I also did not like that Aiden is now totally cool with Anna having murdered his sister, because they're in this prison thing together and "she's changed."

@mizzourita3896

Жыл бұрын

That's what completely killed it for me too, in 2009 my stepsister was murdered at age 9 and it's been 13 years and I still don't hold an ounce of forgiveness for the monster that took her life, they did it to see what taking a human life felt like (their own words) and have shown no remorse to this day, I don't think that's something that just changes inside a person and granted Anna and Aiden were in the prison for 30 years but living the same day over and over again so it didn't feel like 30 years to them.

@avaaaak83

11 ай бұрын

@@mizzourita3896they also lost themselves to blackheath in those 30 years. it's like if you got amnesia

I didn't want to know about the logistics of the prison because for me, that wasn't the point. This was a book about personal agency and breaking cycles. It was a bit hard to follow at times but overall I deeply enjoyed this story and the characters in it.

@TalibHOB

2 жыл бұрын

oh glad to hear something like that because after reading it I also thought that it's more about how we get to the end more than getting to the end, like more about journey than the destination

I’m not going to lie, I really thought aiden would kill Anna in the end but after finishing the book, the only real Moron is aiden, he solves the murder but is so stubborn and attached to Anna even though he willingly went to blackheath to torture her even more.

I actually really liked this book. I thought even though it was a challenge to keep track of what was going on, I really appreciated how well it all tied itself back together. I know that you don’t think that, but I liked this book :)

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

I'm really glad you enjoyed it! I feel like most people did enjoy it, so you aren't alone! It's ok to have a different opinion from me 😋

I agree that it should’ve ended with Michael being the killer. I also was so mad when aiden was so insistent on anna escaping and forgave so easily. I did enjoy the rest of the book and it really made me use my brain lol

michael did know that 'evelyn' is not evelyn, the real evelyn revealed to anna and aiden that felicity went to michael for more money to keep quiet. what bother me about the ending was the fact that aiden easily forgive anna, the woman who killed her owned sister and causing death and destruction accros half the nations of the world. surely 30 years in blackheath are not enough punishment for her. the reason they put her there in the first place was so that she couldn't escape it.

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

Yes, That's definitely one of the issues I had too (about the forgiveness). I mean, he didn't remember his prior life so I guess that's why??

@blabla5938

4 жыл бұрын

I've just reread it I think I disagree with you, hes literally spent every day for thirty years with her, and although he doesn't remember it at one point anna mentions she knows how long shes been there because she can feel it and I think he can feel the weight of all the years hes been there to and after spending literally every day with one person for thirty years and watch her grow to the person she is now he did forgive her I liked it.

@avishajain170

3 жыл бұрын

@@blabla5938 me too

i found the main character to be SO infuriating. he barely spent any time with anna but it was enough for him to forgive her for torturing and murdering his sister on live tv??? also i feel like evelyn hardcastle only ACTUALLY dies in this timeline so how was that an answer? and how did the plague doctor not know who actually killed evelyn if he was there (with all of his memories) for 30 years? he had so much time to figure it out. Another thing that i found confusing is that michael asked evelyn why she was at caves so she decided she had to murder him. it seems to me that the caves were common knowledge (because of how michael refers to them) so i don’t think that anyone would assume that evelyn just left the stable boy there instead of assuming that he just fell in and got trapped. (sorry i know i worded this really poorly but i just found this book to be so confusing for no reason)

@lauraowens3814

2 жыл бұрын

and i have zero clue how he figured out the mystery, i feel like there was no way he could’ve connected those dots

@johnc3525

4 ай бұрын

@@lauraowens3814That's why some people say the book starts out well and then ends like Scooby-doo. 😂

I thought her not being the real Evelyn was one of the more obvious twists. When Millicent mentioned she was an ugly child and was surprised by her being called pretty, I could tell that was important. And then connecting it to all the pictures being redone. I thought it was a very complicated story told it the most comprehensive way possible. Especially since I was listening in audio form and didn’t have the benefit of seeing names. I got confused here and there but the author brought me back to the core. But I agree, I really wanted to understand the purpose, the outer world, and the jail so much more. That kinda all seemed like he’s used all his creativity in the inner story and threw something together for the surface of the outer story. Over all I personally loved the book. Hope it gets made into a series. I saw Netflix scraped one.

