I know not everyone had seen VHSCCS but I had to add it since I saw it live and since it has a special place in my heart! It’s also my favorite musical they’ve ever done

@i.wannabe.m.e

4 ай бұрын

You did the right thing! VHSCC is CRIMINALLY underrated. Thank you for including it!

@emiliadadda914

3 ай бұрын

Where can I watch it? I've been looking for it for ages

@Its_hatchetfield

3 ай бұрын

@@emiliadadda914 it was only available to buy for a few months and now you can’t buy it anymore unfortunately 😭

Clark getting such a high placement almost solely because he sang every single song in Ani is hilarious

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

That and he sang in every song in VHS Christmas Carol(s)!

Seeing Corey make the top ten despite being so underrated for so many years warms my heart in a way I can’t quite put into words

@bunchoflemons

4 ай бұрын

Everyone always says Corey is underrated but every time I tell people he's my fave they're always like "ME TOO!"

@tessawidenhofer

4 ай бұрын

@@bunchoflemons I think it’s a holdover from all the years pre Trail to Oregon where he was barely there and in smaller roles because I remember that summer season being announced and being surprised he was coming back- Trail to Oregon, VHS, and the Hatchetfield trilogy have been good to him, as he deserves!

It's pretty insane to me that thanks to NPMD, Lauren has now tied Jamie's record of appearing in 12 shows.

@justsomegirl862

4 ай бұрын

lets keep it that way, i need jaime to be in more stuff again

@jacobadelsheimer9645

Ай бұрын

And now she’s going to break her record when Cinderella’s Castle premieres in a few months

I do appreciate how everyone agrees that being in 1 show is enough to be a starkid. You are part of the chaos once, you are part of the chaos forever

@catherinetso8928

3 ай бұрын

Once a starkid always a starkid (Edit: unless you’re Robert)

@dooplets._.5776

3 ай бұрын

​@@catherinetso8928lol, ty

@connorbingham4764

23 күн бұрын

@@catherinetso8928 Lol this made me chuckle

Oh man, just the string of the audio quality of the older musicals then being immediately SMACKED by Will in NPMD was some very satisfying auditory whiplash

bryce lowkey the backbone of npmd

@sagegreeeeeeen

5 ай бұрын

Low key? HIGH KEY!

@SmudgedSketch

4 ай бұрын

Real, she did such a good job

@Jason_Bryant

4 ай бұрын

I'm really hoping to hear more or her in future Starkid shows.

@samthorne3765

4 ай бұрын

Having her and Will both absolutely belting their hearts out back to back here is devastating

@charliedvb

4 ай бұрын

@@Jason_Bryant that fact that this is her first musical w them?? and she slayed so fucking hard?? unbelievable

Brian having 42 mins when we all know brian can't sing! what a king!

@dian1545

5 ай бұрын

(i love Brian, this is an old joke)

@IoSaturnalia17

4 ай бұрын

i heard he's been hitting the how to sing books but still can't sing :(

@adami6187

4 ай бұрын

I truly wonder if he'll ever be able to sing... praying for him 🙏🙏🙏

@socksonhands_

3 ай бұрын

I think he just needs some more how to sing books 🙏

i hope Will is in future Starkid projects cause he's so good

I love how Jeff is literally one second away from having a whole hour

@samthorne3765

4 ай бұрын

If only he wasn't in such a hurry...

Nick only having 7 minutes through 5 musicals is crazy

Let us remember the beginning of Starkid. Some of them could barely breathe while dancing, the sound was not as balanced, and the stage was always simple. They slowly created an empire and their productions are next level!!!

I hope Jon Matteson gets more singing roles, the little bit we got in TGWDLM and his parts in NPMD were stellar!

It makes me so happy that Angela has absolutely ate in the two musicals she was in so far. I am so enraptured with her

@goshdangit4503

4 ай бұрын

If you weren't aware already, Angela is also a cast member on a YT channel called Smosh!

@confuseddotcom

4 ай бұрын

She's also in Artist on artist on artist on artist, an improv based podcast

jaime is top 3 but she's so underappreciated omg.... truly deserves a lead role

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

She does!

