Your Favorite Character SHOULD DIE | A Certain Scientific Railgun T (S3)

Ойын-сауық

Light spoilers for Railgun S3. Heavy spoilers for Railgun S2 Sisters' Arc.
Yumiya Rakko vs Frenda, a fight in A Certain Scientific Railgun T (S3, 2020), really PEEVED me for a MAJOR reason--nobody dies. This isn't inherently a problem, but for reasons explained in the video, it can very easily become one in the long run.
Timestamps:
0:00 Railgun T Fight Introduction
3:19 Sisters' Arc Recap (Railgun S2)
4:55 Making death believable
5:35 Railgun/Index's Real Appeal
6:16 Setting a Precedence of Death
7:04 STOP Heightening the Stakes
8:13 Where's the Meat?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."

Пікірлер: 7

  • @huaqinteng6350
    @huaqinteng6350 Жыл бұрын

    You see, the author doesn’t really do deaths, and if he does, it’s usually in just an arc, and if you compare Railgun to Index, Index has way more deaths, and the stakes are way higher too Plus, this video is pretty ironic if you’ve actually watched Index 3 and knew what happened

  • @Sutidamuskun

    @Sutidamuskun

    Жыл бұрын

    This makes me want to watch Index 3, but I also didn't care for Index 1...which means I'm in a conundrum 😵‍💫and yeah the death in-arc thing is def a trend even though the characters may not be human

  • @huaqinteng6350

    @huaqinteng6350

    Жыл бұрын

    @@Sutidamuskun Well that’s your own problem, cause frankly even if Index didn’t have a great adaptation like Railgun did, at least the first two seasons are worth watching, if not, I’d say read the LNs which you won’t, plus you can’t even understand most of Railgun without Index anyway And if you’ve know the full context behind why Rakko even has plot armor to begin with, it’s because she can’t die here as she needs to die way later, but don’t worry, this is not a spoiler and the only mention of it is literally just a phone message And Frenda? You need to be glad there are scenes of her in Index, cause let me just say that most people are gonna be pissed by what happened and you can’t do anything about it cause the things she done in Index is what made her have all these scenes in Railgun Just to give you an idea of how high the stakes can be, at most, Railgun’s goes to city wide, but in Index, it goes to worldwide, and for the LNs, it goes to galaxy wide

  • @Sutidamuskun

    @Sutidamuskun

    Жыл бұрын

    @@huaqinteng6350 I see. So Index is the series that poses the higher stakes and FULFILLS them--makes sense since it's the main plotline. Btw, tbh I've never had an issue knowing what was going on Railgun; I actually didn't watch Index until 3 years after I saw Railgun 😂🤣May give Index 2 & 3 a shot during the Winter since that season seems pretty dead. Also, I'll take that as a RIP Frenda so...RIP Frenda 💀

  • @huaqinteng6350

    @huaqinteng6350

    Жыл бұрын

    @@Sutidamuskun Index def has higher stakes sure, but it doesn’t always fulfill them, cause like I said, the author doesn’t do much killing anyways, plus Railgun can’t have too high of a stakes that will effect Index as a whole Ok, since you’re not having an issue, let me give you a few questions 1) Why is Kuroko in the hospital in Railgun T? 2) Why is the bus service suddenly out while Misaka and Misaki are on their way to Gensei 3) What does SCHOOL(Rakko group) want with the data they’ve gotten 4) Why does Misaki feels like she knows Touma 5) How does the Scavengers know about Accel There are more but I’ll leave it at that, these questions are not big enough to effect the story, but you can’t help but wonder them, also there are references and callbacks in the series that you’ll only know if you’ve watched Index or maybe even Accel, one such example will be Kuroko drop kicking Touma in the folk dance

  • @AeonofHorus
    @AeonofHorus Жыл бұрын

    Funny thing is that Rakko is killed off screen after this kek, her surviving against Frenda in this fight would probably have bothered me more if that didn't happen

  • @AccipiterVP
    @AccipiterVP Жыл бұрын

    ... In January 2008 the volume 15 of Index light novel was puplished in japan .... the first apperance of Frenda ... The Index anime adapted this volume in the third season (2018). (2010 where season 2 was, the first light novel series was finished with 22 volumes) (Oct 2018 the sequel LN series had 21 volumes; => 43 main volumes overall) ... The manga chapters wich covers the second Arc/"Half" in RailgunT were puplished Sep2014 to Oct2017 about Sisters Arc: Index LN volume 3 (Sep 2004) (LN had 3 volumes) Anime episodes 10 to 14 (Dez2008 to Jan2009) (LN had in this time 16 main volumes) Railgun Manga Begin Chapter 18 (Jan2009) (Index had 16 main LN volumes) End Chapter 39 (Feb2011) (First Index LN Series was finished; one month later the Sequel IndexNT had started) Anime started April 2013 => Index NT had 6 LN volumes

Келесі