The Two Paragraphs That Effectively Banned U.S.-China Space Cooperation | WSJ
In 2011, Congress effectively banned the U.S. from working with China in space. The law is called the Wolf Amendment. Its goal was to prevent China and Chinese companies from stealing U.S. technology and also to put pressure on China over human rights abuses.
But today, the dynamics in space are changing. The International Space Station is set to retire in 2030. Meanwhile China’s space station, Tiangong, was just completed at the end of 2022. Both countries have plans to establish a presence on the same part of the moon in the next decade.
WSJ explains why that law was created and why whether it has hurt or helped the U.S. is a big debate in the space community.
Illustration: Madeline Marshall
News Explainers
Some days the high-speed news cycle can bring more questions than answers. WSJ’s news explainers break down the day's biggest stories into bite-size pieces to help you make sense of the news.
#NASA #China #WSJ
Пікірлер: 1 000
As a Chinese I absolutely thank to this Wolf man, He is a cornerstone of Chinese space industry
@hayden1770
Жыл бұрын
God Bless! Best wishes to China! 🇨🇳
@pjw3438
Жыл бұрын
Democracy refers to the manipulation of public opinion through the media to win elections. The main method of election is debate, and eloquence is very important. That most famous German was democratically elected. Western politicians are very eloquent, but they are also the most brazen and confounding black and white. Chinese people's eloquence is generally poor, and Chinese people focus on doing practical things.
@user-li2my9dp4j
Жыл бұрын
😂
@tiefblau2780
Жыл бұрын
You want to work with Copy? *EVEN* *ON* *EARTH* *they* *cross* *the* *sea* *to* *get* *some* *hack* *some* Technology
@calicocat8213
Ай бұрын
@@pjw3438An Austrian actually but never mind.
These two paragraphs single-handedly inspired China's independent and thriving space industry. Thanks to this legislature China's domestic space market has been effectively protected from foreign providers and collaboration, allowing domestic enterprises to fully mature every technical aspect of space exploration. Chinese people thank the US for such an amazing opportunity for their domestic industry
@ronaldchao496
Жыл бұрын
Same as US’s ban on huawei And Chinese chips development 🎉
@nesseihtgnay9419
Жыл бұрын
The chinese people are fine, the chinese communist party, is what is bad. Duh
@maanviss3840
Жыл бұрын
US sanction is like 'Gao Kao' for Chinese government. You can become world leader of you pass it 😜. Also wakeup Chinese people to self sufficiency. -Thanks US, you have give precious lesson to them (China) and they won't forget it.
@Rex-ww4cw
Жыл бұрын
Now they have their own space station
@jagjeevankashid
Жыл бұрын
@@Rex-ww4cw not that only India is also launching its space station upcoming years
American politicians talking about human rights abuses is so funny.
@alanssshh
Жыл бұрын
yes.even after killed millions in other countries.
@tommyboss4067
Жыл бұрын
I couldnt agree more. See what happened to the homeless at home.
@hayden1770
Жыл бұрын
USA = Biggest hypocrite in human history
@yl128pang3
Жыл бұрын
And the "human rights* of the 1,400,000 Americans that went to the heaven due to the inappropriate handling of the pandemic.
@alanssshh
Жыл бұрын
@prankEmJohn killing millions means nothing to you?
Frank Wolf, defender of human rights abroad and supporter of human rights abuse at home.
@jagdpanther2224
Жыл бұрын
No worries, he is a dying old man!
@plutonakamoto8740
Жыл бұрын
@@jagdpanther2224 ayo that’s funny 😂😂😂😂
@benombati6501
Жыл бұрын
You think US cares about human rights, you so naive baddy!
@kattiepenn
Жыл бұрын
👍👍 well said
@hangtuah888
Жыл бұрын
No, he is a supporter of human rights abuse across the universe as he does not know what time of the day he is in.
Ohh yeah absolutely US cares a lot about human rights issues
@jimmielin1141
Жыл бұрын
Only when it suits the US government. Just like a costume they wear , when it comes to that it’s always about human rights and freedom when US feels like they are being “threatened “ or they are trying to steal resources from other countries
@JigilJigil
Жыл бұрын
No it's Xi and China who are the one who care, I mean U.S has 20000000 Uyghurs in camps as prisoners + millions of forced labor.
