The Case For Vampire Bats

Ғылым және технология

In Latin America, vampire bats drink the blood of big animals and spread the deadly rabies virus. Cows die. People die. Ranchers want them exterminated. But scientists are discovering these bats not only have weird abilities - they also form human-like friendships. Does that mean they should be protected? Or would the world be better without them?
↓↓ Links & Info ↓↓
SUBMIT A QUESTION HERE: www.npr.org/skunkbear
SUBSCRIBE: bit.ly/2dH6fpR
TUMBLR: / skunkbear
TWITTER: / nprskunkbear
To learn more about Gerry Carter's research on the social behavior of vampire bats: socialbat.org
For More Info on bats and other interesting critters:
The Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute: www.stri.si.edu/
Credits:
Produced by Ryan Kellman and Adam Cole (@cadamole)
Senior Editors: Alison Richards and Andrea Kissack
Supervising Editor: Anne Gudenkauf
Tree loss map courtesy of Global Forest Watch (www.globalforestwatch.org/map)
Infrared footage courtesy of Gerry Carter and Rob Mies
Bat tongue: Marco Tschapka et. al.
(advances.sciencemag.org/conten...)
Echolocation: Melville J. Wohlgemuth et. al. (journals.plos.org/plosbiology/...)
Bat capturing moths: Aaron Corcoran ( • Bat echolocating and c... )
Wolves: Sicmanta (vimeo.com/105686970)
Copyright © 2017 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use for further information.
www.npr.org/about-npr/1798768...
For permission to reuse this video, visit our permissions pages at npr.org
www.npr.org/about-npr/1798815...
Music Credits:
"At Home With Me" Kuatois, Lee, Mage, and Smith/First Digital Music
"It's All Here" Adrian Williams/BBC Music Productions
"Hell Freezes Over" Patrick Sturrock and Marc Williams/ZFC Music
"Two Hermanos" Alec Milstein and Ron Cohen/First Digital Music BMI
"Shimmering Oasis" Miguel D'Oliveira/BBC Production Music
"Rise Into The Sun" by Anthony Phillips/Chappell Recorded Music Library Ltd PRS
SFX from amazing Freesound.org users:
rhumphries
man
arctura
erh
timbre
bmaczero
qat
stevenbrown
karma-ron
tjandrasounds
abouch
joebro10
13gpanska-gorbusinova-anna
thenudo
martian
deku
karma-ron
keweldog
omar-alvarado_
everheat
spoonbender
amholma
cally06
lunchmoney
stubb
lth-stp
zott820
aldenroth2
psychopancake
kingsrow
fluffayfish
xdimebagx
nemodaedalus
laurent
benboncan_
tomlija
samule44
zozzy
tdes
benboncan
lxx-70
miekyj
kwahmah
ecfike
ianoboe
tran5ient
inspectorj
yellowbear

Пікірлер: 932

  • @kristakalnins2385
    @kristakalnins23856 жыл бұрын

    I really think it's selfish and egotistical to think that the bats have to be useful to humans in order to save them, they have every right to be on this planet as much as we do!

  • @megankeller9399

    @megankeller9399

    5 жыл бұрын

    I agree with this so much. It seems like people only seem to care about conservation to benefit themselves or other people. Animals want to live just as much as we do, and THAT’S why we should save them, not based on their “value” to humans or the ecosystem. A dog is no more deserving of life than a spider. I wish more people would think like this.

  • @cherylputman7115

    @cherylputman7115

    4 жыл бұрын

    Selfish and egotistical.. That's a perfect description of the human race. We believe we're superior to all other life on earth. I think it's pretty disgusting. So, he'll no, we shouldn't exterminate vampire bats.

  • @user-if9oh6zt1j

    @user-if9oh6zt1j

    4 жыл бұрын

    @Dorset Deb why do idots like you always have to blame liberals for shit they dont agree with? There are plenty of conservatives who believe in equal treatment of animals, it's not just a liberal concern. Also wiping out an entire species of animal would be incredibly harmful for the ecosystem and the planet. We can find other solutions to these problems rather than just killing everything

  • @changingmypropiccausetrann4862

    @changingmypropiccausetrann4862

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@user-if9oh6zt1j Lol, the amount of right wingers that are that soft towards animal treatment, are very few compared to leftists.

  • @drthraxine

    @drthraxine

    4 жыл бұрын

    Do u think the same in regards to HIV virus ? Or any other harmful bacteria ? Are you serious with this Bs ? If something has no value to the echo system and it's harmful to everything it touches, it should be eradicated, it's not possible ofcourse and can't be done, but I won't sit here and listen to your moronic justification.

