This series is so underrated.. or is it? I feel it will be legend.

@mediocrates3416

3 жыл бұрын

Depends on how it ends😂😂

@hello_world_0

3 жыл бұрын

The content of this channel is outstanding

@fuhq5121

3 жыл бұрын

I'm guessing you haven't seen the previous episodes.

@mediocrates3416

3 жыл бұрын

@@fuhq5121 A joke. 😂😂😂

@andrewphillips6783

3 жыл бұрын

Closer to Truth is the real deal

Pleasantly surprised that Closer To Truth is still on.

This series is one of the very best.

Love this channel. Thank the universe for internet and KZread.

This channel needs to be subscribed by at least 20 million people

Goethe once liked to say that one thing about the condition of being an architect was that the architect never gets to live in the structures the architect designs. This may or may not relate to Hegel's idea of being for-others (as opposed to being for-oneself), and as architecture goes language too has an architecture, but any architect who designs a building for another to live in is in a sense caring for that other.

@BillyMcBride

3 жыл бұрын

Also, I am excited about your enthusiasm and quest as well as the other scientists' in your well-done video. Thank you.

I enjoy these broadcasts very much. The art of the question is often demonstrated and skilfully drawn, and the people he speaks to are intellectual, reasoned and often very funny. There’s an old adage that says “never read the comments”, but one might expect the viewership of such a thoughtful series to have a little more to offer and more in the way of curiosity to discuss and converse. So, I’m pleased to say that the comments below are largely like that... er, no, wait, hang on..... *sighs*, oh dear. OK, note to self, never read the comments.

@chamade166

3 жыл бұрын

OK boomer

This show is awesome

I agree, underrated! Fantastic interviews.

Goes on forever expanding like a balloon with god observing outside the universes in a different spiritual realm

We are like a virus on a wiper blade trying to understand how the truck came about.

@michaelhall2709

3 жыл бұрын

Wow, that’s great. I’m stealing it. 😊

@Tom_Quixote

3 жыл бұрын

Not really, because we are able to look extremely far away and understand extremely much compared to how small we are. The virus doesn't even know it exists.

@chamade166

3 жыл бұрын

@@Tom_Quixote How do you know you exist and it's not just the universe experiencing itself?

@michaelgermanovsky1793

3 жыл бұрын

@@chamade166 it's exactly what it is....the universe...we are each just a prospective in time spread around a sphere...looking at itself

@TeodorAngelov

3 жыл бұрын

@@Tom_Quixote There are no perfect analogies/metaphors

We need more longer episodes

Yay! Another episode of Kuhn and Friends!

Thank you, for your great documentaries.

Interestingly, if you Google "Brain Cell The Universe" and click on the image tab, you'll see side by side images that for all intents and purposes shows that the Universe on a massive scale resembles brain cells on the micro scale. 'As above, so below' etc etc - all cool stuff. Thanks for video, great episode.

@Scribe13013

3 жыл бұрын

Yeppity deppity doo

@Only1INDRAJIT

3 жыл бұрын

Most probably a classic instance of pareidolia

@robertruark8797

3 жыл бұрын

I have often wondered if we're possibly just a small part of another immensely large being.

@CristinaG

3 жыл бұрын

@@robertruark8797 Yes, and respectively, what quantum realms exist in our own neurons?!? Great day-dreaming fodder for a lazy Sunday afternoon lol !

Just want to thank you for this channel as always your topics are valued to what we all should be searching for. As Truth can be subjective to those whom think they know it all.

Easy, with to uderstand all the other excellent presentations

does anyone know if one can find this awesome map online?

@jamesbentonticer4706

3 жыл бұрын

Search 'Logarithmic map of the universe'.

@_ilincic

3 жыл бұрын

@@jamesbentonticer4706 But I wanna specifically that one. I tried on google but I haven't been lucky enough to find it. If someone can manage to get their hand on it plz link it here.

@Chris-vr8cd

2 жыл бұрын

That was the most mind blowing map of the universe I have ever seen

Awesome, better than fairy tale talk.

