I would say that in Spain we are complete aware of our muslim and Arab influence. And I say more... we are proud of it! If you ask a Spaniard "where it comes Spanish culture from?" MOST probable the answer will be "roman, Gothic, muslim and Christian", no one will skip those 800 centuries. BUT, maybe because christianity became very strong in the next centuries, the rest of the world see us as fanatical catholic. It is the rest of the world who is unaware of this. Not us españoles.

@uptown_rider8078

Жыл бұрын

Spain doesn’t have any Muslim or Arab influence

@uptown_rider8078

Жыл бұрын

@Shallala No, it doesn’t. Spanish architecture has Gothic and Roman influence, there wasn’t any influence taken from muslims

@D_A-G

Жыл бұрын

Sorry bro, you don’t know what you’re talking about with all due respect. The Spanish educational system intentionally overlook and omit critical information from history to undermine the Islamic influence in Andalus and on the entire world. Thank you, Spanish Inquisition.

@uptown_rider8078

Жыл бұрын

@@D_A-G There’s nothing to “overlook” cause there isn’t any Islamic influence in Andalus, non in the present day lives of Spaniards anyways.

@MrGee-fp8gt

Жыл бұрын

@@D_A-G nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition

I'm Spanish and didn't realize that so many Spaniards deny arab influence in our history, arquitecture, cuisine, language and so on. I have always been proud of what muslims brought us. While Europe was living in the dark ages , a great culture flourished in Al-Andalus. All the knowledge from India and Persia from algebra to astronomy was brought here in that time. It's sad to see we've gone back to the dark ages.

@subservant6766

10 ай бұрын

Eghh yes we live in dark age and Arab who live in desert sourounded with camel brings us culture ... Yes thanks Arab .... Arab from middle east who never now what happens around them they just start to be human after discovering oil by European,are proud now because they are iflunced Spain had a big culture debat with us .... How is this possible???? Someone from no where no culture nothing in history beeing the one who bring us architecture cuisine ..... ??? !!!

@Isabel-belsai

10 ай бұрын

@@subservant6766 I'm afraid you seem to be much more ignorant that camels, at least they can find water right in the middle of the desert.

@LevisH21

10 ай бұрын

give me a break with the "Dark Ages" myth already. of course Europe just like any other civilization in human history had a decline at some point. this happened because of constant wars. there was no time for innovation of scientific progress. and besides, Europe was not allowed to innovate because of outside influence and oppression from the Arabs and later on the Ottoman Empire. my country of Romania and any other Balkan Peninsula countries were opreseed and lived in the Dark Ages because of the colonialism and oppression from the Ottoman Empire. and that oppression lasted for 500+ years.

@RedRose-cn8ln

9 ай бұрын

@@subservant6766 Yes, the Arabs brought you civilization such as science, cleanliness and architectural construction during the golden age of Islam. And the Arabs have a long history, such as the Rightly Guided Caliphate, the Umayyad Caliphate, and the Abbasid Caliphate, where the city of Baghdad and the city of Damascus were beacons of civilization and science, and the Arabic language was the language of science for many centuries. If you are ignorant, go and learn before you speak.

@subservant6766

9 ай бұрын

@@RedRose-cn8ln Islam doesn't mean Arab... All Islam civilization are outside Arab peninsula,,,,you mean ppl speak Arabic not Arab + Turkish Persian Kurd Berber....you can't brought civilization when you're are not civilized until 1960.

Salamo Alaikom, I grow up in Morocco and my father side Familly are Andalouse! The most of Muslim from Andalouse exil to North Africa specially Morocco where they build many cities like chafchaoune, Rabat and other also they moved to Italy etc. If you visit Fez or you travel to north of Morocco you can see this culture and people of andalouse. Some families in Morocco they still keeping the key of there house they had in andalouse … Salam 🏇🏼🕊🇲🇦🌴

@klmsps5576

8 ай бұрын

Thank you for sharing this with us! I have noticed some people in Morocco look white and some are mixed with black. When did people start mixing together, because traditionally whites and blacks don't mix together. I have heard that black soldiers from Africa that came with the French and British armies in North Africa used to rape many white women. Is this the real origin of race mixing in Morocco?

@ummunour1118

8 ай бұрын

Alaikum salaam, I did not know this about the keys Subhanallah. Are there any places in Morocco I can visit where I can learn more about Andalucia?

@afrobian1

7 ай бұрын

They didn’t build Rabat. It was already an established city in its own. But true they did build chaouen and tetwan even

@mohammedmgarta269

4 ай бұрын

non sense Andalousian Moresque never built Rabat it was built by its native people Amazigh dinasty Almoouahidin , Morocco is Amazigh country built by its Amazigh warriors , Moresque built some small towns in north where they took refuge from Christians in spain and brought their own culture which is still known to b andalous not Moroccan they are distiguished community in Morocco and everbody knows that but Empire of Morocco was great and was built by its own native people AMAZIGH AlMorabitin AlMoouahidin ect .

@commontouch1787

4 ай бұрын

@@ummunour1118Tangier

My grandmother was born in Puerto Rico of Spanish decent. When the Americans invaded they eventually gave Puerto Ricans US citizenship but they had to swear allegiance. My grandmother refused. She swore she would never even speak the language. I will always remember her with pride. She was a tough old lady.

@krono5el

7 ай бұрын

the Spirit of Galverino or Hatuey, thats awesome because the eruopeans are horrible.

@mariad.a.842

7 ай бұрын

Tu abuela sabía quien era. Eso es todo.

@emmanuelfernandez5528

7 ай бұрын

But didn't the spaniards conquered, invaded PR and destroyed the Taino popupulation? The US didn't invade PR, Spain gave up PR as part of their loss to the US when they want to war.

@kitty16vcat11

7 ай бұрын

The older generations had principles and stuck to it no matter the costs! 💪🏼 May your granny rest in peace! ❤

@phaze_shift_pr

7 ай бұрын

​@@emmanuelfernandez55281) the Tainos weren't completely eradicated many Puerto Ricans to this day have genetic roots to the indigenous. Though it seems there's an concerted effort to minimize our water that down as the US postures to take the island as a state. 2) the Spanish American war was a essentially a land grab by force. The initial desire was to take Cuba from Spain for its sugar commodity. However, Cuba was able to declare its independence before the war so US had to honor their sovereignty. PR was not so lucky as General Miles landed his troops in Guanica on July 25, 1898. There's plenty of of information documenting this fact.

So much respect for you and this video.. so my family is Catholic from Philippines, we have descendants from Spain from my dad’s grandfather’s side. Never thought much of it. Until I searched up Andalusia, or Al-Andalus. I also recently reverted to Islam Mashallah which made me want to dig more. I was mind blown when you mentioned that olives were cultivated in that area by the Muslim community. Our surname is Olivas, deriving from olives…. And another of our family is Sevilla, which is derived from Seville in Andalusia. This just unlocked a lot of things I never thought of about our family’s history and heritage. Definitely sharing this with them! 🙏🏾✨♥️

@ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273

8 ай бұрын

Philippines..? Sulu Sultanate

@PVPTawa

8 ай бұрын

Olives were in Iberia long before this Muslim invasion.

Most of this applies to Portuguese too. As a Brazilian, I know that we have many words in our Brazilian Portuguese that came from Arabic, and I learned more about it from my Lebanese friends here. Beside the names, there are also many surnames in South America that were derived from Arabic, such as the last name of my uncles "Medina", which is an Arabic word that means "The Luminous City", which also refers to one of the most holy Muslim cities in the Arabian Peninsula.