  • @SaltWaterDrums
    @SaltWaterDrums7 жыл бұрын

    First of all, I cannot stress this point enough: Less than one tenth of 1% of all bats in the entire world ever get Rabies (citation) You’d have a better chance of getting Rabies from a stray dog. So to suggest we exterminate all Vampire Bats because perhaps one in one thousand carry Rabies is sickening. By this same logic, does that mean we should exterminate all domesticated dogs, cats, raccoons, and squirrels, too, on the chance they may have rabies? All are potential carriers of the disease. There is also a serious assumption made here: that the bats are in any condition to feed once they contract Rabies. Unlike a “mad dog”, a bat sick with Rabies becomes not aggressive but sluggish, stops flying and dies within days of contracting the disease. The video correctly states that Vampire Bats are captured and poisoned by “spreading a toxic paste on the back of a bat, and when the bat returns to its roost the poison spreads through the whole colony”. The video also says that this is not working, and may actually increase the spread of Rabies (how this can happen is not explained). According to The Secret Lives of Bats (Tuttle, Merlin. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt : NY, 2015) another common practice, not mentioned in the video, is the use of flamethrowers to exterminate bats, and the dynamiting of bat caves. Beyond ethics, the huge problem here is that the exterminators have little to no formal training in identifying a Vampire Bat. In Latin America, the colloquial word for bat translates to “vampire”. As only three of the 1,339 species of bats are actually vampires, there are hundreds of species, including insect and fruit-eating bats, who also die during these campaigns. To start an “exterminate-to-extinction” campaign in one of the most biodiverse bat habitats on Earth could spell disaster for its ecosystem, and human health. To kill any amount of insect eating bats, many of which look to the untrained eye very similar to a vampire (small and brown) would be potentially catastrophic, due to the fact that the home of the Common Vampire is also the home of the Zika Virus. The host of the video also states that “as far as we know, [Vampire Bats] don’t play any important role. The jungle would be just fine without them”. That is an extremely irresponsible statement, because “as far as we know” is not far at all. We have no idea what purpose these bats serve, but they would have gone extinct millions of years ago, or never evolved at all, if they did not serve some purpose. So what’s the solution? The only two offered are exterminating all the Vampires, or a “hugely expensive vaccination program - you’d have to [vaccinate] all the people, cows, pigs, even the bats”. Another mistake: You would not need to vaccinate the bats - that would be akin to vaccinating mosquitoes for Malaria, unnecessary and impractical. There is a third solution, one which virtually stopped Malaria in its tracks in the same country the video was filmed: Panama. During the construction of the Panama Canal, mosquito netting was instrumental in saving lives and staving off the deadly disease. Instead of asking the government to kill things, why not petition for mosquito netting or screens on the rancher’s homes? A bat cannot bite what it cannot reach. Lastly, besides an interview with a few of the ranchers, no scientific proof is offered ANYWHERE in the video or the accompanying article, connecting vampires and these rabies outbreaks. Where is the proof? The ranchers stated only that Vampires were biting their animals (and in some cases, some children who “lived over by the cows for a while”), but not that anyone or anything had died or been infected on their ranch. The video never answers its own question, “Should We Wipe Out Vampire Bats?”. Based on the erroneous statements, factual holes and lack of hard evidence throughout the video, Buddies for Bats has to say, “no”. Before we start killing off an entire species, let’s get all our facts straight, and think hard on the role these animals do play in their ecosystem, and our planet’s. Truth Muller Buddies for Bats, Founder facebook.com/LilBrownBat Bat Conservation International Speaker’s Bureau, Certified Bat Educator since 2013

  • @skunkbear

    @skunkbear

    7 жыл бұрын

    Hi Truth - thanks for your comment - as you can see in the previous comments, I linked to your post and responded with some of my thoughts.

  • @SaltWaterDrums

    @SaltWaterDrums

    7 жыл бұрын

    I've read your responses and I thank you for taking the time to respond to Buddies for Bat's points so thoroughly.

  • @shadowthehedgehog9190

    @shadowthehedgehog9190

    7 жыл бұрын

    THANK YOU for this comment.

  • @marielenapotts848

    @marielenapotts848

    7 жыл бұрын

    Truth Muller like how long did take to type all of that?

  • @SaltWaterDrums

    @SaltWaterDrums

    7 жыл бұрын

    Marielena As the head of an organization (Buddies for Bats) that aims for accuracy, I treat these responses as articles, so a few hours to compose is normal. facebook.com/LilBrownBat.

  • @dark-baker-the-ridiculoush2912
    @dark-baker-the-ridiculoush29123 жыл бұрын

    Vampire bats are my favorite species of bats so I really do hope that we find a way to keep vampire bats safe

  • @oceanman5159

    @oceanman5159

    2 жыл бұрын

    I agree, but I basically like all species of bats for all the different reasons.

  • @bray2964
    @bray29645 жыл бұрын

    For ages, the bats have been hunting mosquitos. Then... Some bat got a crazy idea: *Let's Become The Mosquitos!*

  • @imreallybatman

    @imreallybatman

    3 жыл бұрын

    soo true lol

  • @misterm5063

    @misterm5063

    2 жыл бұрын

    you've become the very thing you swore to destroy.

