HW is doing great work...This is the only news channel addressing the south part of the country...

@Dr.GOWTHAM_EM

2 жыл бұрын

True and it’s genuine

@baskarpattabhiraman8364

2 жыл бұрын

Simple solution - convert change all Medical colleges into Govt controlled ones and cancel NEET which I am sure Center will agree - this anti neet agitation will stop from public side

A qualification exam similar to IAS or IPS should be made compulsory for contesting for MLAs or MP

@aqal5333

2 жыл бұрын

S. Gopal If implemented nearly 50% would fail as they are uneducated including modi.

@Yajna007

2 жыл бұрын

And, a Chapter on Biological Evolution must be compulsory along with some amount of Geology.

@Yajna007

2 жыл бұрын

Taxonomy. Taxonomic classification.

@Yajna007

2 жыл бұрын

Divergent evolution.

@Yajna007

2 жыл бұрын

Stratigraphy. Chronostratigraphy.

In order to clear the NEET exam. not only a student has lost 4 to 5 years but also a lot of money is expended for coaching as well as at the time of admission to private colleges.

@venkat-il5ji

2 жыл бұрын

Thx for brining other aspects of problems/issues associate with NEET.. Most of People r not talking about it, everyone says "Merit" is only established from NEET, as if all other state govt exams r waste/garbage...Fudamendally it's designed to help students from metros/major cities/affluent families/economically well off/doctor kids/generations of graduate families, who can afford the money/exposure/time to crack within 1-2 attempts by preparing for 3-5 years from their 8th/9th standard onwards...I think that's the hardest reality happening in JEE for joining IITs/IISc...

@jibankumarkonsam1819

2 жыл бұрын

@@venkat-il5ji 100%right

@nermaipaathai8867

2 жыл бұрын

Private "coaching" college loot and pickpockets and they are again Aryan dominated.

@teumetreasure8632

2 жыл бұрын

@@venkat-il5ji a student can repeat neet but can a student repeat 12th??

@teumetreasure8632

2 жыл бұрын

@@venkat-il5ji if state board is so good then why didn't mk stalin send his children to tamil medium school, why did he send then to private schools?? The government is playing politics you dumb people

In my opinion let there be neet ONLY for Union governments Universities like AIIMS, JIPMER etc.. This is what happens in engineering also, JEE and JEE ADV are for IITs and NITs, students who wish to study in these colleges will write these exams, students who are satisfied with TN colleges will go by their 12th grade cutoff. Let State government decide by what means they would select students.

@ichu1733

Жыл бұрын

Dude... Ur opinion is highly considerable👍🏿

People who are supporting NEET must understand Tamil Nadu is not UP It has its own medical infrastructure.and pioneer of medical education

@TheKrish1972

2 жыл бұрын

Correct if UP people are not opposing who are more backward. What is your problem ? Btw, TN students have started in excelling in NEET as well. Have something called national interest in mind instead if jumping Tamil Tamil for everything! TN is part of India not the other way round

@frogierally6303

2 жыл бұрын

All states except TN are taking part in Neet and get trained up.

@HemanthKumarismyname

2 жыл бұрын

It's simple up is still struggling in Hindi with 40 percent pass percentage entirely and how come they'll have interest in medical science

@coolcheeka

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheKrish1972 Go and see what UP, Bihar and Rajastan people do in competitive exams? Copying to the core. People from Haryana getting full marks in Tamil for postal jobs. When people are doing all these illegal things, how can you expect the exam to be equal for all.

@sureshkumar-qw9ny

2 жыл бұрын

@@krishnarajagopalan528 If the purpose of NEET is to extract qualified minds then it is absolutely necessary that there be a argument to find out which state had better infrastructure including medical collages and no of qualified doctors. It would indicate a tried and true method which worked in said state and thus could be implemented in other states. With NEET it not only doesn't follows TN's method, a state which has leading no. of qualified doctors and medical collages, it out right ignores how we conduct ourself w.r to recruitment of medical students. *So why is a structure which goes against everything a successful state like TN stand would be considered optimal for extracting qualified minds in medical field?.*

During the British regime, passing Sanskrit examination was mandatory for getting into Medical college. Of course, only the privileged could learn Sanskrit. It was the Justice Party that did away with the requirement. Hence NEET is an emotional issue in Tamilnadu.

@MrJvasud

2 жыл бұрын

What do y ou mean

@nermaipaathai8867

2 жыл бұрын

Aryans influenced and apple polished the "Angrez" and through other means which cannot be written here and so they made a dead language Sanskrit compulsory.

@eniyathendral2728

2 жыл бұрын

Well said bro. It was ridiculous to keep Sanskrit as mandatory for MBBS, similarly NEET exam is ridiculous. Their idea is to push CBSE syllabus to all schools and steal our kids to central syllabus so that they can cook up their own history and inject to the kids heads. Education should belong to every state. Like how the IIT students are flying abroad, these NEET students will never serve the rural India and most of them will fly abroad

@mkrishnaraj1

2 жыл бұрын

@@MrJvasud Yes, that's what happened during that time.

@mkrishnaraj1

2 жыл бұрын

Andru Theetu, Indru NEETu. Always find some ways to oppress the people.

I praise HW news for such an excellent interview.

@Yajna007

2 жыл бұрын

I second that.

@jibankumarkonsam1819

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks hw news.

@sdias07

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed 100%

@venkat-il5ji

2 жыл бұрын

HW news brought the person from TN states to express their views..Badly "The Print" without any panelist from TN, discussing the "NEET" issue....

@cpselvam1

2 жыл бұрын

@@venkat-il5ji This not Print. HW news. By the way he is a retired Judge Commissioned to find out the drawbacks of NEET to Tamilnadu students. He has taken feedback from almost 85000 people from Tamilnadu about NEET and he is discussing about the findings of the feedback he received from those people. Please understand he is not an ordinary person and he talks with data not like Modi speaks in "man ki baat".

Remove NEET 👍 Healthy competition is good , but not the one due to which children are pressurized.

@theevil8844

2 жыл бұрын

End kota culture

@venkat-il5ji

2 жыл бұрын

Thx for brining other aspects of problems/issues associate with NEET.. Most of People are not talking about it, evenone say "Merit" is established from NEET, as if all other state govt exams r waste/garbage...Fudamendally it's designed to help students from metros/major cities/affluent families/economically well off/doctor kids/generations of graduate families, who can afford the money/exposure/time to crack within 1-2 attempts by preparing for 3-5 years from their 8th/9th standard onwards...I think that's the hardest reality happening in JEE for joining IITs/IISc...

Thank you for this eye opening interview. Every state must be united with TN for the future of our young aspirants of India.

