“You Don’t Get To Change Facts!” | Julia Hartley-Brewer x Kellie-Jay Keen On Trans Rights
Talk’s Julia Hartley-Brewer is joined by founder of Let Women Speak, Kellie-Jay Keen, to discuss an essay by JK Rowling in a forthcoming book on Scotland’s battle for women’s rights.
The Harry Potter author said she spoke up about transgender issues because she believes she is witnessing “the greatest assault of my lifetime” on women’s rights and would have “felt ashamed for the rest of my days if I hadn’t”
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#gender #transgender #trans
Пікірлер: 425
KJK is a warrior queen. She is magnificent!
@budweiser600
26 күн бұрын
She's a feminist activist - and that's so far from being the problem causing the end of Western civilisation.
@thetransagender2866
26 күн бұрын
She's also bought and paid for by the Westbro Baptist lot
@Joley964
26 күн бұрын
@@thetransagender2866 That’s not true
@JG-us9lu
25 күн бұрын
@thetransagender2866 Back in your hole. Please.
@thetransagender2866
25 күн бұрын
@@Joley964 Look at her affiliation with Hands Accross the Aisle
A bloke in a dress is still a bloke, no arguments whatsoever!!
@DrJams
26 күн бұрын
A woman with a bread doesn't make them a man
@crawford1083
26 күн бұрын
The idea that you put on a frock and some lippy and a wig and HEY PRESTO you become a woman! It is madness!
@user-tu5ej5lg2c
26 күн бұрын
Correct, but If he identifies as a woman he can use women's toilets, and some people think that is acceptable. If you dare to imply that this is unacceptable, the police knock on your door. I think I've got that right?
@RC-9
26 күн бұрын
@@user-tu5ej5lg2cyes - I believe a policeman in a skirt 👍
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
@@user-tu5ej5lg2c Legally, no, he can't even with a GRC. There are exemption in the equality Act in certain circumstances where exemptions can be applied to protect and/or promote females sex based rights so the protected characteristic of sex. Problem is some people are acting as though there isn't. Logic dictates this aspect of the law will be clarified.
I stand with jk Rowling ❤️
@MsMRJames-ll9dh
18 күн бұрын
me too❤❤
@SMGAPR8
13 күн бұрын
Me too, 👏
@ralfl.k.5636
2 күн бұрын
More and more man recognizes, that freedom of women is in danger. Now first reactions, like Tony Blair. Risc for the pride community, because millions of mens are military trained.
Ms Rowling has nothing to regret or apologise for she, spoke clearly and loudly long enough ago. Her voice has been an important one, you can tell by the number and length of the attacks upon her good name. And she was right Women do exist, and they're not like men, either physically or psychologically. And I as a man can vouch for (and am grateful for) that.
@robertdexter5342
25 күн бұрын
Give ya head a wobble Dave.
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
So you’ve never got ya leg over a trans gal??
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
You sure?
@davetdowell
22 күн бұрын
@@robertdexter5342 Yep.
@unowen-nh9ov
13 күн бұрын
@@robertdexter5342Which trans woman popped u out?
K-JK deserves the utmost respect for her firm stand against the odious trans cult.
Starmer doesn't believe it Hes just a coward
@BrianWaugh-fy4wh
26 күн бұрын
He is a spineless traitor clown.
@RC-9
26 күн бұрын
And that is the crux of the sir liar problem .. he doesn’t believe in anything - except furthering his own career
@jasperhorace7147
26 күн бұрын
It actually makes no sense that any politician relying on votes can advocate so strongly for such a tiny minority while actually ignoring the majority of their voters. Proves they really are thick.
@errin-mp1zy
26 күн бұрын
@@jasperhorace7147 Yes, the only people that are more thick are the women that will be voting for them.
@RC-9
25 күн бұрын
@@jasperhorace7147 yet he will be PM 5 July… what does that say about the British public
Julia and KelleyJay are both warrior women.
@robertdexter5342
24 күн бұрын
Unfinished mtf’s
@johnristheanswer
22 күн бұрын
* Kellie
No such thing as "transphobia". Language is powerful. Don't cave to the mob.
@connor5669
26 күн бұрын
lol that's a really convenient logical fallacy. No transphobia if I pretend they don't exist
@ConnieWobbles
26 күн бұрын
@@connor5669 nobody is pretending that AGP men don't exist, or that there are others with trauma or autism that have been convinced that they're something that they're not. It's the umbrella term of 'trans' that is a convenient lie.
