I want to see this edit with the Tales of Jedi/Empire segments and the flashback from Mando Season 3 Episode 4. Also maybe the flashbacks from Kenobi show but I’m not too sure about that last one
@codemancz79818 күн бұрын
People don't realize what Palpy's original plan was. It was to have Padmé sign the treaty and use the loss of his own word against Valorum, which he did anyway.
@irmaoscabral388021 күн бұрын
I can't put into words my shock when I noticed how little views this has, amazing work dude
@theskywalkercantina381021 күн бұрын
Thanks! I would love for my videos to reach more people but I’m just making the videos for the fun of it right now!
@mazkeraid403921 күн бұрын
Clone Wars (2003) lines up smoothly for the films, and there is not a single looseness when it comes to continuity.
@prerna_padma29 күн бұрын
Great video essay
@theskywalkercantina381029 күн бұрын
Thank you!
@darkgreenrifleman4871Ай бұрын
This is an amalgamation of the excuses for the justification of bad writing.
@theskywalkercantina3810Ай бұрын
How so? Like what do I say specifically that is an excuse? I genuinely don’t know
@blank9793Ай бұрын
Many great animated and non-animated works didn't make the final cut for this video. But in recognition of all the footage we did use, here is a list of all the sources for the clips and corresponding timestamps. If you found something you liked and want to go watch it, this list is for you. Please reply to this comment if I forgot anything or to ask anyone else to help you find what you are looking for. 1:22 - Tom & Jerry (TV Show: 1954) 1:26 - Trolls (2016) 1:29 - SpongeBob SquarePants 1:33 - Speed Racer (1967) 1:39 - Despicable Me (2010) 1:41 - Wild Kratts 1:43 - Wish (2023) 1:46 - Teen Titans Go 1:55 - Fantasia (1940) 2:02- How To Train Your Dragon (2010) 2:07- Kung Fu Panda 3 (2016) 2:12 - Aladdin (1992) 2:18 - Mulan (2020) 2:24 - Beauty and the Beast (2017) 2:35 - The Little Mermaid (2023) 2:45 & 3:00 - Pinocchio (2022) 3:10 - Batman Beyond (1999) 3:17 - The Lion King (1994) 3:40 - The Lion King (2019) 4:20 - Avatar: The Last Airbender (2024) 4:54 - Avatar: The Last Airbender (2005) 5:24 - Spy Kids (2001) 5:37 - Smiling Friends 5:44 - The Simpsons 5:45 - Family Guy 5:45 - Futurama 5:46 - Arcane 5:53 - Invincible 7:23 - Batman: Arkham Knight (2015) [Video Game] 7:32 - How To Train Your Dragon (2010) 7:47 - Up (2009) 7:51 - Drive (2011) 7:57 - Indiana Jones and The Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981) 8:00 - Hercules (1997) 8:05 - Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba 8:12 - Kung Fu Panda 3 (2016) 8:27 - The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) 8:39 - Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018) 9:05 - Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi (TV Mini-Series 2022) 9:11 - Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) 9:39 - Mulan (1998) 10:04 - Moana (2016) 10:09 - Avatar: The Last Airbender (2005) 10:18 - Star Wars Rebels 10:24 - Invincible 10:25 - The Lion King (1994) 10:27 - Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018) 10:28 - Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) 10:37 - She-Hulk: Attorney at Law 10:43 - Lightyear (2022) 10:45 - Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018) BONUS SPEED ROUND: 11:04 - Star Wars Rebels 11:05 - Toy Story 3 (2010) 11:06 - Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018) 11:07 - Batman: The Animated Series (1992) 11:08 - The Prince of Egypt (1998) 11:09 - Tangled (2010) 11:10 - The Adventures of Tintin (2011) 11:11 - JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders 11:12 - Sleeping Beauty (1959) 11:13 - Spectacular Spider-Man 11:14 - Beauty and the Beast (1991) 11:15 - Cowboy Bebop 11:16 - Adventure Time 11:17 - Shrek (2001) 11:18 - Star Wars: Clone Wars (2003) 11:19 - Samurai Jack 11:20 - Soul (2024) 11:21 - The Iron Giant (1999) 11:22 - Arcane 11:23 - Spirited Away (2001) 11:24 - Invincible 11:25 - Justice League Unlimited 11:26 - Puss in Boots: The Last Wish (2022) 11:27 - Gravity Falls 11:28 - The Lion King (1994) 11:30 - Kung Fu Panda 2 (2011) 11:31 - Avatar: The Last Airbender (2005) 11:32 - Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008)
@theskywalkercantina3810Ай бұрын
blank you're a G
@jager35Ай бұрын
I remember being a kid watching The force Awakens when it came out and being bored nearly to tears. Finally got around to watching A New Hope and fuck yEs did I finally understand starwars!!!
