If you enjoyed the video consider giving it a like! If you want to keep up with me follow the Twitter: twitter.com/carthusdojo

@Doyoueverwonderwhywerehere

2 жыл бұрын

Well we can't exactly dislike the video lol

@Maestro_tiktok

2 жыл бұрын

Lol I’m second comment

@user-ej8pu6im7p

2 жыл бұрын

Here

@Wakelled

2 жыл бұрын

Of course!

@ExcellZero

2 жыл бұрын

Hi

I feel like Broly wouldn't be more likely to kill someone. He's been shown, in Super anyway, to actually be VERY pure of heart, to the point that Stardust Breaker didn't really affect him, outside of some damage from the actually explosion, since there wasn't any evil to be expunged.

@Shrine_of_Karma

2 жыл бұрын

He did not kill out of evil he killed due to rage

@maxmanchik

2 жыл бұрын

@@Shrine_of_Karma Exactly! Broly only would kill due to his berserker mode

@foodfood17

2 жыл бұрын

even if he was evil it probably wouldnt have killed him like that because it was just for show for the OGs

@infinitecriativity1588

2 жыл бұрын

He also should be smart enough to wish Gohan back when he first gets the chance.

@Shrine_of_Karma

2 жыл бұрын

@@infinitecriativity1588 why wish gohan back?

I wonder if Broly would retain his bulk without the protein packed bug diet he had on Vampa…

@fearthepiggaming2998

2 жыл бұрын

I mean hes still a saiyan so he probably would still be pretty muscular but he probably would be a bit slimmer

@samsamuelreal

2 жыл бұрын

Bug protein shakes 👀

@fritofreda

2 жыл бұрын

I wonder if he'd be bigger if he grew up eating actual food, or smaller because he wouldn't have to work his body as much on Earth.

@fearthepiggaming2998

2 жыл бұрын

@@fritofreda That's a good point he would probably have more to eat on Earth but he also would definitely have a lower protein diet probably have to fight less

@fritofreda

2 жыл бұрын

@@fearthepiggaming2998 Yeah its interesting to think about. In reality Broly was probably just barely getting enough calories to survive on his home planet, even if it was all protein, so the fact that he's able to be that large is fuckin crazy. Maybe if he grew up on Earth and was always eating good and training as hard as Goku, he'd be even bigger.

Wait. He names the kid Goten? You'd think since his story with Grandpa Gohan was the same that he'd still name his first son after him.

@yomyg9957

Жыл бұрын

ye ikr

@jiggyz5074

8 ай бұрын

alternative situation so alternative outcome makes it more realistic like a separate timeline.

@____________838

Ай бұрын

He hit his head really hard.

@girlbuu9403

16 күн бұрын

There's a lot of weird leaps of logic in this what-if. Why would Krillin not leave for Roshi's? Butterfly effect can only explain away so much. Vegeta HAS to be Bulma's true love when that isn't even the wish she wanted to make. Broly randomly gaining the ability to sense ki, though Vegeta did it too so whatever but it was only after realizing it was possible. Chichi trashing Raditz when she was killed by Tambourine in place of Krillin feels like an unreasonable power jump. Time chamber being abused when the whole reason they didn't use it before to prep for Piccolo Junior or the Saiyans was because it probably would have killed them. It isn't just time dilation, it makes gravity training with capsule corp almost redundant. Communicating with King Kai before meeting him, why didn't Kami do that if it was possible? Sparing Vegeta makes a little sense with the way he built up Broly regretting murdering so many people but it still feels shoehorned. Freeza bringing the Ginyus over a premonition when it should have been concern over Oozaru, Oozaru Vegeta is stronger than Captain Ginyu, but then not having Ginyu swap bodies when he is literally watching these two plow through everyone. Vegeta would probably assume the ikari was super saiyan. Using Piccolo's power boost to justify Chichi and Tien getting that strong, when we don't see Tien do similar in the series after spending over a year there. Speaking of, Tenshinhan SHOULD have learned kaioken in the series. But he didn't. Having him and Chichi getting it is a huge stretch. Like what if they waited another year to resurrect him he would have been able to kick 19 off Goku before Vegeta got there? Then I bowed out of the video when Trunks showed up.

