The "only choose one" scenario isn't Luke trying to impose on Grogu. It is to make Grogu decide What life he wants to lead. Both, the ways of the Jedi and the ways of the Mandalorian are life style and life long ideals that take total dedication. Even Yoda was still learning about the ways of the force hundreds of years after becoming a Master Jedi. Luke knows that he can't make Grogu a Jedi if he has the heart of a Mandalorian, and he knows it must be Grogu's choice.

@jamesmohan7301

6 ай бұрын

As far as we know there was only one Jedi who managed to balance both. He was a Jedi but also very much Mandalorian. That Jedi was the first wielder of the darksaber, last name was Vizla As far as we know, in both canon and legends we've never had a Mandalorian Jedi before or since then

As soon as I saw that silhouette walk across the desert, the hat... when Cad Bane's hat came into view, "Oh, no. Nononononononono THE WHOLE TOWN IS GONNA DIE! RUN!"

Honestly this is one of my favorite episodes of Star Wars ever

Grogu was so attached to Mando, that´s why Luke told him to choose. The Jedi path forbids the attachment.

@Jon_FM

11 ай бұрын

Yeah even if I disagree with it, Luke and Ahsoka are following the code and it insists that attachment leads to fear, anger, hate, and suffering if you use the Yoda argument. Keep in mind that the Fen Rau explanation has the Mando in armour but there is no reason he would have because likely he was a baby (unless the rules were different in the longer past). The Visla's stole the sword from the Jedi temple so the Jedi Visla likely never went back to Mandalore. That is more a Mandalorian tradition. Personally it is sort of sad that this is my favourite episode of Boba Fett but honestly they gave us so much Luke I really do not care.

@IggyStardust1967

11 ай бұрын

"Only a Sith deals in absolutes" - Obi-Wan Kenobi (to Anakin Skywalker). "You must choose!" - Palpatine (to Anakin Skywalker) "So much like your father." - Ahsoka (to Luke Skywalker) All of these things are connected. Think about it... it was the blind arrogance of the Jedi Order that caused their fall 30 years (or so) before this scene. While I understand Luke's intention, to find out if Grogu could overcome his attachment... was this REALLY a good idea to force him to choose? We've seen Grogu use "dark side abilities" before... and while we've been told (through other media) that none of the species has ever turned to the Dark Side.... could we be seeing the beginning of the first time it happens? Or was this choice simply setting up for Grogu to not be at the temple when Kylo Ren wipes it out?

@joumasepoes88

11 ай бұрын

This is inaccurate according to the way Luke sees things. He gave Grogu a choice because of 2 reasons. Not simply because of attachment. 1 was to test to see if grogu was thirsty for power and 2 because grogu is young and Din Jarrin is middle aged and will be dead in a very short time vs grogus aging process. This tested his love and loyalty towards a father figure which Luke so horribly failed with Owen Lars and surely regrets. Luke knows when Din dies grogu can resume training and will have only aged a couple of years according to his species lifespan.

@nathandts3401

11 ай бұрын

​@@crewchief5144That was purely for reproduction purposes and also very dumb.

@nathandts3401

11 ай бұрын

Disney have done great things with Star Wars, ignoring the 9th movie. One of my favourite things is that they're very big on pointing out the flaws of the Jedi. High Republic is peak Jedi Order, Last Jedi pointed out all the issues fans had with the Prequel Jedi, they've explored Dooku's issues with them. I've got pretty high hopes for the Rey movie they're making.

You missed it, but Grogu wasn't jumping to keep up with Luke. Luke was force pulling him along. You can see his hand make the gesture.

@Nighthawk1066_

11 ай бұрын

She realised later

This is actually my favourite episode of live action Star Wars television. You have no idea how emotional it was to see Ahsoka interacting with Luke, the son of her Master Anakin Skywalker. It was such an incredibly big deal when this episode came out.

In respect of the choice and Luke’s comments about Grogu’s lifespan, in my mind he was indeed saying “…you could spend time with Mando, and pick up Jedi training after.”

A very underrated episode of Star Wars media.

