_Hes slowly turning into a Genshin lore theorist, we have him now boys._

@viviansytsui

2 ай бұрын

All according to keikaku as they say. xD

@skelebro9999

2 ай бұрын

When he'll turn into a Honkai lore theorist?

@arianotes6238

2 ай бұрын

@@viviansytsui Translator's notes: "Keikaku" means plan.

@Electric_Bagpipes

2 ай бұрын

@@skelebro9999 clearly you haven’t delved deep enough into the rabbit hole if you think those two are different things.

@adhail8016

2 ай бұрын

@@arianotes6238heh classic.

Hoyoverse literally saw everyone going nuts over Arlecchino in Winter Nights Lazzo and said "yeah we're gonna make the peak morally gray anime protag out of this drip marketing." And so they decided she deserved an entire short anime special. The dark arc of genshin with Fontaine is bringing out the best writing bringing up these kinds of topics, and im all here for it. No more digging through books and npc dialogue for the bleakness, fantasy France says we're now old enough to ride the trauma tube sadness escalator.

@sundalosketch4769

2 ай бұрын

"Fantasy France" is a funny combination of words

Hoyo-mix have released the OST and its called Emberfire for those who want to listen to the masterpiece itself

@UrLastSurprise

2 ай бұрын

Specifically the lyrical song. The mix of music that played through the entire short won’t be released till “The Shimmering Voyage Vol. 4” comes out in late July / early August during version 4.8.

@Caster_-

2 ай бұрын

@@UrLastSurprise i have faith in Tnbee to do this Job for us

@UrLastSurprise

2 ай бұрын

⁠@@Caster_- I respect the hell out of tnbee, but MIDI just doesn’t do it for me, so I wait.

@stevec4185

2 ай бұрын

nah i don't want trauma 😂

@DinoInATux

2 ай бұрын

Thank you so much! I was hoping they’d release it soon

Hi Marco, so the friend didn't betray Arlecchino. It was actually spoiled at the start of the video. Despite the cute graphics and the homey music, Mother was talking about a death game she's cultivating among her children

@Luis-325

2 ай бұрын

I've seen too many people miss that detail.

@MarcoMeatball

2 ай бұрын

Ah missed it listening to the music!

@MrFox-xr9cc

2 ай бұрын

And there is a little two-faced medical bat with an evil grin on its face. And during the animation there is a WAY too big focus on syringes laying around everywhere. So it's not just a children/teenager battle royal she is cultivating, but i strongly think child experimentation too. And the Battle Royal is just a means to an end who rises as the most successful experiment...

@NintendoSucksAlot

2 ай бұрын

terribly f-d up, reminds me of the whole alice game from rozen maiden

@user-ch4wb3en3y

2 ай бұрын

⁠@@MrFox-xr9ccYes, I think you are completely right. She gives me a very strong reference to Cocolia from HI3, but worse is that she never has a bit love to her child, even her true, biological daughter.

the animation starts with will o wisps wandering around becoming children. the European meaning for it is that those are dead wandering children with no family.

Just to add few info. Clerve is the biological daughter of the previous Mother of the House of the Heart or you can say the previous director. Clerve suffered from abuse from her actual mother as you can see the injuries when they were kids because of being weak and Innocent, as the mother say "How Grotesque" she implied that she should have killed her own daughter in the first place aside from witnessing her downfall, there's a theory that Arle/Peruere can't deal the final blow against Clerve so Clerve decided to jump in the sword to kill herself and make Arle the new "King". Genshin is getting their dark season and I'm here for it. To add: "Thank you everyone for sharing your thoughts about this" 😊

@dontmindme3103

2 ай бұрын

The Flower that the Mother is holding symbolizes the pendant on Clerve's necklace or it symbolizes Clerve.

@MrBentalton777

2 ай бұрын

if you look closely arle was holding her sword down by her side clerve was not killed by arle but probably an ice shard from "mother"

@billystokes3917

2 ай бұрын

​​@@MrBentalton777Is that not after Clerve falls to the ground? Cuz if it is, Arlecchino's sword could've just been pulled down with her.

