Marla Singer is a real character, not simply another figment of Jack's imagination. Too many third-party characters interact with her for her to be immaterial. The bit about her standing nonchalantly in the middle of traffic is simply to highlight her feelings of existential nihilism.

@ksl2137

Жыл бұрын

In the novel, yea. In the movie, she is fictional. People interact with Tyler, but he’s still interacting with people. They’re the same person, Marla never have a address but they know where she lives? He’s actually staying at that hotel, that’s how he knows. When he’s her, the hotel is called hotel lindy but when it’s him the hotel is the actual real name “hotel Bristol”

@jinjaninja8096

Жыл бұрын

Smartest comment I've ever seen

@MickeyDeviant

Жыл бұрын

I read the book as Marla being the ONLY real character. She mentions her father wanting a boy, and at the start of the novel, Tyler and the Narrator are polar opposites of 21st Century men...as though she'd made them BOTH up. It also explains the scene where the Narrator is captured on the bus and is going to be castrated by the mob...but then is let go "intact" without further explanation.

@Carnerd101

Жыл бұрын

agreed

@conanboyle7

Жыл бұрын

Agreed, crossing the street showed her lack of care for her own life.

I hate the idea that Marla and Project Mayhem don't exist. Drags the whole film into "it was all a dream" territory

@PLUTOXGOAT

3 жыл бұрын

Marla is real. As much as people say otherwise she is 100% real. And project mayhem did exist. Only thing that wasn't real was Tyler durden (Brad Pitt)

@eclark3849

Жыл бұрын

100 mil freedom protestors most want to end the control of all the psychopaths controlling us

@makegeorgeorwellfictionaga9268

Жыл бұрын

No , its not true, everything else was real just not tyler durden I don;t know where this guy got this information

@whomidity3953

Жыл бұрын

Marla and project mayhem were real, since Marla is in the second book and project mayhem is referenced

@kaidanlovejoy4680

Жыл бұрын

Project mayhem technically did exist since it did happen

If Marla isn’t real the whole movie doesn’t make sense. She is the one thing that holds the story together. She is real!

@MrBuketman

Жыл бұрын

So is the entire movie not real? A guy suffering psychosis and insomnia? A sleep walking nightmare?

@cadburykiller2649

Жыл бұрын

She is real,you can read the novel to confirm that

@davidking4838

Жыл бұрын

I think so too. It's taking things too far to say she isn't real.

Anyone remember When Bob talks to The narrator about Tyler and says “they say he only sleeps one hour a night.” That’s another call to the fact it’s him

@PrinceIsot

Жыл бұрын

Damn I wish I had caught that, I don't even remember that line either. Need rewatch

@fuelsfornerds

Жыл бұрын

Another fact to be highlighted was when Bob says,"they say he was born in a mental hospital" now this gives us a even more perspective of jack's life

A cool theory would be the first rule of Project Mayhem being “You do not ask questions”. Instead of it being interpreted as “questions shouldn’t be asked” it could be meant to be interpreted as “YOU (Tyler)” “Tyler doesn’t ask questions”. They are already aware of his split personality and Tyler could have to them that he doesn’t ask questions, only the narrator does as an indicator of which personality is currently in control.

I am Jack's titanic breath. How did you not make this joke?

@jonathanshaw7355

3 жыл бұрын

I'm jack titanic breathe. With out it The narrator can't breathe, complete the scene and the movie doesn't get made.

@rondoiron6907

3 жыл бұрын

In titanic he is also named jack

@DouglasMcZombie

Жыл бұрын

danny boyle took leodardo from fight club to be in the beach... jack jack jack? still, edward norton is a national treasure

Without this exact cast, we wouldn’t even be talking about what we’re not really supposed to be talking about.

@MyYoutubeChannelBabyyyy

4 жыл бұрын

Huh??

@bringbackmyspace7112

4 жыл бұрын

@@MyKZreadChannelBabyyyy It's the first and second rules. Shhhhh....🤫🤫

@bringbackmyspace7112

4 жыл бұрын

Agreed.

@NKA23

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I cannot imagine the movie would have worked so well with another cast. Also I don't think it would have made any significant impact with another cast. The cast is PERFECT.

@VictorRobotov00

4 жыл бұрын

Agreed. Already great names before the film. But this film certainly catapulted them in my mind.