@hoopa_axolotl9293

11 ай бұрын

It was a great episode, but the reason everyone doesn’t like it is because most of it should’ve been part of season 3

@MikeKennedyNFL

11 ай бұрын

*over, if anything

If I remember correctly, Tarre Vizsla didn't walk the Mandalorian path. He was a Jedi with Mandalorian blood, but he didn't walk the Way. It was his descendants/fellow Vizslas who stole the Darksaber and co-opted it into Mandalorian traditions. So, from a certain point of view, there had never been anyone who followed both the way of the Jedi and the Way of the Mandalore.

@11:10 Twilight?! It should've reminded you of The Empire Strikes Back. When Luke is training with Yoda, carrying Yoda on his back, running through the swamp, lifting things, flipping over rocks, etc... This whole training sequence is one big nod to Empire. "Don't try. Do" is a reference to what Yoda tells Luke. "Try not. Do or do not. There is no try."

@raybernal6829

11 ай бұрын

Yeah thought same 🙁

8:27 I think this might be interpreted as R2 seeing Ahsoka as "the kid". I don't know if that was the idea, but the thought makes me warm inside.

"Not me actually crying, did ya'll cry in this?" 11:19 .... the "Sunset Binary" theme playing... Luke Skywalker... Grogu Of course I cried. The first time I saw it and again today

Mando saying "Hello friend" made me laugh as it reminds me of Boba when he was introduced in the Holiday Special.

When the stranger came slowly walking was truly badass

Luke is following the "attachment rule" because of Vader, probably. It was because of attachment that Anakin went to the Dark Side. Seen Cad Bane in live action for the first time was really damn cool. When it comes to this show, that might be my favorite episode, which is weird because Boba Fett barely appears in it.

@jennym2276

11 ай бұрын

It was because he wasn't allowed attachments. If the Jedi hadn't been so against it, he could have shared with them his fear that Padme would die. Although her death was only an image put there by Palpatine, it wouldn't have been planted because Anakin would have been able to discuss things with the Jedi about his fears.

@JP-yf2fk

11 ай бұрын

There's also the fact that Luke almost fell to the dark side due to his attachment to Leia

@timmooney7528

11 ай бұрын

Differing philosophies. The Jedi order is a monastic order, where possessions and family connections weigh you down. The Force is all you need, and your objective is to become one with the Force. To the Mandalorian, it is the opposite. Strength comes from loyalty to family, and they are defined by their skill in use of their possessions. The Beskar steel is a metaphor - overcoming adversity makes you stronger just like steel becomes stronger under the hammer and in the fire.

It's amazing to me the ease and relaxed way younger fans react to seeing Luke. To people who grew up with only the Original Trilogy, and were basically adults for the rest of the movies and shows, seeing Luke young again was a freak out moment. Some fans cried, others cheered, but his appearance was nearly universally moving. Given the time we are in, that's just remarkable. This is the Luke we wanted to see ever since the end of ROTJ, a powerful and wise jedi master who was the hero we all looked up to as kids. No matter what happens... Filoni and company gave us this, and I think I speak for a lot of fans who will be forever grateful for this episode.

Cad showing up here is the only time I can recall literally jumping out of my seat.

Im a grown ass man. I cried so hard when mando left that had to pause it for a whole day

In the Grogu's Vision, you can see Barriss symbols on the wall. These are her rooms, this is where she fought Anakin in the Clone Wars. Filoni said he has plans for her and this ester-egg may suggest that Barriss will return soon.

@jacktheflash8478

11 ай бұрын

She has two rooms? I wonder what she did to earn that

@hehu4025

11 ай бұрын

@@jacktheflash8478She got a second room probably because she was a perfect student.

There’s very good reason for the Jedi way being non-attachment. Anakin’s entire fall into Darth Vader was because of his attachment. Luke’s complete failure at Cloud City was because of his attachments.