@krac3x438
Жыл бұрын
well to be fair the US cares about human rights, as long as you aren´t chinese, vietnamese, black, latino, russian, a woman...
@RL-lr8ji
Жыл бұрын
And Native American.
@yl128pang3
Жыл бұрын
human rights, democracy and freedom of speech are the Tools that West used to block them from progressing and developing.
A blessing in disguise. Had China participated in the ISS or other US-led space program, there will be restrictions or enticement so that the Chinese cannot go solo but always dependent in some way on others. This was what happened with the Beidou. China participated and invested money in the Galileo project only to be screwed by the Europeans who basically asked the Chinese to take a hike in terms of hierachy. Now Beidou is complete and superior to the Galileo. China thrives in adversity. China has a fully independent space program, the only sure way to master this field.
@badhombre4942
Күн бұрын
Sanctioned proof.
If your think Wolf was an idiot, there was a bigger fool out there in NASA: Bill Nelson.
@tommyboss4067
Жыл бұрын
They are both soon landed at Moon or Heaven. 🤣🤣🤣
@victorkmlee
Жыл бұрын
He looks like Kenneth Copeland ranting and foaming in the mouth.
@yeejlilys9742
4 күн бұрын
Yes, based on Nelson that the US dose not land in the far side of Moon because it is too dark to go there. LOL for a NASA administrator.
This type of sanctions against China actually helps China developing own independent technologies.
@pppp3997
Жыл бұрын
Good for them, but don't help them.
@TitusAzzurro
Жыл бұрын
Thinking any type of move (pro china or against china) only helps china is cheap and ignorant. China being isolated whose only "allies" are Pakistan and North Korea is bad no matter how you analyse the thing.
@imnotyourfriendbuddy1883
Жыл бұрын
You must officially represent the CCP. No one who understands the international economy thinks isolation is good for a country.
@waynejohnson1786
Жыл бұрын
So?
@imnotyourfriendbuddy1883
Жыл бұрын
@@waynejohnson1786 Thanks for sharing your well informed opinion on this particular topic.
US: Saudi Arabia has the best human rights record
@ltipst2962
Жыл бұрын
Is this you trying to shade the Chinese human right abuses? Massacring muslims? Social credit systems? Saudi Arabia at the very least want to improve. I've seen nothing pro western pro joint cooperation from China. Nothing. Anyone else?
@Lochamp
Жыл бұрын
No one here says that, ever.
@yuxiangluo8614
Жыл бұрын
@@Lochamp because other nations' human rights are the last thing American care about. You guys only want to slave other nations and squeeze for money.
@alexanderphilip1809
Жыл бұрын
Saudi's have oil ? Oil benefits American companies and citizens. China on the other hand has undercut American workers courtesy of offshoring.
@duran9664
Жыл бұрын
🤢🤮Frank Wolf is pure disgusting hypocrite creature;🤢🤮 He kept talking about morality & human rights while was sleeping on the same bed with the saudi royal mafia for years. 🤢🤮
The semiconductor ban will again make China great again at developing itsbown tech.
@Sleepless-nights99
Жыл бұрын
Semi conductors are not a thing that can be made cheaply when cutting corners
@user-gc1hg9sp9k
Жыл бұрын
@@Sleepless-nights99 that the reason why china is invest hundred of billion in semiconductor
@DK-yz9xk
8 ай бұрын
@@Sleepless-nights99what now clown? 😂
@Jinitaimei222
3 ай бұрын
@@Sleepless-nights99🤣👉🤡
@user-dy4fm7id1q
Ай бұрын
@@Sleepless-nights99 HUAWEi 5nm
American politicians talking about morality kinda cracks me up.
Basically the US said they were going to take their ball and go home... So China brought their ball to the park the next day!
Bill Nelson: ".. we are not going to let that happen" China: Bill who???
@JS-ih7lu
Жыл бұрын
😂
@andachen7473
Жыл бұрын
what is Bill going to do?Is he going to carry out sabotage🤔Is this the American way of thinking? I can't do it, so others don't want to do it
@IndiAnFasod
Жыл бұрын
@@andachen7473 Yup..the American way is to sabotage things.. Just like Nord Stream pipe... it was definitely the American who blew it and accused Russia. It doesn't make sense for Russia to blow out its own gas pipe. If Russia doesn't want to sell gas to Germany, simply turn of the pipe. And it is not the German either, as the German needs the gas and if they don't want the Russian gas, simply stop paying for it. It was definitely the American, who will then force the German to buy gas from the US at 4x the price.
