We're doing a viewer submitted Commander Clash soon! If you want a chance for your deck to show up on Commander Clash, head over to the community tab and drop your decklist in the post.

@VRanger100

5 ай бұрын

Here's my Tainted Remedy deck I dub "Public Death Care" www.moxfield.com/decks/-bhdv4jlD0io5-8MgVoSlw

@adamhenwood1114

5 ай бұрын

Stats episode!!!

@andrewpierce7782

5 ай бұрын

Cool. Return to MTGO and stop doing this in paper.

@jackl8025

5 ай бұрын

@@andrewpierce7782 guessing they won't be switching in the middle of a season but keep fighting the good fight

@Lucarioguild7

5 ай бұрын

Are you guys gonna do the end of season stats episode?

I love how Richard casts can't wake up....and seth and Crim immediately can't resist humming/singing the rest of the song😂😂😂😂

Ayo captain who?

@burnsboy101

5 ай бұрын

I thought I heard that 😂

@codypickell7

5 ай бұрын

Beat me to it

@tristonshelley96

5 ай бұрын

looked like phil caught it too

Hey guys. Are we going to get a stats episode for last season? Those are my favorite episodes the whole season.

@zacharyenglish2904

5 ай бұрын

Yeeees- stats, I hadn’t even thought about that

@gillgaladii8673

5 ай бұрын

I second this. The stats episodes are always fun. I wonder how much green crim played this past season.

@CreateWorlds

5 ай бұрын

Yes please

@Nathanael_Forlorn

5 ай бұрын

They are currently reconsidering the format. The continuation is in doubt, and it might be altered or canceled. Viewership is considerably down from regular episodes, so reasonable question. At least that what I've gathered from a comment below an earlier episode this season. Some love it and will miss it, if it ends up discontinued. But I guess if the numbers show a lack of interest, it's not feasible.

@OhSarcasticOne

5 ай бұрын

I think they're going to do it as a podcast episode instead

I really like the camera angle on your portraits. It really makes it seem like you guys are playing at the table despite being countries apart lol. Keep it up guys!

Captain WHAT!!!!!

@_claymore

5 ай бұрын

I heard that too.. 🤨😅

@BasedChe

5 ай бұрын

This is why I say nuh gath rod to be safe

@gsmastermike

5 ай бұрын

I was like AYO and then I saw Phil's face 😂

@Kryptnyt

5 ай бұрын

his name is Captain Demonitization

@pacethomson8807

5 ай бұрын

I came to the comments with this exact thought in mind, I’m glad someone else did too lol

imagine how much more success the d&d set would have been if it would have come same time as teh bg3 launch xD

@MTGGoldfishCommander

5 ай бұрын

Seriously. Big missed opportunity.

@donb7519

5 ай бұрын

I believe it was supposed to line up better but then the game got delayed. Also dont forget releasing it 1 month before the masters set

@ethanbrownell4247

5 ай бұрын

The set is also so much better than it has gotten credit for - especially in limited.

Crim going say it with me and Seth saying clash on is the most meta joke ever and i love it

Seth coming in thinking it was Crim week with that deck 🤣

Loving the paper content guys! Getting all the players board vs primarily just one players is really nice. Also, Confounding Conundrum drew waaaay more hate than it deserved. It doesn't "shut off" anything as kept being said, it just turns land ramp into land tutors to hand. It's certainly no Opposition Agent or anything.

@Thecalebpoe

5 ай бұрын

Never mess with the ramp players ramp. This is how it ends.

Props to Phil for making the most American of puns his deck building inspiration!

Politicking a Coat of Arms, that's a new one 😂

Great job Seth. Somehow you weren’t targeted after playing a second commander. Hey Crim. You did nothing wrong and were still targeted. That’s the sign of a great mtg player.

Taking Richard's Boompile because 60% of the time it works every time

@Shimatzu95

5 ай бұрын

what are you even talking about? When was the last time it did NOT work for him?

I would watch the hell out of a commander series that's just cEDH players trying to break randomly assigned commanders with under a thousand decks.

@ImJustHereToWatch14

5 ай бұрын

The "best" deck would probably often end up being a stock list for the colour combo. E.g. a Dakkon Blackblade deck wouldn't be about lands or voltron; it'd be a Demonic Consultation into Thassa's Oracle combo with a ton of tutors

@MakeVarahHappen

5 ай бұрын

@@ImJustHereToWatch14 I mean that's real, but there are commanders that you can leverage in interesting ways if you know your pod isn't going to crush you into the ground with their commander. I'm not expecting lands or Voltron Dakkon, but there's a middle ground where commanders are powerful but not overplayed.

@DabbleDo

Ай бұрын

When a new set comes out Play to Win does this with new commanders from it, looks like it would be fun to do. I personally wish they’d ban Partner commanders, gets boring seeing them every cEDH game

Seth brutally beating down the table with a sword of feast and famine/expropriate just made my week. PS, I feel like I need to see Crim win some games, stop hating him off the table every week 😅 Thanks for the content guys!

