I don't think Sanji would have been found by the Big Mom Pirates in this time line, seeing that Germa only found out about him after he became a known pirate.

@petersmith9722

Жыл бұрын

i agree

@blair5475

Жыл бұрын

Germa didn't care about him. They just wanted someone to marry into the Charlotte family.

@pootsleyer2187

Жыл бұрын

well maybe he gets recognized by something else like being a world famous cheff or something like that

@shenronwish

Жыл бұрын

@@pootsleyer2187 sailing with the Straw hat's made him a better chef, even in the time skip he had to fight queers for food recipe's, and he never realizes his own potential since the rest of the Baratie crew faked a bad opinion on his cooks .

@florianstower5138

Жыл бұрын

But they somehow knew about jeff

One thing that would go differently from what you said is Robin's story. She's either gonna get executed right after being captured by CP0 or if she ends up in Impel Down Iva would most likely save her on the request of Dragon. So at the very least in this Luffy-less universe Jimbe and Robin are still part of one team

@coreym8145

Жыл бұрын

Yeah my thinking too. Especailly after Egghead reveals.. Dragon wouldnt let Robin be killed or executed at impel, he would come for her and so would the Giants since they recovered Oharas treasure... knowledge

@kharonhaden5136

Жыл бұрын

I don’t think she even gets captured by Cp0 at all. We already know before she met the strawhats she was able to constantly evade the WG and that the only reason she was caught was because she started to care about the strawhats

@cleanchimera3870

Жыл бұрын

Yeah dragon wouldnt let his curiosity sit still the moment he finds out that a scholar was imprisoned at level six, of course he would free her and find out that shes from ohara

@Snak3mast3r

Жыл бұрын

wouldn't she be killed by crocodile? Alabasta 'main' events would still happen without luffy. Crocodile had no intentions of letting her live after he used her. So theres no way she would have managed to survive, only luffy realized water was his weakness. Her dreams seemingly crushed and resigned to die.

@eugenio708

Жыл бұрын

I think if Robin stayed with Crocodile, she was untochble... They arrested Crocodile only because they didnt want to say that Mugiwara crew defeated a warlord, so they said that Smoker arrested Crocodile because of that. Without Luffy, Smoker should not be at Alabasta, so Crocodile probably deal directly with government or with Doflamingo and so Kaido

Luffy is so dedicated that even if he wasn't born he'd find a way to be born.

@hidden5515

Жыл бұрын

This genuinely made me laugh

@adammarchione928

Жыл бұрын

LMAO TRUE

@idk8863

Жыл бұрын

Bro would jump from dragon's b@ll and into the w0mb

@El_DiabloReaper

Жыл бұрын

Fr

@Dakshna-mg9oj

Жыл бұрын

Bro ur a legend 😂😂😂

5 minutes in. Thank you Luffy for popping out of the barrel and make so many people happy

@Alexa-cz9iu

Жыл бұрын

AHABDAHXNXS yeah-

@CatvinityJustAnEditor

Жыл бұрын

541 likes and no replies? Let’s fix that

@Ktcplayz

Жыл бұрын

554 likes and 1 comment let me fix that

@10hrburstman

Жыл бұрын

559 likes and 2 replies? Lemme fix that

@jovanbijelic4345

Жыл бұрын

All of you shut up with these replies

This helped me get a better understanding on how to make a good protagonist - someone who heavily influences events and other characters in the story.

@OK-fo5tm

Жыл бұрын

but also manages so that the plot doesn't become stale and the world keeps escalating even where the main protagonist is not present

@sadlobster1

Жыл бұрын

Since Luffy's presence in the OP world IS quite important, I just wish his crew would treat him better. I've lost count of how many times I've rage quit on the series due to the poor ideas of "comedy" the anime has, which mostly consists of beating Luffy to near death

@GoatAmv

Жыл бұрын

@@sadlobster1 i really understand 🥺 but luffy is dumb 😕

@justexist841

Жыл бұрын

@@sadlobster1 Thats due to the fact that luffy doesnt treat his crew as servents but they are friends. He dont need to be macho or strong in front of his friends and he dont want to feel like he has a rope around their neck due to his strength he would rather just have fun and be free enjoy his life and stop anyone he can with his power that threatens that freedom

@sadlobster1

Жыл бұрын

@@justexist841 This is true...however, even the most loyal of friends have their limits. If I were Luffy and had to put up with Nami's beatings every time I "spent too much money," I'd consider breaking Arlong out of prison