The Tyler Durden he sees at the airport is a real person because Edward Nortons back is turned to him. He saw this person and then subconsciously recreated him in his mind.

@jbillson

4 жыл бұрын

Jeff Doe I like that

@gradatim4065

4 жыл бұрын

Holy shit man!! yeah

@gradatim4065

4 жыл бұрын

but how can u explain, we see tyler for a second in the group therapy, and it happens before

@igkgigoh

4 жыл бұрын

Another thing is the poster of a Brad Pitt movie you can see in the background in some scene. So Brad Pitt might exist in this movie, too and that could be why Tyler looks like him.

@CultofThings

4 жыл бұрын

Gradatim the timelines are not clear. You see him at the Airport but you don’t know if its a flashback.

You couldn't be more wrong about Marla being a figment of his imagination

@dryan1387

4 жыл бұрын

I'm thinking the same thing 😑 she has to be real

@marioestrada2573

4 жыл бұрын

I don't think she is real either.

@2macca3

4 жыл бұрын

marla is real there is a fight club 2 written by the same person it a graphic novel.

@2macca3

4 жыл бұрын

@Jacob Dean you need her to be real for any of that story to work she is doing her own thing with the kids who look old when the narrator is doing other things at the same time and how do you expect the kid

@r1g0r61

4 жыл бұрын

tyler is able to PHYSICALLY affect marla. HE isn't real, therefore SHE can't be real.

Me: *looks at video title* "Well the comments are gonna have fun with this"

The last two don't hold up at all

@andydudley1775

4 жыл бұрын

we dont talk about fight club!

@momothebear

4 жыл бұрын

Unless you take into account the possibility that he never went to save her from her suicide attempt and Marla died. But as Tyler says, he's all that Jack wished he could be, including a hero to the one he abandoned dying over the phone, so he fantasize about going to sweep her from her demise and then fucking her like there is no tomorrow and that she'd fall in love with him. Then Marla would be real right up to the point she dies and then becomes part of his imagination.

@jackcassidy9963

4 жыл бұрын

@@momothebear what about all the scenes where people acknowledged her after her suicide attempt

@jacobriel416

3 жыл бұрын

@@jackcassidy9963 Doesn't respond.

When the car they crash pulls up, the first driver opens the door, looks at Ed Norton's character and says, "Don't worry, Mr. Durden, airport parking long term." This was another clue that Ed Norton's character was Tyler all along.

Immens let’s be honest what’s more iconic than Pitts body in fight club? Every guy wants to look like that

@RJ-em1dg

3 жыл бұрын

Lol yeah

@andrewharper1609

3 жыл бұрын

Meat Loaf.

@NARKYCZ

3 жыл бұрын

Have you seen Troja?

When you said "We know this.." I immediately followed it up in my mind with "Because Tyler knows this"

If Marla isn’t real then who is selling clothing when the narrator and Marla are splitting up meetings? Who do the club members drag up to see the narrator at the end? They are physically dragging her through the street when the narrator is talking to Tyler.

@WreckerR

4 жыл бұрын

I guess it's all supposed to be in the Narrator's/Jack's head?

@snazzey14

4 жыл бұрын

Marla is real after they slept together and he was talking to Tyler she asked who he was talking to

@laterreurrouge1917

4 жыл бұрын

In the book as well as the movie she is real.

@WG55

4 жыл бұрын

Jack isn't real either! None of it is real! Even the movie isn't real!

@orchidrose1410

4 жыл бұрын

William Adderholdt 😁Awesome!😂🤣

An additional interesting bit: after Marla's monologue about the discarded prom dress she's wearing, and "Jack" effectively kicks her out, she leaves singing a song from "Sybil" which is the movie based on the 1973 book about a real woman who was presented as having an extraordinary dissociative personality disorder (That woman, Shirley Mason, was later found to have made it all up - she'd developed an attachment to her therapist, who was interested in "multiple personality disorder" as it was known at the time). It's a hint about "Jack" and I *don't think it's about her being imaginary. I'm Team Marla-Is-Real....

@RocketdogandSeptembr

2 жыл бұрын

Anyone who thinks Marla is imaginary is a total dipshit.

@Bonbonbon739

2 жыл бұрын

Marla is real thank you

@KingOfJamos.

