'What Is The Basis For CO2 Levels?': Doug LaMalfa Confronts Deb Haaland Over Interior Policy
Rep. Doug LaMalfa (R-CA) questioned Interior Secretary Deb Haaland at Wednesday's House Natural Resource Committee hearing about the Department of the Interior's FY2024 budget request.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes.com/membership...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
Пікірлер: 315
Absolute con artists and none of us should be tolerating these thieves. It's time to stand up to these people.
@philobetto5106
Жыл бұрын
way past due
@terryshepard8063
Жыл бұрын
Exactly 💯
@millymclarkin2486
10 ай бұрын
Doug needs to get rid of the mouthpiece in Redding California. Damn, I'll tell her something I know as fact and she is always telling me I'm wrong. 🤔
No laws, legislation, mandates, government agency orders, or spending bills should be created based on "no information" , and should be considered fraud against taxpayers and the state
@poppypottschannel
Жыл бұрын
I agree not a NICKLE more let it DEFAULT this is what is deserved when they spend like they do it really is the only WAY to StoP them and their theft
@terryshepard8063
Жыл бұрын
Thank You 💯
@eliteviktor3
Жыл бұрын
Because it is.
OMG...this woman is so unqualified to be doing that job 🤯
If I hear one more of these people say "Thank you very much for your questions but I have no idea what the answer is" I am going to throw up
@couleewildflowers
Жыл бұрын
Grab a large bucket
The percent of CO2 in our atmosphere is only .04% that is 4/100th of 1 percent, if we drop below .02% plant life starts to die off.
@Brucev7
Жыл бұрын
Mike Lee 'The only graph you need to see, is the Ice core record of global CO2 levels and the average temperatures. it's not even disputed science, it's made up data acquired by dozens of different scientists on both ends of the earth who analyzed the ice cores over several years, and it goes back tens of millions of years. What do they show? they show that at the time the earth was coldest, "snowball earth", or greatest ice age, the CO2 levels were over 20x what they currently are, at over 7000ppm (0.007%), they show that the average is about 3000pp, and it shows that at the end it takes this NOSE DIVE down to about 250 ppm, where it stayed until about a hundred years ago when it rose ever so slightly to the current level, 405ppm. At no point in the chart can you establish a correlation between CO2 levels going up and temperature going up.'
@user-sf2ed4ek3c
Жыл бұрын
Preach! While all these people exhale massive amounts of CO2 #sciencefacts. Plants and animals LOVE CO2.
@slchambers1
Жыл бұрын
Y’all are up on your assertions. Humans exhale 30 to 40 million ppm it depends on your ability to bloviate.
@darylredfield9121
Жыл бұрын
@Ah Stuttgart you buy in to the climate cult
@Clarkecars
Жыл бұрын
Spot on, I just posted the same before seeing your post.
NO one crying about the CO2 levels can tell you this answer.
@FaePanx
Жыл бұрын
Actually many do but they are called SCIENTISTS not activists or politicians. Also, his question seemed incoherent or just poorly worded.
@LadyDazzleDance
Жыл бұрын
Right! It's absurd!
@mrrey8937
Жыл бұрын
Wait till you find out what the Co2 levels were historically on earth going back to when dinosaurs roamed the earth. The level of hyperbole and hysteria by this cult today is laughable
@philobetto5106
Жыл бұрын
@@FaePanx core samples from the Antarctic glacier can't lie, we have the lowest co2 levels in 150k years
@warriorinagarden5624
Жыл бұрын
@@FaePanx Well, I had knowledge of another video where he asked it specifically to 3 people and they all thought it was 5% to 7%. The ONLY reason they got that close was the all copied the same guy's answer. You say SCIENTISTS like it is foreign to us.
None of the work they do is based on science, it is all politics follow the money
@mrrey8937
Жыл бұрын
No laws, legislation, mandates, government agency orders, or spending bills should be created based on "no information" , and should be considered fraud against taxpayers and the state
Why don't they ever have the evidence or the experts to explain their findings, always someone else's problems.
