Might be over analysing, but that brief "don't skip ahead" before he asked her made it appear as if he had already played out the scene (or dream in this case) in his mind and knew the outcome. Incredible writing in any case.

@EobardFerguson

4 ай бұрын

It felt like in the script he was talking to himself, but the actual scene he said it to her. Personally I think it would've worked better if he said it to himself, that shows more your point of him having played it out in his head many times.

@blessmybag

3 ай бұрын

It was also sort of like "don't skip ahead" a different way of saying "let me finish, don't worry know how this ends" agree with you there...

@Sierra-Whiskey22

Ай бұрын

That world is missed.

"Well, there goes that dream." This is so painful and yet so beautiful.

@DrAbShahed

Жыл бұрын

and that would be reality.

@lifeissweet9826

Жыл бұрын

That line surprised me. Dominic was not dumb. Remember when he said to siobahn, are we in France now? About eating more nicely. And using the word touché. Neither of them knew it waz French. Dom knew thjngs. He was an enigma. Misunderstood.

@ramblinjack1797

11 ай бұрын

“So painful and yet so beautiful” is the Irish artistic ethos in a nutshell.

@antojames9387

9 ай бұрын

@@lifeissweet9826 Dominic was not dumb. He was mentally unstable because of the constant abuse of his father.

@Turnoutburndown

8 ай бұрын

Stop breaking my heart, movie

Barry Keoghan went into my top 5 fav actors with like 3 performances. This guy is a monster

@no_longer_

5 ай бұрын

Same, i love his ability so much, he doesn't need to show the audience the big anger, big sorrowful to prove he's a good actor himself. His ability is the amount of delicate, detail he gives off for a short scene, it's meticulous.

@herdina7

4 ай бұрын

Did you see Saltburn? Madness. He should be a serious contender for the Oscar.

@tomnewton6231

4 ай бұрын

@@herdina7 not yet but soon thanks for sharin lad

@TaurinoEX

4 ай бұрын

I agree, this guy has a great future

@ftlbaby

4 ай бұрын

Indeed. Green Knight. Eternals. Banshees. Saltburn.

The script note ‘she shakes her head, as kindly as she can’ is just fantastic writing and the performance to boot. What a movie.

How none of them got an Oscar is beyond me. What a moving and spectacular performance by all of the cast.

@captlanc

Жыл бұрын

It was a good year for movies. Competition was great. Tar didn't get anything as well.

@Drumming_Monkey

Жыл бұрын

@@captlanc good point.

@aldrinaldrin4618

Жыл бұрын

Looks like Oscars has been compromised by China's money. The other movie "Everything all at once", it's good but not Oscar worthy in my opinion. BAFTA is more trustworthy now

@captlanc

Жыл бұрын

@Aldrin Aldrin Lmao China doesn't even get EEAAO. Michelle Yeoh's win is controversial in China starting from golden globes because Michelle's nationality is Malaysian and not Chinese. You're just racist. BAFTA isn't trustworthy for not awarding EEAAO. The Brits have always preferred dramas and musicals over comedies.

@Stuart267

10 ай бұрын

@@captlanc Wow! Race card pulling is unparalleled. Its documented FACT that awards in general are all politically driven. Cry fucklng harder. Awards don't mean shlt anymore because people don't win based on talent but on their skin colour #FACTS

This movie was profoundly moving. I was captivated by the entire cast. My sincere thanks to them all for their dedication and hard work to make this film.

@Charles-mv7sv

Жыл бұрын

More like a purposeful trainwreck, captivating and something you never want to see again. so cringe youre kinda curious how lame it is...

@JCMcGee

Жыл бұрын

Yup....that's the phrase...profoundly moving.

@ShadyPlatinum777

8 ай бұрын

@@Charles-mv7svstick to marvel movies mate real cinema isn’t for you

@thiswhoweare1949

8 ай бұрын

​@@Charles-mv7svsure loser

@conephompany

3 ай бұрын

i liked the animals. i felt bad for jenny.