@DR_68

2 жыл бұрын

You to worry that churches are not allowed to loot

@k.v.22-61

2 жыл бұрын

You are absolutely right. Every major States of India should oppose NEET which serves only the coaching industry. Further, it is more important to oppose NEP to ensure our right to education.

@mkrishnaraj1

2 жыл бұрын

@@DR_68 Idiot. How is church related to this topic?

@eniyathendral2728

2 жыл бұрын

brother, these Bhakts always bring irrelevant point to valid discussion.. They don't have point to argue, most of the time they do person attack by looking at the commented person name. Ignore him.

@Mean_men

2 жыл бұрын

@@DR_68 keep ur religion stuff with urself and shut up

Ban Neet - education it’s state power - central should not play any role

@TheKrish1972

2 жыл бұрын

Tomorrow you will say BAN iAS IPS etc etc. Hahahaha

@GM_-

2 жыл бұрын

They're simply brown colonials, long past their use by date. The entire administrative structure needs to be rebuilt from the ground up.

@lioness5838

2 жыл бұрын

Lol. Yes. Another colony China is coming to enslave u.

@praba3402

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheKrish1972 29 medicine related colleges and universities which are funded by our state government's tax are well and there for our people. People from other states can come and study in TN board and get a medical seat .Why would we want a Shah or a Modi to decide that for us?

@mkrishnaraj1

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheKrish1972 IAS and IPS are left over by our colonial masters to educate the British about India. There should be a different way of selecting talents to administer us. It's been proven well that in this 75 years India with so much talent and resources is still a third world country. The politicians come and go, but not these officers who make the policies. No other country in the world has these kind of Civil services exams. It's good to get rid of them.

States are not slaves to the Union Government. Diversity and Federal structure should be respected. People of all states should realise this and speak out for their rights.

Just like the JEE is administered, the NEET can be used for medical institution run by the union govt. let the state govt decides what they need to do for the state govt run institution. let the ego not play a role here and allow every state to formulate their own course.

@pikaase

2 жыл бұрын

I agree, this should be the way forward. Union government first have to understand that not all states are same with respect to the vision, policies and priorities. When COVID cases were at peak, the argument was made by the ruling party at centre that medical is a state subject. It’s all the doctors selected during pre neet days who were running the show through various state government run hospitals in controlling the pandemic excepts very few union government run hospitals like AIIMS

@priyanatraj5634

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly

@sdias07

2 жыл бұрын

True

@venkat-il5ji

2 жыл бұрын

​@@pikaase Luv u bro...Valid points...TN govt's Basic questions/demands r, not at all understood by people from other part of India...From 2008 to 2017, with +2 exams TN could able to produce wonderful doctors...Even prior also (from 1984 to 2007), with the weightage of 2:1 of +2marks:TN Entrance test, we could able to produce fantastic medical professional from TN govt/private colleges...All of u sudden, propaganda was made that only through "NEET" u can gauge "Merit", all other matrix r void...V had produced doctors for more than 25 years from "State board" syllabus, is it all of them r substandard ???...Why some one qualify from AIIMS will be considered as qualified Doctors, they r exceptionally superb, I don't deny it....What country needs s not "Elite/Elitness", v requires moderate to high skiled doctors to take care of the medical needs of the country throughout in every nook and corner...Moreover no of affordable/govt medical colleges/seats r very less compare to our aspirng studetns as well from our country's population.....Unhealthy competition are created to get medical admission, TN only have 5200 Govt medical seats which s fought by minium of 2 Lakh students... Let's do one simple assumptions.....Every year ~ 8 lakhs students writes +2 exams, let's assume only 50% student study science group, it comes to 4 Lakhs, Out of that only 50% aims for MBBS course means, it becames 2 lakhs..let's assume only 10% of the students r well qualified/top brain considering their hardwork/ability/knowledge/skills, it comes to 20000 students......So overall, TN Students are under relentless psychological pressures, stress to compete/prepare/write in Medical courses like MBBS/BDS and so on....Considering aspiration of students & demands for Doctors in the society, Surely TN Can create qualified doctors of 4 times of than their Medical seats...Due to non availability of seats, people r study other medical courses like B.Pharm, BDS, Siddha, Yunani, Vetnairy, Agriculture, Physiotheraphy and so on....Hope the scenario is similiar in all other states....Let's create the medical colleges based on our population and medical infrastructure/health care requirements...Otherwise simply people r wasting their energy/potential/money/time like preparing for 2-3 years for NEET, which is any way lead to unhealthy & inequality..

@masthan001

2 жыл бұрын

right that!

NEET is against social justice which is unique for TN. 85% of the medical seats in any state is reserved for students from that state. 15% goes to All India quota. We are just fighting against NEET to be the eligibility criteria for selecting the 85% of TN students. We are not against the 15% quota reserved for students from all india quota. Even if TN gets exemption from NEET, the number of seats available for non TN students, is not going to decrease. What we are saying is- NEET favours rich urban students and eliminates rural poor students (potential doctors), who will be the backbone of the rural PHCs in TN.

@priyanatraj5634

2 жыл бұрын

True

@bindudevasia7140

2 жыл бұрын

Well explained

@everhigher8040

2 жыл бұрын

@@krishnarajagopalan528 You are making a fair point. But, this issue is something which needs wider discussion.TN carved out its own pathway in determining the health care needs of the people, creating infrastructure like PHCs, medical colleges, district hospitals etc. Trust me, the quality of our hospitals and medical colleges are much better. Now, we have the best doctor patient ratio in the country. 1 doctor for 250 people, which is equivalent to scandinavian countries. Now, we have to keep improving the QUALITY of the infrastructure, not the quantity. There are other states that need more doctors because they have pathetic doctor patient rato. They would benefit from NEET as per your logic, which is true. Also, poor students would be better off studying closer to their homes because of the expenses involved and the benefits they get from TN government rather than going to other states for studying. But, my argument is that NEET favours the rich and is against social justice.

@jespersheeba3759

2 жыл бұрын

@@krishnarajagopalan528 why can't central give free coaching if they are conducting the exam. What you are saying is central should conduct exam and state should bear expenses for coaching... Well done wonderful justice 👏👏

@jespersheeba3759

2 жыл бұрын

@@krishnarajagopalan528 can you elaborate your opinion... What are you trying to say..!?

During my time, we used to have entrance exams for engineering and medical seats. For the admission they will consider the 12th grade marks and the exam marks. I believe it was for 250 marks - 200 from the 12th grade and 50 from the entrance exam. Since the entrance exams are from state board syllabus and also it gives more weightage to 12th grade marks, I think it was fair to to have those exams. Still we cannot crack the entrance exams without going through the coaching classes, which is disadvantage to the rural kids.

@saty85

2 жыл бұрын

But to some extent the coaching class fees was affordable at that time. But now the situation is totally different.