@tommyboss4067
Жыл бұрын
Too arrogant. Sadly, majority heard him.
Wolf seems to be the one who accelerated China's advancement in this field. Kind of an egg on face moment... oops
Wolf was so short sighted, basically he gave China a chance to fully developed their own space technology. With China’s might in manufacturing, no a surprise if one day it could overtake US in space. It’s better for US to collaborate and lead in space programs.
@hanfucolorful9656
10 ай бұрын
Chinese chip industry would be totally wiped out if the US continue selling chips to China for another 10 years, ... now every factory in China needs to find a plan B, and chip manufactures business in China is booming。。。
@user-gu8qi4me8x
3 ай бұрын
I actually genuinely agree with you and finally some one who l found in the comment section that actually has a functioning brain for once and this world actually genuinely needs more people actually like you in this world @@hanfucolorful9656
I guess separating mother from babies at the US border doesn't count as human right abuse in Frank Wolf's moral compass.
@rickjames18
Жыл бұрын
Guess you’ve never been to the border or lived there have you? I find it interesting that people would politicize such a topic without actually knowing what they are talking about.
@CentauriSphere
Жыл бұрын
He spoke in 1998, but yeah it's not correct behavior.
@colinhogan5661
Жыл бұрын
Moral compass isn’t a word in the CCP
@outerspace8158
Жыл бұрын
@@rickjames18 ignorant no limits seperated mom with her baby 🍼
@kngharv
Жыл бұрын
@@colinhogan5661 the difference is that CCP doesnt pretend to operate under a moral guidence
China has to thank the Wolf amendment for its advancement in space technology....
It’s funny that Bill Nelson said that he’s not gonna let that happen! Like, with what in his arsenal can stop that?! NASA had a chance to collaborate with the Chinese and explore the universe together, but was too proud or scared of the new comers! I’m sure NASA had “borrowed” a lot of techs from the Russians
@jagdpanther2224
Жыл бұрын
Americunt were backstabbers, see what they has done to Russia through Ukraine war? No cooperation was a good option for China!
@tommyboss4067
Жыл бұрын
Too arrogant. Sadly, majority heard him.
@tiefblau2780
Жыл бұрын
You want to work with Copy? *EVEN* *ON* *EARTH* *they* *cross* *the* *sea* *to* *get* *some* *hack* *some* Technology
@Oppos-qx4jr
9 ай бұрын
@@tiefblau2780rubish comment.. idea of the rubish fuking..heart of the evil syaitan 😈💯
@davidz7858
Ай бұрын
This kind of mentality does not only exist in space discover, it exists everywhere in US, anyone or any country could be on top, but not China.
My father told me when i was little: 'Do not worry about to be used by ppl. You should always worry about being useless to others! ' And my 40+ years of life on earth have proved he is right! Too bad these politicians of US dont have a chinese father like mine.
@winkus8586
Жыл бұрын
I really love this wisdom. I am going to teach this to my children. If God willing to give me some.
@Levitiy
7 ай бұрын
Even in death we serve.
When I hear Bill Nelson, I see stupidity.
Competition is good. Collaboration is only good when all parties are on the same level.
@KillahManjaro
Жыл бұрын
Well said.
@KoolRanqe
Жыл бұрын
Sounds like Marxism
If Singapore reluctantly became a nation because Chinese people were kicked out of Malaysia, the PRC reluctantly became a technological superpower because the US won’t share its technology 😂
@knightzhao8476
Жыл бұрын
Sometimes pressure is good giving that human being is lazy and prudence. We don't know what we can do only if we have no choice.
@wongpohchan9485
Жыл бұрын
China actually has US to thank for its superfast speed in catching up to advanced technology in many fields. By keeping China out from accessing high tech products, China has no choice but to develop its own technology, thus hastening China's progress.
@stalker0006
Жыл бұрын
@@wongpohchan9485 'thank' is not a good term. The tech advancement is crucial to minimise threats.