2 жыл бұрын

Marla is Jacks feminine side. Tyler is Jacks masculine side. Bob has two full grown children that no longer return his calls. Bob is in essence a hermaphrodite with male and female organs. Bob is the creator of Marla and Tyler. No one is real.

@lisaspikes4291

Жыл бұрын

The song Marla sings is from the movie Valley Of The Dolls. Not Sybil.

@wolfhors3_660

Жыл бұрын

@@lisaspikes4291 thank you

All of the things tyler does are actually done by the narrator, the movie shows that. If Marla was imaginary then he would be talking to himself like he does with Tyler. But then why would he imagine tyler talking to her and going to her house, which would be things that couldn't happen? Along with the imaginary house you might as well say everything in the whole movie was just imaginary.

@richardcollier1912

7 ай бұрын

It is. Chuck P. made it all up.

One of the off hand fights when some rando asks to go next, Tyler tells him to lose the tie. It was cornflower blue like Jacks boss'.

Someone hasn't read the Fight Club 2 graphic novel, also written by the original author, Chuck Palahniuk. The narrator's name is actually revealed to be Sebastian. He and Marla get married and have a kid together.

@jeanmichellelaurent

2 жыл бұрын

Except the writer admits it’s not canon

@CreativeCache101

Жыл бұрын

@@jeanmichellelaurent the movies not cannon lol, no suggestion in the book that anyone but Tyler is an alter ego

Is it weird that I never noticed that Edward Norton doesn't have a name?

@PacalScat

4 жыл бұрын

Of course fucking or course

@JorenMyers

3 жыл бұрын

No, it isn't meant to be noticed on the first watch.

@joshuakehl5891

3 жыл бұрын

Very.

@jacobriel416

3 жыл бұрын

@@JorenMyers I usually forget names in movies (except for the rememberable ones) and I think that I just remembered "Tyler Durden" and thought I just forgot The Narrator's name. It made me a bit annoyed that I forgot it because I liked his character so much, so I watched the movie again (no complaints there) and sure enough he didn't have one. hahahaha

Also in the beginning when they're in the terminal, Edward Norton says something along the lines of "if you go to sleep, can you wake up as someone else?" All while the camera is on Tyler Durden. I've always assumed that was obviously foreshadowing what's to come too.

The insomnia is what really drew me into this film. The madness it creates in you is pretty much exactly as it's depicted in the film. You are essentially slowly going mad. You can feel yourself going mad but occasionally you get a half-decent (by insomniac standards) stretch of sleep and you feel like you've held back complete insanity for just a bit longer.

@rebeccamatyas691

2 жыл бұрын

Right, I've had insomnia since early elementary school mixed with not being allowed to go out of the yard for most of my life I started talking to myself and still refer to myself as us or let's or we're.

@falkorornothing261

Жыл бұрын

Marijuana is helpful 😁

@jj18057

Жыл бұрын

Can't discuss movies about insomnia without talking about the machinist

Still the best movie ever. And incredible how it got even more actual with time

The name of Edward Norton's character is... well, depends on who you ask. The script and credits refer to him as the narrator. On set during filming, he was referred to as Tony. If you watched the VHS with closed captioning, he is referred to as Rupert. The fans refer to him as Jack. Oh, and all the names he uses for his Hello My Name Is... stickers are all names of Robert DeNiro characters.

@conanboyle7

Жыл бұрын

Hmm. I still maintain that Tyler is both characters, the creator and the monster. Check out my comments above; the story is very similar to Mary Shelley's Frankenstien.

This movie made me go back and read the book. Then I ended up reading everything Palanuik wrote up to 2011. I need to get back to reading his newer stuff.

@Baalenciaga666

3 жыл бұрын

Matthew Bittenbender don’t

@matthewbittenbender9191

3 жыл бұрын

Denis well beautiful you sucked. Seemed more like a foray into erotic, but it clearly was a commentary on the over use of cellphones and internet. Damned was good, being the sequel. It really didn’t disappoint, but just not as impactful. All others are up for question.

@swoops41

Жыл бұрын

Nah his newer stuff isn’t as good. I can’t get through Adjustment Day for the life of me. And Damned (plus the sequel) weren’t that great

@matthewbittenbender9191

Жыл бұрын

@@swoops41 opinions.

