I'm not muslim, I'm a Christian, but I could sit and listen too the older gentleman with the beard speak about life for.hours on end.

@elizabethwolf492

7 ай бұрын

Real wisdom transcends language barriers, differences in religion, class, race, gender... we could all learn from him, I think.

@masztaarc

5 ай бұрын

So could I.

@saturahman7510

4 ай бұрын

Yes, I respect them.

@KiNKnives

4 ай бұрын

I don't think these guys are Muslim

@saturahman7510

4 ай бұрын

​@@KiNKnives Maybe you think, maybe you dont think.. but I respect them anyway ! Greetings from Finland.

it's pretty amazing that they all totally get the message and symbolism without knowing the language. the imagery conveys more than the words

@theothertonydutch

7 ай бұрын

"If the Iraqis aren't used to freedom, then I'm glad to be part of their exposure. We've been punishing our parents, our wives, our loved ones with this music for ever." James Hetfield, about the use of Metallica in torture to break Iraqi soldiers. Fuck Metallica.

@DK-xd3ct

7 ай бұрын

Well they don’t understand English but they’re clearly not idiots.

the guy with the yellow turban always gets me, he's amazing, even though he isnt exposed to the western world he always waits to say what he thinks, hes not judging, he's trying to understand what the new things mean. love him

I'd love for James to watch this and say how he feels about their interpretations.

@RobwLPOC

4 ай бұрын

James would probably shed a tear of Joy he is quite a humble man his reaction to hearing Elton John say that nothing else matters was one of the best songs ever written was beautiful

I have been a fan of this channel for a while, and it is truly a humbling experience to watch a culture react to another’s. I truly and deeply love that as a “western” person, I get to see the real people that our media hides. ❤❤❤

@spiffydigs

4 ай бұрын

well said. cheers

Glad to see Mr Abdul back again. His interpretations are always very astute

I absolutely love the fact these guys get the deep meaning of this song without even being able to understand the lyrics. Love this channel keep these videos coming

Beautiful discussion. The man with the long blonde beard gets it. A man of God.

🌹💙 I totally appreciate the depth of perspective the Tribals have for this song! Thank you for choosing this piece of great music for their reaction. Bright Blessings! 🌞🙏

Ramadan Kareem ❤ I love the way these uncles interpret songs with so much insight.

Love to see these wonderful people discovering the diverse world of wonderful music!

Wow, it’s amazing to see people who probably never had listened this kind of music, feeling and enjoying the Kirk’s solo … that solo is probably the best in all Kirk repertory (and he has many amazing solos) … the music breaks barriers

A well made reaction video. Not just some people saying "oh wow", but real input and analysis. You brought out the character of the music, and the listeners. I hope the new, indepth approach works well for this channel. 👍 EDIT perhaps I have been too quick to judge, perhaps you have been this good for a while now...

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

Sure, it really takes a lot of work but in the end we all could look at things in a very different perspectives. And that's why I love to ask for them to teach us more 🤗

@AnyoneForToast

7 ай бұрын

@@TRYBALS I have missed your stuff for a few months, I am catching up now. And I think you are doing well. Thank you.

Music is an universal language ❤

Always interesting and truthful to listen to these people's insight. Wish more people in the world were like them. Glad to see Chacha again! I really hope he is doing better

The old man closes the path behind him to the boy following him just as he's getting the window open. If he had passed on what he had worked for all that time, he could have easily lifted the boy out of the room, but he doesn't want what came hard for him to come easily for the child. The lyrics at this time are "you label me, I label you." It's very common that people take out their frustrations on people they can overpower, because they don't have the power to punish the person who really wronged them. The key he was carving with was the lock for the door he left behind. So just like his father left him to find his way through a maze, there is a danger a man will leave the same obstacles behind for those who come after. By hoping only for his own future, he was unwilling to make sacrifices for people who came after him.

"The hard work is the key to success " part he said at the end I really feel that he broke it down perfectly. I been watching this video when it was released and never really caught that part. Amazing

I have just discovered your channel, amazing work you are doing here! And important too, you are providing an arena for cultural exchange. I mean, this is what the internet is for, right!? Meeting, exchanging, learning and growing as a global community of humanity. I would like to suggest playing and reacting to Helene Sjöholm "Du måste finnas" (It´s in swedish but has english translation in subtitles). It is from a classic swedish novel-made-into-musical about a woman and her family going through intensly trying times. When her seventh child dies she starts questioning everything, even God. This song is her confrontation with doubt.

