Super le mec belle métaphore pour faire comprendre aux jeunes d'arrêter

Meilleur film français des années 90. Chaque scène est puissante et a une signification. Celle-ci est assez émouvante, j'apprécie particulièrement le fait qu'ils écoutent ce vieil homme avec attention, intrigués par son histoire et qu'ils semblent chamboulés quand ce dernier s'en va. Quelle que soit la métaphore, l'analogie ou le message de cette histoire ce que je trouve très fort c'est l'interaction avec l'ancienne génération. La Haine est un film incroyablement humain.

👍👍👍culte

Du grand Art !!!

Alors je temps la main

cette scène me travail depuis +20 ans...

Such a smart scene. The old man's story really put Vinz and Hubert's problems into perspective.

The best Monologue in late film history...

Vinz and Hubert both resent the system of violence and oppression in which their lives are trapped. Each wants to break free, but they disagree on how to do so. Vinz argues that oppression must be met with violence, to cultivate fear, and therein respect from their oppressors. Hubert argues that this kind of violence only perpetuates their oppression--"hate breeds hate." These two opposed approaches each satisfy a need--to cultivate respect, or to cultivate peace--akin to holding up one's pants, or grabbing the man's hand. They cannot elevate the status of the ghetto without satisfying both these needs. But you can't do both at the same time, and ultimately, you just freeze to death.

I love the touch of the guy who is afraid to exit the toilet until everyone has gone...

Poor Grunwalski had a choice. If he dropped his pants and grabbed the man's hand, he would lose his modesty and honor but keep his life. If he held on to his pants, he would keep his honor but lose his life. He flip flopped between these two until it was too late and he died.

the grunwalski story is a metaphor for what is happening in Vince's life. Grunwalski represent Vince in this story. And the one reaching his hand to Grunwalski represents Hubert. Hubert keeps on reaching to Vince, so he can help him get of the negative path that only leads to death and destruction. Vince is torn between what is happening around him in his life and what he thinks he is supposed to do and to react. (part1)

I see that a lot of people get it wrong. Heres why:

one of the key scenes of this incredibly good movie

This is the best Movie of all time, respect vrom germany.. ;)

It's about pride being a 'sin' - Grunwalski was too prude, which in the end was his downfall. This reflects Vincent's attitude throughout the film and how he ended.

"Il ne faut pas se demander si on croit en Dieu, mais si Dieu croit en nous."

I was high the first time I saw this, honestly it nearly killed me cos I couldn't stop laughing so hard, I had some real good times when I lived in France!!

That is a good estimate, relating gramp's story to the whole film. There are so many interpretations of this story. My original impression was that the gramps was the bad dude for teasing Grun till he strayed. from the tracks.

one of the best movies ever!!