@johnc3525

4 ай бұрын

A lot of girls are ugly when they're little and turn out pretty when they get older.

I think if Aiden would have gotten out and gone home to his other life and left Anna in there it would have been a better ending, him forgiving Anna so easily is what completely killed it for me, in 2009 my stepsister was murdered at age 9 and it's been 13 years and I still don't hold an ounce of forgiveness for the monster that took her life, they did it to see what taking a human life felt like (their own words) and have shown no remorse to this day, I don't think that's something that just changes inside a person and granted Anna and Aiden were in the prison for 30 years but living the same day over and over again so it didn't feel like 30 years to them. You can't fix that kind of broken.

I think the murder wasn't the main focus, the main focus was actions of Aiden and thats what I believe the story wanted to ask us what would you do if you find yourself in such a situation, would you crumble to your habits and convenience or would you fight them. Aiden wanted to redeem himself by setting Anna free and that thing just made me love this book even more. The way it talked about identity, accountability and morality is amazing

@BedtimeBookworm

2 жыл бұрын

Interesting perspective! I’m glad you enjoyed it and thanks for sharing your thoughts, I’m sure you’re not the only one to feel this way!

@TalibHOB

2 жыл бұрын

@@BedtimeBookworm 🙃

I agree with many of your points. It did land in my favorites of the year because I enjoyed the journey of the book, tho it did take some time for me to get into it. I did call it being Evelyn’s double and her brother being the killer, I don’t remember how I called it, it has been a year, but I liked those twists. Where the book lost me a bit was the sci-fi part of this being a prison. The whole “his sister’s killer” part and the other psycho guy in there with them... those bits were vague. And I too wanted to know more of the logistics of the whole thing. Like: How will they escape? How does one ‘live off the grid’ in this advanced society? Is she truly rehabilitated? Who exactly is the plague doctor in real life? Does he have any authority over this situation? What’s up with the other plague doctors interpreting with the situation? I also didn’t feel like this needed to based on an actual unsolved murder. A computer generated one should have been fine. I’m glad other people think about this weird stuff too with books and it’s not just me😉

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

I can’t believe you called those things, you’re good! But yes the logistics you mentioned are all questions I was dying to know more about! Haha I don’t think these are weird things to think about 😆

I really liked the premise, but it turned out I just really wanted a simple murder mystery with the repeat time twist. There was too little time spent solving a murder and to much on interesting ideas that weren`t quite executed well enough, in my opinion.

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

Ooh yes I agree with this!! It was a great idea

I fully agree with your review! Amazing job!! 💕💕

Totaly agree!! thank you for your review!

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

So glad to hear that!! Thank you for watching!

Just finished reading the book, and I don't understand so many things! And finally found a review where someone is actually concerned about the logistics of the whole thing...I thought there would be a sci-fi twist in the end... Like it's in a virtual world or something like that... Because I don't know how else Aiden going from host to host is even feasible... And I would loved to have seen more elaboration on the whole virtual world thing... Despite its flaws it was a very interesting read!

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

Haha always nice to find you’re not alone in how you feel about a book - that’s actually why I made this video review, since I had a bit of an unpopular opinion 😆

This is a great review - thank you! I just finished the book last night, and it left me feeling... unsatisfied. The book was slow to start, and I enjoyed it from about 30-60%, but then it just kept cycling the same processes over and over. It could have been much more concise and probably would have been more enjoyable. The ending reminded me of the ending of "The Honey Farm" by Harriet Alida Lye. It just kind of ends, without giving you enough of the answers you crave.

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

I totally agree! I think if the story had ended a little earlier I would have enjoyed the story more!

I was terribly disappointed and frustrated by the ending, that Anna was allowed to leave. Imagine Hitler instead of Anna, could you let him go?! Forgiveness can only be considered after somebody feels remorse and asks to be forgiven, which was not true in Anna‘s case. The author has to reconsider his moral vectors.

@johnc3525

4 ай бұрын

I agree, the fact that she only remembers 1 day makes it impossible for her to change. She's changing from what to what? She's a blank slate.