@MrBentalton777

2 ай бұрын

​@@billystokes3917 it is as she falls to the ground you see her hand by her side in the water reflection. not to mention at that close distance the area where she was hit wouldnt make any sense as that close to arle would not result in a sword going straight as thats simply not how arms work. as well as her wound is bloody while arles sword is spotless.

@billystokes3917

2 ай бұрын

@@MrBentalton777 Looking back at it, you're right. Nice catch 👍👍

The children choir/hymn part really felt like the rest of the orphans pushing Arlecchino/Peruere to help her defeat "Mother". It felt a little like in the Inazuma quest where we (MC) listen to the wishes of the people/their visions and ambitions in order to fight the Shogun. As if the other children in the House of the Hearth were urging her onwards and giving her strength, like a whole "power of friendship" protagonist moment in a way. I really love it honestly, it makes Arlecchino's love for the House of the Hearth/the orphans seem so much more justified and gives it a whole new meaning. Replacing the seemingly sweet and caring "Mother" who was actually psychotically pitting the children against each other and experimenting on them, with the seemingly 'cold and unfeeling' "Father" who actually genuinely cares for the orphans after being one herself. In short - god, i'm gonna be so broke after 4.6

Marco is great, not even 15 seconds in and he is already spot on.

@CarlosAnglada

2 ай бұрын

the music just speaks to him in ways I can only imagine

@caseylp7121

2 ай бұрын

So glad I found his channel about a year ago

@skelebro9999

2 ай бұрын

he's the top Genshin theorist without even trying 😂

@CrAzY799999

2 ай бұрын

love it when he said "obviously this friend of hers is gonna die tragically...oh, I called it" lmao

I love the way you just predict everything as you watch it 💀

@arnavkamble7144

2 ай бұрын

I mean a musical artist being able to understand musical foreshadowing (hoyo are the only people who do this I've never seen other media pull it off so well) isn't that surprising lol

@The-hamster2471

2 ай бұрын

Knowing hoyo mix i mean yes

@teeman7137

2 ай бұрын

Im just a normal person but when a character is too sweet and kind, they have already seal their fate. Moral : be a douchebag if you ever happen to be a side character

the choir with children voices representing the children of the House of the Hearth putting all their hopes and dreams on Peruere and now I can't stop tearing up that part

@Alex_Deam

2 ай бұрын

And presumably the main female vocal rising up represents Arlecchino herself

@rosiealmonds7521

2 ай бұрын

@@Alex_Deam *cries even harder*

So, To give a clear explenation to what happened. The Original Knave, who's title was "Mother" was the owner of the House of the Heart. Peruere (Arlecchino) was one of the children. "Mother" acted very nicely and gentle. The story at the beginning is the ritual to become "King", while we don't have an explanation, it seems to be different from becoming the next owner of the Orphanage. But it works as follows: Every kid will be taught and raised to become fighters, then they will fight to the death and the winner will be crowned as "King". This is an English translation thing, but when Clervie (Pink Haired girl) is all bandaged up Peruere asks "Do mothers normally argue with their daughters" The actual translation should've been something along the lines of "Do biological mothers normally act like this with their daughters" Which confirms to us that Clervie is the previous Knave's biological daughter. Clervie ignores the question for obvious reasons, and then makes that beautiful promise to Peruere. Then we skip to the end of the Ritual. Clervie appears to be stabbed by Peruere's blade, but her words and the pose they're in makes it seem like something else is happening. It's highly implied that Clervie actually purposefully ended her own life to make Peruere win and become "King" her saying "I'm sorry (cuz she couldn't keep their promise) Thank you (likely because she's free from her "Mother") " and the weird angle of the sword are a clear sign that this is the case. At that point it should've been over. Peruere won, so she would be crowned as the new "King" but of course, she wasn't happy with that outcome, so she decided to kill the current Knave, "Mother". Another thing to note is that right before their battle, when "Mother" talks about the flower, it's implied she's referring to her daughter, which makes her an shitter individual. During the fight you can actually see how powerful Peruere is, as every one of her steps and attacks break the ground, and "Mother" is clearly struggling, until she gets a good hit in. Then, Peruere sees the flower, and decides to fully embrace the Curse's power, making quick work with "Mother". Another translation mishap, but again nothing super context changing but instead of "My Awnser is no" the actual line in CN-JP is something along the lines of "You're not good enough" likely refering to "Mother" saying she would guide her to become the one true "King". After that Arle gets arrested for killing a Harbinger, but soon gets to take her place. At the end when we see her meet that orphan kid (who i believe is just some random kid, nobody specific) she says "I will be a strict, unemotional Father" , This is likely due to her view of "Mother". "Mother" acted gentle, and nicely, she was sweet and kind when in reality she was an awful and spiteful person, who hated her own daughter. Arlecchino didn't want to become like her, so instead she decided to act strict and unemotional, when in reality she probably truly cares about all the Children of the Ophanage, and assumed the title of "Father" to not be connected to "Mother". One last thing, in the 4.6 Livestream we hear Arlecchino say "I want you to become the new King of the House of the Heart" refering to Lyney. I believe they're messing with us. The ritual is likely different and would involve protecting your loved ones and working togheter instead of killing each other ruthelessly. This is the end of my Ted Talk, thanks for reading