@mkrishnaraj1

2 жыл бұрын

@@saty85 I agree with you. The coaching classes were affordable during my time. I don't live in India. So don't know the cost now. I feel generally everything is expensive in India.

State run medical college's seats shall be filled based on state government rules only except few all India quota...let the central government fill-in seats in those central government run institutions (such as AIIMS, Madurai)...why put ur nose in the rights of TN..

@chandranchandran9159

2 жыл бұрын

There is no AIIMS in Madurai (foundation stone is there off course!)

@prathapsing

2 жыл бұрын

@@chandranchandran9159 yes..I know bro

@chandranchandran9159

2 жыл бұрын

@@krishnarajagopalan528 yes, it tells, giving up hindi as a compulsory subject is not considered, for that was the reason for opposing navodaya in TN. it is a great concept if only the language policy was kept flexible to the people's will.

@chandranchandran9159

2 жыл бұрын

@@krishnarajagopalan528 that's what I said. it is very good concept but enough mind was not applied to implement in TN also with flexibility suiting to the people will. The center wanted to implement bluntly, and the state opposed bluntly. people are losers either way..........

@chandranchandran9159

2 жыл бұрын

@@krishnarajagopalan528 I spoke my heart. people are the losers. both the center and state didn't take enough effort to implement in TN. I say the same again.

All private coaching centres preparing students for NEET should be banned. Any middle class family can not pay such a huge fee as collected by these coaching centres.

@RakhiDhavale

2 жыл бұрын

Correct 👍 looting students and families

@TheKrish1972

2 жыл бұрын

Then ask JEE UPSC IAS and all there other courses also to stop coaching. Why can't you ask #Mundakalapastalin to conduct free Coaching from his own pocket for students who are poor. AarivuAlayam has a lot of space and DMK has a lot of looted wealth !!

@kiranjosepr6398

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheKrish1972 JEE and all other entrance exams are only for that specific institutions, whereas NEET is mandatory to study medical at all… know the differences before you put up an argument. Do you think india has equal educational opportunity to everyone ? Then how can you deny medical education to rural an urban poor students who cannot afford coaching classes ? Only those students are serving in Govt hospitals and primary health centers. All this coaching factory made doctors will not care about the society, they will only make money.

@mkrishnaraj1

2 жыл бұрын

@@kiranjosepr6398 Even in US, there are no equal educational opportunities. But the Universities will make sure they bring in people from diverse background - rural/urban, different races, etc.

@kiranjosepr6398

2 жыл бұрын

@@mkrishnaraj1 is that the case in India ? The US and other European counties have more social equality than India, we can’t compare india with the west as of now. Right now our concern should be bringing up the poor and needy to create an equal society. NEET shall be implemented in India but this is not the time.

The NEET is brought to filter the poor. In early 90s, Tamilnadu students faced the same situation where we have entrance exam coaching centers in nook and corners of the cities and towns having advertisements of cracking medical and engineering entrance exams. Later it was found only who had money/from cities went for entrance exams coaching and who are not affordable just went and attended the entrance exams without coaching center classes. Then It was like (M/2+(P+C)/2+ entrance exam marks)/300 formula is used to get cut of mark which is some what acceptable where the entrance exam marks are objective type question paper of same syllabus of TN government 12th standard books. But now the scenario is different. What earlier Medical students have to do and post NEET it is changing the social health system and the PHC system under TN government is becoming unstable. In earlier system medical students-graduated in TN medical colleges belongs to the state and neighboring states(quota), who have to compulsorily serve the TN government PHCs in villages for 2 years to get admission in Medical PG courses. So there is no shortage of doctors in PHCs in Tamilnadu. After implementation of NEET the first batch came out 2019 and it was found almost 60% of doctors never joined the PHCs for service, since they all are from upper middle and elite class who went for higher education abroad. From now onwards TN government PHCs which is having shortage of trainee doctors who can assist the government doctors. also NEET the students have to study different set of books other than 12th standard as well. TN government is one of the few state where the Medical system has saved the people from Corona pandemic.

@bindudevasia7140

2 жыл бұрын

This is so sad, but true

@grthilak

2 жыл бұрын

Well said

@sankar7847

2 жыл бұрын

How injustice to expect a student from rural background to return to a village. I am from rural parts of tamilnadu. If i need to go back to rural areas, improve the infrastructure, the hospital facilities etc.. any rural or metropolitan doctor will come and work. Neet is not a tool for addressing these issues.

Very knowledgeable interview. Mr Justice has explained very well.

@gtalk2k

2 жыл бұрын

Oh! That's News! What did he explain ? He only explained his perspective from the legal way any act is passed. NEET should be discussed on the basis of doing Justice to Education. Again half baked

Govt which is really interested in the development of poor and socially backwards wouldn't allow NEET. What for +2 , .. test tube baby cannot be compulsory one..

Tamilnadu bravo…. Let the politician sit for exam to enter politics…

Thank you Rajan Sir and HW news

Neet was introduced by which Govt at first place?

There should be a NEET exam to become a politician and it should be conducted by an international body. Do you thing except for few, none of the current politicians will survive. Should start with our PM

@theevil8844

2 жыл бұрын

modi amitshah yogi will get negative mars

@Subzero09

2 жыл бұрын

And the PMs and CMs should score 90%

@elizabethsundaram2822

2 жыл бұрын

Our pm will be start answering the difficult question first and he will be there till the end of time

@chandranchandran9159

2 жыл бұрын

@@elizabethsundaram2822 :) !!!

All South Indians and Maharashtrians must watch this channel regularly. I have informed many of my South friends living in my neighborhood in USA and of course to my Visakhapatnam friends via FB. Great work HW guys 😊👍Keep rocking.

Are there not Coaching institutes for UPSC and even State PSC exams in Tamilnadu itself? Why does not TN govt. appoint Dy.Collectors,DySPs etc based in plus two marks alone ?

@grthilak

2 жыл бұрын

🤦 you cannot appoint a DM with plus two marks. Eligibility is to have a bachelors degree and so is for all the other state PSC and UPSC. Which means they have already reached a position where they can make a decent living with their education. NEET is denying that bachelors degree itself to the underprivileged people. You don't even understand what the issue is here.

