i forgot revenge of the island at 30:34 because i'm smart youtube reviewer man but it'd prob be C or D.

@ThreeGuysandaGirlinaBeac-hm9vi

Ай бұрын

L. Revenge was goated

@mummyman5

Ай бұрын

​@@ThreeGuysandaGirlinaBeac-hm9vi L isn't on the tier list. best i can do is C.

@ThreeGuysandaGirlinaBeac-hm9vi

Ай бұрын

@@mummyman5 I see you're a Light fan, me too btw

@christophershaver-nt8kf

Ай бұрын

only happens once

@bryankennedy3719

Ай бұрын

Lightning was the man he made that season

The confessionals turning into internal monologues wasn't a reboot thing; it affected the series more each season.

@Just_Daze

Ай бұрын

based Uncle Ray pfp

@theamanchannel6800

Ай бұрын

Seriously

@craigpatton8579

15 күн бұрын

Sounds like they are copying anime

@BintanginTaya

6 күн бұрын

What? It's more like a mockumentary sitcoms. ​@@craigpatton8579

“Scary Girl” could’ve been the new Izzy. That was a HUGE missed opportunity. Still a dumb name for a character tho lol

@BucketIHead

Ай бұрын

Her actual name is lauren but like no one uses it

@hunukocapybara9324

Ай бұрын

Fr​@@BucketIHead

@petthequeenofmaddness8592

Ай бұрын

I was hoping it would be Izzy in disguise or something

@moniqueperkinsmp

Ай бұрын

tbh i didn't understand when i saw the leaks why she was just Scary Girl, and the name feels lazy tbh

@tykamen5588

24 күн бұрын

Kinda glad that they didn't make her the new Izzy

The fact that Bowie is the straight man is pure irony.

@azimmeme9994

Ай бұрын

More like the gay man

@Kizaco

Ай бұрын

Yeah whenever I realized it I audibly groaned but it’s funny.

The Total Drama Daycare thing is a fever nightmare that chef has. He was never the same after. Headcannon

Italian here, tbh Total Drama (the first three seasons at least) was extremely popular in Italy when I was younger, probabily way more then in North America

@josephrowe849

Ай бұрын

I'm only of Italian descent but I've never seen TD before.

@michelefumagalli81

Ай бұрын

Confirm, I remember the sheer hype in middle school when the season finales were approaching

@justawarlord

Ай бұрын

@@josephrowe849 you should look up the debates of Sub Vs Dub in italian. some people get as heated as the weebs of japan

@invertebrado

Ай бұрын

@@justawarlord LMAO is that something that really exists?

@forgidendrogo

Ай бұрын

​@@josephrowe849 Do you live in Italy?

that joke about her brother's posture genuinely caught me off guard lmfaoo

@hhgreggthememe260

Ай бұрын

holy shit caliborn

@gabrielcastejon7914

Ай бұрын

Wait, plz explain it for me!

@k0metz590

Ай бұрын

Talking about siblings... how is your sister?

@fakecore9811

Ай бұрын

@@gabrielcastejon7914 i dont remember what the line even was im so sorry LOL

@thegreatestfallout1794

27 күн бұрын

@@gabrielcastejon7914 Stick up the butt. That's what people describe as walking and standing very stiffly

Wait, didn't the original island sink in the end of All Stars?? Isn't that the reason there was an all NEW island in Pahkitew???

@FishwicksREAL

Ай бұрын

all stars was retconned

@TheGamer19856

Ай бұрын

It got better.

@SalmonsAnimations

Ай бұрын

Yeah I thought that too, apparently its an island that's modeled after the original one

@FishwicksREAL

Ай бұрын

@@SalmonsAnimations no all-stars ending was retconned

@TheRealLifeKillerMoth

Ай бұрын

@@FishwicksREALI’m hoping that whole season was retconned 😭🙏

Going back to SG, wasn't TD's whole thing in its OG run taking characters who start off flat and one-dimensional stereotypes and making them shockingly nuanced people overtime? Why couldn't they just do that with Scary Girl? Yes, I am attempting to compensate for her being my favorite, thank you for noticing!

@derpydoggo8880

26 күн бұрын

Fleshing out stereotypical characters was its thing. They also had more episodes to develop characters and pace the story.

20:14 "im kinda sick of characters just being gags" EZEKIEL. EZEKIEL. AND EZEKIEL.