@manareikitsu4398

2 ай бұрын

I’d like to say for the “my answer is no”, better translation could be “you don’t worth it”

@Fraink5

2 ай бұрын

I have a question (because I don't know any Chinese language); how do we know for sure that Clervie is the Mother's bio-daughter? When she asks whether mothers fight their biological children, could she not just be comparing their abusive situation with the hypothetical situation of living with one's birth family? I don't mean to suggest you're mistaken; I just want to know why it should be read one way over the other.

@Fraink5

2 ай бұрын

Lmfao, actually, I can understand Japanese, so I just rewatched the video and answered my own question. Sorry for the bother! 😅

@ZukuUzu

2 ай бұрын

@@Fraink5 i can give the jp example aswell. In jp it's little easier to interpret as Peruere says "Hontou no Okasama" which would translate to "Real Mothers"

@swagmasternim2807

2 ай бұрын

Another note that the child that Arle recruited at the end is most likely the injured (and later died) Snezhevna from today’s video.

I love the analysis of how the Harbringer being the protagonist of their own story

@pacificnebula4899

Ай бұрын

That's something I love about Genshin Impact's use of music. When Arlecchino defeated "mother" the amount of weight in the song truly made her feel like the main character. And with La Signora's battle theme is actually quite romantic. It makes the final boss feel like they are the protagonist.

I always praise his insights. Today Imma praise his wide eyed reaction to that kick 😂

@MarcoMeatball

2 ай бұрын

😂

Man, she put her own child in the 'orphanage' and when her own kid dies, she thinks she should've just killed her sooner. Sheesh.

@saif-gv6gl

2 ай бұрын

Arlecchino was so pissed she went straight for the kill

The song is also already releasew btw. It's titled "Emberfire", on Hoyo-mix channel.

@funnylawyer52

2 ай бұрын

it says not available

The song "Emberfire" slapped my heart to be crying with warmth beautiful scene 🥲👍🏻

@lopsidedlollipop

2 ай бұрын

Thank you for dropping the name of the song! I've been wondering, it's gorgeous.

I really like that Marco touches upon the Fatui being the protagonists and not the antagonists around 15:00, because that was also the feeling I got when I played during the Sumeru and Fontaine arcs. I don't have the words to verbalise what the music made me feel, but Marco put it so splendidly. I 'm really looking forward to seeing how it all plays out in Natlan and Snezhnaya.

It is assumed that the House was raised so that there would be a fight to the death, and the one left standing would be "King." Peruere resented that, and so became the "Father."

@bookswithike3256

2 ай бұрын

It's more that she's rejecting being a "Mother" because Crucabena displayed this outward appearance of loving and caring for her children, but was actually extremely cruel. Peruere is the opposite - she's strict and cold on the outside, but truly deeply cares for her children.

