I would put horrortale to A tier

HorrorTale: Personally, I would put this in A tier. Mainly because it takes on the neutral route instead of genocide, or pacifist. Oddly, I don’t see many people try to make an Au based on the neutral take, like there is a lot of alternate endings just by itself. There is so much you could do with it, and yet, I don’t see anyone try to make a interrupt ending based on the neutral route. As the title suggests, Horrortale does a pretty good job at being what it is. The underground is basically ruined because of the Player/Frisk since they took souls and just left. We don’t get an update at to what happened to Frisk, but we do see the aftermath of the underground. Now I would further into details but I do recommend people to read the comic, or watch a comic dub about Horrortale, because the story itself is pretty long, and I don’t want an essay about Horrortale. Something New: Honestly, I’m more surprised someone understood Killer’s story since it’s kind of a mess. B is good place to put him in. Now is it a bad writing? Ehhh, it’s more a meh story, definitely not boring but it could use some better writing. My critique is that Chara was shown to be more of the Villain side instead of the player. It stated that THE player was the one who mess up Sans. Now you think the player would be more shown right? Nope, it’s Chara…why? Cuz idk? Why not? Anyways, I think the most interesting is his soul. His soul is just a mood swing; Killer/Sans has no control of his soul it all depends as to what he’s feeling. In some cases he can be nice while he’s in stage 2, in others he’s not. I think Killer would have been a decent Au if only the creator did try to put more care into it. Disbelief: This definitely belongs into S tier, it captures Papyrus personality so well. When I originally watched it, I was kind of mad that Papyrus didn’t try to kill the human/player at the end. Looking back it actually does capture cannon Papyrus personality really well. Papyrus wants you to be a good person, despite YOU killing everybody. Even when everyone is dead he still believes in YOU. As tragic the ending is, it’s the only AU/AT that would realistically happen. This AU/AT is the only one that tries to be cannon as possible. GlitchTale: F or D. Now this controversial but the writing for GlitchTale is pretty terrible. Hell it couldn’t keep the simple weakness for Betty, which is Determination. All it took was Gaster to be pissed off, and “kills” Betty. Now, this is just one of the points of its bad writing, someone decided to make an 1 hour long video taking about the writing for GlitchTale. I cannot stress this enough, the writing is way more messed up than Something New. It has so many plot holes that I cannot make all the points in this comment. The only redeemable quality is it’s animation but even then, she copied a frame by frame of an anime. I’m not exaggerating on that part, y’all can look it up (I think the anime was called MOB). So, this series terrible. UV: A tier. I think this is the only series that tries to get its every Au’s personality cannon character part right. Because majority is really well done, and the animation is beautiful, especially for ONE animator. Just like Horrortale I recommend people watching this on your own, unless you don’t like the protagonist being Sans focused on then thats understandable.

@Foreign885

Ай бұрын

I agree with this

@CoolAndyne

Ай бұрын

Imagine if there's no Glitchtale, no Beti and anything Everything stop in Megalomaniac

My boy Murder is getting done diabolical.

insanity is a okay au to me, he loses emotions and overtime discovers resets and is able to reset and continue doing whatever but then deciding to full on do lots of genocides and when the human comes sans just wants to kill them for the fun of it.

HorrorTale is not b tier bruh.

murder sans aka dusttale sans can be kinda out of character if you are looking into fanon but if canon version then you need to know sans tried something before ever doing a genocide, because remember gaster theory is allowed.

So for dusttale imma say the reason why he's out character is probably due to the fangame. The fangame actually isn't canon at all and how evan stated is just a take while in canon murder sans actually feels sorry for the sins he committed even in the fact after beating the human he traveled to other timelines and help out other people to atone to his sins. Insanity!sans the au you put in F tier is an alternative timeline we're gaster screwed sans up by injecting determination into him, it didn't cause him to melt but he lacks happiness,confusion and empathy wich lead him to not care about anyone anymore but he kept it for himself until a human fell into the underground as they went out of the ruins sans immediately took the opportunity to kill them while they we're still weak. He then absorbs the soul and starts his own genocide run.