I'm really digging the paper format and editing style. I know you guys complain about not being able to get all the new cards on MOTO, and it's always interesting to see what you guys are cooking up in paper.

Hey Crew loving the paper games this season! However I wish you guys would do more niche themes that take advantage of the fact that you’re no longer using MTGO. For instance everyone makes a non-legendary creature their commander, silver-border week (silver border cards are legal), No ban list week, Planeswalker week , etc

@noah2508

5 ай бұрын

lots of UB stuff that they can do now too!

@Spotifist

5 ай бұрын

This is already possible on MTGO through Freeform commander, I think they have already tried it. But I agree, would be cool to see more unorthodox commander games!

Once again, great job guys. Still loving the new live format. As long as you guys can get the cards you need to keep it quirky, this seems great.

They really did Shadowheart dirty with her bad Baldur's Gate card arts

@dariengoheen747

5 ай бұрын

Because the art director for the set hates women

@DiscardatRandom

5 ай бұрын

@@dariengoheen747who’s the art director?

@dariengoheen747

5 ай бұрын

@@DiscardatRandom justice geddes

@VivBrodock

5 ай бұрын

@@DiscardatRandom justice geddes, he has openly expressed transphobia, mysogeny, homophobia, and racism. He's also voiced support for Halord McNeill (you know the guy who drew racist cards).

@DiscardatRandom

5 ай бұрын

@@VivBrodock thanks for telling me

I loved Phil and seths decks this week! Didn't quite see enough of crims and Richards to understand them.

No MTGO fails these past few episodes

Since you film your episodes with the top camera view I'm actually excited for new episodes and you climed up to one of my fav. edh game formats. Thank you for that :)

I really love the paper cards with the overhead angle! Also the episodes are much more watchable and flow better! Love you all so much❤

Seth popping off with decision-monicon.

16:12 who gave Richard the pass?

Awesome to see you play paper magic! And great game, Seth living the dream with the Valeyard.

I'm convinced that Phil picks his deck based on the shirt he pulled out of the closet that day. Also Confounding Conundrum is cool, but it ironically helps Landfall decks.

@singularleaf3895

5 ай бұрын

Are you sure he doesnt just buy a shirt to match the deck he has?

@alaraplatt8104

5 ай бұрын

he gets his deck ideas from the t shirt shop

@Kryptnyt

5 ай бұрын

You think Conundrum helps landfall decks right up until the Copy Enchantment comes out.

I'm really digging this live stuff!! Clash on!!!

The switch to paper makes the banter better in my opinion. Keep up the fun!

Tomer coming out with one of the best opening statements about his deck all campaign.

aside from getting crim beat up for no reason, confounding conundrum was solid even in a non green meta. glad to see the inclusion. get em crim.

Great episode! This one was a lot of fun. I’m still n out a huge fan of the paper magic format, but the editing has improved a lot over the last couple episodes.

Phil's thematic tshirts >>>>>

The Crim hate is rough, and just because of the Conundrum? C'mon guys, every week hating out Crim first gets old. On top of that, he comes to the table with the best attitude each week, imo. I'm not sure I could do the same being the first one out every time.

codfather hit us with the 16:11 during bhm

Loving the "live" play, so much fun 🥰

Killing Crim first because he played a confounding conundrum doesn't make a ton of sense. . . If it's like late in the game, and he'd die quick, it makes sense, but it's not like you get the conundrum removed in time for you to ramp. Which makes it feel kind of vindictive.

@Andrewlstewart

5 ай бұрын

It's why it's a bad card, draws a ton of aggro for a mediocre effect.

@Belena711

5 ай бұрын

@@Andrewlstewart I've played it a bunch of times, without it drawing a ton of aggro. . . It's not like confounding conundrum makes someone a threat... And killing someone first who isn't a threat is poor threat assessment. Which isn't the card's fault.

I am loving the paper magic over mtgo! The production and editing is great btw!

I wasn’t sure about leaving mtgo but I’m really loving the new set up. A+ content

At around 25 minute, Coat of Arms gives creatures +1/+1 for each other creature of the same type, weren't there your four Merfolk, each gaining +3/+3 and not +4/+4?

Shouts out to Crim for the descendents shirt!!! Milo is back on the menu

Loving the paper format for this season guys! :)

Looks like Phil caught the interesting N'ghathrod pronunciation eh? 16:10

I love how much shorter these got, while still packing in all the fun and action!

i love that u moved from mtgo for this season it looks so much better in my opinion. also the editing is great 👍

Once again expressing my love of paper over MTGO. So much of those games seem to be just waiting for the engine to catch up. Plus it's great to have a full proper view of all boards.

Love the editing

Wow, Seth absolutely lived the dream there

I love the change to Spelltable. It's probably more work on your end, but the games are so much easier and more enjoyable to watch :)

On this week of "Punt or Bluff?" Seth has been distilled and injected into us. Will Phil get *even more value* from a few bears or will Crim shapeshift into The Professor? Tune-in to find out!