NEET was implemented with assurance that it ensures talented entry, uniform opportunity for all students from urban & rural, even poor can get. It was told that all coaching centre and poultry schools who train only +2 syllabus from +1willvanish. In tamilnadu few area schools were given example. But actually NEET made +2 study invalid and only who read NEET syllabus and for exam is enough. Entrance coaching becomes much costlier and hence rural or poor can't afford. MCI guidelines says private colleges shall fill only 50% with NEET, balance seats can be filled in management quota. Even those who got negative marks in physics and chemistry in NEET also got admission eligibility. So statement that NEET ensures talent is invalid. After introduction of NEET fees also increased, so another barricades for poor. In any way NEET doesn't helps in developing all categories of people. Also it is against social justice by blocking opportunity for all. Anyhow students have to score minimum pass mark to get MBBS degree. Which means minimum required talent is ensured there

@kirubakirubakar2554

2 жыл бұрын

Those schools too evolved into neet coaching centres

@gokulsan79

2 жыл бұрын

@@kirubakirubakar2554 pure business. V can't blame them even parents too

@jenishmaniraj.j.c7738

2 жыл бұрын

Now I came to know what is the catch here. The thing is, the way of approach for studying for Board exams and for NEET is different. Its like training your children to play guitar and forcing them to participate in a piano competition.

TN Government medical colleges were established by TN State Government for TN students. How can the Union Govt determine eligilbility or dictate terms of the students to be admitted ? No logic at all. Intrusion into State's autonomy and rights.

@srinivasanpadmavathi5578

2 жыл бұрын

Medical Institutions to open a college they should get the permission from Medical Council of India.

@augustusimmanuelpauldurait9729

2 жыл бұрын

@@srinivasanpadmavathi5578 Illogical still.

@srinivasanpadmavathi5578

2 жыл бұрын

@@augustusimmanuelpauldurait9729 Medical Education brought under concurrent list by late Prime Minister Smt.Indira Gandhi in year 1976. So there is no intrusion.

@augustusimmanuelpauldurait9729

2 жыл бұрын

@@srinivasanpadmavathi5578 Very good, but it was not taken for granted so far to intrude into State's autonomy. Only after BJP came to power cocurrent power was effectively used for intrusion.

Just Compare the number of students studying in state boards and CBSE/icse. Compare their social and economic status. Can any one scrap these boards and bring single board?. Sivakumar Bangalore

Instead creating an unfair advantage to some sections of the society, by denying Entry into Medical Education, let the IMA conduct a Common lisencing Exam to ensure standards in delivery of Medical Education in the country. They can do it once a student completes a Professional Medical Educational program, like the Bar Council does for Lawyers. Those who qualify should be lisenced to practice medicine anywhere in the Country. That would be fair to all, while ensuring standards.

@mkrishnaraj1

2 жыл бұрын

Isn't it already there for doctors after they pass their medical education?

I hope you have clearly presented views of an expert in pointing out how federal Govts all over the world are handling education to suit the needs of their States.

Had anyone got a spark on what Mr AK Rajan was explaining about the Marriage Act ?

@sankar7847

2 жыл бұрын

Unrelated like his report is. The data covers very specific detail and try to generalize to the universe. We certainly respect AK Rajan but this is not expected from him. The issues that they are trying to address should be better handled with reservation policy. If the rich is excluded in reservation then you have 50% of poor taking medical courses of which atleast 20 to 30 percent can come from rural area . Among these 50% if they want to further restrict then give reservation only to govt schools , everyone will be leveled.

HW doing great journalism...!🤝👍

If neet necessary let's dismiss all Indian doctors who did not pass the Neet.

Mruthnajaya homam(done for long life) is not working.

In my opinion, There should be NEET All over India, but the thing is we need to use this test as a tool for checking the eligibility of a student to become a medico. I mean, a student should face the test and get a minimum score to enter the medical course but the ranking and minimum cut-off marks to enter medical colleges should be given on the basis of the marks that the student have scored in the board examinations of each states. If this happens all over India, then its fare.

If a state (with crores of ppl) is having problems, the supreme court instead of shoving their judgement in their faces I believe they need to conduct a proper investigation and take everyone's wishes and comments before coming to a conclusion. The spate of laws being passed and shoved at Indians faces nowadays is alarming, which makes one wonder if we are too big to govern ourselves properly.

Common north india when will you start fighting for social justice.

@gtalk2k

2 жыл бұрын

Come on Guys! Common Sense helps North India identify people like Walter White

@infantajeesh7437

2 жыл бұрын

They don't know what is social justice. First they separate people using some technics and keep them people fight.

@sankar7847

2 жыл бұрын

There is no big social injustice than bringing leaders from same family. We learned our lessons and threw the indira congress into dustbin. When will you do it in tamilnadu?

TN govt should retrieve our rights back. MKS will do that sure.

@TheKrish1972

2 жыл бұрын

Right for What ?? SC has passed A verdict that the exam will stay!! TN is not a separate country. It is a state in India as far as I know!! Btw MKS is #mundakalapastalin nothing more. He is fit only to sweep floors nothing more

@aliendude4064

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheKrish1972 you have no idea of the constitution of India right.. FYI it is a federal government, so if a state decided to leave the union they can leave and the institution of the states comes under the control of the state.. So they have the right to have their own decisions..

@divay997

2 жыл бұрын

@@krishnarajagopalan528 No elders should kick anyone.. looks like you and ur elders both r in need of education..

@divay997

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheKrish1972 why should Central govt decide who shld be admitted in State government owned medical universities? When central govt cant even build one AIIMS in TN, who are they decide admission criteria.

@aliendude4064

2 жыл бұрын

@@krishnarajagopalan528 dude, you kindly consult a good person who has knowledge of our constitution.. My uncle is notary public.. He has a good knowledge of our constitution than any of us..

Whybother states have no probkem. Kerala has better meducal facility than TN. Whats ur take on it

Very nice explanation Justice A.K. Rajan Sir, Law is for the people. Save our children.

Neet Examination is purely 100% Biased examination and against poor. My son studying in cbsc school in Chennai. If he want I can spend coaching 3 to 5 lacs . If he not thro first time . He can affort to wait one or two years. But is this possible to poor students. Latest survey says more than 50% students are attempted second time. They most of them all Rich people. Also more to than 90% studying in State board . But question are from cbsc syllabus. Many people not understand why Tamilnadu alone fighting against NEET. Tamilnadu medical infrastructure is so big . Most of the town having primary health centre each district having big govt hospital. Most of the doctors of primary health center and govt hospital are come from middle and poor background. If the system allows only rich people to study mbbs . They mostly preferred not work in govt hospital. union govt have to think about poor people......

@praveenbaskar12

2 жыл бұрын

If NEET is cancelled, will the private college fee be made as equal as the Govt college fee? Will counselling in private college be conducted by "State Government"? The main aim is to admit lots and lots of govt school/poor students right, so will the fees of private colleges be revised?

@Kondrai_

2 жыл бұрын

@@praveenbaskar12 your talking about fees, I am talking about getting seat. To get MBBS Seat , need at least 3 to 4 lacs for coaching. in tamilnadu no of seat in govt quota is high Who ever come from poor background they will get scholarship . Past 30 years tamilnadu primary health centre runs because of poor background doctors. I am not from poor background . One of my servant daughter scored more than 95% in State board . Her ambition is become doctor. she is from very poor background . Living their whole family in single room. She works before school. She studied fully free cost till 12th std. she is not qualified for mbbs because of neet.. If she have 3 to 4 lacs coaching she surely became a doctor. We opposing the inequality in education.