The guy who was speaking around the 19:30 mark said that "every single one of the stars in the sky was produced from a quantum fluctuation". From what I previously have understood, it's not the case that every single star(or clump of mass for that matter) was each individually brought about by a quantum fluctuation, but rather, there was ONE quantum fluctuation that produced it all. It's a subtle difference, but if one commits himself/herself to saying that each star was brought about by its own personal quantum fluctuation, then that would be an extremely unparsimonious answer to the problem. Just think of how unlikely it would be for every single star(or particle for that matter) to have its own quantum fluctuation that produced it? That would be wild speculation and very unparsimonious. But to say that one quantum fluctuation produced these, seems to be a very simple yet powerful explanation that doesn't fall prey to the same objection.

@sven888

2 жыл бұрын

Most excellent.

This is such an amazing series. Even with the dyslexia typo, that map is incredible. Does anyone know where to find a copy?

This proves that the earth is the centre of the universe. Amazing!😉

my wife is vast and expanding

@David-on1mr

3 жыл бұрын

I know

Recent research indicates it wasn't "Gravity operating alone", and that Electromagnetism played (and continues to play) a significant part in the developmental structure of the universe, some scientists believe it may be the dominant force in the process.

@ferdinandkraft857

3 жыл бұрын

@Ψ Thanks for alerting.

@nihlify

3 жыл бұрын

Hello pseudo-scientist believer.

@espaciohexadimencionalsern3668

3 жыл бұрын

If at first was plasma that to me is neutral state, then it was not alone due that plasma is the made of a hot matter state and a cold one so to make a system we need of the 3 states just like water cicle here in earth.

@espaciohexadimencionalsern3668

3 жыл бұрын

@Ψ plasma alone just wont do a cicle you need hot evaporated matter or light and cold matter or cold light to do a cycle.

@erixoz8535

2 жыл бұрын

Well, E&M is 10^39 times stronger.

Loeb is awesome

❤ Very good 👍🏼

Wonderful. I wish I had a map of the universe.

One dimension (ours) falling into a heavier dimension, pulled faster at the ends,(like water over a fall) stretching out all matter in between.

Everything you experience is happening within your individual MIND that is created much like an AI system that speaks.

I was impressed that the Princeton man mentioned Pioneer 10 the poor old Pioneers tend to get skipped and you'd think that the Voyagers where the first man made interstellar probes when you read the history our outer solar system exploration.

Anyone else notice the mispelt 'Quark'? @ 4:02 😉

The universe as a collection of material things and observing conservation of mass has a centre of gravity which is also a superblackhole , around which supergalaxies revolve, while galaxies revolve around its respective centre in an individual supergalaxy , and even smaller systems like the Solar System revolves around the centre of its own galaxy.

Omg, I love this channel. It's just mind-blowing, truly wonderful. 💫💥💫 I want that map but my flat is not big enough.

This is amazing work!!! Thank you

37 seconds into the portentous, "To Boldly Go........." intro and I'm baling.

@HyzersGR

2 жыл бұрын

Baling hay can wait. This stuff is important.

Hope you enjoy Iceland

Where can I get that map of the universe?

Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful... I'm full of wonder and can't get enough of it... By the way, I think having noticed a small error on the map...: The "Up Qaurk"...? Or, is it on purpose written differently..? Great thanks to Robert L. K. to make it possible for us to "meet" all these extraordinary people and let us get a glimpse of the fascinating scientific life of those great people...!! It is so beautifully done! Bravo Robert, and another thanks!

Dear Robert Lawrence Kuhn, can i get a copy of Gott's map of the universe please. can i get it somewhere ?

Cosmic scaffolding. Something to hang the galaxies on. That may be what’s growing at a faster rate and causing the universe to expand. We’re individual memories in a cosmic brain

The explorations of these ideas in science, and this program, are best when the interviewer poses thoughtful, well-researched, and non-trivial questions and lets the scientists expound on their responses to their logical conclusion. It is helpful to have the restatements in concise formulation, but the focus should be on the science, not the presenter.

Spacetime.

Where did all the matter come from? I'm just not getting that part. From Plank scale to galaxy is a heck of a lot of matter from seemingly nowhere. What am I missing?

@jedi4049

Жыл бұрын

God

@dayglowjim

Жыл бұрын

@@jedi4049 Really? I don't think there's any such thing.

@jedi4049

Жыл бұрын

@@dayglowjim keep searching forever you wont get the answer. Ppl would rather believe a random fluctuation from nothing over God and that is sad.

