Please consider adding this book to your collection. The more places wisdom is preserved, the better!
www.amazon.com/Birth-Modern-W...
KNOWLEDGE VALUE INDEX (KVI)
Audience scores:
Goodreads: 3.8/5 stars
Amazon: 4.3/5 stars
Critical evaluation:
"The Birth of the Modern World" by C.A. Bayly is a comprehensive and ambitious work that offers a fresh perspective on world history during the long nineteenth century, spanning from approximately 1780 to 1914. The book challenges traditional Eurocentric narratives and presents a nuanced, global analysis of the complex interplay between various societies, highlighting their contributions to the development of modernity.
Bayly's work is praised for its sprawling scope, covering a wide range of themes and geographical areas, while also providing stimulating ideas and insightful comparisons. The reviews emphasize Bayly's ability to weave together political, economic, and cultural transformations, offering a balanced and nuanced account of the period.
One of the central arguments of the book, as noted in the reviews, is that historical processes were driven by multiple causes originating from various parts of the world, rather than solely by the emergence of modern Europe. Bayly asserts that the rise of Europe was less pronounced and occurred later than most historians suppose, and that globalization during this period was multicentric.
The reviews also highlight Bayly's attention to the role of state power, nationalism, and religion throughout the nineteenth century, challenging the notion of a purely secular age. His comparative treatment of major upheavals, such as the Taiping Rebellion, the Indian Rebellion, and the American Civil War, is commended for its ability to counter exceptionalist tendencies.
While some reviewers may find certain aspects of the book lacking, such as its treatment of Latin America, Africa, or population growth, the overall assessment is that Bayly's work is a groundbreaking and invaluable contribution to the understanding of world history during the long nineteenth century. The book's wide-ranging scholarship, engaging arguments, and thought-provoking insights make it essential reading for anyone seeking to comprehend the complexities of the birth of the modern world.