@juliebaggett9875
Жыл бұрын
Because this is another way for the elite to fatten their bank accounts. This global warming has been going on since the early 1950's!
@LadyDazzleDance
Жыл бұрын
Cause it's all smoke and mirrors baby to keep the money laundering scheme going.
@mrrey8937
Жыл бұрын
Because that data in comparison to earths historical data will show they are extreme and hyperbolic in their views about what is happening today.
@philobetto5106
Жыл бұрын
Randall Carlson geology ice core samples
@chrisbraswell8864
Жыл бұрын
Because this is the answer they don't have a clue what it is or why, it a poison gas so lets get it down to nothing at all cost and save the world. This is another Democratic hoax. They are spending all this money on high level jobs in Washington DC that are another waste of our money. Just like we have plenty, don't we. No we have none and it it worth less every day that Democrats are in charge. We are printing money.
This department head is USELESS!
What is the basis for STUPIDITY ?
@juliebaggett9875
Жыл бұрын
Creed!
@terryshepard8063
Жыл бұрын
Joe BIDEN
@MrSession11
Жыл бұрын
@Ah Stuttgart Oh no. Poor thing* Dont worry* It's okay. Even though you're very sensitive. But why are you so sensitive? What happened today in your life?
@mattharvey515
Жыл бұрын
@Ah Stuttgart No. It's the Democrats and the "scientists" who have been bribed by the Chinese. The Chinese are laughing at us. They know there is no climate emergency.
Should we not have someone who is actually rubbing a few brain cells together as the Secretary of the Department of the Interior?? Just asking!
@jerrybrickley2115
Жыл бұрын
Pocahontas checks all the right boxes, including brain cells.
The incompetence of Madam Secretary is amazing. It is only exceeded by her ignorance. She is supposed to know the basics to be able to do her job. The only thing she seems good at is collecting her pay and that is deposited into her bank for her.
@cziprick
Жыл бұрын
She fit the Profile. Why would they want to have someone in the position who actually knows what they're doing?
yet another Secretary in a job which she is unqualified. In private industry she would be fired.
They seem to forget that the planet was greener back during the Dinosaurs time and that was due to higher CO2 levels than we have today.
@scottcarr3264
Жыл бұрын
Yes, about 6 times the amount as now, and the World was a JUNGLE, and Plants give of OXYGEN, so that we can Breath, so do they want us all to die, from lack of Oxygen, just so they can get the co2 numbers down to where "THEY" want them. THAT is NOT Science.
@RattlerSSBN
Жыл бұрын
Yes...and there were a lot less Left-Woke-progressive Democrats...........ah, those were the days
One of the biggest changes in Washington needs to be how people are chosen for these important departments managing our countries infrastucture and our natural resources. Whenever I see these hearings they seem to be a waste of time, we ask questions no one seems to know the answers to or else they say, I can't answer that as every response. What are we paying them for, this would never be acceptable in our corporations or on everyday citizens jobs, you would be fired. So many of these postions are filled with political hires, people get high paying jobs for supporting, donating to or other IOU's, not because they are qualified. I am an everyday citizen and I would fire half of the people I see speaking to Congress on behalf of the citizens. This woman has evaded every question asked of her with roundabout answers that answer nothing.
@terryshepard8063
Жыл бұрын
This Is The Whole Administration They Are All X Walmart Employees
@shanen457
Жыл бұрын
If they actually answer the questions truthfully, they will incriminate themselves and the entire administration.
@bobwhite2
Жыл бұрын
She seems crooked.
@chrisbraswell8864
Жыл бұрын
By Democrats and by their Party.
@scottcarr3264
Жыл бұрын
She would do well in the Canadian Liberal Party, they Can't Answer Questions Either.
. Thank you so much for that question that I have no intention of answering.
"So much of our work is based on science". I'm filled with confidence.
@TheRealDrJoey
Жыл бұрын
So, is Fauci running that dept?
@PDDunn
Жыл бұрын
I like your answer. Had a good chuckle. Thanks!