Chuck Palahniuk was not mentioned, not even once on this list, he knows many "Things You Didn't Know About Fight Club"

@joshwhite9954

4 жыл бұрын

Probably couldn't pronounce the last name

@ItsTheMojo

4 жыл бұрын

He doesn't talk about it.

@eddmario

3 жыл бұрын

He also prefers the movie over the book

I cant see Reese Witherspoon or Sarah Michelle Gellar "not having getting fx*ked like that since grade school" to goodie Two-Shoes. Maybe Christina Ricci.

@GreenCrim

4 жыл бұрын

SMG could have done it. There's a Buffy outtake where one of her friends is shocked to hear the 'neutered' vampire Spike is being sheltered by her and SMG goes off script. Willow: He sleeps here!? Buffy: Only when he fucks me before dinner.

@WreckerR

4 жыл бұрын

@@GreenCrim Must be a B-roll thing because I REALLY would have remembered that... And liked it.

@MastinoNapoletano420

4 жыл бұрын

Then you need to watch Cruel Intentions...

@heatherhorton4514

4 жыл бұрын

@@MastinoNapoletano420 or Freeway

@sobrietyisoverrated

4 жыл бұрын

michael lawton Watch FREEWAY with Reese W and you’ll be able to imagine her saying anything. Fantastic far out movie.

Marla is real and they are married in the sequel comic by the original author.

@rudrakshsaha8210

3 жыл бұрын

theres a comic???

@Wolfsheim23

3 жыл бұрын

Did the comic carry on from the book ending where Tyler was continuing to run Project Mayhem for much of the time that Jack was unconscious in the Hospital?

Fight Club and Falling Down! Both movies are classic descents into madness!

I thought that the case of Marla Singer saying, "I want to have your abortion" was changed, or maybe also changed, from the book because Brad Pitt explained to David Fincher saying that his mom is gonna see this movie. This was said by Chuck Palahniuk the author himself when he was on Joe Rogan's' podcast.

Marla called Norton Tyler durden, near the end of the film when he's asking her if they've slept together and what his name is. It's a gigantic plot point towards the end. How did you miss that?

@maxshepherd9790

Жыл бұрын

This video is about things people miss. The moment your on about is the moment the penny drops for the audience. It's the moment no one missed.

@janniknielsen9292

Жыл бұрын

@@maxshepherd9790 Wouldn't that mean that The narrator is Tyler Durden, thus not nameless.

@donalmcg4185

Жыл бұрын

@@janniknielsen9292 No, Tyler isn't real, "Jack" unknowingly portrayed himself as Tyler.

@janniknielsen9292

Жыл бұрын

@@donalmcg4185 He has multiple personality disorder, so whatever Brad Pitt does it is Edward Norton doing it, which means Tyler is "Jack" too. Tyler is as real as the Narrator persona. Tyler is an extension of The Narrator. Tyler Durden is the only name we know him by and he made cards with such a name. He is unknowing of Tyler is him, as part of his condition.

Definitely gonna give it another watch. One of my favorite movies, I went to see it 3 times at the theater. I think I'm gonna give the book another read too.

@builtdifferent244

2 жыл бұрын

they have a book?

Was that quick splice of Ash due to her love for “Fight Club”?

@NIronwolf

4 жыл бұрын

Twice.

@MikeMJPMUNCH

4 жыл бұрын

Josh and Ash are the same person

@devinpackard6332

4 жыл бұрын

I was hoping someone else say this I thought I was going crazy lol

If you had read the book you would know that Marla is real. For the narrator, the house is also real. I don't want to spoil the book ending but his 'other self' double crosses and protects him from his own suicide by ensuring that he is 'looked after' by other members of 'project mayhem', what I got form the book is that the narrators personality is actually a figment of his own imagination, and Tyler is the conscious self, as he slowly has a complete break from reality, I still question whether he actually talks to the cops or not. Excellent book!

@arisrayden

8 ай бұрын

true but if you had alswo read the real sequel written by the original author of the original book then you would know that tyler durden is actually a demon and can leap to other people

NEVER thought about Marla as imagination. Will watch again with this point of view in mind.

Another clue about Tyler's true identity is when Marla calls the narrator at Tyler's house and tells him he left a forwarding number. That forwarding number was left way before the apartment blew up.

Marla is real, her character is referred to and also real in the book. Anyone who hasn’t read the book should. The film was so loyal it’s a quick easy read only about 149 pages.

