Пікірлер

• 
  @Baeath17 сағат бұрын

  piano3 jumpscare

• 
  @jarlbalgruuf77012 күн бұрын

  It’s funny how simple and easy this part looked to edit without having to go out of your way to add VFX to remove the gold off Smaug. I don’t know why more fan edits don’t just do that, it still achieves the same effect.

• 
  @M4Studios2 күн бұрын

  Well it still uses vfx but you’re right it’s much less than keeping the full shot

• 
  @tdevine37303 күн бұрын

  Thorin had 10 years to finish Azog

• 
  @danielpinedo413910 күн бұрын

  Is this in 4k or will it be released in 4k?

• 
  @joenesvick704310 күн бұрын

  I'm surprised they didn't do that for Return of the Jedi

• 
  @Genghiskhanofficial10 күн бұрын

  Man why the hell did they think it was a good idea to cut this?

• 
  @scotscottscottt11 күн бұрын

  Hey man, just wanna say thank you so much for all your continuing work on this. You've turned the borderline unwatchable trilogy into one of my favorite fantasy films of all time. I'm excited for the ISO downloads to finish and watch this new version! Cheers!

• 
  @lateshagallman577812 күн бұрын

  3:30

• 
  @lateshagallman577810 күн бұрын

  3:26

• 
  @lateshagallman577810 күн бұрын

  2:03

• 
  @user-tk3sm6eu8s14 күн бұрын

  Cool place for honey moon for ve and his w we know who minus zv wwc lm they go Riverdale with map and all our wwe tna aew rap metal rock hip hop rege actors actresses pop sisters and brothers ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ get the orcs ssp sa bb Ruben Alicia bs ca ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

• 
  @danielpinedo413915 күн бұрын

  This looks so good, will you release a 4k version? I can only imagine what this would be like with the updated soundtrack.

• 
  @gabs975318 күн бұрын

  GREAT EDIT!, Also wherer did you find the bombur and bifur scene?

• 
  @M4Studios18 күн бұрын

  It’s in the desolation of smaug appendices, part 10 i think

• 
  @gabs975318 күн бұрын

  @@M4Studios thanks, do you know where o can find This?

• 
  @per-torereiniurfjell542419 күн бұрын

  First time I watched this edit (the 2024 version), and haven't rewatched the hobbit movies since I saw it in the cinemas. It's really something to see a Bilbo-centered story like it is in the books, and the pace is quite entertaining! This is perfect for a 16 hour marathon, and I look forward to rewatch it again to notice more. (haven't seen any other edits before, only summaries of some). (I have also seen the commentary video you did with Random FT2, and I agggree, the only thing that would be nice to further include, if possible, would've been Smaugs "No Blade Can Pierce Me" line, and the whole company meeting Thranduill before they are incarcerated, but the last one would require cgi background fickling to have a chance at working.)

• 
  @M4Studios19 күн бұрын

  Thanks! The 2024 version does finally include “no blade can pierce me” along with two others. Not possible to do full CGI backgrounds that look as good as the rest of the movie

• 
  @per-torereiniurfjell542419 күн бұрын

  @@M4Studios Oh, I didn't catch that in the Smaug scene! I'll do a rewatch eventually, though! Again, amazing effort!

• 
  @joshuadiven892920 күн бұрын

  Just watched it myself recently, and my god, the pace of the experience became so great!!! Having only watched the original films on theaters, I remember dreading a rewatch knowing the amount of material that would make for a long, multi-sitdown watching experience with forced add-ons and side plots that take away from the world and the experience. Thank you so much. This truly elevates the material to a proper telling of the source material.

• 
  @janysalinas683821 күн бұрын

  AHH IM SO EXCITED!! I have been eagerly waiting to watch a fan edit like this and have been so excited reading the website and seeing your edits as its been coming along. Rewatched the extended editions again recently and was sort of 'editing as i went along'- wishing that it was all cut down to the really good bits that i like them for without all the garbage. SOOOOOO HAPPY that you are making that a reality!! literally downloading the file as Im typing this. I saw that you can even burn them on cds and you've designed the disc art and box for it- THANK YOUUU! Hopefully i will be able to make use of that so that I can proudly have your edit on display next to my box set on my hobbit shelf. Youve done the lords work...

• 
  @newtpondskipper22 күн бұрын

  You had me at more faithful to the book!

• 
  @isabellaribeiro902824 күн бұрын

  The title😂

• 
  @warfare110124 күн бұрын

  While I do like it, I feel as though the scene goes a bit too fast

• 
  @M4Studios23 күн бұрын

  There is no more footage to use. The stuff I cut has to do with Bards imprisonment and Tauriel and the Dwarves in the boat which I cannot have in my cut because it would make no sense to have this random footage when these plots/characters have been removed elsewhere

• 
  @Tommytwotimes34527 күн бұрын

  where can i watch this edit

• 
  @M4Studios26 күн бұрын

  There’s a link in the desc you can download it

• 
  @MikiAnne2927 күн бұрын

  I was so hyped to add this banger to my playlist, only to find out it was unreleased and got really sad, because it's the only song in the sounding that I would add to my playlist :(

• 
  @M4Studios27 күн бұрын

  Way Back then & also Murder Withour Violence both kinda have a similar style to this one. I agree out of all the soundtrack I like the pieces with more simple drum and that classic sound

• 
  @Darkmiss707827 күн бұрын

  Watched it, Loved it, and reviewed it. it's perfect. brought back the memories of reading the big green hardback book, for the first time a good few years ago, Thank you.

