What other What Ifs would you like to see?

@chrisp.chicken5654

2 жыл бұрын

What if… ahsoka brought back anakin or ahsoka stayed in the jedi order

@ethankeith526

2 жыл бұрын

What if Ventress didn't help Ahsoka when she was on the run?

@enegmatixerebro

2 жыл бұрын

What if Qui Gon killed Darth Maul?

@apexoftheworld6927

2 жыл бұрын

What if T'Challa becomes a Star-Lord?

@user-Pulse1147

2 жыл бұрын

Back to the Future! Maybe go for What If Biff didn't take the Almanac to his younger self?

"Jedi civil war" Revan: "hold my lightsaber"

@thatoneguy9485

2 жыл бұрын

which one?

@LoliMaster69227

2 жыл бұрын

@@thatoneguy9485 yes

@richardgadberry8398

2 жыл бұрын

OH GOD MY HANDS!!! AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!

@kabob0077

2 жыл бұрын

@@thatoneguy9485 All of his collection.

@romanian_thief

2 жыл бұрын

hello Lord DIO, I did not expect you here

So Anakin becomes, Revan like... _I see this as an absolute win_

@HammarPwnsYourFace

2 жыл бұрын

This is point in time that we have lived to see.... am i am found wanting so much for more...

@rlift

2 жыл бұрын

Only a Sith deals in absolutes...

@HammarPwnsYourFace

2 жыл бұрын

@@rlift and you say it like it’s a bad thing....

@vasyear

2 жыл бұрын

@@rlift which is in itself an absolute

@jagnestormskull3178

2 жыл бұрын

I mean, Revan's story and Anakin's story already rhyme with each other. -Built protocol droids that are improvements on existing schematics. -Lead Jedi into a war while some in their own Order tried to sabotage their efforts. -Claimed a mask and a new name. -Claimed the title of Darth in a two Darth system (the Dark Lord of the Sith and the Shadow Hand; the Rule of Two was based on Revan's teachings to Bane after all) -Was betrayed by counterpart. -Ended up redeeming themselves by defeating that counterpart.

I demand this be written fully and put on the big screen... Imagine a world where all the awesome movies we know and love are remade with alternate paths! this is awesome.

@magnumsmth

Жыл бұрын

Abolishing copyright would help with that, or at least putting every megafranchise like Star Wars into the public domain, free from companies like Disney

@juanmaidana3421

Жыл бұрын

@@magnumsmth I mean it IS possible, we have elsworld stories made animated flicks, and some big productions have that idea as a basis, like LOGAN, the idea of a light side vader is quite AWESOME and would definitely sell, at the very least an animated version like "WHAT IF" would be the very least it deserves.

@GlareBoxTV

11 ай бұрын

If Disney were smart, they'd expand their 'What if' series from Marvel into the Star Wars universe. They have the budget to make these alt scenarios a reality.

Imagine if Anakin never dreamed about Padme's fate, it would literally change everything imo.

@Kalell1701

Жыл бұрын

I agree. It was a self fulfilling prophecy. Seeing her death caused him to take action to stop her death which in turn caused her death.

@jacobpederson1047

Жыл бұрын

Not sure which is canon, but there's 2 explanations for the visions. Either Sideous planted them into his dreams, or Anakin was so powerful with the force that he had the ability to see major events in his future. I lean towards the Sidious theory, because it seems too convenient for the plot to rely on his foresight abilities, and not be able to see any other moments besides his mother, and Padme dying. How else do you think Sidious knew to say the line "he could even save the people he loved from dying" if he had not been the only triggering Anakin's fear of loss?

@drishalballaney6590

Жыл бұрын

​@@jacobpederson1047 exactly its definitely Sidious who must have planted the false vision

@mariusconstantin6057

8 ай бұрын

That would mean he wouldn't know she was pregnant and for things to go a different route

I just realized something. Yoda said “impossible the future is to see”. Then why the hell are they listening to and following a Jedi prophecy?

@generalilbis

2 жыл бұрын

I'm not familiar with current canon on the origins of the Prophecy of the Chosen One, but I've always interpreted it as something recorded centuries or millenia prior when the Force wasn't so clouded by the Dark Side. That the Prophecy was a Force Vision so detailed or so vague based on it being a glimpse of the far future that it was recorded to be carefully studied and watched out for. The problem seems to be that the Prophecy was made so long ago in relation to the PT that it was seen as more myth than a glimpse of the future, that the apparent defeat of the Sith a millenia prior meant it no longer was valid or had been fulfilled without the Order realizing it.

@simonmacomber7466

2 жыл бұрын

When Yoda says "impossible the future is to see," he means that the future is impossible to see _right now_. Normally the Jedi _can_ see the future, but, right now, the Jedi can't because the Sith, by merely existing, are limiting their vision. Remember, in later movies Palpatine is able to foresee the events of the Battle of Endor, though he did miss out on a few details. Of course, there is also the possibility that Yoda was simply not that powerful a Jedi and only had his position based on how old he was. Then there is the sequels, which ultimately shit on the whole prophecy in it's entirety, since *none* of the elements of the Prophecy came true.

@liferealgood

2 жыл бұрын

@@simonmacomber7466 yea but I remember hearing another story about Jedi Master Sifo Dyas having visions of the future (which is why he contracted the Clone Army) and the Jedi basically telling him that he shouldn’t rely on visions. Something about visions not showing the full picture and not being reliable. This was before the Sith returned. Just probably a bit of continuity issues I guess but we agree about the sequels being an absolute shit show.

@Ben-Ken

2 жыл бұрын

Only Qui Gon believed in the prophecy wholeheartedly. The rest either didn't believe it or went along hoping that it would prove to be true.

@jacobdean4833

2 жыл бұрын

Are you new?

I think after Anakin takes his own life Ahsoka would naturally act like a mother to the Skywalker twins as she knew their father more than most people, whilst also fighting alongside him for years

@Angelo-nd4lg

2 жыл бұрын

Lol they already grown conspiring to kill anakin they dont need to be adopted

@kimjongun5691

2 жыл бұрын

Wouldn't Padme still be alive? Ahsoka would be their protector, but not their legal guardian

@GarkKahn

2 жыл бұрын

Well she would be like an old and wise motherly figure for them, maybe they won't see her as their mother but still they will trust her since she's close to both them and their father (and surely highly respected by the order and the people)

@prvtcaboose

2 жыл бұрын

@@kimjongun5691 in this alternate timeline, padme died... This the inner turmoil for Anakin in the first place... Listen to the story again

@user-ks1ze4io6b

2 жыл бұрын

Auntie Ahsoka

This was fantastically done. An for some odd reason, I found Vader's blue saber hall rampage kinda soothing.