“Go do that thing over there I was gonna do”. Jeez, I just got that reference. Such a sad arc for this character, but so well done. I think, if there are any victims in this movie, it’s him. That other scene where he says “that’s probably the meanest thing I’ve ever heard” and looks completely devastated about realizing who is friend really is was also really got me.

@SomethingGamecatAdjacent

5 ай бұрын

Is it implied that he kills himself?

@db5094

5 ай бұрын

​@@SomethingGamecatAdjacentyeeep

@SomethingGamecatAdjacent

5 ай бұрын

@@db5094 well now im all sad

@faithlucas4092

3 ай бұрын

I just caught that, that was the moment of his ultimate decision 😢….. so much sadness, so profound. Like any movie or role he’s in wins, no matter what else it does.

@alexh8503

2 ай бұрын

OMG.. that's grim.. over the rejection? ​@@db5094

That head movement after 'well, there goes that dream'; as if waking up from the dream....incredible touch.

Superb characterization by Barry! The finger-twisting and eye movements express the tortured turmoil he's experiencing. Then, that soulful, " Well, there goes that dream. " Jesus wept.

Heartbreaking scene. I was blown away by the dialogue and the acting..

@drinfernodds

4 ай бұрын

Barry Keoghan is brilliant in this. You know inside it hurts but he was already prepared for rejection. It gave him the go-ahead to drown himself since there wasn't much for him to live for.

Never heard of Barry Keoghan before this movie and when I watched this scene it was the most heartbreaking moment in film I had ever watched. I couldn't believe his talent.

@shelbywells4624

3 ай бұрын

Same!! Omg his performance was incredible. Horribly heartbreaking

@aaronforsythe8556

3 ай бұрын

He always plays a character that's off in some way and usually does it really well

@dawnkikong637

3 ай бұрын

He's also excellent (and very creepy) in Killing of a Sacred Deer, also featuring Colin Farrell.

@TheTasneemali

Ай бұрын

Watch killing of a scared deer.. his performance is epic in that film as well❤

Wow, now that I've seen this again, it really does feel like he was ready to off himself here, but ran into her and it changed his mind for a moment. Like, realizing that Padraic wasn't as nice as he thought was what initially made him lose all hope. But running into her gave him a spark of hope that he knew was highly unlikely but just wanted to give it one last shot. Unfortunately, he was right, there was never any hope for him. I can't believe I missed it the first time I watched. I genuinely thought the prediction of the old woman of two people dying would be Jenny and Colm. Turns out, it was Dominic.

@joewood5757

Жыл бұрын

and arguably Podraic

@kithu1231

Жыл бұрын

And the Adorable donkey

@aldrinaldrin4618

Жыл бұрын

It was Colm in the end. If he could cut his fingers off just for Padraic talking to him.. he could kill himself when Padraic starts to make Colm's life a living hell. In the end you'd see the old lady also holding the stick while staring at the body of water. The old lady kind of resembles death but with a hook to fetch dead body from water instead of a scythe.

@joebees21

11 ай бұрын

And when his dad tells the lady in the post office that some fool drowned himself earlier.

@Tangvu

9 ай бұрын

You were suppose to miss it the first time you watched it, that's a sign of great writing. No one knew what he meant when he said he was going to back to do whatever it was he was going to do, it could've been anything, benign or otherwise.

I can only hope we see more of him so he can show his range. His acting in this movie was incredible.

@mjinba07

Жыл бұрын

Talented guy, astonishing range. He was in Dunkirk, The Killing of a Sacred Deer, Chernobyl...

@AriffRed01

9 ай бұрын

He's everywhere nowdays

@SuperNils666

9 ай бұрын

well he's the Joker for the new Batman so look forward to that

@sheya5402

8 ай бұрын

even in that mediocre marvel movie he was incredible. Would really love to see more of him

@TonioToutBeau

7 ай бұрын

@@sheya5402 that's funny :)

This scene is like..... devastating. Like, when I saw it, I was laughing at first, but then something about how kindly but bluntly she turns him down just breaks my heart

@drinfernodds

4 ай бұрын

I think it's because it's the right balance of kind and firm for that scenario on top of Dominic knowing that "No" was going to be the only outcome. Siobhan lets him down easy, but leaves no doubt that she will never feel romance for him.