For fuck’s sake....”vs.” is “versus,” not “verse.”

#21 Norton was having a hard time getting into character because he didn't have a name. So he gave the narrator a name that he shared with the director and no one else. To this day he refuses to tell anyone the name he used to get into character.

One other thing I noticed was when the narrator hit himself to set up his boss, he didn't seem uncomfortable with it. It was as if he fought himself before. Knowing that Tyler is his split personality, this is just another detail that makes perfect sense.

@nerdynurgle7777

Жыл бұрын

"for some reason, it reminded me of my first fight with tyler"

Showed Fight Club to a couple kids when I was about 15, think they were 12 and 14, they loved it and it blew their minds… turned out their parents were evangelical and sheltered their kids until that time, I blew up that over protection like the banks were blown up at the end

@maartenbrilleman7575

Жыл бұрын

Sure you did

This is a great list guys! Just when you think you knew all there was to know. And sure, you've Seen it all but you didn't know it.

This was brilliant!

Thanks Joshy, I have to go watch it again now

Josh. The last 3 things you theorize are not THINGS WE DIDNT KNOW. They’re theories. You can’t include them in this list without writer or director admitting them. They’re your theories, or somebodies theories...and that devalues all future lists you expect us to watch.

@jamesk9459

3 жыл бұрын

This isn’t “10 things Josh thinks could be secrets about Fight Club”. So don’t include your theories in a WatchCulture Video. It devalues the channel. Save it for “Josh’s Stoner Hour”.

His name is Chuck Palahniuk

Thank you, Josh, for your inciteful video.

I haven't watched this in years and never analyzed it that closely very crazy stuff good points

Perfect timing. My review of "Fight Club" is already in the works. I forgot it came out in 2000.

@tylerdurden5488

3 жыл бұрын

+381665600399 Viber Call if you are you/Tyler Durden.........

I wish I'd left the 20 things unknown.

2:07 I'm just glad I could pause the video on the Tyler in the airport scene to see your little easter egg.

Thank you Ashley to also show up, I didn’t know you also were in the cast great

Nice flash of Ash...lol

STOP BREAKING THE RULES!

I live on Paper Street in the toxic waste part of town and I love it!! My neighbors are industrial and other than the highway at the end of the street, this whole area is mine after 7:00 p.m.!!!

One reason why the number of shirtless scenes for Pitt would be such a negotiable issue is because he had to "dehydrate" himself days before each shot to achieve that sort of ridiculous muscle definition.

jack, says somthing about Tyler and marla never being in the same room, and his parents pulling the exact same trick.... in this sense it like a reconstruction of his childhood

@plymouth491

4 жыл бұрын

That's what I love about this movie; there's so much to it to consider.

@esperoutdoors9421

4 жыл бұрын

@@plymouth491 could well be my fav movie all all time, at least top 5

Marla doesn't exist. Just forget the scene where a waiter clearly adresses her and takes her order. Also the house doesn't exist because even though there a many scenes in it with Marla, the space monkeys and a working phone which the cops call, the number doesn't match the card. Really grasping at straws to finish the list on an even number huh.

@mandarb23

4 жыл бұрын

Well she doesn't exist and mayhem doesn't exist and the house and it wasn't the first time he hallucinated a phone call then yes the waiter was clearly a member of the non-existent fight club who could interact with the fake girlfriend and the fake girlfriend could be in the fake house and the members of the fake club could drag the fake girlfriend to the top of the building.

@taylormoore3400

4 жыл бұрын

She exists, so do the followers of fight club. Read the fight club 2 comic book.

@momothebear

4 жыл бұрын

@@taylormoore3400 it's funny you'd say that because that's exactly the problem Narrator/Tyler has given his mental condition: differentiating what is real from what is not. For him everything he sees and therefor what you see is real but then you slowly realize that things you thought were real were in fact imaginary and then who's to say what is real. You can't very well ask someone you know and trust because you just got the realization that the one person you knew and trusted the most is your imaginary friend. So what ever you read in the novel or comic book or what ever is related to Ed Norton's character can be a figment of his imagination but the reader doesn't have a clue because the reader sees the world through the eyes of the narrator who's an hallucinating schizophrenic.

