The fact he retired after one of his best seasons is a testament to his greatness

@doocies

9 ай бұрын

@@zekejordan7434 for as many games as he missed it would've taken him another 4 or 5 years to get to 2k

@LockheartTifa

9 ай бұрын

@@zekejordan7434 even without that 2K hits..hes legitimately 1st ballot HoF..even if theres 2 players for example trout and posey,who should go in the HoF i think posey deserve..he accomplish alot since his breaktrough..

@nobeardthepirate9172

9 ай бұрын

​@@LockheartTifago compare him to Thurman Munson before you call him HOF

@doocies

9 ай бұрын

@@nobeardthepirate9172 Word. Even Yadier Molina might be considered the best catcher of his generation. He has as many gold gloves as posey has full seasons played

@romanvaldivia9863

9 ай бұрын

All I gotta say , 3 rings

I’m so glad buster is getting the shine he deserves. My favorite player of all time, and he should be a first ballot hofer, but he won’t.

@CSDonohue11

9 ай бұрын

Buster always has & does get His Shine Because He deserves it Buster Posey is A Straight Up Gangster out there on The Field Especially behind The Plate

@poipoipoi35

8 ай бұрын

How wont he be first ballot

@whyistherumgone8184

8 ай бұрын

It wasn’t mentioned how well he framed pitches. And then Madbum wouldn’t want to work with any other catcher. Posey was a legend.

@luc2k23

8 ай бұрын

​@@poipoipoi35 just cause he doesnt have the cumulative stats to be a hall of fame lock. I think he should get in the hall of fame but thats the argument.

He is a hall of famer. He was the captain of 3 World Series winning teams. His Offensive and defensive impact was stellar and made his whole pitching staff better. It would be irresponsible to leave him out after what he contributed to baseball

@Music--ng8cd

9 ай бұрын

And he caught 3 no-hitters. Pay the man.

@briansolo

9 ай бұрын

Irresponsible & disrespectful

@ChairmanMeow1

5 ай бұрын

Captain of 3 WS winners is all I need to hear, personally

@claytonreid996

17 күн бұрын

@@Music--ng8cd 2 No-nos and a perfecto, was on 1B for Timmys 2nd no-no, that one was Hector Sanchez

As a Giants fan, I was completely shocked by his decision at first but he has always been a family first guy and it was amazing walk away on his terms accomplishing every feat he could have while keeping his health.

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

He left in a position unlike many others!

As a Dodgers fan, it was a pleasure watching this man play he was a class act and an incredible player

That broken leg in 2011 was a tragedy. The Giants would’ve repeated if he’d stayed healthy and he was having a career year. His GS @ Cin is my favorite home run of all time. 1st ballot HOF

@aGrizzlyProduction

8 ай бұрын

I’ll remember that GS until the day I die

@brockman562

8 ай бұрын

yup, easilyyyyy... I think we were leading AZ till the injury. our offense was putrid the rest of the season after injury as well. AZ ended up 8 games ahead of us. that fuckin year, we were up there with PHI for best pitching staff, and right behind them for team ERA. We woulda had a great fuckin shot at a repeat...eaaaasilyyyyy.

You know a players good when they win MVP as a catcher

@doocies

9 ай бұрын

only because of his offensive ability, defensively he was very average

@jclips2098

9 ай бұрын

@@doocies he was FAR from average behind the plate. His impact can’t be measured by stats. I watched his entire career, and he made every pitcher so much better than what they were “supposed” to be. There’s a very good reason as to why the staff wasn’t as good in 2022, and it was because of Buster not being there, thankfully we have Bailey now.

He's most definitely a HOFer! Yadi is the best defensive catcher since Pudge and he's also the reason why Posey didn't win more gold gloves, but he's a better overall hitter than Yadi and he won more rings.

@jeffn9952

9 ай бұрын

You can't hold a catcher's lack of longevity against them. Gotta be in the HOF as maybe the most valuable player of his time, considering how instrumental he was in the Giants' playoff success. Being a clubhouse leader and philanthropist doesn't hurt either. All-around all-time great.

@jeffkiewiet806

9 ай бұрын

I just don’t see how a guy with only 1500 hits is a HOFer. Yeah was great and has rings but that’s a team accomplishment.