I totally agree with your review. You basically felt the same as me about it. Made me feel better having someone think all those things about this book when I feel like so many people liked it so much

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

Glad to hear you felt similarly! It is definitely quite popular, and i can see why people enjoyed it but I just had too many issues with it to enjoy it, at least by the end.

I felt the same way you did about it being convoluted! My other complaint was that it was just WAY too long, and the bouncing around between the guests just became so boring after a while. Definitely one of my disappointing reads last year! 😩

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

Haha yay another book we agree on!

I did enjoy the read but feel exactly as you did in a lot of ways! I was left with so many questions about the prison system including the passage of time in “real life” and what 30 years actually meant. There were so many good plot points that kind of got danced over.

@ster2600

2 жыл бұрын

But that's completely irrelevant to the story?

Thank you for this review! I just finished the book and I share the same sentiments! Ultimately, a frustrating experience. I also failed to have a strong attachment to the main character... I feel like he was so lost in the character of those he inhabits that there was never a strong sense of self, so it was hard to really care about what was happening (which didn't help to follow along such a complicated plot).

@BedtimeBookworm

2 жыл бұрын

It's nice to know we aren't alone haha especially because this book seems so well loved!

Hi Thanks for this review, I totally agree and hoped I wasn’t the only one! The concept of punishment of that type is so interesting but wasn’t explored, nor the many questions which arose. I enjoyed the idea of the host and the book overall I thought was good ... but I found it difficult to visualise at times through lack of depth of description of the surroundings and atmosphere. Plus there seemed to be almost two styles of writing going on and the end was such a surprise I felt short changed 🤓

Being a big Sci-fi fan, I actually really liked the time travel, body jumping aspects. The tension of running from the footman and the way Aiden’s bodies starting falling like dominoes made me feel like I was reading a really well-written thriller. The message and the ending were the disappointing parts for me. How can Anna be changed or repent if she is an amnesiac who was no idea what she’s actually done? How can Aiden forgive her if he doesn’t even remember what his sister looks like? There can be no true forgiveness when there are no feelings of resentment or vengeance in the first place. Forgiveness does NOT equal forgetting because forgiveness is the process of letting go of negative feelings. Heck, even the reader barely knows what Anna’s done (we’ve only been told, we were never shown) so even the reader can’t truly forgive Anna because we didn’t hate her in the first place. Also, the whole Evelyn was not Evelyn thing just seemed…. contrived and unnatural. A true mystery gives the reader all the clues so that when the solution finally appears, it is obvious when looking back on it. Even when looking back on this solution, it was not the most obvious or believable answer.

@johnc3525

4 ай бұрын

Well said! It was a good premise that turned into Scooby-doo with a laughable ending and lots of shortcuts and Deus ex machina. What was the point of the footman, though?

Oh my gosh I felt so validated by this review. I wanted to like this book so badly but it just didn’t do it for me for some of the reasons you mentioned.

Great Review!! The ending was awful!! So much so I was looking to see if there was a second book as soon as I was finished. It feels like the publisher’s never actually read and finished the book. Everything interesting starts happening in the last 30 pages and you’re left with more questions than answers.

Okay, I love this book review, and everyone I entitled to their own opinion which is why I feel okay with sharing mine. I was actually able to draw up the conclusion that Maladine was somehow involved when Evelyn said Millicent was murdered and then Aiden had to think of why and just who was in the window with Evelyn on her walk with Johnathan (her son). I kind of knew from there, and its the strangest thing, I felt like I'd read or seen how everything else played out right before Evelyns big reveal when Aiden told Anna she was the one who needed to figure it out I just felt like I'd heard this story before. I'm rambling now, but I just find it so weird. Anyway, great review! I do agree that it was kinda all over the place, but still a good read!

@laurennelson5826

2 жыл бұрын

That’s impressive!! Good thought about who would be in the window with Evelyn. I was trying to think so hard who it could be but it never came to me

@SarastistheSerpent

Жыл бұрын

I didn’t know that the killer was Madeline, but I did figure out that Evelyn wasn’t the real Evelyn. As soon as Cunningham brought Aiden the message Evelyn read at the well with a “drawing of a castle”, I knew. Millicent Darby also mentions how the party is a disaster because the parents are MIA and Evelyn is busy “playing dress up”, which is another clue.

I couldn't get through this book. I got to page 250 and had to DNF so thank you for making this video I did want to know how it ended.

