Someone give this man a show already. Enough with the storage wars reruns history channel, this is actual history. You sir are doing Gods Work….we thank you!

@randomnickify

Жыл бұрын

TV is fallen civilization.

@EhEhEhEINSTEIN

Жыл бұрын

Haha TV is 100% a fallen civ.. My most despised is TLC. It is now the antithesis of a channel about learning.

@anxninanxnin7859

Жыл бұрын

No joke, I would get cable again to listen to him tell me about fallen civs

@audioupgrades

Жыл бұрын

I prefer it not being TV. The slower, meticulous presentation opens your mind's eye. On TV it'd be ruined by re-enactments and cutaways with Tsoukalos.

@davidmacaart953

Жыл бұрын

@@audioupgrades you're bang on with your analysis.

This really is the best history documentary channel on the internet. The production is impeccable.

@nothankyouYouTube420

Жыл бұрын

Idk about best

@rudolphguarnacci197

Жыл бұрын

@@nothankyouKZread420 Ikr

@tonywoutrs

Жыл бұрын

@@nothankyouKZread420 which one could top this? now I'm curious since I love this kind of content

@MrDarthbader

Жыл бұрын

Fs

@quetzalcoatlz

Жыл бұрын

@@nothankyouKZread420 please share your recommendations

Needed this so badly. Was stuck in a mental spiral of self hate and suicidal thoughts. This is what i needed to distract myself long enough for the mood to pass.

@brycebrown6596

Жыл бұрын

Yeah also sleep, helps me to sleep, try to get some more sleep.

@dorriepruvenok8598

18 күн бұрын

I don't know you or what religion you are. But i myself had the same issues. Please go talk to a Catholic priest about the suicidal thoughts. They can get you in contact with a priest with faculties who can help. I fought off suicidal tendencies for many years and doing what the priest told me after a few months completely stopped me being attacked by such thoughts. I pray you'll find help and healing like i was. After 25yrs i have life back. Give it some thought? ❤

You have taught me more about ancient history than any teacher ever has. Thank you for bringing such invaluable information to a free platform. Plaudits to you sir

Fall of Civilizations never disappoints. As always, much gratitude to Paul and his team for putting together another thought provoking video.

Petra is truly an amazing place. Had the opportunity to do some archaeological work there in 2014 and I will never forget the first time I saw Al-Khazneh.

@brianlara6451

Жыл бұрын

May I ask a juvenile question? How real or prevalent are grave robbers?

@rockydubois2418

Жыл бұрын

So did you see the place where Satan landed on Earth?

@KellyBell1

Жыл бұрын

Wow. Amazing! I dream of going there and seeing it and experiencing it some day. That must have been awesome!

@robinkeuneke6780

11 ай бұрын

I too, explored Petra . And this show answers questions I have pondered since being there! I bet even as an archaeologist, that you learned a lot from this show too. For one thing, who would think the Nabeteans had all that water and knew how to hide it?

As someone who hasn't been lucky enough to travel much or experience different cultures, these podcasts are a small glimpse into the beauty and rich histories of our world that I am very grateful for. Thank you and your team for such high quality educational and yet emotional videos.

@laetitialogan2017

Жыл бұрын

So true..

@jeremiahbrand4838

Жыл бұрын

I would just like to say that while traveling is wonderful, you are not limited by your lack of experience. Despite what some say, there are many people who travel, yet remain culturally illiterate. Don’t forget that our recent ancestors, before the age of common travel, were well-versed in the history of many cultures. The men who founded the United States, for example, were typically educated in multiple languages (usually Latin and Greek) and they had deeply studied world history (much more than the average American today). Don’t ever let someone make you believe that you can’t understand foreign cultures because you haven’t had the opportunity to “travel.” It’s not often that people study even their own history these days. I would argue that if you pick a country and study its history deeply, you can, in fact, become more educated on the subject than the average citizen of that country. Nobody gets to gatekeeper history.

@Beofware

Жыл бұрын

@@jeremiahbrand4838 You're the man, Jeremiah

The quality of this podcast is unrivaled

Finally another one! Love your content! Can't wait for the video!

@kylehedrick9653

Жыл бұрын

I just dont know... I mean where are all the ancient aliens in these series? History channel (it's in the name even) tells me that maybe, just maybe, certainly everything was made by aliens with rock cutting lazers. Though I do feel that Giorgio Tsoukalous hair had something to do with it also.

@ronalddunne3413

Жыл бұрын

@@kylehedrick9653 Bwhahahahaaaa!!!!