As someone who has read basically a lot of undertale au lores. Killer sans is something to behold. Hes strong, and hes got a good concept which is somewhat well executed. Murder sans though.. probably wouldnt happen. Yeah i get the concept of sans seeing all the other routes but, in his battle he knows youre the anomaly. He knows about the timelines starting and stopping. He even gave up a long time ago as he says. Yes, he didnt kill the player only cause of the promise but still, if sans went rogue he wouldnt handle it like murder. Insanity, since he is getting new lore is edgy but meh, Insanity besides reaper and maybe killer is one of the strongest on the list. He has basically unlimited stamina, and is factual stated by UTF (his owner) that he likes punches and bones more than the rest of his moveset. Though, i dont know how to feel on the part that sans loses his mind because of shattered dt, yes its not actual dt which wouldve made him melt instantly, but still its not a great concept of sans having dt in the first place. Reaper is reaper so based. And the thing is canon ink and error both had horrible fights with swap papyrus, ink even ending up having a damaged skull. Ink even lost to killer sans. So basically, some sanses are on a power trip and others are just weak.

Where would u put swapfell?(canon)

solide

WHAT ABOUT YELLOW WHAT ABOUT UNDERTALE YELLOW yeah yeah i know this is not an AU but this game is🔥so i think you should do smth like this too but UTY (undertale yellow) including your video is 🔥too bro keep at it👍

Now hear me out, Ashes Sans and Undyne fight, and Ultimatale as a whole.

Comedytale (wikifandom)?

To be fair, Fandom did ruined UnderSwap but there still Peaks does exist. Example: TS!UnderSwap UnderSwap Relaxation ClassicSwap SS!Swap RevertSwap (yeah its actually swap au)

CaseohTale When? (Jk)

I would pput dragon tale above s tier fr🔥🗣

Insanity, Murder, and Horror is an easy A, so is Dusttrust despite not being finished. I understand everyone has an opinion, but in the nicest way possible this is a very debatable tier list.

@whosthat6048

Ай бұрын

insanity sans has no official story. Beside sans using determination which made him insane, killing the human, and everyone and pretty much that's it. It's F tier, the design is still cool. Same with dusttale but with more original and cool concept which i would put in B tier.

@N0_0ne_N3ar

Ай бұрын

@@whosthat6048 Insanity is far from F tier💀 It doesn't have to be all about story, his design is one of the most intimidating out of a OG Undertale AU Sans. Not only this his strength is absolute and his theme slams. His story may be kind of generic but that doesn't make him F tier. Understandable rating on Murder tho, Horror is an easy A. Dusttrust is B since it's unfinished. Still a very debatable tier list.

@whosthat6048

Ай бұрын

@@N0_0ne_N3ar writing is one of the most important things that decided whether the character is good or not. Cool design alone and horrible writing would make a character by default F tier. It doesn't matter how good their design is; the concept being original and cool can make an au decent without story but just statements. However, aus with good writing like; horrortale, reapertale, dreamtale will always be better than aus with no story. The idea or concept of an au is being different than classic sans or oringral, perhaps. The design don't have to be fully like classic sans or like sans at all in order to be considered as something cool. Take these stuff into account UT fans. While the design is decent, the story and au is so mid and lack many context as i said. The design of insanity sans is not like sans characteristics but it's still original and unquie. Not copy-past. Dusttrust has no good writing either, basically a rip off of dusttale. I'll just say the design is quite decent, and so the themes, and phases. (It's finished, he has 4 phases and even if not, that won't change his tier list, atleast for me) Because that would just be adding extra phases or unnecessary stuff.

@N0_0ne_N3ar

Ай бұрын

@@whosthat6048 Character is another key factor to an AU. Something Insanity lacks but still has which is unique. Insanity may not have the great story like Horrortale or Dusttale, but I stand by Insanity being still pretty high tier despite having a mid story. His design kills too, him holding his still living brother's skull alone is terrifying when you think about it. Maybe with further development Insanity could be placed higher, but Insanity really doesn't deserve an F. But Insanitytale, the one with Rose, Avenge, etc. is quite cool too. Both Insanity's need more attention. One thing I didn't know tho was that Dusttrust was finished, Fanon Dusttrust is C and Canon is high B. Both are interesting, but still follow the same sort of storyline as Dusttale which is why they aren't A. But I get where you're coming from.