Tbh I really enjoy Chi-Chi’s inclusion throughout this what if, and I hope to see more content that way!

@seith2022

2 жыл бұрын

She’s been made ridiculously OP! She kills Nappa and fights head to toe with final form Frieza…meaning she’s way stronger than both Canon Goku & Vegeta in the Namekian Saga…hell she might single handedly claim the title for mightiest warrior in the universe

@douglasdebose3339

2 жыл бұрын

@@seith2022 yes but if you watch Carthu’s other vids, he keeps the cast of characters reasonably scaled. The humans have shown great potential, plus like is said in most videos group training and having a goal to reach with motivated characters leads to growth. Chi-chi was a fighter, she’d have that drive and tenacity to stay reasonably on pace

@seith2022

2 жыл бұрын

@@douglasdebose3339 Krillin’s had it for all his life (earlier than Chichi ever did even) and he got wrecked to pieces by every single Freeza transformation available. The only selling point is that Broly would be stronger, thus anyone training with him somehow would automatically become stronger regardless of their inherent potential

@user-rb2hg

Жыл бұрын

@@seith2022 yeah it makes no sense

@ddd09ish1

Жыл бұрын

i agree, her exclusion from the main cast was always the biggest eye brow raiser as a kid, and i really liked her inclusion here

I watched the original so this should be really exciting. It's kinda like Final Fantasy 7 and Remake the differences at least.

@HiemalUncia

2 жыл бұрын

Same

@Kaizer_GG

2 жыл бұрын

First time?

@HiemalUncia

2 жыл бұрын

@@Kaizer_GG yes this was a what if but he made it a full story and edited it a little but

@Kaizer_GG

2 жыл бұрын

@@HiemalUncia uhm i have seen many before?

SPOILERS INBOUND I absolutely love this story, and I really liked the subversions you did with Broly not turning Super Saiyan against Frieza which really surprised me and threw me for a loop. And while Frieza looked untouchable seeing Trunks come in and one shot him made me happy as a trunks fan and also glad to see everything be alright. Removing Earth's Dragon Balls from the story along with Future Trunks staying in the present for a justified reason is also pretty unique. This is a supreme improvement of the original in every way.

@Curseycubey

2 жыл бұрын

Why

@Wall207Slow

2 жыл бұрын

Chi chi best character

@satgurs

2 жыл бұрын

sad goku noises

@alfalldoot6715

Жыл бұрын

You seriously think a short hypothetical video is better than the entire Dragon Ball franchise?

@maikidot

Жыл бұрын

🤓

Though i love it it's kind of depressing knowing baby kakarot just died like that

@angelafwuffycuddles5806

Жыл бұрын

If only his mom was like Bardok I feel so much remorse when I heard that

@UnwantedGhost1

Жыл бұрын

@@angelafwuffycuddles5806 But then Bardock wouldn't be compelled enough to steal a space pod to send Kakarot away because of the absence of Gine's kindness.

@angelafwuffycuddles5806

Жыл бұрын

@@UnwantedGhost1 to specify I geuss, more of his craftiness not removal of her kindness

@UnwantedGhost1

Жыл бұрын

@@angelafwuffycuddles5806 Remember, he spared Granolah and his mother because they remind him of his kind wife & newly born Goku. Manaito by extension was saved, which helped Bardock immensely when he was battling Gas. Both he & Elec told the Saiyan that his species won't be around much longer. Afterwards, that's what made him create the decisions in Dragonball Minus/Super Broly.

@UnwantedGhost1-anz25

6 ай бұрын

​@@angelafwuffycuddles5806New account. I'll try answering what if Gine had Bardock's craftiness while still keeping her kindness. She would arguably be more useful & helpful for Bardock than she was originally. Even her two sons would have more benefits, mostly Raditz. Gine might even change him to be more close to being righteous like Vegeta overtime on Earth. I'm not sure if she'd be smart enough like Bulma to craft the space pods to not be detectable by Freeza's empire so that all her family can escape together. But there's a good chance that they might all leave right when the planet gets destroyed to fake their deaths. And either live with kakarot or separately. It's up to you whether they reunite with the youngest son on Earth or not.

Also if Broly Black did happen, he would automatically kill everyone. Since it's the soul of a god giving him his God Ki, the Ki that would be bursting out would bloom from within. If he could access super saiyan of any form its over for them.

