VW Beetle vs Golf I vs Volkswagen I.D. Evolution of Design interview & review - Autogefühl
Автокөліктер мен көлік құралдары
►Subscribe and/or bookmark our direct channel link: www.autogefuehl.com
►German Blog: autogefuehl.de
►Support us on Patreon: / autogefuehl
►Exclusive supporter: Ajlan Saeed
Facebook: facebook.de/autogefuehl
Twitter: / autogefuehl
Instagram: / autogefuehl
**Playlists for latest reviews**
FULL REVIEWS 2016 Q4
• FULL REVIEWS 2016 Q4
FULL REVIEWS 2016 Q3
• FULL REVIEWS 2016 Q3
FULL REVIEWS 2016 Q2
• FULL REVIEWS 2016 Q2
FULL REVIEWS 2016 Q1:
• FULL REVIEWS 2016 Q1
**Playlists for car brands**
Alfa Romeo: • Alfa Romeo car test re...
Aston Martin: • Aston Martin
Audi: • Audi car reviews
Bentley: • Bentley
BMW: • BMW car reviews Fahrbe...
Cadillac: • Cadillac
Citroen: • Citroen test drive rev...
Ferrari: • Ferrari
Fiat: • Fiat test reviews Fahr...
Ford: • Ford reviews
Honda: • Honda
Hyundai: • Hyundai car test revie...
Infiniti: • Infiniti
Jaguar: • Jaguar test reviews Fa...
Kia: • KIA test reviews Fahrb...
Land Rover: • Land Rover car test re...
Lexus: • Lexus reviews
Lamborghini: • Lamborghini
Maserati: • Maserati car test revi...
Mazda: • Mazda
McLaren: • McLaren
Mercedes: • Mercedes cars reviews
Mini: • The new Mini
Mitsubishi: • Mitsubishi SUV and off...
Nissan: • Nissan test reviews Fa...
Opel: • Opel / Vauxhall test r...
Peugeot: • Peugeot car reviews
Porsche: • Porsche test reviews F...
Range Rover: • Range Rover car reviews
Renault: • Renault car reviews an...
Rolls Royce: • Rolls Royce
Seat: • Seat
Skoda: • Skoda test reviews Fah...
Smart: • smart car reviews & news
Subaru: • Subaru
Tesla: • tesla
Toyota: • Toyota test drive reviews
Vauxhall: • Opel / Vauxhall test r...
Volkswagen: • VW Volkswagen cars rev...
Volvo: • Volvo test reviews
**Playlists for car genres**
Editor's selection: • Editor's selection
Special Autogefühl episodes: • Special Autogefühl Epi...
Electric and Hybrid cars: • Electric car test revi...
Acceleration: • Acceleration videos
SUV: • SUV cars test reviews
Luxury cars: • Luxury cars reviews
Performance cars: • Performance cars reviews
Supercars: • Supercars
Dream cars: • dream cars
Пікірлер: 86
If you're looking for a SUV version then check out our latest video of the VW I. D. Crozz: kzread.info/dash/bejne/dnmIvLCNgNDSZ7A.html But we can also offer you the future Transporter: kzread.info/dash/bejne/eaB30dd6lpa-mJM.html
Join us on this fantastic tour through automotive history and design!
@sketchpro12
7 жыл бұрын
thanks for doing that!, really good to see them side by side. I currently drive an e-Golf, so it's great to see the next stage :) At first I thought the 'eyes' were a bit of a gimmick, but now hearing about the autonomous mode having a personality it makes sense and I can see would make people want to buy this. I glad to see VW embrace the grill-less front end again, especially on an EV which doesn't need them :) I just hope the final version is a 5 seater, 4 is a BIG no no at least in the US.
This was so cool, best car channel on KZread!!
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks so much, spread the word :)
Great video and presentation Thomas! Really enjoyed it.
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thx buddy!
For an enthusiast like me, this video was a journey thru time. A tour de force in the Volkswagen's visions of what can define a great car. The presence of the head of the design department in the entire VW group is a proof of the prestige of Autogefühl. The VW ID is a jewel of design, function and space. It paves the way of the future and I hope can see it happening... Excelent work, Thomas.
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
great comment :)
This is becoming my favourite car channel. Great job Thomas and everyone else behind the scene.
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks, stick with us!
Hi Tomas thank you for great reviews!!!