@tahutoa

Жыл бұрын

blue has a partly calming psychological effect.

@lopaka76

Жыл бұрын

@@tahutoa I know blue calms and red enrages, but he is still slaughtering the poor rebels.

@TheCheeseburgerJudgesYou

Жыл бұрын

Me too

Just the smallest thing, I don’t know if it was intentional but I love that you hovered on Jar Jar Binks when you talked about removing Sith Pawns from the senate. I find the theory that Jar Jar was an agent of chaos both hilarious and not completely out of the realm of possibility 😅

@anadaere6861

Жыл бұрын

The Force birthing Jar Jar to both curb the Light and Dark is very Force esque

@terryprentice9657

Жыл бұрын

@@anadaere6861 Interesting. Is Jar Jar's birthdate canon? Both Anakin and Grogu are born ~43 BBY. Could Jar Jar share the same birthdate? Are "Yodas" so rare because they are only born "of the Force"?

@jacobpederson1047

Жыл бұрын

that was the original plan, but George Lucas was bullied out of executing that plan. Jar Jar was supposed to be Darth pleagus

@thecatfather857

Жыл бұрын

@@jacobpederson1047 Prove it.

Ideas like this, are why we need a Star Wars "What If" series. Maybe we let Qui-gon act as our "The Watcher" for some reason, maybe the guy is just that in-tune with the force that he can see what could've been, and we get to see these crazy alternate universes that either end up better, or worse than the mainline universe. I'd pay good money to see that.

@jamesbah2561

2 жыл бұрын

This sounds amazing

@100subsfornoreason2

2 жыл бұрын

Qui gon would be the perfect narrator. But at the same time i don't want to have a multiverse in Star wars

@EhsanVreeken

2 жыл бұрын

@@100subsfornoreason2 doesn't explicit imply a multiverse just a what if instead

@100subsfornoreason2

2 жыл бұрын

@@EhsanVreeken If they make it so the stories are not canon to each other I am all for it.

@jamiecraft1032

2 жыл бұрын

Yea and one of the episodes could be “what is obi wan died and not qui gon”

the only good thing about the new trilogy is it makes every star wars fan appreciate the prequels.

@michaelbutchee334

2 жыл бұрын

That and pretty much anyone can shit out a better trilogy thank Disney did. 🖕🏻Disney!

@hermitcraftfan2625

2 жыл бұрын

@@michaelbutchee334 i could make a trilogy of the tale of my shit and it would be better

@michaelbutchee334

2 жыл бұрын

@@hermitcraftfan2625 agreed, you probably could.

@IMFREAKINOUT101

2 жыл бұрын

STOP BEING RIGHT! 😂

@chromaticcobalt8358

2 жыл бұрын

@@hermitcraftfan2625 make a gofundme and sell the trilogy to kids lmao

I was with it all the way until the point where you said Dooku kills Mace. There's just no way that ever, ever happens. Also, I believe that even if Padme died, the fact that Luke and Leia are still around would prevent Anakin from fully losing himself to the darkness.

@shadow_realm47

Жыл бұрын

Since Anakin was more Calculating in this one. I think Palpy would have killed Dooku, Mace would have killed Palpy and Anakin would have killed a weakened Mace after his battle with Palpy.

@szymi13_

Жыл бұрын

Even if he dipped into the darkness, he already had full potential at that point, being a gray jedi and sharpening his skills. He would not lose to obi wan. No chance

@robertlupu7964

9 ай бұрын

Obi wan had the high ground, did you forget?

@anton.chigrinetc.96

Ай бұрын

Dooku and Windu were equals. Dooku was the best fencer in the Galaxy, Windu had his dark side reflection gimmick he used to beat Palps (albeit not exactly the best match: against any more or less good fighter, Palps sucked ass).

9:59 Here is my only problem with this theory. This battle between Obi wan and Anakin should not end with Obi wan winning. Because this duel will now be delayed 10 years after the dual they were supposed to have in episode 3. Obi wan is now beginning to grow old while Anakin has gotten another 10 years of training. That is double of what he had when he fought Obi in episode 3. so Obi wan should lose this one, he is weaker in this timeline because he’s older when they confront, and Ani is way stronger.

@ExistentHope

Жыл бұрын

@@toasty28 but Anakin with his full midichlorians and prime would be beyond Obi Wan I think.

@TheDeepFriedDonkey

Жыл бұрын

OH I DONT THINK SO

@GLUFSAREN

Жыл бұрын

@@toasty28 A stable anakin beats even the obi-wan in the new series. Especially one without the vader suit.

@theoutlawking9123

Жыл бұрын

Anakin losing to Obi-Wan is bullshit in every regard. It's destroys the whole "He's The Chosen One," prophecy. The Chosen One shouldn't fucking lose to anybody.

@MerkhVision

Жыл бұрын

@@theoutlawking9123 You’ve totally misunderstood the concept. Being the chosen one doesn’t mean he has to be a master duelist, that’s not what the prophecy is even about. It’s not about being the strongest or anything like that, it’s only about bringing balance to the force. Which he did by ending both the Jedi and the Sith!

Anakin’s ideology of embracing both light and dark is what Luke does with his Jedi Order in legends

@DarkHound9999

2 жыл бұрын

@@DaniMol There is a difference between embracing the Dark side or not and deciding not to use it afterwards.

@joshmanchester5873

2 жыл бұрын

Father like Son

@mixmaster3028

2 жыл бұрын

I think their Ideologies a little more aggressive.

It is ironic that the Jedi's collapse derived out of their fear of fear itself. By fearing Anakin's relationship to his own personal ones they ended up paving the road for hos descent.

@heartoffire5902

2 жыл бұрын

This is precisely the issue that developed over time within the philosophy of the Jedi. They correctly attribute the root of many consequences to fear, yet many of the policies and decisions they've made in more recent generations are based in fear. They avoid studying, understanding, and coming to terms with certain aspects of the Force because they're afraid of their own vulnerabilities and potential weaknesses - which ultimately leaves them susceptible to it, as Sidious has shown. If you refuse to ever study the techniques of your opponent, you leave yourself vulnerable to the unexpected. It is much easier to comprehend and analyze such things when you are willing to experience them from another's perspective. Everyone must face their own inner darkness to create balance within themselves, or they'll forever be manipulated by it on a subconscious level. I love the Jedi. They're noble, inspiring, and beautiful symbols. But the hubris and inflexibility they eventually descended into, shattered them. I'm glad they're finally getting the chance to evolve, but it would've been so much less painful if they'd taken that path on their own instead of being forced into it with the Purge.

@Eccentric_Charlie

2 жыл бұрын

The ladies would certainly jump on getting with the Jedis.