  • @fumikoadullaha449

    @fumikoadullaha449

    2 жыл бұрын

    That’s why they should be exterminated I love animals but I’m not going to let them eat me or my family to me they seem like lazy entitled and aimless

  • @awrongperson

    @awrongperson

    4 ай бұрын

    to cut out the middleman, so to speak

  • @howardyates4848
    @howardyates48486 жыл бұрын

    Vampire bats don't even actively bite humans, and they are barely dangerous. Your about 10x likely to die from a mosquito than a vampire bat, don't suggest killing them all.

  • @howardyates4848

    @howardyates4848

    6 жыл бұрын

    Edit; I just went on Wikipedia, only 0.5% of vampire bats carry rabies.

  • @owenw.1643
    @owenw.16437 жыл бұрын

    love how quickly this video turned, i was starting to think the idea of killing them wasnt so bad, and then they started talking about the cuddles... now i have tears in my eyes

  • @SergioLeonardoCornejo

    @SergioLeonardoCornejo

    2 жыл бұрын

    Generally speaking, making any veryebrate species go extinct is a terrible idea. Even some invertebrates are more important than we think. Now, tapeworms and other parasitic invertebrates though, well. We must investigate further, because their existence looks like a net negative.

  • @sharonkaczorowski8690
    @sharonkaczorowski86903 жыл бұрын

    I was afraid of bats as a child...the whole get in your hair thing terrified me. Then I saw a vampire bat at the Sonora Desert Museum and fell in love! They were adorable with their little doggie like faces and tiny teeth.

  • @lisandrali.
    @lisandrali.6 жыл бұрын

    Cmon, The cuddle with other bats, How sweet is that?

  • @prixe12

    @prixe12

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@desertedanimalow the edge

  • @premlochab27

    @premlochab27

    2 жыл бұрын

    And deadly !

  • @Cooperlandsmann14

    @Cooperlandsmann14

    4 ай бұрын

    Just as long as the bats are healthy and are not sick

  • @stainlesssteel3162
    @stainlesssteel31625 жыл бұрын

    Even though vampire bats aren't a major carrier of rabies and that you're more likely to catch rabies from a squirrel, i think we should also remember to ask "who caused this?" Once again our ignorance and greed is to blame, and this is what we get for destroying and tampering with the ecosystem.

  • @HORIZONNNN

    @HORIZONNNN

    Жыл бұрын

    Rodents are less likely to carry the virus. You’ll most likely get it from domestic dogs and cats, coyotes and Raccons

  • @Jon_beetle
    @Jon_beetle6 жыл бұрын

    I genuinely teared up a bit thinking that it was the bats very ability to be social aiding the spread of poison, they just want to hug but are killing each other in the process.

  • @peterc1911
    @peterc19117 жыл бұрын

    Loved the video. Trying to kill them off will likely end up doing some unintended bad thing.

  • @mr.computer7538

    @mr.computer7538

    4 жыл бұрын

    Yah Corona

  • @mr.computer7538

    @mr.computer7538

    4 жыл бұрын

    It happend

  • @shaheedharun445

    @shaheedharun445

    4 ай бұрын

    Nah. They are a straight pest!

  • @DivineTimeline
    @DivineTimeline7 жыл бұрын

    We'd lose a model of ideal mammalian cooperation: resource economics. Sesame Street taught us this, but adults forget, it's called sharing.

  • @Randomdudefromtheinternet
    @Randomdudefromtheinternet4 жыл бұрын

    Maybe there's a way to fix this without killing them off, maybe by returning their original prey or by breeding their predators and settle them nearby villages (birds of prey mostly, maybe by raising owls to have a taste for vampire bat meat, then nest them nearby villages, that way vampire bats will avoid villages).

  • @skunkbear
    @skunkbear7 жыл бұрын

    The facebook group Buddies for Bats just posted a critique of this video - you can read it here: facebook.com/LilBrownBat/posts/1343313549089989:0 This post brings up several points that I am happy to address. First - the general critique that this video does not include various pieces of information. This piece is the longest video we have ever published, and we made it that long because we wanted to capture the different perspectives and nuanced ideas surrounding this topic. The first two minutes don’t contribute much to the story, but we felt it was important to underscore that nearly ALL bats are harmless. One big thing we didn’t have time to delve was the fact that campaigns to eliminate vampire bats sometimes take out other bat species. People think all bats are vampire bats - and those mis-informed humans kill indiscriminately, deeply damaging the ecosystem. That’s one of the reasons we wanted to be very clear about bat diversity up front. It’s also why the poison paste method mentioned in the video is employed by the government - in theory, the poison is spread by grooming, and vampire bats only groom their own species, so there is no intra-species contamination. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3060955

  • @skunkbear

    @skunkbear

    7 жыл бұрын

    On to some of the specific points from Buddies for Bats. In the video, I mentioned that efforts to cull vampire bats might actually increase the spread of rabies. That’s based on recent research from Daniel Streicker. He wrote to me “There are several hypotheses there (none of which has been sufficiently tested)” - we decided not to tease out those various hypotheses in the video.