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks for the support !
Thomas, another great review! Was just wondering which car do you drive on daily basis?
Awesome video!
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks !
Excellent, great video
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
appreciated!
Always enjoy your videos :)
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
also in full HD and full screen? :D
@worldtravel101
7 жыл бұрын
yes, but often on mobile device too
Love your discussion with these three models. Maybe pick other iconic cars to discuss? Mini, Ford, etc.
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
let's see if we can do somehting in this direction
I never understand why the finished cars are so wildly different to the concept cars. It’s an exercise in futility - “let’s build something we will never actually make! Look at what you’ll never get!”
Hi Thomas, thank you for the interesting and brief review! Before I start, I like to mention that when this KZread started to play, I thought you are in a painting! I liked the background wall color behind you mixed with the floor color below you, together in a way I couldn't notice where the wall & floor intersect! Sure I like the beetle and its model through the years, and the latest beetle is really great! Also the Golf, even it was a revolution in the 70's, we could notice that year after year it was getting better and sure the latest Golf got the most beautiful shape! I remember one quote for VW I read it since around 15 years in one of their Golf brochures "The aim of design is not doing something different but doing something better", now! Regarding the VW I.D, for me, in general it looks great, I only didn't like the A1 & A2 pillars, they look a very old design solution like a van or a bus, I don't know! Since Mr. Klaus mentioned that this car will face further little changes until its final setting, I advise you to look after these two A1 & A2 pillars, try to hide them both or keep only one pillar "PLEASE"! Beside that, I don't have any other negative feeling towards it, I believe it is a very successful shape and can be improved successfully year after year through its future! :)
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks for the feedback m8 !
19:00 they forgot to hide the plug :D (underneath the car)
Thankyou for this wonderful historic VW journey. Isnt it amazing that the Golf 1 is still being sold in South Africa as well as the newer Golf models. The Id is an exciting look into the future. Very enjoyable video, Thomas !
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks! Didnt they stop the city golf in 2009 or 2011 ?
@ericburbach632
7 жыл бұрын
I havent been to SA for a while so you might have better information than I have
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
hm, wikipedia says production stopped 2009. Incredibly long still
@ericburbach632
7 жыл бұрын
I drove one to Namibia, it wasnt much fun
Great video Two motoring icons and a third about to be reality
Would be awesome to see the type one mould come back into production
This is really great and I like the focus on the important part of the history of VW. Was this also recorded in german language as well?
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks! No, we offer a service for the international community, thats why English :)
@Hvitserk67
7 жыл бұрын
OK. Thanks a lot :)
I bet it looks quite a lot different when it actually comes on sale in 2020
Thank you Thomas. The 1958 Beetle is my favorite. How will we transition from autonomous to non-autonomous driving in the future? In one fell swoop or will it be something that occurs gradually? One other thing: The 2017 Passat R-Line in the US offers great features for a very reasonable price. Would it be possible for you to review that car?
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
good question. Let me try to find out if that's possible
"...in this unique package." Interesting term, "package." The 2017 Golf Family VW Brochure describes the Golf R as follows: "Everything in the Golf R is dialed up. It creates a total package that's expertly crafted, sophisticated and technologically advanced." I've reflected on this video over the past few weeks and I"m not sure that I fully grasp the strategy, planning and execution that goes into marketing a vehicle's "package" and why. Is a car manufacturer's model the package, or is it the trim level? Is it more than that? What about available features such as an optional lighting package or driver's assistance features? How does that impact the package? Any thoughts?
Good to hear comments from the head of VW design - Thanks Thomas. At 6:25 you said that earlier he had been responsible for interior design at VW - I wonder whether he had been involved in the superb clean interior design, and big step up in quality, of the 1996 Passat B5 interior and 1997 Golf Mk4. Anyway, good interview.
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks gordon!
Excellent report Thomas, I can hardly wait to see the final version of the ID actually on the road, it looks very promising. Have you heard what may be available when it's finally released such as maybe a six seat version or a wagon/estate for more flexibility?
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks! I think they will start with the "basic" version first
@peterfriswell2875
7 жыл бұрын
Thanks. I was expecting that but just wondering what may be in the pipeline further down the track using that platform. The industry changes from now on will be very interesting to see.
Loved it
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
Excellent Vlog, thanks. I used to own a Beetle and loved it. I was looking at the Tesla model 3, but after seeing the I.D. I think this has the chance to be much better!
