If you select student for medical college only based on 12th marks. We know, how marks are scored in class 12th. It's not good. Competition should be there for every one.

@khedhareeswari4700

10 ай бұрын

Agree but I think neet is very difficult and no level playing field

@suryadeepvishwakarma3454

10 ай бұрын

@@khedhareeswari4700 so, paper should be easy, but then how will seats be allocated for large number of students.

Its called #randironaa. Why not oppose IIT JEE or CLAT or IAS exama or any other nationlised tests .

@studywithconcepts4689

10 ай бұрын

That's becase they have seperate examination for their own engineering for IAS there is their own language and sellebus is such that Tamilnadu history book is must read for upsc aspirant. So they have their own system.

@offred6013

10 ай бұрын

@@studywithconcepts4689 so TN is a separate Country. Lol They should have their own Army too. Lol

Student suicides is an entirely different subject which needs to be dealt with irrespective of NEET... it is a reflection of the society where failure is not acceptable... neither do the governments show any alternate paths in case of failure.. just another reflection of failure of government to provide skills relevant to the society and provide quality education free of cost... as long as our politics revolve around caste, religion and some alien topic not relevant to people’s lives, politicians will not respond... at least the media must put things in the right context and push the politicians...

@gratitude789

10 ай бұрын

Agree with your point. Also, parents/society needs to look beyond medical/engineering courses. It is clear that not everyone will get a seat in medical College, one should look beyond it as well.

@phaseneutral3006

10 ай бұрын

1.people need to understand, only students who can afford CBSE or coaching institutions are more than 95% who got medical seat this time 2. if only the performance during mbbs decides whether you become a doctor or not then why there is a need for NEET 3. tamil nadu ranks no1 in medical tourism which means we have better doctors and infrastructure so stop lecturing us how to select our students 4. NEET didn't eliminate anything, you still have to pay a hefty sum of money to join a medical College. if you can't afford the fee, you still wont get a seat even though you passed the exam but a student who got lower marks than you in NEET who could afford the fee will get a seat

@unknown.m.e

9 ай бұрын

Why central taking the seats Tamil Nadu govt medical colleges which are developed by Tamil Nadu for their people. UP or any other state can also build why they didn't build these educational institutions in their state. Now saying Tamil Nadu opposition but don't say other states are under developed even with high budget they get from central

The reality is that the government school system has failed to provide good education to children

The Hindu is now batting for the private medical colleges lobby 😂

This is just useless. So they want admission in medical colleges without any entrance ?.

@piranha3037

10 ай бұрын

1. NEET gives us the opportunity to become a doctor based on merit. In the past only rich people with crores of money would get the seats. At least, it has given a level playing field based on merit. 2. Is NEET coaching costly? Not really. Online Coaching Centres like PW are providing yearlong coaching with Rs 3500 to 4500 range. Many other good coaching centres are following the suit. 3. Are the competitions high? Yes, but what do expect for the most populous Nation on the Earth? But it at least transparent, based on merit with no hint of corrupt practices. 4. A standardized test throughout the country ensure that good meritorious students even though poor pass the exams. 5. Want to reduce the pressure? A good way to begin is to open more Medical Colleges rather than breaking a good system. Earlier, it was all about money. 6. Who are protesting? Politicians, Private College owners. 7. The Private Medical Colleges of India charge exorbitant fees more than anywhere in the world. Students prefer to go to war ravaged Ukraine but they cannot afford private medical college fees of India. Why not reduce the fees of Private Colleges? Increase more colleges, reduce the fees of Private Colleges and reduce the pressure of the candidates. Stop political gimmicks over the matter. The media houses must not entertain or indulge in such gimmicks which is bad for all.

@sureshvenkataraman608

8 ай бұрын

then dont have 10th and 12th exams too

@ALOKKUMAR-vc6ie

2 күн бұрын

@@sureshvenkataraman608 objective exam is more transparent in evaluation then subjective exam

In a country like India, all coaching centers should be mandated to take in aspirants from economically weaker households who have scored top 10 percentile in their last board exam. The government should pay for the fees of these students for the coaching classes and monitor that they are not discriminated against in the coaching centers.

@monojeetdey7409

10 ай бұрын

We have to increase your tax for that.

