Ok watching these so far I understand why buddy gets mad like he makes classic elegant desserts and duff makes the weirdest things I’ve seen in baking, like the car cake one buddy was right that was stolen from him beyond belief I’d storm off too

@aisling4171

5 жыл бұрын

I agree. We obviously know which one was better, and that lady is delusional. Buddy OBVIOUSLY put more work into it. I personally really loved his cake. His reaction was a little inappropriate, but I can't say I don't understand his reaction.

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

Did you watch it live? I did and Buddy's car had a lot of problems. The KZread video didn't show them all.

@LeolaGlamour

4 жыл бұрын

Buddy is a douche

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

@George L like I said before. I'd rather have one that tastes good. Not the one who's electronics works. And again, if you watch the whole video Buddy's car had way more problems than they showed. When they are talking about how to vote they pointed out all the problems with his cartoon car. They didn't like how it didn't look nothing like him either.

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

@George L so the fact they all said it was too sweet means nothing to you. Or maybe you should turn the closed captions on. You obviously missed the fact they didn't like it.

I swear, duff payed the judges to make him win.

@Kingkong69..

4 жыл бұрын

Andrew Silverhart you are smart to thing that of course he dis

@nurainasofia866

4 жыл бұрын

If u like him don't watch duhhh......

Omg Buddy made something without fondant and rice crispies...mind blown!

@andalusiacadiz9986

5 жыл бұрын

LMAO!

@andalusiacadiz9986

5 жыл бұрын

@@sheavaccaro2282 Yes, I have! I have actually, met them both. Buddy is a consisted, egotistical, arrogant, self-centered person I have ever met.

@janetguzman814

5 жыл бұрын

@@andalusiacadiz9986 no way where? Spill the tea

@rutriggered7882

5 жыл бұрын

Pvc pipe and 2x4s.

@toukie5527

5 жыл бұрын

Wow now it’s GLOBS of frosting😉 No hate👍🏻

Why is Buddy on a show and being judged by other people...he’s a legend. Just saying.

@tristanhnl

4 жыл бұрын

Buddy is an expert in cakes mostly, because that's what his bakery is most known for. Yes, he does make other baked goods, obviously. Yet, when it comes to other baked goods, he's not as refined and knowledgeable, as this show Buddy vs Duff reveals. If Buddy were to go on The Great American Baking Show, which tests competitors on knowing the really fine details that make or break a dish, I don't think he would do so well. For example, in the technical challenge on that show, competitors are not provided details on how long to bake the item, nor details on how or when to incorporate certain ingredients that affect the final outcome. The bakers need to rely on their knowledge of those finer details. That's where I think Buddy would struggle, because apart from his specialty cakes, everything is mass-produced, straight-forward and formulaic. As for being judged by other people....Sherry Yard is definitely one who has the clout and prestige to judge Buddy. She's a 3-time James Beard Award winner, a legend in her own right. You don't win the James Beard Award 3 times unless you're really darn good. So when it comes to things other than cakes, it's interesting to see how Buddy performs.

@tristanhnl

4 жыл бұрын

@George L , OMG you're stalking my comments LoL. I'm not promoting anyone. I'm simply responding to various comments on this forum. So just because I don't agree with you, that means I work for Duff? Brilliant logic there.... Plus, what I said in response to Carrot Stick is completely valid. Just because Buddy is a professional baker, he can't be on a competitive baking show? And in what way am I wrong? Buddy is mostly about cake...cake....and cake. Whenever he has to make other stuff, he does things that are very basic. Have him go on the great American Baking Show, with Paul Hollywood and Mary Berry as judges. So there, now you can't say there's a conflict of interest. Buddy would still flop, as all his baking talent is cake stuff.

@tristanhnl

4 жыл бұрын

@George L , additionally you do realise Buddy is *ALSO* in the Food Network family, don't you? In the UK, "Cake Boss" is carried on the Food Network, although he's on TLC/Discovery in the USA. I'm trying to say this as nicely as possible, but you're starting to sound....not very smart.

@yveewong

3 жыл бұрын

IKR

@begoodtoall3164

Ай бұрын

​@@tristanhnl Rubbish talk!

Love both Buddy and Duff. Clearly, Duff has more technical skills and pushes himself to go outside the box. I have watched all of the Cake Boss episodes. Love his family life. In the beginning I wanted Buddy to win. When I watched Duff at work and his abilities, was very happy he won the competition.

@Guadalupe-tp1pj

5 жыл бұрын

Bady te vendiste para dejar ganar a druf ? Tu eres el mejor ,no dejes q te gané ,los jueses están en tu contra .