@jager35Ай бұрын
I see this phrase *everywhere* but I'll be the one to say it too. Thank God th sequel trilogy was made so we all could go back to see how good we had it with the prequels and clone wars
@brethilnenАй бұрын
What no views. I loved this video, keep up the good work!
@dabigdikdanglerАй бұрын
I tried to re-watch "The Phantom Menace" last night but Jar Jar Binks and the annoying kid that played Anakin kept stopping me. I'd pause the movie at particularly cringe points and forget and do something else. After 3 hours I still wasn't through with it.
@Tripp393Ай бұрын
lol Phantom Menace is not a bad film by any stretch of the imagination.
@What_do_I_Think2 ай бұрын
Maybe the plot of Episodes 1-3 was just to intelligent for a huge percentage of its audience. (yes, I admit that some things were bad, really Jar Jar!)
@What_do_I_Think2 ай бұрын
I absolutely agree. The prequels where slammed by so many -- but in spite of their existing flaws, they at least had a real story arch over all three movies and an interesting plot. The sequels in contrast have neither, they just have stupid, cheap visual effects.
@gnc6232 ай бұрын
It's ironic how most prequel critics complain that the Phantom Menace is too childish, but they even admit they don't understand the plot. Lol.
@theskywalkercantina38102 ай бұрын
I guess that is pretty ironic haha
@gc3k2 ай бұрын
It's interesting that Palpatine, one of the central characters and clearly the arch villain of the prequels, doesn't appear in the original posters until Revenge of the Sith as Darth Sidious, hidden in the bottom corner
@gnc6232 ай бұрын
Personally, I think that was a brilliant move. Even though he's the big bad, they don't overplay him. Even in Clone Wars, they use him sparingly. But when he does show up (namely to fight Maul and Savage), it packs a punch. Not overusing Sidious has been one of the brilliant moves of the prequels and Clone Wars. It gives the villains a chance to shine, but it also builds up anticipation all the more to Revenge of the Sith when the Master behind it all comes out into the spotlight.
@Lionhearted6262 ай бұрын
I don't think it's a bad movie. :( I think it's a great movie.
@gbroyce552 ай бұрын
May 4th an updated version comes out with tales of the Jedi added in... he also did an extended episode 1 now too
@blank97932 ай бұрын
2 years of waiting, and I'm not dissapointed.
@theskywalkercantina38102 ай бұрын
Next video coming summer of 2026 💪
@nolastname9083 ай бұрын
I need to do a Star Wars marathon with Revenge of the Sith Ultimate Edition and the TV shows on Disney +
@disneyboy30303 ай бұрын
I definitely would like to see someone combine this edit with Mecha Salesman's edit to make a dinfitive edit of it. Would you like to see that.
@geoffstonehouse58294 ай бұрын
There is still one giant hole that doesn't make sense to me. Why did Palpatine care if Padme signed the treaty to accept control of the trade federation on Naboo or not? In fact, had Padme accepted control she probably wouldn't have fled to courscant, and in turn wouldn't have started a vote of no confidence in the current chancellor, and Palpatine wouldn't have been elected. Even if Naboo lost to the federation it made little or no difference to what would have eventually happened. So after he could get elected why did he care? The first part of his plan was already in motion, playing out exactly as he needed it to.
@theskywalkercantina38104 ай бұрын
I think that palpatine had leverage either way. If Padme accepted the treaty, it would mean more worlds would be angry about corporation's having too much power, therefore stirring the conflict, and on the other hand we see how things played out since she didn't sign it. Palpatine is always playing these games where it is a win-win situation, although one way might favor him more, he is always two steps ahead.