@traceymeyer7523

Жыл бұрын

@@ronalddunne3413 mhm mm mhmhtmmmh mhmmhhmmmom gjut hmo Uuu You mc Y i No nh Okay I HuMr Mmum I Munmhk Im I uunnum n huuh hey my ym

@traceymeyer7523

Жыл бұрын

@@kylehedrick9653 ye

@erebody

Жыл бұрын

just wait for the April 1st eppy 😂😂😂

I was starting to suffer from a fall of civilisations podcast deficiency…Phew.. just in time 🤓Thank you for the history!

@Dontdoit_

Жыл бұрын

Withdraws were real. I thought YT was hiding this great content

@TshepoNkadimeng5

Жыл бұрын

😭😭😭😅🤣

@fetusbuddha3908

Жыл бұрын

Time to timetravel

@alexweatherhead1212

Жыл бұрын

I feel ya mate! Great day all round

@lunavieira3616

Жыл бұрын

Same here!

I was lucky enough to visit Petra in 2015. It is a breathtaking place and I was fascinated by the history of the people who carved the buildings out of stone. Another exceptional podcast!

even though it only came out today, i'm still a bit offended that it doesnt have a billion view already. These are the best thing on youtube.

Nabataea is such a magical name for a civilization

I love this series. This is probably one of the best channels on KZread for ancient civilisation history. I especially love the style of storytelling, the sounds, music, and the "voices/quotes" of historical people makes you feel as if you’re right there with them in that time period.

@lizeggar2421

Жыл бұрын

I also love his voice.

Awesome. I'm always checking how long ago the last podcast was and when it gets to three or four months I know that any day it's coming.

@thomas316

Жыл бұрын

Subscribe and turn on notifications so you always get an alert. 🙂👍

@zaneweaver4185

Жыл бұрын

I just binged a few personal favorites in preparation over the last 2 weeks

@jonatan7238

Жыл бұрын

Haha this is me aswell

@Arty123

Жыл бұрын

Same

@gyllenspetzfamily7993

Жыл бұрын

It's history time!

I was recently wondering when Petra and the Nabataeans would be covered. I visited there in March of this year, and the site was nothing short of spectacular, one of the greatest places I've visited.

@ShyFly1000

Жыл бұрын

That sounds amazing.

@alexanderheynen4779

Жыл бұрын

I went to Hegra in March this year. An equally amazing Nabatean city.

@darrynmurphy4764

Жыл бұрын

@@alexanderheynen4779 I've wanted to see Hegra for some time as well, I'd definitely be interested to see how it compares to Petra

@alexanderheynen4779

Жыл бұрын

@@darrynmurphy4764, I was in Petra in 2004, but I really want to go back. Especially since I saw the documentary 'the sacred city' by Dan Gibson. Would love to see if it makes sense what he is stating.

I've told everyone I know about how great this podcast is. I think it is one of the best things out there on the Internet right now. I wish you guys sold a CD library of all the episodes!

May I suggest the Mitanni and Hittites for future consideration. Love your work! The fact that you teach how the people and the land shape each other has this geographer's approval.

@davelauerman6865

Жыл бұрын

I second the motion for Hittites

Incredibly helpful . My oldest daughter is at Petra as I watch this program. So amazing ! Thank you very much .

Beautiful, beautiful storytelling - I cried a little for Petra and its people, caretakers of a rich desert culture long gone. Thank you.

These are the best to listen to and eventually drift asleep to.....I mean to take in and learn from. Yea that's it!

Seriously, that sonata intro has a special place in my heart. I love this podcast.

Welcome back Paul💙💛💙💛. Cannot wait to enjoy this about 134 times.

@benc2972

Жыл бұрын

Lol I do that too with these podcasts.

@BucolicNightlife

Жыл бұрын

Glad I’m not the only one that listens well over 10+ time each episode. 😎

Your series fills me with such a sense of wonder and emotion I have rarely felt. Truly thankful of your efforts.

Oh my goodness!!!! I really needed this. I keep relistening to the Sumerians and the Aztecs and wanting for more. I’m beyond happy. Normally I like to wait for a season to be over before I watch a show. But I fell on to this podcast and I’m so in love.

@ianrobson9601

Жыл бұрын

The ending of The Sumerians episode and the Woolly Mammoth was so sad and it's definitely my favourite

Reminds me of when the History Channel was actually about history!

My favorite channel on KZread

Hearing about these people and Petra it makes me feel like I’m transported to Arrakis and I’m learning about the Fremen and their sietches.

I’m still working my way through your absolutely fantastic series of programmes thinking to myself “what do I do when I’ve finished them all?” and hey presto a brand new episode appears! ⭐️

@tpolutts3309

Жыл бұрын

Then you start over at the beginning. And on the 3rd time through you start sorting by mic quality.

