I like how Frisk literally died the opposite way Chara did. Chara died having their soul absorbed by Asriel, but taking over control not letting him slay the humas as Frisk on the other hand died absorbing a monster soul and having their control overtaken by Asgore, not letting them leave. Very Fascinating.

@Vanilla_boy

Ай бұрын

Chara didn't take control over Asriel, what are you talking about?

@heitoraubinzanettimion3426

Ай бұрын

@@Vanilla_boy in this au chara did.

@Vanilla_boy

Ай бұрын

@@heitoraubinzanettimion3426 oh. Uhh. My bad sorry

@unreal_idk.

6 күн бұрын

for some reason the last two words on this comment made me feel satisfaction. thank you ig

I stood there watching for an entire minute thinking the video of the AU just had the worst framerate imaginable

@romeokukita277

Ай бұрын

Unoptimizedtale

@rosenfeldfamily9966

Ай бұрын

Unplayabletale

@bloxxer717

Ай бұрын

?

@funnybluecandle

Ай бұрын

they just forgot to reduce the polygons on the models

@Koronofoxy

28 күн бұрын

The game is a slide show.

This AU's Undyne and GG! Fell Sans have one thing in general, that is the fact that they love murdering helpless orphans.

@6.9LITRE-W16FAN.IsveryKool

Ай бұрын

that sht sounds like a kink 😭🙏

@thomasmoir3997

Ай бұрын

Just like me fr

@Thisisdragongod39w

Ай бұрын

Relatable

@MARSHTMP

Ай бұрын

also see: fellswap toriel

@Serperior1212

18 күн бұрын

@@thomasmoir3997your an orphan now

I just noticed that the comic makes it look like Frisk is teleporting throughout the underground.

@basedguy.4229

Ай бұрын

They kinda are..

Toriel dying like that was kinda funny/non-serious tbh

@takiallahjamai

Ай бұрын

TORIEL-PANCAKES

@Nerdonardo-1

Ай бұрын

"MOVE DAMMIT"

@cbbblue8348

22 күн бұрын

CESSAAAAAARRRRR

Negativetale truly had a positive impact on my life

@Jesz56

Ай бұрын

loud buzze

@tomaszwroblewski1395

Ай бұрын

I guess it's negativity was multiplied by your negatives.

@AlexDillon-xl2tf

Ай бұрын

Man this is great

@AlexDillon-xl2tf

Ай бұрын

Man this is great good job

@Your-Lucky.clover

28 күн бұрын

But whens positivetale?

I originally though "sigh another sans mad au" BUT HOLY PEAK??? A GOOD AU WITH COOK CONCEPTS AND WRITING???? HOLY PEAKNESS

I've been wondering about the talk around this AU but personally it seems comically edgy I can't take it seriously lmfao the french dub makes it even more entertaining definitely a page turner

@basedguy.4229

Ай бұрын

the french dub is great

@brainfreezzzze6900

Ай бұрын

​@@basedguy.4229 if only I could understand it.

@Pastol-ep2ft

Ай бұрын

it has some rlly edgy moments but its a good au with some nice lore. The characters are really fun and the opposite message of undertale is cool asf even if it could've been executed a little better

@khaosinkorporated9493

Ай бұрын

Yeah. Honestly, this is a pretty terrible AU. Basically it’s “UNDERTALE but everyone is the opposite of what they usually are.” Well, not really opposite. It’s just that they have all of their worst traits bumped up to 11 while removing most of their nice traits. It’s honestly just kinda depressing. It’s not fun, not funny, not emotional, it’s just upsetting. And the ending makes it all feel completely pointless since nothings changed and Flowey failed and everyone died. I predicted everyone was gonna die as soon as Toriel died. From there it’s comically boring too. It’s edgy with absolutely zero purpose aside from making you go “maybe being nice in Undertale was stupid.” Which, obviously, completely misses the point of Undertale.