@ahmedal-somail4657

11 ай бұрын

And Luke saved Vader because of his attachment to him luke in the expanded universe built the new Jedi academy with a new thinking love and attachment wasn’t a bad thing it was a good thing and it was successful but Disney came of course and change everything that’s way a lot of people didn’t like Luke in the sequels because he did the same mistakes the older Jedis did and now the Rey movie will explore that hopefully Luke will be a big part somehow because it was his storyline or people will hate it

@JuliusNovak_

11 ай бұрын

Very true in EU of Star Wars Luke did let his padawns have attachments and Tarre Vizsla was a Jedi his whole life remember mandalorian used to be a race of people and the reason the dark saber gets heavier with each attack is because of the curse put onto the dark saber by house Vizsla which made it have a flatter blade

@Commander-vf1lk

11 ай бұрын

@@ahmedal-somail4657Not to mention because of 1 Jedi, Anakin chose to let millions or even billions of people around the galaxy to suffer. Several planets under the Empire. He condemned many worlds & allowed many to suffer including the Clones who served them before being decommissioned. All those lives died in vain, all for what they thought was right… He robbed so many lives of others including those who were born during the Empire’s time for his own because of his attachment. The Emperor & his so called Empire had reformed the education of other planets. Because the Emperor won, after the Clone Wars, they wrote their own truth in history making them the so called peacekeepers (good guys) & the Jedi the enemy to the public. Overall, Anakin, selfishly chose his life above others. All paid the price & none of them had to if he hadn’t intervened Mace Windu. Also if Qui-Gon didn’t die. Imagine those who weren’t born during the Clone Wars. The Empire is the world you live in. Because they rule, many would think the Empire is good to ensure peace & stability. Being born & told those lies all your life sucks. Just kids being told & reading books in their schools that the Jedi were evil as they tried to overthrow their way of life.

5:17 Luke looks better in this one for many reasons. One it didn’t have to be a secret anymore they brought Luke back and another thing they brought in some other designers as well as using more designers. That’s the problem with surprising people with a character cause you don’t want a lot of people working on it so there’s less chance of leaks. 6:31 Id love to see Grogu’s digestive system. To be able to eat an animal whole that’s close to your full size. 7:15 Luke is using the force to help Grogu keep up with him. You could see Luke use his hand making the motion to move Grogu forward. 17:36 he’s older than Boba Fett by probably 15year at least. 19:02 yeah you did in the episode that showed Boba stopping their train and had them in the sand talking. 19:44 that’s called chain mail made of Beskar so he’d be protected. 20:12 cause choosing both will give into attachments that the Jedi don’t believe in. The armor will always make him think of Mando. 21:53 they have to follow the Jedi teachings. It’s all black and white with no gray area.

If there was a more perfect half hour of Star Wars in any form, I don't know. John Williams playing in the tree tops, Ahsoka, Luke, R2 and ending with Cad Bane... Such a grin inducing episode. :D

1:14 who will we see in this episode today Producers: “Yes”

Emme, you're killing me. The "don't try, do" is a callback to Yoda saying "Do or do not. There is no try." And Luke running through the woods with Grogu on his back is a callback to Luke running through the swamp with Yoda on his back.

No attachements, It seems you don't learn the lesson Darth Emme.

This episode is definitely one of the best episodes of the D+ Star Wars shows of all time. Better deep faked Luke, Cad Bane, Vanth… it had everything.

Hi Emme, i just wanted to say thanks. I am really enjoying rewatching "The Book of Boba Fett" with you. :o)

"I hope it's not too scary." Proceeds to a flashback of Operation: Knightfall, part of the Great Jedi Purge in which Vader led the 501st Legion in an attack on the Jedi Temple. It was concurrent with Order 66 and often mixed into it. First Cad Bane reappears in The Bad Batch for the first time in years, and then he makes his live action debut here. It was an epic return of the character.

19:50 'tis properly called a hauberk - a shirt made of chainmail.

I think Mike Myers should voice adult Grogu. "Get in my belly! I'm gonna eat you!!!"

11:10 It should be reminding you of Luke and Yoda on Dagobah in the Empire Strikes Back. 13:08 No mixed feelings. Just tears.

So awesome you got Cad Bane!

The best part of your reactions is when you say "Let's GOOOOOOOO!" 🙂

"I feel like I'm getting my hopes up too much just hoping we see Grogu." Sees: Grogu, Luke, R2-D2, Ashoka and Cad Bane. Yeah, this was the spoil us rotten episode.

Ahsoka and Luke are old school Jedi (when convenient!) following the defunct Jedi Counsel’s decrees!