Key Hua Quan deserves the world, but look at this boy, bro gave his best act in this movie, & Banshees of Inisherin didnt get any oscar.

@maximiliancordedda1492

Жыл бұрын

agree. huge respect for Ke's comeback and all, but in terms of acting Barry was the better one

@playermartin286

Жыл бұрын

Barry was miles ahead and so was kerry condon for that matter

@horsemann7354

Жыл бұрын

​@@maximiliancordedda1492 Kerry and Ke were not competing in the same category

@maximiliancordedda1492

Жыл бұрын

@@horsemann7354 I mean Barry

@johansmallberries9874

Жыл бұрын

True. This was transformative acting. Key Hua Quan basically played himself: sweet, charming and earnest. But it wasn’t a big transformation.

This is just an incredible film. The fantasy of being with her, getting himself to where he can express it and then seeing the futility of it all expressed here is some of the the best acting I've seen in a really long time.

To me the most impactful line is “no, yeah, no. I was thinking no”

It's so weird, how the "There goes that dream" line in the script has an exclamation mark at the end, yet it is just so much more impactful with the way Keoghan says it. Maybe i'm reading into an exclamation mark too much, but it feels like he captures the emotion behind the line better than the script does.

@dawnkikong637

3 ай бұрын

He almost tosses away the line just as the dream must be discarded.

That line was so good it pulled me out of the movie, and I thought to myself that is the best delivered line in the history of cinema.

This is such a great film. A few years ago I started watching Irish made films and I have found them to be fine, rich, powerful things imbued with passion, tragedy, humor and heart.

@DUANEYAISER

Ай бұрын

My four favorite adjectives describing the Irish arts.

Possibly, one of the greatest movies of the last years. Every character is important.

His character broke my heart. This whole movie was such an experience. I wish I could go back to 2022, to that little theater I went to after a 12 hour day, and see it all over again. I wish movies like this happened more often than every other year, but maybe they wouldn't be so special.

should've won best picture and screenplay imo. It's so beautifully sober and poetic.

@skaboard3119

Жыл бұрын

wasnt sober at all, had quite a few scenes that took place in pubs

@maximiliancordedda1492

Жыл бұрын

@@skaboard3119 🤣

@playermartin286

Жыл бұрын

And best supporting actor and actress

@maximiliancordedda1492

Жыл бұрын

@@playermartin286 indeed

@jeffscheiner1553

Жыл бұрын

Agree on both counts.

Watching this scene in the cinema, I felt like I'd been kicked in the guts, truly winded by the unbearable, subtle emotion of it. Kerry and Barry's acting - so real.

Barry keoghan is genuinely my favorite actor currently. Just incredibly talented

This young actor's performance in this scene is something special.... Powerful and resonant. Talent!

The ripping of the heart portrayed perfectly

Her reaction shots are minimal but wonderful,she's being kind but hurting him at the same time.

this movie should have win best original screenplay, i love EEAAO, but this script goes to straight to the heart, such a simple story going big and crazy, lovely

@linn1607

Жыл бұрын

Agreed, the laundry and taxes line is great and all but banshees script feel more balanced and rounded

@GregoDoblaje

Жыл бұрын

Oh, most certainly. EEAAO is good. This is a masterclass in screenwriting.

@itcouldbelupus2842

Жыл бұрын

For sure

@maurobengoechea

Жыл бұрын

It would've been definitely well deserved too, I agree. But in my opinion, the overall craziness and originality of EEOAO made it worthy of that prize. I, however, would've given Best Director to Banshees.

@TheNotthediver

Жыл бұрын

@@maurobengoechea honestly opposite, the direction in Everything Always was perfect and the screenplay in Banshees was perfect

This scene . So beautiful and sad and humerus , heart wrenching . A masterpiece..All in one scene . Lost count of how many times I’ve watched this . Barry Keoghan…….bravo young man .

The most heartbreaking part of the film... hopelessly devoted... I've already cried here inconsolably because you immediately know where he's going...❤

This performance rips out my heart every time. Agonizingly perfect.

This scene just broke my heart when I saw it.💔 What a talented young actor.