@GigaLigma

Ай бұрын

Man I was really hopeful for that clueless loser to get some actual character development. After seeing all the other characters become more interesting over the course of season 1, then suddenly they bring Ezekiel back? I thought oh man, I can't wait to see what kind of character he turns into if they can make me like someone like Heather! But nope... he's the one and only character they never tried to do anything with, for no apparent reason. Just turned him into an unfunny recurring joke with no redeeming qualities whatsoever.

@TotalleeLee

26 күн бұрын

@@GigaLigma i think the fact he slowly over time became a loo that's set on getting that suit case is *something* they could've just never brought him back

@GigaLigma

26 күн бұрын

@@TotalleeLee They turned him into an inhuman goblin with no personality. It's a shame because he wasn't that bad in episode 1 aside from being absolutely clueless and full of himself.

@XanderMatthews-nv9zf

24 күн бұрын

Eva, Katie & Sadie also got the same treatment

@GigaLigma

24 күн бұрын

@@XanderMatthews-nv9zf I see what you mean but I really don't think anyone went quite like Ezekiel did. That was a special kind of bad.

I can confirm there’s a big fan base in Italy… it was basically aired every day, even the first season, for like almost 20 years

@Psyrens

5 күн бұрын

This is good to know. Glad Italy is carrying this show's Fandom on its back. They're probably responsible for this season existing and to that I say Italians must have excellent taste in shows.

Schrodinger's Cartoon. A show in a constant state of not existing and already being finished. (seriously where do you even watch this thing)

@zemiguel8261

Ай бұрын

kimcartoon

@poopyscoopy6984

Ай бұрын

@@zemiguel8261 Based

@jagerzaku9160

19 күн бұрын

They are deliberately trying to kill it. No way to support the show.

"Scary Girls thing is that she's actually crazy, to the point of homicidity, so she's just my type" Too true, too true

julia would be my favourite if she did anything on screen s2

@PepsieCat

Ай бұрын

Who'd win in a fight; Batman with prep time or off screen Julia?

@flourrrr

Ай бұрын

@@PepsieCatsorry off screen julia mogs batman low diff

@nuibaba280

Ай бұрын

@@PepsieCat The fight would cut off right before it happens with Julia showing up as the victor.

@blazethebluefire6352

Ай бұрын

have you seen season 2?

@LeonDeLlama

Ай бұрын

@@nuibaba280STOP LOL

7:47 saying the characters look boring then having zoey, one of the most boring and generic td characters in s tier is more insane than scary girl.

@Raddish-IS-Radd

2 ай бұрын

26:47 also this rule is broken in tdi by cody lmao

@mummyman5

2 ай бұрын

oh, i agree completely. i just like her bc i liked her as a kid. which _is_ insane. also i dont think julia or scary is actually S tier overall, that was hyperbole.

@conanhighwoods4304

Ай бұрын

@@mummyman5 I too liked Zoey as a child. IDK why.

@kennyl4699

Ай бұрын

​@@conanhighwoods4304 It was such a disappointment for me as a kid because I enjoyed the idea of having a character with an interest in retro/indie fashion and culture. Despite this, after her audition tape, it felt like that aspect of herself - The Indie Chick was supposed to be her archetype, mind you - was just completely forgotten and she became Mike's satellite love interest.

scary should've been around for the longest............. 1D characters can always become 3D then it's super interesting

i not gonna lie hope if there comes a reboot s3 damien has gotten enough of all this bullshit and becomes the main villain/antagonist

Scary girl made the show interesting until she was out and then drama happened when Julia was exposed 😭which made me interested again after loosing lauren

@ScaryGirl_TD

2 ай бұрын

TY WHOEVER LIKED THIS COMMENT

@RobinLuv

2 ай бұрын

Nah they had to make her booted early 💀💀 SOMEONE FREAKING MAKE HER WIN A SEASON FOR GOD'S SAKE

@ScaryGirl_TD

2 ай бұрын

@@RobinLuv FR

@muffetmissulena6540

26 күн бұрын

@@RobinLuvhonestly, based PFP

For Chris McClean, if you can't get the same VA, just change the character. There's no reason to keep it the same character... Seriously, they should've made him Topher. He even SOUNDS like Topher...

Seeing someone "dislike" the reboot is honestly a breath of fresh air to me. I did like the reboot quite a bit but it has so many flaws that I feel like most people just don't talk about because they're blinded by us finally getting a new Total Drama season. And yeah the way this show has been released is dog shit, I want to rewatch it mainly to see if my opinions would change but I just don't know where I can. Anyways, great video you deserve more attention

@goofyahhkuroze

Ай бұрын

I think its because the reboot has alot of positives tbh

i actually forgot that this only has 300~ views from the quality. very underrated

@mummyman5

Ай бұрын

i appreciate the sentiment. tho, i think the quality is kinda mixed, especially the audio quality. also 300+ views in under 24h is pretty good for me.

