I found your website when I was 16 years old, 23 years ago, and I’ve popped in throughout the years to see what you’ve added. Your explanations of grammar in the Quenya course (which I printed secretly in school) awoke a lifelong passion for language that is still with me to this day, to say nothing of you making Quenya comprehensible and my love of Tolkien’s languages seem valid and worthy of pursuit. I’m ecstatic to see these videos. Thank you.

@DonZooman

2 ай бұрын

Same here🥳

Since I already *am* the strange person my neighbors are whispering about behind my back, I might as well, when my writing of absurdly bad young adult fantasy novels leaves me some time. BTW, I was already a fan of your Ardalambion website and downloaded everything twenty years ago. I still have it filed somewhere. Great to see the master in action. In the words of one immortal wizard: "You haven't aged a day!"

How disrespectful, both to the victims of the Kinslaying in Alqualondë and to the language of Quenya itself, to speak Quenya in full sentences on the lands of Middle-earth, after Thingol decreed it forbidden. Did Thingol ever retract his ban? I think not. Have some respect for the unforgotten dead, cease profaning the tongue of Valinor, and speak Sindarin for all purposes excepting sincere prayer.

@Cenindo

15 күн бұрын

Since both Thingol and the victims of the Kinslaying are dead, not to mention a tad fictional to begin with, Thingol's First-Age edict against the use of Quenya does not seem to worry me very much. Even in-universe, Tolkien noted that what he calls "low Quenya" was sometimes spoken in Middle-earth, apparently outside purely ritual contexts.

@johnhannibalsmith3456

8 күн бұрын

He was the lord of but Heculbar from the days he was called Thingol, never the sovereign of Endore.

So funny! Thank you very much!

I have read your grammars for Sindarin and for Quenya and quite enjoyed them. I also like your work with The Fellowship.

You are making history again - using Quenya in context 😍 and giving us a taste of Nor(dor)wegian humor, landscape and neighbours.,We have been reading, we are watching now 😜

This is fantastic! Thank you so much. I'm one of the fortunate readers of your Quenya course book, as it was published here in Brazil. This video presents itself to me like an unexpected gift. Looking forward to the next episodes. Quenya is surely a worthwhile passion - after all, samilvë Mairë lá qualien Nanwiénen. Cheers!

Wow, I haven't expected this! I've read your course all these years ago. So happy to see you in person and I'm really excited for this course! 👏👏👏🥳

Please keep up with the series. Thank you

Thank you so much for this class.

This is absolutely fantastic! Subscribed!

Excellent series!

Ta arya nin! Mal masse Arcastar tence i ilye Eldar ista quete Quenya? Mana Eldaron i hehtaner i Lendon ar uir oménie Etyangoldi tenta? Pá hya - Omentielva Nerteasse equétien ó Chistopher Gilson pá tulurya Parma Eldalamberon ar uilte ehehtie rihtalta, san amatire picila ter sinyastance loar estel tauva nin.

Me imagino que para los Nórdicos, Tolkien debe de significar alguien muy especial, por que los cuentos están basados en toda la cultura Nórdica.... que risa cuando lanza el libro: Nature of Middle-earth por la espalda, jajaja.

Fantastic work, Sir! One question, I hear you pronouce the geminate tt as if it's /ht/, I believe I've seen you explain this a long time ago, but I do not call there was a reference given, and I cannot find that post any more. Would you mind commenting about it here? Or if you prefer e-mail, please let me know. Hara máriesse!

@Cenindo

4 ай бұрын

I wonder if it is not somewhere in Parma Eldalamberon #17 it is said that TT, PP, KK are pronounced as aspirates, but I can''t readily find the page reference. I will update if I locate the page.

@Theo-oh3jk

Ай бұрын

@@Cenindo Fascinating. If this is the case, then these geminates in Quenya were evolving into ejective consonants. I wonder if they are a feature of fourth age Quenya?

If memory serves me right, Hostetter once reported that there is even a comprehensive Adûnaic grammar in existence, not even to mention all the Quenya and Sindarin material! Why do you think they withhold all this information for decades? Seems kind of unreasonable.

@Cenindo

2 ай бұрын

I fully agree. They haven't published anything for almost ten years now, except that Hostetter included a few new scraps of new material in "The History of Middle-earth", which only touches on linguistics incidentally. I don't think there is an ADÛNAIC grammar still waiting to be published, but there is apparently one for a language called "Taliska", an early form of Mannish that in-universe may be an ancestor of Adûnaic. It was first announced in the early 1990s; by the mid-2020s we have heard nothing more!

@coreyander286

Ай бұрын

Clearly the information is too dangerous not to withhold. Speaking Adûnaic or Taliska carelessly, one might inadvertently utter some incantation which hasn't been heard since the Fourth Age, and wake barrow-wights from the earth or who knows what.