The Supreme Court of India in its Judgement dated 20th January, 2020 held as follows: "... Merit cannot be measured solely in terms of marks. Merit must be construed in terms of the social value of a member in the medical profession (Pradeep Jain (supra); ....... Thus, we need to reconceptualise the meaning of 'merit'. For instance, if a high-scoring candidate does not use their talents to perform good actions, it would be difficult to call them “meritorious” merely because they scored high marks. The propriety of actions and dedication to public service should also be seen as markers of merit, which cannot be assessed in a competitive examination. Equally, fortitude and resilience required to uplift oneself from conditions of deprivation is reflective of individual calibre."

@AmalTan

10 ай бұрын

True but what is way to measure it. Entrance exams have their problems but still better than all others.

If NEET exempt to TN Other states pass a law those who are not passed the NEET not eligible for Medical Practice in their respective States

@azhagirisamy1006

2 ай бұрын

Kk good idea,our TN doctors at the time when neet doesn't even exist are well experienced,they don't depend other states,entrance exam can't decide their talent, it's about money and about who could afford costly coaching center.students who cleared without coaching is a rare.neet should be eradicated otherwise entrance exam must be controlled by respective State govt and also respective state's medical seats filled up of respective state's students.

@Kiruthi26.

2 күн бұрын

Tamilnadu is already medical hub of India and Chennai is medical capital of India

What solution do you have ? Introducing MCAT instead of NEET

@piranha3037

10 ай бұрын

1. NEET gives us the opportunity to become a doctor based on merit. In the past only rich people with crores of money would get the seats. At least, it has given a level playing field based on merit. 2. Is NEET coaching costly? Not really. Online Coaching Centres like PW are providing yearlong coaching with Rs 3500 to 4500 range. Many other good coaching centres are following the suit. 3. Are the competitions high? Yes, but what do expect for the most populous Nation on the Earth? But it at least transparent, based on merit with no hint of corrupt practices. 4. A standardized test throughout the country ensure that good meritorious students even though poor pass the exams. 5. Want to reduce the pressure? A good way to begin is to open more Medical Colleges rather than breaking a good system. Earlier, it was all about money. 6. Who are protesting? Politicians, Private College owners. 7. The Private Medical Colleges of India charge exorbitant fees more than anywhere in the world. Students prefer to go to war ravaged Ukraine but they cannot afford private medical college fees of India. Why not reduce the fees of Private Colleges? Increase more colleges, reduce the fees of Private Colleges and reduce the pressure of the candidates. Stop political gimmicks over the matter. The media houses must not entertain or indulge in such gimmicks which is bad for all.

A standardized test is needed in India. In the US students take MCAT (for medicine), LSAT (for law), SAT, etc These are all standardized national tests.

@piranha3037

10 ай бұрын

1. NEET gives us the opportunity to become a doctor based on merit. In the past only rich people with crores of money would get the seats. At least, it has given a level playing field based on merit. 2. Is NEET coaching costly? Not really. Online Coaching Centres like PW are providing yearlong coaching with Rs 3500 to 4500 range. Many other good coaching centres are following the suit. 3. Are the competitions high? Yes, but what do expect for the most populous Nation on the Earth? But it at least transparent, based on merit with no hint of corrupt practices. 4. A standardized test throughout the country ensure that good meritorious students even though poor pass the exams. 5. Want to reduce the pressure? A good way to begin is to open more Medical Colleges rather than breaking a good system. Earlier, it was all about money. 6. Who are protesting? Politicians, Private College owners. 7. The Private Medical Colleges of India charge exorbitant fees more than anywhere in the world. Students prefer to go to war ravaged Ukraine but they cannot afford private medical college fees of India. Why not reduce the fees of Private Colleges? Increase more colleges, reduce the fees of Private Colleges and reduce the pressure of the candidates. Stop political gimmicks over the matter. The media houses must not entertain or indulge in such gimmicks which is bad for all.

