Even they lost so much weight, netizens won’t stop commenting about their appearance.And that makes me sad.

@SsmilingSsmile

26 күн бұрын

not only netizens, just look in this comment section and you will find many people talking about idol's appearances.

at 0:08 the girl on the left is Bestie's Dahye, the girl on the right is Wonyoung. It's disingenuous to make it seem like a before and after by cutting off Dahye's face.

The bullying of that member of Riize is absolutely appalling. Making fun of his background and the way he looked. What’s wrong with people? In a country that doesn’t like it when IDOLs bully, they sure like doing it to the idols. Very hypocritical.

I still remember Izone’s Hitomi weight loss… In one interview she said that she would swap body with Wonyoung because of her great proportions. Poor girl stopped eating and looked even thinner than Wony. I am so glad she got back to “normal” in japan.. But Hitomi’s socials are inactive for many months now, she is probably trainee under some korean company

@_Wonnielvrs

26 күн бұрын

It had nothing to do with Wonyoung’s weight but her long legs and tall height all IZ*ONE members used to gush over Wonyoung and her long legs

when there ribs show they said oh they are weak they should stop losing weight but when they have healthy body like not to much slim they say oh they need to lose weight like seriously what does some of these fans want

@sonya_nxs5293

27 күн бұрын

@@dontcrosstheline-skz-oneus I agree so so much on this comment.Like some people doesn’t count them as a human, and want them act like a robot.

@chaesbestie_

27 күн бұрын

I had a stroke reading this😭

@dontcrosstheline-skz-oneus

27 күн бұрын

@@chaesbestie_ i just notice that i ATE some words lmao🥲😭

Rosé's weight was definitely the MOST concerning one

@irneaa

27 күн бұрын

no

@tubby_1278

27 күн бұрын

Rosé even looks skinnier than Lisa.

@user-rv8yh6xh8z

27 күн бұрын

@@tubby_1278 Lisa hasn't been worryingly skinny since like 2018

@irneaa

26 күн бұрын

@@tubby_1278 Lisa gained weight

@zulapichu7786

26 күн бұрын

their all worrying the sam ein their own way

The industry is so hard on them and their pressure on how to maintain their bodies

The beauty standards (especially regarding weight) in the K-pop industry and South Korea are really concerning. Being over 50 kg is considered overweight there. No wonder the fertility rate is going down. This skinny trend is one of the reasons. I hope there might be some changes soon, like debuting a group with idols who aren't considered 'skinny.' This would help boost the confidence of common women too.

I don't really like Hyuna, but I definitely don't want her in pain. I'm glad she's feeling better now.

when she said hyuna i was like wow until i realized im 40 kg( actually 39.9 but ) and im not even 5ft and then said hyuna's height I was shocked i cant i imagine what she gone through

Well unfortunately the "skinny" trend is back again.

@ayaloid7533

27 күн бұрын

Just look at the Kardashian...they throw all their implants... And I think take oz£mpic to lose weight... Not just Kardashian , Oprah,Kelly Clarkson and others Hollywood star now getting skinny ....it's a Trend... They all start throwing all the implants,it's good but taking the oz£mpic part is not good ... I think many kpop idol also take oz£mpic now ...

@tubby_1278

27 күн бұрын

You could look skinny and healthy. You don't have to be THICC to be healthy

@tingle2323

26 күн бұрын

Anyone who promote such things as trend isn't mature

@misskata8511

16 күн бұрын

It always has been a trend and being fat is not healthy

@mariafotog

15 күн бұрын

Only in Kpop tbh...and I don't think the trend never disappeared unfortunately

I just wanna say, ribs showing doesn't necessarily mean someone is underweight. My ribs show quite a lot, but that's just cause I have prominent bones. Same thing with my collar bones and my wrists. But I'm not underweight.

@jenovella70

26 күн бұрын

I wanted to say the same thing. Some people's bodies are just built differently & that should always be taken into account. I am actually overweight but I have a slim neck, wrists, ankles, & my collarbones and ribs still show!