@CogitoErgoSumFortis

2 жыл бұрын

@@heartoffire5902 you've explained it quote nicely! Indeed I admire the philosophy too, but it's the perfect example how somethimg inherently good not handled properly in a systemic way can result in the corruption of the very fundamental principle. Their system got corrupted, their fear towards the Dark side hampered their own philosophy. In the end they became soldiers, using violence to maintain peace. That's what Sidious exploided, and their ignorance, to reach power, manipulate the Senste and eventually provoke the war that built his empire, all sponsored by the Republic and the Jedi. Quite an itneresting parallelism to our own society. Lucas is a genius.

@Ghal-ht2um

2 жыл бұрын

@@heartoffire5902 I disagree with this. The Jedi fell because Anakin broke every rule the Jedi tried to teach him. If they would have expelled him or just not trained him like the Council wanted, the disaster would have been avoided. You say that Jedi didn't face their inner fears, but this is contradicted by the Clone Wars episode "The Gathering" where younglings have to face their personal fears and failings in order to find their own kyber crystal. And presumably every single Jedi has to do the same thing. It is true that the Jedi fear the dark side, but for good reason. It can completely corrupt even the noblest being. But it is not true that the Jedi never face it or know nothing about it. The Jedi Order in the movies hasn't faced the Sith in 1000 years, so of course they should be rusty, but they are not shown to be incompetent, corrupt, or denial about the threat. Yoda tries to teach Anakin what the dark side is and what leads to it, but he just completely ignores his advice. @J Mondragon The Jedi Order are meant to be the guardians of peace and justice in the galaxy. They don't just sit in their temple doing nothing. Their lightsabers and fighting skills are not for show. They are warriors and they have always been warriors. That's integral part of their very essense. And they don't just do nothing when a Sith lord starts a rebellion and sends droids to devastate worlds. Bad guys don't respect pacifism. I have seen many people constantly say that the Jedi fell because of their own hubris. I even saw people accusing them of corruption. I can't see that personally. The movies and the show constantly portray the Jedi as noble people who do everything they can to stop the Sith, but fail, although the fight was close. If they are meant to be something else, then that's the fault of the movies and the writing. If anything the Sith embody arrogance and hubris. People like Dooku and Anakin started with good intentions but got completely corrupted by the dark side. They tried to change and control the entire galaxy but should have started with themselves.

@clonesolar

2 жыл бұрын

@@Ghal-ht2um If Anakin wasn't there, the Jedi still would of fell. Palpatine would find another way to frame the Jedi, he was smart. Anakin wasn't the key to the puzzle, he was just a piece of it.

This NEEDS to be made into a “What if” mini series!

@originalSiiiN

11 ай бұрын

don't we already have enough "whataboutisms" in our own Democratic Republic?

Ironically, this is similar to what I had hoped Disney would have done with Last Jedi, a union of Sith and Jedi resulting in a Gray Empire that the galaxy 'might' not be too keen on, considering some of the factions' roots. It's a shame Disney didn't call on you and Templin Institute to write the trilogy. It'd have been phenomenal!

@andrewhernandez2987

Жыл бұрын

I was hoping that Disney would have Rey remake the Jedi Order but with Grey Jedi morals. That way, true Balance, equal light and dark in the force, would be achieved. It'd have made me genuinely surprised and impressed with Disney. Thankfully, that's what fanfiction is for.

I like this "smarter" Anakin. It shows that, if he was just more allowed to use his emotions as a Jedi, and be more used to experiencing them, he's a smarter man because he doesn't act nearly as rash when he feels a sudden surge of all of his other emotions besides his Love for Padme.

@skynet1234567890

2 жыл бұрын

This was luke's strength aswell

@ramiroexposito4010

Жыл бұрын

I like it too, and thats why I prefer Clone Wars Anakin to prequel Anakin, there is more intelligence and wider enotional concern in that character.

@thalastianjorus

Жыл бұрын

If Anakin had been born around 200yr before he was? He'd not only have learned to deal with his emotions - he could have married Padme. Openly. With no need to hide. Sadly Yoda's long life turned the Jedi into what they were during the Skywalker saga. Yoda saw this happening, but he couldn't STOP it. He had been teaching all of the younglings for centuries, and as such they all had some hero worship for Yoda. Thus they tried to _live_ like Yoda... emotions suppressed, chaste with no relationships, etc etc. These were natural to Yoda and Yaddle's species, but _humans_ (and most aliens) simply cannot live like that without, well, exploding. Yoda knew this, and tried to teach the little kids _not_ to do it, but they did anyway. As Yoda became Grandmaster the Jedi Council (with Yoda voting no every time) made rules again marriage, strong emotions, having children, etc. Those rules only came into existence between 100-80BBY.

@Andrew-ew3uv

Жыл бұрын

He should have joined another sect of Jedi that was allowed to have feelings, one in particular had a master that Anakin actually met once and would have been a perfect master for him to master his emotions without supressing them

@matthewramirez7807

Жыл бұрын

@@thalastianjorus I’m not disagreeing with you per se but even grogu shows attachment in the Mandalorian so many not so much as natural as something that comes with living so long and watching so many loved ones pass before you?

This was pretty dope. Love the idea of Jedi Civil War. The grey order would have lots of redemption and betrayal.

@daveconrad6562

2 жыл бұрын

Can you elaborate?

@ShadowNinjaDestiny

2 жыл бұрын

@@daveconrad6562 1. The movies show very little of large scale Jedi vs Jedi battles (or the occur off screen). Most battles are 1 v 1, Jedi vs monster or enemies with guns. Would love to see how it would look with live action of a war. 2. Star Wars leans heavy on absolutes, light and dark, Jedi and Sith. The idea of a middle or Grey area Jedi is a new twist. Is it a better option, more powerful, would the Sith and Jedi considered them outcast to kill/arrest on site? Given how politics and the old Jedi council work would they hunt them down sperately or together, use bounty hunters?

@daveconrad6562

2 жыл бұрын

@@ShadowNinjaDestiny i see, the grey ones would end up being major componets kn a jedi war

@vuvuzela691

2 жыл бұрын

Well according to George Lucas/Filoni grey Jedi isn't accurate. A Jedi is supposed to follow the will of the force and seek balance. The Jedi order of the prequels serves the Senate not the force, and are too dogmatic, rather than the will of the force. That is why the prequel Jedi allowed the Sith to rise and destroy them

@katearcher8514

2 жыл бұрын

@@vuvuzela691 are you trying to say that grey Jedi are just Jedi?

Anakin: “if you want, I can hide with you and we can let the people in the city suffer longer.” “Or help now…” Basically what Revan said during the Mandalorian Wars. 4000 years later and still fighting over visions and pondering on what to do.