What I don't understand is how a hydrogen cloud coalesce to eventually start a fusion reaction. Gravity is mentioned but isn't gravity the result of bending spacetime? How can a cloud of hydrogen accomplish that feat?

We still are not sure whether such really Large Structures like Sloan Great wall Large quasar groups or Hercules Corona borealis are structures or chance alignment of certain objects. More data needed

Anyone notice the "Up Qaurk" at the center of the map?

@jonrutherford6852

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, and also "Alpha Centuari" later. These observations did not inspire confidence.

So exactly what direction is this ship headed in that we near closer to truth captain?

The Life-Structure is the same eternal structure, mirrored in the rainbow, Large and small-scale, (size) have to do with the Perspective-Principle. From a Micro-Perspective, our bydy-structure looks in principle the same, Space and Particles.

The central neutron in the central iron atom in the core of the Earth has a typo. Explains a lot.

By my calculations, the universe is a 4 dimensional hotdog bun.

@NightBazaar

3 жыл бұрын

Please pass the mustard and relish. I think the hotdogs are ready.

If it's dark _energy_ can it be transformed into mass like regular energy? And is that mass like regular mass?

Is a famous book by Jim Peebles

too much for me .. thanks for this ... i like this stuff ... but have no understanding of it ..

💪🙏❤️

Galsxy siper cluster

The universe is actually not very big ---- we are just very, very small. Much much smaller than we even think.

@theliamofella

3 жыл бұрын

Everything is relative, but I agree that the universe could be considered small on a certain perspective

Ok, so this means one edge of the universe is the Big Bang and other side is neutron or even strings? Universe existing and creating within itself,simultaneously? Like it’s just there not having beginning or an end, wtf!

Don't you mean the universes?

That map is getting further away. Not only in space but in time. He is going back into the past. Can we sense someone else's past? If we cannot why is the universe's past a singular phenomenon?

Is it possible that our Universe looks the same now as it did when it begin four instance may be over time we see something different because it is distorted through time such as listening to a piece of music from 20 years ago the difference to listen to a piece of music now the clarity Within that music is different because of time and Technology.

@ferdinandkraft857

3 жыл бұрын

Nope, the early universe was extremely hot.

@sprocketslip4564

3 жыл бұрын

@@ferdinandkraft857 Damn. I am with you. It’s mind blowing . Somehow thought , I don’t think there’s a beginning nor an ending.. well of what we can Observe.

What if this accelerated expansion is due to the gravitational attraction of a much denser region that surrounds our observable universe? Maybe it's black because the gravity is so intense. Then you would have no need for any of this big bang from a microscopic point nonsense. And could the CMB be Hawkin radiation from this distant source that we're all moving towards?

@mattcorregan4760

2 жыл бұрын

You could be right. I think there are a lot of assumptions that are glossed over when they describe the small heterogeneity in the early universe that eventually lead to structure in the universe. I would imagine that other fields played a role in the development of the universe in a way that no one has even imagined. We are still in the "There be dragons" stage of cosmological understanding.

@troyyoung1121

2 жыл бұрын

Are you suggesting the expansion be due to the mother of all Supermassive Blackholes beyond our observable universe . Do Blackholes that large start from the death of extremely large stars to begin with .Or that it’s swallowed so much it’s become that large and gravitationally attractive

@mattcorregan4760

2 жыл бұрын

@@troyyoung1121 I would think if we were surrounded by a supermassive black hole that our universe would be beyond the event horizon of that black hole and subject to the extremely high gravitational forces of the black hole. The gravitational force would then cause the universe to collapse rather than expand.

episode 602? F*ck me! That's a lot, eh?

Qaurk?????

I just want this poor guy to wear jackets that fit.