@MaximumCarnage-

2 ай бұрын

@@bookswithike3256 This

@claidheamhsoluis3044

2 ай бұрын

But I have played a secret side quest regarding a friendly Cicin Mage working undercover as a shrine maiden in Mt. Yougou, where they say Arlecchino sends killers to deserters like that friendly Cicin Mage...

@mrminecraftcubeable

2 ай бұрын

@@claidheamhsoluis3044 wasn't she talking about the previous administrator of the house ?

@worm2976

2 ай бұрын

I agree with you. There is a core of cruelty to what Arle is doing (whether out of duty or otherwise) including raising children into mini intelligence agents and fatui operatives, ready to lay down their lives for "Father". This coexists with the fact that she does care for her children. Like her vengeance in the recent character teaser.​It is a twisted sort of affection and protectiveness. but it's there. The two truths coexist. @@claidheamhsoluis3044

Oh btw the "Mother's" name is Crucabena, Gallic equivalent of the Welsh enchantress Ceridwen.

Hi Marco! It's been awhile since i commented in one of your video! You pretty much nailed almost everything. I'd like to answer some of your questions. As to why Arlecchino seems to 'betray' her friend is stated at the beginning of the short animation: House of the Hearth under previous Knave was a kin to a battle royale for the kids she took. It seems to me only 'the strongest' is worthy in Mother's eyes. - Mother seems to be portryaed as this soft and caring parent while as Arlecchino grew older it became apparent Mother is cruel. - Clairve is Mother's biological daughter. This was made clear in JP/CN language when Arlecchino asked her friend about 'do mother argue with their daughter?' - Clairve was wearing Lumidouce bell flower pendant. Which in Fontaine represent parting and hope for reunion. - Mother mentioned how she 'should have pruned the flower sooner' indicating she should've 'eliminated' her own daughter bcs she was 'kind' and 'innocent'. Calling it traits that are useless. I'm assuming Clairve hated the idea of fighting Arlecchino and i don't think she had the intetion to do so. I personally think Clairve sacrifice herself to make Arlecchino a 'King'. When they showed Arlecchino and Clairve toether there's this lyrics about 'not chained by fate'. I think Clairve believed in Arlecchino to change House of the Hearth for the better.

@wienzard36

2 ай бұрын

Which explains why Arlecchino told kids she will be 'strict and unfeeling' Father. From Arlecchino trailer in Livestream, it seems to me the battle that will take place was only for Lyney, Lynette and Freminet against herself. This in itself is already different than the battle royale which previous Knave held. Other children raised under Arlecchino's House of Hearth became foot soldiers for the Fatui, is it good? No. But at least they have a resemblance of 'family'.

4:47 the prediction at the exact instant lol

The music for this video is honestly godlike. It really elevates everything to another level

I really liked your whole analysis at 3:07 it was wonderful! I am always able to appreciate Genshin's music just as much and even more every time I watch your videos!

Loved your breakdown! This trailer was awesome, there were so many cool details, and the music was great! The music and Pierro's voice when she got appointed as a Harbinger gave me chills when I first watched it.

love seeing you excited at the end of Hoyo's video 💜

Amazing breakdown like always. I can't stop listening to this song on spotify. I really love how songs adds to the emotions we feel. I had chills the whole time. Truly beautiful!

I luv how u explain the music segments and how it enhanced the story-telling in the video ❤

And I’m pretty sure we’re also getting an Arlecchino Character Teaser tonight! Hoyo really loves Arle!

@benafleck7310

2 ай бұрын

idk why they made her mid with that BOL thing no hate no nothing i saved 150 wishes for her its just idk what happened

@ugotnojams6945

2 ай бұрын

​@@benafleck7310it's part of her lore. The curse on her hand really lined up with her kit. Also I think her kit is pretty good. Not op like neuvi but definitely enjoyable.

@PhuongHoang-cj9jz

2 ай бұрын

​@@benafleck7310Furina was said to be mid before she got released too, while Xianyun was shafted on hard. Neuvi was "worse" than Childe cos low hydro application. Wait for her officially before judging ya.