@brolydictcumberbatchmontou401

2 жыл бұрын

yeah but if Elder Kai unlocked Brolly's potential like Gohan wouldn't that be cool? he could almost always stay in base, unless needed to go higher for short bursts in time

@brolydictcumberbatchmontou401

2 жыл бұрын

holy shit the level of fear you brought out of me fully considering the implications of Goku Black powers instead being bestowed upon Broly? Broly Black draws me back in fear and trepidation dude. even regular broly might find it hard to go up to a rose form of his self but thanks to dbhero he might pullout ssj4 legendary ss form

@LILT910

2 жыл бұрын

@@brolydictcumberbatchmontou401 I dun know bro. I feel there are some things to consider. Like, would Zamasu have the same resistance to the rage Broly's body produces? If that's not the case and Control isn't second nature or Instinct to Broly's body at the time, Broly Black would automatically go into Ikari. With Broly's pure potential it wouldn't take long at all before he began to embody Zamasu's soul and go Ikari Rosé. From there it would be a wosh, the planet would be destroyed most definitely. If Super Broly is anything like his movie counterpart then he has a solution for space travel, and could freely do it.

@pawekrzysik6606

Жыл бұрын

@@LILT910 If super Brody had solution to space travel, hi won't be living on Vampa

@pagansaiyan8114

Жыл бұрын

that legendary God ki next form confirmed 👍

It's been a great What If! Great story telling, narration and some clever ideas in the mix, especially with the characters, changing the cast and give some characters more time to shine, being my favourite part for me. Keep up the good work man!

@somebodyrandom1781

2 жыл бұрын

Imagine typing all that and the only response you get is "fax"

@somebodyrandom1781

2 жыл бұрын

Lol

@kbk489

2 жыл бұрын

@@somebodyrandom1781 fax

@Oh_So_Based

6 ай бұрын

The problem w this Story line is that Roshi said that Goku was basically an evil, rebellious toddler until he hit his head one day. After he recovered ; he turned into the nice lighthearted Goku we know today. If Broly never hits his head or if he doesnt react the same from the hit then its over for Earth & the rest of this story line doesnt get to exist

I just like how Broly stole Goku's spot for this story and become more stronger. Good job Carthu!

I feel like Broly would be pretty OP no matter what, despite the nerfs. His power level would honestly be really cracked either way, because he has an adaptive power level. He sort of negates power scaling in a way, and multipliers with his rage boosts. Its how his Ikari Form could match Super Saiyan God. Its how he was so strong in his base form. Any time he got angry, it'd honestly be game over. But still.. Either way, this works well for story telling! You probably should've used another large nerf though. Something that'd make more sense. Let's be real, DBS power scaling is on some meth.

@infinitecriativity1588

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, Also Broly is not dependent on transformation and taking a beating for to long like Piccolo did would boost his power without needing Ikari.

@jpdokkanesestr

9 ай бұрын

Just having a "Mutant Zenkai" is OP As hell

The original was already really good, I can't wait to see how this one ends up!

@Doyoueverwonderwhywerehere

2 жыл бұрын

spoiler alert ends exactly the same way

@tae..3715

2 жыл бұрын

@@Doyoueverwonderwhywerehere Ik all he did really was change the art lol

3:15 Despite the timing being more in line with Goten's birth I think that "Goku" would still name his name his son Gohan.

I love when what-ifs show Chichi continuing to study martial arts.

@calvinkopp1735

Жыл бұрын

Me too. Such a wasted opportunity at the beginning of Z.

Love the Vegeta reference in the early part of the story. Would’ve loved to see that in the actual anime.

You can tell Carthu loves the Frieza dialogue😂

@rarescevei8268

10 ай бұрын

Could you blame him?

Broly is just going to clap everybody during the years of Kid Goku in dragon ball, because everybody is the power level of 100 - 1,000 probably, and Broly was born with a whopping 10,000 power level. So, it's pretty obvious Broly just destroys all the "Kid Goku" villains until Saiyan and Frieza saga where it might make things more difficult. *BY THE WAY THIS IS BEFORE THE VIDEO*

@CarthusDojo

2 жыл бұрын

Brody is only 920

@kaiserquasar3178

2 жыл бұрын

@@CarthusDojo he still can be scaled to Goku's base form using ratios Broly as an adult in Ikari from could slap SSJB Goku so he undermines everyone's power until he meets Beerus, who would be the only non-angel character stronger than Broly throughout the story at any point, as with a SSJG boost+ absorbing it to his base later on he'd clap even Jiren and might unlock SSJB which would make him even more OP

@jermaineartis4323

2 жыл бұрын

@@CarthusDojo which broly are you referring to, cause I thought it was 10,000 as well?