@Andrew-ew3uv

Жыл бұрын

Thats because the visions are like riddles, they arent allowed to directly interfere with the galaxy

@Andrew-ew3uv

Жыл бұрын

Seems like you are trying to come off as sophisticated and wise like some sort of hipster doing slam poetry. I have no idea what you are trying to say. Anyway the Jedi and the sith have nothing to do with what the living force does. Its all in the lore, im not talking out of my ass about theory here. Also the Jedi started to ignore the visions becoming less connected to the force which is why noone was able to sense that palpatine was right in front of them. Qui-gon was the last Jedi in their sect that could have semsed his evil because he still embraced the force as he was taught to do by Dooku his master.

@shloggin

Жыл бұрын

@@Andrew-ew3uv 🤓

The one thing I want pin point from this is the twins conflict at the end because it’s really good. They’re both grey jedi with capital G, so the conflict probably isn’t about dark and light or good and bad, rather their differences as a people

this “What If…?” content is becoming some of my favorite stuff on your channel and I love the idea being applied to Star Wars

@charlesdean7563

2 жыл бұрын

I was going to like this comment but it’s at 66 likes. Good soldiers follow orders...

@leandroroman7053

2 жыл бұрын

I expected A LOT of "What if?" content since the feature of the World between Worlds on Rebels.

They should do a Star Wars What If like they’re doing with Marvel. That would also provide more avenues to make more content with alternate storylines

@Alfredo12

2 жыл бұрын

The possibilities and ideas of What if from Star Wars are many, from something simple like "What if Jango Feet didn't die" to "What if Ahsoka doesn't leave the Jedi Order" Or "What if Satine wasn't killed"

@mehmetcetin9570

2 жыл бұрын

@@Alfredo12 or what if Vader realized sooner that his children lived?

@taytmw18

2 жыл бұрын

Its called star wars visions

@neo6906

2 жыл бұрын

@@taytmw18 visions is not a what if series, it has no connection to canon

@jagnestormskull3178

2 жыл бұрын

@@taytmw18 Look, I like Visions, but it is not a "What If" series, it's a series of random episodes loosely inspired by the setting. A "What If" series explores the great ripples (in Star Wars terms, "echoes in the Force") of a single alteration to the timeline. No singular alteration to the timeline would create a ex-Sith Ronin who hunts other Sith and collects their lightsaber crystals facing off against a Sith Lord with a lightsaber umbrella. That episode was a very badass tribute to an element of Star Wars's origins, samurai movies, but it was not a "What If."

I like this thought experiment. This tweak of Anakin’s character reminds me a lot of Revan in the KOTOR games-willing to question the Jedi ways, make grand plans, and even sacrifice the lives of many in order to achieve security and deepen his power in the Force.

It was really cool, I loved this whole story. that said, I'm not necessarily sure that Obi Wan wouldn't have followed this version of Anakin. Especially if he is guided by Qui Gon, let's not forget that Obi Wan, despite everything, has a potential gray Jedi side, he often (and once did) wanted to leave the Jedi for love. And in this beautiful version that you told us, an Anakin and Obi Wan alliance, the civil war will not last long xD

I'm fairly sure that Obi-Wan would end up joining with Anakin, he too can see the flaws in the jedi order. Remember how he almost left to be with Satine?

@Silver4Hire2

2 жыл бұрын

But the epic duel?

@GawkyDevotee

2 жыл бұрын

He almost left because of his feelings for satine, he probably wouldn't leave for anakin

@dumb_lifeexe2264

2 жыл бұрын

He wouldnt leave for anakin he was also blinded with the jedi ways

@mowermen1762

2 жыл бұрын

@@GawkyDevotee What if Satine joined anikan so obi could have the best of both worlds plus the dual could be a sparing match gone wrong and anikin got to emotional

@GeoKk7

2 жыл бұрын

@@GawkyDevotee Satine would propably have the save fate as she had in the Clone Wars. I don't think Maul would have stayed in the shadows from the events of episode I to when he shows up witg his Sith army. That would be almost 30 years. His arc would be pretty much the same up until he gets captured by Sidious. And he manages to escape after the chaos caused by his death and then hides maybe on Dathomir, preparing for his return while watching the Jedi falling apart.

Could you imagine Jon and Dave making a series of this What If?! I think it would be one of the greatest Star Wars stories ever!!! Totally blew me away!!?

@placeholdername3818

2 жыл бұрын

I'd also love a what if Anakin won the fight with Obi-Wan.

As alternate timelines go? This is going to be my Star Wars Legion army backstory. Wicked work.

I think if Anakin had listened to Qui Gon’s ghost, there would be far less violence than in this scenario, even with the death of Windu (which is unlikely given his power and skill) . He would know that he needed to absolutely hold to a non violence strategy. After Padme died there is no way that Qui Gonn wouldn’t arrive again and reset Anakin on his path. Also, imo there is no way Anakin could fight Obi Wan to the end knowing that he hadn’t ruined his whole life before. Great video though, love to see alternate theories like this about the series I love. Keep up the great work guys.

Fun fact about Dooku, he stayed true to his resolve, even to the point that the dark side could corrupt his body. Dooku is probably the most based sith

@mkpoyo5720

Жыл бұрын

What about revan? He used the dark side but didn't get corrupted by it. Dooku is based tho.

@djcwittz3012

Жыл бұрын

@@mkpoyo5720 I haven't played KOTOR, I got it and an OG Xbox from a friend but it never worked. Is he based?

@djcwittz3012

Жыл бұрын

Also which path was canon?

@korykrebs

Жыл бұрын

@@djcwittz3012 light side is canon, with romanced bastila

@djcwittz3012

Жыл бұрын

@@korykrebs good to know, but I'd say non-canon is still worth looking at

Then really need to do a “What If…?” for Star Wars.

@samgondel2657

2 жыл бұрын

in clone wars animation

@Punz18

2 жыл бұрын

@@samgondel2657 Or in Star Wars Visions animations because those will be just as dope

@samgondel2657

2 жыл бұрын

@@Punz18 i hate anime animations

@xaoz2362

2 жыл бұрын

@@samgondel2657 and?

@thekingmr.z2515

2 жыл бұрын

@@samgondel2657 Same, I've never liked Anime Animation style

This is a really interesting idea, but I'm pretty sure Palpatine wouldn't be so easy for Anakin to kill. Palpatine is smart and his reflexes are insane, and I'm pretty sure he'd retrieve and activate his lightsaber before Anakin could strike him down.

@Marcusjnmc

Жыл бұрын

I don't think Anakin even had a chance at that point vs Palpatine without it costing him his own life & then only via acting as a force conduit at near death to channel , pretty much only an uninjured Anakin that spent a decade or so gaining strengh & actually widening his grasp on the force could have beat Palpatine without dying doing it, Anakin embodies near endless but ultimately unrealised potential .