@katiem.3109

3 ай бұрын

Her voice is incredible, and her range is extraordinary. She can basically sing anything that's been written for a women, whether it's for a soprano, mezzo, or contralto. In one of her covers she actually hits a D7, a note that even operatic coloratura sopranos would struggle to hit, and she's not even a soprano!

jon matteson's voice has INCREDIBLY improved from tgwdlm to npmd ! would love to see him singing more in future shows

I was so sure it was going to be Dylan, because he's got so much to sing in both Twisted and VHS, but he missed a few shows, so it makes sense. Joey was my second guess :) I'm glad that him, Lauren and Jamie are in the top three

Thank you for making this!!! It’s crazy how much Jon has grown vocally since tgwdlm when he still described himself as an actor who could sing not a singer who could act. Also I’m dying of excitement bc the next Hatchetfield musical is gonna be about Miss Holloway and we’ll get to see Kim sing so much more

@enjolras_irl_1874

4 ай бұрын

Wait what!?!?? Do you mind telling me where you heard that from because oh my gosh she's my fav hatchetfield character and ive been saying she needed her own musical for so long!!!!!

@turnipcrazy4602

4 ай бұрын

Yes, I've been dying for a show that's lead by Kim and Curt and if it's a Miss Holloway musical that had to mean that Duke is in it. I love Duke and Miss Holloway's relationship and I know Kim will kill it with the vocals.

@Jason_Bryant

4 ай бұрын

The last thing that I heard about more Hatchetfield was from the "Nerdy Prudes Must Livestream" fundraising video. There they said that they only planned to do three Hatchetfield musicals, then move on to something else, at least for awhile. If they've given any more info than that, I'd love to know where.

@violentdelights3195

4 ай бұрын

@@Jason_Bryant They revealed a lot about future plans for Hatchetfield in the Halloween stream. It was available for rent for a while on their website.

@violentdelights3195

4 ай бұрын

@@enjolras_irl_1874 This is a reveal from the Halloween stream! Nick said the Holloway musical is basically already written. Also if we get NT3 there will be a long episode titled Miss Halloween where Miss Holloway has to deal with supernatural threats after losing her powers.

I need Jeff to sing for exacrly 1 second more so its 1 hr

Just more proof that Joey is not just a sidekick ❤

watching joey and lauren's improvement over the years is so neat! (obviously everyone has improved, but I think theirs is the most dramatic by virtue of both where they started at and the sheer length of their tenure)

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

I have a video on my channel that shows that with all of the starkids by showing their first and most recent line in starkid if you haven't seen it and want to check it out! I thought it was cool to see their improvement in that video too!

Dylan has some absolute BANGERS, also we need to see Corey in a lead role ASAP

Jeff Blim is the Lin Manuel Miranda of Starkid

@seorikkuns

Ай бұрын

except jeff's singing is pleasant to listen to /lighthearted

@FakeDogs

12 күн бұрын

Put some respect on jeffs name!!

And it won't interest anyone but me, but the average amount of time they sing per show is: Janaya Jones 20:23 Clark Baxtresser 11:48 Rachael Soglin 11:44 Jamie Burns 11:43 Tiffany Williams 11:25 Mariah Rose Faith Casillas 11:08 Angela Giarratana 10:59 Curt Mega 10:56 Bryce Charles 10:13 James Tolbert 10:03 Jeff Blim 10:00 Darren Criss 9:57 Joey Richter 9:29 Kim Whalen 9:02 Jon Matteson 8:51 Robert Manion 8:49 AJ Holmes 8:19 Ali Gordon 8:01 Lauren Lopez 7:43 Dylan Saunders 7:34.25 Will Branner 7:34 Jaime Lyn Beatty 6:12 Meredith Stepien 5:54 Joe Walker 5:28 Alex Paul 5:20 Brian Holden 5:15 Nick Gage 5:10 Bonnie Socha 5:07 Corey Dorris 4:48 Brian Rosenthal 4:09 Nick Strauss 3:40 Tyler Brusen 3:28 Devin Lytle 3:14 Denise Donovan 3:06 Kendall 3:02 Brant Cox 3:01 Jim Povolo 2:40 Joe Moses 1:30 Nick Lang 1:28

Curt overtaking Darren is so poetic to me, Glee foretold this when they made him sing the lead for Uptown Girl with The Warblers after Blaine left But also how magical is it how different his voice is in each clip

i can't believe this video doesn't already have way more views, this was such an interesting concept and you executed it perfectly so kudos on all the hard work!

@Its_hatchetfield

5 ай бұрын

Awe thank you so much!!

I need more Brosenthal 😭 he has one of my favorite voices

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

I know!! He’s my favorite StarKid!

Bless VHSCCs for finally giving Curt solos as he deserves.

Bold of you not to put "we're all just pawns in a fucking game of chess" for meredith in hmb

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

Rouges are we is my favorite hmb song so any time I had to get a part from that musical I tried to get it from that song lol but I do love that part

@Fire-Lord-Azula

4 ай бұрын

@@Its_hatchetfield yeah rogues are we is also my favourite hmb song and meredith absolutely slayed in that song so can't blame you

I was so sure it was gonna be Jaime, because she’s been in every production (not counting Ani since it ran concurrently with TTO) I actually just realized she wasn’t in NPMD! Her streak broke!

@leilaofpaper

4 ай бұрын

do we know why she wasn’t in NPMD?

@sarahmiller909

4 ай бұрын

@@leilaofpaperI would also like to know!! 😭😭

@skepticskeksis4242

4 ай бұрын

@@sarahmiller909 I could be mistaken but I believe she moved back to nyc with her husband instead of staying in LA and thus couldn't do NPMD

@sarahmiller909

4 ай бұрын

@@skepticskeksis4242 ohhhh okay thank you!!!!

@NotSoRealEllis2004

4 ай бұрын

​@sarahmiller909 She is co-creating the next Starkid project, 'Space Baby' (not a musical) with Curt Mega Edit: it will obviously have songs, just won't be a Stage Show

I was between Lauren and Joey for my guesses of the top spots, and I figured Joey might take the lead.

I can’t believe Jeff got just under an hour. Literally another reprise or something could have pushed him over, that’s so painful

fun way to find out it's my time of the month is i started bawling at the 2 seconds of world's at stake lmao

I called Joey being #1 but I think it's so cute that my favorite celebrity couple hold spots 1 & 2

videos that make me want to rewatch all the starkid musicals

@cass1857

4 ай бұрын

Yeah this reactivated my hyper fixation hard this is about to become my entire personality again for at least however long it takes me to watch all of them again 😮‍💨

idk why i was surprised joey was #1 he's literally the lead role in three musicals and plays major roles in pretty much every other musical

@allakadamn

4 ай бұрын

i just really thought it would be lauren

Haven’t watched yet but here are some predictions: Joey is probably up there just based on sheer volume. I bet Dylan is top 3. I was just rewatching Twisted and marveled at home much singing that role has. He must rack up the minutes there. And when he does sing, he gets full songs or duets. Could Joe Walker be a sneaky high rank? Jaime Lynn Beatty probably up there too. Jeff gave himself a lot of singing to do in TTO, TGWDLM and BF, so could see him up there.

Such a jumpscare clicking on this video and the FIRST PERSON JUST HAPPENS TO HAVE MY EXACT NAME.

I was confused then realized you only did stage ones and not the zoom call ones with it

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

Yeah it would have taken a lot longer if I did nightmare time so I decided not to

this just made me realize i need to watch vhs christmas carol also, joey and lauren, power couple at the top

will branner left no crumbs

Slightly disappointed that Clark's oooh from Firebringer isn't in the video but I love this!

this was so interesting and fun to watch!! i had guessed who was in the top three right but i was totally wrong about the order lol. thanks for putting all this together

I have been wondering myself how long different Starkids members sang for. This is such an important video. Thank you for compiling this.

Honestly Joeys improvement is one of the most drastic to me!! His voice has matured so beautifully!!!

THEY GOT EVANNA LYNCH TO PLAY LUNA LOVEGOOD??? NEVER WATCHED THE VERY POTTER MUSICAL AND SEQUELS BUT NOW I REALLY REALLY WANT TO!!!!

@evn3585

4 ай бұрын

It’s only for a very potter senior year, but it’s still not worth it

@lisiczka6560

4 ай бұрын

@@evn3585 the potter trilogy, its totally worth watching. why do you think otherwise?

I KNEW ITD BE JOEY

The amount of time and effort that went into this video… omg I can’t even imagine. This is totally awesome!!

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

Thank you!!

woah rachel is so good at singing in a character voice!!

You are The Star Kid

dude thank you for doing this, actually insane

@Its_hatchetfield

5 ай бұрын

Of course! Thank you for watching!!

so proud of myself bc joey was my guess for the top singer followed by lauren and jamie and I WAS RIGHT ! then when i got to lauren and i was like i think joeys probably sung around 1 hour 40 or 45 minutes overall, a good ten min more than lauren and i was right again !!! makes sense tho, joey, lauren, and jamie have been in the most shows overall (the only shoes they havent been in are ani for all three, mamd for lauren, twisted for joey, and npmd for jamie) and joeys played a lot of characters with big songs like protags with i want songs or villians with villian songs, that was my logic for my guess and i guess it was right lol

A couple things I love here: 1. 10:51 Robert warning 2. 12:09 - 12:16 "I know it's haaaard" transitioning to "IIIII'm deeeead"

I know my parents are gonna be top 2 (I'll come back later if I was wrong)

i guesses lauren would be 2 and joey would be 1, but i actually expected them to be a bit closer than they were. I always forget joey has played lots of leads that get lots of singing lol

the line you picked for Joey in vhsccs is my favorite so I'm Very Happy

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

Mine too lol

I didn't know AJ Holmes ever played Scrooge, I've only seen the version on their official channel with Dylan Saunders as Scrooge.

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

Yeah they did a production of it in November in Chicago that I went to and saw live. Dylan, Brian Rosenthal, and Corey couldn’t make it so they had others replace them like AJ, Curt, and Brian Holden! The clips were from a digital ticket that’s no longer available

Joey has such a great range

i knew the top two would be between joey or lauren and i guessed lauren, dang it. major kudos to you, i can’t imagine how long this took to make. very enjoyable watch!

Now I want to see them ranked by what percentage of each musical they sang on average (just dividing the total time by how many musicals they were in)

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

Someone in the comments did that actually! If you want to look through and find it!

I knew that Joey and Lauren had to be on top three, but I forgot Joey didn't show up yet when Lauren came on 2nd and scream "who could be 1st???"

this made me wonder about how starkids' longest totals within one musical (as in, [x] sang for 15 mins in twisted, [y] sang for a billion minutes in tgwdlm, [z] never had a role with more than 5 minutes of song)

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

That would be interesting to know. I didn’t really keep track of that stuff while making this but I wish I would have

@mel-burnes

4 ай бұрын

@@Its_hatchetfield yeah, a shame but fair enough! i reckon jeff'd definitely be at the top via tgwdlm considering how he was in almost every song and i can't think of anyone else off the top of my head who'd be able to rival him but i'm sure there's someone

Kinda wish you'd used the clip of Jamie in tgwdlm singing "It is time... to DIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIEEE!!" lol.

We all knew it was between Lauren and Joey, it's just obvious

Congrats Joey for being the most singing Starkid ever

i actually guessed the top 3 correctly

I was spot on for my top 3 guesses, just got the order a bit wrong lol but it makes so much sense

The amount of effort that went into this! That's amazing

This is sooo interesting!! Thank you for your hard work🙏

This is the kind of content I want on youtube. Love it!

this must have taken you so long. thank you~!

This must have taken so much time! Thank you for the video!

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

It did take forever lol but it was fun! Thanks for watching!

I’m so glad vhs was included

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

I had to since it’s my favorite show they’ve done!

@Meeee12346

4 ай бұрын

Sammeeeee

Omg i had no idea janaya was a starkid! I know her from IT at Rockwell

Wow! Awesome! How long did this take you?

Hey! Happy new year! Thanks for being awesome

@Its_hatchetfield

5 ай бұрын

Awe thank you!! Happy new year!!

i bet some of these would change if you included nightmare time and NMT2 but i understand why you didn't

Corey Dorris is always so good. One of my fave starkids

dedication 👏👏

I was so convinced Jaime Lyn was gonna be first welp (at least my guess for who was in the top five was correct) Great video!

The range some of these amazing actors and sing er’s have in characters they can portray. From a complex character like Emma to “dADDY you came to LOVE ME” to Linda And Joey, Ron and Peter are like diametrically opposite to McDoon, and Ted who play on some of the same aspects as McDoon, but whose comic relief is still so different And Dylan who is the emotional backbone in most shows (also as Dumbledore XD) Hilarious video you’ve made! By number 8, I had all of them nailed, though I thought Jeff would be higher And also, hilarious that Jon has had such a big impact on fans, and not having sung that much (might be because he spend a whole musical trying to avoid singing XD) A quick question if you’re still reading, why didn’t you include Jeff and Dylan’s very, very minor performances in NPMD during Hatchettown? I’m just curious Thank you for making this hilarious video! It must’ve taken ages to record the time, but it was well worth it

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

Thank you! And I didn’t include Dylan and Jeff’s npmd performances because they just had small cameos in the pro shot only. So Dylan and Jeff weren’t actually in the show just the pro shot. Same with James!

@andrealundgaard1838

4 ай бұрын

Touchè, makes sense!

So sad i can't watch VHSCCS 😢

@Its_hatchetfield

5 ай бұрын

It was so good!! I actually saw it live twice and it was incredible

haven’t watched it but joeys GOT to be number one he has bug, MAMD, ron, bandit king, wiley, AND now pete!!!

@dashvm2366

4 ай бұрын

SPOILERS ALERT: i was right my adoptive mother and father getting #1 and #2 has healed my pain❤

I guessed Joey, mostly because I knew Little White Lie wasn't going to be part of it. Although looking at the times, I don't think LWL would've given Lauren 10 more minutes.

Cool!

I feel that Nightmare Time should have been included as singing time

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

I only wanted to include their stage shows for a few different reasons. I planned on adding it at first but it would have taken too long

I’d love to see Jamie Burns in more shows

IT WAS JOEY AFTERALL???

can someone please explain the robert drama to me im new to starkid and have seen some stuff here and there but im still confused 😊

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

He admitted to sending some inappropriate stuff to one of the StarKid band members which made them super uncomfortable

@fayc_fayc2115

4 ай бұрын

@@Its_hatchetfield oh God i had no clue. thank you so much for telling and it was very wise to add a warning. loved the video a lot though! 😁

Joey wasn’t in twisted and in b@than if I recall right, what show was he missing from else I’m drawing a blank here lul

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

He also wasn’t in Ani because he was in TTO!

@ms.mine_

4 ай бұрын

@@Its_hatchetfield a)thank you b) it somehow blew over my head that ani countedaswell😂 c) amazing video thank you for the effort you have put into it

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

@@ms.mine_ thank you!

Alex Paul ❤

Ive just recently gotten into starkid through being obsessed with Angela in smosh and im confused about why there was a warning for Robert. Can someone explain pls?

@Its_hatchetfield

3 ай бұрын

He admitted to sexually harassing someone. I think it was one of the band members.

@taylordouthit3397

3 ай бұрын

@Its_hatchetfield oh jeez that's terrible

girl you could do a separate video of just who's been in most musicals

@mustachedclouds

4 ай бұрын

i think theres already a video with that concept!

i'm so proud of myself for getting top of 3 right lmao

Damn... how long did all of that take you?

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

A few months I think. I took some breaks in between though but it did take forever haha

I’m not into starkid, but I *am* into smosh, and ANGELA WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE.

@NotSoRealEllis2004

4 ай бұрын

Go check Starkid out

@cjdavis7924

3 ай бұрын

She was in Starkid before Smosh

@catherinetso8928

3 ай бұрын

Belting her heart out as Lex Foster and Grace Chastity (to answer your question)

Which one is joey missing. And have there been 12/has no one been in all of them?

@yourgrammarisnotverygood1827

4 ай бұрын

I think there are 15. Joey isn't in Holy Musical B@man, Ani, and Twisted. No one is in all of them because Ani and The Trail To Oregon happened at the same time and didn't have any overlap in the cast.

9:12 Angela from SMOSH?!?

@Nkp_09

4 ай бұрын

Always fun to see people have the opposite experience I had when I watched a smosh video and went "Angela from Starkid???"

How many times did you watch those shows for this... are you okay?

@Its_hatchetfield

4 ай бұрын

Way too many haha. I had to take a lot of breaks because it was making me go crazy for some of them😭

This must've been a long time to edit

@Its_hatchetfield

Ай бұрын

It was😭

@Nickthewriter1996.

Ай бұрын

@@Its_hatchetfield well props to you! AMAZING JOB! Not sure if you watch Smosh, but they have a musical episode tomorrow!

@Its_hatchetfield

Ай бұрын

@@Nickthewriter1996. thank you!! And I do watch smosh but I didn’t know about that. I’ll definitely be watching it!

@Nickthewriter1996.

Ай бұрын

@@Its_hatchetfield You're welcome! If you wanna check my videos out. I do some singing and comedy sketches.