@LivingLonger
Жыл бұрын
@@stalker0006 'tech advancement'? National Geographic: 6.5 millions American believe that the earth is flat and a movement growing. yeah, maybe that will Make The World Great Again and surely not for the American.._ . *16 Jan 2019 - National Geographic - Flat Earth vs. Round Earth | Explorer.* The Ancient Greeks concluded Earth was a sphere, which has been validated by scientists ever since. Despite this, there is a movement growing claiming the Earth is flat. (VideoId: 06bvdFK3vVU )
@fannybirot2362
Жыл бұрын
Think about that the US is kicking China out of the semiconductor industry....
So Matt Damon is screwed😂😂😂
@BradleyGao
Жыл бұрын
@mudshovel 289 I believe he's referring to how in the Martian, they used a Chinese spacecraft to resupply The Hermes, which wouldn't be possible according to the Wolf Amendment.
@adimilyada7517
Жыл бұрын
@@BradleyGao it is possible since 'the martian' was funded by chinese thru TSM entertainment. that's why they help to resupply the Hermes. no wolf amendment required. lol
@poweredbynato6313
Жыл бұрын
Matt and his family will be screwed...
@khai96x
Жыл бұрын
@MasteroMatter Those are the days the Chinese still look up to the US. But things have changed now. Whilst the Chinese preach collaboration, the US preach discrimination. Whilst the US struggles with domestic terrorism at home, the Chinese people enjoy peace and security. Whilst the US debt-based economy makes thousands to lose their jobs and thousands more to the street, China prospers.
now let's hear it from the Chinese perspective.
@hwangi0404
Жыл бұрын
Too bad that perspective is banned in China.
@adlerzwei
Жыл бұрын
It's censoredby the party.
@Sone418
Жыл бұрын
On cooperation? The Chinese have always been open to international space cooperation. While they probably do have their own terms for said collaboration, there's no Chinese law preventing US-China space collaboration.
@adlerzwei
Жыл бұрын
@@Sone418 True cooperation required openness and transparency which China is incapable of. They literally can't even allow their own people free access to information how are they supposed to cooperate with the outside world? 🤷🏾♂️
@Sone418
Жыл бұрын
@@adlerzwei that may be, but I'm just providing the Chinese POV
No matter how evil human rights are if it serves America’s interests then it’s fine.
@naughtyfrog8257
Жыл бұрын
i’m glad the chinese don’t have the same human rights ideas as the US. which year does the US have not been in a war causing death and destruction?
@MrGanbat84
Жыл бұрын
Absolutely
@KoolRanqe
Жыл бұрын
Similar to how Americans vote and ignore international laws amongst thier own country TO national born citizens if it's supposedly profitable?
@huiqinjinxi4514
Жыл бұрын
Exactly.
@culturecomp09chn64
Жыл бұрын
truly!
That Bill Nelson talk more like a politician than scientist
@JS-ih7lu
Жыл бұрын
That’s because he is. He was the Senator for Florida before getting the top job at NASA. Wouldn’t know science if it hit him on the head 😂
Frank Wolf kicked in a home goal.
Mr Wolf has started the next space race, honestly good job
@duyataksis5210
Жыл бұрын
He absolutely motivated China's space program and its determination to succeed alone. His spiritual successors are currently doing the same for the Chinese semiconductor industry.
@alexanderphilip1809
Жыл бұрын
@@duyataksis5210 Times have changed Wolf's positions are now held by the majority of the US establishment. If you think the semicon sector is something that can easily be "won", Then I suggest you go back to school. Unlike space tech which had non western competitors semicon's firmly under the aegis of western states you dont see leading edge technology nodes being built in china esp. not at scale.
@duyataksis5210
Жыл бұрын
@@alexanderphilip1809 How little you know. You're the one in sore need of an education - lucky for you, I'm here to provide it. The CEO of ASML was just crying that if his machines are banned in China, then China will just come up with their own. He understands that the only thing slowing China's indigenization drive is that his company is dumping its scanners into China. China already has a stockpile of Western DUVL machines and will soon introduce its own. Furthermore, it's also in the early stages of constructing its EUV prototype and that will be ready in a couple of years. If anything, semiconductors are easier than space. China started from 0 in space and built its industry by itself. In semiconductors it's already starting from 80 and closing in on 100 extremely quickly. By 2030, China's semiconductor industry will dominate the world like it dominates in solar panels today. Remember this moment when that day comes and US companies are filing for bankruptcy.