Okay! I just finished it!

I agree with what you said about exploring the world of the prison as it exists in the real world. I also had a lot of questions at the end about how Ana and Aidan were able to escape. Where did they escape to? Are they in the simulation? I enjoyed the book overall. Just wished these things were explained.

@johnc3525

4 ай бұрын

Yes, they are in a simulation because the plague doctor says the other people are just characters in a light show that will cease to exist when the lights are turned off, so Aidan and Anna don't need to save them.

Hey can someone tell me the age rating of this book plsss Is it appropriate for a 13 or 14 yr old?

you did raise some interesting points and now I am thinking about why the specific murder was intended. Nevertheless, it was a fantastic read.

This book could’ve been one of the best murder mystery books ever written if it was less convoluted. The middle part of the book felt so unnecessary. I kept thinking “what’s the point” and never really found one. The ending was cool but didn’t work for me. Great murder mysteries need a SOLID ending and this book just didn’t. A classic Agatha Christie doesn’t get caught up in itself like this book did. This book would be better as a movie.

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

Totally agree that it would make a great movie! Yeah it was just a little too convoluted for me too 🙈

@JesusChrist-iu3mh

3 жыл бұрын

Hey! I am a book reader who has read a lot of murder mystery books and I think this is the best one of all yet. You didn't like it. That's completely understandable. But I would like you to explain the "what's the point" more because if it is possible for me, I would try my best to make you understand every point that you couldn't. About the ending, I think it's perfect, as it leaves you thinking and imagining what could be their life after the incident.

i must say that overall i really enjoy this book however the ending was really frustrating for the same reasons you said... it just didn't make sense (or at least i had much higher expectations) so i couldn't enjoy this type of ending plus, the fact that he forgives Anna at the end even though he knows she killed his sister is really really weird like it's not even like he didn't care, he cried when the plague doctor told him so why ?

Yes! The world building was a fail for me from the beginning. You articulated a lot of what I was feeling. Great critique of this

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you! Always nice to hear that others agree with what I thought 😊

I totally agree with you about the world building! It's bugging me so much! Nothing about it makes sense! Or, maybe it has the potential to make sense but we're missing half of it. We don't even know if it's magic or technology doing this. And either way, if the people who built it are that powerful, how are we supposed to believe they can escape? Will Anna remain changed? Can you truly change that much if you were that terrible? We know next to nothing about who they were before or really who they are now, so it's impossible to tell. Aidan was in other people the whole time so we barely know him. Was Anna the same? Has she been in that maid's mind this whole time? Does that count as rehabilitated then? Where are their bodies? Have they aged? Has time passed? Did their bodies require upkeep? Because then they definitely won't escape. I'm not even mad about the Evelyn reveal. They had thrown so many twists at us by that point that I just figured "fine, what's one more." It was unnecessarily convoluted but it was a terrible place filled with terrible people. Fine, whatever. But the main theme of the book seemed to be redemption and forgiveness but we don't have a clear idea of who these people are or were, so we don't know how far they've come or if they deserve their second chance. And it may seem insignificant in the grand scheme to some people, but I feel like we need to know the logistics of this. How does it work? Why would anyone come up with this? What kind of society implements it? How are they supposed to live, if she's thst infamous. He wants to keep the truth from her, to keep her from backsliding but if she's that infamous there's no way to avoid it. The ending prompts nothing but more questions and it's do frustrating because there will never be answers.

I feel like the Shutter Island/ Black Mirror (White Bear ep) prison idea was a turnoff because they never explained that anymore. Whereas I enjoyed the multiple twists about Evelyn/Felicity and the clues leading up to it. It definitely was convulated, but I still enjoyed the book.

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

I'm glad you were still able to enjoy it! Most people like the twists and turns. I really did want more explanation behind the prison thing too though!

Yeah. I didn't like how he could interact with himself as other hosts. I thought it would be he's in one body each night, seeing it from another perspective. And I wanted to know more about the prison and how it worked and the people running it. Is it just a physical place? Is everyone hooked up to some machine where it's all in their mind? Disappointing, because I loved Devil and the Dark Water. And I had seen a limited series on Netflix like last year called The Island, and while reading this book I kept thinking of that show asking, "Is this all going to end up being some sort of prison thing?" And sure enough. It was.