@errin-mp1zy
26 күн бұрын
@@connor5669 Didn't say they didn't exist, just no such thing as transphobia, which is true. no-one as an irrational fear of these fools.
@jurgalt2005
25 күн бұрын
@@connor5669 you should be more concerned about misogyny, as it is much more prevailing. women are getting abused both in their private spaces, raped in female prisons by males "identifying as women ", also women cheated out of their hard earned medals in sports.
@godzillas6301
25 күн бұрын
Phobia is an irrational fear of something . Very much different to not subscribing to the idea a man is a woman .
It is about time we started bringing criminal charges against people who make false accusations against people who haven't said anything transphobic. If they don't have evidence of transphobia they should be prosecuted for slander.
@jaijai5250
19 күн бұрын
It’s a made up word. It doesn’t means anything . Very few people fear or hate them. We simply want them to leave us alone. They can do as they wish but leave the rest of us alone.
@nacho-mammy
8 күн бұрын
There is no such thing as tranz- phobia
KJK has held the line since the beginning! She has peaked people all over the world. Brava and thank you!
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
I’m not convinced. I’m sure she has a girldick.
2 wonderful ladies talking the truth and showing us exactly how sick this world has become! This madness must stop and this insanity ended! 😮
@brimkathstampex2306
7 күн бұрын
Where has it all come from?
Warrior Queen Kellie-Jay, 👏👏👏👏👏
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
Yer. She’s a regular Boudicca that one. Oh wait……..
Can you imagine a time when a doctor will look down at a newborn and say "we dont know what sex it is".. that will be the future if this nonsense doesn't stop
@warwickpayne3338
11 күн бұрын
😂😂😂
@brimkathstampex2306
7 күн бұрын
@@warwickpayne3338 Quite - the baby is either male or female, a girl or a boy. One has a vagina, the other a penis. Why is there a problem, when the reality shows that there isn't a problem? It's quite simple, even a child can understand. It's just a convoluted load of nonsense, propagated by a bunch of idiots who reside in Cloud Cuckoo Land and La La Land.
I think more men should be standing up for their mothers. .wives ..daughters...regarding safe spaces ..sports ..schools etc...
@loreman7267
26 күн бұрын
It's a lot easier to fire men for naughty thoughts, especially if they're public figures.
@JG-us9lu
25 күн бұрын
Its time more women stood up for their own rights.
@sidnotvicious8442
25 күн бұрын
Men should support their women standing up for themselves. Women need to do this with men's tacit support.
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
I’m a man. And I stand up for all women including trans women. It’s that simple.
@JG-us9lu
22 күн бұрын
@@robertdexter5342 No not really. You're are a product. Never a man,.
What is 'transphobic'? Not believing that anyone can be 'trans' - sex is immutable. Therefore I'm transphobic and proud to be so.
@user-zb1dn5du8r
26 күн бұрын
Phobia is an uncontrollable, irrational, and lasting fear of a certain object, situation, or activity (is coming from the greek word phobos). I don't think JKR is afraid of anything..
@catwoman7462
25 күн бұрын
@@user-zb1dn5du8r I know, but it's used in the wrong way, so if it's a word the TRA loons want to use - and you can't explain things to them as they're not rational - then I'll just tell them that "yes, I am. What of it?".
@lemon1657
12 күн бұрын
To be honest, some of these buffalo bill types do terrify me, especially if I had to encounter them in a 👩🚻 but that's not irrational. They're trying to say a 👩's natural fear response and instincts are wrong. Nope. Always listen to your instincts and ignore these socially shaming nonsense terms.
@catwoman7462
12 күн бұрын
@@lemon1657 Exactly. We've got these instincts for a reason - to protect us.
Good on KJK
Been following KJK for a long time now. She’s experienced so much nonsense, for just stating biology. 1 thing I also hate in this. I’m. Not. Cis. I’m a woman. No need to shove anything on the front.
Love Kellie J's 'I'm over the rainbow' T-shirt! 😀
@usafvet100
19 күн бұрын
Clever word play, I like it!😂
Been fighting this since 2019. It’s been dreadful, never experienced anything as frightening as this assault on women’s rights despite working in all male workplaces for years in the 80’s which could be hard going. I’d swap back to those times rather than today’s horrors being thrown our way.
I've yet to hear ANY trans activists express ANY concern over safeguarding when young people or even children make tragic mistakes. The activists appear to put the ideology well above the real risk of permanent harm. Quite the opposite. All I have heard is those who regret their transition are ignored or treated as traitors by those in the cult.
