Transgenderism and the "scientific consensus" after the Cass Review
Please help me continue to make videos challenging gender nonsense. www.peaktrans.org/donate
Sources:
The Cass Review can be downloaded here cass.independent-review.uk/ho...
Vrouenraets et al 2015 pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26119...
Paper published in the BMJ doi.org/10.1136/bmj.p382
Gender Medicine’s Citation Cartel www.realityslaststand.com/p/g...
Jesse Singal piece in The Economist www.economist.com/united-stat...
WDI USA statement with link to petition: womensdeclarationusa.com/bide...
Пікірлер: 196
Well done! No one is denying the existence of people who believe things that are not true.
@KickRocks-me7hh
24 күн бұрын
That would be transphobes
Leave the children alone!!! Urgh its so disgusting. I get so angry
It’s a logical fallacy, things don’t become true just because a lot of people believe them.
@rhymerlegend2717
24 күн бұрын
I’m a Christian and about to throw shade at my own beliefs but…. Wouldn’t that make God a fact because a lot of people believe in Him? Even though we don’t know for sure and never will?
@gissellest333
24 күн бұрын
exactly.
@jodieiscool9351
24 күн бұрын
@@rhymerlegend2717I really like that you can step back and be prepared to 'throw shade' on your own belief (religion!) to make a point. Not many people speak like that. ❤
@penny-farthing
24 күн бұрын
@@jodieiscool9351Yes! Respect 🎉
@Randomzooowner
24 күн бұрын
Don't forget Islam, too@@rhymerlegend2717
Recalling the consensus around the efficacy of the lobotomy....
@CaraHTheRealCie
3 күн бұрын
Also, the benefits of thalidomide for pregnant women.
Listening to you is like reading an article: well structured, sources mentioned, fluid and clear. I love you so much and thank you for your effort. Best wishes to you from a detrans radfem❤
That is absolutely mind bogglingly insane
Smashed it out the park ❤
@terfalicious
24 күн бұрын
She always does! 💞
Thanks for fighting the insanity Maria. I've made a small donation - I'm sorry it couldn't be more.
@PeakTrans
24 күн бұрын
Much appreciated!
@EbonyPope
24 күн бұрын
@@PeakTrans Have you heard about the claim that Hillary Cass has walked some of her claims back? It was at least claimed by some activist called Erin in the morning. She linked an interview with the Kite Trust. Now there is speculation about her comments that she just wanted to deflect criticism. I just think they misunderstood her when she said that hormone blockers were given too late. I think what she meant was that we have no reliable data to distinguish if the hormones or just time passing resolved in some cases the psychological distress that some of transpeople felt.
@EbonyPope
24 күн бұрын
@@PeakTrans Have you heard about the claim that Hillary Cass has walked some of her claims back? It was at least claimed by some activist called Erin in the morning. She referenced an interview with the Kite Trust. Now there is speculation about her comments that she just wanted to deflect criticism. I just think they misunderstood her when she said that hormone blockers were given too late. I think what she meant was that we have no reliable data to distinguish if the hormones or just time passing resolved in some cases the psychological distress that some of transpeople felt.
@EbonyPope
24 күн бұрын
@@PeakTrans Have you heard about the claim that Hillary Cass has walked some of her claims back? It was at least claimed by some activist called Erin in the morning. She referenced an interview with the Kite Trust. Now there is speculation about her comments that she just wanted to deflect criticism.
@lidahall5928
24 күн бұрын
@EbonyPope "Erin in the Morning" is a lying man who was named Anthony by his parents.
One of my favourite whinges is that "such and such isn't included" and it turns out that it is one of the organisations that, when asked, failed to contribute to the Cass Review.
Really interesting. Thanks for this analysis, although the implications are so disheartening. Thank goodness for the Cass Review.
One Of The Reasons There Would Be A Consensus In That Wild Ideology Is Because The "experts" Could Face Possible Lawsuits And Loss Of License If They Refuse To Agree...Another Reason Of Course Would Be For Profit...And There Are Many More Reasons "experts" Would All Agree But All Of Their Reasons Are Questionable...
@AndyJarman
23 күн бұрын
Or the kommisars in HR with have you fired for breach of company DIE policy.
Excellent analysis. I found your discussion on citation cartels fascinating.
I just have to tell you how heart leaps with joy every time I see you've posted another video! I know something good and terfy is coming... makes my day! Thank you dear lady, and keep up the good work! PS - left a small donation in appreciation from the USA, and I encourage others to do likewise 😻
@PeakTrans
24 күн бұрын
Wow, thank you!
Have you seen the article by Ben Johnson on the Daily Signal, June 15 2024 regarding a 'massive' German study indicating that "the vast majority" of people "identifying" as whatever will desist? Ute Heggen, also on YT, did a review on it recently. Now that's science, folks!
@PeakTrans
24 күн бұрын
Yes, indeed!
@skepticusmaximus184
21 күн бұрын
I don't care. 😠 I'm going to continue identifying as a time travelling Delorian with a flux capacitor, no matter what.
Thank you again and if I wasn't worried about how I'm gonna pay my rent every month, I would send you whatever you need to keep you going....
Thanks for the great video as usual! Very much needed! Its def gonna inspire my texts im writing in polish about this nonsense!
Thank you Maria! Been waiting for this one!
Another excellent video Maria! Hit home for me having seen this exact claim about a consensus a lot.
You *rock,* Maria. Ave Maria! ❤ from northern California! (Cuncti Simus Concanentes)
How could there be a medical consensus if they claim a woman or a man is a construct 😂😂😂
@r-platt
17 күн бұрын
Your confusion is what happens when people with no training and no experience try to explain complex concepts. Can you imagine her trying to explain what a Planck second is? There is medical consensus that: 1. Gender identity is a mental trait independent of biological sex. 2. Gender dysphoria is real and requires treatment. What that treatment is depends on the needs of the patient. 3. Gender affirming care starts with therapy accepting where the patient is in life - not as a diagnosis, but as a safe space to discuss taboo topics. 3. The terms "man" and "woman" define common behaviors and experiences by the majority of the population. A "social construct" is a shared idea held by a society.
@PeakTrans
17 күн бұрын
The terms man and woman refer to adult males and females, regardless of how they behave.
@r-platt
17 күн бұрын
@@PeakTrans That is 1 way to see man and woman. That's not the only definition for man or woman. Context matters. When discussing trans people, man/woman is different than male/female in order to makes sense of trans experiences.
@Mel-wn9gb
16 күн бұрын
@@r-platt Society doesn't share the idea that women equate to 'femininity' and men equate to 'masculinity'. Only sexists think that.
@philipbriney4430
13 күн бұрын
@@r-plattWrong you are spouting manure in fact you piled it deep enough to fertilize all my wheat fields!!
The cass review is being attacked by a team in Yale -.would be interesting to see who the yale team are as there is a high chance of an ideological lean coming out of a US university
@lidahall5928
24 күн бұрын
Yes, not to mention a financial one, too.
Thankyou for your work. Im so pleased more and more people are doing these videos, esp intelligent, articulate people like yourself ❤
Has anyone tried discussing this with a school aged child recently? They are all indoctrinated with this, they believe it all verbatim.
@dcollins4679
23 күн бұрын
On the other hand there's a 12-year-old schoolboy how has been the attention of antiterrorist police and reffered to Prevent (anti radicalisation agency) for saying there, are only two genders. He had a National Trust toy cross bow that fires foam arrows so I can obviously see, why he's concidered a threat.
@FronteirWolf
22 күн бұрын
Those foam arrows, very dangerous, definitely a weapon of choice for terrorists.
I’m glad you brought this news up. It’s so important
Always happy to find a new video…and I watch the adverts. 😘
Thank you
BRAVA !!!
Great video!
Consensus is somewhat over rated, I understand that she was formerly known as a prominent atheist, and i believe that a belief in a God is the consensus view in her country, that doesn't make her wrong or right.
That’s a great shirt.
@helendancelot
24 күн бұрын
Made me look
Thank you, Maria! I've been thinking of you the last few days and wondering when you would post next ❤
Ooh, first.
@XKenny77
24 күн бұрын
Fancy!
"The consensus" is just her religious belief!
@r-platt
17 күн бұрын
Backed by 80 years of research and testing nearly ever drug and treatment. That's how doctors came to the current treatment. They literally tried everything else.
@grahamfinlayson-fife73
17 күн бұрын
@@r-platt Who is "they", what do you mean by "try", and what is "everything else"?
@r-platt
17 күн бұрын
@@grahamfinlayson-fife73 I mean over the past 80 years doctors have subjected trans people to nearly ever medication and form of treatment (e.g. electroshock therapy). They recorded the results. Nothing had any affect on gender dysphoria until doctors started listening to trans people.
Sent you a little donate, please don’t stop what you are doing, we need you ❤
Great work Peak Trans - you do a really good job.
💜🤍💚
To all those who purport to be so supportive of transgender rights: how many would choose to date or marry a transgender person?