@praveenbaskar12

2 жыл бұрын

@@Kondrai_ Coaching is a personal option..it's not a compulsory thing. I have seen so many people cracking neet without coaching. Can't the government introduce additional classes for NEET by hiring engineering grads/science grads with good knowledge but no jobs who might be interested in teaching..this would increase Job oppurtunities for fresh grads and also a great education for poor students. If not, they could increase internet facilities in rural areas. Nowadays internet has so much content that people can literally top the exam if they are consistent and hardworking.

@praveenbaskar12

2 жыл бұрын

@@Kondrai_ Earlier the cutoff for mbbs admission via 12th was always 197 above. Imagine if a student is short by 1-2 marks. Then he can never think about mbbs for his whole life. What if such students still commit suicide? If pvt clg fee remains the same We could organise classes for both neet and entrances in rural areas and also mental health sessions, so that such students can fight as hard as the CBSE/ICSE students and they don't commit such mistakes incase of failing exams too. If possible, we could keep x% of 12th marks and y% of NEET marks and finally give admissions based on total of (x+y).

@Kondrai_

2 жыл бұрын

@@praveenbaskar12 You need to understand Entire NEET exam System. First I don't understand why we need to crack exam. Neet is only gives training. But Quality comes only in learning. If you understand the difference between learning and training . You may not support Neet . My point is NEET is agaist social justice.( We need a equal opportunity and comman system ) . Statistics says neet is a additional burden its not increasing quality, reversibly it degrade quality. and pulling money from poor people.

This is not problem only for Tamilnadu.. it's for whole Indian poor people problem... NEET will destroy the medical system Tamilnadu crossed GER : 51.4% now , but India overall planning to achieve 50% by 2030.. Then this shows who is right. (Tamilnadu state is an medical hub of India) Before NEET we have world level specialist doctor.

North India n The Hindi Heartland should First Realize they Don't have a Smart n Educated PM n HM, When they will Get One Only God Knows. Son until then Only Govern Gujrat it may keep them Busy !!!

@mpscaspirant9543

2 жыл бұрын

Don't show you South Indian people are to superior

@Saurabh.up81

2 жыл бұрын

@@mpscaspirant9543 Bhai Marathi ya Hindi mein likh de. Google translate kar dega. Kyun English ki le raha hai 😂

@ashirdaniel3933

2 жыл бұрын

His comments are on the basis of the way the leaders are elected in the north and the leaders capability is seen by their policies.

So rural students find difficult to clear 12th and thus neet denies them opportunity. So do u think u will go to that doctor for treatment? Playing with human life?

BJP want only Brahmin getting more available seat for Medical college. Most of Dalit poor student affected in Neet exam.

@Max-nc1yx

2 жыл бұрын

This was brought in by congress and dmk govt. Private medical colleges admit students who have 40% mark.

Arthi I wholeheartedly appreciate this interview. Please try to improve the audio quality of the guest. 14-15 minute is the real valid point. Thank you. Tamil Nadu is way ahead in Inclusive and universalisation of education.

NEET must be scrapped!!!

Tamil Nadu,s argument is genuine.

Agreed

Neet must be mandatory for politicians yes or your call

Neet is a big discriminatory exam, lots of Coaching poor ppl cannot afford. Being a doctor, I feel that we should get the mindset out that only the top student can be a good doctor. A good doctor is one that's hard-working, has a humane heart and empathizes with ppl and understand treat patient and family. Doctors are equally important as other professional bodies like lawyers, software engineers, and designers. Still feel that penetration and awareness of various other jobs are very less, and Universities are not creative enough to attract for other professions. Children are often under extreme pressure and its not healthy. Madness and extreme competitiveness do not make better doctors.

NEET marks are not at all an indicator of true learning and knowledge. Coaching classes simply teach the tricks to score high marks. People lack awareness and think too high about NEET. But, NEET does not bring out real talent and knowledge. This is the truth. It's sad people don't understand this fact. TN syllabus is good but question paper pattern should be changed like CBSE.

his conclusion based on the government data which is opposing neet. his report has so many flaws . with neet capitation fees from 50 lakh to 1 crore are blocked. before neet anyone who can pay 1 crore can get a MBBS seat in TN . now even if u r ready to pay u have to pass neet. there r some hurdles in neet as TN schools lag in core subjects updation. thats y state board students r struggling to crack neet but now MBBS seat allotments are more transparent than before

Could you conduct like neet exam in priest.in politician particularly ministers

Why do we need 12th exam when you have an entrance exam.

I am also one the student who went through this and failed. I have to live with it for the rest of my life . But the issue is we have no other alternative other than to just filter out the people. I don’t think its a matter of standard or status of the profession the aspirants must achieve, since those is unfair if a person can just cash out seats in elite medical colleges in india just if he/she is qualified in neet. In short i don’t think people can come up with any other system other than finding the fittest among them which is not just seen in India (for reference just search about GAKAO in china).

Education , though in the concurrent list, is a State subject, by the Indian constitution and accordingly every state has the power of its own to devise the system, as each and every state differs from one another with regard to culture, language, basic/ higher educational facilities. Hence the Union should not intervene.

Simply i suggest Union gvt 1)First build hospital for Poor states which already looting our taxes in name of tax returns(GST) 2)Then develope basic education infrastructure there, then try to Grab developed states assets If this continue then india is going to be the next Soviet union. First wat is that one country one language One country one religion One country one Exam?😂 Funny people why dont you say one country one caste?😂 Give the temples in hands of dalits/Tribes who is the real ancestors, will u? Why specific brahmin wants to enjoy india in name of religion and monopoly? Tamil Nadu will resist all your gimmicks as always since 1000BCE

If schools are so good in Tamil Nadu then why can't they pass NEET exam. Getting marks given in some states is very easy but in some its very difficult. Solutions should be that schools should raise their standards to the level of coaching.

@adhilibrahim3577

2 жыл бұрын

We have much better and standard education system than entire north india

@balachandarv1571

Жыл бұрын

Then why even having "standardised syllabus"(CBSE), cbse student going for coaching institution where they pay lakhs of money. Competitive exam must be based on what knowlege they acquired from school not by having strategy to clear particular exam. Neet is only based on how well using strategy to clear exam thats it.Second if the competition exam conducted by union gov then it should applicable only to union gov owned MED clg like JEE for iit, Nit.Interveneing in state subject is against Federalism.

Those who were asking like IDIOTS then what is the use of 12 years education was totally useless? So they can skip all these from 12 years exam? This modi was a chief minister 15 years he never opened one medical college for his States students? Tamilnadu constructed infrastructure!!!medical & engineering!!!