@I.disagree

2 ай бұрын

​@@PhuongHoang-cj9jzIf a character doesnt powercreep another character, people call them mid, it's inevitable. Although some people also called neuvillette mid or bad without c1 pre-release

@PhuongHoang-cj9jz

2 ай бұрын

@@I.disagree yeah, this game is super casual and noncompetitve anyway. As long as a character has good gameplay and is stylish then it's a good character. I couldn't care less about number.

I'm always so fascinated by how well u are reading through songs like this, damn

Great video as always Marco

Is really cool Marcos work, sometimes we are having so much feelings listening the music, but by dont undertanding the tecnical part we can't describe, and Marco explain for us, im the end i completely understand my feelings about the music and start vibing much more

5:09 pretty sure she offed herself the shot right before is kind of a common way to depict that in anime and manga without fully showing it, and we dont see her hands so she is likely holding the sword hilt.

thank you Marco for doing this for us. Your thoughts and opinion is very interesting to watch

I'm not the best at discerning lyrics in choral music, but I'm pretty sure that when the children's choir starts singing, it's in Latin, which adds another layer of power to that part of the music.

I love your videos Marco! I am such a fan of Hoyoverse’s music and animations, and always look forward to it. But every time a new video gets released, I know that you will always cover it. Watching your videos gave more depth in the music choice and let me appreciate the music more. I think some viewers also share similar sentiments, and we hope that you keep up the quality of your content! ❤

@MarcoMeatball

2 ай бұрын

Happy to hear that!

I find it really interesting that in the moment the mother says "let your mother guide you and become the one true king" the lyrics of the music land on "I wont be tainted by fate"

I like while the mother used love and care to manipulate and use them as a tool Arlecchino chooses to be strict instead because she cares and wants the children to be able to withstand and fight the injustices of the world

I have no formal music training but I love listening to your analysis

Never knew a god damn nursery rhyme esque song would go so well with a fight scene

There are two groups that are marketed very heavily, The Harbingers and The Archons(except the early archons sadly..with time their production quality is increasing thus making it seem like the new harbingers and archons are more important than the older ones..except Morax and Venti know the most about Teyvat's history, so they will be much more relevant than some of the new ones).

@apoorvjoshi2383

2 ай бұрын

P.S. if u notice all archons have mostly support and subdps traits while all harbingers are main dps with no off-field support trait. Its almost like the harbingers are meant to be the protagonists that will fight the war while archons support them from behind

@aichisendou6375

Ай бұрын

@@apoorvjoshi2383 support and subdps, but they are still the major player to the team, bringing some of the most unique and busted skillset, or in case of Furina, highly versatile and fulfill 2 extremely different support spectrum with ease. i feel like this is an important aspect to them too

Marco doing the cat "huh" meme sound really caught me off guard. Great analysis! Personally that part of the trailer (blwoing up the building and the music going sky high) really gave me chills.

11:54 it seems she makes the kids refer to her as “Father” to distance herself from her “Mother”…it’s like when someone as an adult refers to their abusive parents by their first name, instead of mom or dad to distance themselves from them…

I was excited to see your reactuon to this the second this video was announced

Just as always, i absolutely loved your video! 🧡 As for protagonist-not antagonist, the point is that antagonists are protagonists whose stories weren't explained. Something bad is not born, it's created. And there aren't true evil characters in genshin (well, bar Dottore, he is his own warning). Its all gray area.. and after Fontaine, Celestia has a lot to answer for too. I personally think that eventually we (as protagonist) will end up siding with the fatui and abyss. Just.. feels like everything is coming down to it, given how steadily dark Genshin gets with every step By the way, from the scene where Arch friend is impaled on her sword, i think its more like the friend impaled herself. If you look carefully, you would notice that Arch wasn't even holding the blade and was shocked. And.. if so, its all so f$cked up 😢 we are truly coming down to honkai, eh?

@bookswithike3256

2 ай бұрын

To side with the Fatui and Abyss is an interesting thing to say, because the one thing we know for sure about the Fatui is that they are actively fighting against the Abyss. I mean it's possible we'll have to bring every faction together to oppose Celestia, but at the moment the Fatui consider themselves enemies of the Abyss.

