Honorable mentions: bit.ly/3P1fLGp

Honorable mention to the green card that got me to stay in my country

@violet_broregarde

3 ай бұрын

@averagenoncitizenresident8632

The other crazy thing about Up the Beanstalk is that it's not legendary, meaning you can stack them. Get two out and suddenly you're not just breaking even with Solitude or FoW, you're actually netting a card!! It's insane!

@TuberTugger

3 ай бұрын

I wouldn't say you net a card. It's 2 for 2. But you net the effect for free which is usually worth a card.

@AnonymousHuman-ku5wh

3 ай бұрын

@@TuberTuggerSolitude exiles a creature, and force counters a spell. The net effect is that you spend zero cards to remove one of your opponent’s cards. You do net one card of advantage.

@fyreaxis4938

3 ай бұрын

@@AnonymousHuman-ku5whRight! Just because your hand size doesn’t increase doesn’t mean you didn’t net a card. Removing a creature is one less card your opponent has.

"It's definitely elvish mystic." Yeah, gonna have to disagree, Jamin. It's Llanowar elves.

@tylerprime6741

3 ай бұрын

Nah definitely fyndhorn elves Granted arbor elf is like, all of these but arguably better since it lets you untap a forest, which means you could use more than just green with dual lands

@klb2164

3 ай бұрын

@@tylerprime6741but arbor elves is definitely worse because its just not mana acceleration

@tylerprime6741

3 ай бұрын

@@klb2164 it's virtually the same effect as the other ones. You just untap a land rather than it making the mana itself. You still get access to more mana

@klb2164

3 ай бұрын

@@tylerprime6741wait im braindead i thought it was a different card and got confused

@simanolastname2399

3 ай бұрын

@@tylerprime6741 Arbor elf runs the risk of you not having access to forests.

I had to laugh at how Carl hesitated to say "Channel Fireball" then decided to say "Fireball Channel" instead just to not their competitor get a free mention.

@JohnFromAccounting

2 ай бұрын

Channel Fireball is the name of the original combo, and the company took that as their name to reference that combo.

haven't watched the video yet but, I swear to god, if I don't see Colossal Dreadmaw...

@JohnFromAccounting

3 ай бұрын

Draft playable, that's it.

@daltronius

3 ай бұрын

​@@JohnFromAccounting, no its in all my dino decks, gotta rep da real ones

@SpinosaurTamer

3 ай бұрын

They were trying to make the video at least a little reasonable, having the best card in the game that lets you win all the time is too good

@PersonWithProblemss

3 ай бұрын

@@JohnFromAccounting 🤦🏼‍♂️🤦

@bestbeekeeper8931

3 ай бұрын

they're actually all colossal dreadmaw

The original art for Birds of Paradise was meant for Tropical Island. Art direction back then wasn't quite what it is today, so when they got the art back and saw how prevalent the bird was, they just decided to whip up a card to still make use of the picture and made a new Tropical Island in-house. Jesper Myrfors was the art director back then, and this wasn't the only time he had to patch up their art assignments for whatever reason. I believe Circle of Protection: Black has a similar story behind it, but I can't quite remember it. The originally assigned art was way late or something, so they had to throw something together at the last minute.

@ChouRaiyuki

3 ай бұрын

Was that why volcanic Island didn't exist in alpha but did in beta?

I feel like Birds of Paradise beats all three elves at their job, back when it was printed it an instant staple

@Sauvenil

3 ай бұрын

Plus birds dual-wielding a sword and a hammer are pretty annoying. (Not THAT hammer... the Loxodon Warhammer. Birds need to fly to smash face.)

@mofomiko

3 ай бұрын

For sure, its just objectivley better (unless youre elf-balling of course)

@ReyosBlackwood

2 ай бұрын

BoP, or (ig)noble hierarch, or Delighted Halfling, all feel better for that spot than the elves, unless you're specifically in elf tribal

“Number 6000 will surprise you” killed me

So technically not green but... Gaia's Cradle is THE reason I started playing green back in the day

@funfunfun18

3 ай бұрын

Last year I managed to retrieve several boxes of cards from the loft space of my mum’s garage that builders had built around 🤦‍♂️ I didn’t really know what was in them, so imagine my surprise when I found soooo much loveliness including a Cradle! They were cards I had drafted back in the day

@devinanni8117

2 ай бұрын

I still have my playset. My babies xD

Fastbond should be in the top 5. Probably at number one even.