@nadoaus7795

25 күн бұрын

i’m 37kg and 5’5 and my ribs just don’t show!!! 😭😭 i guess it’s just my genetics

@HaRacycEBLErAtIng

24 күн бұрын

Same, I have good bones too

Can you imagine looking at a random photo of someone, noticing the curtains in the background, searching for who knows how long to find the name and price of the curtains, only to announce on social media that that person is poor? What kind of miserable, empty, lonely, and pathetic existence that person must live.

It's not easy in the tough world of Kpop, image means a lot, idols are scrutinized with too much pressure placed upon them to be pretty perfect, it's no wonder they drastically change and lose weight to maintain that high standard and it doesn't look good because its not healthy and can lead to unhappiness and misery in the long run

Even though I am not listening to Hyuna anymore, I am still glad she is healthier now. I wish K Pop stars works great themselves better. There is no point in being thin if you are fainting all the time. They just need to learn to balance their foods, and not pander to fools who expect too much from these human beings whom they insist on calling idols.

@petabulmer3317

25 күн бұрын

Edit- I wish K Pop stars would treat themselves better.

They didn't need to lose weight the were and are beautiful

Weight is hard

I love how (G)I-DLE members always straight forwards in speak up any things especially when it cames to mistreatment company. Recently, Yuqi even mentioned that CUBE really force them to on diet.

Seeing someone's ribcage is pretty normal though. It depends on people's body types. I'm a US 4 and am a very healthy weight and my ribcage is very prominent. It really depends on the person. I definitely think most of these idols look unhealthy though, especially Rose, but Minnie does not look unhealthy to me.

@laprisa442

11 күн бұрын

Yeah it on body types but the Korean weight “standards”become a problem for me when they look very underweight for some in their 20s

It’s unfortunate that image is such a seemingly integral part of being an idol. Fans comment on idols looks so much that the idols (and their companies) start obsessing over it. It’s such an unhealthy culture 😢

Knetizen critisize them when they gain weight and when they lose too lmao

i hope rose is okay

Either way, when idols lose or gain weight, it's always mentioned constantly. That's how ppl get depressed & anxiety. Ppl should just mind their own business.

Cube is taking everything They can squising G Idle for the remaining time. Less than 8 months remaining

Hyuna? Does anyone care about her anymore? She and her criminal are something else. She needs to retire.

winter’s body looks the same since the debut to me, her body was just more exposed in the Spicy stage outfit so that’s why you’re thinking she lost a shit ton of weight

Rose is really skin and bones.......its alarming

Some of these are big reasons why not EVERY idol needs to be on a diet! It cam be way more detrimental than anything good esp if their already skinny of at risk of being too skinny

My rib cage shows but I have belly fat not little but a decent amount but I'm not sick I'm healthy and my brother he is really skinny and his ribcage shows so much like a lot but he is healthy

I am shocked Jimin is not on the list cause he literally starved himself for 10days straight and he literally fainted a lot of times he lost about 10-15 kg according to google

@RUKA_BABYMONST7R

25 күн бұрын

U must be talking abt lbs bc this many kgs in 1 and a half week is humanly impossible

Please check your eyes Y'll SOHee looks amazing and he is freaking talented.

@Yujinyeah

18 күн бұрын

He is talented,but we know sm. He might be underweight,although I'm in no position to judge.

am I the only one who is getting motivation by watching this?

Felix is below weight too.😢

@RUKA_BABYMONST7R

25 күн бұрын

How many is she?

@Choeyongki

15 күн бұрын

​@@RUKA_BABYMONST7R He*

@Choeyongki

15 күн бұрын

​@@RUKA_BABYMONST7R He's 56kg

@RUKA_BABYMONST7R

15 күн бұрын

@@Choeyongki oh my gosh

no hate but it's clear HyunA and Rosie are going through an eating disorder aka anorexia I hope they get well soon:(

@yasminchan7425

27 күн бұрын

I think most if not all female kpop idols have an eating disorder.. Trainees are all put on a strict diet and bc of the toxic Korean beauty standards they have to be incredibly thin to be considered "pretty enough", it's so sad..

@olivesareoliver

26 күн бұрын

Don't just assume such things.