@infinitecriativity1588

2 жыл бұрын

Z Broly is 10,000 and S Broly is 920 as a kid.

@infinitecriativity1588

2 жыл бұрын

@@CarthusDojo I think that Super Broly is smart enough to either obey Gohan order to not look at the moon or wish Gohan back at the first chance with Bulma.

The chemistry of Broly and Chi Chi is far superior to Goku and Chi Chi’s as Chi Chi starts off as the main rival for Broly while training with Roshi, then became friends at the end of the first Strongest Under the Heavens Tournament, then became partners at the beginning of Z, and then they got married at the end of Cell Saga. Talk about natural progression and unbreakable partnership.

I’m glad Vegeta is usually still alive and apart of these stories, he’s my favorite character

I like to think of Vegeta yelling "I WILL NOT LET YOU DESTROY MY BULMA!!" during his fight with Beerus

I fell that Broly would be obedient enough to not look at the moon or smart enough to wish Gohan back to him when he first gets the chance.

@TheZombiesAreComing

Ай бұрын

It's just Carthu trying to mimic the plot exactly except with name swapping Goku for Brolly which is completely unrealistic. Different people have different personalities baked into their DNA

I think Goku would have been sent regardless

Carthu I want to thank you for making these great what ifs, you were the first what if creator I found for dragon Ball and you'll always be on my list of best 2021 creators

Man Carthu, I'm really inebriated rn and I just wanted to tell you that your content goes so hard no matter what mental state im in. Keep up the good work pal.

@Carterino9404

3 ай бұрын

I am high and I love DBZ

Man seen this story again was neat, and with the ending changed too. Because yeah if the Future Timeline is still their then the Present Timeline would be the same. Although I thought Broly and Chi-Chi's son would be named Gohan instead Goten since I could see Broly wanting to honor his Granda Gohan like Goku did. Finally looking forward to whenever: What if Gohan was like Goku? Fully Story comes out. Anyways another really good Full Story, and looking forward to your next video soon. What if suggestion: What if Goku and Tarble were sent to Earth?

I like it but you know broly would get to friezas power level extremely fast while fighting him. He got to god level in his base form pretty quick.

Can’t wait, Broly is my top three characters of Dragon Ball

This "what if?" is awesome! Except you forgot one thing... What about the "special training" Chi-Chi got from Master Roshi? I honestly like this version of the story more than the original... is that bad?

@TheOnlyTienEnjoyer

2 жыл бұрын

@aditeya srivastav lol

@calculator4482

2 жыл бұрын

No ...........

@TheOnlyTienEnjoyer

2 жыл бұрын

@@calculator4482 what?

@Kris2005isMine

Жыл бұрын

No. No "special training."

@Skai03_

5 ай бұрын

it’s obviously secret punches and secret kicks

Thank you so much for these great what-ifs, Carthu's Dojo! I really enjoy them. Maybe a Dabura turning good one?

@ajm2612

2 жыл бұрын

I guess you could do that and the change could be vegito distracts buu then dabura turns him to stone Also because of this bearus would be angered by dabura attacking him or trying to turn him to stone And imagine a god ki dabura, give him a transformation even if it’s made up and instead dabura get the z sword 🗡 and doesn’t break it

@johnquach8821

2 жыл бұрын

@@ajm2612 That's an interesting possibility! Dabura was stronger than normal in Xenoverse 2 so that's a start: Demon God Dabura.

@kpounder4908

4 ай бұрын

My take would be that before buu turns dabura into a cookie he turns him into stone to everyone’s surprise. Then he agrees to help the Z-fighters by wishing for krillin and piccolo to be freed from their stone imprisonment

The takeaway here is that Tien's this alternate DragonBall universe's Yamcha. He cannot catch a break.