I found it a third too long for the story it was trying to tell. I also thought throughout that the plague doctor was going to be Aiden in his later years, relying on his younger self to solve the mystery of the death of the women he loved (Evelyn). But no. It was a really, terrible ending. And halfway through I stopped caring who killed Evelyn!! 🤦‍♀️

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

Haha I agree! Aiden ending up as the plague doctor would have been super interesting, I would have been down for that!

@dgyeoulwon9401

Жыл бұрын

omg i was thinking the same thing 😅

Agreed, a linear timeline would have been easier to follow. The ending went too far in trying to shock us as readers. The author was trying too hard. Overall, I've read worse but this wasn't great. It was just okay.

Ahh I just finished this book because so many people recommended to me and I did not like it at all. I agree with pretty much everything. I just kept saying to myself “this is the bad place” lol was it a simulation? This was odd. So much exhaustive effort went in to writing the povs but soooo many loose ends in the end

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

Haha yes exactly how I felt too!! It left me with more questions than answers in the end haha

@ster2600

2 жыл бұрын

What loose ends were there?

Your questions are spot on -- this book was a tedious mess

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

Haha, glad to hear it wasn't just me! There are a ton of people who loved this book but it really was a miss for me personally.

One thing that I disagree with you on was that nobody recognized that Evelyn was Felicity. Millicent Derby did and that's why she killed her.

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

That's true! But I still have a hard time believing that nobody else recognized it

@JesusChrist-iu3mh

3 жыл бұрын

@@BedtimeBookworm Nobody had seen her for 19 years except her brother so it makes sense.

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

@@JesusChrist-iu3mh yeah... I just have a hard time believing she looked so different after 19 years personally

@JesusChrist-iu3mh

3 жыл бұрын

@@BedtimeBookworm Well, it was also hinted at many points that the people in Blackheath were ignorant and selfish. So it made sense no one cared if she looked like the real Evelyn Hardcastle or not. And even Aiden could not notice until he laid Gold's artistic eyes on her face up close to spot the similarities between her and Thomas Hardcastle.

I got 90 pages in and ended up dnfing it I just couldn’t get into it

@BedtimeBookworm

2 жыл бұрын

Totally feel you on that! Good job on DNFing after so many pages - life is too short to read things you aren’t enjoying!

I strongly agree with you, but I still did enjoy it (3 stars on GR). The book is way too long with way too many details, and I 100% agree with you that the book should have ended with Michael being the killer. Personally, I thought it was a coin flip between Michael (for inhertiance) and Charles(Revenage) when I was reading. I am a fan of time travel and fan of mysteries, but I certainly didn't enjoy the blend.

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah the blend sounded right up my alley but ended up not working for me! The author has a new book coming out this fall but I'm on the fence about picking it up. Thank you for watching and your thoughtful comment!

I love this, I’m glad we are in agreement because I’ve heard people raving about this book and was worried I’m the only person who didn’t write it! First of all, I found the writing was very clearly that of a journalist. It was very to the point and phrases like “the lantern was so bright that it shrouded what it was supposed to illuminate” were used more than once. Could have been a deadline thing but I thought there were places that could have used editing. Then there’s the piece of the hosts fighting back that didn’t work for me. And when the changes happen because of something a future host does, who is living the lives of the previous hosts and making those decisions? Why doesn’t his memory “catch up” to the changes that then happen? I was so frustrated that he fell for Anna when he’d killed her only the life before? What proof did he have that she’d changed so much? How could he give up his precious life and the memories of his own dead sister and run off with her murderer?! Also, who left the note telling Evelyn she had to kill herself or someone she loved would have been harmed? Maybe I missed that part. I appreciated the review, thanks for sharing ☺️

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

I know haha i feel like such and outlier for this one, but we're not alone! There were a lot of unanswered questions and I just found it all so confusing LOL. Thank you for your thoughtful comment!