Everyone to follow TN for this case

Sorry this Audio is not very clear

I wonder why other states and the people are not worried about this NEET. Why not they join hands with tamilnadu fight against it? If you want to introduce a common entrance examinations first make the standard & quality of education common to all students in india and reachable to all students whether they are poor or richer... God damn it! Meanwhile, i love you Arti! 🤩❤️

@mohancm3449

2 жыл бұрын

Last line suddenly made me 😭

@whythiskolaveridi1883

2 жыл бұрын

Other states don't have medical Colleges 😭

@mkrishnaraj1

2 жыл бұрын

Tamil Nadu is in forefront for social upliftment. It wants to give equal opportunities for kids from rural, poor and uneducated backgrounds. Because of the policies followed by the TN governments, it was able to lift lots of people from poor background. Now kids from the rural areas are able to get into medicine and other courses. Other states may not have so many kids from rural background who aspire to become doctors or engineers. On top of that I don't think any other state is trying to uplift socially backward people.

@vijayakumarsamuel7748

2 жыл бұрын

@@whythiskolaveridi1883 Not really the underlying reason is in Manusmirti .Education for the upper class deprive the poor. Only state that has Social Justice as its guiding principle is TN and so no other state opposes NEET

State High Court and State Government having equal powered. Both Great Establishments are for the wellness of particular State. Here, this bjp rss sponsored NEET exam causing severe damages to Tamil Nadu repeatedly. Tamil Nadu government's decision to repeal NEET exam is a right and well planned decision.

The fact that class 12th board exams counts pushes students to take school/Jr college seriously instead of bunking lectures and spending lacs on coaching classes where kids spend the entire week leaving only weekends to study. People in my state are spread very thin between college and coaching classes, and most don't even make it after spending all that time and money. Focusing on secondary education board results will push them to improve the quality of their institutions.

@venkat-il5ji

2 жыл бұрын

So happy to hear it, Hard truth are coming out...TN already gave a importance for +2 exams, from 1984-2007 weightage of 2:1/similiar given for +2marks: TNPCEE (TamilNadu Professional Course Entrance Exam)...200 marks from +2 marks (Physics, chemistry, Botony,Zoology each have 50 marks) & 100 marks from TNPCEE (Physical Science =50, Botony&Zoology=50)...Medical admissions were conducted based on Ranking from the above weightage/marks out of 300, through single window counseling systems..From 2008-2017 only +2 marks were considered for Medical admission , Entrance test was abolished due to the hardship faced by rural students/weaker section of society/small towns/villages students from coaching centres fees/availability/affordability stand point...

@cauliflowerhead2735

2 жыл бұрын

@@venkat-il5ji I suppose, this will also ensure more well rounded performers rather than students who focus on a few subjects and assume a one-track thinking to fit the format of entrance tests, while colleges will test you on both theory and practicals which entrance tests don't. Here in my state coaching classes are more expensive and organised than colleges themselves. We have allowed our institutions to languish by making 12th marks invalid. You guys are doing the right thing.

@venkat-il5ji

2 жыл бұрын

@@cauliflowerhead2735 u brought a valid points..Some people r good in theory & some r good in objective/logical reasoning/twisted questions...As a govt, v should consider all the aspects of studies, not only objective questions, am I right ?... Most of people from North India taking about mass copying, favouritism, question paper leak, extra time for writing exams and so on...V never heard about large scale malpractices/corruption in conducting/evaluating TN state board exams especially for 10th & +2.. V have a great faith in TN exam systems & standards which s relatively very robust...TNPCEE/Entrance test was conducted on TN State board syllabus...Most of the students studied in TN syllabus from 1st to 12th std...All of a sudden, how they can write exams in CBSE syllabus...It is injustice, is n't it ???...V do agree, TN state board syllabus have to upgraded to at par with CBSE syllabus...Give a 10-15 years time to revamp the entire curriculum from 1st to 12th std..At any cost, v don't discard the +2 marks & v do conduct Entrance test only in State board syllabus not on the CBSE...If Entrance test must then V will go for weightage of 2:1 or 1:1 for +2 marks:TNPCEE...V felt above s a very fairer systems compare to throwing +2 marks into garbage...If other states r not predicting the foreseeable issues, TN don't need to simply accept what ever Union/Central govt says...V want our doctors, to be working in Primary Health Centre (PHC) in rural/small towns...I can tell you affluent people/Doctor's Kids/Upper middle class/Economically well off/Metro guys/City breed, who ever studied in CBSE/ICSE/ISE from 1st to 12th, don't do the service in rural /PCH... ...Every doctor must do PG course to specialization in various part of human organs....All over India, PG courses r only 45000 seats compare to UG course of 70000 seats...With their money affluent/upper middle class guys , will simply fly to UK/US/Europe/Canada/Australia/New Zealand for PG studies, may settle in developed countries or comeback to open the hospitals/work in Metros/major cities , they don't go to least developed districts/small towns/villages...For Engg/other professions only v would require to go metros/major cities for jobs/work, for doctor profession every one s customer from villages/small towns/whoever roaming in parks/market ...

why don't India abolish biased interview systems in IAS, IPS, IFS etc.? Just have exam. Exam for GOVERNORS. If a guy can't speak without prompter wanted to decide about the life of 1.35 people, then we Indians are in deep trouble. Farmers law revoked so can the unwanted NEET.

Admission to any college including medical colleges should be based only on the performance of the students in board exams. Only then really talented and hardworking students would get admission to colleges. In board exams, there is always a guarantee that systematic and dedicated learning attributes to success and high marks. NEET on the other hand requires extra coaching and is associated with probability (no guarantee of success) and luck. This is why there are increasing number of repeaters in NEET. This puts lot of pressure on young children. Competitive tests are a good choice only for employment. In case of tests for jobs, already the candidates would have taken up semester exams in their college and they would be well versed in their curriculum. In this case, conducting tests for jobs will help to select best candidates for jobs. To sum up, there should not be entrance tests for admission to educational institutions. Competitive exams are a good choice only for job recruitments.

What is tha problem every states not like tamilnadu bcoz this issue!

NEET killed many worthy students😔.. who can do well in mbbs.. But the people who cant even pass the first yr of mbbs are getting seats... Just with the help of coaching factories...so plz keep some most toughest entrances for those people tring to rule us...

Tamil Nadu had laid a road for poor/rural to get into Medical Seats. NEET is a Huge block in that path. Tamil Nadu has converted more rural/poor students as Doctors preNEET than any other state in India.

Correct

If corrupted doctor is there then it affects the patient. If corrupted politician is there it affects the entire country. Hence NEET like exams are more important for politician than doctors.