@duran9664
Жыл бұрын
🤢🤮Frank Wolf is pure disgusting hypocrite creature;🤢🤮 He kept talking about morality & human rights while was sleeping on the same bed with the saudi royal mafia for years. 🤢🤮
@decreer4567
Жыл бұрын
@@alexanderphilip1809 He is a wumao. These are false prophets who claim to know the future but truly not.
Indeed, US has always somehow inspired chinese scientists to build their own space technology with zero dependency on foreign countries in such annoying ways.
I love the fact that the US constantly puts China in an outsider/underdog position whether in space program or all aspects of technologies because this gives China a strong impetus to thrive.
It's absurd to keep this tensions, especially with China, and about space. Fighting among huge nations only makes everyone more miserable.
@JigilJigil
Жыл бұрын
No it will just make China miserable, If the total decoupling happens and it probably will, It certainly would have some effect on the west but they can manage as other countries will replace China as manufacturing hubs, the only country who is going to be poorer and miserable will be China, they will experience widespread poverty is China, they have 1.5 billion people to feed plus they need to create/keep jobs for all those people while losing trillions of export dollars,.
@NPC-oc9oo
Жыл бұрын
@jigil jigil keep dreaming. You think the rest of the world will sanction their largest trading partner just because America throws a trade temper tantrum?
@denniswen8483
Жыл бұрын
@@JigilJigil thats right, the west is not the only countries that China can depend on.
No dogs and AUKUS citizens are allowed in Chinese space station. Should be booked in Chinese constitution!
@NMHTEKLU
Жыл бұрын
China's space station has allowed many countries seeking cooperation, such as Russia and Japan, to exclude the United States.
@David-dq4xn
Жыл бұрын
No Chinese communist locusts allowed in ISS
@NMHTEKLU
Жыл бұрын
@@David-dq4xn 美国禁止了同中国在太空上的合作
@JR-vc4gm
Жыл бұрын
I totally second this
@SW-fy8pq
Жыл бұрын
@@NMHTEKLU Japan is a pet dog of US, it will be too dangerous for China to with them as they might undermine China space station to please their master.
Old section. China doesn't need your old space station anymore. It is funny that Russia is allowed there.
@davidz7858
Ай бұрын
Russia is not good partner for China, Russia was China parter in last 30 year because they don’t have choice that China should appreciate to US.
They are doing just fine without us.
@kosia1972
Жыл бұрын
Hard to swallow but it's true
Some people should never have a say on science related matters. Good going Wolfie-boy... keep hand-cuffing progress.
When it get tough the tough get going. Thank you for making China strong and determine.
Hopefully in 2030 we will live in a time of more collaboration, peace and harmony in space.
I demand my military analyst have blue hair.
Never trust a person call himself Wolf.....
Wolf may be a smart animal. But there are no comparison to human being.
The fact that china still claims "Developing country" status for trade while they have a space station is insane. It would suck to have people up there when war breaks out.
@psl7360
Жыл бұрын
it sucks to know China be allowed to steal our technolgy but if they are ahead, our law allow us to cooperate with them. Now the voice is louder than when China was behind.
@TheExtraterrestrial99
Жыл бұрын
Because China still keep on developing, instead of declared developed and stuck there. That's just some superiority complex.
@ijling
Жыл бұрын
Just remember not to declare war on China for your on sake. China stands for peace and has always been since ancient times. They built the Great Wall to keep out the enemies. Their strategy is always to defend the nation but if provoked, they will fight to defend themselves. America has found a worthy adversary because America made China its enemies and not the other way round. If war comes, there will be heavy losses from both sides but whoever can endure more loses will win the war. And we know from history who will be the first to quit and run.
Thank you, Frank Wolf!
Basically the USA has already lost.
Interesting that the report left out a glaring question - what is US plan when their space station retire.
Competition is good. If China was involved with ISS, the worst case scenario would be like what we have now, a major player (Russia) leaving the only station humans have. Different nations should have different stations. Humans should not put their eggs in one basket.
@morbid747
Жыл бұрын
Competition also means the waste of resources. Each country should have different mission like US on Mars , China on the moon , Japan and EU on asteroids etc.