@striker44

10 ай бұрын

Many premier universities in the US are not considering SAT scores anymore. Also, one cannot directly go into a medical school directly from high school. Standardized tests have created a massive coaching center business. Even China, Korea, Singapore, Japan are all looking for alternatives. Education of the future is evolving with AI and online resources. This is the time for India to revolutionalize the education system than adopting old systems. TN is far advanced to many other states in innovative progressive ideas. State autonomy is important like in the US, where law, medical etc.. professionals are certified at state levels. Having said the above, politician run colleges and universities should be shut down. Pay for quota seat should be shut down ( though such practice is there in private universities like Harvard, USC, Stanford and such).

@Kolgai

10 ай бұрын

Yes, but they also have a standardised syllabus.

@manishgoodnotes5310

10 ай бұрын

Well said

@wolfmangoland7972

10 ай бұрын

@@striker44 SAT scores are optional only for the last couple of years. SAT is optional, but students submit AP exam scores in 5-8 subjects or IB exam scores for most top universities. Furthermore, their admission process is very different. It is holistic. I don't believe India is ready for that yet.

Why only Tamil Nadu has this problem 😂 hypocrisy

@kumar.193

9 ай бұрын

Because other states never bothered about studies.

@AminaBengmu

Ай бұрын

Becoz only tamilnadu has the problem of chutiyapa​@@kumar.193

@samudragupta047

3 күн бұрын

​@@kumar.193ohhh, out of 29 only 1 bother?😂

@Kiruthi26.

2 күн бұрын

​@@kumar.193now these people are crying to ban NEET

Bro i m studying in tamil nadu no one student is against neet this is only a political agenda set by dmk .neet gives us oppurtunity to appear more than once and can improce your score which is not in case of board exam marks consideration

@khedhareeswari4700

10 ай бұрын

How many times you will write that exam to improve your score i am from Bangalore my friend wrote neet she is from cbse and wrote thrice but failed Then answer why students SUCIDE You are studying did you clear by yourself or went for Coaching

@phaseneutral3006

10 ай бұрын

poda sangi

@phaseneutral3006

10 ай бұрын

1.people need to understand, only students who can afford CBSE or coaching institutions are more than 95% who got medical seat this time 2. if only the performance during mbbs decides whether you become a doctor or not then why there is a need for NEET 3. tamil nadu ranks no1 in medical tourism which means we have better doctors and infrastructure so stop lecturing us how to select our students 4. NEET didn't eliminate anything, you still have to pay a hefty sum of money to join a medical College. if you can't afford the fee, you still wont get a seat even though you passed the exam but a student who got lower marks than you in NEET who could afford the fee will get a seat

@5RoadsSalem4

10 ай бұрын

@@phaseneutral3006poda DMK 200 Rupees sombhu

@5RoadsSalem4

10 ай бұрын

@@phaseneutral3006answer me one question. How come students from all over India ( except Tamil Nadu) has no issue with NEET. This is nothing more than a political gimmick by DMK government. Their agenda is to make money in everything and anything. Most corrupt political party in India.

“Examination is something quite different from education, but in the name of raising the standard of education, they are making the examination so impossible and so severe that the backward communities which have hitherto not had the chance of entering the portals of University are absolutely kept out.” - Babasaheb Dr. B. R. Ambedkar. (Babasaheb Dr. B. R. Ambedkar Writings & Speeches Vol. 2 Page 50).

@AnadiMishra2

10 ай бұрын

pure drama arguement..

@gajendrababu9947

10 ай бұрын

​@@AnadiMishra2Drama that started in the days of Ekalavya and Karnan continues till date.

@AmalTan

10 ай бұрын

True but how to select who gets those limited seats for education. NEET is tough because there are too few medical seats. Although there is 100% increase in medical seats in last 10 yrs but more increase is needed. NEET is not the issue paucity of medical seats is.

@unusualbug1113

10 ай бұрын

@@gajendrababu9947 god, you bhimtas are so obsessed with Hinduism, The story of Ekalavya is not what you think it is. India is a hindu nation whether you like it or not.

@gajendrababu9947

10 ай бұрын

NEET is just a market gamble. Allow the children to study their lessons. Based on Board exams admit them in College. That is the only stress free option. Competition for fewer seats will always be there. There is no use torturing students.

There are entrance exams to all undergraduate programs in India. Why only single out medical? Entrance exam may not be the perfect way to select but certainly better than all others.