@Pastol-ep2ft

Ай бұрын

@@khaosinkorporated9493 i mean i agree the ending was kinda dumb but the mettaton stuff and flowey stuff was pretty emotional idk, and the characters were fun with how different they were especially alphys, sans, mettaton. I thought it was a really interesting au especially with the concept and the message that you can't be nice to everyone is p cool

Lesson to Alphys: If you're gonna make a attemped deadly machine, don't be suprised when it turns against you.

So unless this guy speaks french or korean, he experienced this AU by reading the subtitles of a french dub of a korean comic.

@basedguy.4229

Ай бұрын

Yeah,but since I can understand french pretty well it was easier to traslate here

@Serperior1212

18 күн бұрын

@@basedguy.4229bonour

"Flowey is nice this time around, what an unique concept!" Although at the least 5 AUs have made that a thing

@killercat241

Ай бұрын

Underfell, horrortale, negativetale, underswap and uhh I forgot

@zenochara7522

Ай бұрын

@@killercat241UTY

@bloxxer717

Ай бұрын

@@zenochara7522yellow doesn’t count it came out after this A lot after this

@Mr_sigmaballs

Ай бұрын

​@@bloxxer717Wasn't uty in development for a long time

@zenochara7522

Ай бұрын

@@bloxxer717 mb

After watching this, I appreciate Negativetale more and it's now one of my favorite aus. It really feels like Underfell 2.0. Flowey is trying his best to save you so you can go home, Toriel is batshit insane bc of her deceased children and it's trying not to let the same fate happen to you, Sans is a selfish greedy man, but a least he's has a decent heart. Papyrus has none. He's cruel, aggressive and powerful. Basically the opposite of classic Papyrus. Undyne's a corrupt guardian that's obsessed with Asgore, and etc. I might make my own au take based on it sooner or later.

Honestly, this AU seems to do a better job than most versions of Underfell when it comes to showing an underground where canon Flowey's "kill or be killed" philosophy is the norm.

I loved when you said “it’s water falling time” and waterfalled all over the place

@SansINess53

Ай бұрын

this joke isn't a joke anymore, im tired.

@benbamburg3132

25 күн бұрын

go to bed then​@@SansINess53

@benbamburg3132

25 күн бұрын

​@@SansINess53go to bed then

@Watermelon_King1

4 күн бұрын

@@SansINess53it’s been a month you need to sleep

@SansINess53

3 күн бұрын

@@Watermelon_King1 I slept, it still ain't funny.

This negative tale left a sad and bitter taste which isn’t bad and it not having a happy ending for frisk/player was interesting and having some of the major characters he killed was cool and the story was quite interesting with some characters being so different from what you’d expect and this story was in my opinion the story was a cruel reality that shows how not every story will end on a happy note

Also, "Insert the Number 1 victory royale song here".

Negativetale has always been interesting to me. I remember reading on some wiki that MTT was a girl in this AU and was the only kind person in the Au. I'm looking forward to another great video for a very based guy.

@leopoldosoto779

Ай бұрын

You also forgot about mad dummy, there also another kind monster including muffet in this au.

Okay the introduction to Toriel is so well done I have to make a comment before even finishing the ruins. She comes in and talks about how she never thought she would see us again, which tells us everything we need to know about her mental state, then we see that she straight up destroyed the puzzles (I am 2:29 minutes in, nothing I say is a huge spoiler) and KEEPS HOLDING OUR HAND, and then we got the froggit scene and honestly it speaks for itself

FINALLY some negativetale lore! (fr i litrally never seen someone talks about this au)

Basically this au's ending in a nutshell: "And everyone died, the end." (Not really because some are still alive i guess.)

Why does asgore even look down in the fight if he doesn't feel guilt ?

@dylanzlol7293

Ай бұрын

Because he's so tall he needs to look down to see negativetale frisk

@basedguy.4229

Ай бұрын

Because the asgore battle sprite was TOO GOOD to be changed!