About the key and the window, I'd like to point something out that everyone seems to have overlooked. The old man finished carving out the block for the window, and carried it across the room. He places it in the mouth of the tunnel through which he entered that space so many years ago. We were even provided a short flashback of him as a boy crawling through. Then he locks it, and discards the key. He's opened the path to the light, and shut out the rest of the world. This can be an alliteration to both the peace and finality of death, but also opens the question... the block was obviously made to close the tunnel to cruel reality, was his purpose to set the block, open the window, or both? At that point, did he even remember what was beyond, or did the incessant fight against others' wills blunt that knowledge? The observation can also be made that there would be only two paths... harsh reality, and beyond. Although I suppose someone could place the block elsewhere, that's not what was done here, as the man found himself trapped between, by his own works.

I love their compassion and understanding of these types of songs. They feel the emotions and message. I haven't heard this song in many years but got so much more out of it listening to their thoughts and insites of this song. I love these guys. Very wise with loving hearts and souls. Thanks for sharing your videos with us.

Excellent analysis, gentleman! Really enjoyed this one. Also happy to see Abdul looking so well. Sending my best wishes to the whole team! Thank you, everyone :)

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

He's doing much better, I love to see him smile 🤗❤️🌹

The old man reminds of my father. Good man

Doesn't matter where you are from the world, what language we speak, or religion we believe in or education we have, the sufferings for humans, the ups and downs is all the same no matter where in the world and all walks of life. Thanks to all the bards, songsters, bands, singers, musicians and composers who captures the sadness and joys in our lives to inspire us to keep going.

Adnan is so wise! Respects Ustad..

the more the pain, the more the learning.., so true!

Your set it so bright and cozy!

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

Thank you so much, glad you liked it. The sculpture you see btw is made by me 🙂

@karenfryberger4260

7 ай бұрын

@@TRYBALS Good to know! Now I can give credit where credit is due. You are a productive, creative man, Adnan. As always, wishing you and your family and everyone involved is this endeavor the very best. Love to all.

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

@@karenfryberger4260 thank you mam 🤗❤️🌹

I never noticed before but the opening guitar riff almost has a Sitar sound to it. The opening riff is one that might feel familiar to people who listen to middle-eastern music.

I'm glad you guys are still making these videos!

I love this song. Nice to hear the thoughts from all of you too about this. 🖤

You have to appreciate the amount of effort that goes into these videos. Filming each gentleman separately to get their authentic reaction. Respect sir, respect.

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

I appreciate that!

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

And many people get wrong with it that there could be a crew behind the camera. It's just me with everything behind.

@stlong8903

7 ай бұрын

Well done! . Your culture looks rich and beautiful from your outfits to your headdress. It shines through the wisdom that is provided through the reactions. We are worlds apart, yet music can unite us. Much love from me to yours! 👏 ❤🇺🇸

"We are all broken, that's how the light gets in" - Earnest Hemmingway . He needed to let the light in to chase away the darkeness and become enlightened.

@peasinourthyme5722

7 ай бұрын

Wow, that quote must be the true origin of one of my abs. fav. quotes of all time "There´s a crack in everything, that´s how the light gets in" by Leonard Cohen. Daaamn, I thought it was completely his work! So glad you taught me a new thing today, gracias!

Everyone is always dressed so handsomely. Those chairs rock!!!

Thank you!

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

Thank you Anna 🤗❤️🌹

In my opinion. Music is open to interpretation. Even when the band says what their meaning is. If your interpretation is different, to there's and you still feel it. Then that's what music is all about.

Finally i waited long to see a reaction to this, amazing video. For me personaly from my sight the end and my conclusion from it it with the lyrics is, the old man didnt want other children to go that way, thats why he locked the tunnel infron of the kid approaching to save him from the path and so he has at least something good to remind himself (the Window he carved out to remind he had something good done from himself and not what others expected from him, to save others from it or in the video case save at least 1 life from going down the same way he did) But thats my interpretation from the last scenes with the lyrics, i dont speak english fluently but try to understand every day more, since there are so much beautiful songs out there with great messages within the lyrics itself. Still an amazing video, would love to see some reactions on like Jelly Rolls songs he has some good songs with a thinking/meaning in the songs lyrics aswell. Keep it up Trybals

So happy to see Abdul again! :)

This is the best of KZread. Great content.