@RC-9
26 күн бұрын
You never will
@ralfl.k.5636
9 күн бұрын
"No risc no fun" - even if children can be the victims. Worldwide mothers now realize the danger for their children. (Corrected)
@brimkathstampex2306
7 күн бұрын
@@ralfl.k.5636 Dinger????
How could anyone vote for Starmer? A man that does not know what a woman is. The fact is it's one of his other lies, there's so many now it's had to keep up.
@crawford1083
26 күн бұрын
I get that so many are fed up with the ConSocialists. But being pro-Liebour (sic)? Do not get it.
@RC-9
26 күн бұрын
Sadly enough gullible uninformed people will and hence welcome to starmers Britain 5 July… 😔
@etaylor6965
26 күн бұрын
Exact;y, all these misogynistic supporters putting men with mental health issues before women and then asking women to vote for them, the brass neck. The men are bad enough but the women who support this BS are disgustingly pathetic traitors to women.
@johnmartin7158
26 күн бұрын
Get use to it bud.
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
How do you explain Ann Widdecombe?
Nice accolade from JKJ to Julia. Both these women and JKR are heroines.
KJK and Julia HB thank you both 🙏
Julia - Legend
Both of these women are heroes. Kellie-Jay for relentlessly campaigning on this issue. Julia for raising awareness in the media. I am so grateful I found Julia’s breakfast show during lockdown. A voice of reason in that time of madness. She asked parliamentarians questions that others in the media would not dare whilst most of the media were towing the line and suppressing opposing views.
@berylwelch3526
10 күн бұрын
Like climate change ,all of this silliness is a scam
I’m over the rainbow too x
@helenwalker5704
4 күн бұрын
Right! I want that T shirt 😄
Warrior Queens 👑👑❤
So refreshing to hear two people speaking the truth fearlessly
It's not a competition. Great women leaders empower other women 🏆
I am so full of love for anyone, male or female, who doesn’t accept the easy road to victimhood. Much respect to both of you
Love Kelly’s T-shirt 😂🤣.
Thank goodness for strong courageous women like yourselves, why are there not more of you?
Keep going ladies you are doing a great job
Any rights that sh*t on others human rights are demands not rights.!
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️🏳️⚧️🏳️⚧️🤩🤩🤩 thanks for being an allie!!
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
@@robertdexter5342 No worries, I'm glad you realise that people support T people existing in their own right and not at the expense of women, girls and gay peoples culture and civil rights.
Kellie-Jay Keen is a heroine, and please not, I used the feminine term instead of the what has now become gender neutral "hero".
@monhurstptyltd160
25 күн бұрын
or even....Shero!
@ribbonsofnight
25 күн бұрын
@@monhurstptyltd160 fingernails on a chalkboard.
@monhurstptyltd160
24 күн бұрын
@@ribbonsofnight Shero sounds pretty good!
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
Personally I’d call her a haggard has been. But it’s debatable if she’s ever been attainable.
Massive admiration to both of you for your courage & clarity.
JHB spoke for around 6 minutes, KJK for around 3.5minutes. LET KELLIE SPEAK.
@TheDreamfinder99
26 күн бұрын
The woman can’t shut up. Takes her 4 hours to make a point or ask a question. Would rather just listen to Posie all day long
@robertdexter5342
26 күн бұрын
You timed it? Christ on a bike you must be one boring excuse .
@JG-us9lu
25 күн бұрын
Oh stop
@ConnieWobbles
25 күн бұрын
It's a conversation between two women. Nothing wrong with JHB.
@robertdexter5342
25 күн бұрын
@@ConnieWobbles two backwards uninformed bigoted hags. With no gay or trans friends, otherwise they would’ve mentioned their dire makeup and fashion debacles.
Women Won't Weesht!
@anneg5720
26 күн бұрын
Neither will you!
You’re both warriors. Thank you b
KJK is right, thank you Juila - you're both heroes and Megan Kelly too, and JK Rowling, and Helen Joyce
Any men and women who turn the other cheek on this issue may find their lack of courage will come back to bite them hard. In society we always reap what is sown, and it’s likely that if this delusion is perpetrated it will affect your grandchildren’s lives.
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
Agree but reality is, this will affect everyone's lives. This is not just about women, this about the truth itself
The sad thing is is that they have changed facts, and MP's support this nonsense as well. Normal people are attacked when we speak out about this sort of stuff.