@youyououmf8200

Ай бұрын

@@basedguy.4229 it just don't make sense. He should've looked at frisk with a grin and a confident look

@dor701

Ай бұрын

To me it looks like Asgore is being confident with his power and thinks he doesnt need to even look at the human to win the battle​@@youyououmf8200

Banger video right there. I'm so glad to have found this, otherwise I would have never knew what negativetale was. Such a nice AU, and a huge breath of fresh air too. Really looking forward to more of it in the future. Also this was extra good for me cuz i'm french so I can understand the dub without the subtitles :) Btw I really like how Frisk is portrayed here. They feel pretty bad for every death that happens, Chara even tried to reassure them once, telling them that it wasn't their fault that Undyne died at 26:37 (from french dub). I love the twist that Flowey here lost his hatred and anger instead of his happiness and love too. tldr: banger au, banger comic, banger video.

I find this au so interesting… sans is so cool in this au

gotta love how Undyne just hits MK with a back throw.

0:50 you should’ve said you’re making a negative video about it, because two negatives make a positive.

i really liked that one, i didn't thought that negativetale has such a nice and at a same time sad lore. thanks based for showing us the au as well as the translation you did for it

the ending was kinda bullshit but i appreciate the message it was trying to tell. its kinda of a reverse undertale being nice to these monsters did nothing, they all still died in the end after all, it actually just made things worse. If frisk had killed the monsters and gained lv they would've been capable of holding out against asgore's soul

U should cover the genocide route for this au (even tho there isnt much aside from the beggining of the sans fight)

I just want to say this as a criticism. You should consider typesetting a bit more, the big white text on clear backgrounds and on top of the white/clear effects makes it a bit less easy to read. Maybe using smaller fonts/text to the side when characters are speaking would help a bit, it'll still read fine in 720/1080p.

man, this au and the lore is just. chef's kiss

This truly was a negativetale Fr tho this was really good👍

hell nah 51 minutes on one au??? im watching it all for sure

Sans and papyrus's relationship is basically their relationship in GG!underfell, but swapped

To be honest, I’m not too much of a fan of evil versions of Asgore either, as a lot of them have no depth to them, and are just evil, edgy, and that’s it, though there is this one old Underfell animation from 2016 that revolves around Asgore in Underfell, and there’s a whole long battle and everything. Even though through most of the fight he is pretty much Satan incarnate and brags about how ruthless and awful he is, he eventually sees that your kindness and determination isn’t giving up, he basically ends up breaking down, realizing how pathetic he really is, beginning to truly see how much damage he is done to the kingdom and his people, and that his anger was all over the loss of his children, he pretty much wants you to kill him for his actions. That’s atleast what I could find on an “evil Asgore” that gives more character to him, yes the fight in the animation is edgy, but in my opinion the ending is really good and emotional.

FINALLY SOMEONE WHO GETS IT, it’s my favorite au

Sans and paps here is the opposite from the gg!underfell lmao and i love it

Wow... I really enjoyed watching this video! Made me want to go back to being the big Undertale fan I was back then, even if that wouldn’t be the best for my health… I’ll never truly return to the community, but I’ll continue watching this channel, it’s great to see someone critically analyzing different Undertale community media and sharing love and exposure to those that deserve to succeed and the criticism deserved for ones that don’t. It was something I now realize was lacking in what I saw in my blind love back then.

And they say Underfell is edgy and violent. Edit: Speaking of Underfell, would Negativefell be a little better or somehow far worse?

@winningsmilefan4888

Ай бұрын

Dusttale (deviant art edition)

great to know that there’s a au that involves too much fortnite and everyone dies, including frisk negativetale (except sans for some reason)

@dylanzlol7293

Ай бұрын

Keeping Sans alive to get him to interact with other AU sanses

Also known as: Frisk accidentally kills everyone, and then dies.

It would be cool if trying to kill the enemies ended up surviving

At first, i thought negative tale was undertale but bandit sans. But the moment i saw the interaction between him and papyrus in snowdin (the first one)... ...Yikes.