Sylvan library,Fastbond, glimpse, natural order, eureka..so many strong green cards

Before watching the video, my guesses are, in some order: Natural Order, Survival of the Fittest, Primeval Titan, Tarmogoyf and Deathrite Shaman if we count the hybrid cards, if not then either Golgari Grave Troll or Hermit Druid. EDIT: I forgot about Channel and Oath facepalm.

@spoopyboi1882

3 ай бұрын

Feel like Pod should be a consideration too

@smwg4187

3 ай бұрын

@@spoopyboi1882absolutely. I thought about it for roughly two minutes, hence forgetting Channel and Oath

@spoopyboi1882

3 ай бұрын

@@smwg4187 fair, i forgot about channel and oath as well lol

@swordrush

3 ай бұрын

There's a lot of really, really strong green cards. All of those are great choices. I would also consider Genesis/Hypergenesis and Protean Hulk. They also mentioned Fastbond in their article, which seems particularly more powerful than the ones this video is about.

@Sauvenil

3 ай бұрын

@@spoopyboi1882 Except that Pod is just slow Natural Order, etc. There's usually a better version, even though that particular version (Pod) makes a combo in some situations.

Strongest to Weakest 1) Channel 2) Natural Order 3) Oath of Druids 4) Tarmogoyf 5) Birthing Pod

@asteros6387

3 ай бұрын

id replace oath with BOP, protean hulk, or maybe survival and move it down to 5, i dont think oath is just generally as powerful as either of those 4.

@RawketPawnch

3 ай бұрын

I've found the Jund Player!

@alexssain

3 ай бұрын

Sylvan library top 3 ez

@AnonymousHuman-ku5wh

3 ай бұрын

Oath is a vintage deck. Channel isn’t. Natural order is barely in legacy. You’re also missing fastbond and survival of the fittest.

@AnonymousHuman-ku5wh

3 ай бұрын

@@asteros6387Of these five cards, only one is the core of a vintage deck, and that’s oath.

12:15 Ackshyually; according to a quick scryfall search, there are only 5652 green cards, not 6000; and if we're only counting monogreen cards, that goes down even further to 4131 :P

@hoodiegal

2 ай бұрын

that's why number 6000 will surprise you - it's not even printed yet!

That Channel art is just awesome

channel, fastbond, natural order, prime time and probably some 1 mana dork most likely birds . 2 of those I don't even play in my powered cube because they break magic more than black lotus and moxen .. and even more in combination /edit .. was thinking about up the beanstalk, but that's such a new card ^^

Top 5 long form discussion instead of rapid Top 10. Card Market making it work

can't wait to see the other colors! colossal dreadmaw is obviously the number 1!

Love to see Carl wearing a Pits and Perverts t shirt!

@alexandertheok5624

3 ай бұрын

I'm from the US, so I wasn't familiar with the shirt or story. After reading about it, I'm glad that Carl wearing the shirt and your comment could fill me in on such a unique and empowering story.

@nickyheart

3 ай бұрын

is carl gay? i didnt know. thats amazing

@alexandertheok5624

3 ай бұрын

@@nickyheart maybe he has a side hustle as a miner....

@Cliech

3 ай бұрын

@@alexandertheok5624 If you can find the film Pride it's well worth a watch!

I drafted Dominaria Remastered with a friend and discovered the power of Battlefield Scrounger on my own. I love this theme (and the fact that it's in Naya colors) in old dominaria sets

Natural order is much more powerful than up the beanstalk.

I like these vids, hopefully we'll also get best colorless spells! Or maybe something like "best enchantments" and "best planeswalkers"

The classic card to oath into was Cognivore and then Spike Feeder, Spike Weaver and Morphling. Battlefield Scrounger was part of a combo deck called Turboland and the card you wanted to draw was Time Warp. or in some convoluted way any single card in your deck. The deck was great and mindmelting.

Saw you guys at the paupergeddon! Hope you like lecco city and the event! Love u guys 💪🏻❤️

love the random talk at the end😂

My guess (before seeing top 5: 1. Channel 2. Golgari grave troll 3. Oath of druids 4. Fastbond 5. Hermit Druid Honorable mentions: noble / inoble, OUAT, primetime, beanstalk, natural order, survival of the fittest

@eliaswolter2955

3 ай бұрын

Yeah I was thinking about Once upon a Time as well

@alexssain

3 ай бұрын

Sylvan library?? Colossal dreadmaw?

@Kettwiesel25

3 ай бұрын

Much better list than the one in the video if you ask me

Jamin's channel segway is amazing!!