@MahmoudAlJammal

9 ай бұрын

The word Portugal itself is derived from the Arab word "برتقال" pronounced "Burtuqal", that is "Orange" fruit.

@Hmm-oc1wg

9 ай бұрын

@@MahmoudAlJammal The word Portugal derives from the combined Roman-Celtic place name Portus Cale; a settlement where present-day's conurbation of Porto and Vila Nova de Gaia (or simply, Gaia) stand, along the banks of River Douro in the north of what is now Portugal.

@MahmoudAlJammal

9 ай бұрын

@@Hmm-oc1wg Yeah, right!!! I was once told that "Fatima" is a Spanish saint name, so no doubt you can always find an abracadabra alternative of any story. It's called "cultural cleansing", and, like it or not, it happened in the Iberian peninsula more than any place on earth. Anyways... Thank you for your informative reply.

@Hmm-oc1wg

9 ай бұрын

@@MahmoudAlJammal This is in Arabic "برتقال" and when you say burtuqāla it is from Latin Script and letters that Arabs use from Latin. Spain/Portugal has most from the Romans and their Latin Scrip and letters and language.

@MahmoudAlJammal

9 ай бұрын

@@Hmm-oc1wg "Letters that Arabs use are from Latin"!!!!! Arabs created the Alphabetical order, it was Ugarite alphabet of Latakia the first in the entire world, Arabs also created the very same numbers you use until today ... What kind of weed have you been smoking dude?!!!! Man, you went waaay too far, it's the craziest thing I ever heard in my entire life... Wow, people like you do exist in real life!! FYI: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ugaritic_alphabet

A real pleasure to have found this magnificent video on the historical subject of Islam in Spain, I am a Lebanese descendant. And a new Mexican fan, from Guadalajara

@robertvazquez2964

9 ай бұрын

Even me as a Latin American from the US I have learned much about this time of history in Spain and it’s interesting the influence Islamic culture left on our culture. Well today we have Shakira and we are very proud to have her enriching our culture with her music and beauty!

@republitarian484

9 ай бұрын

A real pleasure to have found this magnificent video on the historical subject of Christianity in the New World. I am of German descent and my ancestors never colonized any land in North America nor owned slaves but for some reason ALL white people are being portrayed as white devils.

@abubarakah2981

9 ай бұрын

Did you know Guadalajara is from arabic as well?

@abubarakah2981

9 ай бұрын

وادي الحجارة Wādi al hijārah Meaning valley of stones

@rashakor

7 ай бұрын

@@abubarakah2981and the river which runs through it (the Spanish city! Not the new Mexican one)! The Guadalquivir.

One of the most comprehensible videos I have seen, to this startling, confusion time epoch. Quito-Ecuador 🇪🇨❤️

I am from Mexico and all this information blew my mind, they never taught us this in schools when they really should have.

@WingsxFreedom

3 ай бұрын

Apparently we're more than Mexicas and Tainos

Thank you for this. I have shared this history for years with anyone who would listen. I am appreciate your ability for taking it further than I.

This guy brings history pieces that are not in other channels on similar contents. Keep it up and we appreciate your work.

@christopher9727

9 ай бұрын

God created the world in six days He can also save you from hell and have a personal relationship with him today He can give you his Holy Spirit to guide and teach and comfort you today Romans 6:23 For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord. Come to Jesus Christ today Jesus Christ is only way to heaven Repent and follow him today seek his heart Jesus Christ can fill the emptiness he can fill the void Heaven and hell is real cone to the loving savior today Today is the day of salvation tomorrow might be to late come to the loving savior today John 3:16-21 16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 17 For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved. 18 He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God. 19 And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. 20 For every one that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved. 21 But he that doeth truth cometh to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God. Mark 1.15 15 And saying, The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand: repent ye, and believe the gospel. 2 Peter 3:9 The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance. Hebrews 11:6 6 But without faith it is impossible to please him: for he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him. Jesus

@ikman3410

7 ай бұрын

@saewha Information super star, enlighten us then.

@missylearned9821

6 ай бұрын

I think anyone who can read history, knows about the Muslim influence and rule of Spain. Those same people also know that historically there was actually little genetic imprint on the native Iberian population since the natives rarely mingled/married (thus, did not convert) with the Muslims. This is reflected in modern DNA studies which show

@ikman3410

6 ай бұрын

@@missylearned9821Spanish capital is built by the Muslims. Spain was at the top of the world and now a bankrupt country. Good job.

@egutiguti3337

2 ай бұрын

@@missylearned9821no tanto como se pretende que creamos. Arquitectura si, en Andalucía, se olvidan de la principal románica y gótica, gastronomía….. es muy discutible, el gazpacho lo trajeron las legiones romanas, la curación del jamón del cerdo ibérico, la vid, etc. tiene mucha más influencia ibérica y romana, la lengua… 4.000 palabras, en un idioma de 88.000….. más bien son extranjerismos. Este vídeo está muy sesgado e intencionadamente destacando todo lo árabe, más de lo que es en realidad.

Brother. I have literally binged watched all your videos! Please make more content . Your are appreciated. Barakallah

Hello Omar, one last comment. I wouldnt say that the Islamic heritage of Spain is something purposely hidden or unknown. The period and its heritage is not only taught in schools at different levels of educations and to different extents, but its a daily presence in quite a bit of the Spanish geography and daily life. The architectural heritage of a lot of cities, the cooking, as you very well mentioned, a lot of our vocabulary... Some of our biggest touristic places and UNESCO heritage sites are of muslim heritage (Alhambra, Cordoba's mosque-cathedral...). The presence is very much noted. Undoubtfully, a lot of Spaniards live their daily lifes giving very little or no thought to this topic, their more earthly worries take most of their mental space; but within the more educated elements of Spanish society this is very much something taken into account when talking, thinking, or discussing national matters. Politically speaking this happens to, both the groups that like and value this heritage and those who try to diminish it or deby have to deal with it, its an undeniable fact. Basically, those 700 years are accepted as fact, as something that is very much part of the Spanish identity, wether there are ideological positions that like it or not.

@delgadogarces

7 ай бұрын

I agree that the Islamic heritage of Spain is purposely hidden. I have asked educated Spaniards about the Islamic contributions to the region and never get an answer!!! Most likely not taught in grade school or high school, I am guessing!

@RGBAnarchy

7 ай бұрын

yeah exactly its right in your face everyday in those places of influences, architecture, some types of folk music, and not to mention una fiesta dedicated to that whole era : ). thou i can imagine a Spanish person living far away from that zone has no clue about it.

@elingrome5853

7 ай бұрын

Weird, in my experience the Spaniards are well aware of the cultural and linguistic impact of the Moors... seems like a bit of a strawman to me...

@TheKingofTheUniverse.

5 ай бұрын

Islamophobia in Spain is real. It's a shame if their ancestor "Muslim" back then.

@malvarez8484

4 ай бұрын

When you make these affirmations you should say Andalucía not Spain. North of Andalucía the Muslim influence drops dramatically. To say Spanish culture comes from Islam is nuts.

This documentary is very awakening. I happened to visit Malaga to gather evidences of Islamic remnants and relics there. I found Alcazava, GilAlfaro, the oldest Muslim market there, the mosques which were converted to churches, Islamic bath house, and many more interesting archaic artifacts made by Muslims.