  • @skunkbear

    @skunkbear

    7 жыл бұрын

    Another point from BfB: “You would not need to vaccinate the bats - that would be akin to vaccinating mosquitoes for Malaria, unnecessary and impractical.” People are actually working on vaccinating mosquitos in an effort to eliminate malaria and dengue: www.sciencemag.org/news/2014/10/beat-malaria-and-dengue-vaccinate-mosquitoes. Vaccinating vectors and reservoirs can be an effective way to eliminate a disease. Gerry Carter suggested we might be able to vaccinate the bats via a similar system to the poison paste - catch one bat, and have it bring an oral vaccine back to its roost.

  • @skunkbear

    @skunkbear

    7 жыл бұрын

    BfB suggested: “Instead of asking the government to kill things, why not petition for mosquito netting or screens on the rancher’s homes? A bat cannot bite what it cannot reach.” That’s a great idea that actually wasn’t brought up by anyone I talked to. It would certainly limit the loss of human life - but that’s only half of ranchers’ concern. They also don’t want their cattle to die - and their herds live outside, so they wouldn’t be protected by netting.

  • @skunkbear

    @skunkbear

    7 жыл бұрын

    In the video, I mentioned that “as far as we know [Vampire Bats] don’t play any important role.” That’s true - none of the experts I talked to could point to a specific ecosystem service vampire bats provide. It’s also true, as Buddies for Bats points out, that “‘as far as we know’ is not far at all.” That’s an important point. Our understanding of the way the world works is so limited - it would be foolish to assume we figured it out. But if you are trying to argue the case for the bats to someone who wants them killed, it’s hard to point to something specific that they do for the world. [A related question: should we only protect things that have a known purpose? I think most ecologists would say no].

  • @skunkbear

    @skunkbear

    7 жыл бұрын

    Another quote from Buddies for Bats: “We have no idea what purpose these bats serve, but they would have gone extinct millions of years ago, or never evolved at all, if they did not serve some purpose.” I think this gets evolution wrong. Organisms do not evolve to serve a purpose. They also don’t go extinct because they cease to serve a purpose. Would the extinction of vampire bats send out ripples? Probably, but we have no evidence to support that based on current science.

  • @vegetafan9922
    @vegetafan99225 жыл бұрын

    A Jamaican fruit bat "Skkrreeee,Mun!"

  • @TuberoseKisser
    @TuberoseKisser5 жыл бұрын

    We don't realize what we have till we loose them. Removing Vampire bats will show us what we lossed, especially since their saliva is being used in medicine.

  • @hartini1186
    @hartini11864 жыл бұрын

    I thought if we get bite by a 'vampire bat', we could be a vampire. Turns out, it isn't. I was sad 😔

  • @cosmicdoggo9296

    @cosmicdoggo9296

    4 жыл бұрын

    You can get a Corona or rabies thats close inuff right?

  • @hartini1186

    @hartini1186

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@cosmicdoggo9296 yeh it is for now-

  • @roastedcrickets1767
    @roastedcrickets17676 жыл бұрын

    NOOOO bats are my favorite animal, always will be, never will not be, AND NO ONE CAN CHANGE MY MIND.

  • @abigailporras5243

    @abigailporras5243

    6 жыл бұрын

    Honeystream Pancake I am on your side🤞🖖🤘

  • @Dreamsoniacxx

    @Dreamsoniacxx

    6 жыл бұрын

    I wanna join cause bats are also my favorite

  • @abigailporras5243

    @abigailporras5243

    6 жыл бұрын

    ThatOnePersonWhoLoves Fandoms you have a good heart for bat!😉😊💗💗❤❤❤💖💎✌

  • @marvthevampire3004

    @marvthevampire3004

    5 жыл бұрын

    Bats are my favorite They should eat us. there are too many people not enough bats

  • @raven7146

    @raven7146

    5 жыл бұрын

    Honeystream Pancake same

  • @kaavishnaidu9863
    @kaavishnaidu98636 жыл бұрын

    Vampire bats are also living creatures they just suck blood but we eat animals example:beef chicken pork deer.You just can,t let them die

  • @trentons2000
    @trentons20007 жыл бұрын

    It could be possible to use CRISPR to introduce a gene that makes vampire bats immune to the Rabies virus, and make it a dominant gene, having that immunity spread throughout the mating line (much like what certain scientists are trying to do with mosquitoes and malaria). Sure, it would take a lot of time, but eventually it would create an entire species of vampire bats that can't spread rabies. It could prove insanely beneficial, preserving both the livestock addressed here, as well as saving these vampire bats from extinction.

  • @AnalkingSkinwalker69
    @AnalkingSkinwalker694 жыл бұрын

    I think vampire bats have an important role To keep away humans from destroying the jungles

  • @KQEDDeepLook
    @KQEDDeepLook7 жыл бұрын

    Terrific video as always! Are we talking about wiping out the local population / subspecies, or an entire species? How close is the nearest relates species of vampire bat (if any?)