This guys blow up is not at all shocking after seeing this movie. I’d never seen him before and when seeing this movie in theaters I was completely blown away. His performance in this was outstanding 💔

As an Irish Islander- this guy’s performance is easily the best portrayal -with his candid emotional sincerity showing through a common Irish demeanour that we call ‘skeety’ where I live.. And though it would refer to sketchy folk - and despite his off-putting quality that is likely a representation of autism when it wasn’t identifiable.. there are many people I know who fit the categorization who are as kind hearted, and witty as his character. Kinda like how Mickey in Snatch turns out to be the cleverest - that kind of guy. Irish slang and prononciation can make the smartest people sound less intellectual also imo tbh. Irish ‘street smarts’ and eccentricities always shine brightly. The one who appears to be s burnt out Irishman or Newfie can give you the best advice ever, be the best friend you have- common it is for sure. Also I wonder how it sounds to non-Irish people who are unaware ‘never’ and ‘ever’ mean the same thing.

@TheRedhenProductions

4 ай бұрын

I’m Irish myself and I’ve never heard anyone called skeety before, whereabouts is that used?

@quackerzdb

4 ай бұрын

​@@TheRedhenProductionsCommon in Newfoundland. I never knew it had Irish roots.

@s.z.2101

2 ай бұрын

This is so so fascinating !! love hearing about all the unique qualities of language and culture especially with how they vary from larger regions v.s. smaller more isolated areas. cheers from california! 🇺🇸 Would absolutely love to visit one day if I could. Ireland has always seemed so beautiful and inviting to me - would love to see and experience especially more of the local parts if I could

Barry's deviations from the script are ALL big improvements e.g. he does not emphasize "that" in "There goes that dream" as the script does, which would've been much worse. "Should have planned this really" is a great ad lib not in the script. He also cut the part about "bony little feet" which seems tonally wrong for the scene. Barry knows what he's doing.

@MrLethalShots

Жыл бұрын

"Should've planned this" was in the script, also an actor doesn't get to choose which lines he says and which he doesn't 😂 more likely some were cut in the editing room. But I like your first point 😁

@alextttttt

Жыл бұрын

@@MrLethalShots That's true but he did add "really" to "should've planned this" which is an improvement (edited comment to reflect that). I get that the actor doesn't have the final say but Barry likely ad-libbed the modifications (since they're not in the script) and McDonough liked them and kept them. In contrast, Kerry Condon's lines are delivered exactly as written.

@Ryanrea2002

Жыл бұрын

@@MrLethalShots An actor actually can choose, if they have a good relationship with the director and confidence in their abilities they'll almost certainly give a different iteration

@MrLethalShots

Жыл бұрын

@@Ryanrea2002 Sure thing, but that's the exception, not the rule.

@Ryanrea2002

Жыл бұрын

@@MrLethalShots A very common exception

I love getting surprised by movies like these. Watched it having no idea what it was beforehand, was blown away. Such a good movie.

This guy's performance in this movie was something else. I did not expect Brendan Gleeson and Colin Ferrell to be outdone by anyone, and yet... frankly all the actors in this were incredible!

There’s a lot of praise for Barry in these comments, and rightfully so, but Kerry does her part so naturally and with such subtlety, the slight crack in her voice as she responds with ‘i don’t think so’ - conveys the sorrow so central to this film that we cannot choose who we like to be with

What an actor

what great acting, so much was said in those few sentences, his whole life laid bare for her, Hollywood wouldn't understand anything that just happened between them, truly great writing and interpretation of the screenplay,

This story had so many emotions. This was a lovely written scene.

Wow hard lines to pull off without sounding a bit goofy but he did.

Don’t know if anyone noticed in the beginning of the film Dominic asking Padraic what he thinks they use the hook for and at the end the old woman uses one to pull him out of the water

She shakes her head as kindly as she can. EMOTIONAL DAMAGE!

This dude is in like half the movies I watch, and I adore it. Keep em coming, Barry. You’re a genius

incredible writing and masterfull performances by all actors in this movie. Masterpiece 👏👏👏👏👏

Barry is a brilliant actor with such a bright future!!!