@taylormoore3400

4 жыл бұрын

@@momothebear just read the fight club two Chuck wraps the whole thing up for everyone esp the people who didn't read the book and only watched the movie. Hate to be the bearer of bad news but she's real, so is fight club.

@momothebear

4 жыл бұрын

@@taylormoore3400 the question is not whether or not she and the fight club are real, the question is to what end is the narrator's interactions with them real. See Marla is real when he meets her in the groups therapies She's real when he phones her after blowing up his apartment but from then on, there is no explanation as to how she got a phone number for a house he didn't have during their meeting when he didn't even give his number for the apartment he had when they met. Let me put it this way, if you dream about having sex with a movie star, does that mean that said movie star "isn't real"? No. But does it mean the sex you had was real? Absolutely not. The image of that person you had sex with was a figment of your imagination. And that's what the theory suggests. There is a real person attached to this fantasy but what you see (or what the narrator sees) isn't happening for real. And that would indeed be characteristic of paranoid schizophrenia. I mean the symptoms are all there: Seeing, hearing, or tasting things that others do not. Suspiciousness and a general fear of others’ intentions. Persistent, unusual thoughts or beliefs. Difficulty thinking clearly. Withdrawing from family or friends. A significant decline in self-care. But of course there is a real Marla, and there is a real fight club... they just never did most of the things you saw in the movie.

Thank you

Ok I am so relieved that those flashing Tylers were actually a thing and I wasn’t seeing things wow! I was watching it at like 2 AM and thought my lack of sleep was screwing with me

The frontman from Live is the waiter who recommends against the clam chowder.

Tyler Durden is literally Tyler Durden's Stand

@borisnk9434

3 жыл бұрын

@Linda Reyes Shit?Is that a motherfucking jojo reference.

I love that scene where Jack Narrator and Tyler Durden pass each other on the escalator. Also, for some reason, I keep thinking about awesome Ash Millman for no reason

Really interesting list

I wish What Culture and Cinefix would sit down with Screen Rant and help them understand how to create content (other than Ryan George, who is terrific).

Not sure I'm comfortable with your breaking the first rule of Fight Club. To this day it remains Helena Bonham Carter's finest performance though.

Nice, even though I have only ever seen this film once.

Good stuff

I thought we weren't supposed to talk about it.

@tylerwoodward9517

4 жыл бұрын

Entertainment by MCE no one talks about fight club!

@FatherFunk

4 жыл бұрын

Literally came here for this comment

@GreatRedGeneral

3 жыл бұрын

Fughetaboutit!!!!!!!

@azpuru3

3 жыл бұрын

X

@paulelroy6650

3 жыл бұрын

Jesus that would have bee funny 20 years ago.

I've never even heard of Fight Club. So I guess they did their job well.

@TheRealMinotaur667

4 жыл бұрын

Okay. Stop. Go watch it, then come back. His name, was Robert Paulson.

@literally_john1507

4 жыл бұрын

Marcus James it’s a joke, because you aren’t supposed to talk about fight club

@paulelroy6650

3 жыл бұрын

How like how have you not? You must be very young yeah?

Wow! That was interesting!

Thank You!

@tylerdurden5488

3 жыл бұрын

+381665600399 Viber Call if you are you/Tyler Durden.........

Also Marla knows Tyler and the Narrator are the same person. Narrator doesn't know this, so why would he imagine Marla to know this?

@banehog

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah, Marla being imaginary makes no damn sense, and would severely undercut the main themes of the story

@laterreurrouge1917

4 жыл бұрын

It's as wrong as it gets. Marla is real in both book and movie. That was utter bs.

@thisisarandomname4150

4 жыл бұрын

That theory makes me sad for humanity.

@JebeckyGranjola

3 жыл бұрын

@Corby Dorian Watch the movie again, then slowly read my comment again. There is one person that Marla knows as Tyler Durden, the leader of Fight Club. This is the person we the audience think of as the Narrator. Both we and himself incorrectly believe there are two different people: The Narrator who doesn't know that he is actually Tyler (Edward Norton), and the person who he thinks is Tyler who is a figment of his imagination (Brad Pitt). He realizes this when he explicitly asks Marla, "who do you think I am?" and she says, "You are Tyler. Tyler f***ing Durden!" Now gtfo You brain dead moron.

also, in the book ending, "jack" realizes project mayhem is very much still going on, as the orderlies tell him "we're waiting for you [to come out of the asylum]".