The "Thank you so much for the question Senator" is a classic line for "I am not going to answer you"
@TheRealDrJoey
Жыл бұрын
It's also a strategy to run out the guy's 5 minutes w/o answering anything. What does a cabinet sec get PAID, anyway? She doesn't know what CO2 levels are???
@robertsmith2956
Жыл бұрын
They always leave off the implied, for not boxing me in more narrowly.
"Thank you for the question" must be made grounds for immediate dismissal.
Deb 'Philabuster' Haaland never answered a question. They're dumping the water down the river so fast homes are almost getting flooded while the lake is only at 1/3 capacity. This is an attack on our food growers.
@kellycarver2500
Жыл бұрын
ALL DELIBERATE DESTRUCTION OF OUR NATION ACCORDING TO SATANIST UN PLANS TO REDISTRIBUTE AMERICAS WEALTH! WHY DO U THINK THERE IS FOREIGN BEEF IN OUR STORES and they are DELIBERATELY KILLING OUR!? Our filthy gvt has been torturing and killing our helpless pets and loved ones, using our devices. Many yrs ago, my little short haired blk and tan mini doxy started having violent seizures every month. We took him to vet aftervet and they gave him meds that didn't help. I changed his diet, changed his water, and nothing helped. Sometimes the seizures were so bad he almost died, and we had to rush him to the vets to save his little life. I always cried and prayed when he had these seizures, because it hurt me so deeply to see my baby suffer so bad. Well, about a yr ago, my husband and I were sitting here in our living room and we heard his cell ph make a strange, hi pitched but quiet noise it never made for any reason, and IMMEDIATELY my dog started having seizures! I have been targeted over 30 yrs and never thought that the sick freaks could be deliberately CAUSING the seizures, BUT THEY WERE! I couldn't believe that someone could be so heartless and cruel that they could do such a horrific thing to a helpless little dog!! But they DID! The seizures stopped that day, and a week later my babydog went BLIND. I was heartbroken AGAIN, to see my bay walk into walls, fall down stairs (till we blocked them) and get lost behind a door or the couch!! HEART BREAKING!! His little organs swelled up inside of his belly, and the vet said it was his pancreas. My baby got very sick a couple weeks before Thanksgiving. He was vomitting, had the runs, and refused to eat for me. He was being SHOCKED every hour, night and day, and neither of us could get much sleep. I busted agents AGAIN, using the speakers on this PC to put out FREQUENCIES, hurting my little boy! I unplugged the speakers and then busted them again, using the built in speakers to emit these dangerous frequencies!! I shut down the pc and could still hear a high pitched whine coming directly from the MONARCH TOWER LLC across the street! My baby got so sick he couldn't even lift up his little head anymore and he died in my arms THANKSGIVING DAY about 4pm. I AM HEARTBROKEN and I miss my babydog terribly! THE SICK FREAKS TORTURED AND KILLED HIM just as the had the three prior to him before I realized what they were doing to us!! They are doing these horrific things to HURT US. They are sick satanist freaks who ENJOY hurting helpless, innocent people and animals that cannot defend themselves! Let me also say that they tested other bioweapons on us as well, which cost the life of my longhaired doxy, and nearly cost my life as well, a couple yrs ago. The sick freaks have put nanotech systems in the shots, masks, tests and swabs, and then using the towers to manipulate and control those systems inside the victims. They are also CAUSING inf, disease, organ damage and death w frequencies! WATCH YOUR DEVICES and keep vol low or off and never sleep near any devices!! These sick freaks MUST be stopped! They are deliberately killing us and our loved ones. This is ALL deliberate!
How did Haaland get her job? She appears to be completely ignorant of her job description.
@couleewildflowers
Жыл бұрын
She wasn't caucasian
@earnestleesaddened3779
Жыл бұрын
Maybe she just had to be as old as sleepy Joe.
O.O4%
ANYONE that is involved with the GW C02 issue that does NOT know what the percentage is should be FIRED.
They hate facts, metrics and real data.
WHAT? THEY ARE ARGUING FOR LOWER CO2 BUT DON'T KNOW THE LEVELS, UNBELIEVABLE
Unprepared. These secretaries are making gazillions & they can't even answer this.