1:30 "Now eventually you do plan to have Boba Fett on your Boba Fett show, right?"

Yep I cried too. This was a very emotional episode for many reasons.

I think Cobb Vanth knew who Bane was, he just didn't want it to be him cos he knew that he didn't have a hope in hell of out drawing him if it came to that and that's why he looked at his deputy when he walked out and was trying to help, Cad Bane outdrew jedi on several occasions

Cad Bane is assigned a birth year of 62 BBY by Wookiepedia. That makes him 71 at the time of this episode. He'd have been in his very late 30s during the Clone Wars. and his very late 50s during the time of "Star Wars: Rebels". Yes, you've seen a Pyke without their helmet, back when Boba met with the Pykes to try to collect their fee for using the Sand People's territory. Amazing episode. My only wish was to have seen a longer dialog between Luke and Ahsoka. She'd be like kin to him. You're quite right, though, to wish for more Boba Fett. I kind of wish they'd have assigned the war council dialog of Fennic to Boba. I really like Fennic, but this is Boba's show. I also agree regarding the potential for Grogu to become the second great Mando-Jedi.

Luke making grogu choose between mando and jedi way is another reason why luke in the old canon is so much superior. The whole attachment thing was handled so much better. Thats why luke became the most powerful and wise jedi ever after the plot of the movies... Sad

This episode was AMAZING,made lots o us cry as well as mando s2 finale

Fun Fact: They got the original voice actor Corey Burton to voice Cad Bane.

Attachment. A Jedi can't have attachments. When they do, it tempts them, and can lead them down the same path Anakin took.

11:11 Seriously? It reminds you of twilight? Not Empire Strikes back where Luke carried Yoda?

It was surreal to see Ahsoka and Luke interact. Also it meant a lot that she said that he was so much like Anakin. As in the Anakin she knew which was the best version of Anakin.. By the way all clone wars fans lost their mind when they saw Cad Bane

I Emme, I am super excited to see this episode with you!!!!👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽I knew you be very pleased to see live action Cad Bane for the first time. You were close Emme, it is "Chain Mail". The X-Wing pilot in the last episode is Luke's body double, too. They used the Deep Fake guy in this episode to improve Luke's appearance. That episode went by sooooo fast! We know that the person that wielded the Dark Saber was a Manalorian and a Jedi. Fans are wondering if that is Grogu's destiny at this point in the series. Great reactions to episode six, Emme!!!!🎬👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

Cobb Vanth is hands down one of my favorite characters. Also, I never thought they were gonna incorporate Cad Bane. Fun fact: Lucasfilm hired a KZreadr named Shamook to work on de-aging Luke. You can find a video of his edit on the Season 2 finale of The Mandalorian online.

Jedi have the ability to view possible futures. They fear losing those they are attached to and it clouds their mind. So much so that they panic when they invision their death. (Anakin with his mother and padme) Jedi are not only powerful in the force but are powerful emotionally as well. This is why they can not be attached. So Grogu must choose. The cool thing is that Luke gave him a choice. The old Jedi Counsil would not have.

Actually, the only Mandalorian to be a also a Jedi was Tarre Vizla (the one who created the darksaber) so it's not a common combination - on the contrary, it's unique. And since then, Mandalorians and Jedi have been well distinct, also given the clashing ideals. I believe it's only fair, while sad, that Luke gives that choice to Grogu, explaining exactly what would mean to take one or another way.

Grogu spent years training at the Jedi temple. He is remembering more than Luke is teaching. Grogu has had more years of training than Luke has had . Luke knows this. Grogu must decide to be Jedi or Mando. The fact is Grogu already is a Jedi as far as training. Luke is what 20-22 years old here. Grogu is 50.

Don’t mess with boba fett destroying everything, but you care cad bane

Cad Bane's 71 now.

Cad Bane was like 72 in the book Of Boba Fett

Dont worry im a full grown man and i cried when Mando left the planet

being a mandolorian isn’t the problem, it’s his connection and attachment to mando

I don't love the writing choice to have Luke force Grogu to choose right there and then, but he can't be both at the same time. Mostly the writers needed an excuse to get Grogu and Din back together for ratings purposes AND keep Grogu from being slaughtered by Ben Solo/Kylo Ren.