Tamilnadu plus 2 syllabus is on par with CBSE syllabus. Tamilnadu students are far better than other states students in terms of hardwork and intelligence. Don't insult the curriculum and ability of Tamilnadu students without knowing anything about it. People from other states totally ignore board exams and simply prepare for NEET by attending coaching classes and they sit for multiple attempts. This is unfair. Also, NEET exam puts lot of pressure on students. Both economically weaker sections and middle class students ( of all boards including CBSE) cannot afford high fees for attending coaching classes. A student with a cut off of 198 out of 200 in board exam will be definitely a far better doctor than a student who has scored 720 out of 720 in NEET. That is why we oppose NEET. Don't underestimate the capabilities of Tamilnadu students without knowing anything about Tamilnadu.

We need to bring entrance to pass prime minister no knowledge to politicians no education only ego and revenge especially BJP Modi Govt guys can anyone tell me what modi qualifications

Tamilnadu plus 2 syllabus is on par with CBSE syllabus. Tamilnadu students are far better than other states students in terms of hardwork and intelligence. Don't insult the curriculum and ability of Tamilnadu students without knowing anything about it. People from other states totally ignore board exams and simply prepare for NEET by attending coaching classes and they sit for multiple attempts. This is unfair. Also, NEET exam puts lot of pressure on students. Both economically weaker sections and middle class students ( of all boards including CBSE) cannot afford high fees for attending coaching classes. A student with a cut off of 198 out of 200 in board exam will be definitely a far better doctor than a student who has scored 720 out of 720 in NEET. That is why we oppose NEET. Don't underestimate the capabilities of Tamilnadu students without knowing anything about Tamilnadu.

Coaching classes are not a MUST. If the student has studied very well his subjects, then he or she will fare well in any Competitive Exam !

@abishaek6760

2 жыл бұрын

94% who cleared the Neet were studied in some coaching institute or integrated coaching at school.

@guru8104

2 жыл бұрын

​@@abishaek6760 It will be around 99+% only a few who doesn't know anything other than books and exam secure a good rank without the help of coaching. Other even private school students go for coaching classes. But how can government school students afford it?

@abishaek6760

2 жыл бұрын

@@guru8104 well obviously Govt and Govt aided school students can't afford that much money, I studied in private school (gov aided) and most of my friends chosen Arts and Science degree though they scored good marks in board because we can't afford for coaching unless getting a loan or something like that

Why NEET is required if TN is doing perfectly well without it. They have the best medical infrastructure, best doctors certified by international community, best hospitals , students get plenty of opportunity to go abroad because they are smart even without NEET. Why Central government should destroy their future ? TN state students are far better than the average Indian students. NEET is great injustice to not only TN also to the entire South and East Indians. SCRAP NEET immediately.

Just one syllabus. Then neet. Only expectation is CBSC, Matriculation, state board, ISC, evrything in one curriculum. If only neet Mark, them school mark.

@zeph2087

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly

@sethuramramamoorthy6630

2 жыл бұрын

Even then also why another entrance exam in addition to thr board exam? No entrance exam requiired at any level or in any condition.

For centuries midwives attended deliveries. And few village men who were trained in healing injuries, animal bites and palliative care were forefathers of formalised medical profession. All one needs is the keen interest in medical care and a good academic scores in school. In Tamilnadu there is no entrance exam for engineering; and the engineers from Tamilnadu are ruling the software industry worldwide. Research has proven that the potential of urbanised village youth is tremendous. The government should have sense to realise the power of rural youth and remove the impediment of NEET exam in medical profession which requires enormous coaching cost. NEET only encourages Corporate entrance test training business.

Education must moved from concurrent list to under state list

NEET creates money minded doctors as they have to spend a lot to pass NEET. They will not be willing to serve the rural areas, they will try to go abroad to earn more money. Also the children from the rural areas cannot afford for NEET coaching, so they are automatically deprived of becoming a doctor. By allowing NEET you say that doctors should come from urban background only.

@bijoytk3042

2 жыл бұрын

You can't estimate a majority based such spineless thoughts. The TN government can pass new bill such as qualified mbbs holder must serve in the government hospitals. Not just for a sake, and it will be monitored on regular basis. That would help public to access government hospitals. When I was in TN, my fellow friends (tamilians) strictly adviced me to go only private hospitals and they said you'll get only poor treatments in government clinics. I really wondered. Because even in my native the PHCs are doing extraordinary jobs. Anyway TN government will face a set back soon. Mr. Stalin will get chances to pass such bills frequently.

This is the reason Tamilnadu is a leader of United States of India.

NEET is not good for TN.

With NEET the quality of doctors have come down (comments on Bihar By the Doctors Associations)

NEET is a great injustice to underprivileged students. The level playing ground is not the same for students studying different syllables.

Mr.Rajan is blissfully ignorant. Has the audacity to claim that 12th exam marks/knowledge is wasted. If students studied 11th and 12th sincerely, they should easily clear neet. This commision is prejudiced. Very shamefulm

Instead of taking steps to cancel NEET, Start a government NEET coaching centre ,because the problem is poor students are affected due to lack of money to join in coaching centre, NEET is the best entrace exam to qualify a standard student , I don't know why these people are fighting to cancel NEET Because It decreases the standard of education And on the other side some people are raising to increase the quality of education, In this situation how standard of education will increase If the cause was for the poor students who unable to pay fee to study NEET in coaching centre , then start a GOVERNMENT NEET COACHING CENTRE , that's the solution

@ashirdaniel3933

2 жыл бұрын

For your information most of the medical colleges in tamil nadu are constructed regulated by the state government and the centre cannot impose without the states consent..because the state govt knows the state better than the central govt!!!

@rmsh911

2 жыл бұрын

Union govt can bring in entrance exam for Institutions established by Union govt similar to IITs IIMs... No one will oppose that...let alone the Medical institutions established by state govt... People who can afford coaching classes can attend and give entrance exams...for the rest they can get admitted based on the School Final exam scores...all segments of students get a fair level playing field...

This Scoundrel is a DMK stooge. He is a Judge and what respect does he have for law ? If the SC has ruled NEET would stay, an ex- Judge he should advise the Govt to not to oppose. I don't understand how these people can be such back stabbers!!!

Nice explanation

NEET syllabus not required. pls don't overload students. Design and keep the system such a way that those really interested guys will choose medical professional. Though the really interested person stays in rural, poor in financial and academic, system should accomodate him/her in medical profession. Generally, person learns when he/she starts working in field. In college, new vocabularies and terminologies are learnt, and importantly, colleges give protective environment from external disturbances. That's all. pls think on useless gate keeping exam whether those required or not. pls don't stress students with ur egos. Really interested guys can be excellent in medical profession even though his/her college marks were just pass. Medical passion guys learn throughout their lives.

