I love documentaries about Joan of Arc .. she was the most interesting woman in history.

@s.williamc.

Ай бұрын

I agree her sister Judy of Arc was pretty boring!

I love documentaries--especially about Joan of Arc. The only problem I always have is reinforcing that being illiterate somehow means being ignorant. Illiteracy only means one cannot read or write; it has nothing to do with actual intelligence. Aside from that, I love this channel.

@s.williamc.

Ай бұрын

Mumbo agee!. Litecy nat imporceant aT oll’!/(

You have a way of telling a story that makes it come to life. I have such a clear idea of Joan as a real person, waiting to be seen by the Dauphin, telling soldiers to confess and behave, and handling herself with dignity in the travesty of her prosecution. I appreciate that you told the narrative and saved the modern interpretations for the end. Yes, I am a 21st-century woman, but I can only understand history if I can see it from the perspective of the people who lived in other times. Sometimes, I wonder what we miss in living our lives today with our minds and hearts closed to other possibilities. Thank you.

@heroesandlegends

5 ай бұрын

Thankyou for that lovely compliment!

It is so sad when people say Joan just had a mental illness. This girl was raised in a war torn land! That was all she knew. Her parents thought a king born in France would be what is best for their future so she was raised around people who fully supported the disowned king elect. She did what she thought would be best for her home and the people in it. Her story should be a lesson to us all about war. A cautionary tale we all should pay attention to because some areas of the world are looking a lot what Joan had to endure.

Another enjoyable video thanks! I think your channel's coverage of people from the past who were celebrated, but now are either not well known or worse wrongly discarded and derided by the anti-history revisionist culture today, is priceless.

I’ve seen just about every historical video about Joan, and this one is the best by far! Thank you ✌🏻

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

Wow, thank you!

@jgunther3398

Жыл бұрын

Have you read "Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc" by Mark Twain? It's written from the perspective of a childhood friend who ended up accompanying her as her scribe. It's written in the year 1492 and the writer is an old man by then. It's accurate and detailed biography but entertainingly fleshed out. Twain spent a few years researching for it in France.

How does this channel not have a million plus subs

@heroesandlegends

Ай бұрын

Thanks mate! Hopefully I'll get there!

Thank you. Another well told depiction of our history. The way your open mindedness covers all side with no bias is the best. Your segways back to the topic makes me laugh. "anyway" LOL Thank you again. Good day Sir.

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

We all carry our own inevitable bias, even when we try to be objective. The telling of history necessarily involves perspectives- of which there are many. I'm just trying to have a good time while i take you all along with me! Thanks for joining me, i hope i continue to provide quality material.

After a Scots army defeated an English army at the battle of Bauge to give the French hope that they could prevail against England, Scots became Joan's bodyguards.

@RayB1656

8 ай бұрын

That's spot on, absolutely. Patrick Ogilvy from Angus Scotland commanded the Scottish Guard protecting Jehanne la Pucelle, with 50 Scottish knights and 70 archers . Ogilvy and Carmichael, including numerous other Scottish families, Crichton, Kennedy, Lennox, Steward, Stuart, Galloway, to name a few, also fought the English troops with Jehanne ! As Jehanne la Pucelle entered triumphantly in Orleans, Spring 1429, the most famous ''March of Robert the Bruce'' was playing in the streets ! It is said that without the thousand and thousand of Scottish troops on French soil, during the Hundred Year War, (the Auld Alliance) , history might have been different ! That Scottish protection was only for the royal family yet Jehanne was included ; furthermore, she was also granted the privilege and given spurs of gold, which was a sign of royalty !

She was amazing!

We can see how modern world mankind had decayed to unimaginable low lines. Thanks for this beautiful video. 🎉

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

Thankyou! It's great to read such generous reviews!

Thank you for making this supurb history of Joan video, I keep a special place in my heart for her Thank you God bless you

I've known about this wonderful, inspiring person countless times and am looking forward to know more about her with this video. Thank you for the upload

this was so good that i listened to it on loop for several hours and at the conclusion of all this and Joans unexplained knowledge i just wonder if anybody in the crowd watching her burn ever YELLED Breathe the smoke so the flames dont kill you slowly. the irony of heroism and mediocracy never varies.