@flyflip87

5 жыл бұрын

I'm actually the opposite. I watched Ace of Cakes way before I heard of Cake Boss. Love both of them but I was for TeamDuff

@itsnotatoober

5 жыл бұрын

@@Guadalupe-tp1pj 100% this is opposite world wtf is going on. These people dont apprecuate talent. Duff should have gotten zero on presentation and creativity, 2 on difficulty if it actually tasted good. Buddy got screwed

@Kingkong69..

4 жыл бұрын

Yo duff’s cake was like a art work, I thought it was a pie compilation, buddy is unarguably the best in the world

@arkham5940

Жыл бұрын

so according to you thinking out of the box is create those things of werid things? plus pie and icecream is just generic dessert, catn belive people like u things that thinkig out of the boxis tu put a fish draw in the pie

I love how Duff just always has a smile on his face.

@khyati2474

5 жыл бұрын

Thats because he know he'll win As he works for Food Network No hate Just my opinion

@aldomartinez3579

4 жыл бұрын

a stupid smile.....in a funny good way.

Clearly we can see buddy can not take constructive criticism🤦🏻‍♀️, every good baker has flaws.

@leeteplitz7673

5 жыл бұрын

Adrian Torres Amador That’s because he’s very arrogant

@nataliemira2073

5 жыл бұрын

Yup you see the fire in his eyes when they criticized him lol he stuff isn’t even that great I had his cupcakes before and they were disgusting

@bunycat

5 жыл бұрын

@Jefferay you know Buddy has several stores right?

@missgoldie6257

5 жыл бұрын

Buddy is a spoiled little boy. Duff is an artistic baker.

@missgoldie6257

5 жыл бұрын

@Jefferay, so do you feel better now that you're really TOLD me what you think? Bless your little heart. Now, go clean Mommy's basement like a good boy.

"This is gonna be a tough one to judge" HOW?!?!

I can't believe how stupid the judges are. Duff's pie looked like my 4 year old colored it. It's all fake

@heycutie1473

4 жыл бұрын

youre right

@Gabuscus123

4 жыл бұрын

It is fake lmao.. it’s a show... they’re not gonna be choose one guy all the time. They wanna make it more interesting for the viewers.

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

I don't know if you know but they score on flavor and how it's cooked more on how it looked. And I've had way too sweet pie. And it sucks. It may be fake also. But, unless you taste it it's hard to judge by looking at it.

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

@George L First, they would not have chosen Duff's to win if it was just the ice cream. Next, I don't know what you think but, how it looks has nothing to do with how it tastes. I don't care how good something looks. If it tastes bad I don't want it. Finally, there are times something at a grocery store tastes better than some restaurants. It's obvious you didn't put much thought into all three of your comments to me as they are easily cast off as garbage.

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

@George L god your dumb. The judges tasted the pie. This is not who had the best looking pie. Your point of what would you pick at a store is moronic and pointless. How do you not see cooking contests are about taste 90% look 10%? Would you pick a piece of dog shit that looked like a beautifully cooked steak or a chicken nugget in the shape of Mickey Mouse? Yeah, just as stupid as your question but just as valid. Look is not the main factor in cooking contests. Period.

Buddy's pie looked like something out of a magazine. Duff's looked silly. I'm not a big pie person but Duff's probably tasted better because it wasn't sweetness overload.

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

@George L so you would like an over sweet bad tasting pie or, a silly looking delicious pie? Not even a question what i would pick.

@runarandersen878

4 жыл бұрын

I also wanted Buddy to win, but I agree. I think I would have liked Duffs pie better without the childish decorations. A plain good blueberry pie with ice cream is hard to beat.

Sometimes keeping it simple wit the flavors is the key. Buddy loves to top everything with extra sugar.

@iguessso1790

5 жыл бұрын

It was waaaay to much cream

@iguessso1790

5 жыл бұрын

@George L i rather have no crust then too much cream, too much cream can ruin the taste

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

@George L too many blueberries will ruin a cupcake.

Buddy's sicilian death stare reaction during duff's pie presentation hilarious. I could see the italian accented cursing rage about to come out with knives and vendettas

Buddy's pie looks way more appetizing

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

It looks great. But, taste us where it counts.

Duff needs to go home and just stay there

"We're gonna see some serious piping technique" PFTAHAHA😂😂😂 1:41

Ngl in this round I deffo preferred Buddy’s, Like it I went into a bakery I probably wouldn’t even look at Duffs.

@gracebritz59

5 жыл бұрын

The Great Saffouf you’d pick that giant piece of bird shit .. yikes

@thiccducc2620

5 жыл бұрын

The Great Saffouf true it’s all about presentation

@thiccducc2620

5 жыл бұрын

Grace Britz and you would take that piece of aquarium?