@GergelyKosztolanyi

Жыл бұрын

Maybe Anakin would just make a different choice during Windu's confrontation with him. They were pretty much evenly matched, he could have just cut off Palpie's head instead of Windu's hands.

@arcadedomination8006

Жыл бұрын

Anakin could simply reveal Palpatine's true identity to Mace Windu like he does in the movies. With four Jedi Masters and Anakin together, they could arguably take Palpatine out.

@errebusaether

Жыл бұрын

@@Marcusjnmc Yeah this What IF story is like how a regressed Anakin would’ve done if he had his former experience as both Vader and Anakin turning him into a grey jedi.

@LanMandragon1720

Жыл бұрын

@@arcadedomination8006 Definitely could no arguably needed Windu did so by himself OTL.

I would love to see a Star Wars "What if" series with this as a storyline.

the fact that every little thing is a "path to the darkside" is a fact

Very interesting take on a huge what if story line for Star Wars. I would actually be an awesome movie series

@MrLee-cy1pw

2 жыл бұрын

Yes. You would be an awesome movie series, Ryan Thomas.

@memeeater4703

2 жыл бұрын

@@MrLee-cy1pw it's settled then. Ryan Thomas would actually be an awesome movie series

@TexterEX

2 жыл бұрын

Yes you would be.

@earlwyss520

2 жыл бұрын

Better than the last 3 films.

@zenvis

2 жыл бұрын

I completely agree!

I thought about the Jedi Civil War, but I always thought it would be Mace Windu who wound up causing it, not Anakin. It was Mace's idea that the Jedi overthrow the Senate and take its place in order for Sidious to be brought to true justice. Yoda talked Mace down, saying they had to trust the system, arrest Sidious, and hope the Senate can see through the lies. Mace and three masters do try to arrest Palpatine, but he kills three of them and brings Mace to the brink of breaking his vows and killing Sidious when he appears helpless. Only Anakin betraying Mace and cutting his arm off did Sidious get the upper hand. If Anakin just stood there, slack jawed and uncertain what to do, Mace would've killed Sidious. I think that would've torn the Jedi order apart, with Mace becoming a darker version of himself who believed the Jedi knew what's best for the Republic and Yoda leading his own army who still believe democracy is best and the Jedi should merely be anmbassadors of good. I think Mace would get Anakin on his side if, after the death of Sidious, he recognized Anakin as a Master. Mace was always against Anakin and his ideals but, in many ways, Mace's way of thinking matched Anakin's, and if the guy who's been hyper critical of you since you were a boy suddenly realizes you had the right idea and embraces you as an advisor, of course Anakin would jump at the chance.

@curlyhuemen9063

11 ай бұрын

Would Anakin really join mace, I think not lol

GIVE THIS MAN A MEDAL this is the fresh new beginning we need in star wars

I feel like mace would’ve killed dooku instead of the other way around leading to Anakin killing windu. But besides that this is a great alternate timeline.

@andrewforte3852

2 жыл бұрын

Luke wanted to kill Mace since episode 1 when being screened or tested to be trained. So that would've been more fitting.

@rookie8302

2 жыл бұрын

@@andrewforte3852 what are you talking here man? Luke in episode 1?

@andrewforte3852

2 жыл бұрын

@@rookie8302 Oh I'm sorry 😐. I mean 9 year old Anikan. Thank you 😌 for the correction.

@Starwars-Fanboy

2 жыл бұрын

I feel like there's no way Anakin would've let dooku into his order. Anakin would use him then dispose of Dooku just like he did to sidious in this alternate timeline. I could believe he'd allow ventress a shot a redemption though. She did help Ashoka in S 5

@Tamamo-no-Bae

2 жыл бұрын

@@Starwars-Fanboy Dooku was always pragmatic, so I think he would genuinely turn to Anakin's side and while Anakin wouldn't trust him, his expertise and ties to Qui-Gon would let him keep him around.

Anakin's "Jedi Empire" sounds a LOT like Sauron's plans to rule Middle Earth: both lovers of their personal form of order, and both believing they would have to impose THEIR order on all.

@Unholy_Brez

2 жыл бұрын

I mean to be fair its a concept that was used is star wars before with Darth Revan. and honestly I can see the Parallels with LOTRs nd Starwars in said story.

@LordVader1094

2 жыл бұрын

@@Unholy_Brez I think you mean Darth Revan right? Lol

@Unholy_Brez

2 жыл бұрын

@@LordVader1094 thank you I didn't even notice till I read the reply😂😂

@orctrihar

2 жыл бұрын

@@Unholy_Brez To be fair Sauron existed before Revan

@ADDISON6368

2 жыл бұрын

@@orctrihar not fully.. darth raven made in before 2003 because comics and novels of him before the Knights of the Old Republic which in 2003 so you can say they both around same time both around 2001+ to max 2003

I love this timeline almost more than the original.

I think this alternate universe/timeline you created is interesting. I’d love to see it in a comic like the old “Star Wars Alternates” or even as a Motion Comic here on KZread. Thankfully the BoBF gave us a glimpse of Ahsoka with Luke, I always wished for before, and even after seeing that, that Ahsoka would have more of an active role in Luke’s life, sharing stories about their father and the battles they fought together, and stories of their mother and just what type of leader she was. Hope to see more!

I really enjoy Ryan's little what if stories.

@chadcognac5626

2 жыл бұрын

Absolutely.

@saugatanandi7918

2 жыл бұрын

IFKR

@ElisonTheDuck

2 жыл бұрын

but not ryan johnson's

"Would you like to see more?" You bet your ass I would. This alternate timeline is so beautiful and it fits so much to the Star Wars universe or multiverse, the original characters are not forgotten and the prequel's characters acted as how they are like and this truly feels like a What if by Marvel Studios lol. Overall, if possible, we need a Disney+ show about this alternate timeline.

Anakin is supposed to bring balance to the force. Which he did by killing all the Jedi so that there are almost as many Sith as there are Jedi. In the Republic there were almost no Sith and a lot of Jedi. With this prophecy no one ever stopped to think what balance means. They just thought it meant something good.

@knightsofpie

Жыл бұрын

but if everyone is a grey Jedi that brings balance as well, because they use both sides of the force.

@asldfjkalsdfjasdf

Жыл бұрын

@@knightsofpie If Anakin hat the chance to talk about the dark side with his mentors and discover this power with a guide like mace windu he might not have seen the necessity to save palpatine. So yeah the cultish ways of the jedi order where its downfall in that one moment.