@LockheartTifa

9 ай бұрын

@@jeffkiewiet806 he was the face of the franchise not zito not baumgarner..one man club,multiple rings,consistent and clutch..his accomplishment is better among his peers even trout..

@user-em9vc4vq1z

9 ай бұрын

@@jeffkiewiet806 He did so much more than 1500 hits and three rings. Best player at his position in all of MLB for the better part of a decade 7x All-Star, 3x WS champ, MVP, Batting title, 2x Comeback Player of the Year, ROTY, 5x Silver Slugger and he even managed to hit over .300 for his career with the majority of his games as a catcher. Name 10 catchers that had a better career than him? Most experts have him pegged around the eighth greatest catcher of all time.

@NickPR87

9 ай бұрын

@@jeffkiewiet806 Which is the end goal of playing the game, plus he won those as arguably the most important figure on the field with his bat and behind the plate. His rings have more weight than someone's with 3k hits or 500+HR, but who won one ring at age 40 as a bench player who hung around the game way past his prime.

Mickey Cochrane played from age 22-34, was an MVP, won 3 World Series and had a career OPS+ of 129. Career WAR 49.7 Buster Posey played from age 22-34, was an MVP, won 3 World Series and had a career OPS+ of 129. Career WAR 44.8, but likely would have closed the gap had he played in the COVID year. In 1976, the Sporting News named its All-Time All Star team (this was the 100th anniversary of the National League), and they named Mickey Cochrane as the catcher. So Posey is basically the equal of a guy who was once considered the GOAT at the position, so, yeah, he's a Hall of Famer.

@joebatyko1072

9 ай бұрын

Awesome comparison bro I agree he should be a shoe in

2010-2014 giants will be forever underrated era in baseball

Posey has one of the most interesting HOF cases of all time in my opinion. The longevity and counting stats suggest he is incredibly far off, but the position he plays and his accolades frame him as an easy first ballot guy. Will be interesting to see how he fares, but I think he eventually makes it

@jclips2098

9 ай бұрын

As a giants fan, I’m biased in saying that he is a no doubt first ballot, but knowing baseball writers it’ll take a few ballots for him to get in.

@jeanpayano1506

9 ай бұрын

​@@jclips2098im not a Giants fan but Buster is a first ballot HOF anyone with baseball knowledge understand his case

I played against Buster growing up as kid and teenager. He was always levels above the rest of his peers. Glad to see him get the recognition he deserves.

I grew up in San Jose California and one of the best memories of growing up there was watching guys like Cain, bumgartner, and posey come up through the minors and skyrocket into the majors

@brockman562

8 ай бұрын

Bumgarner ...no 't' buddy.

I think he still gets in. Hes just the guy who wins at life…and honesty he deserves it. To put up the numbers he did over his best 7 years…

Nothing to say but absolute legend.

We need a Lance Berkman video. One of the clutchest playoff performers of his era and actually held the record for doubles by a switch hitter for awhile till Brian Roberts broke it in 2009.

@jamman950

9 ай бұрын

If you can’t wait seventh inning stretch made a vid on him

@CSDonohue11

9 ай бұрын

The way that BiG Boy could play CF & did it in H Town with The Pole & The Hill …. I remember watching Him run up that hill , back to the plate while falling & making over the shoulder basket catches Lane was a Menace out there & a Rival of My Reds at the time So I know what A Freakin Menace That Man Lance Burkman was Him, Bigio & Oswalt were The Leaders of those Championship Caliber teams that did make a World Series With Roger & Andy helping that staff & Wagner SLAMMiNG The Doors Closed on Hitters . 💪

@imahobolin

9 ай бұрын

Big Puma! one of the h-town fav too especially how he carried Rice

I've always liked Posey because my step brother played with him when they were young, and he said Posey was always the coolest guy, and best player he ever played with.

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

I believe it! A true leader and example of how to play the game the right way.

@pbmander3949

8 ай бұрын

Sorry, a correction to be made after talking to him. He played in the same league against Posey, however he reiterated Posey was the best he had seen and was a stand up guy. My mistake. My memory had failed me in old age. Still, I admire and respect Posey

@Cam23

8 ай бұрын

@@pbmander3949 No worries, thank you for sharing!