• 
  @Darkmiss707827 күн бұрын

  I just recently watched your edit and LOVED it... 🥰

• 
  @fattylumpkin589928 күн бұрын

  Looks amazing! I just wanted to ask is there any way to download the .iso files without having to pay for a Premium Mega Plan? Cheers

• 
  @M4Studios28 күн бұрын

  The FAQ document in the Mega drive has some recommendations, but you don’t have to pay to download you can still wait for the cooldown

• 
  @DEMIX_DX29 күн бұрын

  Uhh it says java.net.socketexception:connection reset

• 
  @stepankuzmin3946Ай бұрын

  Sorry still a bit confused, where can I watch this? Looks amazing

• 
  @M4StudiosАй бұрын

  Hey, I added it to the description

• 
  @tylertomars2312Ай бұрын

  Well done

• 
  @utl94Ай бұрын

  I greatly admire your work to save what can be saved! It is simply a shame that there is not a better product underlying it all. For some reason I just find this line silly: "the keeper of the keys", it strokes me all the wrong way.

• 
  @M4StudiosАй бұрын

  The 2024 update to my fan edit is finally out. Keep in mind, my previous test clips posted in 2024 were not representing of the final product, things still had to be finalized and adjusted, I read all of your comments :)

• 
  @IGonnaBeFatherАй бұрын

  Link in the description?

• 
  @M4StudiosАй бұрын

  @@IGonnaBeFather Same link as prev versions, my website m4-studios.github.io/hobbitbookedit/

• 
  @Denz-El28 күн бұрын

  @@M4Studios Has the Google Drive link been updated as well? I'm not accustomed to MEGA. 😅

• 
  @M4Studios27 күн бұрын

  @@Denz-El No, I don’t have free google drive space anymore. Mega is the same idea you can just right click a file and press download

• 
  @Denz-El27 күн бұрын

  @@M4Studios OK, thanks! :)

• 
  @utl94Ай бұрын

  I watched the first movie in the theatres, in armour, with some friends. Needless to say I never watched the next two. "Unfortunately" I own the DVD box but have never watched all of it. I could not make myself to do it. Now, having "your" Blue-ray discs, this is to me the authoritative cut of the movie and it will be included in LotR marathons going forward. Outstanding work!

• 
  @ILLRICARDOАй бұрын

  i cannot stand pointless filler and am so grateful for this fan edit.

• 
  @EzBlitzzzАй бұрын

  How to watch the Titanic 1912 fanedit? Cant seem to find it in your website or channel.

• 
  @M4StudiosАй бұрын

  It’s on my links section on youtube titanic1912edit.wordpress.com/

• 
  @matklacarАй бұрын

  Saw it yesterday with my best friend. This is our movie canon now. Incredible work, well fucking done mate!!

• 
  @SentecaMorvanАй бұрын

  I just watched it for the first time and am really impressed (I used to watch the Dustin Lee Cut, which is also really great and has a lot of similar goals to this imo). Fantastic work and you really feel the refinement of this cut. There are very few moments when you kinda "feel" the cut (I remember like: Bombur hanging hanging on the tree, Gandalf not noticing the ring and some moments during Thorins fight against Azog on the ice). Overall you have found really incredible solutions. Your way of including Beorn seems so natural I couldn't imagine it otherwise anymore. I also like the Bombur jump-kick and also the intercuts with Kili's fight in the finale. Thanks to your inclusion of Subtitles I will show this to my wife for sure. Greetings from Germany!

• 
  @MrFiresethАй бұрын

  Really nice video you put together here! I ended up switching out to a different OptiFine version since the one you provided it had sometimes showed invisible chunks for a millisecond when turning. I also installed a mod that adds the version label on the top left of the screen that says, "Minecraft Beta 1.7.3". Other than those two things, this is the best compilation I've seen! Love the tall grass removal too.

• 
  @hubertkuborek7831Ай бұрын

  Please make videos without plagiat

• 
  @M4StudiosАй бұрын

  It’s not plagiarism dummy, I never claimed that I owned this. The advertisements on this video have been placed by Warner Bros and they are earning money off of it. I put “fan edit” in the title

• 
  @SNWWRNNGАй бұрын

  The Smaug scenes are beautiful. It's a shame they're tainted by the fact that Bilbo's discovery of the weakspot barely matters in the movies, because the knowledge about it is already in Laketown. I wish the information about the weakspot had been brought from Bilbo to Bard in the movies in some way, even without the thrush.