Negativetale is such an forgotten diamond, peak au ngl deserves more love

Negativetale my favourite au now. I love it

He says he'll translate but he doesn't for the beginning of the battle.

About time you get an outline on your text. I could barely read anything in alphys’ lab. Despite that, it’s still a great video. Your truly a *based guy*

Negativetale: who needs determination when you have FASCISM.

I really thought sans would just steal all of your golds and run away since he tends to just steal from other monsters, but nah he's actually chill

Just realized if frisk had absorbed toriel's soul right away the child would be able to leave underground without dying in the end

@nightmoro6905

Ай бұрын

apparently at that moment frisk didn't know he could do that, and also, the same thing would happen when they absorb the soul

@actuallynoone3240

Ай бұрын

@@nightmoro6905 toriel is not a psycho, just a desperate crazy mother who wants her children back, i doubt she'd take over frisk's body to do shit like asgore, also if they reseted they would know

@nightmoro6905

Ай бұрын

@@actuallynoone3240 Even if it resets, Asgore is in control of Frisk's soul, so it would be impossible for that to happen.

@actuallynoone3240

Ай бұрын

@@nightmoro6905 isnt the player who controls the resets rather than frisk itself?

@nightmoro6905

Ай бұрын

@@actuallynoone3240 the player doesn't exist here (at least that's what it seems), frisk is what was in control of the soul, before Asgore took control, so you can say that Asgore is the player now

This looks cool so I'll watch it Friday, loved your work based

That was truly… a Negative Tale… 🔥🔥🔥

Oh wow, this video is acctualy really well made! I really like the way you are analyzing au's. On other note.. Do you think alphys was let go way too easy in og undertale? I have been thinking and even undyne get's more backlash than alphy's. (and i don't get that, wss undyne wrong for trying to get your soul?)

as flowey opened up his domain: omega void, asgore shrunk back in fear. he then asked: "are you worthy of the six human souls because you're flowey, or are you flowey because you're worthy of the six human souls?" flowey then replied: "stand proud frisk, you're strong. but nah, i'd win."

@Serperior1212

18 күн бұрын

domain expansion: SAVE STATE 7

okay now negativetale sans is one of my fav sanses

Now that you’re starting to cover comic stuff, could you please, please, PLEASE do a video on Differentopic next? It’s the very first random role AU. And it’s the first random role AU to get a comic. It’s a very important AU to me and it does a good job staying true to characters.