@whosthat6048

Ай бұрын

@@N0_0ne_N3ar the thing with insanity sans is that he don't even have a story to call it mid. He just has few statements and that's it. i would just put him above F for the sake of his concept and design. Beside being used in many fan made stuff. More than that, he'd never come close to horrortale or any au with an actually story that are well written. Insanitytale (green one) is decent Atbest in writing. As for dusttrust, being unfinished really doesn't change anything about his tier list in currently time. I've seen many versions, they're all has the same lore or slightly different but same concept. We also can't put them in F tier because the fact that these aus we're liked by many people and has many animation, fan arts, theme. Just like insanity and dust sans. But with an actually oringral story ? Nope.

You are just straight up wrong.

Putting Horrortale less than S huh. Like it's the only AU which has a creative mind before it and actually has a little-detailed storyline.

Me: put insanity sans A tier ( not putting him s tier because classic/UT sans is the S tier )

no inverted fate or ALIVE! au so I'm sorry to say your opinion is invalid until you watch them

@Inkrack

8 күн бұрын

Inverted Fate is an easy S, and idk about ALIVE tho.

Do we get any reason why insanity is F tier?

@killerhorrordustsans

Ай бұрын

Hell nah that man is s trier

@CoolAndyne

Ай бұрын

Because of its air-level writing

@Inkrack

Ай бұрын

Bad writing and bad character design in general.

There's no way bro isn't fishing us🎣❌❌❌ or bro made that tier list irrationally to fish us😲😲😲 jk I knew that's your opinion ofc, most of them is reasonable except Dust Sans

Xtale top of s Tier by far the best what y’all on

Dude's putting popular AUs in F tier with no reason? Like I thought this was a tier list, the least you could do was explain why. And I'm confused on why Dust was placed so low. The reason that "Sans would never kill everyone" is weak, as you could say that about literally ANY alternate timeline. HorrorTale Sans wouldn't become psychopathic if he was injured by Undyne, he has 1 HP. His eye does not function as a life source, it only functions when using telekinesis. Likewise, Geno would never use DT, as Sans doesn't affiliate with Alphys and therefore wouldn't know what DT is. Even if he did, he can't remember resets and wouldn't see a need for it. However, this argument conveniently wasn't made for Geno, Killer, Delta, etc. DustTale isn't supposed to "make sense." It's supposed to be a dark and twisted consequence of UnderTale's genocide route that was very unique at its time.

@KeefeRudyardDelaCruzDigital-Ar

Ай бұрын

I agree, because how people hated Sans being the center of everything in so much of the AUs, especially the early days, stuff like these opinions float around without explanation to begin with. Take Dusttale for instance, people said that Sans just gave up and it was impossible for him to kill everybody when reality, it's in his character if push enough, and along being possible due to betrayal kills and killing intent being most monsters' weaknesses. Also, how Sans was able to remember has multiple interpretation like the glitch, Gaster, and DT, would be all of the possible outcomes. Heck, this could be that all three would exist at the same time. People also tend to forget some aspects of the original Undertale that make AUs possible like Dusttale or Something new (Killertale). The whole reason why Sans was this lazy or just never tries is because all he sees, he and his people would never be free, and that we hold their fate in their hands. In Killer's case, he was given a opportunity to become the very thing just to feel something, and as a coping mechanism for his situation. For Dusttale, this is the result of someone who had gotten bless to remember timelines, only for that would turn it into a curse when he became desperate after all other options than LV have failed. Horrortale would also make sense considering that Sans had head injuries that would even make Papyrus question him, and Sans would have to trick Paps just to agree with him. This is at least in character, but outside of that, just point that this is a AUs and be done with it. Delta's case, the soul system were a bit different than OG Undertale, like how Sans lose his ability to use KR due to him absorbing the Bravery Soul. Fangames won't help or just make it worse as almost everything makes their lore wrong, like WTF can we be able to defeat people who can literally break the game and some even manage to come to the Player's world and kill them, which makes it more pathetic to those Fangames. I honestly would do is to look it up the original AUs and see them as they are, different Timelines and Universes that would work, so long as the Multiverse thing is real within Undertale.