@skydriver5709
Жыл бұрын
Their job isn't to actually know anything their agency knows. Their job as 'heads' is to just make sure everyone below them is working. Anytime you hear Congress call a head of an agency, they're calling the least knowledgeable person available. They do this so they can NOT get answers, point at them and blame them, look good to their constituents, get absolutely nothing done and waste tax payer money.
Rep. LaMalfa knows his district like the back of his hand. He is very knowledgeable about all of the relevant issues there. This "challenged" woman should have stayed as a backbencher in Congress. She is obviously waaay over her in her current job. She must know that she was selected to check a box. This is a sad situation, both for Sec. Haaland and our country. She is a microcosm for this entire incompetent, corrupt administration.
Did she say yes or no?
This lady is a prime example of what happens when you lie on a resume and accidentally get hired…. She never had a clue about anything
The were inept when answering questions ad nominees and are inept in their posts now.
When you are incompetent and as unknowledgeable as this woman, you should be fired. She doesn't know anything about what her department is basing decisions and actions on. Sad and shameful.
The Secretary of the Interior of the United States continues to issue excerpts from sixth-grade science project reports in response to most any question.
The more CO2--the better the plant life. An absolute Bumper crop, superfluous flowering plant life, etc., etc. It's called photosynthesis.
@joshkenney
Жыл бұрын
And we produce it and exhale it, which feeds the trees that give us oxygen to breathe!
@willcruz943
Жыл бұрын
@Ah Stuttgart you do understand that plants grow less and slower if the CO 2 levels are low, right? Tell me, what’s the average temperature in greenhouses that are found in botanical gardens, private gardens, research labs and farms and how high are the CO2 levels in those greenhouses?
@joshkenney
Жыл бұрын
@Ah Stuttgart the Earth is cooling, dude. Nice try.
@truegret7778
Жыл бұрын
@@willcruz943 We don't live in greenhouses, unless you are living in Biosphere II in Oracle, AZ. Our current level of CO2 is somethin like 0.04% .... Not sure the temperature is an issue here. Mother Earth seeks balance - conservation of energy "energy can be neither created nor destroyed", first law of thermodynamics. [edit] - I see now you were responding to @Ah Stuttgart whose comment I missed.
@eliteviktor3
Жыл бұрын
@Ah Stuttgart Higher levels of co2 also makes the air more humid.
This woman doesn’t answer the questions.
@rodneyhearld8151
Жыл бұрын
well she would actually have to know the answer to be able to answer any kind of data or accountability questions with woke blank empty space sitting on her shoulders does not help her
" They/They&They have a system they work out of ..." I bet they do ...I bet they do.
We will all stop breathing and they will be happy
"Thank you so much for the question" doesn't answer the question, it just takes up time and is the start of the witnesses filibuster.
Thank you senator for asking me this question on a topic i came here to testify on but please let me get back with you on this, since i have no idea what i am talking about
wow she's a genius huh
Thank you for the question, now let me not give you the answer you're looking for
Why do these witnesses always say “thank you for the question” when they really don’t want to hear that question and do everything they can not to answer
@cziprick
Жыл бұрын
It's done for Decorum and to use up the questioner's time. It's done to stall for time.
How do these people think this is right to not give a straight answer? This never worked in school.
0.43. That woman knows nothing she couldn't tell you her shoe size
@terrykavanaugh2481
Жыл бұрын
By design
"Thank you for the question, I do not know the answer to any of your questions and even if I did I would not give them here but rather I would refer you to someone in my department who can spin the facts the way we want?" Did I get that correct?
Perhaps I am stupid, but why haven't American citizens gotten rid of all Washington staffs and started over? Seems to me the handling of that , in the end, might actually result in sanity in Washington These hearings are a reflection of the mess. Just start over.
@philobetto5106
Жыл бұрын
we used our tax return to pay our property tax and now we can't afford the gas to drive to Washington dc
What does she do. I will get my office to send you over the info. What. I'd like to know her salary. Wow.