@brokenarrow5590

10 ай бұрын

Invaders are kick out and what to do with their places?

@aimanalmouallem2297

10 ай бұрын

Alandslus is considered by Arabs , as paradise on earth

@picatu2667

10 ай бұрын

Why this content creator talked about the good deeds of Muslim in Spain? Catholic church fthrs of spain are finding his location!!

@no-cov-jabpureblood4959

10 ай бұрын

Those regions were ORIGINALLY christian, then taken, then won back.

@no-cov-jabpureblood4959

10 ай бұрын

A partial truth is simply a LIE.

I am of Spanish descent. My father was Spanish and my mother was Asian. I remember my father telling me that we have Arab blood through my great grandfather from my grandfather’s side. While my grandmother left us with quite a number of her things with many Islamic designs/decorations. I only met her twice when I was a toddler and then she passed. She had many photos of her in Andalucía. I decided to go there in 2018 to visit and Córdoba and Granada as well. It is obvious that there was Islamic influence there and was also told of the history of Al-Andaluz when we went to the former palace. Having mentioned about my father, my surname perhaps has it’s origin from the Arabs from my great grandfather’s side which is Azad/Azada, which is Spanish for hoe that farmer’s use?

@jubanumidia8460

9 ай бұрын

Azad looks persian

@sergioponce7464

9 ай бұрын

Yout father didn't know what he was talking about.

@Surayahti

9 ай бұрын

Could be Asad (Lion)... Also Could be derived form the great Arab tribe Azd.

@achraf2095

9 ай бұрын

@@sergioponce7464 como te pica la verdad eh primo?

@sergioponce7464

9 ай бұрын

@@achraf2095 infórmate sobre el tema, la historia verdadera y los estudios genéticos que se han hecho sobre la genética de los españoles, que hoy en día es muy fácil con internet.

The Iberian Penisula was not Spain at that time. Spain or what was to become Spain did not exist. The Catholic northern region by Asturias was the genesis of Spain. These people after realizing that the moors were traveling north with the intent to take over large portions of Europe, decided to confront them and eventually defeated them, taking over their vast stronghold, and with it, all that they had built there. This is similar to what happened in the US with the westward expansion and their wars won against Mexico, where lands were taken but cities and towns remain to this day with heavy Mexican/Spanish characteristics, names and architecture.

It is great brother , I am from Afghanistan I newly immigrated to Spain , I already had study about Islam in Andulusia and Grenada, you video increased more information Wish you all the best

@mohammedrashid2906

Жыл бұрын

Nice

@trinchuzosparty

10 ай бұрын

Bienvenido a España. Te deseo una gran estancia.

@hoosomio

10 күн бұрын

ESPAÑA tiene cultura árabe .pero sus raíces son romana cristianas

Great video brother! More people need to know this

Great job! Thank you for this amazing piece of content ❤

Excellent video! Brilliant, interesting, and scholarly comentary. Thank you for this.

Thank you brother, your make easy and understandable videos with amazing information and sources 🙏 and keep up the good work🔥🔥

@user-ei4ep6nt7v

10 ай бұрын

nobody called them the muslims they were the moors

@riazshaikh8108

10 ай бұрын

@@user-ei4ep6nt7vand what was their faith?

@user-ei4ep6nt7v

10 ай бұрын

@@riazshaikh8108 muslim

جزاك الله خير،هاذا المحتوى الذي يستحق المشاهده

Trying to explain this to Americans with Spanish heritage in a town called New Iberia in the US leaves them with their mouths open. I am lucky that i used Flamenco as a vehicle to connect to my heritage and studied the history as a child. I tried to bring this knowledge to my American neighbors but it’s hard for them to swallow sometimes. Thank you for sharing this interesting topic.

@skyleonidas9270

8 ай бұрын

Well, flamenco is only from one of the many regions of andalucia, I being from spain have never even seen flamenco

@snakey319

7 ай бұрын

we have good genes in southern Iberia.

@Jdekbws

7 ай бұрын

With KZread, it might be easier for you to send them videos to watch and learn!

@angelcamachodelsolar

7 ай бұрын

@@snakey319 yes, from northern Iberia.

@ferriscemila8912

7 ай бұрын

Thank you for doing that!

Your pronunciation of Arabic is actually impressive for a non-native speaker. I can confirm that it's legit. Also the history you spoke of is very accurate and well informing. I'm from Morocco btw, mad respect 😅👌

@D-E-S_8559

8 ай бұрын

Someday we will learn the true history of the LOST GENERATIONS of African, Moors and Muslims in Europe---when the Vatican eventually opens the miles of records hidden in the Vatican catacombs to the scholars.... A name to remember in history is Pope Urban the 2nd, he that gave us the terminology "urbanization" and was responsible for the creation of Crusades, Inquisitions and Black Death----the systemic institutions responsible for the eradication of generations of "infidels" from Europe; and the culmination of racism, colonialization and slavery in the years immediately following the fall of Al-Andalusia and Granada....

@afrobian1

7 ай бұрын

I think he’s Arab?

@stefanvermeer3209

7 ай бұрын

​@@afrobian1i think hes jew

@AliAli-uk9nh

7 ай бұрын

​@@stefanvermeer3209by his name Omar perhaps he is Muslim and maybe of Syrian or even Turkish origin. To me he looks Syrian

@Meryawey

7 ай бұрын

He missinform, tell half truths, lies, manipulations, to let the christians and us today as the evil ones while at the same time he romantize the muslims and andalusí period. It's not objective, he contradicts himself, and insult the spaniards with his ignorance.

That's a lot for sharing and for taking the effort to compile this informative and comprehensive piece. Looking forward to more, you've just got a new sub 👍

Incredible video thank you !

Thank you brother! Your effort is amazing.. Great job.

Absolutely refreshing to see and learn something about a topic I always wanted to learn. I am a Muslim, but I enjoy learning about how different cultures influence each other. I believe we need to embrace the truth how we have been influenced by other cultures. By doing so, we can come closer and respect each other. Love for all Hatred for none.

@republitarian484

9 ай бұрын

Now you can pay reparations to white Europeans for what your ancestors did to them. Or better yet. . . preach from the Mountain top about how white people aren't the devil that they are being made out to be.

@hectorlopez4365

9 ай бұрын

Tyh

@christopher9727

9 ай бұрын

. Jesus Christ is the only hope in this world no other gods will lead you to heaven There is no security or hope with out Jesus Christ in this world come and repent of all sins today Today is the day of salvation come to the loving savior Today repent and do not go to hell Come to Jesus Christ today Jesus Christ is only way to heaven Repent and follow him today seek his heart Jesus Christ can fill the emptiness he can fill the void Heaven and hell is real cone to the loving savior today Today is the day of salvation tomorrow might be to late come to the loving savior today Holy Spirit Can give you peace guidance and purpose and the Lord will John 3:16-21 16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 17 For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved. 18 He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God. 19 And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. 20 For every one that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved. 21 But he that doeth truth cometh to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God. Mark 1.15 15 And saying, The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand: repent ye, and believe the gospel. 2 Peter 3:9 The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance. Hebrews 11:6 6 But without faith it is impossible to please him: for he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him. Jesus

@Trancymind

7 ай бұрын

The harsh reality is that the muslims see non muslim culture as inferior and unimportant to them which is why other cultures see them as arrogant and aggressive reaction to non muslims.