@piranha3037

10 ай бұрын

1. NEET gives us the opportunity to become a doctor based on merit. In the past only rich people with crores of money would get the seats. At least, it has given a level playing field based on merit. 2. Is NEET coaching costly? Not really. Online Coaching Centres like PW are providing yearlong coaching with Rs 3500 to 4500 range. Many other good coaching centres are following the suit. 3. Are the competitions high? Yes, but what do expect for the most populous Nation on the Earth? But it at least transparent, based on merit with no hint of corrupt practices. 4. A standardized test throughout the country ensure that good meritorious students even though poor pass the exams. 5. Want to reduce the pressure? A good way to begin is to open more Medical Colleges rather than breaking a good system. Earlier, it was all about money. 6. Who are protesting? Politicians, Private College owners. 7. The Private Medical Colleges of India charge exorbitant fees more than anywhere in the world. Students prefer to go to war ravaged Ukraine but they cannot afford private medical college fees of India. Why not reduce the fees of Private Colleges? Increase more colleges, reduce the fees of Private Colleges and reduce the pressure of the candidates. Stop political gimmicks over the matter. The media houses must not entertain or indulge in such gimmicks which is bad for all.

@UjwalRam

10 ай бұрын

If there's no entrance exam they will have their own exams and then take decisions based on recommendations, referrals etc. We saw this and still seeing this. Buying the seats .

@giridharanvasu1013

10 ай бұрын

@@UjwalRam even after NEET recommendations and referrals works, please verify yourself.

Why only TN is facing problems +2course course is not tailored for medical admission it is a general course aptitude should be the criteria for admission Suicide could happen even if neet is abolished nothing to with need meritorious poor students should be given scholarship if ambedkar could become a great man caste is not a problem

@khedhareeswari4700

10 ай бұрын

I think it's not true I heard many people who are doctors are from tamilnadu this syllabus only then he can you say

Change the Thumbnail, Who said Tamilnadu is opposing, only the politicians and people who own medical colleges in TN oppose NEET, because previously they were earning crores of rupees from Management quota, but now they were not able to do so. There is no more doubt in this. End of discussion. For this Hindu channel has released nearly 10 min video, waste of time. Put your time in creating useful resources.

@piranha3037

10 ай бұрын

1. NEET gives us the opportunity to become a doctor based on merit. In the past only rich people with crores of money would get the seats. At least, it has given a level playing field based on merit. 2. Is NEET coaching costly? Not really. Online Coaching Centres like PW are providing yearlong coaching with Rs 3500 to 4500 range. Many other good coaching centres are following the suit. 3. Are the competitions high? Yes, but what do expect for the most populous Nation on the Earth? But it at least transparent, based on merit with no hint of corrupt practices. 4. A standardized test throughout the country ensure that good meritorious students even though poor pass the exams. 5. Want to reduce the pressure? A good way to begin is to open more Medical Colleges rather than breaking a good system. Earlier, it was all about money. 6. Who are protesting? Politicians, Private College owners. 7. The Private Medical Colleges of India charge exorbitant fees more than anywhere in the world. Students prefer to go to war ravaged Ukraine but they cannot afford private medical college fees of India. Why not reduce the fees of Private Colleges? Increase more colleges, reduce the fees of Private Colleges and reduce the pressure of the candidates. Stop political gimmicks over the matter. The media houses must not entertain or indulge in such gimmicks which is bad for all.

@Kolgai

10 ай бұрын

Lol, the management quota has upped its fees under NEET. Now candidates without NEET pay 1.5-2 x what candidates who've passed NEET pay.

@UjwalRam

10 ай бұрын

​@@Kolgaithat's why the management has to be dealt with not remove the exam.

@UjwalRam

10 ай бұрын

​@@piranha3037well put. And this is the same situation with engineering exams as well not just medical .

@Kolgai

10 ай бұрын

@@UjwalRam The exam increases the fees for average parents which many can’t afford. TN state board topper came from poor background and had to choose accounting rather than medicine this year. Bring strong laws against management quota, Tamil people will support. What’s this added exam for?

very well explained

Is it correct to consider this sad suicide /s are the only cases that have happened for the first time ever due to tough course. Is it that earlier in the past thers were none for identical reasons of ghose times ? Is it not necessary toook at these statistically and their relation to causes . What were the counsellera doing in helping the sad victims . Why thousands of kids are doing well

How NEET ensures quality doctors ? This has to be established first instead of implementing NEET right away. Proper research should from the socialogical point of view. We also need answers with large amount of evidences on why NEET is required in the first place.