TN has more educational institutions for medicine and engineering which was best among the union states built by our forefathers in early years from 1986 with such a reputation in the universe. Now union government wants have pice of pie for their in capability across the country.

I really appreciate HW and Arthur to talk about this type social important news.Hats off.Neet is against poor..

Excellent soeech nice findings. Tamil Nadu does not want neet. If other States Students whi has passed Neet let they once again write an exam which the Tamil Nadu Government conducts. If they pass this exam they can be made to join in Tamil Nadu Colleges.

Students request was one common exam instead of statewise.multiple exams. Highersecondry marks should be given weightage. All kinds of malpractice is going. On in Hindi speaking stats

The TN is right.

Tomorrow if more students who scored good marks in Neet but scored less in 12th commits suicide, Will you change ur decision? Whoever gets emotional to such things and support the ban must be either stupid to not understand these or doesn't have capacity to compete in NEET. Compete in common exam and prove to get medical seats. If not, there are multiple options for u to study. If you are so focused On medical then put efforts on studies. I'm sorry for those who committed suicide. But govt, instead of running counselling sessions to students to not commit suicide, they encourage such behaviors by taking these measures.

@priyanatraj5634

2 жыл бұрын

It is not about the suicide...NEET is against the poor and socially disadvantaged people those who don't have access or afford for coaching...

@Bunnyandus

2 жыл бұрын

@@priyanatraj5634 neet can self studied. Like every other exams. Be it Cat or IIT JEE or UPSC. Coaching class will teach the same that is studied from 6 to class 12th for all these exams. If people can't understand the importance of medical system and standards even after losing so many lives due to covid. Nothing can change TN People mindset.

@priyanatraj5634

2 жыл бұрын

@@Bunnyandus theoretically yes...it can be self studied. But these are competitive exams...when your competitors have advantage of getting additional coaching then you...is it fair for you? don't you automatically feel intimidated??? Normal humans does..

@Bunnyandus

2 жыл бұрын

@@priyanatraj5634 competition is every where. Tamil people should stop blaming those who have natural advantages to coaching center. In that case in Every competitive exams UPSC, cat, IIT people from coaching centre clears, do you want all these exams to take only 12th mark? TN will never grow with this mentality.

@aravindhanra2647

2 жыл бұрын

@@Bunnyandus Do and study post NEET admissions in Private colleges... 5 lakhs per seat per year through NEET. Even those who have low NEET score can join. NEET is just to filter students for limited number of students. 15 lakh students keep on fighting and wasting precious academic years because of this repeated coaching tamasha. Merit argument is when a student completes course and final exam clearing is needed for merit calculation. Not the entry level exam itself. It is a fallacy that NEET is merit rather it is a demon aggravating inequality by diving elite vs poor,.

In TN, there is drastic reduction of Tamil medium students from rural areas/ urban poor joining MBBS course after the introduction of NEET. The percentage of CBSE students clearing NEET is much more when compared to State Board students as the question pattern for NEET favours CBSE. Plus Two marks are made irrelevant for joining MBBS. More than 98% of students resort to coaching classes and coaching Business for NEET has become a multi billion industry. Majority of the students are making repeated attempts through these coaching institutes. Coaching business is out of reach to rural and urban poor as they don’t have the wherewithal to defray huge sums of money. Therefore NEET is anti egalitarian to the majority of students. Make the plus two marks as the qualifying marks as done before. The doctors who were qualified under plus two marks system have made huge contribution to the nation without compromising the quality of service to the patients at large. The constitution has been amended 105 times by the Parliament. Therefore, please do not be pro elite helping the coaching institutions.

@venkat-il5ji

2 жыл бұрын

Superb Buddy :-) 🤝 🤝 🤝 🤝 🤝 🤝..Keep Rocking👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

I am not fan of coaching/neet exams but school system is also not full-proof? so there are some questions that we must ask to improve selection procedure of our india. - How much % of poor people's reduction in admission after neet? Bcs private schools have more good scoring students than govt. So argument of rich getting admission after neet is not very valid if data is not provided. - Does it increase the pressure on students during board exams? So what about suicide cases for board exams? - Cheating in school exams. I heard some students get good grades despite not knowing anything. How to prevent school level bribing? - Does this mean that tamilnadu students have two chances- state and through neet.

@yashuvishnalia

2 жыл бұрын

+ve things of school system: 1. Students time and money will get saved. No need for repeater students. 2. Govt. will be forced to improve schooling system of our rural india/public schools. Because students future depends on it. So parents will raise questions if public schools do not provide good facilities.

@praveenbaskar12

2 жыл бұрын

@@yashuvishnalia Time and money is saved. That's fine But what about those students who really want to pursue Medicine as a career, but due to any reason they perform slightly bad in 12th exams. Can we repeat it?? Does that mean we have to forget this career??

@yashuvishnalia

2 жыл бұрын

@@praveenbaskar12 🤔 This is a valid point. I didn't think about second chance.

@praveenbaskar12

2 жыл бұрын

@@yashuvishnalia Yes, that's what we are trying to say. But people don't seem to understand at all Via NEET We can compete for our state seats as well as all over India seats l. But via boards it's not possible Imagine if there are 2000 govt seats in our state (which contains all sorts of reservations) What will the 2001th candidate do? Should he forget mbbs? Can't he look for other states? Or AIIMS/JIPMER/other central instis?

Thank you Sir for enlightening people and union govt about law and constitutional rights of state on which union govt has NO rights to change the university laws and administration which only can be done by the state as per our constitution. So the bill passes by the Tamil nadu govt against NEET is valid the President should sign the bill soon. Once again my Respectful salute to Justice AL Rajan for his details report and recommendation on quashing of NEET.

NEET is very important to maintain national standards for admissions in medicine. These are people dealing with human health. With removing of the NEET now private medical colleges will charge their own capitation and take who they like. Again in TN who has money will get into private medical colleges the ones who cannot afford capitation will need to rely on government medical colleges.

@aravindhanra2647

2 жыл бұрын

Do and study post NEET admissions in Private colleges... 5 lakhs per seat per year through NEET. Even those who have low NEET score can join. NEET is just to filter students for limited number of students. 15 lakh students keep on fighting and wasting precious academic years because of this repeated coaching tamasha. Merit argument is when a student completes course and final exam clearing is needed for merit calculation. Not the entry level exam itself. It is a fallacy that NEET is merit rather it is a demon aggravating inequality by diving elite vs poor,.

@rmsh911

2 жыл бұрын

Union govt can bring in entrance exam for Institutions established by Union govt similar to IITs IIMs... No one will oppose that...let alone the Medical institutions established by state govt... People who can afford coaching classes can attend and give entrance exams...for the rest they can get admitted based on the School Final exam scores...all segments of students get a fair level playing field...