  • @skunkbear

    @skunkbear

    7 жыл бұрын

    I think the ranchers would say - whatever works! Unfortunately, current efforts to poison local populations don't seem to stop the spread of rabies - in fact, they might have the opposite effect. One solution would be to completely eradicate the entire species - but of course, that would be nearly impossible. How would you get to all the bats? Who would fund it?

  • @skunkbear

    @skunkbear

    7 жыл бұрын

    There are three species of vampire bat - two that primarily feed on birds (Diaemus youngi and Diphylla ecaudata) and then the hero of our story (Desmodus rotundus) who prefers mammals. They all have a pretty similar range, though I think Desmodus rotundus is much more abundant because it has access to all that free food. There are some accounts of the other species switching to mammal and even human blood now that bird populations are dwindling.

  • @KQEDDeepLook

    @KQEDDeepLook

    7 жыл бұрын

    Thanks!

  • @emilyharp3120
    @emilyharp31205 жыл бұрын

    We watched this in science class today, and it changed the minds of many students of how they view the vampire bat. Thank you!

  • @shaheedharun445

    @shaheedharun445

    4 ай бұрын

    They are a straight pest! Are you going to force your class into sympathizing for serial killers next?

  • @jerrygu5316
    @jerrygu53167 жыл бұрын

    Sure they have an ecological role, keeping them pesty humans away from the jungle.

  • @johncharles3907

    @johncharles3907

    2 жыл бұрын

    hahaha

  • @mintykiwi

    @mintykiwi

    2 жыл бұрын

    judging by what people are doing to jungles rn i would say it's a pretty important role (although there are people who do traditionally live in the jungle, they know how to take care of it and not you know destroy it for resources)

  • @chrissim4115
    @chrissim41156 жыл бұрын

    "Drive them to extinction" Perfect humans are good at this 😒

  • @jaundicehinch

    @jaundicehinch

    3 жыл бұрын

    VERY Good.

  • @mikylafleming9058
    @mikylafleming90587 жыл бұрын

    I like bats

  • @marielenapotts848

    @marielenapotts848

    7 жыл бұрын

    Mindy Fleming so do I, my favourite species is the long eared bat 🦇

  • @raven7146

    @raven7146

    5 жыл бұрын

    Mikyla Fleming me too

  • @KakorineReal

    @KakorineReal

    5 жыл бұрын

    @@marielenapotts848 mine is the vampire bat

  • @Rassenomatjutut

    @Rassenomatjutut

    5 жыл бұрын

    Me too (although it's thanks to mr. Bruce Wayne); it's not the bats who want to harm us, it's humans who are uncapable to interact with them.

  • @muhammedm1998

    @muhammedm1998

    4 жыл бұрын

    I like Humans more than bats.......

  • @pusheenbuttercup8319
    @pusheenbuttercup83193 жыл бұрын

    Honestly I think eliminating "rabies" would be the best approach, not just for vampire bats but all the other animals they spread that to. Bats aren't the only thing that get it after all. I'm sure it is very expensive and would take a lot of work- but long term solutions are often better, right? Obviously of course I can't say where in the heck you'd get the money from, and getting human beings to all cooperate and agree is difficult enough as it is... but it certainly sounds worthwhile to me.

  • @blueberrychocolate4238
    @blueberrychocolate42383 жыл бұрын

    I love bats, and seeing people question whether or not to just exterminate a species hurts.

  • @Rytonic69
    @Rytonic694 жыл бұрын

    That's so sad, that the poison spreads from bat to bat because they like to hug it out!

  • @MrGweilo
    @MrGweilo7 жыл бұрын

    Skunk Bear your videos never EVER disappoint. It's such a delight, every time

  • @spaniardlex8222
    @spaniardlex82224 жыл бұрын

    5:05 He just rolls up and says "Mmmm mm!! I love me some pork chops!"

  • @Dragonmongamer

    @Dragonmongamer

    4 жыл бұрын

    Spaniard Lex bat: especially the juicy pork chops

  • @ostrich3335
    @ostrich33352 жыл бұрын

    I love them so much they’re such cute little bats

  • @willemvandebeek
    @willemvandebeek7 жыл бұрын

    difficult question that remains unanswered... :-/ But I am in the 'do not wipe out'-camp, because you can ask the same question about mosquitos, (which suprised me that comparison wasn't made instead of wolves)... yes, they are parasites, but they are also part of an eco-system, who knows what you will eliminate with them...

  • @cosmicdoggo9296

    @cosmicdoggo9296

    4 жыл бұрын

    Killing of mosquitos is well if people knew how to do that we would have done it a long time a go

  • @NessaTheBat1
    @NessaTheBat15 жыл бұрын

    It's a great video. I love bats and they're amazing. I don't think that exterminate them would be good. The relationship between humans and wolves get better too. It's very cute how they act with each other.

  • @SergioLeonardoCornejo

    @SergioLeonardoCornejo

    2 жыл бұрын

    I think there must be a way to erradicate rabies without eliminating the entire species. It may require raising a clean populatin in restricted territories and culling the infected ones though.