@dastardlyokami9682

Жыл бұрын

I don’t think this is correct he’s supposed to bring balance to the force. Not to the amount of force users

@alphasma

Жыл бұрын

Balancing the force doesn't mean having an equal amount of Jedi and Sith because as long as the Sith exist, they'll attempt to unbalance the Force. Instead, it's all about allowing Dark and Light to interact in harmony, like a river, which is basically the whole "grey jedi" ideology

@tlanda6

Жыл бұрын

@@asldfjkalsdfjasdf you could possibly be right, but the Council feared him so much due to his power and seemingly “unstable” nature, meanwhile they only furthered his fear and instability. Especially that grudge-holding Mace Windu. He needed Yoda & Obi-Wan, and when he needed them most they were too blind to their OWN fears that they induced more instability and fear into Anakin. I’m glad he turned, he did bring balance. Awe, is it not exactly the balance the arrogant Jedi had in their arrogant minds? You’re telling me the prophecy wasn’t EXACTLY the way the Jedi envisioned it in THEIR minds…right. Arrogance on such a high level it’s ridiculous

I like this alternate turn of events, It's always great seeing or thinking about paths not taken.

This could make for a great What If series. I hope you’re paying attention Disney…

@TheAutisticBrony

2 жыл бұрын

While I think that's a great idea I don't think Star Wars canonically has a Multiverse. I could be wrong tho

@XenoZbornak

2 жыл бұрын

I can assure you they are not.

I like this theory. Even tho Grey Jedi isn’t technically “canon”. I personally always gravitated towards that lore.

@555cutsnake666

2 жыл бұрын

Same. I always thought the grey should be canon. Only giving the old "good vs bad" just doesn't make sence anymore

@N7spongy

2 жыл бұрын

@@555cutsnake666 But why, it's so out of place with the movies

@kirannkornat7761

2 жыл бұрын

This whole scenario also isn’t technically “canon” so what’s your point

@iloveowls90

2 жыл бұрын

@@555cutsnake666 agreed!

@krakhedd

2 жыл бұрын

I believe pre-Disney canon included grey force users, even rarely Jedi. General Kota comes to mind

I wasn't expecting it to be bad, but that was way more interesting than I thought it would be. Great concept! I can totally see this as part of a what if series.

I like the civil war idea, however Anakin being a dad will change him, most dads become gentle, very protective sure but by changing that moment of not killing the Raiders and seeing his mentor, will change the future, but he has his old master as a guide. Now for the Vader issue, there has too be a Vader so make it a clone that the emperor had as a back up. Overall I like the beginning of the video premise however I don’t think the Grey Jedi would be as aggressive as you imply. Great video

(3:13) Exactly - the Jedi think that everything is a path to the dark side - and because the Jedi take the policy of ignorance and denial (denial of attachments, ignoring that the Jedi are sapient beings who will get curious...) instead of acceptance and training (accepting that some Jedi might want to have a family - and accepting that and letting them raise said family in a safe environment, as well as training Jedi to resist the dark side instead of denying it exists). Do I want more of this series? Definitely yes.

@lonesomewendigo

2 жыл бұрын

"A life without emotion is no life at all. A life controlled by emotion will be destroyed by it."

@BansheeKing22

2 жыл бұрын

@@lonesomewendigo I like kratos quote to his son about anger. "Anger can be a weapon if you can control it" Its better to be the one in control while at the same time not denying said emotions exist or suppressing them.

@CliffCardi

2 жыл бұрын

“Only a Sith deals in absolutes.”

The only issue I have with this is palpatine dying so easily…. Palpatine could feel anakins conflict and was really observant all the time. I think palpatine would play a huge part but towards the end of the first civil war.

@luuska8657

2 жыл бұрын

i get you but even if palpatine fought against anakin at that moment, he would've still died very quickly, either to anakin or the jedi council

@flaminghotcheetosarebest7117

2 жыл бұрын

@@luuska8657 What? Palpatine was a equal match to YODA anakin would never stand a chance unless he got to his full potential.

@flaminghotcheetosarebest7117

2 жыл бұрын

I feel like there is a lot of flaws with this. Like me i love star wars and theres just so many things that are wrong. obi wan would not win to a more calculated and powerful anakin. and his suit would be without a mask because darth vaders suit was made with the wrong alloys and cybernetic to be uncomfortable and painful. It was palpatines way of punishing him and to channel more dark side energy through pain.

@attilaseyfullah8522

2 жыл бұрын

An Anakin as wise as in this scenario, would not start a civil war untill the sith are annihiliated.

@the_broke_spartan

2 жыл бұрын

You all are forgetting one thing by the time anakin betrays Palpatine he will have an entire army of deadly Grey jedi and ventress anakin count dukoo and ahsoka could overpower Palpatine but killing dukoo

I love this thought exercise. I don't think it would have been easy for Anakin to recruit other Jedi without arousing the suspicions of the other Masters, however, as they were already on high-alert after the return of the Sith for any Jedi showing "alternative" viewpoints. Ironically, I think the one that has the best chance of converting to Anakin's side is Windu, at least at the flashpoint of Windu vs. Sidious. At that point, Windu was going against both the Jedi order and Republic law. If Anakin sided with him then, there could perhaps be a conversation between two soldiers on how corrupt things had become, and what to do to change it. Windu as a collaborator would be a great smokescreen for Anakin's recruitment.

The creativity was off the charts for this one Ryan

I feel like Palpatine would be able to sense that Anakin wasn’t truly on his side. Just like Anakin could sense the conflict between his children. At the very least, I think he should have been on guard for Anakin’s betrayal, and maybe had a brief duel before realizing Anakin was too powerful when leaning into the dark and the light, and he’s then defeated.

@tianyizhou6108

Жыл бұрын

if anakin had to face palpatine head on, he would have lost. Even vader was not strong enough to beat the emperor, at least not yet. eventually he would have, but anakin is way too inexperienced in the dark side to defeat palpatine unless it was a sneak attack.

@JeffreyAllanBackowski

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, that was the first red flag for me, the second was Palpatine told him about order 66.

@westenev

Жыл бұрын

​@@tianyizhou6108 I disagree - I think pre-vader Anikin could have won against anyone if he was able to get a hold on his inner demons (the fact that he couldn't was why he lost to Obi-wan). As Vader, his life support was deliberately left exposed, which would be a huge hinderance in a fight.

@tianyizhou6108

Жыл бұрын

@@westenev the suit fueled the dark side in him. He was in constant pain from the burns since the suit was only able to keep him alive but not completely numb. Also he lost Padme and that was a lingering thought as well. I don’t believe that anakin would have been able to be aggressive enough and strike down palpatine without the will like Vader does.

@jordanlyons2609

Жыл бұрын

@@tianyizhou6108 it was stated Anakin could beat Vader in a fight

Its funny how luke is always stated to be the strongest jedi. We all know, that Anakins medichlorian was the highest which makes anakin to the most powerful.