@luisgarrido51852 ай бұрын
The treaty is a deceit or the pretext for galactic conflict. I think the "treaty" in Palpatine's scheme was going to be used against the Republic by the Trade Federation if Amidala signed it (hypothetically). It was the motive in order to create a civil conflict within the Republic. I think what Palpatine's design was: to become elected as chancellor and queen Amidala stayed at Coruscant while that happened. In that regard, after he was elected he could have expelled the Trade Federation from Naboo by using jedi knights. In that scheme, perhaps the Clone Wars (or a politico-military conflict similar to that) could have begun way before it actually did in Episode II.
@lightning2034Ай бұрын
@luisgarrido5185 yeah I agree I think he was trying to push that as plan a but when queen amidala fled the planet it became more of the distraction. palpatine was a master of misdirection
@connorgibson52244 ай бұрын
Obi wan was the one playing 4D chess in their last fight, obi never needed to overpower maul, cause he could outsmart him This video has a criminally low view count for how god damn good it is by the way, keep them bangers coming 👊🏻
@theskywalkercantina38104 ай бұрын
i have halfway made probably 10 videos but i just dont got the time to finish them :(. Thanks for the encouraging comment though!
@Gufupandi09th137 ай бұрын
Can you do a remake cause we're getting order 66 alot
@ryanbarth66918 ай бұрын
Shhh we don't talk about Disney Star wars in this video
@ryanbarth66918 ай бұрын
Can you make a video on the fandom menace
@theskywalkercantina38108 ай бұрын
Probably not, my goal is to be as positive as I can
@kwamster90048 ай бұрын
This is almost perfect for me I just have to find out how to mix in the 2003 clone wars into it And I have one question as well Is there any part of Tales of the Jedi that can mix in?
@theskywalkercantina38108 ай бұрын
Probably the only part is right before Rex and ahsoka confront Jessie
@JIKwood4 ай бұрын
@@theskywalkercantina3810 The bit where Ashoka and Bail Organa talk at Padme's funeral could also work.
@Habsfan567449 ай бұрын
The transition from Ashoka to the battle of Coruscant was amazing
@bp_30949 ай бұрын
It was not cold when I watched this, I mean it was 25 degrees celsius, and I got chills literal chills
@Salikino10 ай бұрын
Can’t wait for the update next month!!
@MadmansKnowledge8 ай бұрын
Might not be coming quite as soon as I had said, but still soon! Just finished a major step in the process and watched the final draft last night!
@Salikino8 ай бұрын
@@MadmansKnowledge Final draft? That’s so awesome!!! Congrats and thank you for your work!
@idiaridiNADecio2 ай бұрын
@@MadmansKnowledge Are you continuing to make an updated version? Even though I follow you on KZread I hadn't heard of it
@MadmansKnowledge2 ай бұрын
@@idiaridiNADecio Yep! Coming May 4th now
@BLACKout_TF2 Жыл бұрын
its only 4 hours tho?
@theskywalkercantina3810 Жыл бұрын
It is 6 hours. It is divided into two 3 hour movies.
@BreMue10 ай бұрын
There are 2 cuts, one includes a bunch of extra stuff, and then I think there is another 4 hour cut with some things trimmed (IIRC the 6 hour cut was recommended if you'd never seen the episodes before so you didn't miss anything)
@JIKwood4 ай бұрын
The ROTS Extended edition is 4 hours of I remember correctly. Also made by the same guy. And that's clone wars and ROTS. Ultimate adds the first episode of the bad batch in.
@kevingreenfield Жыл бұрын
Rubies is a load of rubbish do not get it or even buy it don't.
@taylorandreas695 Жыл бұрын
Disagree that Obi Wan wasn't able or wise enough to train Anakin. Anakin was manipulated by the Dark Side from a young age. In a different Multiverse, he became the strongest of all Jedi and took the grey path bringing true light and dark to the balance of the universe through understanding and training
@backtothefutureman1 Жыл бұрын
My favorite part of this edit was Obi-Wan’s message from Rebels as that’s my favorite Star Wars show.
@theskywalkercantina3810 Жыл бұрын
That part was a surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.
@backtothefutureman1 Жыл бұрын
@@theskywalkercantina3810 Yeah, it was.
@RunnerX13 Жыл бұрын
Did people not know that Senator Palatine was Emperor Palatine or that Palatine was Sidious? I don’t remember Episode I trying very hard to not make it completely obvious who the bad guy was.