@dingjeffrey5382
Жыл бұрын
@@morbid747 I think such extent of “waste” is fully acceptable and meaningful . Your plan may be the most efficient globally, but too idealized. No country will fully share the key info with the others for their own interests, by the way, how to judge which country shall explore which planet, fairness just can’t be guaranteed. It's important for multiple countries repeat same mission to summrize experience of techniques by comparison.
Recently, the United States has also imposed sanctions on many fields and enterprises in China. Let's look back ten or twenty years later.
@Hoo88846
Жыл бұрын
just boycott all American brands and kick them out of China.
Everyone sees US like Homelander, but US see themselves as Batmy
"Life will find a way."
It's not about human rights abuses, free speech, democracy etc. When we create war every decade. What it's really about is ensuring we Americans are always on top, any challenge to that we will do what ever it takes to take them down.
@kattiepenn
Жыл бұрын
Well said, spot on!
@yeejlilys9742
Жыл бұрын
Well said. All talks of human rights, free speech, democracy, and more are excuses for a real purpose of dominance.
@JigilJigil
Жыл бұрын
A Chinese wumao petending to be American.
@aq3614
Жыл бұрын
So true
Always interesting when people acting on their fears create the circumstances that they fear. I suppose competition has its merits. Although the current path with the decoupling from China and Russia will make us all poorer.
@vueport99
Жыл бұрын
But it also exposes the ugly truth about these countries for all to see
@JigilJigil
Жыл бұрын
No it will make China poorer, If the total decoupling happens It will certainly effect the west but the only country who is going to be poorer and will experience widespread poverty is China, they have 1.5 billion people to feed, they need to create/keep job for all those people while losing trillions of export dollars.
@thomasherrin6798
Жыл бұрын
You can't co-operate with Countries that outright lie, provide disinformation and threaten your security, in the end that will cost more, Russia is a pyrrah state, China is making its way there, both will run out of their citizens money and will be bust, their ambitions are bigger than their population can pay for!?!
@larrylai7089
Жыл бұрын
@@JigilJigil U r right, but the truth is that there is no country wants to decouple with china so far
@edwardcardozo8325
Жыл бұрын
Say no one ever.
That law should be adopted into the chinese Constitution. It’s been the best boost to Chinese space program in its recent modern history
Bill Nelson summed it all up at the end there....
same thing will go with chips. Watch out for china’s chips
@golonawailus4312
Жыл бұрын
Not fried chips, the other kind of chips
My love, respect, and admiration for China grows every day! 🇨🇳
The space launches graph used in this video are out of date. I think it stopped in 2019?? We’ve (USA) definitely picked up the pace the last couple years.
@hyy3657
Жыл бұрын
Actually space x
@JS-ih7lu
Жыл бұрын
So has the Chinese 😂
Digging a hole, jumping into it, being locked in, and saying, hey I have no access to you.
The facts you discriminate against an ethnic has already a violation of human right. Period.
@badluck5647
Жыл бұрын
Agree. The people of Xinjiang and Tibet should be released from Chinese concentration camps.
@sapaiyo9810
Жыл бұрын
@@badluck5647 did you realise the xinjing news are all a fake news and propaganda cropped up by the US government?. please read more.
@badluck5647
Жыл бұрын
@@sapaiyo9810 You can see these camps from space from any independent satellite. They are built like prisons with tall fences, barbed wire, and guard towers. Also, why doesn't the Chinese just let the UN Human Rights team tour it independently if there is nothing to hide? Just use some common sense.
@sapaiyo9810
Жыл бұрын
@@badluck5647 I am providing you some link kzread.info/dash/bejne/qqFpyLCPYNW5kaw.html kzread.info/dash/bejne/qKh1wcaEmsWadpM.html kzread.info/dash/bejne/ZaalzrSdlKrNlLw.html You are the easy target which the US and UK government propaganda regards as first tier audience (i.e., readers which easily convinced)
@user-hh5ms5qd4g
Жыл бұрын
@@badluck5647 美国为什么不让中国搜查一下白宫呢?你是印度人吗?
Even his name wolf
Such A Long Video For A Single Word Racism .
Thank you Frank Wolf on making China self owned space station .❤
Frank Wolf is next to GOD
The hindsight wolf had, amazing. I hope others at hill learn from the man.