@timmooney7528

11 ай бұрын

During the Clone Wars remember Obi Wan was given the choice of leaving the Jedi order to be with Satine Kryze, duchess of Mandalore.

@hardybryan

11 ай бұрын

@timmooney7528 the jedi always have the choice to leave. My issue is with Luke saying 'hey your dad stopped by, choose right now with no warning or time whether you want to stay or not'

The Jedi way of shedding all attachment is dysfunctional from the roots. It was this detachment that kept Anakin from being able to return to his mother for a decade. It was also Jedi detachment that forced Anakin's love affair with Padme to remain secretive. The Jedi Order was detached from reality and cloistered in tradition and archaic philosophy. The fact that Luke is rebuilding the dysfunction back into the New Jedi Order condemns it to the same fate as the old.

I just KNOW that You're gonna enjoy this Episode, Emme! Grogu, Ahsoka AND R2D2!

I know it wasn’t on the table but I would like Grogu to be with Mando but also can he please have that lightsaber? Nobody else will need one that size.

He can't do both. If he gets strong in the force and then Mando gets himself killed or something before Grogu is ready, we have a new, short Darth Vader. At least Ahsoka and Luke would be super scared of that happening. So right our wrong, this is EXACTLY what Luke and Ahsoka would do. It's the whole reason Ahsoka wouldn't risk training Grogu. Too nervous about making a new Darth Vader.

Attachments usually lead to negative emotions which in turn can used to temt jedi to the darkside. Anakin is a prime example. Attached to his mom and padme, and his feelings were manipulated and tempted him towards the darkside. Now not every jedi with attachments go dark, and not every ideal jedi stays with the light, but it make sense that eliminating one source that can lead to the darkside can help minimize jedi from turning. Plus with all the emphasis on attachment for Grogu, if they did what you wanted then we would probably be seeing a Drath Grogu in a future show/movie. Lolololol

One of the coolest episodes. Proves Dave Filoni should helm all of Star Wars. He cares about the fandom and lore.

@obiwankenobi687

11 ай бұрын

Nah, he pulls out some good stuff every now and again. But the whole of Star Wars? Absolutely not, no thanks.

@tiago_s_

11 ай бұрын

@@obiwankenobi687 better than KK

@obiwankenobi687

11 ай бұрын

@@tiago_s_ Well KK has never written any Star Wars has she so the comparison is sort of moot

Grogu has some much potential for his life, that why i personally think he would make a great jedi, but its Grogu's life, he decides what to do with, Luke is just giving him the choice to do whatever he wants for his life, whatever he chooses to do with it he will great.

I think luke following the jedis rule on attachments is complicated. On the one hand he is trying to brimg the jedi back and what he knows is somewhat limited. Though having ahsoka there certainly helps fill some gaps. Seeing that attachment is what caised anakon to fall probably colors his perception of it, but also attachment brought Vader back at the end. There are merits to the ways Jedi did things. There is clearly some room for improvement since what they did lead to the order falling in the first place.

Mandalorian or Jedi? You cant ride 2 horses with one butt... That being said... I think Grogu is the "Chosen One" to bring "Bring balance" between the Mandalorian and the Jedi... I don't think he can reach the full potential of his destiny without being both...

Being force sensitive and receiving training to be a force user in SW is difficult to compare with anything in our existence. Imagine if there were a few dozen people (on planet Earth) who were powerful force users and how precarious that could be for all of humanity. There would be so many people/organizations whose entire strategy for success would be centered around manipulating the emotions, desires, and fears of force users. I think the temptation is to think of it as strictly an individual's philosophical or theological debate. For instance, can a military person rationalize fighting for a nation and also be a Buddhist or Christian or whatever religion? But, the sheer amount of superhuman abilities force users have, makes it a far different existential problem for all of humanity and not just what the individual is able to rationalize for themselves.

mr dave felion has made the episode

Don't worry, Emme! If You've seen any OTHER Reaction Videos for this Episode, there were a BUNCH of people crying!!! Lol

Luke is making Grogu choose because, as Din said, the two ideologies are fundamentally opposed to one another. Now, that being said, this is a mistake on Luke's part. Clinging to the old Jedi ways that gave rise to Darth Vader.