If Luffy never existed: Koby doesn't escape Alvidas ship. Considering how weak she was, eventually she gets defeated. Kobys fate depends on who defeats them, but likely never becomes a marine. Zoro dies after the marines betray their deal. Morgan still is captain in the marines. Buggy sacks Orange Town and continues looking for Captain Johns treasure, eventually he would likely be arrested or if he stumbled into Arlongs territory, killed. Kuro kills Usopp & Kaya and retires in peace after killing off his old crew. Mihawk kills Krieg and Sanji remains on Baratie till the Vinsmokes find him and take him away. Gin might actually survive this encounter and either become a captain or stay at Baratie. Nami gets betrayed by Arlong like we saw, but this time the whole town dies when they uprise. Nami either dies, kills herself or becomes a slave for Arlong. Smoker never leaves Logue Town. Laboon is killed by Baroque works, unless Crocus steps in to fight. Dory and Broggy are captured and handed to the WG by Mr 3. Vivi is found out and kept captive by Crocodile. Crocodile takes over and the bomb destroys most the city, without Pluton he likely kills Robin. Crocodile would likely be broken, as his plans would have been for nothing - likely regretting killing Robin as he will never find Pluton without her. Hard to know what he does next. Bellamy doesn't change whatsoever, remaining a overconfident lackey for Doffy. Enel would destroy Skypeia and head out with his priests. If he goes to the blue sea eventually he causes a lot of Havok before being defeated (likely by an Admiral). CP9 eventually find Franky and capture and torture him for the blueprints, which they may find and begin to rebuild Pluton. Moria would eventually kill Lola and her friends, once Oars and his Zombies are ready he would travel into the New World and try to take out Kaido. He'd be killed for certain along with his crew. Ryuuma would likely be destroyed in Wano, so they would finally get back the sword and end the grave robber mystery. After his death at the hands of Kaido, Morias shadows would release, returning Brooks and allowing him to leave the Triangle. Nobody attacks Saint Charloss, no Admirals come to SA, The 9 Supernovas leave unimpeded. Caime likely rescued by Rayleigh using CoC, if she ended up at the auction. Blackbeard fights Ace. Without a Warlord spot open at the time, he won't be able to hand him to the Government. BB might kill Ace because of this. There is no prison break in Impel Down. Blackbeard can't gain access to the gates of Justice without Warlord status, and has no reason to go there. There is no Whitebeard War, as there is no Ace to execute. Whitebeard likely remains in the dark about BB and Aces fate. Whitebeard remains a Yonko until a stronger Blackbeard kills him a few years down the line or he dies of age/illness. Sengoku doesn't resign, Akainu doesn't become FA until later on. Fujitora isn't an admiral. Jinbei likely would have killed Hody, if not Pekoms & Tomago would have killed him sooner rather than later. FI may have been destroyed if Vander Decken still raises Noah. If Whitebeard is still alive at this stage then maybe some of his men kill Hody & Co instead. Law can't become a Warlord, and likely gets killed by Vergo or Doflamingo. Caesar remains making smiles, and giant kids for Big Mom. Maybe the Vinsmokes never get an alliance offer if the science labs of Punk Hazard are still intact. Dressrosa stays under Doffy. The Warlords never disband. Sabo never clashes with Jesus Burgess, never gets the Mera. Dragons HQ isn't discovered, likely there is no raid at the reverie. IM doesn't move forward on any plans without Alabasta involved, or Poseidon being discovered or BB / Luffy rise. Kaido and Big Mom do not ally. The Scabbards eventually get killed on the promised day, Kinemon & Momo never escape Punk Hazard. The Supernovas likely remain bitches for the Yonko, with Urouge & Kidd eventually being killed if they continued to fight them.

@blancspaze

Жыл бұрын

Damm!! This was one of the best "What if luffy wasnt born?" theories i've ever read.

@Colaschnittchen

Жыл бұрын

There would be an open spot for BB, since Moria dies by Kaido (depends obviously on the timing of morias death)

@GoatAmv

Жыл бұрын

@@blancspaze really appreciate that!! 🥂🤝

@Chatedh

Жыл бұрын

Why wouldn't smoker ever leave loguetown?

@rosa1212

Жыл бұрын

@@Chatedh he leaves because of luffy.