It is not advisable to study medicine because in another 10 years atleast one doctor will be in everystreet.you cant earn equal to a petishop owner unless you are prepared to go abroad.

We want neet only. don't remove neet because of your political games and bright students will love neet mad students will against neet

👏

Have some Domicile quota.

I hope, the Hindu will completely stop accepting ads about RANKS. To me, that is more hurtful than any exam. No country does those 🙄

Education is on the concurrent list so central law will override the state law. Thus centre is well within its right on NEET, argument of infringement of state autonomy is invalid.

@piranha3037

10 ай бұрын

1. NEET gives us the opportunity to become a doctor based on merit. In the past only rich people with crores of money would get the seats. At least, it has given a level playing field based on merit. 2. Is NEET coaching costly? Not really. Online Coaching Centres like PW are providing yearlong coaching with Rs 3500 to 4500 range. Many other good coaching centres are following the suit. 3. Are the competitions high? Yes, but what do expect for the most populous Nation on the Earth? But it at least transparent, based on merit with no hint of corrupt practices. 4. A standardized test throughout the country ensure that good meritorious students even though poor pass the exams. 5. Want to reduce the pressure? A good way to begin is to open more Medical Colleges rather than breaking a good system. Earlier, it was all about money. 6. Who are protesting? Politicians, Private College owners. 7. The Private Medical Colleges of India charge exorbitant fees more than anywhere in the world. Students prefer to go to war ravaged Ukraine but they cannot afford private medical college fees of India. Why not reduce the fees of Private Colleges? Increase more colleges, reduce the fees of Private Colleges and reduce the pressure of the candidates. Stop political gimmicks over the matter. The media houses must not entertain or indulge in such gimmicks which is bad for all.

@Kolgai

10 ай бұрын

No. Centre and state are co-equals in matters under the concurrent list. This is how TN has a 69% reservation whereas the national nominal limit was 50%.

@AmalTan

10 ай бұрын

@@Kolgai That is factually incorrect. On a concurrent list issues central law always overrides state law. What TN is asking is an exception from NEET, which centre can give if it wishes.

@Kolgai

10 ай бұрын

@@AmalTan Technically untrue. The President can give assent to any law, state or central. It so happens that the President acts on the recommendations of the union cabinet, which usually means that whatever government is in the union gets its way. In law, however, state and centre are co-equals in the exercise of their own legislative and executive competence in respect to their positions on the lists. Of course, the whole thing would be moot if the Congress gets rid of these incompetent imbeciles at the union.

@AmalTan

10 ай бұрын

@@Kolgai Yes only way to get this done is having a govt in Delhi which gives such an "exception" to TN. But my point is that not giving such an "exception" does not amount to infringement of state autonomy.

Why can't they provide free coaching to poor students ?

What about then of CUET? What TN say?

Rightly so..... South Indians are the most intelligent people

Suicide is a resilience issue as well. Why can’t it be One Nation and One Board. Already too much nonsensical autonomy has been granted to TN, if anything it should be curtailed. The more I read about TN And DMK history more I feel it needs to be integrated to rest of India to prevent self harm.

@karanraj97

9 ай бұрын

That's why TN is more developed

@AminaBengmu

Ай бұрын

​@karanraj97that's why tamilnadu is so much unsecure in his thoughts

One nation one exam

These politicians want to destroy the merit system 😠. Full support to NEET as a parents of NEET aspirant, I am saying this

@subbaraotanguturu9271

10 ай бұрын

Why other states not objecting NEET!? It is due to politics only. Which issue it not made political any way!?

@Kolgai

10 ай бұрын

How much did you pay for coaching?

Please talk about the content of curriculum for NEET and it's matching with the minimum eligibility of the student to take up. medical education. You are harping painfully on the polical sensitivity of the upgradation of content Shouldn't there be a limit to politics and growth in quality . Is medical education the only route to making bucks Sad people resist genuine progress

Tamil Nadu is not against NEET. The Tamil Politicians are against NEET bcoz they've lost the 50% management quota in their own private medical colleges

@muruganr4517

10 ай бұрын

Tamil nadu is against Neet

@balakumaran1

10 ай бұрын

@@muruganr4517 You can't pass. avlo thaan. That doesn't mean others cant

@muruganr4517

10 ай бұрын

@@balakumaran1 talk with sense , people coming from family struggling for everyday life with ambition to become doctor not able to study NEET syllabus. Any one can pass this exam all they need is situation to concentrate only on study and some money for coaching. India is not in that situation yet. And let's see the people getting out will serve in rural area i bet they will flee for foreign for sure

@balakumaran1

10 ай бұрын

@@muruganr4517 whose fault is that? why is the Tamil Nadu State syllabus not upto the mark? When students from other state boards are clearing the exam, why not students from TN government schools?

@muruganr4517

10 ай бұрын

@@balakumaran1 other state people , politician never cared about how MBBS admission was before and we knew it, no state syllabus is as difficult as CBSE . 'Upto mark' ? Those came from state board before NEET became doctor , they might be one you visited . What difference NEET did, if state board student can study MBBS why this objection NEET in between to join NEET? You hate particular politicians no problem, this issue is different

India has examination system not education, they both are different yes😮

Don't spread propanganda.. I myself have given NEET exam. All questions do come from NCERT only. Even if, you think coaching needed, Tamil Nadu government should provide FREE coaching to all Tamil students. Student who committed suicide scored 400 out of 720. It was enough score to get admission in other medical courses like BHMS , BAMS etc. What alternative you might suggest, of NEET, direct admission based on 12th marks!! Then students who score less in 12th will commit suicide, thinking that they would not be able to get medical seat. You must open More MBBS colleges & reduce Fees of Private college by coming with a bill, instead of just trying to politicise the things, trying to abolish NEET

@piranha3037

10 ай бұрын

1. NEET gives us the opportunity to become a doctor based on merit. In the past only rich people with crores of money would get the seats. At least, it has given a level playing field based on merit. 2. Is NEET coaching costly? Not really. Online Coaching Centres like PW are providing yearlong coaching with Rs 3500 to 4500 range. Many other good coaching centres are following the suit. 3. Are the competitions high? Yes, but what do expect for the most populous Nation on the Earth? But it at least transparent, based on merit with no hint of corrupt practices. 4. A standardized test throughout the country ensure that good meritorious students even though poor pass the exams. 5. Want to reduce the pressure? A good way to begin is to open more Medical Colleges rather than breaking a good system. Earlier, it was all about money. 6. Who are protesting? Politicians, Private College owners. 7. The Private Medical Colleges of India charge exorbitant fees more than anywhere in the world. Students prefer to go to war ravaged Ukraine but they cannot afford private medical college fees of India. Why not reduce the fees of Private Colleges? Increase more colleges, reduce the fees of Private Colleges and reduce the pressure of the candidates. Stop political gimmicks over the matter. The media houses must not entertain or indulge in such gimmicks which is bad for all.

@subbaraotanguturu9271

10 ай бұрын

Rural students should get seperate coaching to increase their merit not to be accommodated with lower marks simply because they hail from rural areas. In these days of on line coaching is possible it's not impossible to teach rural students on line also. Bijjus like government or private platform should be used for it.

@AnadiMishra2

10 ай бұрын

@@piranha3037 Exactly.. Your points prove that Tamil Nadu government is just doing politics & The Hindu is biased

Educational infrastructure is built by the individual states and hence should be under the state domain. Let the Center control only Central institutions like IIT. AIMS.

@nareshshingote8081

10 ай бұрын

Who gonna issue medical licence then

Common entrance exam should be normalized as it asserts uniformity of syllabus....and select few of the bestest minds....but dealing with coaching mafias should be under gov policies as they charge excessive high

@UjwalRam

10 ай бұрын

You are right, the coaching mafias , emotional stability of kids should be addressed . No point in removing whichever competitive exam gets difficult for us

what were you doing when IIT mains, JEE etc were introduced ?

@kumar.193

9 ай бұрын

ITT JEE is not an eligibility test for the reputed colleges in Tamil Nadu. Its only for IITs, unlike NEET which is for all Medical colleges. With this sort of knowledge about reality people want talk as if they are experts. Sad state of India.