Barry Keogh just makes your heart bleed in this. His talent paired with Martin McDonagh's writing means it's a winner.

she shakes her head as kindly as she can

Best bit of the film.

Wonderfully crafted character writing and amazing acting to match its splendor. Magnificent!

"Look at this I found! A stick with a hook. What would you use it for I wonder? To hook things that are a length of a stick length away..." I knew the kid was doomed. Chekov's hooky stick.

I'd forgot how bloody good he is in this.

Best actor in the world.

Simply one of the best movies of the last decade(s).

I loved EEAAO, and don’t begrudge it any of the Oscar wins it got. But I do wish Banshees had won a few that night. I thought for sure it would at least get best original screenplay.

@bartafterdark900

Жыл бұрын

Genuinely feel the academy were too thick to appreciate the genius of this film and all its components

@Nonviableaccount

Жыл бұрын

Let’s be real, Banshees was 100% white people and an Irish production. 0 chance that wins any awards up against a Hollywood funded Asian American project.

@randywhite3947

6 ай бұрын

@@bartafterdark900they appreciated it enough to nominate it

Such a GREAT actor

i dont know why this resonated with me so much, when the "fall in love with a boy like me, would ya" line hit something uniquely genuine was there

Bloody roller coaster this film. It’s soo soo good

It’s, simply put, one of the best scenes I’ve ever seen in any film. Ever.

This movie, even though not set in Ireland really reminded me of Hemingway’s writing. The strong performances, script, the pastoral landscapes, the accents… this scene though… it’s the perfect “iceberg theory” on screen. There is so much going on in this scene but only a small percentage of it is visible. When you realize he was on the way to kill himself, it makes it much darker. His story was the most tragic, seeing his one crush at the end and her rejecting him.

@owendispensa8953

Жыл бұрын

*even though set in Ireland.

Barry Keoghan is the new Sam Rockwell. Just a complete chameleon of an actor. So versatile.

The range of this guy is amazing

Our favorite line of entire movie was, "Well I'd best go over there and do whatever that thing over there I was going to do was." Just perfect from a pathos, humor, etc etc. Amazing actor. Amazing cast all the way around. Favorite movie of the year.

@daphneglasurus7886

Жыл бұрын

He’s referring to offing himself, I think.

@davidcolistra3897

Жыл бұрын

@@daphneglasurus7886 No doubt, yes. Thanks. So much wrapped up in that line. Especially considering we had no idea that was what was going to happen when he said it.

Heartbreaking. What a performance!

Spoilers alert: In the preceding scene, the inspector harshly confronted her, criticizing her appearance and asking, "Who will like you?" The following day, she contemplates his words while sobbing on her bed. The next morning, on the verge of taking her own life by jumping from a rock into the sea, Dominic intervenes, confessing his feelings for her. Touched by his declaration, she finds solace in the realization that someone loves her. Empowered by this newfound positivity, she decides to pursue her dreams, rejecting Dominic in the process. Heartbroken, Dominic, realizing he can never be with her, tragically ends his own life by leaping from the same rock into the sea. The poignant contrast lies in the unexpected turn of events, with the one preparing to die ultimately surviving, while the one who seemed to have hope succumbs to despair. It's a captivating and emotionally charged scene, contributing to the beauty of the overall movie.

@Annavslv

4 ай бұрын

Bro i was crying while watching this scene, Dominic is such a sweetheart like i wanna hug him and be his friend man you know? And after the ending like i prefer to think that he just fell and it was an accident and not suicide…

@donaldfiddes2096

4 ай бұрын

Well fuck, thanks for ruining the movie I've not seen

@misteral1083

4 ай бұрын

@@donaldfiddes2096 I'm usually quick to complain about spoilers, but in this case, I think you would have needed to read an awful lot before you got to an actual reveal

@nilaypatel849

4 ай бұрын

@@donaldfiddes2096 I am really really sorry. My bad🙏

@nilaypatel849

4 ай бұрын

@@Annavslv yes. I would also like to think the same.