  • @Become-Eggplant
    @Become-Eggplant6 жыл бұрын

    If you get rid of vampire bats, how is batman going to get his daily dose of "Traumatize me because I'm terrified of bats"? As well as filling up the Bat cave.

  • @LukeVelly
    @LukeVelly6 жыл бұрын

    Blame Columbus!

  • @AkilahOsa
    @AkilahOsa3 жыл бұрын

    I learned a lot from this short video, I really didn't know any of this stuff, but I wish to know more. So I'm going to do some more research. Because I really do like bats.🦇

  • @OrionInskip
    @OrionInskip6 жыл бұрын

    Do you know what other species serves no beneficial purpose? Humans.

  • @crazygreninja1150

    @crazygreninja1150

    5 жыл бұрын

    Livestock in farms are mostly for our source of food. Other that they do nothing to us. Humans call them very useful.

  • @MadamePianissima

    @MadamePianissima

    5 жыл бұрын

    So im guessing you completely forgot wildlife preservation exists. P.S. Pandas would be extinct if it wernt for humans .

  • @MC-qc9iz

    @MC-qc9iz

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@MadamePianissima humans wouldn't have cut many of their habitat, so who knows. And then, that's just nature, species just vanish because they haven't learned how to adapt to a new environment... So no, humans in that sense serve no beneficial purpose. Yes, we can "balance" a specific area through hunting (with the right plan I mean) and other things, but in a natural perspective... No, we being on top of the chain do not serve some sort of beneficial purpose. We think we control nature, but that's not the case: we're ruining it, we're polluting our planet, exploiting our planet.

  • @MadamePianissima

    @MadamePianissima

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@MC-qc9iz You literally just contradicted yourself. Lmao

  • @luisalonso959

    @luisalonso959

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@MadamePianissima we erradicate more than we save.Pandas are still alive cause they are cute and harmless compare to any other kind of bear.

  • @Checkmate___
    @Checkmate___4 жыл бұрын

    "bats love to cuddle" that's the cutest fucking thing I've ever heard in my entire life

  • @DanieleTrapani
    @DanieleTrapani7 жыл бұрын

    Amazing episode, thanks Skunk Bear!

  • @mikedearing7736
    @mikedearing77362 жыл бұрын

    So vampire bats need to be useful to ‘us’ in order to be worth saving? That’s ridiculous Loved the video btw

  • @mrkewi1

    @mrkewi1

    Жыл бұрын

    well that's out selfish, greedy humans for you.

  • @thespaceace8164
    @thespaceace81646 жыл бұрын

    What didn't Columbus fuck up?

  • @fireamber5027
    @fireamber50276 жыл бұрын

    Batman is really important too

  • @bobkarh
    @bobkarh5 жыл бұрын

    "How are vampire bats useful to us?"...' I would answer with another question: What would it do to us,as humans, if we took them to extinction?, Do we want more blood in our hands?, Is that how we deal with problematic living beings?, "if it's not useful then it has to go"... The conservation of vampire bats is useful because it help us maintain our humanity.

  • @justintouchon2726
    @justintouchon27267 жыл бұрын

    Awesome video Gerry! Skunk Bear, thank you for telling such a compelling and interesting story.

  • @DjProfiK
    @DjProfiK3 жыл бұрын

    Who are we to play god and decide to drive a species to extinction Edit: except mosquitoes they gotta go

  • @williamcole960
    @williamcole960 Жыл бұрын

    As a non-rancher, these little guys are my favorite and I think they're very cute so I say, don't kill them(-:

  • @blackironman4947
    @blackironman49474 жыл бұрын

    Vampire Bats: Coronavirus hehe. Batman: Am I joke to you😂

  • @babehunter1324
    @babehunter13246 жыл бұрын

    But if we lost them... Where would Future Predators evolve from? :'(

  • @robrodriguez9243
    @robrodriguez92434 жыл бұрын

    They are so cute! them feeding eachother and cuddling ❤️🦇❤️🦇❤️🦇❤️🦇

  • @HORIZONNNN
    @HORIZONNNN Жыл бұрын

    Wiping out a species because they aren’tuseful is not gonna do anything. Vampire bats are not the only species to carry rabies. Domestic stray animals like dogs and cats can spread it too. While it’s expensive, I’m all for vaccinating the entire cattle population and the people where these bats inhabit. I love these cute little bats. They really are just like us.

  • @nigel-b
    @nigel-b3 жыл бұрын

    For thousands of years they weren't a problem ?!? ... the first vampire bats evolved around 26 Million years ago ... they've been here ... not being a problem ... a lot longer than humans

  • @Rex-lg6co
    @Rex-lg6co4 жыл бұрын

    "Most bats are harmless" Covid-19: Are you sure about that?

  • @gamercinderace5030

    @gamercinderace5030

    4 жыл бұрын

    The bat thing is a rumor, plus, if it were true, they were eaten, they didn't bite.