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
thanks keep supporting us! A Beetle Cabriolet special will be coming up in a couple of weaks :)
AMAZING THANKS
I enjoyed watching it but you could have done better. Who was this film for? On one hand you don't mention such basic things like the trunk space behind the rear seats of the Beetle. On the other hand, if this material was meant for people with more knowledge, it's a pity you did not ask more sophisticated questions about design to such a well-informed person.
Thank you
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
no problem
The Golf 1 design really is a masterpiece so I loved when he said that lol
@chch_chris
4 жыл бұрын
VW South Africa continued to produce the Mark 1 for many years as the Citi Golf. They had a great advertising campaign when it launched, using a Piet Mondriaan concept (the cars were originally only in blue, yellow, and red) kzread.info/dash/bejne/i4mhl7CbcdG2Yrw.html kzread.info/dash/bejne/X4xkqK18fszFppc.html
Great video. Love seeing the evolution of design. Not a fan of autonomous cars though. I actually like to drive!!
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
Thanks for sharing your opinion with us! Hope you also tune in to our other videos :)
The I.D. looks very cool and it definitely is the way for the future! But what I'd like to see is a modern rear-engined Beetle! The next gen Beetle could be rear-engined!
@McBeamer94
7 жыл бұрын
Either electric or hybrid! But I think electric is a more practical solution, for some reason or another! Batteries on the floor pan, electric motor at the back! Yeah, this can be done too! And then play the air-cooled boxer's soundtrack from the speakers! ;-P
do a VW Atlas, waiting for it.
I DON'T SEE THE ID LINE BECOMING THE NEXT BEETLE.
Why was the beetle has a bug shape because it resemble the egg shell which known for its rigidity provide by its round shape despite its thin sheetmetals. It is give best compromise for strenght and lightness. The golf which is designed by italian, which is a trend in 70''s. It obvious the metal technology has become better, and you don''t have to have rounded body to provide strenght. Moreover the angular shape of the golf give it spacey room despite the compact size. Much better than the cramped beetle.
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
interesting aspect!
The Beetle is by far the best looking car out of the 3 !
Last car looks like a baby toy car from Japan
vw I.D. very nice
The notion of the "autonomous car" is both worryingly utopian and dystopian at the same time. Moreover, in spite of all the technological advances that have been made since the days of the original Beetle or Golf, Volkswagen - or any other car maker for that matter - really need to remind themselves that cars are meant to be driven by humans, and not humans being driven by cars.
I wouldn't talk about the *roots* too much! wink wink
id is the original Citroën id 17
The beetle is the best Volkswagen car
Evolution? More like a stagnation.......
Pathetic. Cars should be driven for fun. Whats the point of progress if it result only in more work and less free time. Nobody will want to drive autonomous electric car in their free time.
@Schmexy
6 жыл бұрын
It'll have a steering wheel. You're thinking too far into the future.
First
No-1 nothing more...
beetle and golf 1 were never good cars just only sucessful.
Volkswagen always looked ugly in my opinion, the new one are getting better, but I still don't like them very much ^^
@lunarpking
7 жыл бұрын
I'm sorry that you think that
i couldn't follow the whole Video due the bad english and the often "ughs" of the Designer. A head of a big company should talk english much better to be honest....
@autogefuehl
7 жыл бұрын
his English is perfectly fine
@unluckynumbersleven
7 жыл бұрын
Paddifex Ka so... you're expecting the head of design of a GERMAN COMPANY to not only speak English (which he did very well) but for it to be completely unbroken, and I'm presuming without a very thick accent, as if he were a native to an English speaking country...? That's pretty ignorant.
@unluckynumbersleven
7 жыл бұрын
Paddifex Ka also let's not forget that this was filmed on location IN GERMANY on a KZread channel run by GERMANS featuring a GERMAN company. And because a native GERMAN struggled to remember a few words immediately in a foreign language, you're salty. Really let that sink in. anyway, hey Thomas! Great video as always! you're the best!
@gordonbennett6057
7 жыл бұрын
Tanner Young+ - I agree. It was great to hear a few views and opinions from such an important person from within this large global company that employs lots of people, being interviewed in a courteous, sensible and polite manner. (Oh, and as you say, he spoke perfectly good English - better than me, I'm sure).