Finally the story got remastered and it actually has a good ending. So much better than the one with them and all universes getting erased from the original

I seriously want a series based off these videos. You'd make a great narrator as well Carthu

Ready....don't know how I missed this story by you, but I get to see it put together!

Now THIS is an ending I can get behind!

Trunks coming in last second for the save caught me so off guard I actually recoiled in shock

Broly went from star level to complex Multiversal in MINUTES. No one would be able to stop him in Z, except maybe the Androids and Cell since Gero would have Broly’s research and DNA.

I love how on every video like these when Trunks show up, he's confused as hell lol.

“What if Bardock raised Goku on Vampa” “What If King Vegeta was the Emperor of the Universe” “What if Majin Buu absorbed Shin (or Zamasu)”

@Shrine_of_Karma

2 жыл бұрын

Interesting

a masterpiece, I love this channel. I'm really glad I grew with this channel

1: Why didn't Krillin train with Roshi? How does the first arc even remotely impact Krillin's decision to leave?

@ge9884

2 жыл бұрын

Creative liberties for a narrative that doesn't follow the same story beats.

@genuinearity8790

2 жыл бұрын

Because the plot demanded that Chi-Chi is the main character's best friend

@Khipher

2 жыл бұрын

Honesty, you could probably just say it’s basic butterfly effect in play. That one change of Broly being sent to earth instead of Goku could legitimately cause a lot of plot differences since butterfly effect has been proven to be a thing that can occur in Dragon Ball. Krillin just so happened to not want to train with Roshi this time around 🤷🏾

@drabnail777

Жыл бұрын

@Genuinearity It's like a typical woke show

@TorranceTheBest

Жыл бұрын

@@genuinearity8790 fuck chichi krillin is my guy

What if Cabba, Caulifla and Kale were from Universe 7 instead of Universe 6?

@IamMcLovin69

2 жыл бұрын

They'd be dead.

@vaultboy5492

Жыл бұрын

@@IamMcLovin69 fr mclovin

@decoy3418

3 ай бұрын

They would feel tingles in their back and kill Frieza on the spot.

This definitely would be a great alternate story arc it's far shorter and ends pretty neatly all things considered, even without the dragon balls our alternate heroes still managed to overcome the odds and pull through together. And Chi chi gets a better love story than if the actual goku had been alive. Akira would be jealous of this story for sure.

@Mark-be8yk

Жыл бұрын

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Can't wait I've been waiting anxiously for this vid!

I would love it if someone could animate an alternate DBZ series with your plot ideas. I really enjoy your plots and reasoning for different plot twists. Thank you for the upload!

This was an epic rendition! Well done!

Finally. A Dragonball related video in a while. 👏

Bruh this was a work of art, not just story but art, editing, music!!!

King Piccolo: "Ha, you failed to save your friend. Now bow to your king." Brolly: *"WHAT IS A KING TO A GOD!?"* King Piccolo: "Hol' up"

Just hearing goku never existed just shocks me

Usually when some arcs aren’t shown, it’s a sad ending. Happy that this isn’t the case

very nice alternate story Love it, i hope u go on with the story would love to see more

This is really creative. I feel that this is a good example of a what-if story told well.

I’m looking forward to this!

This was a really good video Carthu! Thank you for making all these what ifs.

This feels like more of a fanfiction than an actual what if. Reason being that things like Goku staying on Vegeta and Krillin staying at his temple have nothing to do with a Goku going to Earth. Those are basically what ifs of their own.

Loved it. I'll always watch anything involving Broly. Absolutely my favourite DB character!

I can't wait for this premiere!

his saiyan spirit, the oozaru form and his power level would've probably lead to the destruction of earth early.

That was really awesome bro!

That Frieza impression is shockingly good

25:47 "Chi-Chi" is actually holding her own against freiza" what the hell

This was great. Can’t wait to see your next video. If you need some ideas, you could try “what if vegeta and goku went to earth together.”