@angryatheist

Жыл бұрын

@@tpolutts3309 lol 😂 true that I’m now learning to play the intro music

@danv8718

Жыл бұрын

I'm currently on my 10th or 11th rerun...

@animula6908

Жыл бұрын

We’ve all been there! Fortunately they bear up to multiple listens. I put them on at half speed at night and not only do they help me sleep, but it makes it take longer for me to wear out an episode.

@ygh1973

Жыл бұрын

@@danv8718 I have a feeling that at some point I’ll be there too!

I wait up for your video podcasts with waaayyyyy greater anticipation than marvel movies. Your content is worth its weight in gold

I love the smell of new Fall of Civs episodes. Can't wait to rewatch it with imagery

The first civilization I had not heard about before in this series! Thank you for the incredible content!

These are honestly superb, my personal favourite was the Byzantium episode. Superbly researched, superbly narrated, structured superbly, and even bringing in traditional musicians. This channel reminds me why I don't watch TV generally, because this is head's and shoulders above what most producers can do on 6 times the budget. Bravo, you have a new patreon subscriber, long may you continue making these 👏

@gyllenspetzfamily7993

Жыл бұрын

I know what happened in Hagia Sophia...if I watch Byzantium will I be able to sleep? Or will I be sickened with horror?

I got my interest into ancient civilizations from my world history class in the 8th grade. the story of the Indus River valley Civilization really stuck with me. it made me fascinated with how ancient civilizations around the world end in such a similar pattern. whether that be war, lack of resources, too large of a population, or climate change and other environmental issues. I started to do my own research, and that's when I came across this channel. next year, I'm going into 9th grade. and as someone who still wants to learn more, I really appreciate everything that this channel does. the audio quality is on point. I love to listen as I go to sleep and picture in my head how these civilizations got by until they're subsequent end. I'm planning on going to college when I graduate, and studying ancient civilizations. I love linguistics, and would like to be a linguistic anthropologist. so, thank you for making such great content. it really makes my day whenever you upload.

Thank you. Listening to this is absolutely magical.

Try and imagine the way they must have felt, as they watched the time pass on the last podcast available. They must have looked on in fear and dismay and wondered, how could this podcast ever end? They would have pilfered through the youtube channel, taking anything of value, the comments barren and abandoned. All jokes aside, this podcast has given me great joy. I appreciate all the effort you and your voice actors have put into this.

@FallofCivilizations

Жыл бұрын

😂

I do wonder whether the absolutely superb documentaries in the “Fall of Civilisations” series could be picked up, funded by, and broadcast by the BBC and/or PBS. I have been particularly impressed by the quality of the *WRITING* in the series. Nothing I’ve seen on either the BBC or PBS can rival the rhetorically engaging writing; thorough cultural and historical research; or high production quality of each of the brilliant episodes in the series. I hope to see the podcast on the Nabataeans turned into a video as visually alluring and poetic as those on the Han, the Songhai, Vijayanagara, the Assyrians, and Byzantium (my personal favourites).

My favourate intro to a KZread video. Every time that music starts I know I'm about to get a serious dose of ancient history!

It feels like my birthday every time I open the podcasts app and there's a surprise new Fall of Civ episode waiting for me, thanks so much for creating this incredible series!!

I'm so excited for this series! I'm so interested in the fall of civilizations.

@stronkveak5917

Жыл бұрын

Me too!!! Can't wait for ours!

@lordshittington135

Жыл бұрын

@@stronkveak5917 Not too much longer to wait.

@Exalt7

Жыл бұрын

@@stronkveak5917 What do you mean by "ours"? Like an episode on your culture's past?

@alexgheorghita4583

Жыл бұрын

@@Exalt7 It was a joke. They meant the fall of our current civilization.

Love the whole series of podcasts. I would suggest for a future series of shows, a series on what stage various civilizations were at , at particular points in time

I was just rewatching the Inca and Aztec episodes! Thank you for making such amazing works of art and for doing so much research to educate us KZread folks! Keep it up and thanks again

@laetitialogan2017

Жыл бұрын

Yes, so did I...fascinating and done so magnificently

Absolutely beautiful. My favorite parts of these are the bittersweet lamentations at the end.

Love the obscure civilizations focused on that conventional history overlooks. This episode is fantastic.

A new one ♥️ Can't wait to watch this new episode 🙂 Thank you

37k views in under 24 hours!! Wow! You deserve it man, top notch research and presentation. I'm thrilled to see your channel rightfully grow, congratulations. Please keep it up.