Growing up as a dodger fan I actually admired posey loved how he was the captain behind the plate and actually took control of the whole game the one job a catcher has is to be the captain and posey knew that well no doubt a hall of famer.

@Cam23

8 ай бұрын

Posey was the kind of guy no matter if he played against your team you wanted to root for him. Unreal talent behind the dish

Nice job… As a diehard giant fan for 65 years was nice to see. I was raised in Pacifica, so I’d love to see a Keith Hernandez video. He was a superstar in Little League.

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

Thank you, I’m glad you enjoyed! Keith is a great suggestion

@brockman562

8 ай бұрын

Nice. Pacifica rules. went there today. Pacifica is what my Santa Cruz 'used to be like'.... chill, mellow vibes, beach town, leisurely pace, and without the tweakers and homeless. keep it that way.

Giants fan checking in Posey LITERALLY caught every pitch of GIants postseason baseball the entire time he was in the league read into that what you want but at the end of the day when CHIT mattered MOST he as the guy easily a Hall of Famer

As a dodgers fan, 100% should get in, class act, amazing player, so much respect for him.

@user-em9vc4vq1z

9 ай бұрын

A part of me always wanted to see him and Kershaw go in together. But that would mean Posey would have to wait a few years for Kersh to go in first ballot.

@YaBoiJamo

9 ай бұрын

@@user-em9vc4vq1z I didn’t think he was gonna retire that early

I have nothing but respect for tremendous catchers. The hardest position on any team no doubt.

I'd love to see a video on Jim Thome, possibly one of the most underrated players in modern years despite hitting over 600 career home runs. The dude had so much power that hit hit the longest homer at Targrt field at age 40.

Your channel is my favorite among baseball video essayists. The videos, the rich amount of information, and the sincere excitement in your analysis are noticeable. Great job, and cheers on another stellar video!

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

Thank you for the kind words, I’m so happy to hear you’re enjoying the content!

Certainly a hall of famer. Careers cut short by injuries should not disqualify obvious hall of famers.

HOFer, no question about it. Longevity should be one of several factors considered; it never has and was never meant to be dispositive. While I am bias, as I am a lifelong Giants fan, Posey’s teams in the 2010s represent the last real dynasty in baseball. He was their best offensive and defensive player and impacted the game at every level. He deserves to be in.

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

Well said! Posey was the leading member of that dynasty, definitely is worthy of Cooperstown on that alone.

He's a no question first ballot if you've been awake for the last 10 years.

If Roy Campanella made the Hall as a catcher after just 9-10 seasons - then Buster deserves to go in as well.

Definite hall of famer! Look what he did in those 11 years! 3 rings, MVP, ROTY, comeback player 2x, a batting title, and 3 no hitters! Fogettaboutit!

I’m a new baseball fan with no knowledge of baseball legends of past. I only know the great players today. Turns out Buster Posey was a legend. You gained a new sub and fellow baseball fan 💪

@LetDylCook

9 ай бұрын

Cam, I had a question for you. I ask this to all of the baseball YTs I watch. Is there a way a new baseball watcher like myself can get familiar with the game of baseball and past generations. I play MLB the Show so that helps a little bit I feel like you can add more knowledge as an experienced baseball watcher.

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

Thank you, and welcome to the channel! 🙌That's awesome, there's so much to learn and even someone like myself who's been a fan for as long as I can remember, it's overwhelming trying to keep track of it all 😂 We're going to learn about the legends together!

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

@@LetDylCook That's a great question. By watching mini biographies and documentaries on KZread you're already on the right track! I'd say that Ken Burns baseball taught me a lot about the game's history, he's an incredible storyteller and he does so primarily through pictures. Side note: It depends on what part of history interests you the most. The Negro Leagues are gaining more attention in recent years, and it's so cool because there's a lot to learn about baseball pioneers such as Rube Foster. The movie 42 is great for Jackie Robinson history, and going to visit museums in person is another great way to learn. The Babe Ruth museum in Baltimore is one of many possible places you can go to see relics, baseball cards, and memorabilia that you won't find anywhere else.

im not a giants fan but i truly respect most of the players and the team, heck i wouldn't be mad if my favorite team lost to them in a world series

Posey absolutely should be in the Hall of Fame. A career .302 as a catcher in the 21st century is unreal. Add the awards & rings & he should be a shoe in, regardless of the injuries & retiring early.