@Intusr

9 ай бұрын

so be it. you need to filter mass and find the best right ?

Please make your comments section off. Some it wing groups are filling in this comment section. Please say no to neet.

I think u have to learn that not to cheat!!!

@piranha3037

10 ай бұрын

1. NEET gives us the opportunity to become a doctor based on merit. In the past only rich people with crores of money would get the seats. At least, it has given a level playing field based on merit. 2. Is NEET coaching costly? Not really. Online Coaching Centres like PW are providing yearlong coaching with Rs 3500 to 4500 range. Many other good coaching centres are following the suit. 3. Are the competitions high? Yes, but what do expect for the most populous Nation on the Earth? But it at least transparent, based on merit with no hint of corrupt practices. 4. A standardized test throughout the country ensure that good meritorious students even though poor pass the exams. 5. Want to reduce the pressure? A good way to begin is to open more Medical Colleges rather than breaking a good system. Earlier, it was all about money. 6. Who are protesting? Politicians, Private College owners. 7. The Private Medical Colleges of India charge exorbitant fees more than anywhere in the world. Students prefer to go to war ravaged Ukraine but they cannot afford private medical college fees of India. Why not reduce the fees of Private Colleges? Increase more colleges, reduce the fees of Private Colleges and reduce the pressure of the candidates. Stop political gimmicks over the matter. The media houses must not entertain or indulge in such gimmicks which is bad for all.

I think this is a call to change societal pressure on children. I believe so many of the students who didn't pass committed suicide because over the course of their lives they were led to believe that their scores and their career in medicine defined them, and that without them they were nothing. We tend put too much pressure on and demand too much of our kids for them to grow up living healthy lives, and so they end up desperately pursuing the careers we want them to so they can fulfill our own desires, and if they are unable to do it they might just end it all

Very sensible assessment. Age appropriate syllabus is the norm in school education around the globe. Lesson Plan, Pedagogy and evaluation are part of the syllabus. Once a student is assessed and found to have achieved the needed skill for that age, naturally they can do what is possible in the upper age too and that is the basis on which the student is allowed to proceed further. Once a student could do what she or he is supposed to do for that age, surely they will perform what is expected of them in their next stage also. An eligibility test after the evaluation by the board which drafted the syllabus, is only to benefit the market and it has nothing to do with improving the quality of Education. Presentation by Mr. D. Suresh Kumar in this video is placing the fact as fact, allowing the listeners to further disseminate. Thank you The Hindu for opening this dialogue. Regards.

There are limited number of seats in National level and students are getting so much depressed whn they lose... Tamil Nadu s stand is right👍🏻👍🏻

Don't mislead, say why DMK is opposing the NEET😠

Now DMK people will scream "Centre is trying to impose H!nd! On us" Lol what 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣

@piranha3037

10 ай бұрын

1. NEET gives us the opportunity to become a doctor based on merit. In the past only rich people with crores of money would get the seats. At least, it has given a level playing field based on merit. 2. Is NEET coaching costly? Not really. Online Coaching Centres like PW are providing yearlong coaching with Rs 3500 to 4500 range. Many other good coaching centres are following the suit. 3. Are the competitions high? Yes, but what do expect for the most populous Nation on the Earth? But it at least transparent, based on merit with no hint of corrupt practices. 4. A standardized test throughout the country ensure that good meritorious students even though poor pass the exams. 5. Want to reduce the pressure? A good way to begin is to open more Medical Colleges rather than breaking a good system. Earlier, it was all about money. 6. Who are protesting? Politicians, Private College owners. 7. The Private Medical Colleges of India charge exorbitant fees more than anywhere in the world. Students prefer to go to war ravaged Ukraine but they cannot afford private medical college fees of India. Why not reduce the fees of Private Colleges? Increase more colleges, reduce the fees of Private Colleges and reduce the pressure of the candidates. Stop political gimmicks over the matter. The media houses must not entertain or indulge in such gimmicks which is bad for all.