Im so glad Seth is playing Valeyard, I've been struggling trying to make a deck with him

Turns out the only thing worse than losing to four extra turns in a row is being forced to read more Dr. Who cards during those turns

How expensive would be cameras and lights that would make the cards bit more readable? I am genuinely asking because for example on Seths board everything is so badly visible

Phill with the bear shirt; SWEET

Is paper the new regular medium for you guys?? Or is this temporary?

@MrDesoron

5 ай бұрын

Believe it is for the season

You guys could have a week where you all bring a house rule 😂

Phil actually playing the casual powerhouse bear

Richard is a man of refined taste.

Hey, is the viewer submitted decks video going to be in paper or on mtgo? It matters for which deck i want to submit

@singularleaf3895

5 ай бұрын

I think, I remember, they said they are going to be all physical except for certain matches. Such as Chaos week. I wouldn't be surprised if Viewer decks also get played on MTGO just to make it easiest on everyone.

@matthugenberg8869

5 ай бұрын

@@singularleaf3895 exactly why I want to know. I'm not going to submit a deck they can't play if they are doing it on mtgo

Confounding Conundrum lets goooooo!!!! We gotta see Psychic Surgery in there too!!!!!

Crim is lookin Lit! He’s his own worst enemy🎵

13:03 you can always trust a dishonest man to be dishonest.

Richard shoehorns a one piece reference each episode…..and im totally here for it! 😂

Glad that Sir Crimothy was the threat, imagine if he wasn't

Holy crap i told crim to run confounding conumdrum and its his first spell of the game!!!! Misery baby!!!

I enjoy the paper magic so much more. I know its probably much harder to do! But I really do love seeing the cards being played!

Sweet deck Seth

Still loving the live play! Every Friday, this is my must watch vid.

Richard always hit em with. "Yeaa we are friends right ?" Lmao 😂 with a 7/7 trampler.

I love that some of also plays OP ❤

I like this format way better. I feel like the games go faster now.

I really enjoy these physical episodes! Guessing it may have to do with Ultimate Guard promotion, but hope it continues! Much more fun to watch than MTGO! Also...how do people like Ultimate Guard? Sleeves and matts? Interested.

@Niuttuc

5 ай бұрын

I'll preamble with the disclaimer that we're sponsored by them, because that might inform things. Their Katana line of sleeves are some of the best I've played with, and they're the ones that feel best to shuffle of any sleeves I've used so far, they're really smooth without being slippery (after the initial few shuffles)

@bondeulv

5 ай бұрын

I'll preface this by saying I'm not sponsored (and that I'm presuming you didn't ask specifically just the MTGGoldfish crew). I think the Katanas have an excellent shuffle feel, and I really like their deck boxes (Boulders, Flip n Tray, Sidewinder) and binders I've bought over the years. Dragon Shield Art Mattes are still the superior sleeves for me though.

Surprising that the games are literally 30-60 minutes faster when not playing on MTGO

Funny expropriate story I was playing a game when a player cast expropriate and when I asked what it did the person who played it read it and then said they were voting for time and I tried to respond but they said since they had already voted I couldn’t respond which for some reason the rest of the table agreed with however on their extra turn they tried to cast another extra turn spell which I stole with sudden substitution and killed them on my extra turn

16:12 uh oh, Richard said it

dude... seth's deck is REALLY sweet. I really liked everybodys deck tbh! very fun game

soon as i saw what seth was running i was rooting for him and that last turn.. wow. need to make this for myself. which is nice that the only card in seth's list i don't own over $10 is black market connections and it doesn't feel necessary.

I will admit, the spelltable set up is growing on me. The game is more understandable despite not being able to see the boardstate very well.

Great to see The Doctor win a game of Commander.

Do y'all have all the cards for a dozen decks across the season or order them a week in advance or what? Curious about the logistics for doing a new deck each week.

@ConManAU

5 ай бұрын

I strongly suspect they make generous use of card rental services. And maybe a few proxies here and there.

16:11 RICHARD NOOOOOO

what is the figure behind Richard in the table?

Love see you guys play in paper.

Anyone know what they're using for overhead cameras?

Sad that you didnt do wilson + flaming fist and go full voltron, its a crazy combo that ends games FAST

I really like the new format, versus playing through MtGO.

not seth worrying about milling out with a stolen lab man on board

Merfolk's back on the menu.

Don’t worry crim next week confounding conundrum will be incredible.

The spit take when Richard played nghathrod

yeah not killing seth when everyone knew he was going to do a ton of damage to the whole table or get up to 9 spells for free was a mistake.

CANT WAKE UP!

I'm here to defend Seth playing a voting card in his vote deck, regardless of what it does. Theme!

Crim missing landdrops on MTGO, Arena and in paper must be a literal curse at this point. It's ridiculous.

16:10 capitain what?

The best part of spelltable is crims tats

Relate so much to phil. Regardless of my board state, im always looked at.

Episode 3 and the of new season and still no stats episode I will continue on this crusade until we get one

BEST CREW!