@whosthat6048

Ай бұрын

UT fans trying to Understand that sans aus are not supposed to act fully like classic sans: Dusttale concept is Original, the problem is, that there's no official story for dusttale expect few statements that ask-dusttale comfirmed. The novel also is fanon and just has settings of dusttale. Due to the lack of statements and explanation ask-dusttale gave, the au concept didn't sound right. However the novel has good writing, but it's fanon. Overall, I'd give dusttale B for being a cool concept that inspired many people into making cool animations, arts, games. Perhaps, dusttale plays an important role in the community.

@KeefeRudyardDelaCruzDigital-Ar

Ай бұрын

@@whosthat6048 More like I would consider all the Novels canon, since this AU was made by multiple people, which is why. Afterall, Dusttale is a multiple interpretation of the Canon, so treat it as a multiple interpretation, including the Novels themselves. I just hate that people always treat certain things as canon to a point where it is one sighted and static.

@whosthat6048

Ай бұрын

@@KeefeRudyardDelaCruzDigital-Ar the novel is considered as Fanon by ask-dusttale. This is exactly why ask-dusttale don't have the permission to make an official story; he different people own the project. Semi official and only has dusttale settings.

@KeefeRudyardDelaCruzDigital-Ar

Ай бұрын

​@@whosthat6048 Which does not subtract my point of their can only be one story thing, because that's stupid in my opinion. If their really going to be one canon, then make an official story, instead of the multiple ones. I would even argue that multiple canons would be making more sense than none are canon. If anything, the so-called "Canon Story" is so incomplete and missing tons of view points, that their is no point of finding canon to the story. PS, I'm not saying that your wrong, is that the Novels is not canon is stupid, and Semi-Canon or all are equally Canon are miles better.

Where is dust dust sans 😮

K you totally are mistaking the dusttale fangame for murder and ima need an explanation for DUSTTRUST and insanity don’t just put it there for no reason

@Foreign885

Ай бұрын

I'm not mistaking the fangame for murder, also I just felt like dusttrust and insanity were overrated and weren't as good as ppl said they were.

@thecheesethatdoesnothing9094

Ай бұрын

Idk what they thought about the AUs but I could understand why they put both of those in f tier. Insanity is insanely (get it?) edgy, even more so than dusttale. Dusttrust is an AU that I myself despise. It's basically the worst aspects of dusttale and disbelief along with the bad aspects of sans fangame fights as a whole. There might be some other reasons that they dislike those AUs but that's what I think the reasons are.

@thecheesethatdoesnothing9094

Ай бұрын

@@Foreign885 Oh I didn't know you already comment.

@kairoprovidence9739

Ай бұрын

@@Foreign885 just because they’re overrated isn’t a real reason since that’s not how Zero Danteero and Aude Javel wrote them

@kairoprovidence9739

Ай бұрын

@@thecheesethatdoesnothing9094 well I just see DUSTTRUST as Dustbelief but underswap

Finally someone agrees that old epictale is trash, while the remake is way better

Bro put insanity in f tier

@ProjectN0v4

Ай бұрын

And dusttale carries undertale fangames

@IDK-qq7ct

Ай бұрын

@@ProjectN0v4out of all of the examples you could’ve chosen, you decided to pick the fangames… bruh (almost all of them are bad)

Murder at F tier. Something New at S tier. Outertale at high C tier, its just not that good for me. After at A Tier, Dependds - possibly high B tier. Dreamtale at A Tier Ultratale at Low/High B tier Fatal error at S tier. Disbelief at S tier. TS underswap at high a tier ( No shit its amazing lol ), it can reach S+ Tier.

@user-re6xq7lz4i

Ай бұрын

You have the worst ratings ever

@ImpossibilityOfficial

Ай бұрын

@@user-re6xq7lz4i aight, disprove my points - i'd like to see you try.

@voidlessnull

Ай бұрын

might i know your reasoning as to why murder is so low id understand fangame murder but i dont understand cannon murder so could you elaborate?

@ImpossibilityOfficial

Ай бұрын

@@voidlessnull Canon murder just makes no sense, and its overall just bad.

@ImpossibilityOfficial

Ай бұрын

I dont like it due to the reasoning thats in out of character, and the fact of the effect it has on the community - now everyone thinks that sans > most of the ut cast because of dusttale.

All of them are mid ngl