@PabloSanchez-mo8ui

4 ай бұрын

well said

Thank you. It is a lovely documentary!

Great video! As a Hispanic revert I must say it was informative and very enjoyable. May ALLAH bless your. Amin

@ashirrehmat8096

10 ай бұрын

Muslims adopted every thing from Jews and Christians. They were there before Islam.

@deepb249

10 ай бұрын

?

@Conner.YorkshireRichmond

10 ай бұрын

Evangelicalism Christian is what you need,islam and catholic are not godly,islam will destroy spain and opposite to Hispanic culture

@dariomartinez459

10 ай бұрын

I am sorry for your delusion. Christianity is before islam so if anyone needs to " revert" It's most of the Maghrebi, Egyptian, Syrians etc. that need to revert to the Holy faith and away from the false prophet.

@Oreacts1

10 ай бұрын

@@dariomartinez459 The only delusional one is you! You worship a Trinity which is Polytheism. In other words Pagan. You don't follow Jesus pbuh, you actually follow Paul the liar, and follow a tampered book full of contradictions and mistakes my friend, you have allot to learn! I feel sorry for "your" delusion. Do some honest research and wake up my friend.

One of the most informative videos i have ever seen. Hats off to you for the amazing content and your above all your narration. Many Thanks 🙏👍

you have done a lot and explored Spain's history in detail because we are unaware of the fact that the richness of Islamic culture and politics contributed a lot to the rest of the world. Well done.

this video is an eye opener. Well done my friend! Subscribed!

@user-ei4ep6nt7v

10 ай бұрын

but nobody called them the muslims they were th Moors

Great video brother, ur editing made this easier to understand Jazakallah Khair for spreading knowledge

@user-ei4ep6nt7v

10 ай бұрын

nobody called them the muslims they were the moors

@achmad6962

10 ай бұрын

​​​@@user-ei4ep6nt7vand ? Muslim is their religious identity, "moors" is how the Spaniards used to call Muslims, they also call Muslims in the Philippines (Southeast Asia) as moors, or Bangsamoro which in the local language means Moor nation.

Thank you for this brilliant video!

It's not secret at all, it's openly talked about and taught in school. Spanish people generally know about the history and influence. I've been coming to Spain since 2005- that year I read a children's book written by a Spanish author which was about the history or the caliphate, reconquista, and as you say here it mentioned the people living together (though typically taxes were imposed on non-muslims). If you go to Granada it's talked about. When I started learning Spanish in the 90s we were told in class about words beginning with AL as having an Arabic origin. I think that perhaps this video is aimed at Americans, because in Spain the history is obvious.

@gigihNugroho-en2ku

5 ай бұрын

Well, its fair if non muslim have to paid taxes tho. Because muslim paid zakat and non muslim doesn't have to paid it. In the end the zakat was used for the kingdom to manage the country

@TheKingofTheUniverse.

5 ай бұрын

there are many excemption for non-Muslim taxes. And you pay taxes for protection and security for feel safe to practice your religion and live there while Muslim should pay zakat (obligation tax for Muslim) for needy people but there are not many excemption for paying Zakat. And Muslim obligated to go war for protect the region while non-Muslim is not obligated to do that by Muslim ruler. So non-Muslim have many adventages here. Even today you still pay taxes LoL.

I visited Granada in Spain recently. Still has a very “Muslim feel” especially around the Al-basin area. Al-hambra is just a place for tourists now but to think at one time Muslim Royalty spent time there only few 100 years ago!! Nice video bro.

@frenchartantiquesparis424

Жыл бұрын

A few 100 years ago....???? You mean 700 years ago.

@jojolafrite9265

Жыл бұрын

Les musulmans ont disparu de Grenade en 1492 c'était les derniers musulmans en Espagne, vous êtes au courant. Au minimum ça fait 400 ans , et pas 100 ans comme vous dites.

@jojolafrite9265

Жыл бұрын

@@aaa-qk1qi 531 annes 👍

@abdullahozek8016

Жыл бұрын

@@frenchartantiquesparis424 I have been informed that those Moors of Spain , the followers of Muhammed, the Messenger of Allah,The Revealer of the Book , The Scripture of the Glorious Qur'an also conquered half of France !! Hurray Hurray islam

@jojolafrite9265

11 ай бұрын

​@@abdullahozek8016 il n'y a eu jamais des maures d'Espagne. Les Maures viennent d'Afrique pas d'Europe

This is excellent content Mashallah! Knowledge, delivery, editing all on point 👌

I LOVED your video. As a Mexican living in Europe, I am fascinated by history and the origins of our culture today. Thank you so much for this succinct but very illustrative video. Hasta la vista, amigo!

@Stephen-lx9nm

9 ай бұрын

You're part arab😂

@republitarian484

9 ай бұрын

You're a descendant of Spanish Colonizers and should be held accountable for the sins of your ancestors and stop hiding behind Mexican or "Hispanic". Many white people, such as Polish Americans, never had ancestors that were colonizers or slave traders and yet they are being forced to atone for the sins of all white people.

@carlosm.3426

9 ай бұрын

@@Stephen-lx9nm No he isn't, you wish

@Trancymind

8 ай бұрын

If catholics lost to the muslims, Mexico wouldn't be a hispanic country.

This was brilliantly articulated.Thank you for putting this together. Just on this video I decided to subscribe to your channel. cheers!

Congratulations on such an outstanding video.

Masha Allah. Excellent work, brother. Really enjoyed the presentation. Looking forward for more.

@user-ei4ep6nt7v

10 ай бұрын

nobody called them the muslims they were the moors

@shiroumxm2052

2 ай бұрын

@@thatboyn0xyread any book from that era .. yes muslims were called moor even here in New Spain now called México. Some moors women were brought here long ago

Con todos mis respetos , España es un país con una cultura muy rica , y resumirlo a „orígenes musulmanes „ es propio de incultura o ineptitud involuntaria. El origen de España es su mezcla , de tartesos, Íberos, vascones, celtas , griegos , romanos , visigodos, suevos, árabes ,y el mestizaje con america que nos trajo tanto o más de lo que llevamos al otro lado del charco .

@globalist1990

7 ай бұрын

Muy bien! La mezcla.

@anneeq008

6 ай бұрын

Every country has minor and historically hidden civilisations and peoples. The Arabian peninsular for instance has Kurds, Jews, Chandalians, sand Arabs, Bedouins. But the most influential was the Arab one. It's the one that influences your language the second most, probably after Latin. And the secular scientific scholarship of the Arabs is what elevated Spain way more, with all due respect the Visigoths and the others did. And simply put, you guys don't respect the Arab culture. You always try and demean it. So although every culture has their place. This video is a channel with a Muslim focus. Just like the Muslim focus is forgotten and neglected in your culture. We like to remember it from this context. And it's not even an exaggeration. As it's an integral part of Spain's heritage in all the aforementioned ways

@globalist1990

6 ай бұрын

@@anneeq008 it's not forgotten, it simply happened a long time ago. The Visigoths gave us some important rules of law though, and before them we had the romans. But yeah, there's more to life than big civilisations and most of the people from Iberia has a very prevalent common Neolithic genetic marker. This means it was more of a cultural exchange than anything else. At the time, the moorish culture were more advanced in many aspects and even brought back certain classical elements from rome. After 1500, forget about it. Iberia was far more advanced than Arabs. How do you think it could be an influence then? Mate, we had the best ships (thank you for the triangular sails though), we were bringing new stuff no one had ever seen, we circumvent the moorish and Venetian control of trade with the east. No chance.