nice to see every boss in negativetale feels like sans or undyne on genocide

So out of all the Aus I feel the main cast such as Alphys, Asgore and Undybe don't get enough spotlight and that's a real shame. Because most UT explore mostly the Skeleton brothers so much it feels frustrating. They never get enough spotlight on any interpretations of their character. But in this Battle Royale AU , I liked how the monsters here would show their differences if they never were helped by Frisk especially Undyne and Alphys. Undyne wasn't a horrible person. In fact she wad just a loyal person who wanted to help her fellow monsters. She is a supportive person and she got along with you thanks to you being well nice. She's not my favorites not by a long shot I just feel she never gets enough focus on her character. Though I liked her and I believe she is the most likeable UT character besides Papyrus. But besides other Aus such as Underfell, Inverted Fate and this Au I love a villainous Undyne. As much as I love Undyne she isn't entirely good as she is still one of Asgore's elite soldiers and captain of the royal guard. I'm sure she eliminated humans during her time and in this Au Undyne is not the same Undyne we love. The Undyne in Battle Royale is a merciless individual and unlike the Undyne who respected us for our honor and value, she is a ruthless individual now and I believe its possible The Undertale Undyne may not agree with this might slowly enjoy it until she becomes a villain. After all she is loyal to the Monster's Cause and I do feel she could be a horrifying monster if she hadn't met Frisk. Wihtout Frisk, Undyne would've been terrifying and be a loyal hand to Asgore. Now lets explore Alphys aka my favorite character. (And I will defend Alphys because she deserves more appreciation) I feel AUs should explore more on Villainous Alphys. I love my Failure Girl Dinosaur Geek be a villainous mad scientists that lost her morals and ethics. (Also I'm a sucker of Mad Scientist and Doctor Characters in general) So for Alphys in this AU I feel she would be the most terrifying. Without Frisk to help her open up her mind, Alphys is now unable to learn from her mistakes. She never learned how to move on and here she is now a cold scientist. BR Alphys doesn't sugarcoat her actions. She instead has lost her humanity and instead act like a machine. She doesn't hide any grudges or remorse, this Alphys is honest and tells us she is evil and that's what makes her terrifying. She treats Mettaton as a tool rather than an annoying rolemate. Metta wants to be free from their control, but Alphys never respects him back. She lost her geeky side and now acts like a scientist to make ends meet. As for Asgore, I feel most Aus try to make him evil or don't do anything wih him. I know Undertale doesn't explore him as much since he appears at the end of the game, but that's the point of his character. We think he's a tyrant but after we find him he's a king who questioned his ruthlessness and now lives alone to deal with the consequences. But this Asgore never does. He does not regret everything he did. And unlike the Oriignal Asgore who wanted to make amends, Asgore became a ruthless tyrant. I feel if an AU wants to explore Asgore as a villain, I believe evil Asgore should be someone who is beyond redemption. Someone who lost their own morals for the better good. And I like this AU of Asgore. Overall Negativetale is an interesting concept and while I fo feel it tells too much rather than showing. Or showing more insight on the monsters. I feel this could happen in the original Undertale if they became desperate to defeat the Humans. This may not be in my top 5 but top 10 for me on favorite Aus.

45:40 Betty Noire soul moment:

this is a 10/10 au no more crying sans.

The negativetale monsters when I explain the concept of nuclear warfare to them

32:21 Eyyyyyyy, I know that Sans

I slammed my fist into my table watching the ending... I love the au so much, yet get so angry at it

You should make a video about Hardtale next!

You should do a video on Underworld, as it has a new owner who is a friend of mine. By reading things from the Underworld tumblr and oG creator space, there is alot of stuff interesting about it. It holds many parallels to not only Help_Tale, but unintentionally another AU which has a similar premise and cast which was made in 2015 and has it's own world build.

I enjoyed this video.

I remenber this au,Like Remenber seen the AU versions of Sans and Papyrus in those Sans and Papyrus AU Themes Videos

12:54 "NO MORE OF YOUR PUNS SANS"

"Through heaven and earth, You alone are the merciful one" Well look like we know how Gojo got his lines

the less known negative

this AU is kinda dark wait, DARK??? LIKE GA-

this version of napstablook really puts the nega in negatale

What is it with great stories made by people in korea being underrated.

Koreans are pretty awesome,= with food, movies/tv shows, being overall nice people (In South Korea, anyway) and now something like this! Something I like about the skelebros dynamic is that it feels the opposite of what we've come to except from UF projects, especially Ryno's. Papyrus, normally the nice guy in any UT AU is outright evil and narcissistic, while sans is the one being pushed around by him. Heck, in DT aus, sans only tries to harm his brother because he's convinced himself it's the right thing to do, and in GGUF, sans is malicious but is more apathetic, not caring if Papyrus gets hurt or not but not really going out of his way to do so like with Frisk or Kris and co. Here, Papyrus threatens sans with taking out another eye, implying he's already done it before, and the context implying he did it the first time simply because he wasn't happy with sans. Also, I like the color dynamic with the two. And Toriel feels like a take distinct from UF, as she can't really be reasoned with or trusted, she's dangerous and mentally unstable.

2:17 casually murders a froggit

a bit random. But. Since you gave your opinion on a comic about an AU of undertale. Is it ok is you check the underfell comic by Kaitogirl(? Its definitely worth checking out. And despite still being in progress. Its a very interesting take on the AU

It's about time. P.S: What do you consider the 3 most popular deltarune aus and does UTY count as a AT?