There's a lovely and heartbreaking madness to this gem of a film. You laugh one minute, you cry the next. There's just so much "there" there. IMHO, it should have swept more like EEAAO did, though it was a good film. Didn't hit me like Banshees did though. Aaaaand, it's been too long a while since I've been back to Ireland, so there's that, lol.

Barry Keoghan killed it in this and also The Killing of a Sacred Deer. I’d like to see much more of his art.

Thank you, BAFTA for giving recognitions for these both incredible actors.

Played so beautifully by Keoghan. He’s my new favorite actor.

The guy is just a monster actor. I watched it at the cinema and then again at home.

This the only clip I have ever seen of this movie and I am crying!

He has my Oscar.

I watched for the first time "The Whale" and "The Banshees of Inisherin" today. What can I say? This movie deserved the Oscar af

Most memorable scene in the move imo. The film is excellent and memorable. It does a great job in developing secondary characters.

I got SO SAD in this moment…..the movie’s end just shattered my heart 😔

He is so heartbreaking in this scene

Everyone in this film is giving career best performances, the excellent and economically poetic script certainly helps.

Isolating the scene like this makes me REALLY appreciate the dialogue and the performances. So beautiful. "There goes another dream". Who doesn't know that feeling?

"Don't skip ahead"😄 love this. He does a brilliant job of this part. Funny, sweet and sad all at once ❤

This movie had everything great yet so disappointingly underrated, Barry Keoghan has such great potential, hope to see more of him especially as the joker.

@aurwood68

Жыл бұрын

Whaaaaaat????? He's the joker

@toniosntcrz

Жыл бұрын

Enough with the Joker! Hollywood lovers.

@13strong

Жыл бұрын

God, enough with the fucking Joker already.

@AnimalStomper

Жыл бұрын

I concur enough of idiot joker

@bartafterdark900

Жыл бұрын

He should have won the Oscar let’s be honest.

That was feckin’ brilliant like. This kid is sublime!

Heart-wrenching stories in the periphery. The focus, the 2 protagonists, have the least dramatic and tragic one.

What a scene!!! Great Skript and outstanding acting 👏

Excellent script and acting. Congratulation. You guys did justice to the little big tragedies of life. You made it timeless.

Ok I can SOOOOOOOO see what the hype about this actor is now. . "Well there goes that dream." I saw the words coming up but couldn't imagine he would deliver them so well. ARRRRRGH! I couldn't watch. He is a true talent. Well played, Barry Keoghan, The hype is well deserved. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

@PowerDiva

3 ай бұрын

That's why I love videos like this with the script and the scene together. You can really see what's written and then what choices the actors make in how they deliver those lines. Makes you really appreciate the talented ones like Barry a bit more.

It's interesting to see how the script differs from final version, changes the tone. The final version cuts out lines from the script. Like in the script when he walks away he says something to her at the end. That was cut out. And what was chosen instead was him walking of silently looking back and taking off his hat.

I keep.play this over and over!!!

@robertsidwell5856

2 ай бұрын

Me too

Man I do not care, this movie deserved at least a couple Oscars. One of the most beautiful movies of the year

This scene man.....hits me right in the feels. This cat has a bright future. Phenomenal talent

المشهد كان رهيب والفلم عميق ومريت بشعور الصديق

Atleast he took a swing

there were so many great performances and his was one of them.

I love barry because hes child like..wich makes him endearing..

It's a crime that Barry Keoghan didn't win an Oscar.

I saw this film 3x back to back, mainly because I LOVE everything about it, (and also hoping to catch the actual dialogue). On the 3rd watch, I caught that Peadar's (Dom's dad) earlier news about the 29yo man who killed himself in the river might have meant to ironically foreshadow Dom's own (possibly) suicide -since many has mentioned his 'hopelessness' story line. I am so sad for him. And this is such a good scene (among so many other fantastic scenes!)

@josevanreyes

7 ай бұрын

3x back to back. Fucking hell man. You got time on your hands 😂 How did you even muster the mental stamina for such a feat.

My favourite film for years this

Heartbreaking but beautiful performance.

Barry Keoghan is improving on what Giovani Ribisi set out to achieve. He is quickly becoming my favourite actor of all time.