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for watching, glad you enjoyed it!

This could be titled 'Joan of Arc: The COMPLETE Story'. Really, you did a GREAT JOB.

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

Thanks so much! It means a lot!

Such a soothing channel thanks cool video topic too!

@heroesandlegends

9 ай бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for watching and thanks for supporting my channel!

Awesome documentary! Thank you very much!

@heroesandlegends

Ай бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for watching!

All film sources used in this montage are listed in the end credits. As these videos are solo efforts put together over many long sleepless hours, mistakes are quite possible - corrections are most welcome and will be posted below and in an Erratum in the description section. ERRATUM / CORRIGENDUM: 1. 1:32:10 in the video I mention the French revolution starting in 1798. Of course I really meant to say 1789. oops!

I love the still of the Monty Python crew on their quest for the Holy Grail. 😂😂

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

I try to sneak one in whenever I can!

Wow, a great doc of Jeaune D’Arc! Very detailed. So impressed with her life. Not too much was said of her spiritual visions and communication. Some little hints.

@heroesandlegends

2 ай бұрын

Thanks for watching! Yes, it's hard to cover everything in detail- and this channel has a reputation for diving down rabbit holes! Thanks for watching!

The powers that be never like to have saviors around , especially when its looks like that victory achieved.

@Laocoon283

Жыл бұрын

David and king saul

Such an insightful documentary, Thanks so much for the enjoyable narration to a truly inspiring story. Yes the rulers today will always say they follow God but to which God do they serve?🤔🤔🤔

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it!

Wow! The best thing I've seen in a long time.

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Excellent thanks!!!

Wow, this was fantastic. I personally prefer Mark Twains book over any of the movies. You've done a great job.

@heroesandlegends

6 ай бұрын

Glad you enjoyed it!

White hot charisma, appointed by a cause whose time has full come, under a selfless vehicle moves both heaven and earth in its wake. Such an inspring retelling!

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

Thanks so much!

what you did not say was. there was a prediction that she would arrive to save french from 100year war.

This video admits she was put on trial by the English, but then claims it was because she was a woman rather than because she opposed the English. They also executed a boy named Guillaume le Berger for opposing them, and he certainly wasn't a woman. There are dozens of eyewitness accounts from people who were at her trial who provided behind-the-scenes details of why she was executed (i.e. to discredit her cause and thereby discredit Charles VII as well), so the matter isn't really in dispute. The video also claims she was given a new army to lead, which is misleading on both counts: Charles VII's records show that the units in "her" army were just the same ones that had always been there, and it was always led by a nobleman (the chain of command is also recorded) rather than by Joan directly. Some of the commanders said they eventually came to accept her assertion of Divine support because she seemed to be able to predict the future accurately on a number of occasions, which led them to accept her advice; but they made the decisions and sometimes ignored her advice.

I am Deeply moved by the account and your effort to present. Thankyou!

Thanks for posting

My favorite part of the Joan of Arc story is how she was turned over from the Burgundians to the English.

@50:40 Epic winning!

So the only difference between the Nobles and the plebeians is that the Nobles kill the plebeians for acting like Nobles

@RayB1656

Жыл бұрын

... ''the purpose of religion is to keep the poor from killing the rich. It also kept slaves from revolting against their masters. '' War is 90% information. Napoléon Bonaparte.

I have a request for future content.3 musketeer. Hopefully you will make a video of it. Cheers!

♥️

@rosaliaoliver-qv3gr

4 ай бұрын

❤❤St Joan ,She knew LOVE Was the answer ,and lost her life for LOVE of her country❤❤

@heroesandlegends

4 ай бұрын

She was extraordinary, thats for sure! Thankyou for watching!

Thank you..Joan was blessed and was not enraged when she saw sinning, that is not correct and doesn't fit. Being strong with tough love is not the same as enraged. That movie portraying that is wrong. Typical Hollywood.

Keep at it, I am really enjoying your stuff. Have you considered some more modern/controversial people? Such as Christopher Hitchens?