20 minutes of cam talking about posey now that is a good video

Hard to believe that there were four other teams that could have had Buster Posey in the 2008 MLB Draft and that those teams did not choose him. I’m so glad that he played his whole career for the S.F. Giants.

I remember playing as the Giants in 2k9 with Bennie but didn't play video games with Buster. I remember the great 2010 world series win completely, my family was so excited for SF to win something after the 90s wins with the 49ers. Then 2011 we didn't make the playoffs so didn't matter. 2012 we made the playoffs and I kinda remember winning. 2013 we missed the playoffs, and again didn't watch. 2014 we made the playoffs and as a kid I didn't even watch. At that point I was so used to winning. If we made the playoffs we won the world series. Looking back I can't believe I missed Buster's career and I only remember the first few years. Winning is so hard and I felt it was so easy, I'm never going to miss my team winnign again

glad u mentioned his HR against the Dodgers that almost went into the water, cause I was going crazy yelling as it was soaring thru the air knowing that I mightve just witnessed the very first righty into McCovey Cove, I even get flashbacks of it.

I loved watching Buster his entire career!

Great to see more videos about players from the 2010s, Cutch would be a great fit for the next video!

I'd love to see a video on the greatest righthanded hitter of all time; Edgar Martinez!

Love this guy, it was incredible to watch him play

You know what, I want a Jason Varitek video, especially with his No-Hitter caught Record

Posey is a no doubt Hall of Famer (despite playing "only" 11 full seasons). Buster accomplished everything a player can accomplish, including Comeback Player of the Year... twice! Absolute legend and winner. Just wish we could've seen him play all 9 positions in an MLB game one time, like he did in college.

I would like to see a video about Kenny Lofton, one of the biggest HOF snubs of all time.

28 is and always will be my favorite player of all time

Great videos man you don't get enough recognition

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

Thank you, I appreciate that!

I absolutely loved this video. not only because I am a huge giants and buster posey fan, but out of all the videos (I have seen on him you are the only one to touch on some very key points. The fact that he is tied for 2nd in no hitter caught as a catcher and that matt cain never shook him off during the perfect game, and also the fact that he would have like 5 or 6 gold gloves if it werent for yadi. I don't know if you learned this during your resaerch; after he retired he ended up buying a share of the giants and became a principle owner.

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

That’s awesome! I’m stoked to hear you enjoyed the vid. There were some cool nuggets of info that I had to share and what you mentioned stuck out to me the most. And I did stumble across him becoming an owner, it was neat to find that out!

this brings back so many memories of these playoffs, a shame i was so young and barely remembered the little details

Another great video! I mentioned hoping to see Chipper Jones soon. Also maybe Joe Mauer and Justin Morneau?

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

Thank you! Great suggestions, both of those Twins would be fitting for a video of this nature. But Chipper will be here before you know it… 👀

I loved watching Buster play. He was the rug that really tied the room together on those world series teams. My dad is furious at him though for sitting out the covid season then retiring after the dominant 21 season.

Buster is a giant through and through. When I was a kid I was a huge bonds fan but Gerald easily wins now. He was amazing, effective, clutch and also seems like a great guy

Another great video! Posey a HOFer! NO QUESTION!

As a Dodgers fan, man did it suck to see this guy in the lineup because he was gonna rake and also one of the best catchers of my era of watching baseball..stings that he helped the hated SF to 3 rings in basically 5 years..pretty impressive and he also had them on the verge of repeating back to back..very classy guy and only thing that kinda bugs me to this day but it’s probably for the safety of the players was because someone bull dozed over him and broke his leg, they banned the running into the catcher..but still, guy was awesome 💪🏼💯

@oldjacket9

8 ай бұрын

Oh you must feel the same way about Bailey now!

Absolutely a HOFer. No question.

I love these videos! Subscribed, notifications on 🔔

@Cam23

9 ай бұрын

😎🤙🏼

Coming from a Doyer fan, Ol Busta Posey is definitely a hall of famer!

fire video.