@JesusChrist-iu3mh

3 жыл бұрын

1) The Plague Doctor explained that he had arranged the order of hosts who are the easiest to control to the hardest. The hosts are like a container that contains a soul. The eight hosts in Blackheath had two souls - one of each themselves and Aiden Bishop, as set by Dr. P. And thus, the souls are arranged in the ascending order of their power to fight back Aiden. I think the character of each hosts were explained pretty well by their actions. 2) That's known as character development. The Aiden we saw was not the Aiden who came here for vengeance. He had changed over the course of time and got over his dead sister and at the same time, realised that Anna had also changed. That was enough for him to trust her. Also, a number of scenes were shown which showed that Anna was changed. For example, the numerous times she helped Aiden. 3) There was no note. The entire plot was a plan formed by Michael, Evelyn and Felicity. And staying true to the role for which she was paid, she lied about the note.

Can someone please tell me what was the point of hiring Felicity?

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

LOL at this point i don't remember really, but there probably wasn't one!! HAHA

@lizwillcox9344

4 жыл бұрын

lol that’s literally the whole point...Evelyn wanted some security for her plan. She knew a con artist like Felicity could pull off the plan without inducing too much suspicion, stand a chance of surviving and giving Evelyn a 100% percent chance of making it. Without Felicity, Evelyn could have died/ been caught; with her, both women could (and did) make it. It’s pretty obvious isn’t it?

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks for the clarification but I don’t think it was obvious. The story is written in a very confusing way IMO, but I’m glad it wasn’t confusing for you. Spoiler..... I was under the impression that Felicity died though, didn’t she drink the poison? Sorry - at this point it’s been a long time since I read it so it’s hard to remember the details, especially considering my confusion lol.

@franciscobois

4 жыл бұрын

@@BedtimeBookworm She didn't die. Rashton had an antidote and could save or Michael or fake Evelyn. He chooses her, so she tells him that Millicent was killed too.

@Wats06071

3 жыл бұрын

@@BedtimeBookworm Rashton gave her the antidote.

when we got the anna/annabelle reveal I really thought she was going to be revealed to be a na zi so immediately i lost all sympathy for her

I'm confused... Because of the hair. o.O

@shellyg3072

4 жыл бұрын

Oana-Maria Uliu Me too!

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

Lol I filmed this last fall after I read the book! I didn’t have a chance to post it before now 😆

You’re spot on! I hated this book so much.

Thank you! I just got halfway in and decided to come to youtube to find a spoiler review so that I can be released from the prison of having to continue reading it. This book was such a chore. Forgettable characters, bland prose, overly convoluted plot. And you are 100% correct that the reader isn't given enough clues so that they can participate in trying to solve the mystery. Awful

It was confusing.....

@BedtimeBookworm

3 жыл бұрын

Hard agree!! I would have enjoyed it more if it was slightly less convoluted I think

My main issue with the book was the fatphobia/fat shaming. I found it incredibly uncomfortable. Aside from that though I agree with you about the 'reveals', they were so un-guessable that I didn't find them surprising or interesting. You really end up missing the 'ohhh yeaaahhh, of course!' moment. Shame

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

Yes, those chapters made me really uncomfortable too! And yeah, being so in-guessable is a negative for me too, I prefer when the clues are all there even if I don’t put it together myself.

@mermaidmoxie

3 жыл бұрын

I almost DNF’d because of the fat shaming. There was such contempt that I will not read another book by the author.

@sophiasthoughts

3 жыл бұрын

@@mermaidmoxie I feel the same way

@fafo867

3 жыл бұрын

yall should learn to differentiate between authour and narrator/character

@sophiasthoughts

3 жыл бұрын

@@fafo867 I never said I couldn't. What I said, if you read my messages, is that I don't feel comfortable reading fatphobic content. Especially if it is left unchallenged

Amen amen amen!!! Convoluted! Confusing. Wish it had been linear. Bad ending-insane. I feel so validated!! I hung in til the end but it was a monumental waste of time. on top of all this the book was too long. Sigh. Two stars.

WHY DID YOU SPOIL IT. I ALMOST GOT SPOLED . STAY WARNING OR SOMETHING . JESUS CHRIST

@BedtimeBookworm

4 жыл бұрын

I can’t tell if you’re being sarcastic or not but I very clearly say at the beginning of the video that it will be full of spoilers and not to watch it if you haven’t read it... I have another video that is a spoiler free review if you want to watch that!

@MrGreen-ci2mm

4 жыл бұрын

@@BedtimeBookworm Alright, thank you :)