Love the dance around naming a competitor TCG store. 😂

I can agree with channel and up the beanstalk being up their but here’s a few other than would fit better. Switch Llanowar elf’s with noble hierarch or delighted halfling, Food chain, Primeval titan, Hypergenesis, Protean hulk, Defence of heart,

The fact that no one mention sylvan library even in the comments is just crazy

I remember back in the day, I won one of my first tournaments with an Oath of Druids / Serra Avatar / Spirit Link / Altar of Dementia deck. Nothing like milling my opponent for 35-40 in a turn.

I liked this video and then you mentioned Morphling and it brought back terrible extended blue control memories

I honestly cant belive up the beanstock is on the list when its only pretty good in the formats that consistently play the evoke elemental and is just okay in all other formats

Wild that Wild Growth got no mention. Berserk that Berserk got no mention.

2:50 with the right opening hand, you can use dorks like these to play a six drop on turn three. Play forest, dork, untap, play forest, two dorks, untap, play forest, cast six drop. Of course this is still risky as an opponent can just counter it or kill it

I remember when Tarmogoyf was a menace in the old Extended days. Fun times!

Big fan of number 5 :)

I'm a Green mage and probably my all-time favourite card is Life from the Loam, which is sort of a one-card combo or at least a one-card engine. I don't think I can justify rating Loam higher than any of the bangers on this list other than maybe Llanowar Elves. I've watched enough Legacy to know that Up the Beanstalk is a seriously screwed up card and seeing it on this list is not as mad as you might think. And yeah I remember Goyf as this just super iconic powerhouse card that suddenly was starting to be outclassed by...a big dumb fish from Fate Reforged? That's right, Gurmag Angler was the first sign that Goyf was in trouble, and then Fatal Push really killed the Goyf and then they've printed nastier threats and now it's just a memory/meme card. It does my green heart good to see so many great honourable mentions in the comments such as Natural Order, Prime Time, Fastbond, Survival of the Fittest, etc. Video put a smile on my face. One big sandwich for Carl, Thoralf, and for Jamin. Thanks boys.

@stefanschmid1357

2 ай бұрын

I play a Loam Deck, including Tarmogoyfs. 😮

loads of good ones. Sylvan Library, Survival of the fittest, Craterhoof Behemoth, Glipse of Nature, Fastbond, ..

Ooooh, this is tough. As a former diehard green mage, I feel like I should have good guesses, but… nothing’s coming to mind beyond Channel and Fastbond.

Also as an aside, it was usually always correct to bolt the bird because most players would keep a greedy hand if they opened with a dork.

Jamin needs a raise or a bonus cuz that was the best subscribe lead in I've ever seen

Channel lets you do another crazy thing. If you have Lich's Mirror in the deck, as long as you can keep drawing one, you can repeatedly play the Mirror, off yourself to the Channel to trigger the Mirror, and pile up all that mana in your mana pool since you never switch phases. Then from there you can basically make infinite mana from your life and then win with something like a Walking Ballista.

My favourite green card is Mirri's Guile, the OG green divining top (Sort of).

My favorite cycle Cardmarket Top 5 Videos

Love the goyf, love the channel, love the oath - no love for Fastbond!? Come onnnn guys. I have one alpha card and its an hp copy of Fastbond

Any chance you'll ever play vanguard?

My favorite is probably Natural Order, but I've been playing canlander alot lately.

elvish mystic, llanowar elf and fyndhorn elves are also druids, which makes them even better :D

there is an US exclusive on, that is quite useful

I like the list and number 3 is still one of my favorites. I wonder if it would be too good for pioneer... 🤔

The Channel joke to plug following Cardmarket was an Arena Boys ad in a trenchcoat and fake mustache.

Okay, so 7 and 9 were where my two picks for this list currently reside. I just remember the extended elfball deck that ran heritage druids and nettle sentinels to turn zero people.

I find it interesting that Up the Beanstalk makes the list, but there is no Prime Time or Natural Order. To be fair, Top 5 lists are always tough, especially when biases, subjectivity, and a card pool, the size of which Jamin didn't manage to count in the opening somehow ;) Big fan of making these into "story time" though, so I'm not going to complain :)

Oath decks in old extended played three creatures, morphling, spike feedeer to gain life and spike weaver as fog. And they play gaea's blesseing to never deck themself.

I haven't watched it yet, but there 100% is gonna be channel

7:51 ahhh, the "Siege Rhino conundrum"

A lot of the cards in the honorable mention are stronger than potition 3-5 in the list and even some that didn't make the honorable mentions: Fastbond, Golgari Grave Troll, Primeval Titan, Hermit Druid, Survival of the Fittest, Natural Order.