@Cam23

8 ай бұрын

Thank you! Glad you enjoyed

Anyone from Leesburg up in here, Posey's hometown. I gotta represent for an underrated legend

As a Kansas City fan we need something to to look forward to. Maybe that can be a Brett vid

Digging the 80's beats in the background. Reminds me of The Midnight

@Cam23

8 ай бұрын

I’m glad to hear that! ‘80s music is my jam and it fits these players pretty well

hall of famer for sure, didn’t miss a home game during his fsu career, electric, the reason i’m a giants fan

Funny about Lincecum. I remember there being theories in Timmy’s last couple of years with the Giants that Timmy and Posey didn’t like each other because starting in 2011 or 2012 Lincecum starts would always have Eli Whiteside or Hector Sanchez as his catcher with Posey at first or not playing. Bochy eventually said that it was his decision not to have Posey catch Lincecum starts because Lincecum was physically hard on his catchers with how many of his pitches broke into the dirt. Especially when he started losing his fast ball and relying on breaking stuff.

Blessed to have watched this guy's career. Definitely HoF

Bro was basically the best catcher in baseball for a decade. Factor in the plate incident and the pandemic, imagine what else he could have done. bro better make the hall wtf!!

As a San Fran fan i wholeheartedly agree he will be a HOF catcher!

I freakin Love Posey & LonGo Dope when LonGo went to SF …. I’m still pushing for 3B 9 Matt Williams out of UNLV Made 3 World Series with 3 different teams & Won 1 World Series Ring That Man RAKED & Played some legit 3B over there Especially before the injuries If not for injured Matt Williams would be considered by all an All Time Great No Doubt .

As a Dodgers fan, I felt Posey deserved an NLCS Run for his last season. I’m sure the baseball gods would’ve blessed him on the WS Diamond. Best Catcher

The Hall of Fame is not a legitimate institution if Buster Posey is not in it.

I Loved This ERA In The BAY AREA. We Got CHAMPIONSHIP Spoiled By The GIANTS & The DUBS, But It Was The GIANTS That Kicked It Off 1st.

I think George Foster or Dave Parker should have a video on them, they are both really underrated players from the 70s

I think his mere presence was way underrated. In 2022 the Giants ran back ostensibly the same roster minus Posey and they were a mid pack team.

Can you do Jim Edmonds? Underrated player who should one day be in the HOF

Best FSU baseball player of all time! Great video 🎉

Should be in the HOF all day! The dude was so damn good. I’m so fortunate to have watched him play.

Buster posey IS and will be a hall of famer!

I'd say at some point do an Edwin Encarnación video. Though he only recently retired a few years ago he had an interesting career where he started to come on fairly late into his career to become a 400+ HR hitter with multiple All-stars and a beloved fan favorite for Toronto.

Great video but can you make video on Jim thome

He belongs in Hall of Fame in my book, dude was good in both sides of the game, MVP as a catcher and 3 times champion is hard to argue that.

from the same home town came and spoke to us after he got drafted I think

My favorite player ever

Dude was a beast

Mauer, Posey and Pedroia deserve a place in Cooperstown

Only 27 passed balls in 9,291 2/3 innings. That's pretty impressive.

Mayhap we can get an Adam Wainwright prime video. Help us take our minds off of his recent struggles😂

Chipper Jones next

He’s kind of the American dream taken to the extreme.

Please do a video on Mike mussina

Oh he’s most definitely a hall of famer. Zero doubt in my mind

This is so Yorker (but fr thank you for making a Timmy video)

do one on chipper Jones. Posey belongs in the hof

I wish he played longer

The most impressive thing about him is he took the starting catcher job from a Molina

When he’s been in MLB for long enough you should totally do Patrick Bailey!

Albert belle plz do a 🎥 about him he was a beast in the 90s

Gonna ask again do a Chipper jones video 🙏🏽

Dustin Pedroia technically has three rings, MVP, and rookie of the year, if you count that he played in 4 games in the 2018 season

Buster hugs were the best. I miss his presence behind the dish

Do Pudge next!!

I’d love to see an episode on Alfonso Soriano.

IT WON'T STOP BRO. DUSTIN PEDROIA

His best case for the hall is he was a catcher, 3 time champion and a mvp and Roy. His numbers aren’t hall numbers but we will see