@freefalling4271

5 жыл бұрын

Grace Britz and you would rather take a pie that look like it’s for kids?

@thegreatsaffouf

5 жыл бұрын

Grace Britz it’s cream and meringue 😑 hardly bird feces

Easy to smile when you win. Classic beautiful pie vs what we normally get, food coloring...

I love Duff , he is like a genuine kid and so much fun .💪😁🎈

I Love When These Two Compete With Eachother😊

Whoaaaaaa! I’ve never actually seen Duff baking 😆 I’m used to just seeing him eat and judge other people’s food!

Buddy is such an egomaniac.

@thiccducc2620

5 жыл бұрын

da broncobabe your name is too

@lisapelarske1634

5 жыл бұрын

da broncobabe I agree. That’s what makes him so unlikable to me.

@nopeno358

4 жыл бұрын

@@lisapelarske1634 shut up just because u don't like a person doesn't mean u can point it out if u got nothing nice to say then don't even say it

@hiddenlightning5408

4 жыл бұрын

Duff Sucks...

I love Duff his face eating Buddy's pie

I love the smirk Duff has during the judging and Buddy looks like he’s going to implode. Lol.

Duff be talking about Duff. Buddy be talking about Duff. Buddy needs to pay attention to his own pie

Duff's was ugly and not very appealing!

@AlphineWolf

4 жыл бұрын

His looked like a 4 year old painting

@bryannamarie7539

4 жыл бұрын

@@AlphineWolf agreed

@paulvasquez7897

4 жыл бұрын

He did Have a good idea w/ Blueberry Pie & Vanilla Ice cream tho ... I’ll give him that lol can’t go wrong w/ that

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

@George L is this the first time you saw a cook off? Going the extra mile doesn't work against you. Of course you think what food looks like is more important than how it tastes.

@adamage1766

4 жыл бұрын

@George L your the guy who eats tasteless vegan food and brags about it.

That is not true, buddy is unarguably the best go to pie/cake artist in the world, and the taste fantastic

@Kingkong69..

4 жыл бұрын

Buddy is the best

@Kingkong69..

4 жыл бұрын

You tripping

people always talk about duff's piping but never consider the fact that buddy would smoke him if he actually tried

I don’t like my pie sweet, it should have a sour, salty vinegar flavor, maybe a few hairs init to.

@mirandabillups-hudson9912

4 жыл бұрын

Lmao

Top 10 Anime Battles of All Time

Buddy should have frickin won , geeze !?!

Did Duff storm off camera and complain that he lost the challenge? In week 2? What a cry baby. I have always liked buddy... it seems like every challenge he lost it was all he could do to control himself to storm off stage again... Duff won, Great job Duff!

@conradpena2029

5 жыл бұрын

Buddy walked off and cried like a whiny bitch not duff

@juliannalopezguzman8366

5 жыл бұрын

Adam Brockie That was Buddy...

@itsnotatoober

5 жыл бұрын

No he didnt. His talent is way ahead of duffs. I wouldnt let duff near my kitchen without years of training,.

This show needs to be redone....

I personally think Duff is amazing, but I love and admire Buddy’s work and Buddy’s pie looked more appealing to me!!!!

i love how they said whinsical

Sherry Yard was bias towards Duff! Buddy's attitude doesn't matter it's about the baking & he rocked it!

Buddy always does the same old *"covering up my ugly ass creation w/ a heap of frosting"* that whipped cream is way too much... for me.

@itsnotatoober

5 жыл бұрын

Duff covering up with his best 3rd grade art.

@sawadatsunayoshi3739

5 жыл бұрын

@@itsnotatoober btch 😂

@skylerspetty1963

4 жыл бұрын

itsnotatoober better then what u could do...

This looks like the judges have their mind made up already against Buddy. I don't understand why Buddy is even on a show being judged... he's literally the cake Boss.

Bro how could you put buddy against duff? Buddy’s a legend in his craft, duffs just a guy who is good at what he does

its funny how a perfectly make banana pie could not beat a generic couloring pie with made ice cream

Buddy should have one !

Buddy can’t take constructive criticism at all!!!!! You can see it all on his face he wants to flip a table over

Duff's eating d pie!😂

Buddy's was so so much better. It looked awesome

Hey sweeter the better. That banana pie was gorgeous. If you had been in the south that pie would have got a ribbon.