@mertc8050 Жыл бұрын
Thats the point we never see the sidous's face we only see that oh thats that emperor guy we saw in e6 and he is called sidious also emperor's identity was never known by anyone at the time irl so senator palps the litteraly a side character was the villain and this isnt revealed until e3 so nobody understood shit watching e1 since palps identity wasnt even revealed
@RunnerX13 Жыл бұрын
@@mertc8050 it’s not true that people didn’t know Senator Palatine is the Emperor. They have the same name and played by the same actor. Maybe if you were 5 it would have been a surprise that he’s also the guy in the hood.
@theskywalkercantina3810 Жыл бұрын
I see what you are both saying, but Palpatine's name was never spoken in the original trilogy. It was only used in the 1977 novelization of A New Hope. This means that the VAST majority of people during the prequels coming out would not have known this. Also, my video was more focused on how people knew that Senator Palpatine was Sidious, however they thought his plan was dumb because it didn't make sense to them. The point of my video was to outline why those critics were wrong.
@RunnerX13 Жыл бұрын
@@theskywalkercantina3810 right. Maybe the name was not commonly known but anyone watching the movie above a certain age could put two and two together. The name was used in many different books over the years.
@danielsimms4262Ай бұрын
@@RunnerX13True, but do the vast majority of people read the books? Especially journalists?
@mrdaviddesertfire6801 Жыл бұрын
I knew someone would do this
@Salsa_Shark11 ай бұрын
Thank the Maker!
@shock77 Жыл бұрын
Why does the guy at 0:31 look like he is saying the lyrics 💀
@randoapplebigcheese6169Ай бұрын
“HE’S GOT FREE BIRD PLAYING RUN”
@loona_mew Жыл бұрын
Head canon Darth Vader has a mp3 player in his suit
@eligarcia215 Жыл бұрын
or how about you just let people enjoy what they like? If there's something that grinds my gears it's a 501'st snob ranting about how bad a licensed costume is and how people are mocked at for wearing them. screw the 501'st, people get into costuming to have fun and not to feel insecure about the only choices they might have had.
@theskywalkercantina3810 Жыл бұрын
Normally I would let you comment be. After all everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and this is also a very old video. Here is why I strongly disagree with your comment. 1. I never stopped anyone from buying this. However, from my experience, there is no target market for this costume who would feel positively about it due to the price. I stated in my video that the costume is not inherently bad, it's the price for the quality. 2. Im not a 501st snob. At the time of making the video I was not in the 501st, and two years later I am still not in the 501st, nor do I have any plans to join. I want people to get into costuming. There are so many ways to start. Building your own costume is fun and a great learning experience, and there are better cheap finished costumes out there for those worried about making mistakes. FAR more. With this video I want to spare others the pain of the excitement and then the immediate disappointment I felt. $1200 dollars is a lot of money for any person to be spending. Might aswell warn them there is better uses of their money. And guess what? If the costume makes people happy, they can simply ignore my video. If they like the costume, all they have to do is say "I disagree, I like my costume." and then move on with their lives. This video isn't for those people. The video is for people like me from six years ago. Have a great day.
@WaltherHartwellWhite Жыл бұрын
Now the Helmet is only for over 400+ $
@theskywalkercantina3810 Жыл бұрын
Great investment
@Stonebone-nu8dk Жыл бұрын
Don't know if you did it on purpose, but VADER was deflecting and killing to the beat. IT was awsome
@thecringekid1929 Жыл бұрын
Would you consider doing a review on Mercha Salesman version of ROS ultimate cut. It includes the 2003 battle of coricant.
@theskywalkercantina3810 Жыл бұрын
I’ve never heard of that. Where can I find it I would love to check it out!
@metalvenger2 Жыл бұрын
@@theskywalkercantina3810 kzread.info/dash/bejne/d2iuyNaHYs2Zn6g.html here you go
@madhavgarg74602 ай бұрын
@@theskywalkercantina3810 the trailer for the movie is on his channel , it inculdes the 2003 cloe wars too and it fits the movie , he has linked it in his video where he talks about the movie .
@LifeofSquidMann Жыл бұрын
Finally understanding Palpatine's machinations during the Prequels solidified him in my mind as the greatest villain ever put to film.
@gnc62310 ай бұрын
YES! I have said this about Palpatine for years. Greatest villain in all of cinema!