Im new to these videos but im really impressed with how well thought out these are man. Im mad entertained

I really like the detail of the Vegeta not only having a genuine friendship with broly born out of respect, but that friendship softening him up to the point where he completely acknowledged future trunks as his son and told trunks it wasn't even a question that trunks would be staying at capsule Corp with his family

pov: broly beats goku’s time for speed running dragon ball

@calvinkopp1735

2 жыл бұрын

Because Broly’s potential and growth is much higher than all of the Saiyans in the universe combined. He’s a unique mutant.

man trunks technically had 8 years of training and lost to cell still. 3 years with broly and 5 in the time chamber

I really love the idea at how characters like Tien and Chi Chi can now fight Frieza with minimal effort!

This is almost TOO GOOD!!

I love this what if stories Keep doing what you doing

Very good what if, but idk if I speak for others when I say that certain factors like goku not being sent to earth and krillin not going to master roshis should have a more explanation to the story. As an example, you could have altered it so bardock instead sends Goku to raditzs location, giving rise to a potential broly vs raditz and chi chi vs goku. Idk if anyone also has these minor issues, but I felt that they should be addressed Nonetheless, amazing what if

So pretty much Broly in this story is a slightly more pissed off goku that is playing on easy mode

@the_children_

Жыл бұрын

Correct

You could’ve done the Moro arc and once the granolah arc is finished I can’t wait to see what’s gonna happen with broly good job in this video bro

this was better than i expected i love it

Amazing video i had fun watching it

Ah yeah been waiting for this one!

Hey, Tenshinhan actually wasn't forgotten here!

16:14 - Now _that_ was satisfying. XD EDIT: Honestly, I could say that about the whole story. Nicely done!

i like the way you narrate the story!! you have got 1 new subscriber!!

Love these!

What if the son of Broly and Chi-Chi used the Time Machine to be transported to the Main Dragon Ball Z-Super timeline?

I really like what you did with this story because it's like all your other what-if stories broly is ridiculously strong so everyone who trains with him is ridiculously strong. The fact that chichi has the spotlight in the beginning of these fights is so amazing to me. I don't like the Chichi we have in dragon Ball z. Obviously there are still a little things here and there that just seem odd but I really like this what if. I do wish however though in one of your what-if stories you also have Vegeta so confident and cocky that he sends both radditz and Nappa to do a scouting mission of Earth.

@ricsouza5011

Жыл бұрын

most mainstream japanese mangaka including Toriyama usually dont depict female warriors on par with the male warriors bar the occasional smurfette - that sometimes is as strong or even stronger than most guys (DBZ with android 18 for an example), just like in real life where the average female fighter cant compare to the male fighter

Amazing vid love it im addicted

There's alot of Canon details about broly that suggest this story would play out much differently. Mainly the fact that he is very pure of heart, as seen in the super broly movie when he's hit with that one attack that removes the evil from its target, but he doesn't really change after taking the hit.

I thought goku would go to vampa instead of Broly. But the way you just killed him like fodder.. absolutely great 👍

Goku(Broly) & ChiChi when Whis arrives to train them: “wtf is a Goten?”

This was fire 💪💯

Wrong, If Bulma met Broly her quest to finding a boyfriend would've ended, they both would've fucked and forgotten about the dragon balls.

Great story, enjoyed the listen. My only reservation is that there is no way Bulma isnt interested in Broly upon first meeting him. He is her age and just look at the guy.

You know what would have made these what ifs better ? If they had subtitles !

As always, so cool

Dang this will be awesome to watch

Carthu you're an amazing what if KZreadr

So what happened to kakarot? Ah never mind, he dies thanks to gine talking bardock out of sending him away. Damn it gine

Chi-chi becoming the replacement krillin and simultaneously pwning Raditz as well as Nappa is the single most hilarious and awesome thing ive heard. It would be even better if you somehow got her to learn the destructo disc. Also, would love to see a "What if Vegeta turned Super Saiyan during the frieza arc instead of Goku?" And "What if Krillin was a Saiyan? (How powerful would he be with all those near death zenkai boosts?) ❤

Broly and ChiChi begin training 🤗 WHOLESOME AF I love all of these alternate DBZ abridged series, SO DAMN COOL!! THIS SUS PENSE

Chi chi killing Raditz is based as fuck

Question: "Why does Korrin not simply grow a few batches of Senzu in the Time Chamber to be prepared for future threats?"

@user-op5gr7vr7e

3 ай бұрын

Probably because the climate isn't suited for it

This is amazing.

Super good, great work! The Trunks Twist is just ugh, awesome to the limit of brilliancy