@barti560

2 ай бұрын

@@bookswithike3256 do they, truly?.. though, i think there are much more to the abyss that we know. I mean, there's the hex circle of the mages, then fallen Khaenrians that assumingly formed the abyss order.. and maybe some more. The same situation might apply to celestia (would be rather ironic if they are fighting each other up there). But yeah, in the face of common enemy that is simply too strong to beat alone they will simply gang up together, destroy celestia likely and only then will go on solving their issues. That's rather common politically wise even in our world. Everyone always ganged up on a strong enemy, before going for each others throats 😅 n$zi Germany would be a good example about what happens when you acquire a little to many enemies to the point that even with issues between each other everyone damn ganged up on bastards because they have had enough of their cruelty Ah well, only time will tell

always love your analysis on music, also your character Dvorak makes a return soon.

The song was sang for curleyg they just did’t add on it “Hoyo-Mix” was muzic officals only😢

When I heard this I couldn't help but think of An American Tale when she pushed open the window. The notes were made me think of "Somewhere Out There".

happy/hopeful music when things get dark really tugs at the heart strings - even more so when it's not dark yet but you know it's going to end up so

a little detail as well that I'm not sure if you noticed, but when the blades first clash as Arlecchino jumps at mother, you can hear a variation on the Fatui Harbinger motif played on strings I think (motif? theme? not sure of the right word but the notes are lower here, in la signora's theme they're sung by male voices in an opera style) that can be heard in every other fatui boss's theme

The wide eyes when Crucabena hits the ceiling just got me. XD Mostly he's concentrating, then just like a silent *whoa*

"the house of hearth is place of safety" Marco says it while the caption says "you will defeat all your brothers and sisters to become King" I know he was talking about music theme but damn this both funny and odd timing Also in the Snezhnaya scene it was Jester (in the middle) not Arlecchino. Jester is the first in command/leader and he delivers Tsaritsa (Cryo Archon) order and "promotion" of NEW Arrlecchino (Knave) since previous one got killed. New Arlecchino decided to become "Father" instead of "Mother" since she didn't want to do the same as "Mother" aka give kids false warmth, happiness, etc. and then just betray them, force them into that bloody battle royale, etc. just like what had to experience. Better to be strict emotionless "father" (that actually cares about kids but don't want to show them) than fake nice "mother"

@eliolink4053

2 ай бұрын

He just mistaken signora behind with arlecchino but he realized it and rectified a second later

Thank you for another amazing video! It's honestly fascinating how you can predict what's gonna happen to characters just from music alone... 13:32 you said "Tsaritsa" like a native speaker, it threw me off a bit 😅

To add to all this brilliant musical analysis on a more visual aspect, notice how the cross is a constant re-occurance throughout the whole animation. At the start with the spider funeral, but all through the fight too with multiple crossing swords and after effects. This quite obviously references to divine self-sacrifice to cleanse sins, but it's also what is used to mark a target. Notice how the Dottore rabbit-vampire has one. Oh Peruere has a bone to pick with him, I'm pretty sure. And she probably won't hesitate to sacrifice herself when the time comes.

watching this while focusing mostly on the music really hit a note that it didn't on first watch. Can't help but fight back tears. Dang.

Marco!!!! They already uploaded the song to Spotify!!!!!!!

At this pont marco able to decipher all future genshin story just by music itself 😂

Props to Arle for keeping the same Hairstyle since she was a kid, til now when she's an adult.

@nobblkpraetorian5623

2 ай бұрын

She has long hair now though.

That was amazing love seeing how you doing your videos. BTW you should react to PGR Moonlit Occultation, it would guarantee blow your mind

almost at 300k WE MOVIN

The fact, yet again, that Marco predicted 2 seconds in advance of what was about to happen stunned me. 😀 But hearing the connotation behind the notes which can tell a far deeper story than words sometimes can is impressive. Man, wish music lessons in school were as good as Marco's analytical deduction. 🎹

''obviously this friend of hers is gonna die tragi- '' hoyo didnt even give marco time to finish his sentence HAHAHA hoyo: sayless i gotchu

This man woke up when making this video

its soo exciting to be this early

Waiting for you to listen to "emberfire", after checking the lyrics it feels like it's was sing by Arlecchino's friend. So beautiful and so meaningful

I'm die. Thank you forever

Hey Marko, i just stumpled upon: 【超学生】Innocent Tyrant It completely flashed me and i never heard this kind of vocals EVER before

Hi Marco. Splendid reaction. Very want to see your view of future Arlecchino boss theme. Best Regards.