@musicdonkey007 Жыл бұрын
Thank you! was going to buy a second hand Rubies but didn't want to look silly. So not going to buy there is another video about wearing a Rubies and it doesn't work.
@Rocinante2300 Жыл бұрын
A political drama set in the Prequel era would be pretty cool
@ryanbarth66918 ай бұрын
With Donald Trump and Joe Biden
@theskywalkercantina38104 ай бұрын
@@ryanbarth6691 lol what 😂
@rickiemittag4326 Жыл бұрын
𝐩яⓞ𝓂𝓞Ş𝐦 👊
@redjirachi1 Жыл бұрын
Palpatine actually has a number of setbacks in The Phantom Menace. However, his genius is making a plan adaptable enough to deal with those setbacks. He wins no matter what in The Phantom Menace, but the variable is "by how much"
@Hunter11725 Жыл бұрын
Hell, Palpatine wins in the Prequel Trilogy no matter what. Maul died and the blockade failed? That’s okay, he became the chancellor and now rules the Republic. Obi-Wan, Padmè and Anakin survive Geonosis thanks to the Jedi? It’s all good, he got the Death Star blue prints, Dooku as an ally, the giant false flag operation that was the Clone Wars has begun to slander the Jedi, and Palpatine has emergency powers. Revenge of the Sith needs no explanation, Palpatine wins straight up in that movie.
@What_do_I_Think2 ай бұрын
@@Hunter11725 The genius of Palpatines plan was, that it worked no matter what happened. Naboo falls? -- Great, so he can draw even more sympathy from the senate! Trade guild loses? -- Great, Naboo is the shining winner and he can claim the winner bonus in the senate! The Jedi are clueless -- Great, easier to mess around with them. The Jedi find the ultimative force user -- Great, he can draw him to the dark side.
@simonjenkins5937 Жыл бұрын
Good video. I like prequels, prefer them to originals. I don’t like sequel trilogy
Пікірлер
George: what? I mean.... Yeah... Genius
I want to see this edit with the Tales of Jedi/Empire segments and the flashback from Mando Season 3 Episode 4. Also maybe the flashbacks from Kenobi show but I’m not too sure about that last one
People don't realize what Palpy's original plan was. It was to have Padmé sign the treaty and use the loss of his own word against Valorum, which he did anyway.
I can't put into words my shock when I noticed how little views this has, amazing work dude
Thanks! I would love for my videos to reach more people but I’m just making the videos for the fun of it right now!
Clone Wars (2003) lines up smoothly for the films, and there is not a single looseness when it comes to continuity.
Great video essay
Thank you!
This is an amalgamation of the excuses for the justification of bad writing.
How so? Like what do I say specifically that is an excuse? I genuinely don’t know
Many great animated and non-animated works didn't make the final cut for this video. But in recognition of all the footage we did use, here is a list of all the sources for the clips and corresponding timestamps. If you found something you liked and want to go watch it, this list is for you. Please reply to this comment if I forgot anything or to ask anyone else to help you find what you are looking for. 1:22 - Tom & Jerry (TV Show: 1954) 1:26 - Trolls (2016) 1:29 - SpongeBob SquarePants 1:33 - Speed Racer (1967) 1:39 - Despicable Me (2010) 1:41 - Wild Kratts 1:43 - Wish (2023) 1:46 - Teen Titans Go 1:55 - Fantasia (1940) 2:02- How To Train Your Dragon (2010) 2:07- Kung Fu Panda 3 (2016) 2:12 - Aladdin (1992) 2:18 - Mulan (2020) 2:24 - Beauty and the Beast (2017) 2:35 - The Little Mermaid (2023) 2:45 & 3:00 - Pinocchio (2022) 3:10 - Batman Beyond (1999) 3:17 - The Lion King (1994) 3:40 - The Lion King (2019) 4:20 - Avatar: The Last Airbender (2024) 4:54 - Avatar: The Last Airbender (2005) 5:24 - Spy Kids (2001) 5:37 - Smiling Friends 5:44 - The Simpsons 5:45 - Family Guy 5:45 - Futurama 5:46 - Arcane 5:53 - Invincible 7:23 - Batman: Arkham Knight (2015) [Video Game] 7:32 - How To Train Your Dragon (2010) 7:47 - Up (2009) 7:51 - Drive (2011) 7:57 - Indiana Jones and The Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981) 8:00 - Hercules (1997) 8:05 - Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba 8:12 - Kung Fu Panda 3 (2016) 8:27 - The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) 8:39 - Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018) 9:05 - Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi (TV Mini-Series 2022) 9:11 - Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) 9:39 - Mulan (1998) 10:04 - Moana (2016) 10:09 - Avatar: The Last Airbender (2005) 10:18 - Star Wars Rebels 10:24 - Invincible 10:25 - The Lion King (1994) 10:27 - Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018) 10:28 - Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) 10:37 - She-Hulk: Attorney at Law 10:43 - Lightyear (2022) 10:45 - Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018) BONUS SPEED ROUND: 11:04 - Star Wars Rebels 11:05 - Toy Story 3 (2010) 11:06 - Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018) 11:07 - Batman: The Animated Series (1992) 11:08 - The Prince of Egypt (1998) 11:09 - Tangled (2010) 11:10 - The Adventures of Tintin (2011) 11:11 - JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders 11:12 - Sleeping Beauty (1959) 11:13 - Spectacular Spider-Man 11:14 - Beauty and the Beast (1991) 11:15 - Cowboy Bebop 11:16 - Adventure Time 11:17 - Shrek (2001) 11:18 - Star Wars: Clone Wars (2003) 11:19 - Samurai Jack 11:20 - Soul (2024) 11:21 - The Iron Giant (1999) 11:22 - Arcane 11:23 - Spirited Away (2001) 11:24 - Invincible 11:25 - Justice League Unlimited 11:26 - Puss in Boots: The Last Wish (2022) 11:27 - Gravity Falls 11:28 - The Lion King (1994) 11:30 - Kung Fu Panda 2 (2011) 11:31 - Avatar: The Last Airbender (2005) 11:32 - Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008)
blank you're a G
I remember being a kid watching The force Awakens when it came out and being bored nearly to tears. Finally got around to watching A New Hope and fuck yEs did I finally understand starwars!!!
I see this phrase *everywhere* but I'll be the one to say it too. Thank God th sequel trilogy was made so we all could go back to see how good we had it with the prequels and clone wars
What no views. I loved this video, keep up the good work!
I tried to re-watch "The Phantom Menace" last night but Jar Jar Binks and the annoying kid that played Anakin kept stopping me. I'd pause the movie at particularly cringe points and forget and do something else. After 3 hours I still wasn't through with it.
lol Phantom Menace is not a bad film by any stretch of the imagination.
Maybe the plot of Episodes 1-3 was just to intelligent for a huge percentage of its audience. (yes, I admit that some things were bad, really Jar Jar!)
I absolutely agree. The prequels where slammed by so many -- but in spite of their existing flaws, they at least had a real story arch over all three movies and an interesting plot. The sequels in contrast have neither, they just have stupid, cheap visual effects.
It's ironic how most prequel critics complain that the Phantom Menace is too childish, but they even admit they don't understand the plot. Lol.
I guess that is pretty ironic haha
It's interesting that Palpatine, one of the central characters and clearly the arch villain of the prequels, doesn't appear in the original posters until Revenge of the Sith as Darth Sidious, hidden in the bottom corner
Personally, I think that was a brilliant move. Even though he's the big bad, they don't overplay him. Even in Clone Wars, they use him sparingly. But when he does show up (namely to fight Maul and Savage), it packs a punch. Not overusing Sidious has been one of the brilliant moves of the prequels and Clone Wars. It gives the villains a chance to shine, but it also builds up anticipation all the more to Revenge of the Sith when the Master behind it all comes out into the spotlight.
I don't think it's a bad movie. :( I think it's a great movie.
May 4th an updated version comes out with tales of the Jedi added in... he also did an extended episode 1 now too
2 years of waiting, and I'm not dissapointed.
Next video coming summer of 2026 💪
I need to do a Star Wars marathon with Revenge of the Sith Ultimate Edition and the TV shows on Disney +
I definitely would like to see someone combine this edit with Mecha Salesman's edit to make a dinfitive edit of it. Would you like to see that.
There is still one giant hole that doesn't make sense to me. Why did Palpatine care if Padme signed the treaty to accept control of the trade federation on Naboo or not? In fact, had Padme accepted control she probably wouldn't have fled to courscant, and in turn wouldn't have started a vote of no confidence in the current chancellor, and Palpatine wouldn't have been elected. Even if Naboo lost to the federation it made little or no difference to what would have eventually happened. So after he could get elected why did he care? The first part of his plan was already in motion, playing out exactly as he needed it to.