Get proper judges that know how to do their job properly Respects for Buddy and Duff

U rthe best buddy we love u

Buddy criticizing duffs pie when his cakes are the same 😂 all presentation and no flavor

Buddy is the winner in my eyes

I just love how Duff is always smiling

5:38 😂 Buddy: 😳 Duff:😐

Team Duff😊

BUDDYS PIE SCREAMED PIE WTHHHHH🥺

Buddy’s a poor sport. He doesn’t like criticism. No matter how good you are there’s someone better out there. They are both awesome

The judges favored Duff the entire competition!!! Hey Keegan, IT CAN NEVER BE TOO SWEET!!!

Poll challenge who is really Better

Cool

Buddy is so eragant he can't even loose decently

They should have a guest judge at every episode who get to vote. Even if the judge has to come from another country that buddy or duff don't know.

Obviously buddy's pie was really pretty compared to duff but that not the only aspect the juries consider. 5:04

Buddy I love all your creations .

Now that I look back at it, neither of them actually excuted the theme of the challenge. They're suppose to make the pie beautiful, but now I think it's more eye catching, not the good kind, than beautiful. Duff's can be easily identified as a pie but I feel like he could've done more. Buddy's feel like you have to look at it from every angle to realize that it is a pie and his idea of beautiful was like 'use whip cream and a piping tip with an amazing design, add some bananas, then hoboken style'.

Why is buddy so mean to duff, like Duff is so happy and nice and buddy is always putting him down

Biddys is pretty on the outside, duffs is pretty on the inside...it would be all about taste to me.

That girl is on Gordon Ramsay

duff turning the figurine into pie

tbh if i was duff i will be emberassed giving to the judges the colorfull pie that look liks a 4yr old coloring it,buddy shoudve won

buddy all the wayyyysss

duff could of left no white edges on the round things just shows his confidence yet......when comes to looks i take buddy we dont have taste tv

They need Gordan ramsey😂

There's hope for me😋

Buddy is so arrogant, he expects to win everytime.

@Wackawacka2020

5 жыл бұрын

woah man harsh

@ShawnDRuth

5 жыл бұрын

@@Wackawacka2020 It's true. There is a difference between arrogance and confidence. A thin line, but still a line.

@itsnotatoober

5 жыл бұрын

@@ShawnDRuth Go fuck yourself

@nopeno358

4 жыл бұрын

@@palvphill2639 he didn't mean it that way

Oh buddy all the wayyyyyy!!!!!

I want buddy to win very badly, but can he at least be a good sport and congratulate duff every now and then and not call his pie “finger painting”

Go Buddy!!!!! 😆👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼🙌🏼💯😋🤩😋🤩😋🤩

Buddy!! buddy!! Buddy!!! Buddy!!! :D

I think buddy should have won

Duff’s amazing 💫

Duffs pie looks like a pie on a budget compared to buddys

I feel like anyone could be a pie judge

I love buddys cakea

Duff:-my cake looked amazing Me:-I-I lost my appetite Also me:-I am never having a pie ever again

Both pies had their own positive and negative. I happen to Love, did I say Love, yes! I Love whipped cream! So that was a huge plus for me with Buddy's pie even though the Banana filling looked unappealing. Now, I also like blueberry pie and I can certainly appreciate Duffs creativity, but a fish decoration, hmmm. Not so appealing on a pie. I'm just saying... Creativity goes to Duff. Extreme whipped cream goes to Buddy😁

2:46 that’s a little bit of cream. Me: are you blind that’s a lot of cream on top...

Good job Duff!

For me the winner is Buddy’s.

@goutamsardar8364

4 жыл бұрын

Mine to

Team Duff!

they should have called this show baby vs. duff - the number of hissy fits he threw.....

What kind of contest is this? You don't have a contest for 2 professionals making different pies!

buddy looked mad asf💀

Love how the Cake baby has to cry every time he loses.

No it’s not. It’s not going to be a tough one. Only reason why it’d be a tough time is to not hurt Duffs feelings

Buddy for life

Duff is so adorabllee💖💫

I think it was favoratism because Duff is a regular on the Food Network.

I like duff pie

I go for buddy

Honestly Buddy s pie looked way more attractive .. Buddy deserved this one

The reason why buddy don't win challenges is because hes already a star so judges hate on him Because he's already a star 🌟

Anything with Judges will always be opinion based. Some prefer less sugar and other tonnage of sugar. Like I think my mother in laws peanut butter pie is perfect & rich. My wife thinks it's terrible and only eats the store bought which I dont like. I wouldn't think anything bad from either of these bakers. This was a competition between Duff & Buddy. Buddy has a bakery in NJ and is there everyday. Duff is a mainstream celebrity similar to Gordan Ramsey. Point I'm making is that even though both r great, Duff will always have a leg up on Buddy. Duff has more knowledge on what these kinds of people like so he will always have the edge on Buddy.

I love duff