If they gain weight they don't care about their career and if they lose weight they are influencing others to follow dangerous diet's. It's very hard for them to do anything specially if the K-pop Idol is a women.

The sad truth is, that the Company is forcing them for PR. Focusing on one, gets the name publik and the next time its someone. When they need PR again they using the next one.

Your beautiful no matter, what at least to me, please don't starve yourself, I love you bunches baby gurlsz, a way to help with body image issues is to do something like calestics or something like gymnastics while doing weight loss, you'll feel better doing so ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ I love all my baby gurlsz

When are kpop companies gonna learn ?!? Are you freaking serious ?!?! Sure there to blame as well but the ones who are to blame are these toxic “fans” just because there not perfect idols despite the fact that these fans aren’t even idols and don’t know what it’s like, I’m not saying all idols are good people that get bullied since there are some that are just monsters, we can all learn, but knowing Korean oof no gonna have to take something big and tragic to make it change

Do you still post Kpop-News videos?

@noahyass1

27 күн бұрын

Yup they still do, but the thing is that they might not post much if nothing interesting is happening

I like rose she is my black pink bias but she does look to small

Claim you're under 3h claim ✨️

Rose is the one I'm worried for the most. these idols have so much pressure on them, way more than Western artists, and I think it's really unfair to them. they aren't treated as people, they're put on a pedestal, and are expected to be perfect. you could not pay me enough to be an idol. every word, sound, move they make are scrutinized. I truly hope they are all ok, and realize that it is normal to have flaws and make mistakes.

I know it's both bad but if I had a choice I would rather be too skinny then too fat and this is coming from somebody who used to be over 300 lb and I ended up losing 60 lb and I'm down to 260 lb but even like that that's still pretty big but then again I am 6'2 🤷

As ex idol said theu give them shots that makes them really unhealthyly skinny😢

please take care of yourselves as well, i got into kpop in 2015 (13yo) and developed an ed partially due to comparing myself to idols years later in 2021 and still struggle with it till today and now have health issues bc of it - please know that how skinny idols are often is extremely unhealthy - not always as some people are naturally that skinny but not everyone is built to be that skinny. Theres nothing wrong with either but know youre perfect the way you are and if anyone says any different its a them issue

I m not agaist this but some are too much its not right at all for there health

We are all humans, and we all have flaws, but all my baby's are gorgeous, absolutely gorgeous, your absolutely perfect but we can all get better and healthier, nothing wrong with having goals, but beautiful on the the inside is just more important, don't neglect that, also keep that on mind...... ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ I love you, we love you, If someone says something mean about you then they are probably bad people, not like meuwah ❤❤❤❤❤❤ thank you for the praise, but baby no like???

Minnie doesn't look unhealthy at all lol.

Damn i would dare k netizens to write this stuff on yt. They would be ripped apart by international fans. Its so beyond absurd to ridicule an idol for being poor growing up. 😂😂😂

0:25 whoa wait..is this a before and after? this is the same person?!

i can’t even finish watching this video this is ridiculous. i’m at a healthy weight of 120 lbs or 54 kilos as a 5’4” (163 cm) teenage girl and u can see my rib cage when i move around. i’m sick and tired of people hating on idols for being “too skinny” bc u can see their rib cage. that is something that happens to me as well, someone who is at a healthy weight. “too skinny” should not be determined by whether or not u can see someone’s rib cage

@laprisa442

11 күн бұрын

I mean it depends if you see the bone poking out real bad it is disturbing to see someone bones poking out and I feel like gaining a little weight if possible bc ppl have hard times trying to gain weight but I think it is a good idea to gain a little or even more weight but commenting on someone weight or how they look or how they grew up it shouldn’t be your concern but they have to be going through tough times and it’s not our business but when we talk about weight I would be concerned if it were my friend I would try and make gain a little weight bc it’s very disturbing to see a literal person bones in fact their whole rib cage I mean I would be concern but I feel like they should gain and much weight as they came for fat to kinda cover for the bones not to poke out nothings wrong with your body but for other people it is a bit triggering to see that( not saying that it’s your fault your body is very slim but for some people it’s very concerning) and also don’t reply to this comment if you disagree I feel like you should see it from my perspective which is what I stated in the comment thank you 🤌🏼