@legokingtm9462

2 жыл бұрын

Except did anybody even check Luke's medichlorian?

@vsnipez-btw8305

2 жыл бұрын

@@legokingtm9462 its like 15 k or something

@attilaseyfullah8522

2 жыл бұрын

didn't George Lucas say that Luke had the equal full potential of Anakin?

@jacobhaslam5223

2 жыл бұрын

This would be true if anakin wasn’t damaged and had his powers limited

Damn this was some great story telling man this guy is really creative and i also just generally love his starwars content

Definitely want more of this timeline... thank you ❤

This video was single handedly better than the entirety of the new trilogy. What a cool idea!

@HairyBayleaf

2 жыл бұрын

better than the prequels, too

@luisescalante2063

2 жыл бұрын

Real fans should create SW

@timhaldane7588

2 жыл бұрын

That's a weird way of writing "the prequels"

@TheAverageGamer1

2 жыл бұрын

Imagine letting movies live in your head rent free😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

@alphamale2641

2 жыл бұрын

Well said 👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

This makes me think of Revan’s reason for leaving the Old Order, and I like it

the editing is god tier man

Wow this was spectacular. I truly appreciated the fact that palpatine's reveal left significant scars on Padme's ability to believe in her own governance.

Enjoyed the ending, similar to "the father" celestials actions when Anakin encountered them in the clone wars series. Sacrificing himself to end the sons rebellion.

This would be an amazing Disney plus show

@timvanhoeck7018

2 жыл бұрын

Lol, that will never happen. Disney is too focused pushing diversity quotas and demonizing traditional Star Wars fans than actually making a good story with good characters that's respectful to the source material.

@the_jam_man

2 жыл бұрын

@@timvanhoeck7018 they DID make the marvel what if show

@timvanhoeck7018

2 жыл бұрын

@Dominant Domination The Mandalorian has nothing to do with my sentiments regarding the Disney films. I'm speaking specifically of the Woke Wars Trilogy, which the Mandalorian is not a part of. And no, I am not delusional, I see the Disney films for the absolute abominations and utterly disrespectful Communist propanda trash that they truly are.

@timvanhoeck7018

2 жыл бұрын

@@the_jam_man Marvel sucks just as bad as Disney Wars.

@the_jam_man

2 жыл бұрын

@@timvanhoeck7018 don't worry, I completely respect your opinion just letting you know that we might get a what if star wars show. I'm just saying it would be pretty cool.

This was awesome! Thank you!

This is awesome dude

What if… LOTR, Aragorn didn’t take up the sword, Gandalf didn’t return, Boromir kept the ring, etc…

@matheusfiorelli8829

2 жыл бұрын

What if Gandalf never discovered Bilbo's ring is the One Ring

@grzegorzbrzeczyszczykiewic1139

2 жыл бұрын

What if elves just took the ring to Valinor...

@thedrunkmenace2250

2 жыл бұрын

What if smaug never fell

Screencrush: *zooms in on jar-jar* Also Screen crush: ”The people they know aren’t Sith pawns”

This is great mate thank you

I know I am new to this, but I would love to see more of this universe. Keep it up, my friend!

I feel Mace's position would be more nuanced in this scenario, a bit closer to count Dooku but like a mirror image

Personally I see this like the “what if” Gandalf took the one ring scenario. Anakin would believe he is doing good but it would be a tyrannical rule where individuality is purged in pursuit of being “good”. You should pitch this to Lucasfilm, I would very much watch this Star Wars “what if” series if this was a thing.

@SiddharthShenoy

2 жыл бұрын

I doubt Anakin would do that, he knows what it's like to be a slave, being stripped of will, the only reason Vader went along with the empire was because he had no choice, he just helped kill a Jedi Master and would executed by either the Jedi or Palpatine, if he didn't join him, leading to Padmè's death, and after he lost to Obi-Wan, he lost everything, his wife, his kids, his order, his mentor, and a huge chunk of his body, in a way Palps was the only one he had left, and despite how much he hates him, he goes along with his ideas, so that he can live to fight another day.

@omarcrespo77

2 жыл бұрын

Pitching ideas to Lucasfilm is *TIGHT*!!☝️😁

@lukeskywalker3472

2 жыл бұрын

@@SiddharthShenoy hello father

@obiwankenobi1608

2 жыл бұрын

@@SiddharthShenoy Some say hi to your son damn it.

I loved it, keep it coming.

Hell yeah that was great please continue. I have subscribed.

This was one of the best thought out, well written and edited, what if video I've seen for Star Wars. You really out did yourself with this video. I'd love to see someone actually take a shot of writing out this AU storyline.

I love these kind of reimagining theories. I think this one is wholly impossible though. Anakin, if not the whole Galaxy but Anakin in paticular, has been essentially mindtricked by Palpatine since becoming his confidant. Qui gon can't communicate with him because Palpatine has shrouded his mind already. In fact, as suggested Palpatine's mind fog is so powerful it has clouded the entire Jedi council and Senate by the time the first movie has started rolling. Some proof of how influential and pervasive this effect is: -Whenever Palpatine speaks in his sith voice Anakin always obeys, such as when he commands the killing of Count Dooku -When Palpatine attacks Windu's squad of knights he 'screams', but look at the Jedi response: *they don't move at all.* This is because the Jedi rely SOLELY on the force telling them how to move, and Palpatine is exerting his force power to block their ability to communicate with the Force. Meaning he can cut off the force entirely for even highly trained Jedi even if only for a brief few seconds. -Look at how Windu raises his lightsaber when he goes to kill Palpatine. He goes in for a one handed wide swing, a completely illogical and complicated mechanical movement when a thrust would have done just fine. In fact, the whole conversation with Anakin at this point is labored and Windu's stance somewhat out of character and illogical, his face contorted, frustrated and confused: perhaps because of the influence of Palpatine on their emotions(although I also think at this point Palpatine may be relaxing his usage because he wants Anakins reaction to be authentic, so the psychotic break it causes in him is total. Or perhaps he is influencing and clouding the mind of Windu, but not Anakin)Again, immediately following the death of Windu Palpatine speaks to Anakin and names him Vader all while speaking in his 'sith voice': he is actively manipulating the now shattered psyche of Anakin using the Force. The truth is, the game was rigged from the start. The only complication to Palpatine's foresight and scheming was Luke, and perhaps the Jedi Ghosts, culminating ultimately in Anakin himself actually fulfillinghis role in the prophecy by rejecting the darkness inside of himself in the end. Or perhaps gaining ultimate control came at the cost of losing the subversive power his prior clandestine approach had afforded him. Nevertheless, it seems to me that until this point everything went as Palpatine foresaw and desired and there was very little chance of any deviation. *edit I should add that all of these assertions are based solely off the movies, excluding any movie made post Revenge of the Sith. As an aside I feel pretty confident Palpatine would never make clones of himself because A) he seems to already hold the Dark side power of eternal life and B) would likely not suffer another version of himself running around or to continue his legacy. Even as a sort of body transplant system, I feel his confidence in his foresight would cause him to disregard such action as wholly unecessary.