When you can't see or probe any further, you assume that's the end of whatever, don't put your assumptions to anything you don't know, better to say you don't know than go through a big BS.

it's turtles...all the way down

Why do poets hate Nature so much? Well, by Nature I mean whatever is beyond the language which is untouchable by language. Of course, poets say that they love Nature, and they even sing about it with their poems, but I think what they are singing about is in fact the vocabulary of Nature alone, which are the words we use for Nature, some of which the poets use in the songs they sing about Nature. The same goes, I believe, for the Universe when scientists make theories, as the poets do poems, with a vocabulary in which, because they have inherited that special language, being human and all, the scientists become enthusiastic about the using of a scientific vocabulary. Scientists may hate the Universe in the same way that the poets hate Nature, but they say otherwise, literally, when they construct theories to share with others. I used the word “hate” not randomly, but I mean it only in a harmless manner. The music of the scientists, their spoken words, or written words, cover up this harmless hate for the Universe, if the Universe can be defined as not physically external, but externally beyond any language suitable for any use to talk about anything.

@ferdinandkraft857

3 жыл бұрын

Maybe it's a love-and-hate relationship. We love it but we want to encapsulate it in our equations. And we hate it when it runs away from this mathematical prison.

@BillyMcBride

3 жыл бұрын

@-GinPi Gamma the most recent idea I have had about nature is that it is ironic down to its core. I have a much better verbal imagination than visual, but I feel gratitude to the poets for sharing their visions of nature, things they experienced, their use of nature for storytelling, the life of another time, sometimes simpler than ours, sometimes not. If nature is always fleeting away from us, maybe it is because meaning is not sought within it, or those naturalized words which refer to nature as the poets use to describe it? I am a Harold Bloom fan to my own core, but what I was saying in this comment about the irony, I believe connects to Paul de Man's deconstructive criticism. Thanks for your comment.

God or Big Bang. Gotta say, alot of faith needed on both sides to believe what is thought to be true..

@jordans962

3 жыл бұрын

Why are they mutually exclusive? I don't get this...

daft punk 🎮 RANDOM ACCESS MEMORIES

The "large" scale structure of the universe is the INFINITE number of THINGS that make up the INFINITE universe! They just so happen to be the "small" scale structure too! "Things" create and are the largest "structure" or part of the universe, they are the "FLUID" that fills the INFINITE universe! The rest is ALL action/reaction!

@ferdinandkraft857

3 жыл бұрын

B.S.

@terrywheelock9458

3 жыл бұрын

@@ferdinandkraft857 🤣

I'm getting more concerned about the growing tones of certainty regarding the origin and nature of the universe. These theories should be presented as working hypotheses. A little humility please, we have a long way to go yet.

It’s not the whole universe on one map lol it’s the entire known universe. Obviously there’s more outside of that we just haven’t been given the time to see it. Ignore me I’m an idiot

@reembagadi7875

3 жыл бұрын

Someone said we just discovered 0.01% of it

@NightBazaar

3 жыл бұрын

We will likely never be able to fully see beyond the cosmic horizon since the expansion of the universe is accelerating faster than light could ever reach us.

@deeehmt_305

3 жыл бұрын

@@NightBazaar so what your saying is that what we see now is all that we will ever see. That actually as time passes we will see less and less? That would mean everything is speeding up away from us which would mean we’re the center of the universe if that’s not the case the distance we could see would be different in different directions correct or no?

@infinitemonkey917

3 жыл бұрын

@@deeehmt_305 Everything is speeding away from us but we are not at the center. Every point in the universe also sees everything moving away just as we do.

@infinitemonkey917

3 жыл бұрын

The map is the observable universe which has a radius of 46 billion light yrs.. The actual universe is 250 times larger. In a sense the universe is shrinking for us because galaxies that are currently reachable will eventually be unreachable due to moving away from us faster than the speed of light.

Make a video on Boltzmanns brains

I watch a lot of Closer to the Truth. I am just at the beginning of this one. I bet there is no mention of any part of the ideas behind plasma cosmology theories. No mention of the images showing the galaxies connected electrically forming the web structure seen in the x-ray images.

When you step "outside", it is not that big. How big is a circle? You tell me.

@ferdinandkraft857

3 жыл бұрын

Then go step outside.

@Cuplex1

3 жыл бұрын

How long is a piece of rope? You tell me. 🙂 As far as we know the universe is either infinite in size or at least 1000 times larger than the size of the visible universe which is the size of a sphere with 73 billion light years in diameter. (Non-linear expansion over ~13,8 billion years) The entire size is dependent on the curvature of the universe, as far as we can measure it is flat in topology.