Absolutely adorable, these men are very wise, thank you for this!

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

Thank you for watching, have a ni e day 🤗❤️🌹

“Pain is both temporary and essential for all mankind, the more pain the more learning”. Amen

I'm absolutely in love with this channel and it's videos and with the gentleman in them. I love Metallica and metal music and seeing your reactions are priceless to me. I'm currently having a SERIOUS HARD TIME in my life and seeing this and hearing all your wisdom is honestly like an answer from Heaven to my prayers in this complicated time. Amazing work as always, keep it coming! Greetings from El Salvador 🇸🇻

Plz plz plz do more of these!! Nothing has made me realize that people all around the world are exactly the same until I hear that listening to “Western“ music. We were all the same people keep up the good work.

Metallica were one of my favourite bands growing up, great to see your guys' reaction 🤘

I never realized how much I had in common with this song.

I would love to spend some time with these beautiful souls

I would love to visit with Mr. Abdul. He is a wise wise man. Sending respect, sir!

I would love to see them react to Chopin!! Maybe the Ballade n.1, i'm sure they would be able to appreciate it

I absolutely LOVE Metallica! I also enjoyed listening to the two men's wisdom filled hearts express what their souls received from the video and music. My Late parents typically would not listen to Metallica because they wouldn't like any rock music. They are both passed away but being where they are, I'm sure they have a better understanding of things now.

Love how you are doing these reacts now. Awesome!

I loved this so much.

Sharing Western culture with others and hearing their opinions is a fascinating experience.

aray wah wah adnan bhai ye to meri request thi aap se bht pehle ki thi, yar thx for metallica. I hope to see 2 and 3 also

Incredible song!

Absolutely incredible to see the gentlemen amazing perspectives on music! Most of all, I immensely enjoy Abdul perspective. I look forward so much to hearing his wisdom and I’m always waiting excitedly for his interpretation of the songs. He truly has so much wisdom about life! I would absolutely love to see you guys reaction on Hispanic music. My favourite & many Latinos is Juan Gabriel “Amor Eterno” (En vivo desde el instituto nacional de bellas artes) or “Eternal love”. It’s a song he made after his mother died. He grew up in an orphanage until he was an adult and then got to meet his mother and they were so close the little time they had together. Juan Gabriel lived a Very tough life in Mexico until he became famous through his voice and songwriting skills. The lyrics of the song are heart wrenching, sad and beautiful and he conveys all of it in his performance.

Been listening to Metallica since the late 80s and their assessments are enlightening, to say the least.

I really enjoy the deep analysis and helping each of the Trybals panel members interpret the lyrics. It shows that as humans we are all the same and can understand the personal experience of the pain of the child and having to navigate life with such burdens. Great job!

We are all human. I love the candid thought process that comes from these fathers, brothers, providers who have not been corrupted by sheer monetary gain/power, and have not been fully subjected to corporate capitalism as they grew up. It is really sobering. It eventually comes back to the same intrinsic values of being a decent human being. Even if Culture gets in the way of the same understandings of human emotion. We have all tired our best to teach our future kin to become more content, and become a better version than our ancestors.. It's meant to be ingrained in our Natural ethos. But instead...well you know the rest.

Amazing

I like that you guys do longer videos where you explain what's happening more.

“But the child is lost and alone.” Just wow

Greetings from America! I love these reaction videos. This music affects my emotions, an after all these years. It makes me happy to see others from different countries appreciating this music. We are all different, but have the same struggles with life.

I LOVE UR REACTIONS!!!!!

I enjoy these takes on music. Very from the heart takes and they pick up on alot of the meanings songs are trying to express without fully understanding the language.

WOW! I really love this channel. The feedback on the songs from a different culture than mine really brings new depth to the music!

This channel is doing more for international relations than any politician ever has! Peace and blessings to everybody reading this.

as a white Christian man i like your videos, i respect your views and i know you all have good wisdom, peace be upon you and this world, peace and love is much more strong than hate and wars

❤ this is my new favorite from the channel! Already shared it with all my friends. Fantastic! ❤❤❤

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

Thank you so much 🤗❤️🌹

I would like to see the reaction of these wise men to Unforgiven II and Unforgiven III, indeed I do

I’m American and I feel so much emotion with this video, and also I can relate to being emotionally rejected by my family, isolated and alone. I still don’t feel like I completely understand the video, but it makes me feel great emotion. I look forward to learning from your wisdom today.