If Luffy was one week late to his adventure, lots of things would be different. You could rewrite One Piece based on that. Alies would be different, enemies would be different, interactions, plans, the state of the world itself would a sight to behold

@LeafyReuploads

Жыл бұрын

Thats actually incredibly interesting to think about, Zoro would already be dead at that point since helmeppo had planned to publicly execute him a day after luffy arrived to shell town so thats crazy he wouldnt have zoro on his team either, nami would have her gold taken so she would probably turn to luffy to help her rather than trying to turn luffy away, syrup village would have already been destroyed and usopp is dead, alabasta has been overrun by crocodile, shit a lot of stuff would go down, There would probably be replacement crewmates for zoro and that too, Id like to think that zoro gets saved by johnny and that other guy he was mates with when they were bounty hunting since they were near that area of the sea looking for zoro when usopp blew up the rock near them, but they wouldnt make it in time, yeah thats crazy bruh. Edit: actually luffy wouldnt get caught in that storm and wouldnt be in that barrel, so he would actually start his adventure like he planned to, coby would also be not in the story, damn.

@Renno802

Жыл бұрын

@@LeafyReuploads Gotta love how much the story can be changed by just shifting luffy journey starting point by a few days

@gamers-xh3uc

Жыл бұрын

@@LeafyReuploads zoro wouldn’t have been dead he would be almost dead and too weak to fight but if luffy manages to free him and take him away and feed him he will get back to normal

@LeafyReuploads

Жыл бұрын

@@gamers-xh3uc No helmeppo said that he planned to execute zoro on the next day when he was at the pub when luffy overheard him, meaning if luffy was a week late, he would have been executed.

I also think Zeff is still a great fighter, probably knows how to use haki, and would have kicked Don Krieg's face in, but he chose to stand back and let Luffy fight because he saw something in Luffy, and he told Sanji to watch Luffy closely during that fight because he wanted Sanji to learn a lesson.

@avakinzerochill

Жыл бұрын

Mihawk would've killed him. He only stopped because fighting zoro ended his boredom. If luffy had not been born, zoro would be dead and would not have been there to fight Mihawk

@typeouetco1626

Жыл бұрын

Zeff ran away from paradise, there's 0 reason to assume that he is an haki user

@AnIgniSign

Жыл бұрын

@@typeouetco1626 no, homie killed many many many pirates and marines with his bare feet and stayed in the tough grandline

@typeouetco1626

Жыл бұрын

@@AnIgniSign and then he ran. From paradise.

@Drewskells

Жыл бұрын

@@typeouetco1626 how do you mean “ran from paradise”

Luffy is the personification of someone who liberates civilizations and people,like everywhere he goes he saves them. He is that Light in the darkness,hence why I can only think of very bad stuff happening if he was never born. When the beacon of hope doesn't even exist the world becomes dark and infinitely times more cruel. He has such a massive impact on the entire world of one piece.

@DoubloonGoblin

Жыл бұрын

He's supposed to have a impact, he's the main character.

@trimex7234

Жыл бұрын

Of course he has an impact on the world and strory, like any other main character. No main character, no plot.

@MerajKhan-gd2bs

Жыл бұрын

i kinda agree/disagree. Most story that i've read make main character the center of the world in second half of the series but in one piece. In the very second arc (first if you're anime only) saves coby how ends becoming one of the big guns later in the story.