These guys are tripping

We still need God to make sense of our place in the universe and not greater and larger structures. It's only the tip of the iceberg, the actual cosmos is way probably infinitely larger than what our telescopes can help us to see

@tomashull9805

3 жыл бұрын

God as the first cause... fine-tuning... abiogenesis... the creation of kinds or families of animals and vegetation...

@derreckwalls7508

3 жыл бұрын

It is not "we" who need God to understand our place in the universe, it is only "theists" who need God for that. I'm perfectly comfortable being an accident or coincidence of a universe in which God plays no part. And as an ex-Christian I found the description of God in the Bible to be very self-contradictory and disturbing, not to mention the "magic" needed to make the whole thing work. So God only confused my understanding of our place in the universe. What I see in human nature, the world, and the universe makes far more sense without God. You can't apply your own God understanding to everyone, because not everyone finds God necessary to understand meaning. Maybe there is no meaning, and that's what makes free will possible - not being obligated to some already defined purpose.

@tomashull9805

3 жыл бұрын

@@derreckwalls7508 How close are those to explaining the uncausal cause? None will be alive to hear how wrong thery were...

@tomashull9805

3 жыл бұрын

@@derreckwalls7508 Some just try to find out what the first cause was... some think it could have been God without cause... Others have no explanation... like you... just handwaving...

@derreckwalls7508

3 жыл бұрын

@@tomashull9805 Its not hand waving when someone says we don't know what the universe was like before a certain instant. And if you want to talk about a first cause, the only reason God is eternal is because you arbitrarily defined God as eternal. You have no evidence for it except that it is what you believe. You say the universe had to have a beginning, then I say so did God. You say God had no beginning, I say our known universe is just the most recent expression of an infinite cycle of universes that had no beginning. You can't just say God is eternal because that's the way you understand and define God. If you want a creator of the universe, then it is up to you to scientifically prove that God did it. Otherwise, there is no place for God in evidence based science, and all we can say is we don't yet know. Since you cannot prove or disprove God, there is no use for interposing a god into the explanation. You seem to have a misunderstand of the difference between evidence and definition. I can define the Spaghetti Monster as creator of all things, including your God. Prove that wrong. You can't, because that is what it is based only on its definition. Do you see how your logic breaks down? Until you prove there IS a God, you cannot prove anything else about it, much less that it created anything. Your beliefs and definitions are not testable evidence.

Robert Lawrence Kuhn need to talk with Sadhguru. I would like to see Robert's reaction after or maybe he can't react at all. :)

The maps kinda interesting.. but the earth is not a good place to start from if you want to know how the universe was created.. to do that one must start from a point of nothingness. From that valueless point.. dark matter and dark energy is created in equal and opposite parts.. space and space.. equal and opposite.. dm is negative polarity.. de is positive.. these two fields of space are what sets the quantum oscillations into motion.. which forms matter which forms gravity.. which causes galaxies.. so on and so forth.. but the inflation is created by the creation of space in the form of dm and de.

"The entire universe rolled out on one sheet of paper." This shows how language distorts the truth. Metaphors makes people misinterprete or misperceive. Every scientist should end what they say by saying ,"oh, but i may be wrong". Have they?

IN THE BEGINNING GOD CREATED EVERYTHING .

@eddielopez2373

3 жыл бұрын

TWO PLUS TWO IS FIVE! See? Typing in all caps doesn’t make a statement true.

All the interviewees here are talking stupidities. There's no beggining and no end of the realm called "Universe", the so-called "gravitation" doesn't have an "attractive" effect at all ( Newton's attractive force is a huge error, but his other "considerations" are correct ( which ones?...). /Einstein's erroneous view of "gravitation" doesn't explain what is it that's "bent", and if the matter "bends" "something" ( which it doesn't! ), what would be the reason to do it?, etc; so, Einstein's erroneous theory is just a blind crapshoot, etc;/ the effect called "gravitation" is a reactive effect to the main active one, which is absolutely universal, at any scale micro and macro, a continuous uninterrupted causal chain, etc ), black holes do not exist, the dark matter and dark energy don't exist at all, etc. When you understand the main universal phenomenon, you don't need any of the useless, erroneous, and ridiculous theoretical epycycles, all regurgitated religiously by these sorry-arses interviewees-parrots-scientific-priests here who all manifest almost zero useful brain potence.