just doing the same thing you are with your boy Kyle, putting him on a pedestal. Kyle has been a perennial chocker.

So his main point is that his tattoe buddy schemes guys wide open, he clearly hasnt watched Purdy's highlights.😂😂

Simms said zack wilson was aaron rodgers enuff said

If Purdy retires today he will be the highest rated passer of all time beating our current #1 Rodgers, and #2 Mahomes. He's also just 24 yrs old. We shall see. It's funny that the other QB's that are "vastly" better than Brock play in the same offensive systems (Stroud, Jordan Love, etc...) yet under produce compared to Brock.

What's purdy's passing yards without YAC?

Don’t have a problem with where Purdy is ranked… but I do have an issue with Goff being ahead of Lawrence and Love. For all the same reasons he discredited Brock you have to apply to Goff, with exception to having a strong arm.

Brock is a top 10 QB. He won't get his universal respect until he wins a Chip.

They say he’s above average, 17th is literally below average!😅

Wish you would have a chat with David Lombardi about Purdy. Nick Wright is a fool, but I hold you in higher regard. +

1:00 - “I don’t think any regular listeners would be too shocked with where I ranked him” I was actually pretty surprised. I would’ve guessed Simms would’ve him at top 10.

As a Niner fan, I think Purdy is top 15 so slightly higher than what Simms has him at. But lets be real, if you were building a team and can take any QB, there are at least 10-15 QBs you'd take above Purdy. There's nothing wrong with that. He still deserves a big payday and he can still win a Superbowl.

This isn't anything new. Simms always undermines the ability of QBs at 49ers because he wants his man crush Kyle to get the credit. But Purdy's ability is undeniable and to say anyone who respects him is putting him on a pedestal is just more of the same. Simms would rather spend an afternoon blowing Kyle then actually closely observing Purdy. Not that anyone actually thinks he knows what a good QB is after all the Mac Jones hype.

Chris Simms hates the 49ers. What's new. I use to listen to the guy, but he is so biased and it's most obvious with this team. He takes orders from the producers.

Simms is talking about Purdy like he’d have done better. “Just a hop and a skip and that’s a completion” as if it’s that easy 😂. If Jordan Love just didn’t throw across his body into triple coverage with plenty of time on the clock maybe they would’ve gotten to the sb 🤷🏽‍♂️

Brock Purdy is a top 5 quarterback

He's an above average QB??? You just ranked him as below average. Unless the league has added several teams.

Chris simms talking QB talk is comedy. Ask him how playing QB with Jon gruden went lol

Only greatness will recognize greatness and Chris Sims is not one of them.

Comments section has more substance than this entire video

This is Sims trolling. His ranking, coming out with 17th. If you notice what he is saying is all unprovable so he can say it with no recourse. I like the packers but to think that Love could run Shanahan’s offense is a joke. He couldn’t run the Packers offense for the first half of the year. Love is good, he might even put up similar numbers as Purdy if he was in SF. Sims misses the point. Purdy outshined Love in every aspect of the game except probably rushing yards. He did so coming off of surgery with no offseason and Kyle limiting the playbook in the first 5 games. Chris wants viewers and this is how he gets it. There is no reasonable reason why anybody doesn’t have Purdy in the top 10 until he is not worthy of it. Every team has the same budget and most spend a huge chunk on the QB. The Niners didn’t and boy did they get lucky!

Brock Purdy is showing skills at an awesome level in the NFL. People need to stop hating. But at the same time keep hating him cause I'm loving Brock Purdy smashing all you haters on the Field. This is actually Brock Purdy 1st full season no injuries let's see what Brock Purdy does this year 💯🔥

I don’t think Jordan Love playing in the Super Bowl makes Shanahan run the ball as he should have, or target Aiyuk over Deebo.

Okay…just keep the same energy for Love. Go back and find his missed throws, discredit the wide open looks, and deduct him for “almost” interceptions. Street goes both ways buckaroo!

Chris where would you rank yourself among the best QB's? If you run out of 0's I totally understand. Cleanup your own backyard before you start on other people's Were you ever even mentioned in the conversation for MVP in your short career?

What gets me Chris is your statement that Love would have won SB if he had been QB for 49ers. That is insane and wrong!!