@tylerdurden5488

3 жыл бұрын

+381665600399 Viber Call if you are you/Tyler Durden........

I saw you Ash.. Nice one. :)

this all happens because jack has brain cancer. marla is the hallucinatory representation of the tumor. her first line in the movie 'this is cancer, right?, can be taken as a self introduction. also note her preoccupation with death and how she wants 'the whole brain' in the clothes selling scene. jack starts going to groups because the doctor told him to, hes just in denial about it and deludes himself hes there for some other reason. jack says if he did have cancer he would name it marla. marla says she saw him practicing telling her off, but how would she? its likely he was practicing in a mirror in private. jack shoots himself and tyler dies but marla doesnt, because in shooting himself he finally accepts death, and gets rid of the resistance to it {tyler - the representation of his fight against the morbid reality}, immediately after which marla shows up and they hold hands - his protective illusions crash down around him represented by the buildings and he has made peace with the reality of his cancer. the gun smoke coming out of tylers mouth as he dies mirrors the smoke from marlas mouth as she says her first line about cancer, indicating marla has won the fight for jacks mind} just my take on it

@cerebralm

Жыл бұрын

Damn... that's brilliant.

@richardcollier1912

7 ай бұрын

BOGUS. Nice try.

2 minutes into this video my heart started to float inexplicably. Did I see a subliminal flash of Ash Millman? Damnit... I’m gonna have to rewatch this whole thing for flashes... I’m American, so you’ll have to excuse me if I’m pronouncing this incorrectly: You cheeky buggers.

@nishanttoteja

3 жыл бұрын

Chris Matteson @2:08 secs

@chrismatteson1312

3 жыл бұрын

Nishant Toteja I know 😂 I got a screen shot.

the first rule of fight club...

God-fuckin'-damnit. Now I have to sit down and comb through the whole thing yet again...

I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE WHATCURLTURE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

after numerous viewings of the film (but only reading Chuck Palahniuk's book once) i'm on the side of the "Marla isn't real" theory...but then i'm on the side of the "whole thing isn't real and only exists inside the narrators mind". once you're given the info about the true nature of "Tyler", the rest begins to unfold and collapse in on itself...like Paper! my final understanding of the tale is that its the Narrator trying to reconcile the masculine and feminine in his psyche. admittedly both Marla and Tyler represent fairly toxic extremes of these, but that just the acceptance of Marla needs a veritable army of Men to balance out before they seem to disappear into irrelevancy. When they finally hold hands at the end, he has realised his his need to accept the feminine, and that it might just save him.The Narrator also tells us that Marla and Tyler remind him of his parents. Also i'm sure many fans of the film have noticed that after the big revelations about who he is, and who he is to so many others (ego gratification anyone?), Narrator returns to Paper Street House and finds it swept clean of any signs of the Club...as though it never existed in the first place. Despite the Club growing exponentially (safety in numbers, while it only takes One Marla to unsettle him with her scrappy, passive aggressive nature) , soon even numbers aren't enough...it has to include increasingly violent actions...from self-abuse to mutual-abuse to group plots of anarchy, and then to bringing the whole world down. Narrator needs bigger and bigger acts of physical violence to withstand what is essentially the love of a woman...or in this case, the love of the self (with both its masculine and feminine aspects)..something he just cant get with until it's almost too late, but achieves in the nick of time. When i found out Palahniuk is gay, a friend went "Well Duh!", but i don't think "Fight Club's" layers are so easily defined by its authors sexuality. But perhaps it did give him insight. In any case i expect my "theories"to be totally refuted when i finally get a copy of the Graphic Novel of Fight Club 2! Fight Club will remain one of my all time favourite films.

@ksl2137

Жыл бұрын

Yessssss!!! Like we are clearly not meant to be able to trust anything the narrator saying, he’s not trustworthy. He even says “with insomnia nothing is real, everything is a copy of a copy of a copy”You’ve literally got it! And the film is only an adaptation of the book, it’s meant to tell its own story. Nothing is real! His psyche is just breaking

@DemnRaig80

Жыл бұрын

@@ksl2137 wrong

Apparently, it was missed that Edward Norton's character AND Brad Pitt's character were the same person, thus sharing the same name. If you remember, they backed this up with the phone call with marla. Kind of the root of the movie, to be missing it. Sure, it's implied, inferred, and then confirmed, both vocally and visually, and told pretty well in the storyline...

