TIMING CHAINS vs. BELTS - Differences, Evolution, History and more

What is up engine heads, today we will be taking a detailed look at timing belts and timing chains. We will compare one with the other and dive deep into the benefits and drawbacks of both of these critical engine components all while presenting objective facts on both of these.
So what does a timing belt or a timing chain actually do? Well the key word here is "timing" and timing in this case refers to the relationship between your pistons and your camshafts and valves. For an engine to run properly this relationship must be constant and maintained at all times.
Chains are more resistant to wear because of course metal resists wear better than rubber. But there's a catch. Metal resists wear well only when it's lubricated and this brings us to our first big difference between timing chains and belts. Belts run dry but chains are splash lubricated by the oil in your engine. This means that chains must be sealed away from the environment to prevent oil leaks. The easiest way to tell if your engine has a belt or chain is to look at the engine. If it has plastic covers on the front, it's likely running a timing belt, if it has a sealed metal cover than it's likely running a chain.
Because they are more durable timing chains have much longer service intervals than belts, some chains don't even have service intervals. They last the life of the engine. Even if you don't use the engine at all, a belt should be replaced after 6-10 years, depending on the engine. This is because rubber naturally deteriorates and degrades with time. Timing belts are sensitive to oil and coolant spills, which can significantly shorten their life. High temperatures also contribute to increased rubber wear. A typical modern timing belt needs to be replaced every 60.000 - 100.000 miles. When timing chains do have service intervals, they are need to be replaced every 80.000 - 120.000 miles.
While timing belts are generally the same and don't differ much in terms of their design, timing chains come in two main different types - the silent chain and the roller chain. Silent chains minimize the amount of noise created by chain and sprocket assembly.
Silent chains are very common in engines and are loved by manufacturers because they are simple and cheap to manufacture. They are constructed from multiple links connected together by pins. The profile of the links fits the profile of the teeth of the sprocket and voila the chain turns the sprockets.
On the other hand roller chains incorporate rollers instead of links. The sprocket teeth fits in between the rollers and the rollers roll on the teeth as the chain rotates the sprocket. This both reduces friction and helps spread loads more evenly which also reduces localized wear. Roller chains can be of a dual or single type and as you're probably guessing dual rollers are more durable but due the increased surface area they also create more friction.
The drawback of roller chains is that they are noisier when compared to silent chains and that they are also more sensitive to debris and contaminants in engine oil.
The first ever engine with a rubber toothed belt was racing car built by Bill Devin in the early 50s. It was a Frankenstein engine that used two Norton Manx cylinders on a Panhard crankcase and an overhead cam layout. The first ever mass produced car to feature a timing belt engine was the West German 1962 Glas 1004. In 1966 Fiat also introduced the first twin cam engine driven by a rubber toothed belt and in the same year the United States got their first belt driven engine in the form of Pontiac's overhead straight six engine.
So does this mean that belts are the better choice and that you should choose and engine with a belt instead? No, it simply means that the demands put on today's engines have equalized belt and chain statistics and that some of the good reputation chains had doesn't apply anymore. The reality is that both engine drive systems are equally good provided you maintain your engine and replace components with quality ones when needed.
What's more important than belt or chain is maintenance as well as research. Before buying a car with a certain engine, make sure to do your research well and get acquainted with the engine's weak spots so you know what too look out for inspecting the vehicle and can accurately predict realistic maintenance cost that best suit your budget, needs and preferences.
A special thank you to my patrons:
Daniel
Peter Della Flora
Daniel Morgan
William
Richard
D4A merch: teespring.com/en-GB/d4a-merch
Patreon: / d4a
royalty free Music by Giorgio Di Campo for FreeSound Music
freesoundmusic.eu
/ freemusicfor. .
/ freesoundmusic
original video: • On Bourbon Street - ro...
download link mp3: link-to.net/49870/OnBourbonSt...
#d4a #enginebootcamp

Пікірлер: 2 400

  • @d4a
    @d4a3 жыл бұрын

    Support d4a:

  • @BensHacks
    @BensHacks3 жыл бұрын

    A belt will last the whole engine life. The engine life simply ends, when the belt fails 😜

  • @justayoutuber1906
    @justayoutuber1906 Жыл бұрын

    We had an early Acura that had a belt snap long before the 60k change interval. It was insane how interested Acura/Honda was on the root cause analysis. The engine was totaled and was sent back to Japan. And the incident went way high up in Acura, we heard - like VP level. They knew who worked on the line, what day, etc. It was impressive. Anyway, got a new engine out of it. Been a chain fan ever since.