This is after Shamook was hired as Senior Facial Capture Artist at Lucasfilm. If you didn't know this guy did it better than they did, so they hired him. kzread.info/dash/bejne/qaZ8uqNrk7bWfrg.html

This is the cameo episode. Everyone makes a cameo, even Boba Fett. 😃

It really says something that the best episodes of the Boba Fett show have exactly zero Boba Fett.

@tiago_s_

11 ай бұрын

It says a lot about this series

Marshall is not strong enough, but But I can’t say that

10:48

Sry to repeat. This is in one of the replied comments. I just want to share my personal thoughts on this for everyone to understand my perspective. ​​⁠While the no attachment” rule sucks, I can’t disagree. Hate it actually. Remember, because of 1 Jedi, Anakin chose to let millions or even billions of people around the galaxy to suffer. Several planets under the Empire. He condemned many worlds & allowed many to suffer including the Clones who served them before being decommissioned. All those lives died in vain, all for what they thought was right… He robbed so many lives of others including those who were born during the Empire’s time for his own because of his attachment. The Emperor & his so called Empire had reformed the education of other planets. Because the Emperor won, after the Clone Wars, they wrote their own truth in history making them the so called peacekeepers (good guys) & the Jedi the enemy to the public. Overall, Anakin, selfishly chose his life above others. All paid the price & none of them had to if he hadn’t intervened Mace Windu. Also if Qui-Gon didn’t die. Also, “but Luke’s attachment brought Anakin back”, ok… so how many already paid the price before Luke did, Anakin came back to the light & everyone else? Imagine those who weren’t born during the Clone Wars. The Empire is the world you live in. Because they rule, many would think the Empire is good to ensure peace & stability. Being born & told those lies all your life sucks. Just kids being told & reading books in their schools that the Jedi were evil as they tried to overthrow their way of life.

Mandalorian and Jedi philosophies are categorically opposites.

hello

asking so many questions during the reaction...that will usually be answered moments later

Is it just me or does Rosario Dawson mimic Ahsoka's mannerisms, hand motions, and what not to a T?

This is my favorite episode of The Mandalorian so far. And it's not even a Mando episode!

The spice comes from Dune. But it’s much cooler in Dune. Watch Dune.

By the time grogu chooses to go back to Mando, he's already been training for 2 years. So there is a time jump.

I know people love the idea of having Jedi powers, but how many people actually would want to live the Jedi way? You are basically a monk. There is nothing wrong with that way of living, but I certainly couldn't do it

Ahsoka, Luke, both part of the problem at this point. Trying to keep an out of date way of thinking intact. The Jedi were wrong about so many things and old Luke was wise enough to see it in TLJ Shame Disney keeps promoting the Jedi order as the good guys

Actually, between The Mandalorian 2x8 and Boba Fett 1x6, two years passed according to Favreau and Filoni. Luke saw the same conflict Ahsoka saw. And both know what happened to Anakin. So Luke as a teacher had to make sure that Grogu's heart is fully open for the Jedi way.

A Jedi must not form attachments. Except, the only Jedi to survive, had attachments.

@ghost-iv8gt

11 ай бұрын

attachments which almost drove him to the dark side

Thanks, Emme! 🎋 The Jedi tradition of non-attachment doesn't seem workable... but there's historical basis for it. Kind of like the same reason surgeons aren't allowed to operate on family members. Emotions can cloud judgements. But I think, sometimes, they can also clarify. Perhaps sequel trilogy Jedi will find a better way? #EmmeReacts #StarWars #TheBookOfBobaFett #CobbVanth #Grogu #AhsokaTano #LukeSkywalker #CadBane

Yeah I didn't care for the whole choose a path thing for grogu. I get the old jedi way was all about attachments being dangerous but Luke proved that to be false in the og trilogy. He chose his friends and the path of the jedi and ultimately used his attachment to his father to bring him back from the dark side. I don't understand why they would change his character and make him follow the path of the previously failed jedi order