@godemperorofmankind3.091

7 ай бұрын

Ironically there is several main characters that only made things worse

This is a great alternative story, however I have a few points: 1. Sabo's ship won't be sunk by the celestials. Luffy caused a lot of havock creating delays in Sabo and Ace's plans. That whole arc would play out differently and Sabo would leave on a different day. Meaning Sabo and Ace go on to becoming pirate captains of their own crews. 2. Sanji won't be found by Big Mom, because Judge will just offer one of his other sons for the wedding. Judge and Co didn't know the whereabouts of Sanji so they probably wouldn't want to waste too much time trying to find someone they thought could be dead by now anyway. Thus, Sanji lives out the rest of his life at the Baratie. Big Mom still slays the Vinsmokes and takes their tech though, but Sanji isn't involved at all. 3. Robin might not be caught by the WG. It was because of the Straw Hats that she ended up BY CHANCE on the same island that CP9 is busy with a mission on. She ran from the WG for 20 years, she'll be good carrying on. There's even a chance that she'd run into revolutionaries and they take her in anyway. So 40% chance she's good, 35% revolutionaries find her, 25% she gets caught by WG. Remember CP0 is dealing with trying to figure out Wano, so they're out of the question here. CP9 might be assigned to searching for Robin AFTER taking Franky to Enies Lobby though. 4. IF Robin does get caught, she won't spend the rest of her life in Impel Down. They'd either A) plan a public execution (because at this point they don't have Ace yet, and they love sending messages to the world), or B) make her dissappear (execute her in secret) after she refuses to cooperate with the WG. Either way she'll be in Impel Down for a short time not forever. THEN, Dragon WILL make a move. He told the entire Revolutionary Army to keep an eye out for her and save her at all costs. If public execution, Dragon enacts a surprise attack on Marineford (they won't be as prepared as they were with Ace because they wouldn't expect a battle like they expected against a Yonko). If secret execution, Ivankov and Co will contact Dragon from the prison and alert him that Robin is the new prisoner and from there they plan to break her out. (this can also be another theory as to why Ivankov stayed in Impel Down, to keep watch incase somehow the marines ever captured Nico Robin. Dragon believed Robin was of utmost importance to their cause). 5. Blackbeard won't use Ace to become Warlord. He was looking for anyone with 100+ million bounty. He'd just go after one of the other Supernovas. Remember chasing Luffy was the reason that caused Blackbeard's journey lead to the island that Ace found him on. His entire route from Jaya will be different. Ace will eventually find him and they'd still clash but probably only after Blackbeard is already a shichibukai. There's a chance at this point that he doesn't hand Ace over to the Marines because he already has Shichibukai status. 6. IF it still plays out that Blackbeard hands Ace over to the Marines (for whatever reason, doesn't matter), the Marineford war will happen yes, but Shanks WILL ABSOLUTELY still stop Kaido. Because Kaido's plan was to INTERCEPT Whitebeard BEFORE he reaches Marineford. Therefor Shanks would still want to make it possible for Whitebeard to reach Marineford, thus he will still intercept Kaido to stop him and therefor still arrives at Marineford late. (After clashing with Whitebeard, Shanks could tell WB's strength was fading and knew Whitebeard would not survive Marineford. Thus he also knew WB would not survive fighting Kaido in this condition, or if he does then he'll be way too weakened to even do anything at Marineford) 7. Because of point 6, Kaido will not show up at Marineford because this part of the story plays out exactly the same where Kaido backs off from Shanks and goes back to Wano. Rayleigh might not show up anyway, because of his age and because they all believe in respecting each other's journeys and battles. He can't interfere or force his help onto Whitebeard even though Ace is Roger's son. 8. Whether Ace lives or dies, Whitebeard still dies at Marineford because even he knew he wasn't going to survive. He just wanted to set Ace free. And because Blackbeard dies in Impel Down while Shiryu is still locked up, Whitebeard's Yonko spot is up for grabs because his territories will start to fall as other pirates don't respect Marco or Ace's name as much as they respect/fear Whitebeard himself. And the Whitebeard pirates after suffering many casualties (including the allies), won't be able to defend ALL territories. So Ace will have to grow some more in order to reach Yonko level to be viewed by others and Whitebeard's successor.

I think Nika Ace would actually use Toon force to see Imu's lights and either deviate the beam away or escape before it strikes. Luffy did grab a lightning bolt after all

@raeshonsanchez1187

Жыл бұрын

I'm honestly not sure how that would work and we are unsure how Imu's light works but your theory is possible

@Athorment

Жыл бұрын

@@raeshonsanchez1187 Yeah, it's as big of an assumption to think that Imu's light would kill Kaido... or if Shanks could just split it the same way he and Whitebread can split the skies.

@projekttaku1

Жыл бұрын

@@Athorment or the idea that it can take out 3 yonko's and gear 5 ace.

@leyte68

9 ай бұрын

Luffy Deflects Kizaru’a Blast

I don't know if ace would awaken like that, he was pretty depressed when he would be executed, if he died there he would not be on "synchrony" with the nika nika. When he died he smiled without regrets though, but that was only because Luffy saved him first, something would have to make him snap out of that sadness first for him to awaken.

@xahxyy1551

Жыл бұрын

No, the fruit makes the owner happy and free. Because the fruit has the desire to liberate and makes everyone around the owner happy

@EpicMugenBattles

Жыл бұрын

I'm pretty sure nika couldn't regenerate a chunk of his body lmao

@neutralshadow9717

3 ай бұрын

I also think Ace wouldn't awaken because Kaido explained that an awakening can only happen when a Devil Fruit user's mind and body catch up to their powers, I feel like Ace would not be ready yet. The devil fruit after all haven't been awakened for 800 years it could go for more...

Simple...Blackbeard wouldve been Pirate King...Blackbeard wouldve killed this daddy issued boy Ace.