@exglepersonal

Ай бұрын

about that . . . 🎉🎉​@@mummyman5

@elknothin3403

27 күн бұрын

and now it had over 100k in a month

@jagerzaku9160

18 күн бұрын

@@mummyman5btw if you ever do a follow up to this video. Christian Potenza turned out to be innocent. Accusations were false. So they REPLACED HIM FOR NO REASON.

Dude the chef alternate universe theory went crazy. This was a great video man. Really funny and enjoyable.

My canon ending to total drama island is that chris gets sued and goes to jail for 70 years

Chris has to be one of more subtle yet extreme case of flanderization. It's something I didn't notice until I went back to the first season but he was actually pretty chill towards the survivors with some very slight narcissistic traits here and there but in the later seasons they basically turned him into a war criminal

I don't really understand your dislike for Bowie. To me, he was by far the best character of the cast: he's a villain, or at least a pretty antagonistic force at least in season 1, but he's also pretty grounded: he's not overly "evil", as shown by his friendship with Emma or his relationship with Raj, he's just a dude that plays to win and is willing to stoop pretty low at times(like breaking millie and priya's friendship) to do so. You said that no character besides Julia is good in both seasons, and that no characters has an arc across both seasons, and I'd have to disagree again, pointing at Bowie: his arc and social standing in Season 2 is right on the back of Season 1. He's despised by most of the cast because of what he did during Season 1, which makes him a social paraih and a very easy first merge boot, and he tries to become a better person and tone down with the cheating despise his worst instincts due to his boyfriend that he made in Season 1, Raj. The snowball fight against Julia MK and Ripper in Episode 5 is the climax of that, when he finally puts his boyfriend and their relationship above the game and his desire to win. He then gets eliminated one episode later by offscreen Julia schenanigans. So yeah, I love Bowie. He's also very funny imo. The whole "YOUU! MEEE!" thing when he eliminates Julia in Season 1, him moonwalking in episode 4 season 2, he's just very iconic

@mummyman5

2 ай бұрын

I don't really dislike Bowie. I just didn't care too much for him ig. Objectively, he is one of the best characters in s1, and he is pretty similar in s2. So yeah, I was probably wrong when I said Julia was the only one equally good in both.

@ajb5119

Ай бұрын

Bowie is the most cringe character from the reboot.

I want a tdi show where the viewer votes who leaves + the team members.

@Tr4sh_can34

Ай бұрын

sounds really fun but I could imagine it would take a lot of time to animate

@shuichisaihope398

Ай бұрын

That sounds legit interesting but yeah the break between episodes would probably be massive as they would have to make each episode very separately and not much overarching stories

@yoko881

20 күн бұрын

so bfdi

Congrats to chase for winning both seasons of the reboot! Great player!

@ThreeGuysandaGirlinaBeac-hm9vi

Ай бұрын

He won in my heart

@blazethebluefire6352

Ай бұрын

Ripper won are you delusional?

@sprite9932

Ай бұрын

chase should win next season too1

@Winterrose782

Ай бұрын

omg yall saw the alternative ending.... mr coconut is the canon winner

@CarlosCarlito-ps2wq

Ай бұрын

Scary girl won😤💅🏾

Fun fact for those who dont know : Did you know? That owen returned in one of the episodes in the reboot.

People wanted Priya to finish her arc about her parents and/or get with Damien. S1 wasted our time going on and on about how awful the parents are and usually played it straight. And Damien's arc would've easily intertwined with Priya's screenhogging + her TD experience.

as an Italian , Total drama island was on TV live on the most popular kids TV CHANNEL (Boing and K2) , so we had to watch either that or Teen Titans Go/Gumball (or atleast at night) since it was streamed mainly on dinner time I think thats why it got successful! :D sad thing is that the episodes kept getting looped over and over again cause obviously the series ended and they had to repeat it.p! So thats probably why they decided to dub it in italian first! (cause it still streams on TV till this day!)

I liked Scary Girl the most in the new show and they used her name in one episode.

20:49 *sees Scary Girl as the first eliminated* nope, I'm out.

@jasper_the_ghost

Ай бұрын

Waaay too real. I watched literally until Scary was gone then I stopped.

scary girl was voted off so unfairly

i'll never get over them cutting off the most interesting character early af twice. if lauren was actually given time to flesh out her character, i might have actually watched the show.

23:52 it’s a cassowary!