I think that palpatine had leverage either way. If Padme accepted the treaty, it would mean more worlds would be angry about corporation's having too much power, therefore stirring the conflict, and on the other hand we see how things played out since she didn't sign it. Palpatine is always playing these games where it is a win-win situation, although one way might favor him more, he is always two steps ahead.
The treaty is a deceit or the pretext for galactic conflict. I think the "treaty" in Palpatine's scheme was going to be used against the Republic by the Trade Federation if Amidala signed it (hypothetically). It was the motive in order to create a civil conflict within the Republic. I think what Palpatine's design was: to become elected as chancellor and queen Amidala stayed at Coruscant while that happened. In that regard, after he was elected he could have expelled the Trade Federation from Naboo by using jedi knights. In that scheme, perhaps the Clone Wars (or a politico-military conflict similar to that) could have begun way before it actually did in Episode II.
@luisgarrido5185 yeah I agree I think he was trying to push that as plan a but when queen amidala fled the planet it became more of the distraction. palpatine was a master of misdirection
Obi wan was the one playing 4D chess in their last fight, obi never needed to overpower maul, cause he could outsmart him This video has a criminally low view count for how god damn good it is by the way, keep them bangers coming 👊🏻
i have halfway made probably 10 videos but i just dont got the time to finish them :(. Thanks for the encouraging comment though!
Can you do a remake cause we're getting order 66 alot
Shhh we don't talk about Disney Star wars in this video
Can you make a video on the fandom menace
Probably not, my goal is to be as positive as I can
This is almost perfect for me I just have to find out how to mix in the 2003 clone wars into it And I have one question as well Is there any part of Tales of the Jedi that can mix in?
Probably the only part is right before Rex and ahsoka confront Jessie
@@theskywalkercantina3810 The bit where Ashoka and Bail Organa talk at Padme's funeral could also work.
The transition from Ashoka to the battle of Coruscant was amazing
It was not cold when I watched this, I mean it was 25 degrees celsius, and I got chills literal chills
Can’t wait for the update next month!!
Might not be coming quite as soon as I had said, but still soon! Just finished a major step in the process and watched the final draft last night!
@@MadmansKnowledge Final draft? That’s so awesome!!! Congrats and thank you for your work!
@@MadmansKnowledge Are you continuing to make an updated version? Even though I follow you on KZread I hadn't heard of it
@@idiaridiNADecio Yep! Coming May 4th now
its only 4 hours tho?
It is 6 hours. It is divided into two 3 hour movies.
There are 2 cuts, one includes a bunch of extra stuff, and then I think there is another 4 hour cut with some things trimmed (IIRC the 6 hour cut was recommended if you'd never seen the episodes before so you didn't miss anything)
The ROTS Extended edition is 4 hours of I remember correctly. Also made by the same guy. And that's clone wars and ROTS. Ultimate adds the first episode of the bad batch in.
Rubies is a load of rubbish do not get it or even buy it don't.
Disagree that Obi Wan wasn't able or wise enough to train Anakin. Anakin was manipulated by the Dark Side from a young age. In a different Multiverse, he became the strongest of all Jedi and took the grey path bringing true light and dark to the balance of the universe through understanding and training
My favorite part of this edit was Obi-Wan’s message from Rebels as that’s my favorite Star Wars show.
That part was a surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.
@@theskywalkercantina3810 Yeah, it was.
Did people not know that Senator Palatine was Emperor Palatine or that Palatine was Sidious? I don’t remember Episode I trying very hard to not make it completely obvious who the bad guy was.
Thats the point we never see the sidous's face we only see that oh thats that emperor guy we saw in e6 and he is called sidious also emperor's identity was never known by anyone at the time irl so senator palps the litteraly a side character was the villain and this isnt revealed until e3 so nobody understood shit watching e1 since palps identity wasnt even revealed
@@mertc8050 it’s not true that people didn’t know Senator Palatine is the Emperor. They have the same name and played by the same actor. Maybe if you were 5 it would have been a surprise that he’s also the guy in the hood.