@roarsarch201

3 ай бұрын

@@globalist1990🤓

@yassir2824

2 ай бұрын

Lol just ignore the video then, makes sense 😂

I really enjoyed this video. Thank you so much for taking the time to make it.

I am from northern Spain, where Spanish was born and almost no traces of muslim or arabic culture, but celtic roots: traditions, music (pipes), etc.... It is funny to hear you arabs staying in Spain for over 800 centuries. That was like that only in Andalucía, not in the whole Spain. Also, having some specific words does not mean a high influence on the language. Spanish is a latin language with almost the same structure as French or Italian until the point they are mutually intelligible. The words you mention are also in the rest of the languages and are loans form other languages such as: Guitarra, algodón, azúcar (guitar, cotton, sugar,..) ... Toponims as Guadalajara are not reflected in the Spanish language. We don't say wada for water, but Agua (from Latin AQUA) also we have aceituna and aceite, but we have also oliva and óleo. Conquerors were adding some words (specially related with the agriculture and toponims) as they were recovering some lands down to the south but structure of Spanish wasn't touch by Arabic, actually is along with Sardinian and Italian, Spanish is the closest to Latin (you can find some studies) I find the video quite arabic-"biased" and with deep misunderstanding of Spanish culture. Of course there is an influence, specially in southern Spain, but not that big. I recommend you to watch some videos about Spanish language: kzread.info/dash/bejne/oaSVxKeHXZOrc7w.html You can also compare languages in linguistics.eu: Latin - Spanish: 26,1 These languages are closely related! Arabic - Spanish: 76,6 A possible remote relatedness between these languages is speculative (p-Value* = 0,049).

@martinlopez1184

10 ай бұрын

Brilliant post 👏👏

@jboss1073

10 ай бұрын

Good post. What people don't understand, due to lacking sufficient historical context, is that the Arabs only remained for 800 years in the "already highly civilized" parts of Iberia which were mainly the southern and eastern parts of Iberia. The central, northern and western regions of Iberia were highly underdeveloped and the agriculture mentioned in the video could not be easily brought and started there - the Arabs themselves said those lands were barren and not worth conquering, which is why they never attempted to conquer Asturias. This is never mentioned. The Arabs never saw the value in Iberian lands comprising about the top half of Iberia, which is why it was so quickly conquered back - within one generation from the start of their invasion. So most of Iberia was nowhere near having been controlled by the Arabs for 800 years - not even 50 years for most of the north. The Arabs themselves did not attempt to do that, and they themselves explain the reason why was the worthlessness of the northern Iberian territory.

@ra78100

10 ай бұрын

You’re absolutely right, the actual influence was in the south of Spain to some degree. The moors were kick out entirely by the Christians

@goodaimshield1115

10 ай бұрын

Andalucía? It was only in Granada Kingdom XD

@tyrrell0076

10 ай бұрын

por no decir que habla de que inventaron poco menos hasta el gazpacho y tortilla de patata cuando quedaban 700 años mas para que descubriéramos la patata y tomate... luego dice además que nos enseñaron a extraer y usar el aceite... los romanos al parecer no tuvieron nada que ver siglos antes...

I learned about this in schools in both Iceland and Ireland, its as much apart of European history as it is Islamic, no one denies that. My nephew's are learning about it now back home in Iceland, its standard curriculum.

@itzJKB

10 ай бұрын

not in the UK its not

@tyrrell0076

10 ай бұрын

sad to tell you thats not right, muslims were here for 700 years, but the peninsulars never integrated their society, and the ones who did were second or third tier civilians with almost no rights, but thankfully most of the population migarted to the north, asturias, cantabria, galicia... and then 700 years before we reconquered the territory, they left us some touches and things, but to say ous history is as european as muslim is to not know a single thing about the iberic pensinsule history

@bugzyhardrada3168

10 ай бұрын

@@tyrrell0076 lol, the vid is called the secret history of Spain, is it not? And Spain is a country in Europe, is it not? Is this then not apart of Europian history? And is it then not apart of islamic history?

@aminr4281

10 ай бұрын

@@bugzyhardrada3168we Iranians don’t consider the invasion of the Arabs as part of Iranian history because the Arabs never integrated as a part of Iranian culture. So even though Arabs were there for 800 years, doesn’t mean Spain owes them anything! Yes, there are historical aspects left behind by the Arab moors but they never wanted to integrate to Spanish culture and didn’t see themselves as such!

@bugzyhardrada3168

10 ай бұрын

@@aminr4281 I don't recall implying that Spain owes anyone anything, merely the implications that these are historical events in that they are apart of a nations or a continents history, are they not? A Spainaird in school is just as likely to learn about as a North African-Arab is, because it is apart of both respective histories, why you argue this and imply one owes the other makes zero sense in context to what has been said. These are after all historical events. Now as for your Iranian-Arab example, the same point still stands whether you like it or not, and the implications of the Arab invasion into Iran facilitated the spread of Islam within which affected Iranian history quite dramatically, as I am sure you are aware of, as did the Arab invasions of the Iberian peninsula, again these are historical events and are aparts of both respective histories. You do understand how history works, right, kids in Syria are taught about the Christian Crusades just like the kids in Europe are, you know why, because these are historical events that tie the respective cultures together.

The best video of all I’ve seen so far on KZread , concerning Andalusian history.

Great video! Btw, Portugal is also part of this and also with a very rich islamic background, even more visible as the inquisition was in here and not so intense.

Salaam & Love & Eid Mubarak From Bangladesh ❤❤❤🇧🇩

The world for some strange reason want to downplay the influence of the Muslim nations on the ancient world. I’m so glad to hear you speak well of the Muslim heritage and influence on the world. Thank you so much for all of your hard work. Peace

@theteamxxx3142

10 ай бұрын

Because modern muslims from north africa siria pakistan are subhumans and they aren the inventors and scientists of the 1000

@goranmiljus2664

10 ай бұрын

INVADING, killing, raping, slavery, oppression, 1400 years of expansionist violence.

@ftrujillomolina9064

10 ай бұрын

La influencia musulmana en el mundo finalizo hace como 700 años.

@nastasedr

10 ай бұрын

The strange reason is that they have not had much influence except war.

@houssam4336

10 ай бұрын

​​@@nastasedr?😂😂😂as if European didn't influence by wars

Awesome work! Thank you 😊

Great video, but as a Spanish person, I never saw this as a secret. I think it's broadly known in the Iberian Peninsula, even though some people don't like to acknowledge it. Beside the culture and language, I don't think it's hard to notice the similarities between the physical characteristics of Arabian Muslims and those of Spanish or Portuguese descent. I also believe that South Italians and Sicilians have a similar condition due to the influence of the Muslim Empires that ruled those areas, mostly the Aghlabid Dynasty in the 9th century.

@republitarian484

9 ай бұрын

Talk to white Americans about being blamed for slavery and colonialism. . .even white Americans whose ancestry had noting to do with it such as Polish or Hungarian.