@FallofCivilizations

Жыл бұрын

Thanks my friend!

Great voice and I love listening to the history of the past❤🇸🇸

I was so pleased to see a new FoC released today. Such wonderful storytelling. Every episode is compelling, and through words alone is capable of evoking rich and inspiring imagery in my mind. Truly moving, and a wonderful gift to students of history. Please keep going - and continue even once you have exhausted all possible fallen civs, to other topics. You are clearly a profoundly gifted team, both academically and artistically. Thank you for making my life richer - I've loved each and every episode of this series. Your only fault is that your descriptions of the ancient world never fail to awaken an overpowering wanderlust in my heart. Which, with their touching poignance, makes me want to abandon my own academic pursuits to visit the ruins you so eloquently provide a narrative to match. Looking forward to hearing of the Majapahit, and the heady, haunting tones of the gamelan in the background.

I'm so freaking excited. I've watched the other ones like five or six times in a row and listened to them at night as I drift off to sleep watching battles and armies and mass extinction. It's glorious. I've been starving for some great FoC WOOHOOOOO! My inner fat (okay, outer fat too) history kid wiggles with glee!

Aww yeah! Christmas came early!

I drop everything for these new episodes!

You know every time I listen to or watch one of these I'm immediately struck with the thought that at some point someone will be making a historic assessment of how Western Civilization fell and what caused it and who we'll leave a mark on in the future .

@paulcarver3517

Жыл бұрын

Western society is falling now

I love these documentaries so much!

Always love these. The best podcast and best nighty night medicine.

These videos are extremely well put together, I love the focus on differing perspectives and the information density, and they are told with a true story tellers art

I've been mesmerized by your podcast for some time now. It's hard to find captivating history content in this format, and even harder to come across such incredible research and attention to detail. I hope this reaches as many people as possible. Thank you Paul!

Wonderful thing about this channel is it's universal appeal in uncovering humanities enduring footprints left on all continents. I would really enjoy seeing/hearing a series on the long timely story of Human Migrations that led up to the short bursts of civilization worldwide.

Finally. Yaaaassss I listen to you almost every night. I feel empowered by the knowledge I have earned from this series. 🙌

Thank you! This has filled a great gap of Knowledge of my study on the Nabataeans .

Love you Paul ❤️

Failed my archaeology studies. This Podcast always reminds me of what could've been .... I Love it :D

Another FoC release! Another sincere thank you!

Listened to episode 6 on the way to work (again), only to get to work and find a new episode alert that arrived while I was in transit! No complaints here!

I was so happy when I saw a new podcast posted on my Spotify, truly made my day. Ever since I first came across your episode on The Sumerians, I have been captivated. The in-depth explanations really bring history into perspective to many of us who are so disconnected from our ancestors. I just subscribed to your patreon because I feel like what you do is so important. This isn’t something you can find in some ordinary textbook. The amount of research and composition that goes into each episode is obvious.

@FallofCivilizations

Жыл бұрын

Thank you Sophia, that's very kind! Really glad you've been enjoying.

By far one of the single greatest places on KZread. I look forward to these episodes so much.

Now I know the history every time I build Petra in Civ 6. Gotta love it. Can't wait for the next ones.

These always seem to come out right before I have a long drive! Perfect to listen to while driving long distances! Just a few more days of waiting and then I get to enjoy!!!

Hmm, no mention of Indiana Jones retrieving the Holy Grail from the the Treasury building at Petra. Glaring oversight!

That was totally epic, the most comprehensive roundup of info on the Nabataeans and Petra I have seen. Outstanding work, thanks.

I love this channel. Production quality is great.

Saving this for the long drive home. Thank you for your amazing content and the effort it must take to put this together. Your videos are legendary in this space.

Oh, what a treat! I have to work late tonight and this beautiful voice and captivating story will boost me.

Can't wait for the one with one with visuals! Love seeing artifacts, paintings, maps, etc.

Another magnificent and beautiful telling of a once lost civilization. These are truly some of the best historical analysations I've ever encountered. I appreciate your work so much and I look so forward to ever episode you release. Please do not stop!

Woot! Never clicked so fast on a video. Love your podcasts

Beautiful and interesting. I tried to imagine what your next podcast could be about, but I must admit that Petra never crossed my mind. That city had to be really beautiful in its glory days. The Nabateans lived by trade and, at the end, they died by trade, when their city became irrelevant in the new order of the late Roman empire. The dismissal of Petra by the Romans reminds me of the similar behavior of the Spanish conquistadors in Peru. First they conquered Cuzco, and with it the Incan empire, then they built Lima as a new capital on the coast, because they couldn't endure the height of the Andes. Next time you could make a podcast about the Sassanid empire, Carthage or the Etruscans. They would all make interesting stories.