Liz lost weight gradually however just like Rosé going on tour made the weight loss pick up alot faster

I don’t understand these “strict diets” Koreans don’t usually gain all that much weight on a normal day with dancing for 7-12 hours why are they still dieting?? They should eat more when they are training that much. How hard is that to understand? If they eat they won’t faint, it’s not rocket science 🙄

All this girls hw do they stay a week without eating .i only didn't eat for about 10hrs i was busy when i got home dat day i was climbing stairs i almost fainted 😂😂😂😂 i had to rush inside i ate food for two people that day 😂😂😂😂😂 i almost died zo i duno hw they go for a week without eating

@SHEHRA859

22 күн бұрын

With You girl 😂😂😂😂 even if I didn't eat much, there has to be a snack every hour. I think most of these idols they already suffer loss of appetite due to exhaustion of their activities and negative comments. I hope them all health and i also wish them accept their bodies.

OMG 😳 skeleton 🦴 ribs

They do realize that in order to have children, women need body fat. If you are too thin, you won't even have a period........ This is also why idols take their lives. I think if people want to body shame others, they should have to post a photo, too.

Was this during the time where hyuna was dating dawn?

Now these days I see men into this ohhh lord these beauty things

Those netizens who made those comments are disgusting 😢

@butterfly-jl1ct

25 күн бұрын

agree

Winter's always had a small figure plus aespa always assures fans they are eating. Idek why Winter on this list lol. Also did everyone forget when you're young you have a much higher metabolism? Idk bout y'all but when I was younger I was skinny. I could eat 5 cheeseburgers and still look thin

Hayoung looked much better before.

❤❤

Surprised Onew wasn't on here. "Fans" have always made mean comments about the fullness of his face, so it had seemed those comments finally got to him and he lost tons of weight very quickly. Then he went on hiatus for a long time. And came back recently having gained back some weight and looking healthier. He also left SM recently, which will probably help his mental health a lot.

I understand that some people struggle with food-related issues, but sometimes people simply lose weight, while at other times they gain weight. Since Rosé is on the thinner side, it is normal for her weight to fluctuate. The same is true for us ordinary people. Things happen, and our bodies change.🤷‍♀️

@yasminchan7425

27 күн бұрын

Don't be delusional she's not on the "thinner side", Rosé clearly has an eating disorder

Omg the Liz thing makes my blood boil well all of this does but with Liz she was beautiful no matter what her weight is or was. Why can't Kpop idols have normal bodies what is the problem in Asian culture get with the times already. Having a normal size body is perfectly fine, having texture on their faces is normal, being chubby is sexy, being a woman and having opinions is life not a crime and doing normal every day human stuff like making mistakes having opinions or an illness is totally NORMAL, what is wrong with not being perfect just because you're an actor, singer or performer. I really want to know why most Koreans mind sets are like this, they think that you have to be perfect or act like a robot in this industry it's disturbing.

I'm so early lol

It do seem like every time Rosè makes an appearance she look skinnier and skinnier and it’s concerning.

Seconddd

3rd

sceond ❤❤ i love uuuu❤❤ i really hope all the one are fine now😢❤

who says winter is healthy🤨

@Jenorationn

27 күн бұрын

And how do you know she's not?? She always had a petite frame even during debut and shes literally the biggest eater in aespa. people can be naturally skinny

🙄 I love when people who don’t know anything about health comment on health. Seeing someone’s ribs does not mean they are skinny if that’s the case then every Olympic athlete, underwear model would be underweight. A guy who is skinny enough to see abs you can see their ribs😂 OMG!!!

Thin is in!

Leave liz alone

I agree with the rose one 😅😅😅 She does not look healthy

The skinnier the prettier

@sonamy1231000

26 күн бұрын

"You can always be thinner, look better" - patrick Bateman

Rosie 😂😂😂😂 what a obsession.... with blackpink 😂😂😂