@DavIGHL

9 ай бұрын

The Arabs were in some areas of Spain for 7 centuries. A reconquest took place. Because what is Spanish is what is based on Celtiberian and Latin, not what comes from the Arab invasion, which is what comes from outside. The Christian kingdoms recovered their territory, and some time later expelled the Muslims who invaded Spain and Portugal. The fact that there are words in Castilian/Spanish does not mean anything, there are French words, English words and words from other languages, for example war is a word that comes from Germanic, bellum would be the Latin word. In Spanish genetics, the Arab presence is only 10% of the Spanish lineage. In other words, their contribution is minimal. I have nothing against Arabs, but as a Spaniard I have nothing to do with them, and I know several Arabs, whether Moroccans, Pakistanis or Tunisians, with whom I am culturally unlike.

@anklepick9524

9 ай бұрын

lol I know several Arabs... paktistanis@@DavIGHL

@DavIGHL

9 ай бұрын

@@anklepick9524 I also know several Pakistanis, and Arabs where from time to time I go to eat a kebab. And I know what their culture is like, their way of seeing things, etc. Not to mention that if you mix Moroccans and Spaniards you know where each one is from. All the respect in the world, but we are nothing alike. our brothers are Italian, Portuguese, Latin American and some European countries. Arabs are not in our environment.

@anklepick9524

9 ай бұрын

It's understandable that you feel this way, since the Arab/Muslim influence was so long ago.@@DavIGHL

As a Dutch living 14 years in Andalusia I knew a lot already, but this was a welcome explination. Thank you.

@EUGEN093

10 ай бұрын

Most of what he says is a lie.

@erikstekelenburg3020

10 ай бұрын

@@EUGEN093 I've checked other vids from him. He's a huge fan but missed a lot of the real story ya. No offend to the people, but it's a little more complicated.

@1individeo

10 ай бұрын

true. Great Doc. He only forgot to mention that Muslim and Christian did work and live together but tried to end all Jewish presence in the peninsula. Most Sinagogs were converted to either churches, Mosques or Monastries.

@user-tr4ej8mw4s

10 ай бұрын

This is just a muslim propagandist trying to seduce you to convert to get 72 hurries.

@desireeyalejandro4470

10 ай бұрын

@@EUGEN093 He is a liar. Spain is celtic, iberian, roman and wisigoth. Our ancestors were warriors and brave people that fought to get rid of the muslims. The Reconquista is one of the most amazing historic event in the world along with the conquest of America. Spain prevented Europe of being muslim at the Lepanto battle.

Subscribed. You should have more subscribers for such a wonderful history channel!!

@user-ei4ep6nt7v

10 ай бұрын

yes but nobody called them the muslims they were the Moors

A very honest presentation. Well done. Appreciate it very much.

Very interesting and compelling...great content!

This video is amazing, masha Allah. Keep doing your research. I believe the same and it is really intriguing

In the al-azhar uni egypt, student that learning literature and poetry from andalus era will read about the history that you mentioned... And now you made it more vivid more obvious with this documentary... Thanks a lot...😊😊😊

@user-ei4ep6nt7v

10 ай бұрын

nobody called them the muslims they were the Moors

@khaled2004

17 күн бұрын

I am proud to study at Al-Azhar

Keep up the great work

It can be said that Spain has been *influenced* to (very) various degrees by Muslim culture, but not that Spain has Muslim origins like the video's thumbnail claims. Also, it is very misleading to say that Spain was controlled by Muslims for 8 centuries. It is more accurate to say that some parts of the Iberian Peninsula were Muslim for 8 centuries. Certain parts were never Muslim, and very large parts of the Peninsula were Muslim for much less time than 8 centuries. It should be noted that the Muslims in Iberia were by far mostly converted Hispano-Romans whereas Berbers and Arabs were only a small minority, and also that Iberia was never completely under Muslim control. In 1238, Sultan Ibn al-Ahmar, the founder of the Nasrid dynasty, became a vassal of Fernando III of Castile, and in 1246 Alhamar signed the Pact of Jaén, in which Granada had to pay tribute to Castile in order to maintain its independence. From 1264 onwards, the only Muslim territory in Iberia was Granada, which is smaller than Belgium, and it continued to exist as a vassal of Castile, and therefore cannot be called a "social and political force" since the 1200s.

@muddyhotdog4103

4 ай бұрын

True, it was already christianized long before Islam conquest if it.

@roarsarch201

3 ай бұрын

cope

@CarlosVermeerschSantana

3 ай бұрын

@@roarsarch201 Come back with a real answer.

@roarsarch201

3 ай бұрын

@@CarlosVermeerschSantana I don't care to bring counter points to your revisionist history. Cope.

@CarlosVermeerschSantana

3 ай бұрын

@@roarsarch201 When you don't pay attention in history class that hard that you think actual history is revisionist. Also, stop liking your own comments, it's lame.

Just beyond brilliant !

Really enjoy your video's. Keep up the good work!

@user-ei4ep6nt7v

10 ай бұрын

nobody called them muslims they were the moors

List of a few Arabic words in the English language. Some English words are direct decedents of Arabic words, such as ghoul while others have been indirectly passed down from Arabic through other, older European languages such as Latin, Turkish or French. These words include sugar and admiral. It is estimated that hundreds of words in the English language come from Arabic words. These words encompass food and drink, medical and scientific terms, animals and plants as well as everyday objects and products we use. Some examples include: Alcohol Algebra Average Bled Check Coffee Cotton Candy Gerbil Gazelle Giraffe Guitar Harem Henna Hazard Jar Jasmine Lemon Lime Mascara Mask Mattress Orange Safari Satin Sherbet Sorbet Shrub Soda Sofa So-long Spinach Syrup Tell Wisdom tooth Zero

@timeup2549

10 ай бұрын

The estimation of Arabic in English is 10 thousand, higher than Spanish's 4 thousand.

@deiy.9468

10 ай бұрын

@@seoul68 cope there are literally hundreds of arab tribes from the peninsula migrating to spanish andalus and live there for centuries, banu lakhm, banu qasim, and al-ansar is one of of the many examples. Many prominent scholars there also has arab tribes on his names. Why don't you accept history?

@Stephen-lx9nm

9 ай бұрын

​@@deiy.9468Why do t you ?

@ikman3410

9 ай бұрын

Lol. Algorithm, Alchemy did not come from Arabs??? :) Even the word Gibberish came Arabs. When the Algebra reached Europe, they could not understand a thing of it. So they called it Gibberish. Europe is the dark age while Islamic word had Golden age. Now you see who stole the credits. Europeans are the greatest thieves world has ever seen. They are still looting and pillaging Africa to this day. Then they come and lecture on you moral values and freedom.

@ikman3410

9 ай бұрын

@@LunarBuzzWhat does it mean?

Amazing video. Congratulations!

Good explanation and history! Thank you!

@goodaimshield1115

10 ай бұрын

Rubbish, over 90% of what he says is complet nonsense.

Amazing real history you ensambled here.

Great video. Informative and pleasant to watch. I’m Happy to find your channel on here.

What an incredible video ☆ This got me more interested in reading the history of muslims in Spain.. May I ask what resources you use for the information in your videos? I'd love to check them out ^^

Great presentation. Not forgetting that the Spanish guitar owes its origins to the Arabic Oud while Flamenco, as an art form, arguably also owes at least some of its origins to the Middle East. Hence, the similarity between Flamenco music and that of the Middle East

@V223-df2js

6 ай бұрын

Yes , and also local christian and sephardic and Gypsy influence , as its been proved.Not one thing alone could create the Flamenco that we know today

the names of cities in Spain are Arabic words - Murcia, Almeria, Madrid, Benidorm, Medina Sedonia, Alcala, Alicante, Beniali, Benirama, Benidorm, Benicassim, Tarifa, Algeciras, Toledo, Zahra, Benalmadena, Albarracin there are hundreds of them, I couldn't write them all down, they are Arabic town names but in Spain. these are Arabic names that have a whole meaning in Arabic

@Hippobottomless

10 ай бұрын

We also have Toledo here in America in state of Ohio. I think it’s named after the city in Spain I’m guessing

@EUGEN093

10 ай бұрын

Abdul, it is not abdulic names.