  • @OverBankOscar
    @OverBankOscar Жыл бұрын

    “Should humans wipe out this species?” What sort of question is that. These are the type of people I don’t think deserve what they have.

  • @ValexrockerX29
    @ValexrockerX29Ай бұрын

    Hearing “Taking me into the batcave” is cooler than it should be

  • @BatArtDays
    @BatArtDays6 жыл бұрын

    Dont kill them!!!!!!

  • @TheGamingVillas
    @TheGamingVillas7 жыл бұрын

    Honestly, wiping out one species usually isn't that great of an idea. No one really knows what damage can be done until after it is done. Still I don't see any purpose that vampire bats serve.

  • @tesserisfour

    @tesserisfour

    7 жыл бұрын

    TheGamingVillas do you have a "Serve"?? of course not you're just a kid who lives in a City you just buy food and pollute the world

  • @TheGamingVillas

    @TheGamingVillas

    7 жыл бұрын

    excuse me? Are you seriously arguing I'm useless so vampire bats should be left alone?

  • @tesserisfour

    @tesserisfour

    7 жыл бұрын

    TheGamingVillas yeah humans are the problem we come here destroy other animals habitats and shit on them just like you but still some animals are useless like mosquitoes yes they pollinate but we have bees and butterflies and unlike humans we don't serve a purpose we just shit on the earth

  • @TheGamingVillas

    @TheGamingVillas

    7 жыл бұрын

    XxSlayerKillzxX people are more important than animals

  • @tesserisfour

    @tesserisfour

    7 жыл бұрын

    TheGamingVillas tell me why??

  • @johncharles3907
    @johncharles39072 жыл бұрын

    The world is just cooler with more diverse animals, we need some animals to inspire Dracula stories as well

  • @amhodson
    @amhodson7 жыл бұрын

    Awesome work. Again. Keep it up. I run a philosophy class at my high school. This is a perfect prompt for a needed conversation.

  • @nickc3657
    @nickc36577 жыл бұрын

    As someone with access to rabies vaccine and closed-window housing, I'm pretty sure I have no right to ask these people to suffer for the sake of biodiversity. Ultimately there's no easy answer here, it's a messy situation :/

  • @anthonycraig4698

    @anthonycraig4698

    6 жыл бұрын

    Nick C fuck those ranchers hope less than 1 percent of v bats have rabies

  • @charlottewalnut3118

    @charlottewalnut3118

    5 жыл бұрын

    Yeah as someone who gives no shit about ranchers i want them sent to north korea

  • @maxsilbert
    @maxsilbert7 жыл бұрын

    I don't know, the bats are damaging these farmers livelihoods and I don't think the romantic argument justifies doing nothing about them

  • @hitokitty

    @hitokitty

    7 жыл бұрын

    I was wondering this myself. Wolves are at the apex of the food chain they're in, causing massive changes to the ecosystem. Bat's aren't in this same position, and we're only talking about one species here. Arguing with a romanticized point against the hardships of these farmers, including the rabies risk seems to be grasping at straws. Unless the scientific community can offer more substantial reasons to keep them around, similar to the anticoagulant, I don't see the people of these regions sympathizing much.

  • @BernardoSutter

    @BernardoSutter

    7 жыл бұрын

    max silbert I'm not sure talking about ethics and about what's right and wrong is merely romantic. There are some things that have inherent value without being useful. Those bats need to be kept in check, but I don't want to have to tell my children that the famous vampire bats once really existed.

  • @SolaceEasy

    @SolaceEasy

    7 жыл бұрын

    These farmers are damaging the vampire bats lives, but do provide the bats with livelihood too.

  • @geraldcarter2216

    @geraldcarter2216

    7 жыл бұрын

    Killing vampire bats can actually increase rabies prevalence and have bad public health effects in the long-term. Better to vaccinate.

  • @anthonycraig4698

    @anthonycraig4698

    6 жыл бұрын

    max silbert yes then we should exterminate​ those pesky humans every last one of those disgusting sacks of waste

  • @TranslucentStudios
    @TranslucentStudios7 жыл бұрын

    Another informative entertaining video from you. Thank you so much. Keep them coming.

  • @justinabullard
    @justinabullard7 жыл бұрын

    Another beautiful video, please keep them coming!

  • @carolinatiepel2747
    @carolinatiepel27477 жыл бұрын

    They should have asked these farmers: How many people in your area died last year from rabies after a vampire bat bite, how many after a dog bite and how many were killed by a fellow human being?

  • @sirfijoe450
    @sirfijoe4506 жыл бұрын

    Literally only 0.5% of vampire bats carry rabies

  • @haf816r
    @haf816r6 жыл бұрын

    The bats and trees were there long before the invasive species (people, cattle) came in and destroyed their habitat. Plus they're cute! Lol!

  • @hynesshigh5818
    @hynesshigh58186 жыл бұрын

    *after knowing that bats treat each other like families and how useful they are makes don't want to hurt them*

  • @stephenleblanc4677
    @stephenleblanc46774 жыл бұрын

    Nice video. I wish you answered the question posed. What is the range of vampire bats? Are there ways to control the bats around people/livestock that don't threaten the survival of the species.