@FallofCivilizations

Жыл бұрын

A lovely summary, and thanks for the suggestions!

@colly7963

Жыл бұрын

@@FallofCivilizations Please add the Achaemenids to that list.

@gyllenspetzfamily7993

Жыл бұрын

@@FallofCivilizations if you can do anything on the sassanids or the etruscans, I will have no choice I will have to send you money.

Thank you to you and your narrators this latest fascinating episode. As ever I will no doubt listen to it several times in the coming months; I have revisited your previous works many times, they are so rich and evocative.

I’ve been eagerly anticipating another podcast on the ANE since you covered the Assyrians. Thanks for this! 🙏🏻🤩

Excellent - I'm going to save this for after work, so I can concentrate on the content.

Love this series. Give this dude his own show. On par with Sir David Attenborough as a narrator. My opinion.

FOC podcast Always makes my yard work more interesting👍

Sweet! Episode 15! Ever considered doing an episode on the Phoenicians one of these days?

@caniblmolstr4503

Жыл бұрын

The Phoenicians never fell so....

@MarvinT0606

Жыл бұрын

@@caniblmolstr4503 the fall of Carthage counts as their major fall- after that their people blended with others and faded as a civilization of their own. The sad thing is they contributed so much to mankind's learning yet so few of their words and writings are left to us.

@captainkirk1

Жыл бұрын

Has he not done one

@caniblmolstr4503

Жыл бұрын

@@MarvinT0606 So did the Normans fall? Or did they just incorporate themselves into their local communities? I would go with the second option for both. I myself am from Goa, a former Portuguese trading outpost in India. After 1950 some of us went back to Portuguese (their present PM is one such man) but many didn't. Just became Indians with wierd Portuguese surnames and names.

@MarvinT0606

Жыл бұрын

@@caniblmolstr4503 but remember the Normans sprung from the Vikings after their deal with the Franks. The Phoenicians' origins aren't as certain but they considered themselves (as well as the people around them) to be a distinct people from the rest, with a language and an important innovation in the form of the earliest alphabet.

Two hours that seemed like 20 minutes. This is the second time I’ve played this. There will be more. Encore! 👍

Seeing photos of the "treasury of the pharaoh" cut right into the side of the rock as a kid is what initially sparked my interest in history. I was so fascinated by it and it was the first time I wanted to know more about a group of people.

@RagingRugbyst

Жыл бұрын

Go there if you haven't. It's worth it. There are no words to describe how coming out into that clearing felt. I think I lay there motionless for minutes, just taking it in.

The writing is stellar. This is fantastic. Because i have seen films of this place, while i was listening to this - I was almost transported to Petra. I could smell the frankincense - see the colors, you did a spectacular job of narrating. This is precious to me. Thank you. i am very grateful

Very nice as always. One particular thing I really like and find remarkable in these podcasts is giving some food recipies of each culture and time period.

I am very excited to see this new drop! Thank you for all you do!!!!

this series is absolutely my favorite thing in the world right now. this episode had no moving video for me. i'll continue to check back to see if it's updated at some point. thank you to everyone involved with these episodes, my life is better for having experienced them

@FallofCivilizations

Жыл бұрын

Glad you think so! I am working on the video now - it will be released soon.

What a joy to come across this. I recall suggesting the Nabateans about a year ago. Was well worth the wait, such a masterpiece! Today is a great day indeed.

Absolutely sublime timing ! Thank you for the gold you provide us all. 😎👍

your videos always leave me feeling smarter after watching, and thinking about all those who were almost forgotten

Listening on Spotify. Thank you for producing these amazing episodes!

A new episode, what a great way to start the day

Can’t tell you how much I’ve missed hearing your voice! You’ve breathed new life into some areas of history I used to enjoy so much as a kid through your thorough and easy to understand videos

I love falling asleep listening to these!

It seems like every time I stop looking for a new episode you drop one just weeks later. This content 👌

Listen to these to fall asleep I thought but i always stay awake because they're so interesting

I listen to you on Spotify. I really hope you’re a history teacher, but if not, thanks for teaching us 🙇‍♂️ Such poignant and beautiful framings of history. The primary sources are also amazing. I like what you’re doing a lot!

Even the introduction is like an overture to an opera that excites the neurons of anticipation!

A masterpiece, as usual, thank you so much.....I can't wait for your episode on the fall of Ancient Egypt!