Why can't Grogu be both? That upsets me too. I get why Luke and Asoka, both having dealt with Anakin to Vader, believe that attachment is a problem. But I personally feel that's placing the problem in the wrong spot. Anakin, or anybody, could have been manipulated in other ways. There are many Sith that were turned for other reasons in Star Wars lore. This runs down the same path as Stick's philosophy in Daredevil as well. If you love something, it only gets in the way and keeps you from becoming who you should be. I believe Stick was wrong and DD was right in that one too. It doesn't specify it in the films, but in other sources, not all canonical so treat this as conjecture, the reason Qui Gon was not on the council is because he believed the Jedi were wrong on this point and attachment in love was a good thing. Oh well. It is what it is and I don't get mad at Luke or Asoka for doing what they believe to be the right thing even if I think it's messed up. Keep having fun. I love that you have the same wide-eyed wonder that I had with these.

Only reason Grogu had to choose is because Disney butchered Luke's character so much... In the original timeline, his first students came from all kinds of backgrounds, cultures, species, familial status, ages... and attachment was actively encouraged. You could be a Jedi, and still have a family. Love is Light. It only becomes darkness when, like darkness itself, it consumes you - if there is nothing left of you when you lose your attachments, then shall you fall. But recognise them for what they are, and they will be a great source of strength. Original timeline Luke recognised this, and made it the foundation of his New Jedi Order, realising the failings of the Jedi of the "Golden Age". Disney Luke, however, falls into all the same traps as the Masters of old.

20:17 sadly, Luke is repeating the mistakes of his masters. He believes attachments are to be avoided. What should be taught instead is how to deal with loss healthily. There is no good reason to make Grogu choose other than it’s the Jedi way.

Cobb Vanth stood no real chance against Bane, but looking away like that in a gun fight is the most contrived, horribly written garbage ever.

That style of armour is called chainmail. *Spoilers* Very disappointed with how they handled Luke here, he was originally supposed to be doing things differently from the Jedi (it was his compassion for his father that redeemed him after all) but instead they've had him make the same mistakes just so he can fail for the sequels.

@mareiramv

11 ай бұрын

Spoiler.

@MikaelLima2210

11 ай бұрын

Compassion is not against the jedi code. In fact, it's an essencial characteristic that is valued by them, like its pointed out by the conversation between Ahsoka and Aayla Secura during TCW. But *personal* attachments are what they are against, as it tends to be valued more than the greater good, which is (or at least should be) the purpose of the Jedi as keepers of the peace. That's one of the reasons why Yoda gave Anakin a padawan, as he needed to learn to let go. Not saying that I agree with their reasoning, but that that's how I see their views on attachments.

@tiago_s_

11 ай бұрын

Facts

This is my own understanding of the jedi, so don't take it as canon, more like interpretation. Jedi was never against a jedi having a family. What it was against was having attachement to the family. In both legends and Canon Ki-Adi Mundi, member of the jedi council, had a family. He was of a race that had problem with getting male members. On average, 1 in 10 children was male. Therfor, for the surviveability of his race, it was costums for a male to have multiple wifes and as many children as possible. If I remember correctly, Ki-Adi has 4 wifes and 8 kids. All 8 were females. In the situation of saving your family and letting 50 other people die, or saving 50 people and letting your family die. The Jedi should always save the 50 people. The Jedi should do the best thing for the galaxy as a whole. Even if that meant letting yourself die. This was lost, and after years and years turning into the police force of the senate, which lead to their own destruction. In legends, Luke later lessened in this hard rules against relationships. Himself got married and had a son. This is no longer canon, but we will find out in the future if aspects of this will be turned into canon again.

The only really good episode of the series..Dave filoni

Before the Blue devil guy shows up Cobb vanth was about ready to tell the bartender about the pike shootout

@MrKevinFHaney

11 ай бұрын

Next episode pure epicness sis 🎉🎉🎉

Rosario Dawson as Ahsoka she is so awesome I can't wait for the Ahsoka season 2 start I have spoken

Luke not being able to see the little guy forever no no

Yeah I know I leave a lot of comments and yes we all cried all of us and if a person didn't

Wooteedee 🎉🎉🎉 let's handle this 💞