Ted bundy, the ultimate predator, did a fantastic job of convincing people he was an ordinary and, in fact, charming man. And his modus operandi, was to pretend to be injured to appeal to women’s desire to help, and then murdered them. Protections for women needs to be prioritised! And no I’m not saying that all trans women are predators, but the allowing of trans women into real women’s spaces sadly opens up that risk. We need to find a better way.
Great job women.
The word mysoginy is being misused too
KJK is amazing.
These are amazing women!!
People are generally unaware because they watch the MSM, who don’t report how nonsensical it is.
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
Presumably you think TALKTV is MSM ?
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
@@robertdexter5342 Eh? Did you actually read the post?
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
@@joce11 so TALKTV UK is a failed tv station spouting crap?
All Power to J K Rowling. . Go girl. ❤️
I think if we all ignore being called a phobe or an ist of any kind, and just shrug our shoulders, it’ll all stop. It’s all watered down anyway
@rozzgrey801
26 күн бұрын
Yes, those 'phobes' 'ists' etc are just rude noises leftist bigots compulsively make when confronted with an argument they can't deal with. The left don't debate at all, they just call people names as if those serve in place of reasoned debate..
In scotland they are speaking about if a child is trans in nurseries
@marieparker3822
26 күн бұрын
Time to repeal Devolution for Scotland and Wales. Save the Scots and Welsh!
@RC-9
26 күн бұрын
Devolution is probably the single most destructive decision this country had ever made… I feel for the Scot’s and welsh
@loreman7267
26 күн бұрын
Good ol' SNP! Bunch of smelly tw*ts.
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
Omg! The children!! The children!!! Omg! What am I gonna do? Fk all. Just post up banal content on a failed media platform. Groundbreaking.
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
@@robertdexter5342 I take it you don't have children. More often than not people supporting this are childless.
1984
@uniquevideosUk
26 күн бұрын
You'd think with women still defending & protecting their rights.
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
@@uniquevideosUk Not disagreeing but what makes this so Orwellian for some is people are in effect being asked by the the so powers that be to ignore what we see, feel, hear and know instinctually not to mention scientifically to be true. “The party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.” - George Orwell, 1984
@carocatho
8 күн бұрын
@@joce11this is scary AF.
How can anybody vote for Starmer when he hasn't got the guts to speak out and say what a real women is ( the one's with a cervix) , what a spineless politician , thank god for people like JK and KJ ❤
JHB should have let KJK speak, she kept interrupting her.
JK & KJ 👍👏👏👏
I love the t-shirt! 😊
Why doesn’t Julia let KJK speak?
@sallywright8065
25 күн бұрын
She’s always the same, it’s annoying.
Kellie Jay Keen is my hero! She has guts!
JKROWLING & Posie Parker are Warriors.
JKR won't wheesht either. I hope she eventually says TWaM aloud, especially with the Edinburgh R*pe Crisis tribunal.
The majority of people ARE blissfully unaware of what's been going on.
Julia please let your guest speak 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Not the world over ; not Ghana , West Indies
@jaijai5250
19 күн бұрын
Believe me. They have “Puppet governments” and will eventually be made to fall into line, and will change their legislation.
If you haven't read the book 1984 please do. You would think it got wrote last week. Its absolutely crazy the world we're getting pushed into. We all need to stand up and be counted. ✌🏻
Love these two!
It is a scandal like the postmasters are. There will be a huge enquiry into this I reckon in the future for all the women/children who have been affected by gender ideology.
A man in a dress = Brave and to be celebrated.
Can news channels not afford to pay for JK to speak for herself? Would be great to hear from her directly. She’s a for force of nature!
JK is truly an inspirational role model for every woman and girl on the planet, she is completely impeccable and admirable. ❤
I’m the same as KJK I never peaked. I’ve always been a TERF with this absolute nonsense.
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
Absolutely. How anyone thinks human being can change their biological sex or can be can be born in the wrong body when the only body they have is the one they are born with is beyond me. People can believe what they wish, we all beliefs but beliefs are not facts.
Nicely spoken ladies. You can't teach stupidity.
That's and amazing pair of rainbow kellie, thank you for making my day ❤
Thank you xc
Its not even just a fear of predators in our bathrooms. There are many private things that go on in the ladies bathrooms that demand privacy. And if comedy sketches are to believed, ditto in the boys bathroom.