Always pleasure being on this channel

The baby goat baby human analogy is excellent! Great reaction. ❤

Thanks guys for another thought provoking video 🙏💚

Texas here, a great channel, I love it . 🇺🇸

English is my first language and it has taken me years to even partly understand. there is always more to understand no matter what we think we know. Thx for the reaction

that is an amazing breakdown...and that was before I even got to the song

I love this so much. I adore they give it a chance and the way they interpret. This song has gotten me through hard times the loss of my father.

Very interesting analysis. I've known that song for years and haven't noticed many of the things those guys noticed at first attempt. Also, I love the fact that you divide the song into logical, self contained parts instead of stopping in random places. Great job!

@TRYBALS

2 ай бұрын

Thank you so much, I usually sit down for a day or two to research the topic, song, band or random fun facts and prepare some questions for the guests to gain their opinions and inputs. Thank you for noticing and appreciating my work 🤗❤️🌹

Wow, what a marvelous channel.

I believe the video is trying to explain the song means, even an abused suffering man from a child even, can someday Make it - build a window to get to the sunshine. If you don't give up - it may take 80 years, but once (in the video) he breaks through his "cell"/personal prison,wall, & the sunlight comes through - what he has worked his WHOLE LIFE to make that window, he stands with the sunshine on his face. Glorified, graced, beloved, blessed. I think the message of the song is: Hope will bring you to God (the sunlight). Don't Ever give up, Don't ever give up Hope, & don't Ever believe a label somebody may give you, like a label named "Unforgiven". When the old man found the sunlight, he knew, he was never the child, the boy, the man they called him. The "Sunlight" told him who he is 🤷🏻‍♀️

I love that these gentlemen understood this. They are much more wise than I shall ever be. Yet, I am encouraged because music is universal.. if they can understand this, they can understand love in any language.!! xo

It’s amazing how music effects every kind of person. Whether you’re from Manhattan or a small tribe in the mountains of the middle east, it hits your soul. So cool to see these men enjoy the same music i love.

@Io-Io-Io

Ай бұрын

They're Not from the middle East but Pakistan

I always love to hear from Muharam about music and the meaning he finds in the music and music videos. He's wise and humble, two great qualities to have and qualities that feed each other.

best reaction videos on youtube. i appreciate the effort yall put in and your openness. @trybals can you cover some bob marley such as the heathen or "war"

@TRYBALS

7 ай бұрын

Thank you, I'll look into your recommendation sir. Bob Marley is a must but let's see which song of his.

I love how the one guys is bopping his head. He was feeling it

I loved all these gentlemen's interpretations.

The more the pain, the more the learning - what a huge though, it is hit

Wow I can't believe the older fellow liked the solo. I didn't expect that. Seems that solo is great enough to transcend both the culture and age gap. I'm really curious what songs like this sounds like to foreign ears musically and vocally. I'm also curious what sound quality and volume they get when sampling. I think some decent over-ear noise-cancelling headphones would enhance the experience for the guests.

Pain is both temporary and essential for all of mankind. The more the pain, the more the learning.

Nice to see that they enjoy Metallica ! Greetings from Finland ❤

I like the break Down of the lyrics so they understand as you ask them their thoughts.

Hello! Sending respect and love from Texas. ❤

Until it bleeds , please, very interesting reaction for this clip, thanx

I’m new to this channel and I’ve watched a lot of the music video reactions and was wondering if you have done or ever thought about doing a live side by side reaction with the members on this channel and your supporters? Or even a live or prerecording of Q&A between supporters and members on the channel? I think that could be very interesting. 😊

effing enjoyed that so much. unbelievable energy. Really cool band, super talented, pretty eclectic Next reaction - October Ends Dark 😍

Old men have wisdom. I respect them.

You either try hard, or leave this world with regret. Well said.

Suggestion: Let them react to Pantera - Cementary Gates. There's a lot of stuff to talk to about the song and Pantera as well.

I'm nothing if i'm not truthful. This was a great reaction.👍👍

these guys are great

I think these guys will love Iron Maiden slayer and pantera too . Please upload in future ! Love to see them how they react !

the song is more about how abuse and oppression (control) shapes us early in life, what we learn and what we don't learn, what we become