@DrooledOn

Жыл бұрын

No buggy become king easily

@TheOne11111

Жыл бұрын

He already said in the video. Blackbeard will die in Impel Down. Watch it. That is interesting.

@VidraruSRL

Жыл бұрын

First of all, without luffy the gomu gonu no mi would be eaten by ace, shanks wanted to give Ace the fruit since he thought ace was joyboy, but the fruit chose luffy

@plotholedetective4166

Жыл бұрын

Actually I don't think so because ace would have been different having not grown up with Luffy thusly making his interaction with white beard different which would change literally everything including teach getting his hands on his devil fruit. It would also change shanks trajectory so much his story would be unrecognizable.

@MrArkuz

Жыл бұрын

I'm not buying that everyone dies at Marineford. I would like to think that strongest survives. Ace, Kaido, Shanks etc. Not sure about Whitebeard 😅 And then 3 yonkos and new Joyboy turns against Imu and Gorosei. Let's throw revolutionaries to this final war as well. Plus, I'm completely fine with Blackbeard being killed by Magellan 😎

What I love about this is that even without Luffy, the world still spins. It's just that most of his friends die. It's very in line with his character of caring more about being a hero for his friends than for the world.

@seesemeseeds1217

Жыл бұрын

I will say this a lot of stuff does change in this with how like 3 Yonkos die

@yourpapa697

10 ай бұрын

true. zoro would die, usopp, kaya, and syrup village will die, alabasta will be taken over by crocodile, zeff would probably fight don krieg in baratie, cocoyashi village will also be never freed from arlong, gaimon will probably never see humans again, etc.

@yourpapa697

10 ай бұрын

iceburg dies too aswell as his company

@yourpapa697

10 ай бұрын

the foxy pirates wouldn't have been humiliated if it wasnt for afro luffy

Luffy has saved so many lives without even knowing.

love it. Dunno about Imu being able to kill all those powerhouses with that move, but it was really fun to watch/listen

Damn Ohara, this video is banger, this could have been made into spin off series!!!!!!!! 🤩Such great IDEA!

@Snoozy96

Жыл бұрын

More than 95 percent of this were fan theories from other people... all he did was make a video on it.

@Reference377

Жыл бұрын

90% of the video was taken from Suge Senpai Comparisons...Just search for the title...He made this video over 1 month ago...Still this is a great video, but yeah, this was not really Ohara's idea

@trimex7234

Жыл бұрын

@@Snoozy96 I mean yeah, but it's also not like those theories bring unthinkable ideas to the table, it's just what would obviously happen when you remove luffy from the plot. Although I do understand he mostly used common ideas made by other people about what would happen

I think Luffy is the one piece. In treasure maps, you have X marks the spot for the prize mark. Luffy got the X mark in his chest. That's is what Roger has been waiting for... The One Piece of a Person who will save their world.

@DC-rb3uz

Жыл бұрын

That's an amazing theory bro.

@savo6070

Жыл бұрын

You think Roger traveled to Laugh Tale and discovered Luffy before hiding him?

My biggest correction has to be Nami, and it is darker. The villagers, upon learning that Nami was betrayed, would have done the same thing and challenged Arlong. Nami continuing to chart and steal isn't consistent - she knows they all die. Nojiko and Genzo and everyone dies. She begins to stab her tattoo, as we know. But Luffy won't grab her hand after some moments. No one does. And even if she were to choose to stop stabbing her arm in that day, I can see the result being the same another day, once it sinks in. And once she starts stabbing, she doesn't stop until she's dead.

Big Mom finally getting the respect she deserves.

@skyanimates7409

Жыл бұрын

Omb😂

@RogBearD

Жыл бұрын

ok bruh...

Here I am almost shedding a tear having been waiting for this very video forever!

I was really confused when I saw this in my subscription box because I have been watching a smaller One Piece KZreadr, named Pyro Prima, uploading an entire fan story surrounding the scenario of What If Luffy Was Never Born, and now suddenly Ohara talks about the very same topic, one year after he started.

@pyroprima

Жыл бұрын

Just been enjoying Oharas newest upload, and then I actually found someone who watches my videos. Yep I've been doing a detailed "What If Luffy Was Never Born", since over a year now. At first it was strictly about Luffys journey, however at a later point I shifted over to a more original fanstory.

@NutsInYourMouth

Жыл бұрын

Well...i would see it as an honor... manu's channel is pretty big in the community... if your theories get rewritten by channels like Liam's or Manu's, its not that far fetched. Means also your content is interesting and a inspiration to others.