@MarcoMeatball

2 ай бұрын

Very soon ❤️

An additional visual note many don't seem to remark on: Before Clerve threw herself on Arle's sword(?), the scene was of her describing Schneznya as a place where 'The sky dances with colors', and when she suggests going there together, she has almost the same shocked expression as she does when the Tsaritsa's ice crystal draws her eye back out the window, to the aurora borealis. To the hope she once had, and the... If not innocence, the ability to still appreciate the world to some extent. That, despite the way her steeling herself to the depressing extent that she did, she can still be caught off guard by the beauty in the world. And most tellingly; The Tsaritsa's ice led her to that renewed faith, effectively hinting that Arle would come to replace her faith and care for her best friend to similar sentiments towards the Tsaritsa.

For reference, the woman is Crucabena, the previous Knave, the harbinger in charge of the House of the Hearth, the recruitment/indoctrination wing of the Fatui in Fontaine. Crucabena's MO seemed to be fake motherly love, manipulating the orphans using it. As the new Knave, Peruere is also now in charge of the house. Rather than pretending to be doting to manipulate the children, she pretends to be unloving and cold. It's hard to tell just how much of it is a facade, but she definitely has love and emotion in her voice when at the grave of one of the deceased orphans during her character teaser

When you were talking about the house of the hearth being all warm and welcoming etc you completely missed the part where it said they'd be forced to fight against each other until one's left standing to become king lol

@MarcoMeatball

2 ай бұрын

Oh well

i have some opinion that in 7:53 , i feel the choir is represent the fight,, like, the back choir is mother, and the the lead vocal is arlechino (alone), fighting. and in 8:10 , arlechino is like trying to fightback but the "pham pham pham chan chan chan" thing before it go silent is showing us that mother is so strong and going to throw, and defeat her., and then after the motivation scene (tye flower), precisely at 9:36 the choir is changed to the childrens, after remembering her best friend, her brother and sisters, like whom she fight for is giving her power, is, just freaking amazing. sori for bad english 🙇

I'm so happy because Dvorak is back!

A “Father” is born I love learning more about her story ❤🤍

i know nothing about genshin and this is amazing story telling

If you didn't know the official song without the animation also came out on the hoyomix chanel

15:05 I’d say it goes for the harbingers, and also the archons, in my opinion. Generally the characters that are most important to the main story, which is pretty much harbingers and archons

9:38 for me the choir of little kids is like all her orphan siblings who died

Yeah, I wish I lived in the House of the Hearth, it looks so warm and cozy. Surely I'll be safe there.

can't wait react to the song (Emberfire) and lyrics.

Just to let you know because you missed at the start of the video: The kids needs to fight each other to become the 'king', in other words, being the new 'mother' of them all. And that's why Arle needed to fight her best friend. She needed to, because just one child would survive. The reason why her friend did not answer her at the window scene, is because of escapism, hoping for a world that she knows at the botton of her heart that will never happen. Then, at the end, the 'mother' regretting not letting Arle get killed earlier. But if you think about it, it's not entirely true, since she was kinda made at this position, to continue this position, to find another one to take her place, even stronger than her. After all, she is a harbinger. Proving that Arle was worth more than the older harbinger, Tsarita accepted her as the new one, but Arle hated the nickname 'mother', because of the genocide that she needed to do, that's why she called herself 'father' from now on, to not let everything happen again. But since she became so 'dark' inside after all of these scenes, the real question is: Did she really became different, or isn't she just doing what the former harbinger desired her for?