• 
  @Yeahimman32Ай бұрын

  I really dont like the slow motion in these battle scenes

• 
  @illidangraham2725Ай бұрын

  I wish you could somwhow edit the part where the elves jump over the line of dwarves in the Battle and have then shoot arrows over them, then push the dwarves forward so at least their battle plan would have made snese haha

• 
  @florpodesta561Ай бұрын

  where can I download it?

• 
  @Zizzle4Ай бұрын

  How do I delete the Sound and Skin fix mods because I want to replace them with the BetaCraft Proxy

• 
  @wilhelmfiore8651Ай бұрын

  I love your edit, it is absolutely great! I think all these changes look great as well. The only thing I'd change about it is I'd keep *some* of the Stone Giants - I know they don't look perfect but I think it's a great little action set piece and their presence adds so much to the wonder and mystery of Middle-Earth that Tolkien so frequently emphasized. I saw another edit that kept them, but removed the egregious bit where it turns out the Dwarves and Bilbo are standing *on* a Giant - so instead, the Giants appear, they fight, and all the rocks falling causes Bilbo to almost fall, keeping their presence but skipping the fake out where it looks like half the Dwarves got crushed. It'd be a small readdition but I think it'd preserve so much character, but maybe I'm biased because I love the Stone Giants so much.

• 
  @user-qv2mc3dw5oАй бұрын

  I quite like the bit with tauriel, improves the pacing a lot imo

• 
  @user-qv2mc3dw5oАй бұрын

  mmmm

• 
  @old_Voli_55Ай бұрын

  it is work with a another mode like fycraft in a.1.2.6 ?

• 
  @GeorgeZeaiter121Ай бұрын

  thank you

• 
  @Double-R-NothingАй бұрын

  Here's a fun idea for a potential book-accurate addition. The Appendices show Bilbo saying his witty "Dwarves do take some catching" line before putting on the ring. Would there be a way to put that in somehow, with some keying and clever editing?

• 
  @M4StudiosАй бұрын

  Which appendices? And what’s the context? Like before he escapes smaug?

• 
  @Double-R-NothingАй бұрын

  @@M4Studios I believe it was the Appendices for "Inside Information", near the end of the feature

• 
  @M4StudiosАй бұрын

  @@Double-R-Nothing i found it. Unfortunately he’s just practicing the line so the delivery doesn’t quite work. Such a shame.

• 
  @Double-R-NothingАй бұрын

  Nice revision! Focusing on the human element was always a strength of this sequence, even more so with your edit! I adored your re-shuffling of Bard and Smaug's face-off, having the former assemble the ballista as if to answer the latter's question with "I'm your reckoning, biatch!" 2 questions... 1) Was there no way to integrate the additional shots of Laketown destruction (BTS stuntwork, people burning alive inside homes) with your current means, or was it just not worth using in your opinion? 2) Where can I download this revised version?

• 
  @M4StudiosАй бұрын

  I watched all of the appendices and i did not find any unused laketown shots that were usable, maybe you could provide some rough time stamps . It will be uploaded soon in the same spot as the current version i’ll announce it. Thanks!

• 
  @vastbubbleАй бұрын

  You've done awesome work and when I watched your cut last December I thought it was the definitive version (having now seen a few different fan cuts). The only constructive feedback I have is about the final battle particularly around Thorin and the hilltop/tower/ice battle. My friends commented that the whole sequence felt a bit rushed and that because of how fast paced the battle has become it was harder to follow the sequence of events. The only other comment I had was around Gandalf and Bilbo's goodbye. In the original cut, Gandalf's last stern/angry expression as Bilbo walks away made sense because they'd really played up the Ring and Gandalf being suspicious of Bilbo's lies. But in your more book friendly cut I think his last negative look comes across as a bit out of place. If I remember correctly in the book after Gandalf says you're only a very small fellow in a wide world Bilbo says "thank goodness" or something like that. Their goodbye feels like it should end on a happier note. But that's just a matter of opinion of course :) I'm not sure I can offer much in the way of suggesting changes but thought I'd pass along that audience feedback. The Vimeo link seems to be down so I can't comment on the new battle cut but I'm very excited to see how it all flows. The new changes sound great. Thank you again!

• 
  @M4StudiosАй бұрын

  Hey, thanks for watching. I think I have improved the Ravenhill part of the battle in the new update as (I think) I described in the video, but the core structure will largely remain the same unfortunately. It is simply impossible to make it any slower because I've had to remove all of Tauriel and Legolas from Ravenhill. Personally I don't think it's hard to follow, especially in the update, it's pretty simple with just Dwarves going in to fight Orcs, but the Dwarf deaths we simply don't have any more footage to help slow them down any further. As for the goodbye, I think trimming that shot would be tricky without disrupting the flow, but it might be possible. Regardless, I probably won't because I do enjoy the moment as a balance of book accuracy and also being a non-overbearing reference to the following trilogy, Gandalf suspects something (even if he doesn't outright know details) I should be releasing it in the next few weeks, it's all ready!

• 
  @vastbubbleАй бұрын

  @@M4Studios Thanks heaps and great to hear your thoughts. Keen to see it soon :)

• 
  @ofaliufala2863Ай бұрын

  I didn't watch the whole movie they skipped this part