This conversation is incredible. I would say that Protestants would not even feel allowed to talk about these things. They simply assume that Mary and Joseph had relations and went on with a common life. But they forget that these two individuals were in a rather special apostolate. They were totally consecrated to raising the Son of the Living God to manhood. I'm sure they all three took out the garbage and cooked chicken for dinner and swept the floors, but there was something extraordinary about them that cannot be denied. We want them to be just like us, and they were, but then again, they weren't.

@kelechukwuanosike767

3 жыл бұрын

@@tony1685 you know nothing about the Bible. Joseph and Mary lived in this world, the house they lived is still available, people say them, there are writings about their lives by people who saw them especially the Jews who lived in Judea. This truth is not only available in the Bible, but available in historical records. Your ignorance and hate for the Blessed virgin Mary is because you hate Jesus

@nehaelis8323

3 жыл бұрын

@@tony1685 Jesus was a jews and Jewish people don't accept him as saviour. Jewish people have lived with him there are many more things to learn than to debate on Bible to understand more about Jesus.

@Hypocrisywatch1

2 жыл бұрын

Good old Joseph ..comes home to his wife mary..never has sex with the virgin..and finds out she is pregnant..by immaculate conception..what total bs..then he gets written out of history

@kenle4168

8 ай бұрын

I like the fact no one knew it was Blessed Virgin Mary in love with Saint Joseph "first". 😊😊😊😊😊

@conniecostello3072

8 ай бұрын

Well you're a real joy to know. I guess some people just like to be mean. What are you going to do. @@kelechukwuanosike767

It's good to see Dr Hahn acknowledging that not everything is on the Bible

I love hearing people talk about people they’ve never met as if they know them better than their parents

Beautiful conversation

@paulmiller3469

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, it was.

This just blew me away. Thank you

It hurts Joseph when she cried. That moment when they shared an extreme bond together.

I love listening to these guys.

Some excellent beards in this video! In all seriousness what a thought provoking video. God Bless!

Yes relationship should be like mary and Joseph we should put god 1st in our relationship and both should never give up.should face the difficulty which are coming between relationship.

Beautiful!

Thank you

Two of my favorite people 🙌 God Bless you both Dr Scott and Fr Calloway

You guys are great! I want to meet you one fine day😊

The two superpowers of Catholism!

spot on, great talk. Thank you

one wonders if, when Jesus spoke of angelic marriage, he had them in his mind as the example.

Dearest Saint Joseph, in this holy day of the Feast of the Holy Family, please send me a holy Catholic man for my husband and ask Almighty God to bless us with our own Children who will grow up to love and serve the Lord all their days until death! I ask this in the Holy name of Jesus, if it be His will! Amen! 🙏

Wow

I'm really curious. I wonder who knew more each other, Joseph or Mary?

Are these video snippets of Fr. Calloway and Dr. Hahn part of a video series that is out somewhere?

What is the name of the book Fr Donald Calloway speaks about in this video?

@kathydethman7218

3 жыл бұрын

The book he wrote, Consecration To St. Joseph. Great book!

Not competitive ❤😊

As one who has recently converted to Catholicism from Protestantism I am trying to learn and understand the doctrines of the Catholic faith. In short I am in agreement with most of it's doctrines and while yes I do believe in the immaculate conception I am still struggling to understand the basis for the perpetual virginity of the Blessed Mother. Especially given the verse Matthew 1:25 ( but knew her not( meaning Joseph) until she had given birth to a son. ) Such phrasing as I understand it has always referred to an "Intimate act" between a man and woman. Is there anyone that can lead me to the right direction in reconciling the teachings of the Church on the Blessed Mother that appears contrary to the verse in Matthew.1:25? I ask with total deference.

@arturmonteiro8541

3 ай бұрын

If I say to you, "Until we meet again, God bless you" does that mean after we meet again, God curse you?

A late friend of mine used to say " sex is for babies". There are some marriages that survive on pure companionship and great rapport without conjugal relations.

@kenle4168

Жыл бұрын

Sex is not for babies, sex is for love. You can have sex and make babies but not in love with each others.

Even Joseph doesn't express his emotions to Mary

Excellent logic and talk to be under protection of a at. Mary and st. Joseph!

Mmm was joseph handsome because we always see him as a man with old with jesus as baby? Even movies always plays joseph old .

What an amazing way of twisting the truth .. but I guess since most people don’t read, they would never understand the level of deception.. wake up folks..

How is Jesus from the line of David (from his father, Joseph) if he was immaculately conceived and has none of David's DNA?

@dailybread300

Жыл бұрын

The Immaculate Conception refers to Mary’s birth, not Jesus.

Virgin Mary doesn't care if Joseph is son of God. Joseph doesn't care if virgin Mary was the beautiful woman of all. All they both care is both really loves each others.