I see what you are both saying, but Palpatine's name was never spoken in the original trilogy. It was only used in the 1977 novelization of A New Hope. This means that the VAST majority of people during the prequels coming out would not have known this. Also, my video was more focused on how people knew that Senator Palpatine was Sidious, however they thought his plan was dumb because it didn't make sense to them. The point of my video was to outline why those critics were wrong.
@@theskywalkercantina3810 right. Maybe the name was not commonly known but anyone watching the movie above a certain age could put two and two together. The name was used in many different books over the years.
@@RunnerX13True, but do the vast majority of people read the books? Especially journalists?
I knew someone would do this
Thank the Maker!
Why does the guy at 0:31 look like he is saying the lyrics 💀
“HE’S GOT FREE BIRD PLAYING RUN”
Head canon Darth Vader has a mp3 player in his suit
or how about you just let people enjoy what they like? If there's something that grinds my gears it's a 501'st snob ranting about how bad a licensed costume is and how people are mocked at for wearing them. screw the 501'st, people get into costuming to have fun and not to feel insecure about the only choices they might have had.
Normally I would let you comment be. After all everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and this is also a very old video. Here is why I strongly disagree with your comment. 1. I never stopped anyone from buying this. However, from my experience, there is no target market for this costume who would feel positively about it due to the price. I stated in my video that the costume is not inherently bad, it's the price for the quality. 2. Im not a 501st snob. At the time of making the video I was not in the 501st, and two years later I am still not in the 501st, nor do I have any plans to join. I want people to get into costuming. There are so many ways to start. Building your own costume is fun and a great learning experience, and there are better cheap finished costumes out there for those worried about making mistakes. FAR more. With this video I want to spare others the pain of the excitement and then the immediate disappointment I felt. $1200 dollars is a lot of money for any person to be spending. Might aswell warn them there is better uses of their money. And guess what? If the costume makes people happy, they can simply ignore my video. If they like the costume, all they have to do is say "I disagree, I like my costume." and then move on with their lives. This video isn't for those people. The video is for people like me from six years ago. Have a great day.
Now the Helmet is only for over 400+ $
Great investment
Don't know if you did it on purpose, but VADER was deflecting and killing to the beat. IT was awsome
Would you consider doing a review on Mercha Salesman version of ROS ultimate cut. It includes the 2003 battle of coricant.
I’ve never heard of that. Where can I find it I would love to check it out!
@@theskywalkercantina3810 kzread.info/dash/bejne/d2iuyNaHYs2Zn6g.html here you go
@@theskywalkercantina3810 the trailer for the movie is on his channel , it inculdes the 2003 cloe wars too and it fits the movie , he has linked it in his video where he talks about the movie .
Finally understanding Palpatine's machinations during the Prequels solidified him in my mind as the greatest villain ever put to film.
YES! I have said this about Palpatine for years. Greatest villain in all of cinema!
Thank you! was going to buy a second hand Rubies but didn't want to look silly. So not going to buy there is another video about wearing a Rubies and it doesn't work.
A political drama set in the Prequel era would be pretty cool
With Donald Trump and Joe Biden
@@ryanbarth6691 lol what 😂
𝐩яⓞ𝓂𝓞Ş𝐦 👊
Palpatine actually has a number of setbacks in The Phantom Menace. However, his genius is making a plan adaptable enough to deal with those setbacks. He wins no matter what in The Phantom Menace, but the variable is "by how much"
Hell, Palpatine wins in the Prequel Trilogy no matter what. Maul died and the blockade failed? That’s okay, he became the chancellor and now rules the Republic. Obi-Wan, Padmè and Anakin survive Geonosis thanks to the Jedi? It’s all good, he got the Death Star blue prints, Dooku as an ally, the giant false flag operation that was the Clone Wars has begun to slander the Jedi, and Palpatine has emergency powers. Revenge of the Sith needs no explanation, Palpatine wins straight up in that movie.
@@Hunter11725 The genius of Palpatines plan was, that it worked no matter what happened. Naboo falls? -- Great, so he can draw even more sympathy from the senate! Trade guild loses? -- Great, Naboo is the shining winner and he can claim the winner bonus in the senate! The Jedi are clueless -- Great, easier to mess around with them. The Jedi find the ultimative force user -- Great, he can draw him to the dark side.
Good video. I like prequels, prefer them to originals. I don’t like sequel trilogy
Interesting video