Would you have preferred the Classic Sonic timeline split theory to stay (Neo Classic Sonic Timeline)? Or do you like the idea of one timeline that we currently have? NGL this reveal was kind of insane to me lol

I think that Classic Sonic and Modern Sonic are one, but the Classic Sonic from Forces and Gens is different. I think there are 2 Classic Sonics where the first one did not experience Gens, but the second one did experience Gens and Forces. How is this possible you ask? Well, Classic Sonic from another dimension was brought to Gens and Forces, because of the Time Eater and the Phantom Ruby. They affected other dimensions which causes that Classic Sonic was brought to Gens and Forces. I actually think Classic Sonic is just Sonic from another dimension and that the other Classic Sonic isn’t Classic Sonic, it's just Modern Sonic from the past.

Classic sonic's mind gets erased every time he travels back to his time

I always liked the whole Split Timeline thing, as we already had a Multiverse with the Sonic Rush games, and it’d be an easy way to avoid Time Paradoxes, also a Multiverse doesn’t always make things meaningless, it just depends on how it’s handled, which there are much better Multiverse stories out there than modern media would have you believe

Consider that Sonic Superstars may have been in development when the timeline split was canon. Not that it changes anything, but it's interesting to think about.

At this point I headcanon that classic sonic is changing the future by doing things different in the past. (Hence why modern sonic remembers the new games now)

3:50

Years ago my old school blocked the School district site of which i needed to access my account and student portal. "What the fuck?!" Was my exact reaction, like how the fuck was i supposed to do my work?!

Since the Silver Emerald allows Classic Sonic to homing attack I'd say Superstars comes after Gens since the ending of that game has him attempting the homing dash before he returned back to his timeline with Classic Tails.

I wouldn't mind a timeline split, so they're not as limited with future Classic games, but I understand why they want to try and connect everything together. All I want at this point is just for them to focus on making future stories good. Time travel can be involved, but it shouldn't always be involved because the lore will get really messy really quickly. Everything should be able to work within the confines of its own story. Plot wise, games can build on each other, but they shouldn't always need to. This discussion kind of makes my brain hurt, so I hope people can understand what I mean. 😅

I definitely would have preferred them to separate Classic n Modern Sonic timeline since Sega/Sonic Team will just rope themselves into a corner after trying to fit a new Classic Sonic game timeline into the Modern timeline. Plus if the timelines are splitted, then it would have given more freedom for Classic Sonic to have more interesting stories, new characters, and new abilities that change up the Classic formula.

I’m glad they’re all under one timeline because it goes to show that past games matter to the overall series.

It could be like in Doctor Who when he meet his past self. When they go their separate ways, the past him forget about the encounter to preserve the timeline.

This Mayor Classic Sonic Timeline Theory I kinda agree with. I do know that Classic Sonic takes place in the past. The thing about the Neo Classic Sonic Timeline is how did Eggman in the Classic universe know about the phantom Ruby that came into Sonic Forces but I don’t know if the phantom Ruby split the Timeline I don’t know it’s very confusing with the Classic Sonic Timeline. I can see why people would said that they want the whole entire timeline to be one Timeline instead of two Timelines but I think it would make sense that Classic Sonic had his own timeline.

I know its kinda random but i love your kirby shirt.I love kirby

I prefer having a neo classic timeline separate because if it's separate then they can create new stories, new characters, new villains and they can tell stories that won't be limited because it won't be from the past

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Wow!!! Great job!!!! Thanks for the heads up!!!

W Sonichub and great video

classic games would still matter to M.Sonic even if the timeline split happened like Sonic 1,CD,2,3&K still happened for M.Sonic but when Generations happens C.Sonic becomes his own thing which is why Mania happends since the events of Mania didn't happened for the Modern Cast hacen why M.Eggman wound not know what the Phantom Ruby is in the prequal comic of Forces and after Forces happens Mania Plus & Superstars happened to Classic Sonic and Modern Sonic Continues to other adventures too like Frontiers. The split timeline just makes more sense to me then the one big timeline that they are trying yo do now.

I just have two questions about the timeline: