My dad died 6 years ago. He was born in Jarrow (just outside of Newcastle). This version is our song. Whenever I hear it, he's right here beside me and in my heart. I love you, Dad.

Sting is one of the few musicians who can just stand on a stage and sing...and have complete dominion over the entire room. God bless this man and his incredible, anointed talent.

I think I can help. His dad passed away, and I don't believe they were close. He hinted at that when he was introducing the song and said that his dad never said very much to him, and the one time he did, was to tell him he should go to sea one day. He didn't, and wrote this song as a tribute, acknowledging his dad's only advice for him. 'Why should I cry for you' means why should someone cry for someone they were not close to? The fact he wrote the song indicates he did cry for his dad....

@pistenqueen

4 ай бұрын

Your last sentence says it all……

@demi3115

Ай бұрын

Yeah, you can grief for a relationship that never happened but should have.

This version is my absolute favorite piece of his entire works. Perfect.

@Schmidtelpunkt

Жыл бұрын

Sting has impressive live versions, whereas his studio versions (especially from his early output) often seem a tad too hermetic for my taste. If there was a box set of all his studio albums with all songs replaced with the live version, I'd buy them again immediately.

@adjinugroho896

Жыл бұрын

Indeed... Slower tempo... flows likes an ocean waves...

@DJ_Patent

Жыл бұрын

Me too!

@jooei2810

Жыл бұрын

Ten Summoners Tales was composed after his father died, this is his poem to his late father.

@mikkellandsdorf

Жыл бұрын

​@@jooei2810no, it was the album "Soul Cages", written for his father, this song is from🙏🏼

I lost my Dad 5 years ago, this song helps me keep his memory alive, both the love he had for me and the family and the deep sadness of his passing, thank you Sting an incomparable performance both in arrangement and execution!

A perfect example of why Sting is a musician's musician. Heartfelt,evocative lyrics; gentle melody line with a well built crescendo. Absolutely beautiful song.

When I heard this arrangement, during this tour, I was in the Ford Amphitheater in Tampa, FL. I was a musician who had lost my love for sound. The sun was going down, and the wind blew fast through the seats of the theater; the clouds were pink and orange, and Sting and his orcheatra were silhouetted in the light behind the stage. When the vocal harmony of the chorus rose out over the crowd and the wind passed across my face, I remembered what inspiration was.

@jooei2810

Жыл бұрын

Did you keep it in your soul?

@clarecampbell4481

5 ай бұрын

🫂🫂♥️

My father made me listen to Sting when I was very young; one or two songs and I've had him in my discography ever since - his story and others. I lost my father 12 years ago, and every time I think of my father, I listen to Sting and thank him. My story and what Sting describes in this song have a similarity to what I experienced with my father. I love this music because I know I can find my father through it.

My Dad was a nickel miner and had bladder cancer.He called to see me before he passed so we go there the day before my birthday. He was gone the next day.

I take leave of music. Then I revisit Sting's music and allow it to awe me once again. His music and poetry have moved me since I was a teenager. He has no comparison and I feel blessed and am grateful to be a witness to his artistry.

Well I'm British-American so i can safely say I think: the father/son relationship is difficult and when the son is left alive without the father, there's a great sadness, from so much that was not said, that tears is the normal result. "Why Should I cry" is either a frustration that the tears will not come, or a lament that the tears have come too late.

Sting is the most incredible singer of my generation. Each song has an history behind and that's what makes life continue to goes on. Remain the same.

Every dad should hear this song and think about what comes next

This song -- and, more specifically, this rendition of it -- is my "you're-stuck-on-an-island-and-can-only-listen-to-one-song-the-rest-of-your-life" tune. So incredibly moving in every way. God Bless you, Sting.

Ich war bei diesem Konzert, mit meiner Frau. Es war ein Hochzeitsgeschenk unserer Kollegen. We loved it. It was Amazing.We even had an upgrade in our seats. Wir mussten Leider von gaaanz hinten nach gaaanz vorne. Thanx again to all of our colleagues.

Soul cages ..his best solo work

I can't believe how incredibly awesome he is. This song is art, a big piece of art.

one of the best concert playing with symphonical orcestra..beautiful..extraordinary..actualy,for me,personal,the best live perfomance..great..Symphonicities Tour - Berlin, 2010.

Under the dog star sail Over the reefs of moonshine Under the skies of fall North, north west, the stones of Faroe Under the Arctic fire Over the seas of silence Hauling on frozen ropes For all my days remaining But would north be true? All colors bleed to red Asleep on the ocean's bed Drifting on empty seas For all my days remaining But would north be true? Why should I? Why should I cry for you? Dark angels follow me Over a godless sea Mountains of endless falling, For all my days remaining, What would be true? Sometimes I see your face, The stars seem to lose their place Why must I think of you? Why must I? Why should I? Why should I cry for you? Why would you want me to? And what would it mean to say, That, 'I loved you in my fashion'? What would be true? Why should I? Why should I cry for you?

Linda letra e melodia que me remete ao mais terno e doce passado 😢🥰 Meu pai faleceu quando eu ainda estava com apenas 8 anos. 🙏⚘️🕊❤☝️💙🙌

My uncle was a milkman, and I used to help him out in the summer holidays...he was my dad's best friend. This song summed it up...

Been at this concert. In 2010 in Berlin. Concert started a little later, because of filming it. Remarkable evening. Last time I saw him live. Here in Berlin he playes often open air. And sorry, I'm to old for standing ( in rain). I wanna sit and enjoy it. Didn't think he will come soon to Berlin again. He plays some gigs in Sommer. But to far away for me.

I believe this is the best Sting has ever been..

Gott hat alle meine Tränen gezählt und ich bin lieb,schlau und wertvoll.Lese den Korinther Brief,da umschreibt Gott,was Liebe ist und wie sie geht.

Live IS STING EVEN BETTER! THIS PERFORMANCE OF THIS SONG IS BREATHTAKINGLY GOOD! Amazing concert.

Yes, i consider myself kind of an expert on this song. Been listening to it since 1990 or so. It's one of those rare tunes that you don't want it to ever end. i've no idea how he did it. But, Sting, Nicely Done!!

how can you not be swept away by this performance? wow, simply amazing!

this song is awesome,just make me cry,thank you mr sting 4 creating and sing this awesome song.Goosebump factor!

Just too beautiful .....too much.

Had the privilege to see this awesome concert live in Hartwall Arena, Helsinki 10.9.2010

Imádom hallgatni, és látni, a szívem belesajog.

Makes me think of my father. ...

I cried all night long while my heart kept saying," Why I should Cry for You".

음악회에 온 느낌입니다 Sting 멋진 👍 음악을 잘 감상했습니다

super talent I love you!👄

Majestic.

How can he possibly sing this and not cry...?

I love the melodies and chords of this song so much. I just always want another chorus, "Dark angels follow me...".

No screaming or craziness... Very humble and sofisticated 🌟💧

This simply left me breathless

This is one of the most incredibly beautiful songs I’ve ever heard. You can hear the doubt and regret through the lyrics (“…For all my days remaining, but would north be true?”) with him having a maybe somewhat complicated relationship with his dad and not knowing if he should have followed his father’s wish. “What would it mean to say, “I loved you in my fashion.” Those words have a sting, genuinely no pun intended.

@jooei2810

9 ай бұрын

So true!

Would sting ever consider allowing this song to be a dedication to my mum? Would he sings this at her funeral? Acoustic is all that is needed. Under the same stars yet different people with hearts that bleed for different reasons.

His music covers so many of my pains...good times...and I am always drawn to the songs. Tonight...I ask this question....trying to understand why.....I cry so much...and someone else doesn't. Not for me. I wish I knew why....but I never will. I don't want to ask any more. I never get an answer. The answers are in his actions. Sadly...he has a lot of backup plans. They come in all stages...of age, locale, and brain cells. That is not important enough tho. No one is to him. So I sit....and cry.

The best performance, tour and show ever seen.

Y’know? I used to think that one could only either be “Team Police or Team Sting”. Bullsh*t! I was SO wrong! Sting is incredible! So are the Police and this is SO Devastatingly Beautiful. Im speechless. Thank you for posting!!!!🙏🙏❤️❤️🤘🤘🥹

@patamarias

2 ай бұрын

😮

Truly, A Genius and An Inspiration!!! THE Rockstar of the World!

Beautiful Sting in so many ways Brother!

Performing with this guy is on my bucket list

The Lyrics, Orchestra, Sting, ; Makes it all so very beautiful !

beautiful. i'd be the happiest father on earth if my kids "sing" me this song.

The Star of the Sea... the anchor... the beloved Mother.

Standing ovation for sure ... !!!

Beautiful.

Can't listen without crying ... remember my father

What an incredibly well crafted song. Thank you Mr Architect.

I love you,he is wonderful singer,he is the best for me❤

One the best song of my life.

What a beautiful song

He is already alive legend .

Lovely song! First time I have heard this track! Shall be playing it a lot! Thank you for uploading it so that we can all enjoy!

❤❤❤❤❤

This became and still and always will be my favorite STING song since the day this album was released. Oh. Sting did actually, tell a little more to the story behind this song than was told here. I don't want to spoil it for those listening to simply one of the most gorgeous LOVE/HATE songs ever written.

@aglendaecarroll3769

Жыл бұрын

Been my favorite since 1991 ❤

Sting is the Artist.

God bless you, Sting! This is simply AMAZING!

most beautiful song ever!!!!!!!!

Fantastico!

still always hear it and alwyas say and think that he is a genious......

moving & touching & heartfelt - Sting THX

.. A Legend ... Making Magic....

Sting is a Legend ❤️

So beautiful his music is so moving and deep! Fantastic talent....and yes, finally this song explained!

EMOCIONANTE, PARA QUEM GOSTA DA MÚSICA ☝️♥️🙌🌷🕊🎼❤️‍🔥

he is a professional singer whom i know, and he could sing this song, no tears.......gut luck 4u always

unglaublich schön...

without words!

escucho este tema y me acuerdo de mi viejo sentado en la vereda de casa, con su radio...mirando las estrellas.....como lo extraño!!

I loved you in my fashion--that line kills me. One of Sting's best songs This arrangement is ok, I much more prefer the album's version, I like the starkness of the original recording. I love you Sting!!!

@zapkvr

6 ай бұрын

I disagree This arrangement is perfect. I saw Gordon play it live with the orchestra in Melbourne in 2011. A night I will remember all my life. The music just hit me in the heart. This compressed version cannot do it justice. The only song better than this on the night was Roxanne. It was so hauntingly beautiful it literally took my breath away.

@racourdav

6 ай бұрын

⁠​⁠@@zapkvr…But that’s MY opinion, sheesh! I don’t disagree with YOUR opinion because that’s YOUR opinion.

♥♥♥ love this song

i luv it...the best of...Sting ur the king

Sting is class ..

How i miss you Daddyji......

great song!!!!!!!!!!!!

God Bless You Sting.....

стинг это нечто космическое.

works of a silent master

Menina Rainha, te adoro........................

wow! beautiful song!

Amazing. Thankyou,

Sting.. maestro!

beautiful song

just Awesome !

Beautiful song!

me encanta sting me haria tan feliz tener la letra de sus canciones!!!!

beautiful…

.....meraviglia

Best ever

Ironic, he calls the tune "Why should I cry for you", but it always makes me cry ..

❤

Simplemente el mejor....

This show has such class 🚩especially the audience at pnc bank in holmdel nj⚓️🇬🇧