@velicaleon

2 ай бұрын

One thought I have is whether Crucabena was regretting Arle not getting killed earlier... ... Or, I find more likely, she was referring to Clervie (her own daughter!), who by that point has 'wilted' (Arle meanwhile is alive and well). This would also explain Arlecchino immediately attacking and her angry face, and that Clervie and Crucabena weren't in good terms was also foreshadowed through the former's injuries (the window scene).

Hoyo outdone themselves this time as well, glad they’re jumping into making animated pieces for characters at last

Something I find odd is how the Previous Knave doesn’t follow the trend seen with the Harbingers, as her name, Crucabena, isn’t from Commedia Dell’Arte. There’s probably not a deeper reason behind it other than her no longer being a harbinger during the events of the game, but u still find it a bit strange.

its scary how you can guess the whole story by listening to music purely

and yet the anime is yet to even be announced

Wait to listening to Arlechinno's theme, you are going to go NUTS

it's interesting, spotting the difference between og house of hearth leader and arle. peruere was essentially raised by a "caring" mother, only for that same person to turn out to be extremely cold and uncaring, even abusive, to the children under her care [clerve for instance] -- so in turn she strives to be this strict, unfeeling father while still retaining this vast amount of care for her children. it makes it seem like she doesn't wish to become like her predecessor, which makes things interesting since we know three of her children will be fighting her this upcoming update -- possibly even becoming the "king" in her place

Marco, can you check out Arknight's recently introduced IS4's ost? There's such song as "Evoke" AKA Battle02, involving mongolian throat singing and im really curious about your opinion.

„Mother“- caring on the outside, uncaring on the inside „Father“ - uncaring on the outside, caring on the inside

I think melody at start of fight with mother sounds like fatui theme from rosaline funeral video

Actually since Signora's battle theme, Harbingers are considered as the tragic heroes of their own story. My guess is that in the end game, we join force with them before going to Celestia.

Marco, you have to do the reaction video for her boss music ❤️‍🔥

@MarcoMeatball

2 ай бұрын

It’s not out yet officially

I'd also like to think that the chrous after she gets up is all the other children urging her on

now i waiting you to do the sing or reaction for Arlecchino theme boss phase i and phase 2 XD

One thing to note is that I think the Lumidouce Bells represent the dead children of the hearth and the child chorus all the souls of her siblings cheering for the death of the "mother."

It would be awesome if you could find time to have a collab discussion with some of the lore theorist analyst content creators. Your insight into what music tries to convey could be interesting in contrast to what cold-calculated lore we already have outside of the current cinematic. I would be interested in what sort of conclusion you could make.

Might as well review Emberfire(the full ost)

@MarcoMeatball

2 ай бұрын

Nah but it’s pretty

@_.Kaprine._

2 ай бұрын

@@MarcoMeatball okay 😭

5:56 "I should have pruned this flower long ago... how grotesque." I think Mother is trying to say the other children are the wilted flowers that should have been cut long ago... 9:11 We see the wilted flower surrounded by young blooming flowers, I get the feeling that it is guarding them with all it's might against the crumbling infrastructure. Any stray brick could crush all of them but it is burning its life away to protect them. This is Arlechno, A grotesque wilted thing doing all it can to protect all that is beautiful around it. EDIT: We have seen this story played out over and over with Mihoyo. Someone fighting for what is beautiful against all odds. We have seen these characters time and time again sacrifice themselves for others. Kiana, Mei, Fu Hua, Elisia. We have seen this story play out and we know they DON'T need to sacrifice themselves, but is that the case With Arlechino? Can she or someone else break the curse?

I'm just now noticing the choir at 5:41 has this epic/ominous vibe kinda reminiscent of Overture of Storms which is the one thing that absolutely hooked me into the game for good. I went into this game thinking "Ah, another chinese game, probably trash as all Chinese mobile games tend to be" and boy, was I blown away and was I happy to be wrong. That intro and specially Overture of Storms single-handedly sold me the idea that "This is a high quality production you're playing, we're kinda serious here."

The first 20 seconds got me giggling to myself XD

7:18 "Perusea" lol, the Ace Combat brainrot is real