@nicholassitter6400

Ай бұрын

There were a lot of things that went wrong during the SB but Purdy wasn't one of them. I doubt Love would've done any better than Purdy during OT on the goal line of Chris Jones was rushing free at him.

Simms acts like Shanahan is the only coach scheming WRs open. If Jalen Hurts played behind that OL, he's be on IR in less than 3 games.

Lazy take he’s not always throwing to wide open receivers it’s a discredit to Purdy’s hard work he’s a really good quarterback

So many NFL pundits can't stand that Purdy is doing what he is doing because he makes them look like hapless morons since no one saw him coming. It turns out all these talking heads don't really know what they're talking about. They're right once in a blue moon, but even a broken clock is right twice a day. The 49ers have an amazing roster and offensive play, but no one has been able to execute it close to Brock's level and he still has Similac on his breath. You want to talk about a game manger for the 9ers? That's Jimmy G. Dude didn't have a long ball and could not throw it outside the hashes. Purdy gets all the blame and none of the credit. And to reference Nick Wright... that dude is troll and a moron who lets his KC bias get in the way of all his takes. Simms talks about Shanahan like he could bring a popwarner team to the NFL and make them competitive. Give me a break.

This clown thinks he knows what elite-nfl-quarterbacking is. hey chris, LaVar says thanks for that pass.

Well Chris, maybe you should tell your buddy Kyle Shanahan to cut him and pick up a random QB off the street. Then you won't have to ever talk about Brock Purdy again.

I'm sure if Simms had made these lists back in the day he would have guys ranked ahead of Joe Montana and Tom Brady for the same reasons he cries about Purdy being overrated.

Can’t agree more.

Jordan Love throws to wide open receivers too 💀 Stroud, Love, Stafford, Tua and the Vikings have a very similar offense to the 49ers and the chargers will too this season!

This fool's all about click bait

I’m sorry but his stance on purdy is just flat out wrong. I feel like Kyle puts him up to this shit just to motivate purdy lol

Simms puts his best friend Kyle Shanihan on a pedestal. Plenty of the other quarterbacks throw to open people as well. In thise cases the quarterback gets the credit but in San Francisco the coach gets all the credit. If Kyle is so good then why hasn't he won a superbowl yet as a coordinator or as a coach? Maybe Kyle isn't as great as Simms and the rest of the media makes him out to be. And I don't think Purdy is amazing but I think he's higher than 17 and you can see that by just watching the games

Purdy deserves it.. he saved the day many times..

Shannon has always had a pertty good quarterbacks. The thing is he just cant get over the hump.

Didn't know almost interception is a stat at all, by that logic can Qbs get almost touch-downs as a state also, is only fair.

@Fortune_88862

Ай бұрын

Almost interceptions are tracked they are called turnover worthy throws and Purdy is way down on the list. He is using a 1 game sample size for his take, just an absolute tool.

Simms w/ all his expertise lol

Purdy better than Tua & Baker.

@raniasaad8772

Ай бұрын

Lol

@user-mg6bk2yy1g

Ай бұрын

So Tua and Baker would do worse in 49ers? You don't have to be a superstar with such talent around you. Had Brock played in below average teams no one would question a Nr 17 placement.

@nevillecoley4976

Ай бұрын

And you know this based on what ?

@champsnike

Ай бұрын

@@user-mg6bk2yy1g but he doesn't, he plays on the 49ers. Jared Goff is top 10 for Christ-sake......don't tell me that the talent around him isn't in the ballpark of the 49ers (one could argue with that O-Line, it is better overall!)

@kyle013100

Ай бұрын

​@@user-mg6bk2yy1gTua has Tyreek Hill and Jaylon waddle two number 1 receivers and a good offensive mind legit from the 49ers as his head coach and cant perform in the play offs. Sit down.

Yeah so I'm done with the Chris Simms unbuttoned another Brock purdy hater, is there any of the day Brock purdy made to the super bowl, Jordan love will not go to the super bowl with Green Bay and that's a guarantee

Jordan love plays great in the playoff game against the 49ers and throws 2 picks at the end and loses the game no critique. Brock purdy plays great most of the game against the vikings and throws 2 picks at the end and we are all reminded about how he can't function without the cast of "all stars" around him. Also jordan love plays in the exact same system as brock... draftism....

17th is BELOW average in the NFL...And he lied talking about Brock could've thrown 7 picks vs GB...LIES