Next question: Of all CO2 emitted into the atmosphere each year, how much of it is from man-made causes (globally) vs how much is from natural causes? My searches reveal that humans are responsible for between 3% and 5% of ALL CO2 emissions each year, the other 95% to 97% is from natural causes. You can then split that human contribution to how much from each country, and further split it by what economic sector (power generation, industry, homes, transportation, etc.) From the transportation sector, you can further split the US contribution to air transport, ship transport, rail transport, or vehicle transport. For the vehicle, further split to business and personal, trucks and cars. All personal cars put together make up such a small part of the total CO2 emissions one has to wonder why it is a concern, and if it is worth destroying our country to reduce it.
@rodneyhearld8151
Жыл бұрын
Really should stop the flying there , there is 0.004% of CO2 in the atmosphere not very high level the CO2 is vital for all plant life to be able to grow and produce oxygen for us to live , Now you're talking about CO ,CO is the result of the burning of oil and gas even the CO levels are not that bad and they do not cause over all long term global warming green house temperature rise like they want to claim, CO2 is vital for life on this disk
I'm not a scientist or public official - just a poor immigrant from Eastern-Europe - and I know the level of CO2 in atmosphere is less than 1% - actually about half that. I believe Nitrogen is almost 80% and Oxygen about 20%. The rest are tiny % of 'inert' gases! I'm more qualified for her position than she is - and I didn't even complete the college!
@Brave2standalone
Жыл бұрын
@Ah Stuttgart @ Thanks for the tip - your opinion means so much to me! I almost graduated business (but switched to CS) and I owned several businesses in my lifetime! I'll bet "Deb" lived on government's dime since she graduated whatever 'dumpy' school she attended.
Deb Haaland talks a lot without saying a damn thing! What were her qualifications for this job?
He should have kept asking her the first question until she googled it.
Every time I try to watch one of these videos, I have to give up in despair with the question - where do they find such of a collection of obvious idiots and put them all in positions that directly affect our lives? It is depressing and discouraging.
whos really in charge? obviously not her
It's the sun . These people are taking political and $ advantage of what's going to happen with or with out us humans on the planet
@mrrey8937
Жыл бұрын
No laws, legislation, mandates, government agency orders, or spending bills should be created based on "no information" , and should be considered fraud against taxpayers and the state
@BobHoover-kl6zm
Жыл бұрын
They want you to believe that climate change will kill off most of the population in the next 10 years or so ...that's half true ,except climate change isn't going to depopulate the earth of unwanted humans ,it's the people that are telling us that who are already in the process of depopulation right now
Why does it take a congressman, to ask a department to work off of new data. Isn’t that called common sense?
Most annoying part of these hearings? Running out the clock to say Thank you for the question, every single time.
Why is it that people that appear before these committees seem to no nothing, ever? I want to ask them what they are being paid for and see if they can answer that.
None of them are willing to answer a question directly or honestly... they do it worldwide
In a lot of words, Haaland is telling Congress, "I know NOTHING!"
Jen sake should get royalties for that Circle back comment she used to make.
Reasons why we have EDUCATED IN YOUR FIELD, people incharge.... ticking boxes gets us people that are unintelligent in the field taxpayers are paying them for.... super sad we no longer award jobs based on INTELLIGENCE IN THE FIELD THEY ARE HIRED FOR.... this woman is ill-informed on a major level
crazy...
This woman should be fired and the person who hired her should be fired
Captain Planet science 🙄
Every time she speaks, it's as though she's about to break into tears. She NEVER speaks with confidence!
That Woman is another example of the bluddy double speak these bureaucrats use to avoid questions which matter!
"Thank you for that question" ... "I don't have a clue how to answer it...."
If the tyrant, Newsom would allow the growers to utilize the water coming down from the dam instead of letting flow to the ocean. California wouldn't have an issue!
It's 0.04%. That's why they always use PPM values since most of their base has no clue as to how much CO2 is in the atmosphere. The last time people were asked what the atmospheric percentage of CO2 is in a committee the answers started at 4% and ranged up from there meaning the closest answer was out by two orders of magnitude.