Frankly I'm kind of confused why they seem to target this towards gen z? I'm considered late gen z and yet I'm 17, presumably not the target audience? I watched the OG show as a kid. Presumably the audience would be gen alpha. It seems to pander more towards gen z instead of the younger generation, although I suppose you could argue it is marketed to gen alpha, but given the fact that the whole theme of it is "its a reboot", I find it hard to see how its a kids show- its more so a show for kids who grew up the OG total drama.

@SLW27

Ай бұрын

Gen Alpha are kids bruh

@_exolite

Ай бұрын

@@SLW27 yea that the point I’m makin 💀😭

@SLW27

Ай бұрын

@@_exolite I meant that Gen Alpha kids aren’t teenagers yet, unlike Gen Z.

@_exolite

Ай бұрын

@@SLW27 that’s… the point I’m making??? Lmao??? Do you have reading comprehension??? My point was it seemed marketed towards Gen alpha, who would have grown up on the previous addition of the show, but yet it being a kids show, it would only make sense that you would market it towards kids???

@SLW27

Ай бұрын

@@_exolite How the fuck would they write teenage stereotypes using Gen Alpha characteristics? It also seems as if YOU don’t have basic reading compression, as you confused Gen Z with Gen Alpha in your idiotic reply.

scary girl shouldve been bigger and the fact that she wasn't makes this show a -3 in my eyes.

You actually deserve sm more attention this is really good

TDIR doing a pure squid game parody for a season honestly sounds great too bad they only partly did it

4:21 UPDATE: they're finally releasing it on june 1st in the US

You have no idea how popular this show was in Australia until the end of world tour since I was on ABC

Scary girl shouldve stayed way more and the ripper shouldve never been a thing

i was around 7 when the first one came out and i remember every week our class would deliberate what happened during that weeks tdi, it truly was our survivor lol

This was so good! The video was funny but serious at the same time and I loved it! New sub.

As a fan of the Rockstar title Bully, I highly appreciate the use of the soundtrack as background music! Keep up the good work and great editing! I also wanna say how your structure of the video made it very easy for someone without much interest in the topic at hand, to understand your points clearly and thoughtfully without getting lost!

Bro even if I disagreed with 1 or 2 parts, this is the best analysis review style video of the TD reboot I've ever seen. I love it. You're also just really funny in general.

This is a really good review you actually deserve waaay more subs bro

"The tiny dog is going to be the scary one." I called it the moment I saw it and I still laughed. I'm a sucker for the animal comedy.

loved the video you are a great creator did not expect the 6/10 from the way you worded everything i expected something like 4/10 since it seemed like you hated it lol either way you deserve more subscribers.

@mummyman5

2 ай бұрын

yeah, i regret making it sound so skewed toward the negatives. ig its just easier to talk at length about things i didnt like than did. ill try to fix that in the future. i agree with most ppl that it's good, or at least ok, but i just don't think it's anything special.

We need more reward/non-eliminatiom challenges so theres more breathing room to develop characters

i don't watch this series but it's always weirdly fascinating to check in as an outsider. the only thing i really have to add is that i'm convinced the klepto asian girl is a bad attempt at copying awkwafina.

I think I remember the original show dropping off in quality severely by season 3

scary girl should be a better version of zeek if they bring her back

pretty good video, based SG enjoyer Hope they actually do more with her in a hypothetical 3rd season

Ironic how the 3rd goth in TDI is one of the most interesting additions to the new cast.

YES A PERSON THAT SAYS THAT EMMA'S ELEMINATION WAS UNFAIR FINALLLLY yay (; Good video! (;

Italian here, and yes, Total Drama has been really popular for ages here. I imagine *part* of the reason is that it unintentionally parodies an also extremely popular italian reality show called "L'Isola dei Famosi" ("The Island of the Famous") where a bunch of actual real life celebrities are sent to a carabbean island to live and complete challenges until all are voted out but one, who wins a big prize. Said show has been running for 20 plus years.

@KorinIta

Ай бұрын

Non dimenticarti serie come Grande Fratello, che comunque anche se non ambientati su un'isola è pur sempre un reality show basato sul drama, che in italia va tanto. So che ne esistono altri simili all'isola dei famosi ma non ricordo per niente il nome. Uno aveva a che fare con le coppie mi pare.

Wait, two seasons with the same competitors? Except for Creepy Girl beign replaced by handsome joe?

Honestly I loved this show as a pre-teen. And I had no idea before this video that there was even a reboot lol. Shows how well thats going

very high quality stuff here, exceptional content, great vid man

finally a video essay style vid on the new reboot

the fact that this thing aired in boomerang (in some country that apparently stll has it) was so odd to me, i now feel old again

you reached 1000 subs with this one lol love your narration style so far

Wow, you dislike Ripper? That's such a nuanced and original take.