@danielcarlsen9228
17 күн бұрын
Trans rights IS humam rights (just as anyone else). There are powers in the world that see them as subhuman and support public executions, forced registration, abuse and prison sentences for not following the norm.
@PeakTrans
17 күн бұрын
@danielcarlsen9228 What do you mean by "trans rights"? It isn't a human right to force people to accept you as something you are not and allow you to access the sex-based rights of the other sex. That doesn't mean anyone should be abused or executed.
@danielcarlsen9228
17 күн бұрын
@@PeakTrans I mean they are the same thing, we are all human and have (or should have) the same rights. It seemed like OP indicated that trans people are lesser.
@PeakTrans
17 күн бұрын
OK, I took the OP to mean that, in terms of attractiveness, people who have medically transitioned are a minority taste. Most people are attracted to natural men or women or both.
I really enjoy Maria’s work but I differ a bit regarding the reasons behind this ideology. When I learned about the 4 stages of ideological subversion by Yuri Bezmenov and saw the connection between trans ideology tactics (along with out areas like DEI, etc) and readings from Marx and Foucault, it seems like this is a push for cultural Marxism with a facade of’ inclusivity, diversity and kindness’. A good video to watch is, “The Forgotten Marxists of the 60’s”. Does anyone have similar thoughts around this?
Well, that’s not a SCIENTIFIC consensus. It might be a social consensus in some circles, but it isn’t scientific.
My comments are ALWAYS RESPECTFUL,TRUTHFUL AND BASED ON SCIENTIFIC AND BIOLOGICAL FACT .... APPARRENTLY KZread /GOOGLE HAVE FLAGGED UP AN OFFENDING WORD IVE USED .... I CLICKED ON THE FEEDBACK BUTTON WHICH PROMPTLY DISSAPEARED ..... FEELING A BIT PI....ED O.F
@PeakTrans
21 күн бұрын
Sorry this happened - KZread sucks big time.
Dear Maria, I have just completed John Gray's short work, "Feline Philosophy." It presents a view of cats and humans as animals. With your love of cats, and philosophic nature, I thought you may have come across this work. I think it is brilliant, but nihilistic, so readers should approach with caution. "It ain't for sissies."
@PeakTrans
23 күн бұрын
Thank you. I might have to add that one to my wish list.
@ponyboygarfunkel1675
23 күн бұрын
@@PeakTrans Should you ever read it, I would enjoy hearing your reaction, even if you find it to be rubbish. I am a middle-brow thinker on my best days. Sadly, I don't really have anyone with which to discuss this sort of book. I am the boorish sort who constantly recommends books, films, and music. C'est la vie.
Maria! As always, i adore you and your point of views. I couldn’t agree more on what you are saying. However, i must say, as an entrepreneur myself and lacking the luxury of time, i don’t have time to watch 30 minutes of videos. Even if they come twice per month. This is just my personal opinion, but could you please squeeze them down to 10 + minutes? The idioticy of what you are opposed to is clear. Other ones following here, do you agree?
@PeakTrans
7 күн бұрын
No. I've tried but I can't seem to manage it.
A dentist conducted a study on gum cancer. A third of his team doesn't believe gums can become cancerous. They show clearly that brushing your teeth doesn't stop the cancer and recommend brushes be outlawed for people with cancer. Would you trust such a study?
There's no such thing as trsnsgenderisml
@daniellele6195
24 күн бұрын
'gender identity' is not a physical human characteristic, it's disturbing that so many people think it is
@terfalicious
24 күн бұрын
It's a euphemism for perv
@PeakTrans
24 күн бұрын
Don't be silly.
@KickRocks-me7hh
24 күн бұрын
@daniellele6195 it's a function of the brain and dna. So yes it is
@Randomzooowner
24 күн бұрын
@@KickRocks-me7hh it's a social one. It's not innate
There's no such thing as gender ideology.
@terfalicious
24 күн бұрын
Gender propaganda
@PeakTrans
24 күн бұрын
Yes, there is. Here, let me educate you: kzread.info/dash/bejne/kZuDr5qflMq2cbQ.htmlsi=k-QXIpu1T2ZrJywp
@KickRocks-me7hh
24 күн бұрын
@PeakTrans can you summarise it please. I have left a comment on their video. Hope that helps.
@megarat1777
24 күн бұрын
@@KickRocks-me7hh😂 surely you’re trolling
@KickRocks-me7hh
24 күн бұрын
@@megarat1777 nope. Show me evidence of gender ideology