@julianchan692
Жыл бұрын
War wolf 😅
@AdrianClavijo
Жыл бұрын
@@julianchan692 at least he was a real wolf
@xieibrahim7304
Жыл бұрын
@@AdrianClavijo Wolf for what? For human being or just for his own species?
@AdrianClavijo
Жыл бұрын
@@xieibrahim7304 it's his name.
@justmanuel2000
Жыл бұрын
As the name implied, US is going down.
Its tq 2 those 2 paragraph that china got its own homegrown space station!
"Smart" Move.
Now US is changing tone😂😂
China never came to you but you went to them.
The crude missions sound like a recipe to wars on the moon.
The head of NASA would say that such ban is not in his awareness. lol~
@huiqinjinxi4514
Жыл бұрын
😂😂😂hmmm, maybe he needs a check up on his brain.
a merica and its allies... a perfect movie plot for Dumb and Dumber sequel...
I suppose, history is repeating with the chip sanctions and Chip Act.
This aged well. Maybe we should collaborate on balloon projects too?
Short sighted 🐺.
One crazy man ruins human space collaboration.
@watb8689
Жыл бұрын
thanks to him, the world now has options
Wow the moon is going to be really awkward
Repealing the Wolf amendment would be a smart move.
Bias stems from ignorance.
US's government legislation make it impossible to co-operate on fair terms. For example, Russia co-operate with US government on 2000 to 2014, until the geopolitic starts turning south. Alot of key space technology being transfer to US like space station operation and space shuttle engine (RD180) but later when US get reverse engineer, all the projects get interrupted due to geo-political instability. So to develop any genuine technology, it's better for one country to compete against US rather trying to co-operate on government level.
@ynoylucita3925
Жыл бұрын
Absolutely correct
in 10 years time you'll be saying the same thing about the chinese semiconductor industry. American politicians make the same mistake over and over.
Sandra Bullock: thx NASA. Without your help, how could I take a trip in Tiangong?
How can you call something the international space station if 1/5 of humanity is not invited?
@JerryWang-pp3fz
10 ай бұрын
ikr
Western hypocrisy
American human rights situation is exceptionally examplary in the world. But why are you Americans still unsatisfied?
The wolf and 3 piggies.
When we talk about globalization, that is to bring the world closer together. Through working together to bring economic growth, development and co-operation etc. When it comes to military industries, the US is not willing to cooperate together with China, therefore China was not welcome to share the space station and now the US will soon have no space station to work on.
Space program is all about physics and math, the Chinese is clearly doing way better than others when it comes to that
@badluck5647
Жыл бұрын
🤣🤣🤣🤣
@rickjames18
Жыл бұрын
Not really, they just stole as much as possible from the west, borrowed from the Russians, and poured tons of money until now. Money is gone, CCP is broke.
@poweredbynato6313
Жыл бұрын
India tried and crash landed in the moon. 🤣🍿😎
USA human rights ? Really ? Ask black community about it ? Shame shame shame ! Greetings from the Southern Hemisphere ( Argentina )
NASA should be administered by Hollywood.
Perhaps by the time moon colonies become operational for both countries space technology shall become so much of a production level technology that not one rival station shall take the assistance of the other even if an accident happened and crew is starting at death. Moon shall signify a deadly cold war theatre
@jagdpanther2224
Жыл бұрын
Moon has nothing special but a historic liar will be uncovered: Armstrong never landed on the moon 1969, his footage was shot in a Hollywood studio with artificial communications!
The ISS project has excluded China long before the wolf amendment. I am very curious about why it was.
South ⬇️ pole of the moon 🌝 where the resources are 🧐🤔 did anyone Catch that or I'm I tripping and really going to battle it out for it wow
Then Please, do not use Solid Rocket Boosters....
I hear that India was also kicked out from ISS.
@amos325
7 ай бұрын
If it were true then it is must because of the smell
To be frank there is no morality in USA parliament 😂
Womp womp 1 vs 6 still be chased 😂
Hegemony. Want monopoly. That is all. 😰
Thank you Wolf for making China so advance in space now!
America talking about human right abuses 😂😂😂
Kool
The mightiest may not always be right, but the mightiest always makes the rules.
FYI: every other county are already working with China like Europe and Japan…soon US will be just by itself thanks to Wolf😂