I am the proud owner of both the Black Bay 58 in Navy Blue on the bracelet, and more recently, the black/gilt original all-steel version to compliment a range of watches in my collection that include the classic Rolex Submariner Date 16610 that I've cherished for nearly 20 yrs. The Tudor BB58 is an outstanding well-made luxury timepiece and I appreciate the rather understated blue dial and aluminium bezel. Like-for-like think of the Blue 58 as a more modern take on its original black and gilt sibling. But I hankered for the warmer vintage feel of the original Black/Gilt version and since it was nearly Xmas I thought what the heck. Although not quite up there with the Rolex in the absolute quality stakes - but why should they when barely 40% of a Sub's retail price - go to an AD and try one of these wonderful watches on. An in-house COSC certified movement, 70 hrs power reserve, staggering lume.... you won't be disappointed.

not sure if I'm in the majority or minority now, but I'd much rather pay for this over a Rolex. Much more suited to my wrist size and not too far out of my reach. Great to see it up close and with a solid review.

Beautiful piece! Thanks for sharing J.Antony

I had the Black Bay S&G for about 6 months.

Wonderful review. I just got this, and am really happy with it’s great quality. I love that this fills a niche that the older no crown guard Rolex subs used to fill. I kind of hate the way watches got bigger with no additional functionality. This resets that for me.

I've had one for a month or so and it has been a pleasure to wear. It's perfect for my slim wrist. I got it with a leather strap which comes with a clasp, I found it to be a bit uncomfortable so I changed it for a thick vintage style brown leather traditional strap. Looks terrific, understated but classic and desirably vintage. Love it!

Loved this video, considering this as my first nice watch. I love the vintage look. Look forward to the next video

Was the first to order this piece from my AD the day it was announced and just received it last week. I’m absolutely in love with it! Looks even better in person!

Anthony, my brother, that was a great review. I agree in that I prefer the 79220N better size wise. There’s just something about that clean, classic look that does it for me. My thanks to Bernard Watch for letting you review it. All the best!- Mark

I have the 41mm Black Bay (in house movement) and I love the size and look of it. Literally the most perfect watch in terms of quality/movement/price! Now to save up for a GP Laureato blue dial and Ill have the perfect balance for an everyday wearer and my "fancy occasion" watch :)

I chuckled when you said that Rolex and Tudor and haven’t adopted the AR properties of some of their competitors. I kept saying to myself “Man, what is UP with all that reflection?”

Great review, fortunate to pick up one a couple of weeks back and very pleased. As others note there is no mirco adjust except three pin positions. High demand in UK and was told if your name is not already down you will probably be looking at spring 19. Let me look at that dial again... !!

This is the best black bay for me. Perfect size and look. It’s made me question why I have other watches.

Wonderful watch and really good and detailed video review. Thank you

Those 13 dislikes are from invicta fans😂

this is almost perfect for me. Not the biggest fan of riveted bracelets but other than that size , quality and in house movement and will be my next major watch purchase.

J. Anthony well done, i own the standard one in with same bezel and even though I love mine I would gladly swap it for the less bulky 58, my only complain is mine accuracy is only borderline cosc ( -5 s/day) keep up the good job

Great watch. I'm liking the snowflake handset more and more, with the long minute hand reaching right to the edge of the minutes track. Hopefully Tudor will release more iterations of the 58, including one without the gilt hands and dial.

Great review. Great watch. I have the BB Purple, BB Bronze and Pelagos LHD in the Tudor line up but think at 39mm this is just a little small for me. My 114060 is the smallest watch I wear.

Great Review. I've been thinking about a Tudor for a while but a lot has gotten in the way. Well maybe soon.