@heroesandlegends

2 жыл бұрын

Great suggestion- so many heroes, so little time! I certainly don't shy away from controversy. But first and foremost, the labour of love that these videos demand necessitates that the subject significantly resonates with me personally. But beyond that I do consider who my viewers would find both fascinating and illuminating. We know a lot already about many contemporary heroes - so I try to focus on the more obscure or forgotten ones. From the stable (excuse the pun) of the four horsemen, I'd probably look at Isaac Asimov, partly because he is less known to people nowadays, partly because he was a trail blazer in that domain and partly because as a Gen-xer I loved his fiction writing as well. You've given me something to think about so thanks!

@Vicus_of_Utrecht

7 ай бұрын

Hitchens doesn't deserve a video.

What if she was just so incredibly infuriated with the the way things seem to work in the world that she honestly was with a fierceness unmatched willing to March yourself into battle actually hoping to die in and with Glory while fighting for something Noble and sacred and that have nothing to lose attitude gave her the edge she needed to lead perhaps the crazy person screaming Bring It On somehow Shields themselves from the catastrophe simply by attempting to embrace it full force and extreme prejudice

@jpkatz1435

Жыл бұрын

There are the Devinly inspired, She seems to be .

Its like a story from the bible.

What happened to Joan was wrong she was a brave girl who was trying to help her country

@heroesandlegends

2 ай бұрын

She was one tough kid, that's for sure! Thanks for watching!

An interesting historical figure that is not widely known is Juana Azurduy... just wanted to suggest. Thanks.

@heroesandlegends

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks for the suggestion- an interesting and very relevant figure for this channel! Thanks so much for your support and your suggestions!

Is that Ingrid Bergman in the photo ?-Ingrid also played the non singing role of Joan in Arthur Honegger's opera "Joan of Arc at the stake."

I learned a ton from this

It's important to remember when talking about the consensual age being 12 that people usually didn't live past 40 keeping that in mind makes it easier to not hate people in the past for their customs

@straytarnish9443

Жыл бұрын

And don't hate people in the future for making us live longer neither seems like back in the past you used to get all your living done between the ages of 10 and 20 before that you didn't know what the hell you were doing and after that you're on your way to death hahaha

@Laocoon283

Жыл бұрын

Why do you say people didn't live past 40 lol? If your getting that number from average lifespan statistics than your not taking into account that infant mortality skewed that number. People lived essentially just as long as we do today.

@Vicus_of_Utrecht

7 ай бұрын

@@Laocoon283 It's a stupid fucking myth, you make it passed 3 , you're making it to 60. Just as saying women were always second class citizens in all things, ummm no, that's modern day feminist revisionism. This channel committed the same sin.

She was called to do something. 🌈

Watched all of it 1:35:33

I’m sure you meant 1789 for the start of the French Revolution, but you said 1798.

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

Dammit, I'm going to go cross-eyed as well as dyslexic one of these days! Bloody hard work being a one-man-band! Thanks for picking up on it. Will post in the Erratum.

@mattrooney4904

Жыл бұрын

@@heroesandlegends Instead of complaining about that minor point, I should have commented on the quality if the video - Excellent, informative, and totally enjoyable; thanks for all your efforts.

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

No worries, its important to post corrections and I'm always happy to do so. As a creator the big challenge is being reconciled with the impossibility of a perfect production. Fortunately my viewers are overwhelmingly forgiving of the flaws. I'm glad you're enjoying the content.

55:37

very in depth.

WHY DOES KZread KEEP REPEATEDLY SUGGESTION THIS MOVIE A DOZEN TIMES IN A ROW THAT I'VE AREADY SEEN. SUGGEST SOMETHING ELSE PLEASE

@heroesandlegends

Жыл бұрын

It must be in your destiny to subscribe! Sorry, I can't control the KZread algorithm, but I'm happy to take requests for a video subject!

@Laocoon283

Жыл бұрын

Just click "not interested"

Gods Woman.

@candide1065

Жыл бұрын

XDDD

@seanmaccormack4781

Жыл бұрын

@@candide1065 laugh now cry later

Just alitte too much rye all the way around.