@PrinceIsot

Жыл бұрын

No, Tyler Durden is the created personality. The actual narrators name is not Tyler

@extremepsykosis

Жыл бұрын

@@PrinceIsot Tyler durden is the name of the character AND the personality. They are the same character. I've also read the book, and seen the movie MANY TIMES. Despite the usage of the name "JACK" in some POETRY that was found inside the house, that is NOT the name of the character Edward Norton Portrays. This is verified not only by the fact of the phone call where EDWARD NORTON called marla where she called him Tyler, but is also foreshadowed earlier in the film. It is true that some people were smooth brained enough to believe that Tyler Durden is a totally different character instead of being the same person as the narrator. This does NOT fit into the storyline or narrative, it is only speculation by those less aware of what was going on in the film/book. So... keep thinking you're right, but you aren't. To any capacity whatsoever.

@PrinceIsot

Жыл бұрын

@@extremepsykosis lol okay dude 🤣 go through life like that

@extremepsykosis

Жыл бұрын

@@PrinceIsot You are the one not smart enough to see the OBVIOUS....

@xanderg1957

Жыл бұрын

Wow can cut the narcissism with a knife 😂

This movie was already mind-bending enough as is.

I love. this film .I usually don't watch this type films or thanking serious actors such as Brad ,Edward Helena but now i do and i that also Meet Loaf done pretty much good job.

2:08 i saw that....

I've just seen enough of your videos to know a lot of these lol

for #10. When Tyler picks up Marla from her appartment, they have no reflection in any mirror in the hallway.

@itstyromusic

Жыл бұрын

you can confirm at 14:41 in THIS video

Movie and the book is genius! This movie is why I love the movies. Fucks with your head and makes you question every fragment of life. It makes you understand what is really happening and what is not. I think that this is applied to everyday mentality of people. Just to think that people like this is exist. Is mind boggling! Absolutely splendid!

Thumbs up but the last 3 facts are reaching to the point of Redit theory posts.

Marla not existing is a really interesting theory. Tyler is Jack's devil, dark side, and Marla is his Angel, Jacks Good side.

I noticed him all 5 times but missed the TV one when I watched the movie. Where do you see him?

one of the best films to date . try to watch it every 2-3 years or so just to put my cinematic mind at ease and will probably pick up something new after 25 years . see comments below for reference

The guy in the red jacket looks kinda like James Dean.

Pretty sure Marla's real. If not then who's mother's day were they using to make soap?

@LnPPersonified

4 жыл бұрын

Mother's day?

@Tcheera

4 жыл бұрын

I'm not saying I agree with the video, but if we're to buy the video -- durden isn't real, the street, house isn't real, therefore project mayhem can't be real, therefore none of the army can be real, therefore nothing any of them did could be real... that way Marla could also not be real and anyone who would've ever reacted to her (really the narrator being the only "non-imaginary person" to react to her or acknowledge her or one of his imaginary creations) then sure she could be fake and he's literally imagining everything pretty much from the time he meets Tyler -- maybe even before that he has a psychotic break. But meh... that trope is even more played out like "it was all a dream" than the idea of this one personality was in your head because you needed it. Although if we're going by literal psychology and breaks of DID, it would make sense for him to have a few throughout life -- just it's pretty uncommon for people to imagine a whole world (like in identity). But eh it's a movie. From the standpoint of "we know Marla's not real" in the video because they're both not wearing pants, I'm kinda unimpressed with their proof and not thoroughly convinced.

Caught that ash snipit very nice

Yeah I saw that cheeky Ash in the entry for #19.

"20 things you didnt know about Fught Club" Proceeds to read 20 facts taken straight from IMDB. Copy and paste work at it's best 👍

@nvstewart

4 жыл бұрын

Desperate people do desperate things.

What about the dark horse comics sequel to the novel its really good

@Crall0011

4 жыл бұрын

Which debunks the Marla not being real thing.

@TraverseDavies

4 жыл бұрын

@@Crall0011 I came to the comments just to say that...

In the fight club dvd, if you pause the movie in the glitch right before the credits there’s a photo of a BBC for a few frames

I would love to see the reactions of whoever watches the security footage of Tyler beating up Jack in the garage. That would be fularious