What about Collected Company?

@Sauvenil

3 ай бұрын

It's kind of a one-trick pony - only low cost things and sometimes misses. Not as good as similar OG versions like Oath of Druids or Pattern of Rebirth or Natural Order that just grab anything.

@Curt-ze6hl

3 ай бұрын

One of my favorite cards and barely feels playable :(

@blong217

3 ай бұрын

@@Sauvenil it is and it isn't. It has some perks over cards like Natural Order and Pattern of Rebirth that I feel easily puts it on par. It's powerful because despite its limitations it creates a massive advantage for any deck it's in.

@Sauvenil

3 ай бұрын

@@blong217 You have to build toward Collected Company for it to be awesome. You don't have to go that far for Natural Order. Less restriction and more versatility even though it's only one creature.

@blong217

3 ай бұрын

@@Sauvenil I mean you do have to build towards Natural Order too, you can't just throw it in any deck and expect it to work. It's just you have to build differently than company. I consider company so good because unlike natural order, it gives a better chance at assembling two card combos (albeit specific ones). Plus it does it at instant speed which is also highly beneficial over sorcery speed.

7:10 Tribal is a card type so that it can have a subtype, and it shares those subtypes with creatures. If tribal was a subtype, then it would need to have a subsubtype and I think that would be more confusing. It would also itself still be a subtype not only shared between instants and sorceries, but also enchantments and artifacts, which is a problem because those don't normally share subtypes, so you'd have a sorcery/instant version of tribal, and an enchantment version of tribal and an artifact version of tribal, which then each would share subsubtypes with eachother as well as with creatures. Instead, it's simply a type that shares its subtypes with creatures. Just like instant and sorceries share subtypes. Although trap only seems to occur on instants and lesson only on sorceries.

@CardmarketMagic

3 ай бұрын

That is a very comprehensible explanation of that phenomenon, I didn't know! -Jamin

The channel joke was top-tier.

So what happened to Natural Order and Survival of the Fitest?

@CardmarketMagic

3 ай бұрын

They are in the honorable mentions :)

@JohnFromAccounting

3 ай бұрын

Survival of the Fittest might be banned but it's not very banworthy. Natural Order should be on the list.

@andriyu

3 ай бұрын

Survival of the Fittest is not in the honorable mentions.

can someone explain how llanowar elves made it to the top 5 but fastbound, sylvan library and primeval titan didn't?

I'm not sure how good Rofellos is, but I thought it could have been an honorable mention. It's like a reverse Gaea's Cradle, instead of having a land that yields 1 mana for each creature, you just have a creature that yields 1 mana for each land (assuming they are forests).

most of the time I don't kill mana dorks because I find it better to destroy everything they play with the mana dorks & there is a limit to how much removal you can fit in most decks.

I've just got to Tarmogoyf, there are only two cards left and nobody has mentioned fastbond, oath of druids, or channel. What is going on?

I was like there is NO GREEN CARD BETTER THAN CHANNEL!!! Then i saw no 1... and was like Well yeah. 🤣

15:41 it's no longer good.... But there was a time LOL

funnily enough tarmogoyf is a very good creature still in timeless, even when the format has show and tell and oko in it

I wish you would made like honorable mentions for: Craterhoof behemoth, Primeval titan, Natural order, rancor and Thragtusk. Green is color of creatures after all.

MORE CARDMARKET!! WOOOOO!!!

is dyrad arbor colorless?

1. Oath of Druids 2. Channel 3. Natural Order 4. Once Upon a Time 5. Fastbond

my favourite colour since '99

I was really missing Primeval Titan here until I saw all the other great suggestions here in the comments that didn't make it either. Must've been a tough choice.

The great henge is my favorite green card of all time love the raw Power💪

Im suerprised once upon a time wasnt mentioned. That card was wild when it was released

Toski bearer of secrets. I don't know, but good lord that seems busted. Ohran Frostviper also!

@Sauvenil

3 ай бұрын

Toski is so full of flavor, I love it.

What about Gaea's Cradle?

1. Oath 2. Channel 3. Fastbond 4. Survival of the Fittest 5. Natural Order

If the black list doesn't have dark ritual, I'mma lose it! Great video btw. That channel subscribe bit was 10/10 would sub again.