  • @littlemrpinkness295
    @littlemrpinkness2953 жыл бұрын

    They have little piggy faces. So cute!

  • @lpsecco3940
    @lpsecco39406 жыл бұрын

    Maybe they could do like that guy did where he put out that bat feeder full of blood. And they could put one near the caves. So the bats have no reason to find blood some where else. Just a random idea.

  • @Chairchaser6677
    @Chairchaser66774 жыл бұрын

    This video is making crying because seeing a vampire bat trapped in a cage and another vampire bat coming in and feet it this is such a beautiful scene

  • @SolaceEasy
    @SolaceEasy7 жыл бұрын

    So more cattle equals more vampire bats. They want more cattle. Doesn't that mean more vampire bats? How about eat less beef, and meat, world.

  • @skiiimsk
    @skiiimsk4 жыл бұрын

    The “vampire bats are bad narrative” could also apply to humans lol

  • @Tomha
    @Tomha5 жыл бұрын

    Wouldn't it just be possible to create some Sonic Device that repels Bats? We have the technology for Mice/Rats.

  • @senantiasa
    @senantiasa4 жыл бұрын

    Aww, that was heartwarming... I can't believe to find vampire bats adorable now.. LOL

  • @Ihamed20985
    @Ihamed209853 жыл бұрын

    I mean if we don’t know their role yet doesn’t mean they don’t have one, maybe we just didn’t discover it yet??? Really great video btw

  • @e-krabse.t3498
    @e-krabse.t34986 жыл бұрын

    wow that just blew my mind this video was just plain out amazing i did't know they did that cool

  • @moosbruger
    @moosbruger3 жыл бұрын

    I loved bats from my early age.

  • @KGisthename
    @KGisthename6 жыл бұрын

    Awesome video! Subscribed!

  • @MUtley-rf8vg
    @MUtley-rf8vg7 жыл бұрын

    This video is just packed full of so much awesome.

  • @ThorirMarJonsson
    @ThorirMarJonsson3 жыл бұрын

    That was a wonderful video!

  • @virtuousglean7216
    @virtuousglean72166 жыл бұрын

    Is there not a way to put nets around the animals at night? Like humans do sometimes if they go camping, they put a mosquito net around their bed.

  • @cherylputman7115
    @cherylputman71154 жыл бұрын

    Walk into a dark room with vampire bats AND........... Cue the creepy squeaking door! Lol

  • @alexwilson6513
    @alexwilson65136 жыл бұрын

    That was really interesting, thank you!

  • @rebeccashapley3029
    @rebeccashapley30295 жыл бұрын

    This is the best vampire bat video I've found.

  • @batsrule
    @batsrule2 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for the info ❤️🦇

  • @ashleybelldubai
    @ashleybelldubai6 жыл бұрын

    Awww they feed one another 😭❤❤❤

  • @xmazorax8075
    @xmazorax80756 жыл бұрын

    I've seen many cute bats and even the scary ones are harmless the animals never feel a thing and how much blood can such a tiny thing hold

  • @BoogedyBobby
    @BoogedyBobby2 жыл бұрын

    "Children wake up with bites on their feet" I don't know where on earth other than an island where the only life form is a worm that doesn't have sleeping bags.

  • @Rassenomatjutut
    @Rassenomatjutut5 жыл бұрын

    3:26 Thanks for opening the Pandora's box, captain Columbus.😐

  • @electricbuttercup7954
    @electricbuttercup79544 жыл бұрын

    Vampire bats aren't the only thing that can transmit rabies, killing of vampire bats won't stop rabies. We need a treatment for rabies not mass extermination of a whole species. I think vampire bats are beautiful and they deserve to live

  • @Weredawg
    @Weredawg6 жыл бұрын

    Great video! Cool to see my home country being featured.

  • @dolphinsdaydreams
    @dolphinsdaydreams5 жыл бұрын

    Very wise words of Dr. Gerry Carter.

  • @ladyturantulo
    @ladyturantulo7 жыл бұрын

    How about learning how to get rid of rabies before wiping out a species?

  • @fashioneyefromthestraightg9984
    @fashioneyefromthestraightg99844 жыл бұрын

    I actually enjoy all types of species of bat I enjoy learning about them I even try to build bat houses for them

  • @kupkake433
    @kupkake4336 жыл бұрын

    Here's an idea for the rabies vaccination thing or whatever it was I forgot for the bats take a few from each colony and do almost the same thing as the poison but without the poison obviously

  • @Elimenator89
    @Elimenator892 жыл бұрын

    its always when something dies out they find they did have a purpose creating a new problem

  • @eazythedon54st
    @eazythedon54st4 жыл бұрын

    Awesome Video!

  • @SkkyKiddx
    @SkkyKiddx6 жыл бұрын

    You guys need more subscribers.

Келесі