@themakebelieverproductions6342

2 жыл бұрын

"The truth is... The game was rigged from the start"

@zeph6182

2 жыл бұрын

I don’t know about Palpatine not making clones. He had many interests in the dark side of the force, and I think him cloning himself is not out of question if not solely to experiment on said clone.

@tc-channelhobby4051

Жыл бұрын

yeah the game was rigged from the start so like the video implied how about anakin turns it onto its head? What if Anakin instead of playing fiddle to two factions, instead starts his own and rebels against it.

@ham5838

Жыл бұрын

I think Anakin speaks with qui gon in the clone war series

@fluffykittykat3703

Жыл бұрын

Best 👏🏼 comment 👏🏼 here 👏🏼

This is good. never would have thought of this myself. Well done. now i want more

That was quite enjoyable to listen to and I would actually love to see that story arc.

I'm skeptical that Dooku could take down Mace Windu

@toratiger1

2 жыл бұрын

Indeed, Mace Windu is shown time and time again to have supreme combat effectiveness. Would at least feel more plausible if an aspect was mentioned that put Mace at severe tactical disadvantage. Could perhaps be as simple as overwhelming numbers, hard to sense surprise sneak attack, or Dooku going after light-side younglings while Mace heroically sacrifices himself to save them all.

@flolikeyou6053

2 жыл бұрын

He couldn’t. Mace would beat him.

@fireisfire461

2 жыл бұрын

I think Dooku could maybe beat windu. As plagueis himself one told palpatine that his greatest threat in the Jedi order was Dooku. Both because of his ideas that he passed onto qui Gon. But also because of his skill with the lightsaber. Thus I think Dooku in his prime could whoop maces as when mace was in his prime. But older Dooku would be an equal fight, where victory depends on circumstance.

@krismikewill

2 жыл бұрын

If you remember, Windu had no desire to take on Grievous, who was taught lightsaber combat by Dooku. If Dooku did not use Dark Side powers, he could beat Windu (whose Vaapad "fed" off of Dark Side). But your point is taken either way.

@echo6501

2 жыл бұрын

@@krismikewill yeah I agree, Vaapad is less does not have any effect on Dooku, Dooku may be a dark side user, but he does not have Sith eyes, though he is a Sith. Dooku can defeat Mace WIndu, but that doesn't mean Mace Windu cannot win

I'd love to see this timeline pursued in a series or a video game. Imagine how in depth it could go, a couple seasons covering the rise of the Jedi empire and a couple for the twins, the casting would be a nightmare but it'd probably be SO worth it.

This is interesting I love AU stories. They are entirely my jam so thanks for this one.

This was amazing!!! 👍🏾

This had me and lost me a lot throughout. I definitely liked parts of it. Just want my man Anakin to not get burnt up 😂😂

@Lorenatpwk

2 жыл бұрын

Trueee 😂😂😂

@Asian19981

2 жыл бұрын

I agree with you 🤣🤣🤣

im getting strong "What if Anikin were on the same path as Reven" energy with this and im all for it

Impressive, most impressive. Love the use of clips. I don't find that Dooku would be able to defeat Windu, or that Padme would ever go along with this, but still mostly believable.

Nice job. I dig your alternate time line

“This is where the fun begins” Must inspire SO much fear in this universe XDDD

This was an amazing video!

This was amazing. The kind of What If reimagining I could get behind.

Anakin: "Fine. I'll do it myself..."

Alternate title: What if Anakin acted how he would have in Canon

@Tamamo-no-Bae

2 жыл бұрын

@Dominant Domination Anakin in this what-if acted a lot like he would have in canon. The only difference is that Qui-Gon gave him some pointers and he carried out his ideology.

@ollielast5077

2 жыл бұрын

@Dominant Domination he’s saying that would of likely been the canon occurrence.

that was so good! more of thst please!

Thinking about it, it would be a simple thing for the whole situation involving the control chip and Fives that Anakin could find out about the contingency orders that can force clone troopers to perform certain acts. It also would not be hard for him to convince the kaminoans that it would be better for them to work with him and the empire he would build than Palpatine who would likely decide to eliminate witnesses to keep the truth buried. He would not need to find out about Order 66 from Palpatine in this way.

I would love to see this timeline in movies. This feels a lot more interesting then what we saw with 789. Even though they rewrite 23456. I think If it kept to this kind of outline. It would be a great series. So I want to hear more from this timeline.

Some inconsistencies with this theory: The senate don't know the difference between sith and Jedi, so they would see Palpatine as a Jedi attempting to take over. Furthermore Anakin killing the chancellor would cause outrage, and anti Jedi resentment. This would likely mean that an order 66 like order would happen, maybe not in the form of a purge but something similar. Also because Anakin becomes a grey Jedi it's possible he learns new techniques so the battle of the duel of fates between Anakin and Obiwan would turn very differently

@Fl3XeR4

2 жыл бұрын

I don't think Anakin would have been able to pick new techniques up so fast when he had no one to train him in this specific area of combat . And let alone control over the grey area of the force. with Anakin's week mind it would consume him very fast if he did it with no guidance. the only "grey" jedi that could have taught some grey area techniques and control the force at this time, would have been windu...

@svealon

Жыл бұрын

Yeah I thought about this too, Anakin would win 100% against obi wan

@TheRandomshite123

Жыл бұрын

@@Fl3XeR4 after embracing the dark side for less than a week he was able to go toe to toe with obi wan, after over 3 years of embracing both light and some dark he would dominate obi wan and not be arrogant enough as to get wounded like he did

@munozali1

Жыл бұрын

I don't think that's true. The Senate know about the Sith just from knowing the Republic's history.

@jabs_labs6828

Жыл бұрын

@@munozali1 most senators are corrupt and don't care about the past. They also are not informed in the Jedi's history

This was honestly a very well made theory!

Wow this is done brilliantly..!

Anakin allying with Maul would be an interesting timeline, but Id also love to see this timeline more :D

Wow. Great story. I would love to see a book or comic series tell this in more detail

So good, more please!

3:27 this reminds me a fan film with Revan in it, in this film Revan says the line "You are a fool to listen to your master's if they tell you there is only one way" referring to how the jedi is fighting said the dark side is evil and using is not the answer