Women widnae wheesht! 🏴
Kellie is wonderfully epic too ❤️
KZread keeps hiding my comments. Funny considering the subject matter
KJK lost all credibility when she suggested employers actively discriminate against trans identity people. That’s vile and illegal
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
No, she didn't as full well you know.
Just trying to find some benefit from the infected blood stuff coming out myself, especially since having got rid of the HCV in 2017 there's been no benefit from having done so, something they've been very aware of in Scotland since their previous blood inquiry!?
People do seem to put their head in the sand. I do think so much of the problem is that it is all families can do to keep their lives on track with all the difficulties they are facing they just don’t have time or the energy to devote more time to fighting the cause.
Julia. I don't know if you've already done so, but I do wish you would do an article on transmen in sport. It needs doing.
Ladies and mothers, the real female part of mankind
I'm in agreement with Julia and Kellie-Jay on this issue, as I'm sure most of the population, men and women are, to about 99% of us all. I've got some issues with Kellie-Jay's, and Helen Joyce's approaches, though, which require further explanation from them. 1. There is, in both of their discourses, a tendency to portray (all) men as predators, such as with regards to the issues of trans m-f gaining access to female only spaces. If you're going to claim that language needs to be precise, then that precision needs to be applied to this issue as well. It is ONLY trans male to female persons attempting to gain access to female only spaces that are a predatory risk to women - not all men. 2. There is a tendency to use the word "misogyny" aimed at the trans m-f, with a loose association to applying it to all men. Again, that seems like a deliberate linguistic tactic to slur all men. Linguistic precision is required if women want to have the support of right-minded men in addressing this issue. 3. There is a feminist approach to dealing with this issue coming from Kelie-Jay and Helen. However, this whole trans issue is itself born from feminist ideology. Further, if you look carefully at the activism supporting this ideology, and you only have to look at the video of the march/rally clip shown in the video to see an example of this, 80% of the activists are feminist WOMEN. So, if anything, the misogyny is internalised female misogyny. Would Kellie-Jay or Helen like to try and explain this?
Always good to hear the arguments rehearsed by two such clever women who have “all the right junk in all the right places” as the popular song tells us. 😂😂😂😂😂
The backlash is happening 🙌
KJK was going to stand against Sir keir at the election - is she still going to do so?
@errin-mp1zy
26 күн бұрын
She was going up against Lloyd Russel-Moyle but he has suddenly said he won't be eligible because of a complaint about his behaviour EIGHT years ago???
@alisonwren3624
25 күн бұрын
I think she is waiting to see who will be standing before making a final decision. Was going to be Brighton but not sure now.
The host talks ALL the time and does not give the guests a fair go ! She talks 80% of the time and interrupts frequently. (I do agree with her but try to INCLUDE your guests and give them a fair go)
3:51 true
until the real men stand up and protect our women and children? what are we doing here?
JK ROWLING is a beautiful, strong, talented, inspirational lady 🌹❤️
@robertdexter5342
26 күн бұрын
You talk some right bollocks.
come on!!!
kjk amazing
LOVELY WOMAN JK AND KELLY JAY
🥂
Heroine ❤
We don't even acknowledge the door handle on the women's toilet door, it's such a bizarre thing to do, knowing your male and going on there.. it's not even a conscious thought to most of us. If we need the loo and it's full we just try somewhere else.. unless it's number 2 then their maybe some begging and pleading..😂 maybe I should start carrying a plastic tub..??
I stand with jk Rowling, kj keen ❤
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
Why’s that dear? Are you mtf?
For future reference, Joanne is NOT Scottish, she is English. Born and raised in Gloucestershire.
@robertdexter5342
24 күн бұрын
And that’s a total embarrassment for Gloucestershire.
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
@@robertdexter5342 Yes I'm pretty sure Gloucestershire would be embarrassed to have JKR one of the best selling authors of all time born in their county - said not one logical thinking person, ever. The best selling author of all time is Agatha Christie. IMO, its great to think that two of the greatest authors of all time are British women, adult human females. Its amazing what some women can achieve.
Farage does. His contract has been shown to be a pack of lies.
'I'm Over The Rainbow'. How clever is that tshirt? We're all bloody over it.
@robertdexter5342
22 күн бұрын
Hilarious! Did you think that up by yourself??
@joce11
22 күн бұрын
@@robertdexter5342 No, LGB people did. That's what LGB people say.
@robertdexter5342
21 күн бұрын
@@joce11 and how many “LGB” people say this?