She's not the patroness of the woman's right movement. That's Margaret Sanger

Her situation has absolutely nothing to do with the womans movement or feminism or the fight against the 'patriarchy'. That false narrative needs to end because it's an offense against St Jeanne's Holy name as well as what she went through on the stake. *+SANCTA JOHANNA (SAINTE JEANNE D'ARC), ORA PRO NOBIS*

Love the hep Jesus pic. Power is so corrupt. Always. This is why I can't trust people. Exonerating her after death does nothing. She's dead. That's all they wanted.

It wasn't unusual for women of the time to use visions to give them authority they lacked otherwise

It's telling that you preferentially use the more woke remakes' outtakes instead of the Bergman classic.

@Laocoon283

Жыл бұрын

What do you mean when you say outtakes?

@theomnisthour6400

Жыл бұрын

@@Laocoon283 promotional stills as are often found on internet searches

@Laocoon283

Жыл бұрын

@@theomnisthour6400 Ah oh you mean the mean the video clips. You don't like the shows he took the clips from?

@theomnisthour6400

Жыл бұрын

@@Laocoon283 Having seen most of the films over the years, you can see a clear progression in the productions that reflects cult marxist politicization of the real history, which is one of the best documented instances of revelatory spiritual experiences, since it was thoroughly documented in ecclesiastical trials by both political camps and a Vatican retrial before her beautification. The remakes of the story are interesting studies in cultural marxism, going from pretty straightforward presentation of the historical facts to very politically stilted ones emphasizing feminist or pacifist themes and playing down the religious and spiritual questions her life raises. At the rate things are going, we are very like to see all replaced by an even more "woke" fantasy that makes Joan trans or non-European. I'm tired of modern divisive identity politics destroying history and poisoning naive minds with nonsense versions of what are well documented events

@Laocoon283

Жыл бұрын

@@theomnisthour6400 Yea buts it just entertainment. It's fun to put a spin on things and look at them through different lenses. Joan of arc was represented as a witch pretending to be messenger of god in Shakespeare's king henry the 6th. It's a fictional representation of a piece of history it doesn't have to be accurate.

The glorification of schizophrenia.

@heroesandlegends

7 ай бұрын

Some certainly think so

@Vicus_of_Utrecht

7 ай бұрын

All I know is OP's parents were siblings...

@Ken_Scaletta

7 ай бұрын

@@Vicus_of_Utrecht No, just somebody who has worked professionally with people who have schizophrenia or related disorders. do you think the ghosts of Catholic saints really talked to Joan of Arc? so Catholicism is the true religion then?

Sex as a weapon appears to be a major issue in the west.

Fake. As we know now from Hollywood, Joan of Arc was black. Down with those old racist movies like this one!!

@shukeelc5177

Жыл бұрын

Really? Please share the information

@mrx0088

Жыл бұрын

@@shukeelc5177 I brought the information and other similar examples, but the comment has been deleted... who knows why.

@TheWolverine01

Жыл бұрын

@@shukeelc5177 don't be this naive

@jeffscully1347

Жыл бұрын

Oh, brother. Seriously? Where do you come up with this kind of nonsense? There are statues and paintings of Joan of Arc that were created during the lifetime of her family members. NOT BLACK.

@mrx0088

Жыл бұрын

@@jeffscully1347 Again, when I post the links, the algorithm blocks my comment.

You relate the religious mumbo jumbo as if it was fact. Extremely irritating that such delusional claims aren't clearly identified as such.

@jgunther3398

Жыл бұрын

there's more to this than you realize, even leaving religion aside. thanks for the atheist 2 cents though.

@TheDoctor1225

Жыл бұрын

@@jgunther3398 It's obligatory on any video that has anything in it mentioning religion, no matter how much it applies to the subject at hand. I always find amusing that they exhibit the same telltale sign of being so closed minded in their derogatory and somewhat childish use of terms like "mumbo jumbo" and the like, as though somehow they have exclusive, absolute knowledge of all reality. As though it would take so much more effort to express the same thing but actually do it in a courteous and adult manner.