Tamilnadu, Maharashtra, Bihar,West Bengal and Punjab. Along with J&K... these states always oppose policies made by Delhi. And the Hindu newspaper always gives support to these Anti centre activities

@Sudeep.Manerkar

10 ай бұрын

Maharashtra lol we don't

don't give all this nonsense imporve education system we already have under employment issue due to lack of skill and it is not just neet aspirance who commit sucide so don't make politics from this insted try to find ways to reduce it ,why is it only tn ask for a exception? stop making all this nonsence about hind,neet and let students get educated if tamily will get destroyed by learning hindi wht did you allow english? we need a common language and common education system try fighting for that insted of trying to get vote from students death

The only reason he gives is the imposition on TN. According to him and TN the reason for objection is imposition from Indian Govt. Medical is not a normal graduation degree like BA, BCOM, BBA etc that it does not require a formal mastery of it's core subjects like above mentioned normal degrees. The knowledge of subjects is tested via enterance exam. Questions specifically designed to test subject knowledge, learned from non-learned. They do not understand the concept of professional education and want to judge everything on the basis of 12th marks. There is a difference between general degree and professional degree. I am talking about DMKs mouthpiece TheHindu. They seem to be pandit on everything and criticise India Govt on everything but can't seem to differentiate professional degree from general degree. That poor girl has became their opportunity to pass their ideologics. They are covering themselves behind the veil i.e the poor girl. She was of expectation that her 12th marks was sufficient to enter medical college. This idea sowed in her by her state's political parties, the parties that is opposing every idea by terming them impositions. The tragedy of her and her family is because of a few people that is the political parties and TheHindu. I would also like to dare to think that she maybe had been apporached by DMKs for petition filing. TheHindu should not be anyones mouthpiece.

Karnataka should follow same

1.people need to understand, only students who can afford CBSE or coaching institutions are more than 95% who got medical seat this time 2. if only the performance during mbbs decides whether you become a doctor or not then why there is a need for NEET 3. tamil nadu ranks no1 in medical tourism which means we have better doctors and infrastructure so stop lecturing us how to select our students 4. NEET didn't eliminate anything, you still have to pay a hefty sum of money to join a medical College. if you can't afford the fee, you still wont get a seat even though you passed the exam but a student who got lower marks than you in NEET who could afford the fee will get a seat

My friends son who is below average student failed in neet in first attempt and got 130 marks in 2nd attempt and once he got the elgibilty mark they went on to pay 1.25 crores in NRI quota to get admission in a private college in chennai... all rich people kids need is a bare minimum mark in NEET 120 to 150 to get admission into private colleges, while poor kids and govt school kids who are scoring 300 to 400 marks are not getting govt colleges.... how can this NEET be fair, only spoiled rich kids who cant even pass in 12th and NEET are getting admission into medical colleges... while govt school student who score 95 % in 12th are not able to get into medical colleges who otherwise without entrance exam wouldve got into MMC and stanley.... NEET is for rich people and Forward community to make them doctors...

@AnadiMishra2

10 ай бұрын

without NEET, Rich people were buying seats in crores. Due to NEET, these numbers came down & poor students are also getting admission

@Kolgai

10 ай бұрын

Exactly, all NEET has done is make a two-tier system for management quotas and highly inflated the existing fee structures. My cousin (BC NRI), failed NEET, paid 1.5 crore capitation and 30 lacs per annum for a medical seat. With NEET pass mark, for management quota, the quoted capitation fees was 75 lacs, and annual fees was 20 lacs. Ultimately, the losers are the diligent poor children who can't afford coaching or capitation fees. (Btw, I oppose NEET)

@snat85

10 ай бұрын

@AnadiMishra2 do you have the statistics?.... Before and after NEET rich kids are getting in as usual, but before NEET in tamilnadu more than 100 govt school and govt aided school students used to get admitted in goverment medical colleges each year, do you know the count now... only about 5 to 10 govt school students are joining medical college each year since 2017.... a govt school student and rural student who gets 95 to 98 % in 12th standard used to get into top medical colleges before 2017 when there was no entrance exams, now they cant secure more than 300 in neet and they get only private colleges, how will they pay the fees?... rich kids can pay for coaching classes how will the poor kids pay for coaching class.... and for your information, tamilnadu has highest medical colleges in india and we have been producing best doctors through goverment colleges even without an entrance exams....

@AmalTan

10 ай бұрын

@@snat85 that was before 7.5% horizontal quota was applied for govt school students.