  • @javabean215
    @javabean2153 жыл бұрын

    I used to work on a lot of VW TDIs. All of them were timing belts. I spoke with an engineer about why they went with belts, and the reply was that with 19:1 compression there's no room for error and chains can stretch, especially over a long time. The belt doesn't stretch nearly as much, and by following the VW prescribed timing belt change procedure you effectively re-zero the timing. The correct procedure has you lock the cam at TDC; loosen the bolts on the injector pump to lock it at TDC; then move the crank to TDC and lock it. That brought the engine back to factory fresh timing, and should be done every 100k miles (it was originally 60k miles, then moved to 80k, and finally 100k as the belts improved).

  • @gnarly3327
    @gnarly3327 Жыл бұрын

    I'm an IT engineer but know nothing about cars. I recently bought a car to work on and your engineering take on automotive tech makes me understand the engine and I diagnosed every problem the car had and even improved some points. Thank you.

  • @shawn576
    @shawn5762 жыл бұрын

    I'm amazed someone could make a 20 minute video about this and none of the video is filler nonsense.

  • @Hunting_Party
    @Hunting_Party3 жыл бұрын

    Imagine needing to time an engine.

  • @AliAlhussaini
    @AliAlhussaini Жыл бұрын

    When the belt is sus af, the piston and valves will have an emergency meeting

  • @MegaNardman
    @MegaNardman2 жыл бұрын

    Great breakdown of the subject. It all does come down to the application. There are a couple other considerations which make belts, in general, more preferential to me from a maintenance perspective:

  • @davidrobert2007
    @davidrobert20073 жыл бұрын

    Gear driven cams are the most reliable though.

  • @bustahbuds
    @bustahbuds3 жыл бұрын

    I just watched a 20 minute video about timing chains/belts and was on the edge of my seat the whole time! Great job!

  • @borayurt66
    @borayurt66 Жыл бұрын

    Belts have improved over time too, more advanced rubber compounds combined with Kevlar reinforcement made them quite durable compared to old versions.

  • @waltwimer2551
    @waltwimer25512 жыл бұрын

    Another excellent video! I love the fact that I already know a decent amount about these topics, but I

  • @williamstewart3469
    @williamstewart34693 жыл бұрын

    Someone in the comments called it, this gentlemans hair style keeps getting better. But on a serious note, another insightful and informative video Sir. Fast becoming a legend man.

  • @abhishekchaudhary9542
    @abhishekchaudhary95423 жыл бұрын

    Never knew that there were two different kinds of timing chains. Great work.

  • @ConquerDriving
    @ConquerDriving3 жыл бұрын

    Totally agree with you, in one of my own videos I also mentioned that belts and chains are equal, best to research the particular engine you are about to buy.

  • @SE45CX
    @SE45CX2 жыл бұрын

    What I like in your presentation style is the continues evaluation of pros vs cons on every design aspect.

  • @JoNoBaRr92
    @JoNoBaRr923 жыл бұрын

    Just found your channel tonight. Watched Boost School up to date and iron block vs aluminium plus more. Absolutely hooked! Great presentation and extremely clear explanations of any topic you cover! Love it!

  • @El_Chompo
    @El_Chompo3 жыл бұрын

    I sure hope free valve becomes a thing. There are such incredible amounts of improvements available to engines through unlimited valve timing and duration. It would really be a whole new level of engines. Everybody gets so exited about Vtec. Freevalve is like Vtec times a thousand.

  • @immanuelkouldnt7601
    @immanuelkouldnt76012 жыл бұрын

    I enjoyed 100% of your videos so far, they are very clear and well made. Seriously, keep up the good work!