@mummyman5

2 ай бұрын

ik, i almost didn't post this video because i knew it'd be controversial. but i figured, if nobody else will, i should be the one to stand up for what's right.

@firechillbro720

Ай бұрын

Well to give him credit he did kinda like ripper in the first like 4 episodes of season 1 (heavy emphasis on kinda btw) which literally everyone agreed on that ripper in these episodes was just the worst.

@ajb5119

Ай бұрын

Ripper is the GOAT.

bro never watched total drama island, never even seen this channel but this was a BANGER video!

As someone of the target demographic gen z i like the reboot alot i do think island and world tour are better i think season 2 is above action and season 1 is behind action plus wayne is my favorite character in the franchise now dont ask why hes just funny

ngl I forgot this reboot existed until this vid showed up on my fyp

I was crushed when they booted off scary and kept ripper on the show 😭 the constant fart jokes got old REALLY fast.

12:19 as an Italian, your pronunciation is hilarious haha jk, great video, I honestly thought you had more than 300 subs

the reboot doesn't seem too bad, but there's moments where the characters' black outline for their lips seems too thick, and it looks like a thin, evil goatee, and I can't unsee it

Haven’t seen anything about this show in like a decade but this is still a very well made video

Scary my beloved, the only reason I watched. When she left I left. lol

she is just a wanna be heather tbh

@ajb5119

Ай бұрын

Yes sir.

One of the most underrated channels I've seen in a long time, keep up this quality stuff dude

Wait why did I spend an hour watching a video about a show I always skipped as a kid. To be fair your voice is great and the video is well made. I didn't even expect that level of pro from a small starting channel. So thanks for wasting my time by charming me

5:11 "..just by a glance you can tell what most of their personalities will be" *takes glance* *reads owen's* "Personality: Fat." I almost choked on my beer

This editing is peak entertainment 😭😂😂

as an italian, i never saw anyone talk about tdi at school when the show was airing (might be only me now that im reading another person's experience lol)

Thanks KZread for recommending this channel. I feel like I stumbled upon a gem.

Lmao why did you do Noah dirty like that dawg

bro made it into the algorithm congrats

The thumbnail is everything😂

off-topic but props on the bully ost. surprisingly fitting for TDI clips

of course he likes white goth girl “waifu” more than any of the characters with any content to them, it’s always your type

The way he contrasted it with season 1- there are so many new, uncovered stereotypes to pull from! They hit a few, but they could have had so many more bounce off each other. It seems like these are either not grounded or don't get a chance to matter (or both).

the like button only flashed once when you first asked the question

I think this season is really good but I don't know yet if its actually good or if I'm just blind by my love for Total Drama content (Also Pahkitew ironically had the most recognizable stereotypes since season 1's cast.)

Damn I didnt know about this till I saw this video, I wish I could go back in time to that moment. Great video though, thank you for watching this for me!

5:09 is the most accurate description of any of these characters I’ve ever seen. Based

This guys style is so much like Mossbag and I’m here for it

I don’t really know but by the date you posted this IT IS on HBO Max, watched the full 2 seasons of the reboot there some days ago and loved it

@HappyLittleWorker

Ай бұрын

Do you live in Latin America?

@frimie1

Ай бұрын

Still not available in the USA :/

I really miss how natural the first season one. Moments during challenges where the contestants weren't monologuing to themselves, and the main characters feeling like actual people. These new seasons did fine with bringing the latter back, with Bowie having more going on for him than just 'gay' & actually having a great personality to watch. Meanwhile, Pahkitew had the most shallow cast ever I'm glad this revival came out ultimately

Scary girl Lauren is my favourite. I could fix her

This reboot STILL hasn’t aired anywhere here in the United States. Not on Cartoon Network nor through Max.

when i saw the title of the video i thought he was going to be talking about total drama rama but ive never seen this reboot

30:02 IT'S WHAT SHOULD'VE HAPPENED 51:12 ALSO WHAT SHOULD'VE HAPPENED

@bwakwochibwakwochi777

Ай бұрын

lol

you saying "fecal funnie" caused neuron stimulation for me fellow joey watcher

I think they are just marketing it as a reboot because that's just a popular thing for some reason.

i cant believe that total drama procured the Fulton extraction device to dispose of contestants

If prya was 1 or 2 at the end of season 1, it would still check out since the progression of a child doesn't really diverge from a straight path of improvement by that point.