Anyone else see this big opportunity for Government shenanigans here ?
ENOUGH...answer the dang questions❗ no more "I'll have to get back to you" if she refuses to answer the question she should be replaced by someone who will. Also I don't think any of these folks should get a single cent more until they tell us where/how they spent last years money AND all the covid money 🙏❤🇺🇸 MAGA
A good bureaucrat/politician NEVER properly answers any question. We have a new term for that and it is Word Salad.
I cannot stand the reply starting with "thank you for your question" etc. which means they are getting ready to blow smoke.
If that lady isn't fired for not knowing her job, then we have lost already..what a liar
@ > 'What Is The Basis For CO2 Levels?' Doug LaMalfa, THANK U for Your question!! 👁appreciate your question more than any words can express!! The question is of such importance, an answer of crystal clear clarity is due & owing to all, and because the modulus of elasticity of the intellectual comprehension capacity of each person varies greatly, an answer comprehensible to all must be given so the different degrees of the modulus of intellectual elasticity comprehension capacity of different people is sufficient to comprehend and accommodate the requirements of the modulus of elasticity of the intellectual capacity of each individual. NOW!! The Basis for CO2 levels is based on The simple formula of, E = 2G (1+ µ); E = 3 K (1-2µ),-E = 9KG/G+3K! ALSO!! We MUST REMEMBER that a modulus of rigid Value of any constant is always greater than or equal to 0. Negative sign only shows the direction and not the curve.😊 THEREFORE!! IT IS IMPERATIVE that this simple formula be kept in mind for the crystal clear answer to manifest itself. 👁jus cane make it no plainnurn gnat.
They really need to start sending these questions to there office before the committee meetings. We need facts to see if their even true and not gotcha moments.
@joshkenney
Жыл бұрын
Republicans do this often so they don't have an excuse, but Dems never answer the question even when cornered with facts.
@TheRealDrJoey
Жыл бұрын
YES!^^^
Wow. No idea about anything.
Another person in this administration that dose not know anything about her job.
Why are sea levels not rising Tge Philippines has about 7,600 islands. At last count that number is INCREASING. How is this possible with rising seas?
Government incompetence in action.
“Thank you for the question.“ ‘Just bcuz I am generously salaried and lead a multi-million dollar federal agency I have no idea what the fandango goes on.‘
So much work we do is based on science?
Playing Moon, Soil, Sand ?
@mariarahelvarnhagen2729
Жыл бұрын
His Owe Is Impeccably Pronounced And His Party 2 Is Dang Lit
@mariarahelvarnhagen2729
Жыл бұрын
Really Blowing It Away
But Deb great grandfather said when great white mountain gone great land dry up So we smoke peace pipe now 😆
She say's " I don't have that data/information Senator " all the time. Does this woman know ANYTHING?
None of the people hired under this administration know the basic 101 information of co2 emissions.” WTH 🤦♂️ are we paying for ????
And look at the clowns sittin behind her. Yeah, they're PROS!
How can these people be soooooooo ignorant????
thank you for that question. as i say you uh water wet
Why is she combining ngoa with atmospheric administration? With co2
No answers and always saying thank you for your question and again never answering.
2:55. “Living eating breathing”’on making up shit about “Climate Change”.
This is what happens when you grant immunity to people before they go before and oversight committee.
What shocks me with this global warming mostly is people forget who created the earth, & who created the universe! God does not need mankind's help with anything! As matter of fact God states in the Bible that mans knowledge is nothing but foolishness to Him! Read in the Bible what God told Job & Jonah!
The only reason to reduce CO2 is to reduce population.
They never say anything.
FDH! 😤😠😡🤬👿
When someone begins with ‘science’ in their statement and then doesn’t have the information for the subject they are discussing you know the majority of the answers are lies.
They are concerned with clean air, they aren’t familiar with CO2 but she will look it up and get back to you!
Did they just find stupid people 😐 for all departments?
Thank you for that question Senator = I don't know what the fu@k I'm talking about !!!!!!!!