@lucieb.7991

Жыл бұрын

There are tons of fanfictions and doujis with this exact same "what if"-scenario. Some of these fan projects are even 20 years old! its not a new idea

@raiden3988

Жыл бұрын

@@lucieb.7991 obviously there have been many cases of the same what if scenario, but its still a coincidence that can be spoken about

This is the best Alternative one piece theory ever.. You are the best Ohara❤️

I honestly think it's a bit presumptuous to think that Shanks would have given the fruit to Ace or even that he knew Ace existed I think there is a possibility that he might have eaten it himself other than that tho I think Robin would have stayed with Crocodile because she would be to valuable to him also I think he would have teamed up with Gekomoria to try and take down Kaido so he could get the Pluton they would have obviously failed and Kaido would have found Robin in Crocodiles crew and offered her a good spot on his crew and she would have no reason to refuse a good deal with an emperor since it's a pretty safe place to be and with Robin at his side he probably would become Pirate King and would fight Shanks at Laugh Tale... As for Marineford it's a bit too presumptuous to say that Imu's erasure would work on an emperor class enemy we don't have enough info on it's capabilities yet...

Loved the derpy music when we got to the person who actually became pirate king according to this scenario :'D

ohara in the fanfiction mode, im here for it

Ohara has been on fire with his quantity of uploads recently in comparison to a few years back

I think Ace never had the mentality to become joyboy and therefore won't awaken the fruit. Also I guess the fruit wouldn't let itself be eaten by him in the first place. The fruit might search for a worthy owner for another 800 years 😅

@blair5475

Жыл бұрын

What do you mean the fruit wont let someone eat it?

@lLegas

Жыл бұрын

@@blair5475 The fruit seems to have a will on its own. I think its similar to the ring in Lord of the Rings, if you know that.

@blair5475

Жыл бұрын

@@lLegas Really? Where did you get this from?

@ShifuSage

Жыл бұрын

@@blair5475 Stated in the manga. Its said that zoans have a will of their own and knowing the nika fruit avoided the world government for so long also suggests that it has a stronger will then other zoans fruits.

@blair5475

Жыл бұрын

@@ShifuSage But the world govt had captured the fruit before Shanks went to intercept it.

You should do another what if set on a world where Luffy became a marine. As for Ace and Sabo, they would still become a pirate and a revolutionary respectively, making the three brothers stand on each of the three major factions of the One Piece world.

Well Camie and Papug die being eaten by a sea monster since Hachi never saves them in the cover story. Also i feel that Robin would tell Crocodile about the ponyglyph since there is no member of the D clan that peeks her interest. By telling Crocodile she can remain under a warlord and be safe from the WG even finding more ponyglyphs along the way. Crocodile would obviously plot to overthrow Kaido and can find an easy comrade in Moria.

this was an interesting video. You should make it into a series and do one for every strawhat

Literar Chills in the second part of the video. Epic work

I think it’s interesting to consider what would happen with the gomu gomu no mi if luffy didn’t exist It’s said in the manga that zoan fruits, especially mythical ones, have a mind of their own. Maybe the fruit would have chosen ace if luffy wasn’t born

Bro, can you make a "Recap" of every saga? I wanna reread or re-watch one piece to make sense of everything to the minute detail but with studies and all, it'll take me like a couple of years to do that now😅🙃

wow, that little sound in the beginning really prepared me for the vibe of despair this video holds :O

Ohara dude your videos are so awesome and I can see you put your op smarts and common sense in every video like your videos are 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Ace wouldn’t get Luffy’s fruit because Shanks never knew Ace. Remember how Ace set out when he was first a pirate, he went to Shanks and his crew in a snowy mountain. He wanted to thank him for saving Luffy but Shanks thought he was there to fight and he didnt knew Luffy had a brother.

@MulahFR

Жыл бұрын

I was thinking about that too but your comment made me conclude my decision that it was true. Thanks

Lets start 1. Zoro is executed 2. Nami is an endless cycle of paying arlong till she is killed by someone bad 3. Usopp is in depression / dead 4. Sanji wastes away, baratea is taken but they live and restart. 5. Nothing crazy happens to buggy, who lives a low profile life 6. Coby is stuck with alvida 7. Alabasta is destroyed, crocodile knows about plooton but doesnt dare attack kaido. 8. Chopper dies / goes monster point and wallops the hippo guy 9. Brook roams the florian triangle till his soul breaks 10. Nothing happens in saboady, no admirals were summoned .... Etc etc Basically everything is messed up

Manu, please create more 'what if' content like this

wow that explantion was really good. keep up the good work

Definitely wouldn’t have guessed that ending 😭

There's no way the nika fruit wouldn't influence Ace to act in some circumstances as Luffy did. I think primarily Wapol is a definite target Ace would definitely, easily notice and feel compelled to interfere, probably earning Chopper as a crewmate as well as granting drum island independence and the Whitebeard pirate's protection, even if reluctant protection.