@houssam4336

10 ай бұрын

@@EUGEN093 do you have problems with Abdul ?? There are Christian name start with Abdul

@DubsCS

9 ай бұрын

Toledo is an evolution of the roman name Toletum, it's over 2000 years old

@user-cg4mf7pn1g

9 ай бұрын

​@@EUGEN093human worship human dead is crazy History cristian religion satanic in the world Long live war in ukraine and Russia because religion satanic

A concise and precise account of El Andalus, brilliantly done in just 15 minutes, Olé!!!. As for the denial of the evident in most Western countries, it has become a real political tradition since 1492, and a political football since WWII. Belss you (barak'Allahu feek.

Thank you for providing this fascinating information. Shalom.

Very interesting video! Thanks for putting this together.

@OmaroftheOrient

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much :D

MashaAllah JazakiAllahukhaerian good work

Thank you for the information

I have lived in southern Portugal as a Muslim university student and the locals would always talk about the civilization that Muslims had brought to the area. In fact some of them would say, they don’t understand why Muslims today act the way they do…

@dpp5285

7 ай бұрын

Just the fanatical Muslims… as with anyone taking a fanatical view on religion. The rest of us just cannot understand why such extremism when we have centuries behind us of peaceful living with one another

@dpp5285

7 ай бұрын

@@saewha there is extremism in every religion… what do you call the American ultra evangelist christians?! Wouldn’t they call up a crusade if they could?

@commontouch1787

4 ай бұрын

@@dpp5285they talk about criminality not so called « extremism » , no one is extremist

you are videos are so good and informative about islam

We need more of your episodes!

Interesting,,, however, olive oil was stapple in Spain since the Phoenicians ( before the Greeks, and thus the Romans. ) You seem to forget that the northern provinces were never ruled by the moors, and that Spain's culture has long developped through the dialogue between the strong Jewish element, the Christian forces and the Islamic ones.

15 years ago, i listened to my teacher for 04 hours abt his research on this topic and i got stunned to know abt these things..... i was almost sure that no other person knows abt muslim heritage of spain and arab influence on spain...... glad to see that some other person has also spoken abt the same....

@viviennedunbar3374

7 ай бұрын

This is very well known! I learnt it in my history class in secondary school/high school in England in the 1980s!! You would have to be very ignorant of European history to not know this.

I am Spanish and proud of all the richness of influences in our history

En principio tengo que decir que lo que viene a continuación no es ningún alegato en contra de la presencia musulmana en la península ibérica. De hecho, su influencia no sólo es innegable, sino que en muchos aspectos fue enriquecedora. La cultura española se ha enriquecido con la cultura árabe del norte de África, no sólo a nivel arquitectónico y gastronómico, sino en muchas ramas del saber. Pero como tampoco me gustan las medias verdades y la tergiversación de la historia ( a la que ciertos países le cogieron el gustillo hace ya varios siglos ) pues ahí van ciertos DATOS: Los musulmanes invadieron la península ibérica en el año 711, y la batalla de Covadonga ( que dio inicio a la reconquista ) fue en 722, es decir, que once años después de que invadieran la península ya empezaron a perder terreno, con lo cuál, no es correcto decir que toda la península estuvo 800 años bajo el control musulman. Decir eso es faltar a la verdad. Las zonas más al sur sí estuvieron más tiempo bajo dominio musulman hasta llegar a Andalucía. Así que se puede decir que hubo gran parte de la península que no estuvo 800 años bajo el dominio musulman, a no ser, que los cristianos reconquistaran la península en un sólo día, jeje. Veamos los acontecimientos que no nos han contado: Alfonso VI de León conquista Toledo en 1085. Alfonso I "el batallador" conquista Zaragoza en 1118. En 1137, el condado de Barcelona y el reino de Aragón se unieron dinásticamente con el matrimonio de Ramón Berenguer IV y la princesa Petronila de Aragón. El reino de Portugal se extendió por el suroeste peninsular tras la conquista de Lisboa en 1147. Es decir, que si hacemos cálculos, en unos cuatrocientos años tras la entrada musulmana, más de la mitad de la península ya estaba en manos de los reinos cristianos, con lo cuál, es incorrecto decir que TODA la península tuvo influencia musulmana durante 800 años, sino que desde el centro hasta el norte sólo tuvo influencia 400 años ( y en la franja norte, la presencia fue anecdótica, y en ciertas zonas, nula. Por otra parte, me resulta curioso que digas que los musulmanes seguían practicando su religión en secreto después de haber sido conquistados, pero cuando es al revés, es decir, cuando has hablado de que los cristianos adoptaron el islam, no hayas mencionado nada acerca de la posibilidad de que ellos también hubiesen practicado secretamente el cristianismo. También me resulta curioso que la influencia visigoda ni se nombre, cuando, aún estando poco más de doscientos años, adoptaran el latín como lengua, y se convirtieran al cristianismo, es decir, que yo me pregunto: ¿ qué es más probable que tenga más influencia, la unión con alguien que habla tu mismo idioma, profesa tu misma religión y adquiere tus costumbres, o alguien que ni habla tu idioma, ni profesa tu religión y no adquiere tus costumbres ? por lógica, creo que es mucho más probable lo primero. Por cierto, en el idioma español, también existen palabras de origen gótico. De hecho, alrededor del 1% de los vocablos en español proceden del gótico ( unas 1000 palabras ) y 8% del árabe ( unas 8000 palabras ). Como ves, creo que ninguna de las dos cifras es nada desdeñable. No le restaría importancia a ninguna de las dos ( para desgracia del "ilustrísimo" Boris Johnson ), un "erudito" donde los haya... ( la verdad es que sacarlo al final tratando de restar importancia a la influencia visigoda en la península no ha sido lo más acertado. Resta mucha credibilidad, pero entiendo cuál es la intención ). En serio, yo aconsejaría a los turistas "estudiosos" que cuando visitéis España, no sólo os centréis en la mitad sur. Ya sé que el clima es mucho más agradable, pero si uno quiere de verdad aprender sobre el pasado histórico de España, tiene que visitar distintas zonas de España, porque sino, uno se va con la sensación, de que España es toros, flamenco y paella. Y no es un mal plan para pasar unas vacaciones, pero sí lo es cuando uno trata de estudiar la historia de mi país, a no ser, que uno lleve encima ciertos sesgos que le hacen ver sólo aquello que quiere ver, para contar sólo aquello que le interesa contar. Si amigo, sí... España es un país único en ciertos aspectos, una "rara avis", y es que es una mezcla cultural impresionante, y eso mismo es lo que nos enriquece. España no sería lo que es sin la influencia mora, pero tampoco sin la influencia romana ( que por cierto, ha sido sin duda la que más la ha influenciado ). Pero aún así, en general, ni somos árabes, ni moros, ni judíos, ni somos un pueblo germánico, sino que genéticamente, por mucho que duela al señor Boris Johson "el iluminado", tenemos nuestra propia genética, mezcla de los pueblos celtas e íberos que la habitaban antes de llegar moros, visigodos, romanos, fenicios, griegos, vándalos, alanos etc... porque hasta donde yo sé, esa gente no desapareció cuando fue invadida por todos estos pueblos. Y no lo digo yo, lo dicen los estudios genéticos que se han llevado a cabo sobre la población española. De hecho, para desgracia del archiconocido Sirrrr Boris Johson "el iluminado", prácticamente toda la franja occidental europea ( quitando los países escandinavos, comparten, a grandes rasgos, una genética muy similar ). www.google.com/search?q=c%C3%B3mo+linkear+una+p%C3%A1gina&gs_ivs=1#tts=0 Predomio del halogrupo R1b, ese halogrupo se encuentra presente en la mayoría de los irlandeses, galeses, escoceses, franceses, belgas, españoles, portugueses, ingleses del oeste, holandeses del sur, austríacos del oeste, italianos del norte (valle del Po) y alemanes del sur. Actualmente también es frecuente entre los habitantes de América y Oceanía, debido a la emigración. En realidad el R1b es el haplogrupo más común en Europa occidental, llegando a más del 80% de la población en Irlanda, las tierras altas escocesas, en el oeste de Gales, la franja atlántica de Francia y el País Vasco. Por último decir, que antes de la expulsión de los judíos en España, ya se habían producido deportaciones de estos en Francia e Inglaterra. De hecho, de toda europa, España se encuentra entre los países que menos expulsiones de judíos hizo CON DIFERENCIA. En Alemania fue abismal, pero es curioso de que da la sensación de que cuando se habla de expulsión de judíos, siempre salga la palabra España. Ocurre lo mismo con la inquisición, que siempre va asociada a la palabra "española" cuando en realidad fue en Alemania, de nuevo, donde más condenados por la inquisición hubo, de nuevo, con muchísima diferencia. En fin... parece que España "destaca" hasta en lo que no destaca. ( Espero que esto no lo lea Sirrrr Boris Johson "el iluminado". A lo mejor le da un mareo al pobrecito )