@zeiwei

Ай бұрын

About UTY im pretty sure no becuz its abt the human before frisk so staying with undertales story

@basedguy.4229

Ай бұрын

technically UTY is simply a prequel,about the deltarune aus I'm not sure,but I'd say: Chapter rewritten,Horrorrune and Deltarune ribbit if it counts

@user-mw3yg7bv5i

Ай бұрын

@@basedguy.4229 Yeah, UTY is more of an interpretation of the yellow SOUL's Underground adventure. Also I thought you were going to mention Deltatraveler.

@basedguy.4229

Ай бұрын

@@user-mw3yg7bv5i I'm not sure if deltatraveler really counts,I don't know in which category it should be

So Based01I don't know if you agree with comissions but what on your thoughts on Vs Neo Alphys. Where in the No Mercy Route Alphys instead of being alone, she is there to stop the player to defend Monsterkind. Maybe that could be a good video topic for a next analysis? Do you believe it suits Alphys? Or does it fall flat like how Sans is depicted during his fangame series as OOC? Aka him crying his brother was eliminated by Frisk..................

@basedguy.4229

29 күн бұрын

How could I forget Alphys neo,thats definitely what im making a video on,nice suggestion

One hour dam that cool tho❤❤

When you asked to think about a papyrus that lost hus kindness and inocense, i justo though on revenge papyrus

39:30 bro really sneaked in a jjk reference 😭

@XpathTheChojiro

Ай бұрын

Throughout Heaven and Earth I alone am the merciful one

Lets go, he did it.

My favorite au

This is the 100000000th time i see an animation of sans killing papyrus C'mon guys cant sans team with papyrus once.

@wingledinglegaster

Ай бұрын

Really?

@nightmoro6905

Ай бұрын

That's not dusttale, man

Throughout heaven and earth, You are the merciful one💀

@Hypersonix67899

Ай бұрын

Best go/Jo quote

well this AU is full of consequences of the monsters' wrongdoings. Like every boss fight ended with they killed themselves (including Papyrus "kills" himself for mistreating Sans).

Negative sans is like that one father who leave with milk and starting gambling and steal money like a cowards

cool au

Can you please talk about Papyrus Belief?

Truly the ⛓️🐵⛓️tivity moments

Mettaton got the LTG treatment

yeah that ending does feel like a non ending huh? maybe instead of a game over giving your soul up to make 7 reviving Assy to rule the underground into a more peaceful and prosperous future would have been more interesting then simply dying

@ahmetbulutguner1198

Ай бұрын

I mean ur soul got turned into a monster soul in the ending so getting that soul would be useless

@aboveaveragegaming5503

Ай бұрын

@@ahmetbulutguner1198 uhh no they "absorbed" asgore's soul intertwining them like assy and chara's were he fought to become the dominant personality in that body but that soul was techinically a human and boss monster soul making it more powerful then a single human soul not less

@DaHypnotik

Ай бұрын

​@@ahmetbulutguner1198 It didn't get turned into a monster soul, more like.. set under new management lol I'm pretty sure it became white just to indicate it being controlled.

@ahmetbulutguner1198

Ай бұрын

@@DaHypnotik yea right im dumb

Ok i love this because I like the french dub

What about... Negativetale Genocide though?

@basedguy.4229

Ай бұрын

Man,if negativetale gets some kind of remaster or even better,A GAME,its going to be PEAK

@pzk1mine

Ай бұрын

@@basedguy.4229 I think there is a NegativeTale Genocide route, because I know a theme for Sans exist, but I don't know about anything else.

Cranking 90s is my mercy language

More KNOWLEDGE yeeeeess!!!!

Negativetale is underfell on steroids

Cool

WHERES THE DELTATR oh dang nevermind!

“Perhaps losing one eye wasn’t enough” HE HAS FUCKING EYES? Anyways do a Hardtale review next

@bloxxer717

Ай бұрын

Why does the papyrus encounter dialouge give off “hey, I heard you’re pretty strong” vibes lmao

Man I didn’t know that there was an Undertale Fortnite AU