@MagicCardboardBox

11 ай бұрын

If the fruit influences people in that way anyway, carnivore fruits make people slightly more bloodthirsty, there's never been any indication of full on mind control, it's weird to assume it.

0:06 when it says king, thats a perfect profile picture or when it says pirate

Das ist mal eine richtig gut durchdachte Alternative Timeline!! Cooles Video!! Vielen Dank!

And to think about it, I feel like Crocodile and Moria could have an alliance against Kaido. Their goals just perfectly align. They will still not be able to do anything unless they will acquire some more powerful allies, but their war against Kaido might be much more impactful than we think. Ok, I reached the point of Marineford and I think these two will definitely fight Kaido as shichibukais, this will be a perfect opportunity to take him down.

I love how much he impacted the world in only half of his journey. Without luffy the world would be destroyed before he was supposed to learn haki

@godemperorofmankind3.091

7 ай бұрын

What? No. The world is closer to war and destruction because of luffy. Without him the Balance of Powers is intact and its more or less business as usual

Woah was this video good!!! Did not expect that! But it made too much sense

love your content

Not sure Camie would have been kidnapped. She would have died after being eaten by the sea boar as Hatchan would still be working for Aarlong.

what would happen if Luffy was Rogers son.

@masterdomc5977

2 ай бұрын

Egg

bro this was just a big fat wow.. how do you even think of all of this then remember it you gotta be the most creative person ever

holy shit!!!!! what you said at 14.30 is just unreal!(damn oda! why does that man has to be that good of a writer!) I can definately see this going down! joyboy and 3 yonko in the same place? for sure he use that power!

Camie Would probably be alright, she was caught by bandits who only left to work because of Sanji the pirate and his wanted poster, witch wouldn’t have happened unless the Vinsmokes put out a wanted poster only alive(for a wedding) and we’re going off memory of what he looked like.

Pretty sure Sanji would not have been brought to whole cake because he would never have gained a bounty therefore no one in Germa would even know he was alive

This gave me goosebumps

This absolutely fantastic

no way man, i like to think Robin would find herself with Dragon eventually. the last oharan, i dont think dragon would let her fate be so dark

You really put your thought in it. I like it, its interesting. It could be a good One Piece movie called Unborn Luffy😅

I think that during Aces fight with blackbeard he would have awaken his fruit so Ace never goes to Marineford and "passes away".

This is so cool!! Would you mind to create another video telling 'what if luffy did not eat nika fruit at chapter 1'

Rip all the strawhats, ace would probably not get rescued since the straw hats carried

How would they know sanji was alive if he never gets a wanted poster ?

Yesss I believed the Ace thing as well as it was weird that Shanks of course explored the East blue with that fruit and how he ended up in the island Luffy and Ace was at. Events just had Luffy eat it before Ace did.

Nice Video 👍

Kaido joins Ace after he finds out he’s Joyboy? Why wouldn’t he have joined Luffy then

I'm not sure Ace would come back to life like luffy did if akainu puts another whole in his chest annihilating his heart...the drums of liberation was the sounds of luffy's heartbeat

Mihawk really said “nah i aint getting paid enough for this, i’m out.” And that was a pretty good decision judging by the fact that Marineford gets entirely annihilated.

Unrelated but my goodness ur background music selection is FIRE! what are the songs??😭

I dont think Shanks would have pulled up to Marinford if Luffy didn't exist. I think he'd still try and stop Kaido from entering the war.

I wonder if the fight between Teach and Ace would still have happened the way it did. Sure, Ace wanted to bring Blackbeard to justice for what he did, but Blackbeard's intention were to give Luffy to the Government, which made Ace absolutely snap and go into an all out fight with Blackbeard. Even if this fight would have happened, the result might have been different. I am not saying that Ace would've defeated Teach but he might had the chance to trick them, given that he had different powersand maybe a bit of help from crewmembers this time. I know as well that Blackbeard's Devilfruitpower is kind of OP with the whole erasing of Devilfruit abilities but maybe Ace had stronger Haki at that time, given that he had no protection from the Fire-Fire-Fruit I aint sure how much that would've effected their fight but I think it would've made a difference

Hey ohara. You should make more of these what ifs.