@henryzelman4541

3 ай бұрын

Black should probably be 1. Necropotence 2) dark ritual 3) demonic tutor 4) orcish bowmasters 5) reanimate Honorable mentions to grief, animate dead, entomb, archon/griselbrand, thoughtseize, Sheoldred, etc… I’m probably missing a few but outside of contract from below which is the best magic card of all time, I think the top 3 are pretty indisputable. In general I think mana acceleration/rituals are getting better and better as wizards continues to powercreep on threats while simultaneously avoiding printing rituals/mana acceleration to the point that dark ritual, on its current trajectory will probably be the best black card in the game.

@kylegonewild

3 ай бұрын

@@henryzelman4541 Once upon a time I would have had Grey Merchant in my top 5 black cards.

@henryzelman4541

3 ай бұрын

@@kylegonewild idk about that. In my top 5 list the only new card is Bowmasters. Animate dead, thoughtseize, entomb, griselbrand, goryos vengeance, and even Liliana of the veil are substantially better than Gary.

No fastbond?

Great Video. However, while I understand while Elf got no. 5 I still like Bird more. Despite not being Elf.If you insist on mana ramp , then I say Priest of Titania is much better pick since thats insane ramping. But even then I would overtake it with Wild Nacatl 3/3 for G Is more powerful by itself (and plains and mountain which very easy). Ramp is great, elf is great, but its depending on other cards. What I like on Up the Beanstalk is actually that you draw even if the spell gets countered and you dred before the spells resolves as well. Its pretty good at times. Goyf is very understandable, but hes getting older. But still powerful. Channel could be No.1 , but Oath is acceptable its really strong card. Overall though green is stacked the list could feuture many different card and still not be an issue.

Oath of Creaturelands + Standstill

My top 5 Up the beanstalk, sylvan library, channel, oath of druids, nstural order. Probanly missed something op but ok

Top 5 Blue cards. Mishras' Factory, Powder Keg, Nevinyyral's Disk, Celestial Colonnade, and Tarmogoyf,

Add eternal witness and survival of the fittest to your deck. Honorable mention berserk.

Surprised that Once Upon a Time didn't make it into the list but then again it's not good enough to be banned in Legacy so maybe not. Still better than a vanilla 2 mana 4/5 lol. Nowadays we have 8/8 fliers for 2 mana that also pitch to force.

I thought they would mention the cute little hermit Druid when they said one card combo 🥹

Ok damn Carl, chill with the thumbnail. I don't need you staring into my soul that deeply.

@CardmarketMagic

3 ай бұрын

👁👁

I think The Great Henge and Sylvan Library deserved honorable mentions at least.

7:14 Tribal had to be a type and not a subtype because tribal has subtypes, it shares all of creature's subtypes, so needs to be on the same level that's just the way types and subtypes interact. Tribal was created entirely because there needed to be a type to give access to the creature subtypes on non creature spells.

@christopherb501

2 ай бұрын

Could have still been a supertype, with that property.

@ReyosBlackwood

Ай бұрын

@christopherb501 no, it couldnt because then there would be no type that allowed the subtypes. Every subtype is attatched to a specific type, a forest can only be on land type, an equipment has to be on an artifact type, an aura has to be an enchantment type, and elf has to be on a creature or tribal type.

Tarmagofy is here rather than Sylvan Library or Farseek or... Idk, _any_ staple/good stuff card? Lol

@AnonymousHuman-ku5wh

2 ай бұрын

I agree that goyf shouldn’t be on the list, but how is it not a goodstuff staple? Its been a major player in modern, legacy, and even vintage midrange decks.

No questing beast?

But Tharmogoyf would just die if all graveyards are empty when you play it. So they had to make it x/x+1. That happens rarely in modern because so many people play fetch lands and a 1 mana instant or sorcery on their first turn etc., but it could still happen and would make Tharmogoyf really suck in that situation because it would just sit in your hand until something goes into a graveyard. It would also die if someone cracks a Relic of Progenitus etc. So I think it being x/x+1 is better. It's also really hard to kill with lightning bolt, because the toughness increases off lightning bolt if it is the first instant in a graveyard before the damage gets applied.

Ayy green glad you did the two best colors first

@turtleboy2150

3 ай бұрын

Gruul? Really?

@tylerprime6741

3 ай бұрын

​@@turtleboy2150I stand by it, best colours

@turtleboy2150

3 ай бұрын

my first ever deck was Gruul! It's near and dear to my heart, but the best guild colors? What about Simic? Izzet?@@tylerprime6741

Aw, the lil' sammiches.

Before watching the video: 1. Channel 2. Oath of Druids 3. Fastbond 4. Golgari Grave-Troll 5. Natural Order With an honorable mention of Up the Beanstalk

What about craterhoof