@aladelta55

10 ай бұрын

Muy bien explicado. Es cierto que em video quiere mostrar las bondades del islamismo versus la supuesta bestialidad goda... Ni tanto ni tan calvo...

@ternua

9 ай бұрын

Muy buen comentario. Es curioso el dato sobre el bisabuelo de Boris Jhonson llamado Ali Kemal, político y periodista turco, ministro del interior, crítico con el imperio otomano asesinado por traidor antes de su juicio en la guerra de independencia turca por orden de Mustafa Kemal pasha

@sergiom.5681

9 ай бұрын

@@ternua gracias por el dato👍🏼

@spartawelly5863

8 ай бұрын

​@@ternuawhat does the ottoman empire have to do with andalusia

@spartawelly5863

8 ай бұрын

​@@aladelta55which is completely true...you may support the goths but many people absolutely many did not support them

BTW Subbed. Enjoying the videos!

you share such a beautiful and truthful content because of this I subscribe your channel

MashAllah, nice explanation and informative, i definitely hit the subscribe button, looking forward to the next episode 🙏🏽

@miguellabordaburnett3617

10 ай бұрын

That video is full of lies.

@user-ei4ep6nt7v

10 ай бұрын

nobody called them the muslims they were the moors

Having a small period of influence is different from originating in a culture. Your thumbnail is deceiving by saying "Muslim origins of Spanish culture". Instead it should say, the phase of Muslim influence on spain

@akhlaqali1139

5 ай бұрын

800 or so years isn't a phase it's literally nearly a millennia. Literally 200 years more than how long the the Christians and today's secular Spain have held the land

Fascinating. Thank you.

Very interesting video. I did know most of these things, but it’s nice to see them collected into more of a narrative. I think in the West we’re currently embroiled in this culture war where we’re often presented with history presented to minimize the achievements of Europeans/whites to the point where influences lead down a rabbit hole. But this is a nice unbiased presentation of the Islamic world’s influence where we can celebrate the genealogy of what makes us rather than frame things in a ridiculous us vs them framework.

I'm Portuguese and yes, Salam! I saw once a stamp from Morocco prior to the discovery of Madeira Island with the islands clearly showing on a map on this stamp. Our Portuguese words are no different.

The Spanish language having 8% Arabic is a myth cause a lot of said words are Latin or Greek in origin from North African Romance languages or Iranian (Like Lemon for example). In reality, Arabic influences is more like 4% or so, which isnt that significant considering languages like English or French are 1-2% Arabic as well (words like Alcohol which are the same in all languages).

@khaled2004

17 күн бұрын

The word alcohol is found in all languages but its origin is Arabic My respect to you

Amazing commentary,

i am algerian with Andalusian origins from Gharnata or granada . i did an ADN test and i have 42% iberian ... until today we still play Andalusian songs written 700 years ago in Granada

the reason why may Latin Americans have names like Amir, Omar, etc, is because Arabic immigrants (in particular Syrians and Lebanese) introduced those names.

🔥🔥🔥 I am an Indian Muslim ... Thanks for this eye opening piece of information. Keep going

@shanealarcon7928

10 ай бұрын

Same here Indian Lebanese and Spanish mix

@Rohilla313

10 ай бұрын

Indian Muslim here too

@artculture1711

10 ай бұрын

You do know this has nothing to relate with Indian Muslims .. isn't it ? Though I agree some of the information is good, some imagined for self massaging & some far fetched. No authentic references were cited.. which makes it quite imaginative. Indian Muslims will go & find their relation to totally unrelated people, cultures & societies .. but forget their own original roots & identity. No wonder your situation too will go the pakjstani Muslim way.. slowly, but surely.

@miguellabordaburnett3617

10 ай бұрын

So you forget the terrible things that islam has done in india and spain? Islam is rightfully rejected in bith places by nist of the people, and they have first hand experience of it.

Great info, glad found this. Want to visit south Spain soon, IA.

Thank you very much.The word Mozareb intrigued me in between then you cleared it by telling the original Arabic word Mustaareb(Arabise).We the Urdu speakers have Urduise Hospital as Aspatal,Municipality as Munsipalti etc etc.

It is not a secret, it's just that the Roman/Latin, Basque, Germanic, etc is more prominent. More germanic loan words, more Roman architecture etc. Also, it's up to 8% loan words and that is highly disputed, they are also loan words meaning they have Latin equals that are more commonly used. No one says alcazar they say castillo, no one says alacrán they mostly say escorpión etc. Also, the names do not count as those names are all over Europe. You are trying to downplay it's predominant Latin/Roman cultural heritage, it is over 70% to 80% Latin and the rest is a mix of Germanic, basque, greek, celt-iberian, etc. You are clearly trying to over emphesize a small part of the culture on the Iberian peninsula. The Iberian peninsula was a Roman province for longer, and there is no way that it was 90% muslim by the time of the Reconquista lmao

Proud of my Spanish and my Arabic ancestry

@globalist1990

7 ай бұрын

Spanish have heritage from all over Europe, Northern Africa, west Asia. ✌️ People often forget the Mediterranean was easier to transverse than land then, if you had the means, meaning if you were rich and clever, you'd go all over around the Mediterranean.

Has fet molt bé amic!Molt interesant.Well done!

I have watched many videos on this subject. None have offered so much info that I find un bias. Ten out of ten. Thank you for teaching me about Queen khalifa. Please do a vid about her