@loturzelrestaurant

Жыл бұрын

14:30: ?????

Very great video!!!

Honestly. If you believe in the theory that fruits pass on the personality of its previous users/or changes people's personalities then you could come to the conclusion that the story could have been exactly the same if it was ace. Minus the marineford arc. Or that that's where it would start having major changes, as instead of whitebeard, it could have been all the people ace helped and the remaining members of the roger pirates and the straw hats. Honestly I could see that being the original idea if that arc was the original ending of the series somehow which I personally think that if oda would have stuck with his original timelines marineford would have been the end. Ironic that I post this before full spoilers of this week's chapter. Spoilers. I may be right about there might not have been much of a change.

I think you skipped over the part of Shanks talking good about Roger to Ace. Ace knowing that Roger did what he did because he was already dying, saying Roger was trying to make sure the future could happen, and explaining why everything has happened the way it did. This could of changed Ace’s viewpoint of Roger as Ace hated Roger due to how people talked about him and how Ace’s life ended up. Imagine having a good influence near him, aka his adopted older brother there to talk to him about things.

Very Jazzy Vid good stuff

I love this what-if style video

Theory time, the reason Shnaks was able to talk with the five elders is because he is rocks d xebecs son. There is a video on Shanks and why he is rocks son, but let's consider he is, Rocks was trying to destroy God valley or kill everyone there (I don't know the specifics), but, as we know, God valley disappeared without a trace, hinting that Imu could of wiped it off the map. Considering this, Shanks was able to meet with the gorosei, as an "Exception" because his father had the same goal as I'm Sama, to destroy God valley

@newt2120

Жыл бұрын

i literally played chess against you lmao

It's all fine but why are you considering that all the yonkos would just die. They are the strongest people on the planet and together can't they survive one attack? Even if it's barely still I believe that they would survive the island blaster attack and the story would continue.

love the re zero sound fx in the beginning lmao

Goes to show one person can make a huge difference so be that person

Here are some other changes like: - For Hancock she would have either sublime to her love sickness killing her in the process like the previous ruler or that since she said no to Momonga then she will become a target of the Marines even before the War begins - Since Came would have been sold off then Hachi & Pappag would've risked their lives to save them - Without Sanji setting him straight then Duval & the Flying Fish Riders would continue being thugs who deal with Human Trafficking - Without Luffy & the Straw Hats not interfering then on Little Garden Mr.3's plan to have Dorry be killed by Brogy then after he is weaken then Mr.3 can collect the 200,000,000 Berries for Baroque Works can use that money to fund for Crocodile to take Wano since Kaido may have died during Marineford - Kin'emon, Momo, & the children that Caesar was experimenting on would have been stuck & even die on Punk Hazard while Law would have been captured by Monet & Vergo thus giving Doflamingo the ability to get him to use that eternal youth surgery which would kill him - Speaking of Dressrosa every citizen like Kyros & the contestants of the Tournament would be still forgotten remaining as toys along with Viola being his tool & Rebecca is killed

That's actually a better turn of events than the actual story

Great video

My guy just spoiled the entire Ohara is alive for me, nice

I think I'll wait to see if Sabo is still alive before I assume that all three parties would die...

"Brook never meets Luffy and suffers till eternity"

Haha, I love the Re:Zero noise when things get changed😂🍿

0:30 brother really put a silhouette of crocodile when talking about luffy's mysterious mother💀 Feeding the crocomom theories is wild ohara😂

Nah the Gomu Gomu Nomi can escape which means Shanks can’t just pass it to anyone because it chooses the chosen one itself by prophecy. So if Luffy wasn’t born Shanks wouldn’t have the fruit in the first place UNLESS Ace was another “chosen one”..

I knew it no cap seeing big mom i thought to myself when seeing her she will become a queen

7:20 I think you might not be 100% correct bc if marineford still happens Jimbe will still be arrested and lose his status that’s protecting arlong so nami might be freed by the marines or arrested

Also a lot changes in the Ace light novel as well which would impact the story that would be fun to dive into. Now I want an ace eating the Gomu Gomu no mi story line xD

This was dope

dude that goes to far!!! dont imagine a world without luffy......

Goodman this was a good good video.

nice work

0:02 was that sound from re:zero? I remember it but I don't know where it's from

I don't think shanks ever knew about ace until they met on the grand line, even at that point he had no clue roger had a son.

That is incredible hahahaha omg I love it!

Ace being Joy Boy in this alternate timeline is cool!